News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by SquishyPanda23 on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:33AM (#24755461)
> there is no need, ever, for police to have the automatic weapons, APCs, and "non-lethal" weapons they are buying from the military.

I agree with the sentiment, but my impression (based on little evidence) is that the "need" here is to create a wider market for these weapons.

It takes money to develop new weapons, and a larger customer base helps defray those costs.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:17PM (#24756025)
Under the 1033 program, police departments pay for shipment and storage of the materials they request, but they do not pay for the equipment itself. While the military may purchase more equipment then it actually needs to lower per unit price, the acquisitions as a whole are not made any cheaper and the weapons developers make no more profit. In fact, given that this material is specifically diverted from what would be sold as surplus, the military would have more money to purchase weapons with if it didn't give these supplies to police forces. It's also worth noting that, while military vehicles like MRAPs are very visible, most of the requested property is more mundane: bulk ammunition is the most requested category, followed by office supplies.

It's pretty obviously just a way for the federal government to subsidize domestic police forces with money nominally intended for the defense budget.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:32PM (#24756191)
And perhaps a way to turn over the army's stockpile & keep its suppliers in business.

Quite a bit of the defense budget seems to have this goal, and it's not crazy -- if you skip a generation of tanks/planes/ships because your old ones are OK, the experience to build the next generation will have to be re-grown from scratch.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:44PM (#24756360)
Again though, selling the old equipment as surplus or just scrapping it achieves the same goal but also brings in some money.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:06PM (#24757434)
Sure, but maybe this has better PR than scrapping stuff. Or having it show up in Isis videos.

Mostly I don't think it's clear that "subsidize domestic police forces" need be the main goal.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:36PM (#24757826)
The simplest explanation that adequately explains the observation tends to be correct. There's really no need for any conspiracy here, support for "law and order" has been a winning political strategy for decades. Meanwhile, getting the department of defense to increase the number of MRAPs they order by a fraction of a percent seems like it could be achieved in other, easier ways. It's good to be skeptical, but at some point you need evidence.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:50PM (#24758689)
Conspiracy is quite a strong word!

My take on the neutral explanation would be is to assume that it's like every other policy -- about a dozen people with varying motivations had to support it, and then a few more motivations got added by PR people, and by whoever doesn't want it to stop. Policies "pretty obviously" driven by exactly one factor are extremely unusual.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:10PM (#24759488)
You are talking about a group of powerful politicians crafting legislation with a secret ulterior motive to transfer money to an unknown entity or entities in the military industrial complex. That's a pretty textbook conspiracy.

If you dig into the line items I'm sure there will be some compromises to get the maximum number of votes, but that's a far cry from an elaborate scheme to line the pockets of the military industrial complex.

It's not hard to imagine this bill passing on its own merits without heavy lobbying. No one in the 90s was going to want to be painted as anti-cop, pro-drug, pro-terrorist, and/or pro-government waste. Even if we now see the terrible consequences of police militarization, and many still don't, that's hindsight. At the height of the war on drugs, as children who grew up hearing about serial killers in the 70s were now worrying about their own young kids, taking the weapons that had been lying in warehouses since Nam and putting them to good use protecting the streets here at home had wide bipartisan support. It costs very little, makes people feel safe, and makes a lot of politicians look good.

Again it is good to question the official narrative, but your hypothesis needs to be falsifiable. You will always be able to go a layer deeper and say "oh well they did it this way to make it harder to see their real motive" but without evidence there is no reason to continue going down that rabbit hole.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:31PM (#24759657)
You're mis-reading me. Nowhere have I proposed any well-thought-out secret scheme. I'm pushing back against a story that says there's one precise purpose to this, which I thought was your claim above: "pretty obviously just a way for the federal government to subsidize domestic police forces".

I suggested one other motivation some people might have felt, of keeping the hardware moving. You've suggested some more, too, now, like looking tough on TV. Maybe that means we agree.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by monocasa on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:56PM (#24758759)
Don't they have to take over the fairly lucrative maintenance contracts as well?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:15PM (#24759523)
Most 1033 materials are simple things like ammunition and office supplies, which wouldn't have any maintenance contracts. I'm sure if a police department got an APC they'd want it to be maintained, and I highly doubt you can just take an APC down to the local mechanic, but to my knowledge there's nothing in the 1033 program that forces them to continue a maintenance contract.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jmcqk6 on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:36AM (#24755503)
Maybe those weapons should cost more instead.