News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ericmay on Monday September 21, 2020 @09:23AM (#24543056)
This told me all I needed to know.

"The entire infotainment system is a HTML 5 super computer," Milton said. "That's the standard language for computer programmers around the world, so using it let's us build our own chips. And HTML 5 is very secure. Every component is linked on the data network, all speaking the same language. It's not a bunch of separate systems that somehow still manage to communicate." [1]

[1] https://www.truckinginfo.com/330475/whats-behind-the-grille-...

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by zpeti on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:21AM (#24543802)
I'll raise you:

"It's called Rebo and it's the first bottle that cleans the planet as you drink. One Rebo drunk is one plastic bottle collected as simple as that. Rebo is a smart bottle equipped with a laser time-of-flight sensor and a Bluetooth transmitter that measures and senses the water you drink. The Rebo the app captures the information and records it into the blockchain transforming it into green credits that sponsor the collection of plastic bottles every minute."

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KupJgVupEtk

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by edoceo on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:30AM (#24543907)
What the heck does this even mean? This is crazier than the stuff my cannabis business clients come up with.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by umvi on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:13PM (#24545098)
The bottle cap has a laser sensor that measures the water level in the bottle. When you drink all the water, there is a Bluetooth chip (also in the cap) that notifies the app on your phone, which phones home and records that you drank a bottle of water into a DB (apparently a blockchain). The company then has a deal with some other company that for every bottle of Rebo you drink, it funds the collection of plastic waste collection.

I admit they chocked it full of too many buzzwords to make it sound cooler than it is, but at least the concept sort of makes sense compared to the hot air the Nikola CEO blew.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by giarc on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:20PM (#24545210)
There are a ton of companies doing this "Toms shoes" model (buy one, give one) and it doesn't need to be complex. "For every bottle of water you purchase, we fund the clean up of 1000 bottles". Why bring lasers into it?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ChuckMcM on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:31PM (#24545352)
Because they couldn't figure out how to credibly add "Machine learning" or "AI" and lasers was the next buzzword on the "What's hot" list?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by microtherion on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:28PM (#24546766)
And the EPA would not approve mounting lasers on sharks' heads.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by n_io on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:11AM (#24544358)
You can’t call and raise. You can only either call or raise. ... Sorry for being overly pedantic but as a poker player that one kinda bothers me :)
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by CPLX on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:13AM (#24544376)
That's arguable. A reasonable case could be made for the idea that a call is a required prerequisite for a raise.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by k1t on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:21AM (#24544465)
True - but in a professional setting if you say "I'll call..." then that's it you're calling. You can't tag "..and raise you..." on the end - they would not accept the raise.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by dtparr on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:58AM (#24544885)
I've been in otherwise pretty friendly games where string bets were disallowed. Or at best, the first time it happened (generally by a new player), it was accepted but the table agreed not to allow anymore for anyone.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by Plyphon_ on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:35AM (#24544620)
I've often said:

"I see your [bet] and raise you [x]" - would that be accepted?

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by hn_anon_reply on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:50AM (#24544785)
It can depend on where you are playing, but you run the risk of getting called for a string bet. The way you worded it definitely makes it sound that way because of the "and" combining two actions. If it is a friendly game you are unlikely to face issue, but in a contentious game with unknown enemies, this quote would get you called for a string bet in some of the casinos I've played.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ryandrake on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:04PM (#24547134)
Even most friendly games I play, where the rules are VERY relaxed, do not allow "I see your X and raise you Y" string bets. This pattern is pretty firmly a relic of the past (if it ever existed outside of Hollywood).
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by spurgu on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:48AM (#24544765)
I suppose it depends on the house, and floor, but I think it might be fine as you're not explicitly saying "call". I always just say "raise" and put in the chips (all at once!), or say "I raise to XXX" with XXX being the total amount (call+raise), after which I can take my time counting out the chips (or put more than the total raise amount if I don't have exact change).

Saying call and then adding a raise is similar to string betting, where you first put some chips to gauge your opponents reaction, and then put in some more. That's not allowed but so many beginners do it.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by mikeryan on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:42PM (#24548796)
No that's a string bet. It's generally explicitly not allowed so you can't fish for info after saying "I see your bet....."

Some places may let you do it once, but by rule its not allowed in Casinos.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by JamesSwift on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:26PM (#24546062)
Everywhere I've played would call that as a string bet
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jasonwatkinspdx on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:01PM (#24544941)
Naw, any place reasonably serious will have a string betting rule and similar. The reason is that you could start out with "and I call your 500" then pause slightly to see if your opponent starts moving/reacting in some way that signals their likely response before deciding whether to follow up with your raise. Likewise most places have a rule that you have to count out your bet then push it all out at once, or declare the full amount clearly verbally. Even the piddling little $100 buy in tourneys I played in during the poker craze 15 years ago had these rules.

Dealers tend to just shut down anyone that plays silly games around delaying or feinting what they're going to maybe do to. I was at Acapulco Joe's one time playing the cheap limit tables with a dealer that was out of patience with this one guy that was acting like he was on national tv for the world series finals. Finally at one point when he was dickering around she just looked at him, said "he calls" took his chips and moved on lol.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by mikerathbun on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:54AM (#24544830)
Only on TV. People in casinos can be sticklers when you verbally announce one action and then tack on another. Imagine saying something like, "I call" look for a reaction and if that person looks dejected quickly follow Up with, "and raise you $x". It is sometimes referred to as "Angle shooting"
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by Topgamer7 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:43AM (#24544045)
It looks like it's called "Rebo". Here is a reply on one of the comments on the page.

> Hi Palps, thank you for your interest and time. We generate a green credit that is fully anonymized every time a REBO bottle is drunk and they are certified by the Gold Standard, the most reputable agency in carbon emission reduction certification. Credits are monetized through private sponsors and the funds go to Plastic Bank, an organization that pays people in underprivileged communities in developing countries to pick up plastic dispersed in the environment. We hope this helped you understand better what happens "behind the scenes" to make it possible to clean the planet as you drink with REBO

Its a pretty garbage idea of trying to take peoples sympathies for plastic waste to sell a product. Just donate to recycling non profits or research if you want to support green efforts.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by bluntfang on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:06PM (#24545005)
rebo had a sick booth at burning man
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valine on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:04AM (#24543591)
Rolling the semi down a hill calling it “In motion” in a promotional video is what did it for me.

Original video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAToxJ9CGb8

Nokola’s admission: https://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/09/nikola-admits-prototype...

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by wlesieutre on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:15AM (#24543738)
When they said “Feels like a luxury car with sports performance” I can only assume they meant it like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VoeQdse7aLU
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by dylan604 on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:14AM (#24544392)
the engines had to be running so that power steering and brakes would work. yet they sound designed this to make it sound like the engines were not running.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by wlesieutre on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:26AM (#24544516)
You can also see the tach idling at 1000 RPM, but the "rolling down a hill" part is accurate.

I wonder if Nikola had their brakes working or not.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by djbebs on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:40PM (#24546226)
Why would the engine be required for the brakes and steeri g to function?

Am i taking crazy pills here?

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by dylan604 on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:02PM (#24546470)
Ever tried to turn the steering wheel when the engine is not running? Power steering[0] uses a hydraulic system to make steering the car nearly effortless compared to cars without it. The weight of the car and the rubber of the tires on the ground causes a lot of friction (the actual force moving the car down the road). That friction makes it difficult to just move the wheel. Power steering is one of the many pulleys the engine belt is threaded.

Brakes are also hydraulically operated. Ever pump the brakes in your car when the engine isn't running? That gets very difficult as well without the assist of the running engine.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_steering

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by mikestew on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:30PM (#24547455)
Slight clarification: the brakes don't work as well because the vacuum booster isn't operating (no running motor to create the vacuum for the boosting). The reason the brakes get more difficult with each pump (when the engine isn't running) is because you're gradually using what little vacuum boost is left, until there just isn't any.

And if you'll allow me just a teensy bit more pedantry, you are also turning against the power steering pump when the engine is off. Our '81 VW camper doesn't have power steering, and it isn't as hard to turn as a car with power steering but a non-running engine.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by TylerE on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:00PM (#24547095)
That is true a parking lot speeds, but power steering is a non-factor above about 15 mph.

Doubly true in a mid/rear engined supercar with only about 35% of the weight on the front wheels to begin with.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by itsoktocry on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:13PM (#24545099)
>This told me all I needed to know.

How is this any different the nonsense Musk pumps out:

     1. Machines in the factory moving so fast you need a strobelight
     2. Solar tiles that will print money
     3. Full self-driving on all cars since 2016
     4.  A brain chip that will cure autism
and on and on...
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by bob33212 on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:28PM (#24545316)
Milton cannot explain why HTML5 is secure, because it doesn't make any sense. He is just repeating buzzwords.

Musk can explain how he could build a very fast factory. Maybe he is wrong and there is some sort of thermal limit that he is going to hit before getting it to that speed. But it is a real plan. He isn't just throwing out buzzwords to attract investors.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by sidcool on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:47PM (#24545577)
Musk delivers late. But he does deliver. At this point, any question on Musk's engineering/business acumen cannot stand. He's weird, too ambitious and optimistic. But not a charlatan. The hundreds of thousands of Teslas being driven worldwide and the astronauts flying to and from the ISS are a testimony. But he is weird.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by theptip on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:53PM (#24545654)
Musk is overly optimistic and makes marketing claims and predictions about the future. I think Musk's worst estimates could actually be false advertising (e.g. the claims about Autopilot). But in most cases they are understood to be within some bounds of possibility, even if it's a 95th %ile best-case estimate.

Milton made fraudulent claims about the existing technology that they had built, which is I think categorically different than most of Musk's futurology. There's no sense in which Milton's claims might be true; they were objectively false statements at the time they were made.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by mlindner on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:28PM (#24545318)
Because:

1. Elon Musk has admitted many times since that point that he was wrong (something Trevor never does) about factory automation.

2. The solar tiles exist.

3. Turns out making super good AI takes more time and Elon is always too optimistic, that is still their goal however that they are working towards.

4. That's still their goal and they're working towards it.

You can't call someone a fraud just because they haven't reached a goal yet and it's taking longer than expected.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by 1MoreThing on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:48PM (#24546971)
Good advice that is applicable towards doomsday cults as well.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:12PM (#24547220)
Is there any evidence to suggest that a "brain chip" will ever "cure" autism?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valuearb on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:58PM (#24547750)
What would limit a brain chip from accomplishing that goal?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:12PM (#24548537)
Current understanding of autism is that it is a developmental disorder, and not something characterized by excess/insufficient hormones. It is hard to imagine how a disorder that challenges information processing in the brain could, with our very limited understanding of how such things actually work, be handled by a chip saying "You should respond to such stimuli in X manner, not Y manner". It's not a case of "X is handled incorrectly, tell the brain to do Y instead".

I could potentially see such a thing working for, say, epilepsy, where we might be able to "mute" or counter a stimuli that causes seizure, but, at least for the forseeable future, I don't see "brain chips" working in contexts other than concrete causal links, stimuli, reaction/response mechanisms - I think one hint is that there's nothing we can do to "medicate" autism. Medications currently used are for "byproducts" of ASD, such as ADHD, anxiety, not the disorder itself. Indeed, the closest (and we're not particularly close) we have come to thinking of how to manage ASD is gene therapy, which wouldn't be manageable by a "brain chip".

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valuearb on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:56PM (#24548898)
Autism is a broad spectrum of behaviors, but one consistent symptom is not being able to “quiet” excess stimuli (as I write this my daughter exhibits her self stimulation behavior by running back and forth across our family room).
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by nickik on Monday September 21, 2020 @09:16PM (#24549936)
With people like you it always blows my mind how one can have such a restricted mindset.

You are nip picking a few things and vastly distorting the actual claims to make your point, while totally ignoring everything that actually was accomplished. Elon gets asked about 50 things every day and he gives his median prediction.

If you actually go back 10 years and look at his prediction for Tesla and SpaceX he is remarkably accurate, far, far, far more then literally anybody else.

Tesla underestimated the difficulty of mass production. That happens to basically every company that has extreme growth and the handle the problem and are now in very profitable production and own a huge market share in that cars market. They are massively improving manufacturing as was confirmed by independent experts.

They have 28% of global full EV market thanks that production system that you dismiss. The are outselling BMW, Mercedes and Lexus combined in the US. But of course instead of saying that, lets point out that they had 1 year of production issues.

> Solar tiles that will print money

Can you actually provide a source for that statement? Solar roof was to expensive and didn't sell well, so they made them cheaper and they are mass producing them now. They are not printing money, but they are increasing the numbers they sell and it should turn into a nice buissness.

> A brain chip that will cure autism

Again, nobody ever claimed they would have this right now. Its technology with lots of potential and that's how it was communicated. Elon is literally spending his private money on long term development project that has the potential to help many people and wouldn't get funding otherwise. And people like you shit on him, its baffling to me how somebody can have this reaction. Yeah fuck him for trying to work on some of the hardest problem in the world.

He is to optimistic on self driving, that is literally the only valid argument people have.

Truly baffling to me.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by JetSpiegel on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:07AM (#24679159)
> > Solar tiles that will print money

> Can you actually provide a source for that statement? Solar roof was to expensive and didn't sell well, so they made them cheaper and they are mass producing them now. They are not printing money, but they are increasing the numbers they sell and it should turn into a nice buissness.

"They" who? Not Solar City.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by admn2 on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:20PM (#24546665)
Nikola direct listed their stock so they faced no scrutiny. It opened at $10 and then went up to almost $80 due in part to massive FOMO-inducing posts on Tikok and WallStBets.

If the founder doesn't have the self-awareness not to say non-sensical quotes like that knowing he will be fact-checked, it's a bit concerning.

I don't understand how GE invested and didn't find anything in Due Diligence. They really couldn't see the Robinhood effect? Is FOMO that fervent in the space thanks to Tesla? Reminds me a lot of the crazy multiples RX Bar, Dollar Shave, and Native Deodorant got as all the incumbents got freaked out about losing fractional market share to "digitally native" brands.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by dpiers on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:17PM (#24545151)
Both emperors are naked, one just has a much higher approval rating.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by itsoktocry on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:19PM (#24545190)
Agreed. I wonder if this will have more people asking questions about Tesla.

Tesla is a tougher one, because they do produce a good product, while exaggerating far more than they produce.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by nickik on Monday September 21, 2020 @08:58PM (#24549875)
Tesla literally own more then 50% of the US EV market. The own like 18% of the global EV, and 28% of full electric market. And they have been increasing global market share year over year. They have grown the amount of products they sell every year. They have the largest global charging network. The build the biggest battery in the world. The list goes on.

In 2015 Musk said they want to produce 2020 they want to produce 500k vehicles, and even with covid they will come close to this or even hit it.

To compare the two is beyond ridiculous. Nikola literally never deliver a single vehicle or achieved a single significant engineering goal.

If you actually think they are remotely comparable there is something seriously wrong with your perspective on the world.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by rasz on Monday September 21, 2020 @06:49PM (#24549261)
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by new_realist on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:54AM (#24544833)
1,433 days since Elon Musk started charging Tesla customers for 'self driving' that he said would be able to drive from Los Angeles to New York city with no human intervention by the end of 2017.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ChuckMcM on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:38PM (#24545455)
Not to be an apologist for Tesla here, while Elon has made some pretty explicit statements here the ordering page for cars has always said "equipment capability" and pretty accurately described it was the required equipment for when the capability was available.

And yes, there is an implicit problem there where you can't definitively know this is all of the equipment you need until the capability is released, but I suspect Tesla would have provided any additional upgrades for free if and when they release "auto-drive."

I thought of it kind of like "cable ready" TVs (not that most people reading this would have heard of those :-)) that were TVs that could, in theory, use cable. However, the cable standard wasn't finalized and there was a chance that what came out in the standard would not be compatible with these TVs.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:13PM (#24547235)
> Not to be an apologist for Tesla here, while Elon has made some pretty explicit statements here the ordering page for cars has always said "equipment capability" and pretty accurately described it was the required equipment for when the capability was available.

Right, and he's also made explicit statements that you could FSD "by the end of 2016", "by the end of 2018", "by the end of 2020", coast to coast.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:45PM (#24548814)
> Right, and he's also made explicit statements that you could FSD "by the end of 2016", "by the end of 2018", "by the end of 2020", coast to coast.

That isn't out or character for Musk. He's always set and communicate unrealistic timeline. That doesn't make him a fraud. Take Falcon Heavy:

> By 2008, SpaceX had been aiming for the first launch of Falcon 9 in 2009, while "Falcon 9 Heavy would be in a couple of years". Speaking at the 2008 Mars Society Conference, Musk also indicated that he expected a hydrogen-fueled upper stage would follow 2–3 years later (which would have been around 2013) - [0]

Of course Falcon Heavy didn't fly until Feb 2018, and hydrogen-fueled upper stage never materialized. Still, nobody care about that today. FH is a resounding success and are qualified to be used for NASA's Lunar Gateway and Space Force's National Security Space Launch program, which are as good as stamps of approval can get.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:55PM (#24548889)
I never said he was a fraud, though I am cynical.

But you can't hand wave away his statements on Twitter as "Oh, that's just Elon, all Tesla's corporate statements have very explicitly (in at times very fine print) said it's contingent on 'capability' and 'regulation'" when Tesla have literally said "Elon's Twitter _is_ a Tesla corporate statement".

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:09PM (#24550206)
> But you can't hand wave away his statements on Twitter as "Oh, that's just Elon, all Tesla's corporate statements have very explicitly (in at times very fine print) said it's contingent on 'capability' and 'regulation'" when Tesla have literally said "Elon's Twitter _is_ a Tesla corporate statement".

Yes and no. His settlement with SEC only requires vetting for tweets that have material impact to investors. Anything else is just his opinion, although I agree that's a very fine line - [0]

Take his tweet sent out today about Battery Day event tomorrow:

> Important note about Tesla Battery Day unveil tomorrow. This affects long-term production, especially Semi, Cybertruck & Roadster, but what we announce will not reach serious high-volume production until 2022 - [1]

Clearly a vetted communication. A less serious one in contrast:

> Bitte arbeiten Sie bei Tesla Giga Berlin! Es wird super Spaß machen!! - [2]

[0] - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/apr/26/tesla-elo...

[1] - https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1308148212876812289

[2] - https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1304175179606695937

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by serf on Monday September 21, 2020 @08:07PM (#24549683)
> That doesn't make him a fraud.

Why not?

What is the point of deadlines then?

Being a fraud doesn't mean you fail to deliver.

fraud: 'wrongful or criminal deception intended to result in financial or personal gain.'

He promises deadlines to soothe shareholders. I don't see the difference in his behavior and fraudulent behavior, other than that he has a large fan-base to validate the behavior.

He profits from promises that aren't delivered.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:33PM (#24550319)
> What is the point of deadlines then?

I don't pretend to know his motivation, perhaps his misplaced optimism? or to motivate and set the guideline for his troop? or to indicate Tesla's priority and direction?

Do you think JFK knew for sure that American would reach the moon before the end of 1960s? Or for that matter, I suppose you'd consider NASA to be fraudulent if Artemis program fails to send a crewed mission to the Moon in 2024.

> Being a fraud doesn't mean you fail to deliver.

Fraud usually means all talk and no substance. Can you give a counter example?

> He profits from promises that aren't delivered.

You need to show the evidence of this

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ChuckMcM on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:47PM (#24547634)
I was trying to distinguish between what Elon said vs what the company said in its corporate communications. In Tesla's case the corporate comms types seem to be more honest. In the Nikola case both the CEO and the company comms were misleading.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:54PM (#24547702)
> I was trying to distinguish between what Elon said vs what the company said in its corporate communications.

The problem with that is that Tesla has declared to the SEC that @elonmusk on Twitter is an "official company communication channel". That's why he's gotten in trouble for past tweets.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by JamesSwift on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:30PM (#24546100)
Isn't this argument of "technically correct" semantics exactly what Milton argued for the nikola truck rolling down the hill? Why pillory him and not Elon for the same?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by sangnoir on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:46PM (#24548821)
Milton was absolutely, "technically correct": the Nikola truck was in motion (the video was announced as "The Nikola Truck in motion). What you take away and what was said are 2 completely different things, and the message is specifically crafted to do just that.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valuearb on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:00PM (#24547773)
Because there is a difference between misleading people that an empty shell is a functioning truck, and perpetually claiming you are on the verge of fully autonomous driving, when you only achieve mostly autonomous driving.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by kanox on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:04PM (#24544974)
Being late does not make you a fraud.

Tesla does have a real team working on self driving hardware and software and they're shipping it inside cars.

It's not clear that Nikola has much more than powerpoint. They got a lot of impressive-sounding partnerships going but so did Theranos.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by itsoktocry on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:15PM (#24545120)
>Being late does not make you a fraud.

Then you can literally say anything and claim "just not yet!".

Amazing people say things like this with a straight face.

>It's not clear that Nikola has much more than powerpoint.

Nikola has real teams working on real things, too. They are just nowhere near where they claim to be.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by kanox on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:09PM (#24547870)
It's extremely common across all industries for projects to be late or underdeliver. How can you claim with a straight face that this is the same as fraud?

> Nikola has real teams working on real things, too.

Their technology claims are all over the place and includes a large lineup of electric and hydrogen-powered vehicles that would be impressive even for GM and Ford.

I don't think their leadership plans to deliver all of any of those vehicles. Insiders (including Trevor Milton) have cashed out already and it looks more like a pump-and-dump scheme than a real business.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:23PM (#24548633)
> Then you can literally say anything and claim "just not yet!".

> Amazing people say things like this with a straight face.

Then literally everyone who claims breakthrough in fusion, new energy, medicine, AI, robotics, supersonic travel, would qualify as fraud. Fusion has always been X years away after all.

You've just also described many space projects, notably JWST and SLS. Granted, I'll give you SLS.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Webb_Space_Telescope

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System

> Nikola has real teams working on real things, too. They are just nowhere near where they claim to be.

The trouble is Trevor didn't just say "just not yet!". He insisted that the Nikola One on stage at their Dec 2016 presentation is real, with this vivid description: "I don’t want someone to end up doing something and driving this truck off the stage…so we’re going to try to keep people from driving off. But this thing fully functions and works, which is really incredible."

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by 52-6F-62 on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:14PM (#24546603)
> Then you can literally say anything and claim "just not yet!".

To play a little devil's advocate, then...

Wouldn't that put most startups and Silicon Valley into the "fraud" camp?

Net positive revenue is always coming and funds are continuously raised on that promise...

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valuearb on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:01PM (#24547784)
When did Elon fake a video of a Tesla autonomously driving cross country?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jesseb on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:10PM (#24545882)
Zero days since somebody brought up Musk in a completely unrelated conversation.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by JamesSwift on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:31PM (#24546123)
Nikola/Milton and Tesla/Musk are inextricably linked. I mean... its even in the name.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by rorykoehler on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:55AM (#24544848)
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by tenaciousDaniel on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:05AM (#24543605)
I'm sharing it with everyone I know. This might be the most hilarious marketing copy I've ever come across. It's almost like a parody.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by can16358p on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:16AM (#24543750)
The buzzword soup from the snippets reminded me of the scene from CSI where they were "building a GUI interface in Visual Basic to trace an IP address".
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by gamblor956 on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:01PM (#24544943)
I don't understand what's wrong with that?

IRL that is exactly the type of thing VB is used for. It's easy for non programmers to design interfaces, relatively intuitive to program, and it doesn't require compilation or other fancy or complicated processes to use the completed program.

It's literally WYSIWYG programming.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by maccam94 on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:11PM (#24547211)
It's unrealistic that someone would write a GUI interface in response to an active computer attack. The reference: https://youtu.be/hkDD03yeLnU
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by gamblor956 on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:58PM (#24548910)
I don't think you understand how Visual Basic works or how people use it.

The GUI isn't "written", it's drag and drop. You add functionality as needed to the GUI events, like the code you would have put into a console program goes into a button's OnClick event instead.

It's probably faster than writing a console program for anyone who isn't a developer.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by st1x7 on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:47AM (#24544737)
And of course someone built it for real - https://archive.codeplex.com/?p=guivbip
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by chii on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:24AM (#24543846)
at least that CSI scene still makes sense and is possible!
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by m4tthumphrey on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:55AM (#24544178)
This was new to me so had to Google it. Did not disappoint!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkDD03yeLnU

Edit: The correct URL!

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by dylan604 on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:17AM (#24544419)
I was hoping your link was going tot he CSI scene in question. Sad for me.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by m4tthumphrey on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:25AM (#24544504)
It most definitely should have been! Edited!
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by cbsks on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:50AM (#24544125)
But do they use military grade encryption??

And I’d feel more comfortable if a block chain was involved, somehow.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by dylan604 on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:20AM (#24544460)
They do use the best stainless steel that they "could find", but not necessarily the best stainless steel full stop.

And of course block chain is involved. Everyone knows that if you want a crowd funded campaign or get VC funding you need to only need to include the phrase "AI", "ML", or "block chain". Or add all three for a triple score combo.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by joaomacp on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:22AM (#24543816)
Not even GPT-3 could be this nonsensical.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by croddin on Monday September 21, 2020 @09:59AM (#24543531)
Well speaking of trucks and not understanding technology, that is pretty much on the level of: “The internet is not a big truck. It’s a series of tubes...”
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by new_realist on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:52AM (#24544807)
"What people should absolutely have zero concern about, and I mean zero, is that Tesla will achieve a 10,000 unit production week by the end of next year."
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by seebetter on Monday September 21, 2020 @09:56AM (#24543479)
He should had went with a 'hexavigesimal chipset'. A base 26 system could be capable of rendering reality with the right enhancements.

https://www.quora.com/Could-you-make-a-CPU-that-processes-on...

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jariel on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:02AM (#24543569)
Again this is not remotely worrisome.

Tech people, and smart people in general, need to learn how to step out of their own understanding of the world and see their own fields as others do.

Very few people actually know what HTML really is or how it works, and would be hard pressed to describe it.

This quote is an executive mangling the description of some tech that otherwise might make sense. After all, Javascript is part of HTML5 and that could very well be used on various parts of the system, 'linked on the data network, all the same language'. And it is 'a language' that many programmers know how to speak around the world.

The bit I can't figure out is 'lets us build our own chips' which is a stretch.

This is a guy not really knowing what he is talking about, but with a few word changes, it's mostly rational.

The other stuff is far more scary.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by DevX101 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:11AM (#24543678)
Taken in isolation, the statement isn't catastrophically bad. But it does tell me some things about the speaker's character including:

- Has limited understanding of technology

- Is prone to overstatement, if not outright lying

- Is willing to use technobabble to describe his product

Those conclusions, if coming from a normal layman, might just make me roll my eyes, but coming from the CEO of supposedly technology centric company that hasn't yet released a product, it raises massive alarm bells and has me running to sell shares or short the company.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by bob33212 on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:04PM (#24544980)
Not understanding what is going on under the hood of software systems is a huge risk for a manager. A Demo could look and feel awesome. But the whole thing could be dependent on a npm package maintainer not disabling his account. And you don't understand that until your entire fleet gets bricked overnight.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jariel on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:13AM (#24543705)
So yes, it does add suspicion in context - but of all the 'suspicious things' - it's the least suspicious.

Most car execs would struggle with this were they to have to read an unprepared statement.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by chii on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:26AM (#24543860)
somebody with integrity would just admit they dont know the tech, but point out that he has trusted techies who _do_ know.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by solarkraft on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:19AM (#24544454)
Do sales people usually have integrity?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by kube-system on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:21AM (#24543798)
The concern with his botched technical statement is not one of technology, it is a concern of managerial competence. It is perfectly reasonable for a CEO to not understand technical details. A sloppy statement like this brings into question whether it was made out of arrogance, overconfidence, or incompetence. A good leader will understand their own limits of technical understanding and will defer to subordinates when appropriate.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jariel on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:36AM (#24543965)
I agree with what you are saying - but this is missing my point. Obviously, it's a dumb thing for him to say - but this statement is not much of a 'red flag' regarding fraud.

If you go searching for 'dumb things tech CEO's say about tech' you will find quite a few. My own CEO at one large company I know was actually quite brilliant, and generally knew the tech, but would sometimes mangle some things.

Of all the things this fraudster is going on about, this is not on the list of things I would say points to fraud - possibly just another example of how he doesn't really understand his own tech very well.

The blatant lying about the completeness of the vehicles, lies about solar capacity, lies about customers, lies about actual technical capability, lies about customer orders and deal flow ... all of that is point blank unforgivable.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by vsareto on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:17AM (#24543767)
It's a founder saying dumb things about his own product. That's incredibly worrying since he holds all of the access to all of the employees to get his facts straight - it's obvious he just didn't make use of that. He burned his precious few chances to lead a company in the public eye.

Most of us armchair CEOs would burn our chances just as easily, but it's still important to not be clueless.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by iNate2000 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:14AM (#24543722)
Also, how do we know that the quote is even accurate? If the CEO misstates some technical jargon, what’s the likelihood that the reporter from an unrelated field is going to get the misstatement correct?