News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by new_realist on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:54AM (#24544833)
1,433 days since Elon Musk started charging Tesla customers for 'self driving' that he said would be able to drive from Los Angeles to New York city with no human intervention by the end of 2017.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ChuckMcM on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:38PM (#24545455)
Not to be an apologist for Tesla here, while Elon has made some pretty explicit statements here the ordering page for cars has always said "equipment capability" and pretty accurately described it was the required equipment for when the capability was available.

And yes, there is an implicit problem there where you can't definitively know this is all of the equipment you need until the capability is released, but I suspect Tesla would have provided any additional upgrades for free if and when they release "auto-drive."

I thought of it kind of like "cable ready" TVs (not that most people reading this would have heard of those :-)) that were TVs that could, in theory, use cable. However, the cable standard wasn't finalized and there was a chance that what came out in the standard would not be compatible with these TVs.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:13PM (#24547235)
> Not to be an apologist for Tesla here, while Elon has made some pretty explicit statements here the ordering page for cars has always said "equipment capability" and pretty accurately described it was the required equipment for when the capability was available.

Right, and he's also made explicit statements that you could FSD "by the end of 2016", "by the end of 2018", "by the end of 2020", coast to coast.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:45PM (#24548814)
> Right, and he's also made explicit statements that you could FSD "by the end of 2016", "by the end of 2018", "by the end of 2020", coast to coast.

That isn't out or character for Musk. He's always set and communicate unrealistic timeline. That doesn't make him a fraud. Take Falcon Heavy:

> By 2008, SpaceX had been aiming for the first launch of Falcon 9 in 2009, while "Falcon 9 Heavy would be in a couple of years". Speaking at the 2008 Mars Society Conference, Musk also indicated that he expected a hydrogen-fueled upper stage would follow 2–3 years later (which would have been around 2013) - [0]

Of course Falcon Heavy didn't fly until Feb 2018, and hydrogen-fueled upper stage never materialized. Still, nobody care about that today. FH is a resounding success and are qualified to be used for NASA's Lunar Gateway and Space Force's National Security Space Launch program, which are as good as stamps of approval can get.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:55PM (#24548889)
I never said he was a fraud, though I am cynical.

But you can't hand wave away his statements on Twitter as "Oh, that's just Elon, all Tesla's corporate statements have very explicitly (in at times very fine print) said it's contingent on 'capability' and 'regulation'" when Tesla have literally said "Elon's Twitter _is_ a Tesla corporate statement".

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:09PM (#24550206)
> But you can't hand wave away his statements on Twitter as "Oh, that's just Elon, all Tesla's corporate statements have very explicitly (in at times very fine print) said it's contingent on 'capability' and 'regulation'" when Tesla have literally said "Elon's Twitter _is_ a Tesla corporate statement".

Yes and no. His settlement with SEC only requires vetting for tweets that have material impact to investors. Anything else is just his opinion, although I agree that's a very fine line - [0]

Take his tweet sent out today about Battery Day event tomorrow:

> Important note about Tesla Battery Day unveil tomorrow. This affects long-term production, especially Semi, Cybertruck & Roadster, but what we announce will not reach serious high-volume production until 2022 - [1]

Clearly a vetted communication. A less serious one in contrast:

> Bitte arbeiten Sie bei Tesla Giga Berlin! Es wird super Spaß machen!! - [2]

[0] - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/apr/26/tesla-elo...

[1] - https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1308148212876812289

[2] - https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1304175179606695937

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by serf on Monday September 21, 2020 @08:07PM (#24549683)
> That doesn't make him a fraud.

Why not?

What is the point of deadlines then?

Being a fraud doesn't mean you fail to deliver.

fraud: 'wrongful or criminal deception intended to result in financial or personal gain.'

He promises deadlines to soothe shareholders. I don't see the difference in his behavior and fraudulent behavior, other than that he has a large fan-base to validate the behavior.

He profits from promises that aren't delivered.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:33PM (#24550319)
> What is the point of deadlines then?

I don't pretend to know his motivation, perhaps his misplaced optimism? or to motivate and set the guideline for his troop? or to indicate Tesla's priority and direction?

Do you think JFK knew for sure that American would reach the moon before the end of 1960s? Or for that matter, I suppose you'd consider NASA to be fraudulent if Artemis program fails to send a crewed mission to the Moon in 2024.

> Being a fraud doesn't mean you fail to deliver.

Fraud usually means all talk and no substance. Can you give a counter example?

> He profits from promises that aren't delivered.

You need to show the evidence of this

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by ChuckMcM on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:47PM (#24547634)
I was trying to distinguish between what Elon said vs what the company said in its corporate communications. In Tesla's case the corporate comms types seem to be more honest. In the Nikola case both the CEO and the company comms were misleading.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by FireBeyond on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:54PM (#24547702)
> I was trying to distinguish between what Elon said vs what the company said in its corporate communications.

The problem with that is that Tesla has declared to the SEC that @elonmusk on Twitter is an "official company communication channel". That's why he's gotten in trouble for past tweets.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by JamesSwift on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:30PM (#24546100)
Isn't this argument of "technically correct" semantics exactly what Milton argued for the nikola truck rolling down the hill? Why pillory him and not Elon for the same?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by sangnoir on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:46PM (#24548821)
Milton was absolutely, "technically correct": the Nikola truck was in motion (the video was announced as "The Nikola Truck in motion). What you take away and what was said are 2 completely different things, and the message is specifically crafted to do just that.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valuearb on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:00PM (#24547773)
Because there is a difference between misleading people that an empty shell is a functioning truck, and perpetually claiming you are on the verge of fully autonomous driving, when you only achieve mostly autonomous driving.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by kanox on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:04PM (#24544974)
Being late does not make you a fraud.

Tesla does have a real team working on self driving hardware and software and they're shipping it inside cars.

It's not clear that Nikola has much more than powerpoint. They got a lot of impressive-sounding partnerships going but so did Theranos.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by itsoktocry on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:15PM (#24545120)
>Being late does not make you a fraud.

Then you can literally say anything and claim "just not yet!".

Amazing people say things like this with a straight face.

>It's not clear that Nikola has much more than powerpoint.

Nikola has real teams working on real things, too. They are just nowhere near where they claim to be.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by kanox on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:09PM (#24547870)
It's extremely common across all industries for projects to be late or underdeliver. How can you claim with a straight face that this is the same as fraud?

> Nikola has real teams working on real things, too.

Their technology claims are all over the place and includes a large lineup of electric and hydrogen-powered vehicles that would be impressive even for GM and Ford.

I don't think their leadership plans to deliver all of any of those vehicles. Insiders (including Trevor Milton) have cashed out already and it looks more like a pump-and-dump scheme than a real business.

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jryle70 on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:23PM (#24548633)
> Then you can literally say anything and claim "just not yet!".

> Amazing people say things like this with a straight face.

Then literally everyone who claims breakthrough in fusion, new energy, medicine, AI, robotics, supersonic travel, would qualify as fraud. Fusion has always been X years away after all.

You've just also described many space projects, notably JWST and SLS. Granted, I'll give you SLS.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Webb_Space_Telescope

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System

> Nikola has real teams working on real things, too. They are just nowhere near where they claim to be.

The trouble is Trevor didn't just say "just not yet!". He insisted that the Nikola One on stage at their Dec 2016 presentation is real, with this vivid description: "I don’t want someone to end up doing something and driving this truck off the stage…so we’re going to try to keep people from driving off. But this thing fully functions and works, which is really incredible."

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by 52-6F-62 on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:14PM (#24546603)
> Then you can literally say anything and claim "just not yet!".

To play a little devil's advocate, then...

Wouldn't that put most startups and Silicon Valley into the "fraud" camp?

Net positive revenue is always coming and funds are continuously raised on that promise...

Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by valuearb on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:01PM (#24547784)
When did Elon fake a video of a Tesla autonomously driving cross country?
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by jesseb on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:10PM (#24545882)
Zero days since somebody brought up Musk in a completely unrelated conversation.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by JamesSwift on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:31PM (#24546123)
Nikola/Milton and Tesla/Musk are inextricably linked. I mean... its even in the name.
Re:Nikola’s founder steps down from board as company faces f... by rorykoehler on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:55AM (#24544848)