News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by petee on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:23AM (#23957689)
Somehow I feel good about this. The article claims nothing good can come of deleting exposed databases, but I strongly disagree - I'd by far rather my data be deleted than stolen and shared. If the owner doesn't have proper backups AND can't secure a database, they have no business hosting such data, period. IMHO.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:58PM (#23958391)
I think this is a little simplistic. Depending on what data is being deleted, it may have real life economic consequences for individual people. What if one of the databases has a record of credits you've purchased at your local spin studio? Hopefully they have a back up, but if they don't, you and/or the owners stand to make significant losses. Are there databases that could be lost without consequence except to their owner? Sure. But that is far from all of them.

I also just think it is a little uncharitable to wish harm on people simply because whoever did their IT was inexpert at their job? Like, how does the local mom and pop correctly evaluate a person's IT chops? The nephew says they can set up their website for cheap, and they want to be nice, so they give him the job. Turns out he's a newb and later their database gets deleted and you are on here saying that's a good thing? Hrm. I don't agree.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by Drakim on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:03PM (#23958423)
It can definitely have real world consequences, but couldn't the same be said for somebody being a whistleblower for a company that doesn't following building codes? The company could take a huge financial hit and people might lose their jobs because of their practices being exposed.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:06PM (#23958440)
Sometimes the best path forward does harm, sure. It's just hard for me to agree that deleting these databases is the harm-minimizing path. One example of a less harmful path that comes to mind immediately is installing a random password on the unsecured database and emailing the domain owner the password. That would cause downtime but it would limit the irreversible damage. You could even say that you will delete the database if it is found again with an unsecured password, if you wanted to add some stick to your carrot. It does not seem like this attack has harm-minimization in mind.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by pojzon on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:22PM (#23958535)
What you propose is illegal in most 1st/2nd world countries. In mine, the company could thank you and then put you straight to jail for 30 years. Unfortunately very few small businesses run sade reporting programs and often react with attack.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:32PM (#23958613)
So is deleting a database.

Putting a password and emailing the admin would solve the password problem.

But I agree doing anything is probably illegal. I would leave it... not worth hassle of wearing the superman cape.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by TeMPOraL on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:56PM (#23958815)
The problem is with the e-mailing part. A mom&pop is unlikely to track you down if you lock out their DB, but they'll likely report you to police if you contact them about it.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by Wowfunhappy on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:33PM (#23959090)
Is an email from an anonymous address easier to trace than remote database commands?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by edoceo on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:25PM (#23959915)
Yes. You need good logging on the vulnerable DB to trace the command - and if your DB is vulnerable it's a good bet you forgot the logging too.

Emails have a bunch of info in the headers, so there is more meta-data in the email it self.

Neither is perfect for finding the culprit but one scenario has zero meta-data and the other has some.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jfk13 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:03PM (#23958880)
How about simply emailing the admin to tell them their database is unsecured? Oh, but that would be benign; I'm sure vandalism is so much more fun.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by achillean on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:06PM (#23960181)
Unfortunately it's rarely that simple. If you look at the currently exposed MongoDB instances you'll see that most of them are in the cloud without any obvious attribution. You could email the cloud providers and see if they will reach out to the end-user but chances are they already know about it. Here's an article I wrote on that subject, although it was related to industrial control systems:

https://blog.shodan.io/taking-things-offline-is-hard/

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by vincnetas on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:39PM (#23959118)
“Fix auth”. Add item to todo list and just forget because there are other more pressing tasks to do.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by sgift on Monday July 27, 2020 @04:30AM (#23963219)
It's easy to say "you could have just emailed them" when you are not the one doing this for years without things getting better. Often admins flat out ignore you. Even if not they usually do nothing. And if they do something it takes ages.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jfk13 on Monday July 27, 2020 @11:49AM (#23966239)
I don't doubt that for a moment; I have also reported issues of various kinds -- not this specific one -- that have gone unresolved for ages.

That still doesn't justify vandalism.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by bpfrh on Monday July 27, 2020 @08:23AM (#23964388)
In the article one provider was notified that their database was without a password an publicly accessible.

They secured it, and somehow managed to make it publicly accessible again without password, this time it got hit by this attack.

Honestly this is like if a company decides to keep their paper records with my information on a public side walk, and somebody saw that and decided to bring them to the landfill.

Is it legal or fair? In a perfect world no, but at this point the company is not blameless.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:51PM (#23958781)
I certainly think the most legal approach is to do nothing except notify, or maybe nothing at all. But if you must modify the database, locking it reversibly is more defensible morally.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cheerlessbog on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:29PM (#23959054)
Or just set everyone's password to the same thing eg SecureMe
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by phkahler on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:16PM (#23959411)
>> but couldn't the same be said for somebody being a whistleblower for a company that doesn't following building codes?

No. The equivalent would be exploiting their buildings weakness to cause them to collapse - maybe with people in them.

Pointing out a vulnerability is not the same as demonstrating it.

That said, a demonstration will get their attention more.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by octodog on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:46PM (#23960431)
Your comparison isn't fair - blowing the whistle is supposed to be a last resort. Internal disclosure and attempting to fix the issue collaboratively is always the first step.

This attack is indiscriminate and is without warning, so it eliminates the possibility for database owners to fix the problem in good faith.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Monday July 27, 2020 @10:00AM (#23965140)
Finally, after years and years and years of being told over and over and the bottom line never improving.

I got doxxed with the Equifax breach. How many other companies in the world will take someone's word that they are me based on that data, and what potential is there for my life amongst millions of others to go completely sideways because of companies who won't addmit the systems are broken?

I say the house is already burning, but maybe throwing some fireworks into the blaze will convince the right parties to finally put the damn fire out.

Beyond sick and tired of breach after breach after breach after "oh, there were millions of voter records showing publicly" "no, <insert product name> defaults to no security"

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by TallGuyShort on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:25PM (#23958553)
Just because it's understandable for Mom & Pop to not care about the privacy of the people whose data they've collected doesn't make it a good idea. They should care. If the buck doesn't stop with business owners, with whom does it stop?

IMO we specialize too much and miss important things that we mentally outsource to other people. I'm equally disturbed how often I meet people in tech who are unable to do basic home repairs or cook for themselves. Something, like say, a few weeks of quarantine, and people's anxiety goes through the roof because they've relied on other people for basic life skills.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by mcv on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:09PM (#23958454)
I don't find your example very convincing. Any database storing personal data needs to be properly secured, and if that gym also has ID credit card or other more sensitive data, that data might better be destroyed than stolen.

If it's a publicly accessible wiki with no sensitive data whatsoever, and that's meant to be publicly accessible, then there's a reasonable excuse for the poor security and it's not helping anyone to destroy it.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:19PM (#23958519)
There is no indication in this article that all of the databases had personal data.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by nxpnsv on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:15PM (#23958491)
Why should innocent users be punished? Why not just send a pic confirming you have full db access? This is just unnecessary vandalism.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by tsimionescu on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:53PM (#23959672)
The point is that, if my credit card info is staying in a web-exposed, insecure DB, it is safer for me that it be destroyed than left alone.

I have no idea of that is the intention of the attackers, or if they are maybe even stealing the info before deleting it. But assuming they were good Samaritans and just deleting it, that is the best outcome for me as a user, better than if it stayed up for another day.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by katbyte on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:33PM (#23959971)
Because often that doesn’t actually elicit change. Deleting the data over and over does.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:37PM (#23958669)
Somehow that would be worse. Feels like a ransom call.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jb775 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:06PM (#23958901)
What happens when mom & pop are storing your name and credit card # in plain text and then your identity gets stolen and credit ruined? Should we still be "charitable" to them and their d-bag nephew?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jrockway on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:34PM (#23959096)
Your credit card number being stolen is a problem for your bank, not a problem for you. You can't steal someone's identity with a credit card number.

The concern in this case is when there is some social problem with being in Mom & Pop Inc's customer database. There are probably some people that buy some things that they don't want other people to know about. When the database gets hacked and you are linked to being their customer, that is the unfortunate and potentially damaging information leak. A credit card just gets reissued and the bank reverses the transaction. No big deal.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gowld on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:01PM (#23959299)
It's a problem for the vendors, not the banks. They get hit with chargebacks for fraud that's no fault of their own, hurting the whole ecosystem of vendors and their customers.

https://www.thestreet.com/personal-finance/credit-cards/cred...

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lotsofpulp on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:20PM (#23960277)
The problem could be easily solved by Visa/MC/Discover/Amex implementing chip and pin, or at least 2FA SMS authorization. Bestbuy.com has it working somehow.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Sunday July 26, 2020 @07:26PM (#23960934)
These people can't configure a firewall. How are they going to implement payments in the secure fashion you suggest?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lotsofpulp on Sunday July 26, 2020 @08:39PM (#23961298)
I meant that Visa/MC/Discover/AmEx should be forcing the use of chip and Pin or other 2FA methods.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by owaty on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:05PM (#23960539)
> Your credit card number being stolen is a problem for your bank, not a problem for you.

Not necessarily, depending on where you're based.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by TwoBit on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:56PM (#23959700)
It's still a PITA when my credit card has to be swapped.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by rightbyte on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:18PM (#23958975)
Ye it is not like I trust my credit card to strangers and let them walk away with it for a while.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by Tade0 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:16PM (#23958499)
Like, how does the local mom and pop correctly evaluate a person's IT chops?

Usually by price and unfortunately both mom and pop like a bargain - I've seen this play out more times than I would like.

Also how do you evaluate, say, a landscaper's chops? Or any other kind of contractor's for that matter? By doing research beforehand, checking what kind of reputation that person has etc.

Low-effort or lack of research gives you bad services, for which you pay in losses like these.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by evilduck on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:37PM (#23958663)
In construction and landscaping work those companies are usually licensed, bonded and insured. If they fuck up the work there's obvious financial recourse. Also, the measure of them fucking up is generally a lot clearer for physical labor and for mom and pop businesses, getting construction work inspected by a 3rd party is usually more straightforward and cheaper.

In software, financial recourse generally means you have to jump straight to lawsuits. There's no licensing for who's qualified to build a website, developers don't have to escrow funds or carry malpractice insurance in case they make a mistake, a development business should have insurance in place but there's not always easy or affordable ways to assign fault in most IT situations if you want to pursue them. Software and IT forensics are prohibitively costly and usually mean a lot of money has to be on the line which rule out mom and pop businesses entirely. IT and software mistakes also usually take longer to rear their heads, and people in IT and software also aren't known for sticking around for decades. How do you sue an LLC that dissolved 5 years ago?

It's apples and oranges in my opinion.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by bcrosby95 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:37PM (#23959113)
If someone does a shitty job in home improvement stuff it's usually not visible for years down the line. And good luck with your recourse by then. I've never heard of a homeowner getting recourse unless it's insanely obviously bad right away. The vast majority end up just living with the defects or hiring someone else to do the job again.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wott on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:39PM (#23959584)
10-years warranty is a thing and is mandatory in some places/countries.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by Tade0 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:52PM (#23958785)
I don't how it is in the US, but in my country an audit that would reveal such an obvious lack of security costs no more than the equivalent of a single minimum salary - usually much less. On top of that several companies that offer such services are widely known because their media presence is mostly articles about vulnerabilities in routers, phones, operating systems etc.

I hail from a post-communist country so I assumed the culture in the US is more developed in this regard.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by evilduck on Monday July 27, 2020 @12:05AM (#23962157)
I'm not sure what your country's going rates are but for the US, a small business might budget a few thousand dollars total for their website. A minimal security audit that would catch missing or stupid security would basically double their expenses. Unless they truly needed some custom feature they'd take one look at a security auditor's quotes and then go sign up for Wix or Squarespace immediately. It's not that the services don't exist, its just that they're expensive and typical non-technology business websites don't really need that much put into them.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Sunday July 26, 2020 @07:28PM (#23960943)
If regular citizens of your nation can get a COVID test back in less than two weeks, you should consider yourselves more developed than USA.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cm2187 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:25PM (#23958559)
I am thinking more about the clients of the mom and pop shop who are better off not having their personal details exposed.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by markovbot on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:41PM (#23958705)
> Are there databases that could be lost without consequence except to their owner

I would certainly hope the owner of the insecure database would face massive consequences. IMO there's not _nearly_ enough of that. This sort of breach should be financially ruinous for _any_ company.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by mod on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:45PM (#23958732)
What if the database only contains my blog posts? Or my own personal health information I'm tracking? Or all the Hearthstone cards? Or any other of the infinite data sets that are totally insignificant to anyone beyond the owner of the database?

Not everything is about you, and also you totally misunderstood the post you quoted.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by petee on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:02PM (#23958873)
Then you'll learn real quick to secure your database, make backups, or not post personal stuff online.

And if you've configured your database that poorly, am I supposed to assume you've properly configured your server against becoming part of a DDoS attack? Or a bot net? The base level of negligence you're defending enables a multitude of attacks. Losing your DB would be an immediate sign you don't know what you're doing, and thus shouldn't be doing it.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jaggirs on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:26PM (#23958563)
The possibility of someone stealing your identity (or worse) far outweighs the damages from losing some coupons.

Deleting exposed databases is genious, there need to be real repercussions for companies if they leak user data.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by MattGaiser on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:30PM (#23958591)
> The possibility of someone stealing your identity (or worse) far outweighs the damages from losing some coupons.

That is a very rich person statement.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:14PM (#23958954)
Fine, what about every poor person who gets their data stolen from an unsecured database, and gets their identity stolen?

Yours is also a rich person statement.

Unsecured databases are a huge loss for everyone.

Anything that forces a shift in this naive behavior of vendors, implementors and executives is not just fine by me, I welcome it. If my life suffers because of data of mine that's lost from companies' databases, I now know who to cease doing business with.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by tsimionescu on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:55PM (#23959696)
Not really, it's much easier for rich people to reclaim their identity than it is for poor people.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jb775 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:56PM (#23958825)
But what about the companies making millions in profit each year that are carelessly exposing sensitive data because they don't want to spend a little more on quality IT work?

No one wants to see their local pizza shop lose their pizza-credit database, but if that's the price to pay for data security then so be it.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:27PM (#23959035)
> What if one of the databases has a record of credits you've purchased at your local spin studio?

Usually when you buy something, you get an email receipt. So you print out your email receipt and go to the mom and pop store.

Given they are a local mom and pop store, you likely have a long term relationship with them and they may even remember you buying credits. So it will be a hassle, but likely ok.

It is the huge corporate stores that don’t have long term relationships that would be hurt by this thing the most.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday July 26, 2020 @10:25PM (#23961770)
Depending on what data is being deleted, not deleting it could also have significantly worse consequences when it later falls into the wrong hands.

In the case of the spin studio, you can prove what you paid, the owner just lost his evidence of what he no longer owes you, and will hopefully in the future stop exposing your personal data on the Internet.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by boomlinde on Monday July 27, 2020 @11:30AM (#23966034)
> Like, how does the local mom and pop correctly evaluate a person's IT chops?

Not my problem.

> The nephew says they can set up their website for cheap, and they want to be nice, so they give him the job. Turns out he's a newb and later their database gets deleted and you are on here saying that's a good thing? Hrm. I don't agree.

Mom and pop prefer nepotism over skill, credentials and reputation, without even a second opinion. There is a reason that this is frowned upon (and has been for at least some 2000 years before mom and pop were born), regardless of the domain.

On the off chance that their database doesn't contain any personally identifying information on their customers, this is an idiot tax. In any other case, their loss is completely justified when compared to the potential losses, abuse and manipulation of their customers that come with exposing their PII to the public.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by abbadadda on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:40PM (#23960715)
lol im sorry but this is probably not the best go-to example of real world consequences:

> What if one of the databases has a record of credits you've purchased at your local spin studio?

p.s. bobby tables did it first

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by birdyrooster on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:33PM (#23958626)
A spin class? Really that is the best example you can come up with? That is not at all compelling.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:40PM (#23958685)
What part of the example do you dispute? Spin studios have databases, like almost all small businesses these days.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by birdyrooster on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:47PM (#23958758)
If I knew we were frying fish this small Id a brought a different pan
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:58PM (#23958840)
4000 small fish is a lot of biomass.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by glckr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:31AM (#23957764)
No other bad actors can get it, but we don't know if it's already been found, and now that it's gone we have no idea what data is out in the wild. And as you note, we can't trust the companies to accurately report it themselves.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by petee on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:40AM (#23957859)
I think you make an important point though - deleted or not, there is no real way to know what's been exposed, and no guarantee that they'll ever admit it; so torch all the data expeditiously, and we'll just have to comb through 'successful' leaks just as always.

Another side is that with their database blanked, that will force more companies to explain their downtime or complete loss of data, rather than quietly secure it again and pretend nothing happened

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by HappyDreamer on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:28PM (#23958185)
Maybe this actor A downloaded the data, then deleted the database, preventing others from accessing and selling the same data? Only A can sell this data now?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by na85 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:51PM (#23958333)
So, no difference other than the company now has to explain that their database was insecure. Got it.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by DyslexicAtheist on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:38AM (#23957846)
maybe the authors of meow should "improve" it with a feature that reports every instance to HIBP before deleting it. that is if their intention with this malware was a benevolent one :) but I guess feature iteration in malware that is "supposed to be good" would be tricky
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by mkagenius on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:05PM (#23958039)
> reports every instance to HIBP

no, that doesn't make sense if its only meow who found it. And since there is no way to know that, it does not make sense to mail a copy to hibp

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:17PM (#23958971)
Oh, they'll have to say something when they suddenly stop doing business until a backup can get pulled, and the new db instances actually secured before putting them up again.

Even a bland 'we lost parts of our data and we will have to start recovery processes. please stand by' is a signal.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by Alex3917 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:40AM (#23957861)
Ideally they'd report it so that password managers could warn everyone, but with just the database URI there isn't necessarily any obvious way to know what domain or business its associated with.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by GekkePrutser on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:32PM (#23958207)
Doesn't really matter, as long as the credential is exposed, users can be warned. No matter where it came from.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wtracy on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:57PM (#23958388)
If the attacker can write to the DB, then they can add entries to every table with the string "Hey your database is unsecured!"
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by klyrs on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:20PM (#23958993)
> Somehow I feel good about this.

For me, it's not exactly "good." But I am more upset with the database owners than I am with the kitties. Don't leave the barn door open, or this (or worse) will happen to you, and happen again. If they were instead exfiltrating and selling the data, the equation would change. I'm not saying the cats are doing good, but I do say that the "responsible adults" did the greatest harm by not cat-proofing their databases that contain PII.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by derefr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:11PM (#23958075)
I'm ambivalent about this action in most cases, but in some specific cases there can be a clear reason to have an exposed database: namely when the database is a guest-accessible, read-only repository of public data, i.e. the self-hosted equivalent of publishing a Google BigQuery dataset.

As someone who runs such a "public-access data library" myself, I would be slightly annoyed if someone came along and burned it down, just because it has an unpatched vulnerability.

...but if it got deleted because I left default admin creds on it, though, that'd be my own fault.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jmvoodoo on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:13PM (#23958088)
Databases that are read only would be unaffected by this attack.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by derefr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:18PM (#23958109)
Read-only in practice, not inherently read-only in the way that e.g. CD-ROM is. Such systems still need to have their otherwise-static dataset updated "online" by an ETL pipeline agent-user. Which often means, in the DBMSes with less fine-grained security models, that such users need to have full DML (and even DDL) capabilities, rather than only insert capability.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by dtech on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:35PM (#23958229)
This attack was only possible on databases with unsecured or weakly secured read-write access.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by koonsolo on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:55PM (#23958813)
Who says it's consumer data? It can be a personal project, a blog, etc.

Just because it's not secure doesn't mean you should delete the data, because where does such reasoning end?

Reminds me of the super meat boy web version with database creds in client. Dev knew, but just did a quick implementation. Hacker wanted to prove his point and ruined it for everybody. Making a secure version was not worth the effort, so now because of this prick nobody could enjoy it.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by bhargav on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:36AM (#23957822)
This also affected people who use software for things other than businesses. People with IoT apps for their home, researchers, etc.

Our field is vast and there is a large variance in people just using the basics of CS and those who keep up with standards and best practices, etc.

Your statement is basically akin to someone saying that it’s fine for people to get robbed if they went out with their wallet; or worse.. killed.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by HomeDeLaPot on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:47AM (#23957920)
Yeah. I don't care if some big business loses their Elasticsearch data and their site stops working until they get it secured and re-hydrated with data from their relational database. Good, they learned a lesson.

But I would feel bad if someone's small business had to shut down or lose a bunch of money because they lost all their customer data. I'd feel bad if someone lost all the data they'd been using for a personal project. If they didn't have backups and proper security, shame on them, but ideally they would be contacted and given advice. Ideally, their data would only be deleted if the effect would be minimal.

On the other hand, if this is something that happens consistently -- all unsecured databases get deleted immediately -- maybe the data would be stolen less and everyone would have to learn their lesson early...

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by donmcronald on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:21PM (#23958129)
> But I would feel bad if someone's small business had to shut down or lose a bunch of money because they lost all their customer data.

Don't. When businesses of any size cut corners and provide services they aren't qualified to provide, it gives them an advantage compared to businesses that try to do it properly. They make more money or charge less and can often out compete competent owners. They'll also be the first ones to brag about how brilliant they are at business (in my experience).

Small businesses are no exception. Delete away IMO.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by 52-6F-62 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:53PM (#23959244)
Said small businesses might have no idea their data wasn’t secure. That would be on whoever developed their technology, not necessarily the business. Not all small businesses with customer or sales data is a technology company.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by donmcronald on Monday July 27, 2020 @01:22AM (#23962450)
Good point. You're right. I was really only thinking about tech companies that are doing their own deployments, but I guess there's plenty of room for collateral damage where people don't deserve it.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by hombre_fatal on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:18PM (#23958510)
Seems like a lost opportunity to have a more nuanced position here. And when you can't think of a single case that could make you feel bad for someone, it's usually a sign that you don't have one.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by acdha on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:07PM (#23958051)
I’d feel bad if someone’s hobby project was deleted. Small businesses losing customer data is only slightly more sympathetic than people getting sick because they didn’t think the health code applied to them.

If you collect it, you need to be responsible for keeping it safe. Anything affected by this is already exposed and has to be assumed to have been breached.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by Wowfunhappy on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:18PM (#23958508)
What if it was a small business's inventory data rather than customer data?

Seems to me, there are a lot of things businesses could store in a database which don't necessarily need to be private, or which at worst won't harm anyone other than the database creator if exposed.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by acdha on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:31PM (#23958603)
That’s why I was specific about customer data: it’s basically a question of who’s harmed - if the cost is borne by the person cutting corners it’s more of a self-correcting problem.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by atyppo on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:35PM (#23960368)
It's not a matter of "cutting corners." Think of all of the small businesses that recently moved online due to store closures. These businesses simply do not have the budget required to create something comparable to, say, Best Buy's e-commerce. Sure, Shopify might come close, but how do you think Mom and Pop will find and create an e-commerce solution?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by acdha on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:00PM (#23960510)
That’s the very definition of cutting corners. If they aren’t confident of their ability to operate safely they need to either hire a professional or go without - just as not wanting to pay a plumber doesn’t exempt you from meeting the health code or saving on accountants will be a get out of jail free card when you get audited.

If it sounds like I’m unsympathetic, yes, that’s true. Playing around with building your own database is a good learning experience but that changes once you expose other people to your mistakes. I’ve also dealt with a few small businesses and the people trying to run a business like this are always trying to save a buck - they’re the same ones who stiff contractors, avoid paying overtime, do their own taxes creatively, etc. If you have a successful business, you’ll drop a few bucks on Shopify, Wix, etc. to focus on the business rather than a distraction.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by atyppo on Monday July 27, 2020 @12:00AM (#23962131)
Think how easy it is to take advantage of grandma for "tech support," whether it be from India or at a seedy computer repair shop. It wouldn't surprise me to hear that the majority of small business owners have never heard of Shopify or Wix, as they are more likely to turn to someone they trust, whether that be a "tech-literate" cousin or a local service. Keep in mind that many of these businesses didn't even have websites a few months ago, let alone e-commerce solutions. Not everyone lives in SV or NYC and is perennially exposed to their ads.

I agree that these businesses shouldn't be doing this by themselves, but the tech industry shares some culpability. It should be ingrained in people's heads to think of security first. Most people outside the SV bubble are still using [SO or pet's name]123 as their password. I go to a university in NYC. I've tried to convince several (college) friends to use password managers to no avail. This isn't just a problem endemic in old people. Someone needs to "mainstream" good security. A good start would come from, say, Apple, by including security keys with new iPhones, as much of a pipe dream as that might be.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by paulie_a on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:09PM (#23958066)
Personally I hope this becomes so common place that it doesnt even make the news.

Like the old days with slammer or codered

It took 13 seconds for a freshly installed windows box to be owned when it was put online. Let those days return.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by colonwqbang on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:53PM (#23958355)
> Yeah, I don't care if a big chain restaurant is closed down for having too poor hygiene. But I would feel bad if someone's small restaurant had to shut down because the cook doesn't bother to wash his hands at work.

If you are holding other people's data for them, you have a responsibility to do your best to keep the data safe. If you don't know how to do that and don't have time to learn, you can hire someone who is more knowledgeable.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:28PM (#23958576)
And what about the responsibility to not destroy someone's property?

Do you have the same opinion about shoplifters walking away with merchandise? Would your argument be that there should be armed guards and searches in every retail store? Isn't it reasonable that a thief be criticized and penalized for their actions even if the theft was "easy" to commit and is it OK to blame the victim for not being prepared?

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by smichel17 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:27PM (#23959040)
Agree with nkrisc -- this is like, if I contracted with a storage company, and then my stuff was vandalized because the company's "secure storage location" was an unlocked box out on the sidewalk. Obviously the vandal is directly to blame, but it's also absolutely negligence from the company.

I'm sympathetic for the people who were only storing their own data, but not for companies that failed to safeguard their customers' data. If I borrow stuff from friends, I take better care of it than if it were mine. I hold companies to the same standard.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:48PM (#23959199)
I'm not trying to disregard the negligence concern but I am trying to ensure that the perpetrator is also called out. Several of the top rated comments on this article are praising the perpetrator.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by colonwqbang on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:42PM (#23960032)
You will notice that in my post I'm not defending the people behind the meow attacks. I agree, they are very much in the wrong.

But being careless with other people's data is also wrong and we should not feel bad for companies whose negligent practices backfire on them. That is what I was trying to highlight with my analogy.

Like bacteria, there will always be bad actors trying to exploit poor security. If not these attackers, then someone else. That is why we have security measures.

The people we should feel bad for are the individual customers affected.

Ps also, there is a big difference between being careless with your own property (your analogy) and someone else's property/data/wellbeing (my analogy and the case at hand).

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by nkrisc on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:43PM (#23958714)
But it's my personal and sensitive data that they are poor stewards of, not their property.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:23PM (#23959011)
I agree but I don't think that changes my point that the person who destroys the data has more culpability than the storage service in the destruction of the data.

There tends to be a pass given to people destroying data and I don't think that is right.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by colonwqbang on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:55PM (#23960106)
I agree, but I think it's beside the point.

As engineers we have to assume that there is always someone out there looking to break into our systems. We don't get to blame them for our failure to secure our systems.

For us to be angry at the hackers is as fruitless as it would be for the unhygienic cook to be angry at the bacteria.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:10PM (#23960216)
Why are you making the assumption that I'm making the point "as an engineer" as opposed to just a citizen who thinks it is reasonable to expect people not do destroy something that doesn't belong to them?

Your analogy about bacteria doesn't make any sense, we don't expect the bacteria to be actively seeking out unhygienic cooks. If you want to use your analogy it would be like having someone shake the cook's hand in order to put a mild irritant on their hands so that when they prepare food without washing or gloving their hands the irritant is spread to the food, thus highlighting the fact that the chef wasn't following good hygiene. Would you expect that behavior to be excused? Would you be OK with that if you were the one throwing up?

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by colonwqbang on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:47PM (#23960442)
You're presumably an engineer, I'm an engineer, this is an engineering forum. That is why I may have "assumed you made the point as an engineer".

It sounds as if you think I'm defending the attackers. I'm not. I'm pointing out that the presence of malicious actors is a fact of life on the Internet, like it or not.

I'm not going to take my analogy further. I think it's reasonably clear what I meant.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by aledalgrande on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:32PM (#23959080)
I'm not sure wiping out data from these unsecured databases is the answer, but even for amateur installations which have data of no relevance, the database could be used for nefarious things or the machine itself it runs on could be taken over and used for things such as DDOS attacks.

In that sense, receiving a strong notification that your compute is available to anyone and you should secure it is a good thing.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by bhawks on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:48AM (#23957929)
This is more akin to a person knowing the basics of driving a car but not which side of the road to use or what to do at a traffic light. They are a danger to themselves and others, the others in this case being the users of whatever services the unsecured databases provide.

My sympathy for people learning the basics of our field and missing a few points stops when others are harmed.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by pizza234 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:04PM (#23958032)
Although the parent's analogy is arguably flawed, there's a very good point in the fact that there are users who are not involved in the implementation of the service - "People with IoT apps for their home". They're not drivers, to follow the driving analogy.

It's unrealistic to expect that the population at large starts to pay a significant attention, in particular because the services/gadgets are a black box. How does one know if a device is safe? A layman surely can't; even somebody who's "just a dev" likely can't.

Given the large-scale nature, probably some form of regulation would be the most realistic mitigation. Following the analogy, such users are taxi clients, and for similar reasons, taxis are regulated.

With that in mind, certainly the engineering side of the equation should be held accountable. But it seems that the market is not punishing it at all.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by bhargav on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:20PM (#23958126)
Yup. My point is some people might not even know that their database is accessible from the web lol. It’s pretty easy to follow a tutorial or get something OOTB that’s not secure, so we shouldn’t be saying we’re glad this happened. Even if it’s big businesses, what if said businesses were storing important data such as health records?

I think the learn by failing is a good mentality but was hoping we can be mindful of the fact that this harms more than just the “big bad man”

Edit: Addendum for a more thoughtful discussion, it would be great if these databases and tools provided some default security OOTB requiring no configuration whatsoever. Example: rather than creating user and password with root, is rather have some CMS site generate a random one!

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by rapind on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:40PM (#23958261)
Legislation is just so far behind. User data is useful, but there should be requirements before you can just accumulate it. Cars are useful too but require a licence and insurance to drive.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by DoofusOfDeath on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:50PM (#23959654)
> Given the large-scale nature, probably some form of regulation would be the most realistic mitigation.

Rather than regulation, how about trademark-protected certification? I.e., similar to what Underwriter Laboratories ("UL") does for consumer electrical products in the U.S.?

Except rather than the government requiring certification by UL or similar, organizations could simply decide for themselves whether or not to use uncertified products. And perhaps insurance companies could price certification status into relevant policies.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by fiddlerwoaroof on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:21PM (#23958138)
IoT is unlikely to be affected, unless the device goes out of its way to expose its database via upnp
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by whoisthemachine on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:49PM (#23958324)
This is my thought - why would an IoT device expose a database publicly? And if so, shouldn't the companies producing those devices not be following such bad practices? Maybe the consumer who bought such a device should go to the manufacturer and complain about being sold an inherently insecure device.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by hobs on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:41AM (#23957881)
Just because its offering some useful service doesn't indemnify the ownership from the bad methods they use to deliver the service.

Exposing your database to the internet with default creds is not "standards and best practices" - its highly negligent, and if you are taking people's money for such a service, I have no pity for you.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by nend on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:40AM (#23957860)
>Your statement is basically akin to someone saying that it’s fine for people to get robbed if they went out with their wallet; or worse.. killed.

Uhh no? The analogy would be that there's some benefit that comes from someone's wallet being destroyed, instead of stolen.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by unstatusthequo on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:06PM (#23958048)
I’d say it’s closer to leaving your wallet on the street. If you don’t care to protect it you should assume someone will fuck with it.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by petee on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:43AM (#23957898)
If you can't or don't know how to secure it, it shouldn't be online.

My argument is more akin to a child learning not to leave their bike unattended on a city street corner overnight. I can come by pick up the bike, and tell you the dangers, but there's only one real way to learn.

And clearly my opinion isn't even close to comparison with somebody being killed in a robbery.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by GekkePrutser on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:20PM (#23958120)
Just putting a password on a database is more than a 'standard', it's truly common sense. Really, even a beginner should think of this. Otherwise they shouldn't be messing with this stuff.

And if they do get 'meowed', lesson well deserved.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by tomc1985 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:59PM (#23958397)
Would you send or let people venture out into the Wild West in its heyday unprepared and unequipped?

Why aren't we applying this same logic to CS topics? It's a vast world out there and much of it's out to get you. Be prepared or die.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by hddherman on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:43AM (#23957891)
That's not a good argument, inexperience does not excuse exposing user data.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:22PM (#23958540)
Would you feel the same way if someone burned your house down if you left the door unlocked? Would you support the idea of people walking through a neighborhood and checking every door in a similar way? Does your opinion change if it happened in a business district?

I think it is fine to argue that doors should be locked but that doesn't mean that a crime hasn't been committed when someone takes advantage of a situation.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lallysingh on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:30PM (#23959948)
The first crime committed was leaving people's data out in the open.

If someone had a list of names/birthdays/SSNs posted on their door, I'm not too unhappy if someone blacks out every line with the word 'meow.'

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:52PM (#23960088)
Not sure why you are focusing on the PII scenario. The original report seems to say it is just "unsecured databases" and not databases that have PII information posted.

You are also making an subtle assumption that the service is being administered by a 3rd party. Could be that the service is being administered by the owner of the data.

In any case it is still wrong to delete the data.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lallysingh on Sunday July 26, 2020 @08:22PM (#23961213)
The folks hit didn't have backups (if they did, well anyone can restore them), nor did they secure their db. One is forgivable. Both together get no sympathy from me. Rather disgust that some of them had PII from customers that trusted them.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Monday July 27, 2020 @12:56AM (#23962337)
More justification that this is an appropriate way to teach people a lesson. You don't seem to care at all what the impact might be on those affected. You are in affect encouraging the criminal behavior because the ends justify the means, apparently.

While I understand the concern that organizations aren't taking proper care to protect their data I think legitimizing vigilante punishment for those mistakes is a very problematic stance.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lallysingh on Monday July 27, 2020 @09:49AM (#23965049)
I'm a huge thought-criminal. A threat to the state!
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by umvi on Sunday July 26, 2020 @09:05PM (#23961415)
It's literally any unsecured database, not just databases containing PII.

What if you just have a toy database for a toy project on the public internet and some jerk just deletes it to "teach you a lesson"? It's like, gee, thanks...

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by rytis on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:32PM (#23958609)
Except that I didn’t leave the doors open. Someone I trusted with the keys, left them in their safe. Unlocked. So I rather have their whole place burned down and MY keys melted at the same time.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:39PM (#23958675)
You are suggesting that it was just "keys" but that isn't the case here. You don't know what type of data is being destroyed.

A better example might be a storage unit service that left the front gate unlocked. If someone torches the place to illustrate that they need better security would you be comfortable with that? Isn't there a better approach that we should encourage or is OK to encourage people to destroy things that aren't protected to teach people "lessons"?

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by rytis on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:52PM (#23958786)
Maybe. However, if this was my diary or photoalbum, bank statements, medical reports or anything of that sort I’d rather have them destroyed than knowing that they may have been copied... The lesson is not for the people, it’s for the companies that take shortcuts to save money. It for the MBA’s that think things don’t have to be properly engineered.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:27PM (#23959042)
So you are rationalizing a crime because it teaches companies a lesson? That is a crazy rejection of the rule of law. Would you be comfortable in applying that logic to all crimes?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by smichel17 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:01PM (#23959302)
I'm not gp, but let's take a step back for a sec.

(I've mostly lived in the northeastern US)

I live in a small (~20k population) rural technically-city (but... it's a town) where crime is not much of an issue; my car sits unlocked in my driveway and I seldom lock my house -- when I do, it's almost always when I'm at home (alone) -- it's about a feeling of security, not any real risk of a break-in. I've lived this way in this town for many years and have never experienced a robbery. I think it's pretty low risk, not irresponsible.

I've also lived in a larger city. There, I absolutely locked my doors. And I've traveled to tourist-y locations known for pickpockets, and kept an even closer watch on my belongings.

The internet is two orders of magnitude larger than the world's largest city and policing it is exceptionally difficult, since it spans national borders. There will be crime.

I wish this weren't the case. I much prefer living in a safe place where I don't have to worry about locking my doors when I go out. But when crime is common, it's negligent not to protect against it.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:10PM (#23959373)
I agree with all that and I also don't want to let the perpetrator off the hook. In your example, doesn't matter if the crime happens in a place where it is uncommon or not, it is still a crime and we shouldn't excuse the perpetrator by suggesting that the victim needed to be taught a lesson.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by sinsterizme on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:05PM (#23958890)
I think the major difference is that losing my house along with all my belongings is much worse than losing just some of my belongings. Also data being exposed publicly can be used nefariously by multiple parties, so is likely worse in most scenarios compared to just outright deletion of the data
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:29PM (#23959503)
Ok, but losing "just some of your belongings" is bad also, right? When thinking about the culpability of the person deleting the data or storing the data, we have to start from the assumption that the owner of the data values it.

Whatever analysis you want to put on the situation I don't think it is reasonable to start with the idea that some of the data might not be that valuable.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:18PM (#23960268)
Either the data is something public (name, address, etc) in which case, whatever.

Or it's data that was gathered (in line of business, for example) and its destruction is anywhere from more secure to an inconvenience.

Or it's data that was aggregated beyond legitimate use (hey, FAANG) and by all means, tear it the hell up and throw it away.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:20PM (#23960621)
Why do you feel it is important to characterize the nature of the data? The unauthorized deletion is wrong regardless of the nature of the data.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Sunday July 26, 2020 @07:43PM (#23961011)
...wrong regardless...

That obviously isn't true. Some data shouldn't exist: CP. Some data can exist, but it's backed-up so well that deletion is never a problem. For example, I'm not going to forget my birth date any time soon! In fact, very little of the information that businesses have about me needs preservation. I remember it all, and if I decide the business still deserves it I can give it to them again.

It is of course possible that some of this data didn't need to be kept private, and therefore shouldn't have been deleted. Maybe some medical researchers had compiled the data they needed to formulate the ultimate cure to COVID-19? (I hope they had anonymized all the patient data!) Until those researchers come forward to lament humanity's loss, I'll just assume that all the "victims" who don't want to go into too much detail about the "lost" data were playing fast and loose with their customers' private information.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @08:23PM (#23961220)
So your argument is that any random person is in a position to evaluate whether someone else's "data shouldn't exist" and take unilateral action to delete it? And are you suggesting that in this particular case the person launching this attack is taking time to evaluate the nature of the data before taking action?

> I'll just assume that all the "victims" who don't want to go into too much detail about the "lost" data were playing fast and loose with their customers' private information.

Why the scare quotes? It takes some serious amount of chutzpah to advocate that it is a reasonable assumption to assume the data wasn't important and to use the lack of public complaint as evidence that the data wasn't really important. Why do you even think it was "customer" data?

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Sunday July 26, 2020 @09:25PM (#23961512)
I didn't just invent this idea that businesses are careless with data their customers would prefer to be kept private. Basically every breach we ever hear about features this prominently. Somehow we've created an economy in which there exists a vast asymmetry between corporations who pad their books a few percentage points by abusing their position and the humans who suffer such abuses. The fact that the publicity of small bits of data about a human can cause that human massive harms is itself a contingent creation of our screwed-up system, which benefits the giant companies whose lobbyists write the laws. It's as if someone decided we should all live under the "protect your True Name at all costs" system from the Earthsea novels, without giving any of us any way to do that.

There's very little a customer can do to determine how or even whether her confidential data is protected. Even if she had this knowledge, in many cases she can't just decide to do business elsewhere. In many cases she was never a customer in the first place! In this context, an open database is like a shoddily constructed tall building that will collapse at the first stiff breeze. It shouldn't exist, and anyone who destroys it upon discovering it is doing humanity a service. Even if the building's owners had somehow kept the general public out (which you'd like us to assume), those owners themselves increased their danger with every bit of data added. Now, since the building has been destroyed, its owners and occupants are no longer in steadily increasing danger.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Monday July 27, 2020 @01:07AM (#23962389)
You seem entirely focused on PII concerns and arguing as if the only organizations affected by this incident are "giant companies". That doesn't seem to be the case. I haven't seen any suggestion that this incident is focused on that type of data.

As much as I agree with all the concerns posted here about how data should be protected better I don't think it is necessary to excuse and legitimize the unauthorized access along the way.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Monday July 27, 2020 @11:31AM (#23966041)
Wealthy interests built the system, but they're not the only abusive actors within it. It would not surprise if smaller firms completely failed to protect the data of other parties more often than larger firms did so. The best way for database operators to prevent unauthorized access and deletion is to secure their databases in some way. The best way for anyone else to prevent abusive access is to delete unsecured databases. Working together, this problem will be solved eventually.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:39PM (#23962047)
I think I'm having a somewhat uncharacteristic relativist thought... I feel that the indiscriminate and nearly unregulated collection of any data any company feels like grabbing hold of _should_ be countered.

I feel like the wrongness of deleting unsecured data is a pittance compared to the crapload of other wrongs that have been visited upon us 'products' by failures of diligence or desire or consequence.

I would very much like to hear, if it turns out to be so, that the operators of 'meow' are selectively targeting more likely corporate data, especially with customer/user data, but in the end I'm still ok with the idea of burn it all and let the DB vendors and IT staff who let their asses hang out explain why security was so low on their priority lists.

And yes, I'll take some potential difficulties in my own life due to unexpected deletion complications in the process. I'm not asking anyone else to accept anything I'm not going to be okay with myself.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cm2187 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:27PM (#23958571)
I don't think the parent suggests it exonerates the hackers. Just that the clients are better off.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:34PM (#23958641)
Better off? The idea that victims deserve to be victimized because they didn't take enough care is trotted out every time a security issue comes up on HN.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:50PM (#23958773)
Thr victims are the unaware customers who's data has been stolen because the company wasn't providing security.

If a business left the store open with the customers credit cards details on display. Anyone passing by can go in and copy that info. Someone sees this and burns the exposed records. Perhaps they helped the victim.

Remember no one burned the store down or the table holding the records. They burned only the exposed records.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:51PM (#23959224)
You don't know who was the storage vendor and who's data was being deleted and you have no idea what that data represents or what the consequences are of having to restore it.

You are making several unfounded assumptions.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:15PM (#23959410)
No one knows more information than the article presents.

When you state that victims exist or that the data being deleted is important you are also making unfounded assumptions.

You can't have it both ways.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:24PM (#23959468)
I think it is entirely reasonable to start with the presumption that people have a right to their data and to their property, that it is valuable to them.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:18PM (#23959863)
If a site/service has a right to allow a person to delete data. The machine can be setup however they like. These are not hacked databases. The system said welcome what do you want to do? You can read everything or delete everything or add anything.

So they did.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cryptoz on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:49PM (#23960070)
> These are not hacked databases.

Yes they are. The method of the hack was 'simple' to you, but that doesn't mean it's just magically not a hack any more. These are hacked databases.

> The system said welcome what do you want to do? You can read everything or delete everything or add anything.

I don't understand this. Are you suggesting that the attackers were greeted by the database with an English-language legal directive of what legal permissions they had in the database? What do you mean by this statement? Surely the databases said no such thing.

If you're implying that a private door with no lock is not private but actually shared property that can be destroyed or added to in any way, then I think you're wrong. None of this comment makes sense to me. An unsecured database holding private data, or an unlocked door to a private business or building, is not an open legal invitation for vandalism.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:40PM (#23960401)
If you attempt to connect to a database the database will greet you. It can be configured to ask for a login. It can be configured to have no login. If it doesn't have a login and gives you a welcome prompt it's not called hacking. In order to hack something it needed to be secured to start with.

Databases do greet users in mostly english. Need help? Type help. On the list of things the system allows deleting data appeared to be one.

If you knock on a door and the door opens and says welcome what do you want to do (delete data, read data) and you pick delete it doesn't mean it's illegal vandalism.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cryptoz on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:01PM (#23960519)
> It can be configured to have no login. If it doesn't have a login and gives you a welcome prompt it's not called hacking. In order to hack something it needed to be secured to start with.

I very strongly disagree with this. Can you cite somewhere that unauthorized database access is not hacking if there is no password? To me and I think the law that is definitely illegal and hacking.

> If you knock on a door and the door opens and says welcome what do you want to do (delete data, read data) and you pick delete it doesn't mean it's illegal vandalism.

Yes it does! If you don’t have authorized access then that database isn’t yours and entering it is illegal.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:26PM (#23959024)
These aren't victims; they were harmed through their own gross negligence or the gross negligence of the developer they employed.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:49PM (#23959212)
They aren't victims? If you forget to lock your car door and it is stolen or something inside it is stolen are you also not a victim by your logic?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zbuf on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:37PM (#23959566)
I don't have a feeling one way or the other, but I see where you're coming from and I think there's an interesting aspect that many of the folks here seem to be missing.

Were this sort of attack to become part of the "noise" of the internet (much as the continual bombarding of my SSH ports) then peoples databases would get deleted _before_ they contain any meaningful amount of data.

So in practice this sort of gross vandalism is limited to the appearance of such an attack, but not ongoing.

I had this the other day building OS images, which accidentally left the system a passwordless login. Within less than a few hours it was (presumably) spewing mail or doing awful things -- long before anything went anywhere near production data or any kind of trust.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zamalek on Monday July 27, 2020 @11:52AM (#23966275)
> [Article] They could be the work of a vigilante trying to give administrators a hard lesson in security by raining destruction on unsecured data.

It could be a person attempting to prevent the data from falling into the wrong hands. Problem is: once it's deleted, you have no idea whether your data was stolen and shared. A better option would be to first send a copy to Have I Been Pwned.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by richardrk2 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:16PM (#23959413)
I wholeheartedly agree. I cannot think of a scenario where a company exposes my data and I would not want it to be deleted ASAP. The only thing is that such companies might not be able anymore (if data was not backed up) to email me about a “breach”.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by neutronman on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:33AM (#23957791)
+1

Any entity this irresponsible shouldn’t hold data.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by menzoic on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:28AM (#23957737)
Could be both
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by JaggerJo on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:25AM (#23957707)
agreed.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by goatinaboat on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:31PM (#23958604)
Somehow I feel good about this.

Frankly anyone who is still using MongoDB is professionally negligent and this was if not deserved then certainly inevitable.