Putting a password and emailing the admin would solve the password problem.
But I agree doing anything is probably illegal. I would leave it... not worth hassle of wearing the superman cape.
Emails have a bunch of info in the headers, so there is more meta-data in the email it self.
Neither is perfect for finding the culprit but one scenario has zero meta-data and the other has some.
That still doesn't justify vandalism.
They secured it, and somehow managed to make it publicly accessible again without password, this time it got hit by this attack.
Honestly this is like if a company decides to keep their paper records with my information on a public side walk, and somebody saw that and decided to bring them to the landfill.
Is it legal or fair? In a perfect world no, but at this point the company is not blameless.
No. The equivalent would be exploiting their buildings weakness to cause them to collapse - maybe with people in them.
Pointing out a vulnerability is not the same as demonstrating it.
That said, a demonstration will get their attention more.
This attack is indiscriminate and is without warning, so it eliminates the possibility for database owners to fix the problem in good faith.
I got doxxed with the Equifax breach. How many other companies in the world will take someone's word that they are me based on that data, and what potential is there for my life amongst millions of others to go completely sideways because of companies who won't addmit the systems are broken?
I say the house is already burning, but maybe throwing some fireworks into the blaze will convince the right parties to finally put the damn fire out.
Beyond sick and tired of breach after breach after breach after "oh, there were millions of voter records showing publicly" "no, <insert product name> defaults to no security"
IMO we specialize too much and miss important things that we mentally outsource to other people. I'm equally disturbed how often I meet people in tech who are unable to do basic home repairs or cook for themselves. Something, like say, a few weeks of quarantine, and people's anxiety goes through the roof because they've relied on other people for basic life skills.
If it's a publicly accessible wiki with no sensitive data whatsoever, and that's meant to be publicly accessible, then there's a reasonable excuse for the poor security and it's not helping anyone to destroy it.
I have no idea of that is the intention of the attackers, or if they are maybe even stealing the info before deleting it. But assuming they were good Samaritans and just deleting it, that is the best outcome for me as a user, better than if it stayed up for another day.
The concern in this case is when there is some social problem with being in Mom & Pop Inc's customer database. There are probably some people that buy some things that they don't want other people to know about. When the database gets hacked and you are linked to being their customer, that is the unfortunate and potentially damaging information leak. A credit card just gets reissued and the bank reverses the transaction. No big deal.
https://www.thestreet.com/personal-finance/credit-cards/cred...
Not necessarily, depending on where you're based.
Usually by price and unfortunately both mom and pop like a bargain - I've seen this play out more times than I would like.
Also how do you evaluate, say, a landscaper's chops? Or any other kind of contractor's for that matter? By doing research beforehand, checking what kind of reputation that person has etc.
Low-effort or lack of research gives you bad services, for which you pay in losses like these.
In software, financial recourse generally means you have to jump straight to lawsuits. There's no licensing for who's qualified to build a website, developers don't have to escrow funds or carry malpractice insurance in case they make a mistake, a development business should have insurance in place but there's not always easy or affordable ways to assign fault in most IT situations if you want to pursue them. Software and IT forensics are prohibitively costly and usually mean a lot of money has to be on the line which rule out mom and pop businesses entirely. IT and software mistakes also usually take longer to rear their heads, and people in IT and software also aren't known for sticking around for decades. How do you sue an LLC that dissolved 5 years ago?
It's apples and oranges in my opinion.
I hail from a post-communist country so I assumed the culture in the US is more developed in this regard.
I would certainly hope the owner of the insecure database would face massive consequences. IMO there's not _nearly_ enough of that. This sort of breach should be financially ruinous for _any_ company.
Not everything is about you, and also you totally misunderstood the post you quoted.
And if you've configured your database that poorly, am I supposed to assume you've properly configured your server against becoming part of a DDoS attack? Or a bot net? The base level of negligence you're defending enables a multitude of attacks. Losing your DB would be an immediate sign you don't know what you're doing, and thus shouldn't be doing it.
Deleting exposed databases is genious, there need to be real repercussions for companies if they leak user data.
That is a very rich person statement.
Yours is also a rich person statement.
Unsecured databases are a huge loss for everyone.
Anything that forces a shift in this naive behavior of vendors, implementors and executives is not just fine by me, I welcome it. If my life suffers because of data of mine that's lost from companies' databases, I now know who to cease doing business with.
No one wants to see their local pizza shop lose their pizza-credit database, but if that's the price to pay for data security then so be it.
Usually when you buy something, you get an email receipt. So you print out your email receipt and go to the mom and pop store.
Given they are a local mom and pop store, you likely have a long term relationship with them and they may even remember you buying credits. So it will be a hassle, but likely ok.
It is the huge corporate stores that don’t have long term relationships that would be hurt by this thing the most.
In the case of the spin studio, you can prove what you paid, the owner just lost his evidence of what he no longer owes you, and will hopefully in the future stop exposing your personal data on the Internet.
Not my problem.
> The nephew says they can set up their website for cheap, and they want to be nice, so they give him the job. Turns out he's a newb and later their database gets deleted and you are on here saying that's a good thing? Hrm. I don't agree.
Mom and pop prefer nepotism over skill, credentials and reputation, without even a second opinion. There is a reason that this is frowned upon (and has been for at least some 2000 years before mom and pop were born), regardless of the domain.
On the off chance that their database doesn't contain any personally identifying information on their customers, this is an idiot tax. In any other case, their loss is completely justified when compared to the potential losses, abuse and manipulation of their customers that come with exposing their PII to the public.
> What if one of the databases has a record of credits you've purchased at your local spin studio?
p.s. bobby tables did it first
I also just think it is a little uncharitable to wish harm on people simply because whoever did their IT was inexpert at their job? Like, how does the local mom and pop correctly evaluate a person's IT chops? The nephew says they can set up their website for cheap, and they want to be nice, so they give him the job. Turns out he's a newb and later their database gets deleted and you are on here saying that's a good thing? Hrm. I don't agree.