News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:22PM (#23958540)
Would you feel the same way if someone burned your house down if you left the door unlocked? Would you support the idea of people walking through a neighborhood and checking every door in a similar way? Does your opinion change if it happened in a business district?

I think it is fine to argue that doors should be locked but that doesn't mean that a crime hasn't been committed when someone takes advantage of a situation.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lallysingh on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:30PM (#23959948)
The first crime committed was leaving people's data out in the open.

If someone had a list of names/birthdays/SSNs posted on their door, I'm not too unhappy if someone blacks out every line with the word 'meow.'

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:52PM (#23960088)
Not sure why you are focusing on the PII scenario. The original report seems to say it is just "unsecured databases" and not databases that have PII information posted.

You are also making an subtle assumption that the service is being administered by a 3rd party. Could be that the service is being administered by the owner of the data.

In any case it is still wrong to delete the data.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lallysingh on Sunday July 26, 2020 @08:22PM (#23961213)
The folks hit didn't have backups (if they did, well anyone can restore them), nor did they secure their db. One is forgivable. Both together get no sympathy from me. Rather disgust that some of them had PII from customers that trusted them.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Monday July 27, 2020 @12:56AM (#23962337)
More justification that this is an appropriate way to teach people a lesson. You don't seem to care at all what the impact might be on those affected. You are in affect encouraging the criminal behavior because the ends justify the means, apparently.

While I understand the concern that organizations aren't taking proper care to protect their data I think legitimizing vigilante punishment for those mistakes is a very problematic stance.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by lallysingh on Monday July 27, 2020 @09:49AM (#23965049)
I'm a huge thought-criminal. A threat to the state!
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by umvi on Sunday July 26, 2020 @09:05PM (#23961415)
It's literally any unsecured database, not just databases containing PII.

What if you just have a toy database for a toy project on the public internet and some jerk just deletes it to "teach you a lesson"? It's like, gee, thanks...

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by rytis on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:32PM (#23958609)
Except that I didn’t leave the doors open. Someone I trusted with the keys, left them in their safe. Unlocked. So I rather have their whole place burned down and MY keys melted at the same time.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:39PM (#23958675)
You are suggesting that it was just "keys" but that isn't the case here. You don't know what type of data is being destroyed.

A better example might be a storage unit service that left the front gate unlocked. If someone torches the place to illustrate that they need better security would you be comfortable with that? Isn't there a better approach that we should encourage or is OK to encourage people to destroy things that aren't protected to teach people "lessons"?

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by rytis on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:52PM (#23958786)
Maybe. However, if this was my diary or photoalbum, bank statements, medical reports or anything of that sort I’d rather have them destroyed than knowing that they may have been copied... The lesson is not for the people, it’s for the companies that take shortcuts to save money. It for the MBA’s that think things don’t have to be properly engineered.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:27PM (#23959042)
So you are rationalizing a crime because it teaches companies a lesson? That is a crazy rejection of the rule of law. Would you be comfortable in applying that logic to all crimes?
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by smichel17 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:01PM (#23959302)
I'm not gp, but let's take a step back for a sec.

(I've mostly lived in the northeastern US)

I live in a small (~20k population) rural technically-city (but... it's a town) where crime is not much of an issue; my car sits unlocked in my driveway and I seldom lock my house -- when I do, it's almost always when I'm at home (alone) -- it's about a feeling of security, not any real risk of a break-in. I've lived this way in this town for many years and have never experienced a robbery. I think it's pretty low risk, not irresponsible.

I've also lived in a larger city. There, I absolutely locked my doors. And I've traveled to tourist-y locations known for pickpockets, and kept an even closer watch on my belongings.

The internet is two orders of magnitude larger than the world's largest city and policing it is exceptionally difficult, since it spans national borders. There will be crime.

I wish this weren't the case. I much prefer living in a safe place where I don't have to worry about locking my doors when I go out. But when crime is common, it's negligent not to protect against it.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:10PM (#23959373)
I agree with all that and I also don't want to let the perpetrator off the hook. In your example, doesn't matter if the crime happens in a place where it is uncommon or not, it is still a crime and we shouldn't excuse the perpetrator by suggesting that the victim needed to be taught a lesson.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by sinsterizme on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:05PM (#23958890)
I think the major difference is that losing my house along with all my belongings is much worse than losing just some of my belongings. Also data being exposed publicly can be used nefariously by multiple parties, so is likely worse in most scenarios compared to just outright deletion of the data
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:29PM (#23959503)
Ok, but losing "just some of your belongings" is bad also, right? When thinking about the culpability of the person deleting the data or storing the data, we have to start from the assumption that the owner of the data values it.

Whatever analysis you want to put on the situation I don't think it is reasonable to start with the idea that some of the data might not be that valuable.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:18PM (#23960268)
Either the data is something public (name, address, etc) in which case, whatever.

Or it's data that was gathered (in line of business, for example) and its destruction is anywhere from more secure to an inconvenience.

Or it's data that was aggregated beyond legitimate use (hey, FAANG) and by all means, tear it the hell up and throw it away.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:20PM (#23960621)
Why do you feel it is important to characterize the nature of the data? The unauthorized deletion is wrong regardless of the nature of the data.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Sunday July 26, 2020 @07:43PM (#23961011)
...wrong regardless...

That obviously isn't true. Some data shouldn't exist: CP. Some data can exist, but it's backed-up so well that deletion is never a problem. For example, I'm not going to forget my birth date any time soon! In fact, very little of the information that businesses have about me needs preservation. I remember it all, and if I decide the business still deserves it I can give it to them again.

It is of course possible that some of this data didn't need to be kept private, and therefore shouldn't have been deleted. Maybe some medical researchers had compiled the data they needed to formulate the ultimate cure to COVID-19? (I hope they had anonymized all the patient data!) Until those researchers come forward to lament humanity's loss, I'll just assume that all the "victims" who don't want to go into too much detail about the "lost" data were playing fast and loose with their customers' private information.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @08:23PM (#23961220)
So your argument is that any random person is in a position to evaluate whether someone else's "data shouldn't exist" and take unilateral action to delete it? And are you suggesting that in this particular case the person launching this attack is taking time to evaluate the nature of the data before taking action?

> I'll just assume that all the "victims" who don't want to go into too much detail about the "lost" data were playing fast and loose with their customers' private information.

Why the scare quotes? It takes some serious amount of chutzpah to advocate that it is a reasonable assumption to assume the data wasn't important and to use the lack of public complaint as evidence that the data wasn't really important. Why do you even think it was "customer" data?

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Sunday July 26, 2020 @09:25PM (#23961512)
I didn't just invent this idea that businesses are careless with data their customers would prefer to be kept private. Basically every breach we ever hear about features this prominently. Somehow we've created an economy in which there exists a vast asymmetry between corporations who pad their books a few percentage points by abusing their position and the humans who suffer such abuses. The fact that the publicity of small bits of data about a human can cause that human massive harms is itself a contingent creation of our screwed-up system, which benefits the giant companies whose lobbyists write the laws. It's as if someone decided we should all live under the "protect your True Name at all costs" system from the Earthsea novels, without giving any of us any way to do that.

There's very little a customer can do to determine how or even whether her confidential data is protected. Even if she had this knowledge, in many cases she can't just decide to do business elsewhere. In many cases she was never a customer in the first place! In this context, an open database is like a shoddily constructed tall building that will collapse at the first stiff breeze. It shouldn't exist, and anyone who destroys it upon discovering it is doing humanity a service. Even if the building's owners had somehow kept the general public out (which you'd like us to assume), those owners themselves increased their danger with every bit of data added. Now, since the building has been destroyed, its owners and occupants are no longer in steadily increasing danger.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Monday July 27, 2020 @01:07AM (#23962389)
You seem entirely focused on PII concerns and arguing as if the only organizations affected by this incident are "giant companies". That doesn't seem to be the case. I haven't seen any suggestion that this incident is focused on that type of data.

As much as I agree with all the concerns posted here about how data should be protected better I don't think it is necessary to excuse and legitimize the unauthorized access along the way.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by jessaustin on Monday July 27, 2020 @11:31AM (#23966041)
Wealthy interests built the system, but they're not the only abusive actors within it. It would not surprise if smaller firms completely failed to protect the data of other parties more often than larger firms did so. The best way for database operators to prevent unauthorized access and deletion is to secure their databases in some way. The best way for anyone else to prevent abusive access is to delete unsecured databases. Working together, this problem will be solved eventually.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by zentiggr on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:39PM (#23962047)
I think I'm having a somewhat uncharacteristic relativist thought... I feel that the indiscriminate and nearly unregulated collection of any data any company feels like grabbing hold of _should_ be countered.

I feel like the wrongness of deleting unsecured data is a pittance compared to the crapload of other wrongs that have been visited upon us 'products' by failures of diligence or desire or consequence.

I would very much like to hear, if it turns out to be so, that the operators of 'meow' are selectively targeting more likely corporate data, especially with customer/user data, but in the end I'm still ok with the idea of burn it all and let the DB vendors and IT staff who let their asses hang out explain why security was so low on their priority lists.

And yes, I'll take some potential difficulties in my own life due to unexpected deletion complications in the process. I'm not asking anyone else to accept anything I'm not going to be okay with myself.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cm2187 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:27PM (#23958571)
I don't think the parent suggests it exonerates the hackers. Just that the clients are better off.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:34PM (#23958641)
Better off? The idea that victims deserve to be victimized because they didn't take enough care is trotted out every time a security issue comes up on HN.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @01:50PM (#23958773)
Thr victims are the unaware customers who's data has been stolen because the company wasn't providing security.

If a business left the store open with the customers credit cards details on display. Anyone passing by can go in and copy that info. Someone sees this and burns the exposed records. Perhaps they helped the victim.

Remember no one burned the store down or the table holding the records. They burned only the exposed records.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:51PM (#23959224)
You don't know who was the storage vendor and who's data was being deleted and you have no idea what that data represents or what the consequences are of having to restore it.

You are making several unfounded assumptions.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:15PM (#23959410)
No one knows more information than the article presents.

When you state that victims exist or that the data being deleted is important you are also making unfounded assumptions.

You can't have it both ways.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @03:24PM (#23959468)
I think it is entirely reasonable to start with the presumption that people have a right to their data and to their property, that it is valuable to them.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:18PM (#23959863)
If a site/service has a right to allow a person to delete data. The machine can be setup however they like. These are not hacked databases. The system said welcome what do you want to do? You can read everything or delete everything or add anything.

So they did.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cryptoz on Sunday July 26, 2020 @04:49PM (#23960070)
> These are not hacked databases.

Yes they are. The method of the hack was 'simple' to you, but that doesn't mean it's just magically not a hack any more. These are hacked databases.

> The system said welcome what do you want to do? You can read everything or delete everything or add anything.

I don't understand this. Are you suggesting that the attackers were greeted by the database with an English-language legal directive of what legal permissions they had in the database? What do you mean by this statement? Surely the databases said no such thing.

If you're implying that a private door with no lock is not private but actually shared property that can be destroyed or added to in any way, then I think you're wrong. None of this comment makes sense to me. An unsecured database holding private data, or an unlocked door to a private business or building, is not an open legal invitation for vandalism.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by wolco on Sunday July 26, 2020 @05:40PM (#23960401)
If you attempt to connect to a database the database will greet you. It can be configured to ask for a login. It can be configured to have no login. If it doesn't have a login and gives you a welcome prompt it's not called hacking. In order to hack something it needed to be secured to start with.

Databases do greet users in mostly english. Need help? Type help. On the list of things the system allows deleting data appeared to be one.

If you knock on a door and the door opens and says welcome what do you want to do (delete data, read data) and you pick delete it doesn't mean it's illegal vandalism.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by cryptoz on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:01PM (#23960519)
> It can be configured to have no login. If it doesn't have a login and gives you a welcome prompt it's not called hacking. In order to hack something it needed to be secured to start with.

I very strongly disagree with this. Can you cite somewhere that unauthorized database access is not hacking if there is no password? To me and I think the law that is definitely illegal and hacking.

> If you knock on a door and the door opens and says welcome what do you want to do (delete data, read data) and you pick delete it doesn't mean it's illegal vandalism.

Yes it does! If you don’t have authorized access then that database isn’t yours and entering it is illegal.

Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:26PM (#23959024)
These aren't victims; they were harmed through their own gross negligence or the gross negligence of the developer they employed.
Re:New ‘Meow’ attack has deleted almost 4k unsecured databases by gwright on Sunday July 26, 2020 @02:49PM (#23959212)
They aren't victims? If you forget to lock your car door and it is stolen or something inside it is stolen are you also not a victim by your logic?