News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by ABeeSea on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:16PM (#23108464)
Unfortunately a lot of that solar power will go towards air conditioning. Right now, Qatar is literally air conditioning the outside to make the heat from the sidewalks less deadly. Better than running the ACs in oil, but the amount of AC required to make these places survivable by humans is only going to grow.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2019/world/climate-e...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by theboywho on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:48PM (#23108752)
Why unfortunately? Are you suggesting that air conditioning sidewalks in Qatar is a luxury? Because the only other option I can think of is for people to leave Qatar. It’s far from a luxury.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by ABeeSea on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:17PM (#23109004)
Unfortunate for climate change. The heat from those ACs has to go somewhere. And they emit greenhouse gases.

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/03/countries-crank-ac-e...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by tonmoy on Thursday May 07, 2020 @09:19PM (#23110384)
If all AC is running on solar power then would it be heating up the earth anymore than the sunlight would have on its own?
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by manfredo on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:00PM (#23110612)
Yes, because air conditioning units have net positive heat generation. Though they usually use water as their heat sinks, and if that water is flushed then it effectively eliminates the heat in a practical sense if not a thermodynamic sense.

Reply in comment, since HN is rate limiting my VPN.

> Yes, because air conditioning units have net positive heat generation. Though they usually use water as their heat sinks, and if that water is flushed then it effectively eliminates the heat in a practical sense if not a thermodynamic sense.

This is assuming that the terrain without solar panels would convert as much energy into heat as the solar panels are collecting. In reality the terrain without solar panels reflects a lot of the energy it receives, whereas solar panels are optimized to absorb as much of it as possible.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by benchaney on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:17PM (#23110717)
This is wrong. The net positive heat generation comes from the energy that the ACs consume. If they are entirely running on solar power this energy would have become heat anyway.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by smadge on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:58PM (#23111252)
Unless that energy would otherwise be reflected back out of the atmosphere.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by ABeeSea on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:30PM (#23110801)
There’s a local effect that creates a feedback loop across the region which would then in turn change global weather patterns.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/phys.org/news/2014-05-excess-ai...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Tade0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:45PM (#23109719)
Those greenhouse gases have of course a measurable effect, but I believe it's still the energy source that's responsible for most of the carbon footprint here.

Especially if the units are supplied with electricity generated from burning oil.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by snypher on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:39PM (#23111181)
There must be alternatives to trying to battle the sun in this way. Could people spend more time indoors, like in extreme Artic environments, or even possibly underground?
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by duxup on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:07PM (#23106098)
Of all places that could benefit, those places seem high on the list.

I grew up in a state with tons of wind, but wind energy was hardly ever used (outside the old farmer windmills that were largely around because they looked cool). It was a great candidate for wind power but the local power companies were already heavy net exporters of power, coal, hydro electric. There just wasn't the incentive despite a lot of availability.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by k__ on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:14PM (#23106995)
Here in Germany many people simply are against wind-power-plants. They think they're ugly, loud, and dangerous.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by jseliger on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:21PM (#23107085)
The rule of thumb seems to be, "Everyone is against everything, but everyone still wants power, and preferably cheap power." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21992958
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by baxtr on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:17PM (#23108474)
I think it’s just a little subtler than that: “I’m not against it in general, but not in my backyard/neighborhood/ town/state...”
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by fragmede on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:28PM (#23108586)
There's a push back against NIMBYism with YIMBYism (Yes in my backyard!), but that's as fraught with politics as ever, with aspersions that everyone's in some elses' pocket. It's frustrating, to say the least.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by mhh__ on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:25PM (#23107124)
But don't worry guys, we're only burning coal to produce 40% of our power!
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by 101404 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:50PM (#23107394)
And by doing so, we produce twice as much CO2 per capita as France or the UK. While having one of the most expensive electricity in Europe, because we pay a huge "renewable energy tax".
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by vinay427 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:08PM (#23107634)
I wanted to double check as this seemed potentially affected by industry and other sources of CO2 emission, but as you implied, the CO2 emissions are actually much higher per unit of energy produced than in France. That's rather incredible to me.

https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/indicators/overview-...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by tialaramex on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:26PM (#23107862)
Yup. Big Nuclear fleet. Most of France's base load is just a bunch of fission reactors, very high efficiency, very low CO2 emissions. Germans are scared of them, decided to just burn lots of coal instead.

The UK imports a bunch of this cheap nuclear electricity from France, we have a 2GW bi-directional line. In principle that line could sell power from our gas turbines in mid-winter if France needs the extra power to keep things running, but most of the time it imports French nuclear power because it's much cheaper than our gas. Our own nuclear fleet is too small for our base needs (6-7GW of nukes compared to ~18-20GW base)

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krssst on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:48PM (#23109747)
However, the direction in France seems to be to replace part of nuclear with renewable. But building wind and solar power (hydro is already maximized to my knowledge) means the nuclear plants have to reduce their power output when there is wind and sun, so basically they are used to save uranium. But uranium is cheap, what is not is building the actual plant. So it just increases nuclear price per MWh since they have to produce less over time to make room for wind/solar power.

So basically by building renewable we are reducing nuclear power's viability on the grid. Since there does not seem to be viable storage option (if there was we'd be building that instead of gas power plants everywhere), running only on renewable is not possible. So I really don't see the point in using renewables as we do when electricity is already low-carbon.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by 101404 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:46PM (#23109729)
And we don't burn just any coal. Of course it's brown coal, the worst kind of coal when it comes to pollution.

But that's the price we pay for rapidly switching off all our nuclear plants and heavily subsidizing low efficiency inland wind farms.

That's the result of too much ideology in energy politics.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Tade0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:48PM (#23109745)
Germans are scared of them, decided to just burn lots of coal instead.

I think it's less about being scared and more about the eye-watering cost of storing waste responsibly.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:38PM (#23108008)
Germans are scared because there are reactors which have been overdue for years now and because of of accidents and underreporting that happens and threatens them. No sane person would blame them. This is no backwater terrain in some former soviet republic. This is the middle of Europe.

Luckily, they'll finally be decommissioned now as France turns towards renewables: https://phys.org/news/2018-11-france-nuclear-reactors-macron...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:22PM (#23107818)
France, to a first approximation, runs on nuclear power.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:48PM (#23107374)
At least we have a plan to turn that off at some point in the future (2038) now.

Something which can't be said about storing our nuclear waste for example...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by manfredo on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:51PM (#23108146)
Nuclear waste is a trivial problem. The amount of waste is incredibly miniscule. The entirety of the US waste generated from nuclear power generation fits into a volume the footprint of a football field and 10 yards high.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:40PM (#23109202)
Next year when the last nuclear reactor goes down in Germany we'd have something around 15.000 tons. Since we're not the US of A with a hell lot of space and the fact that we've been looking for a spot for years now, it's not a trivial problem at all.

But maybe you can convince your government to take our waste and fix this "trivial" problem? I'm sure we'd be able to pay for it a nice sum and your current president looks like he might be stupid enough to actually do it.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by manfredo on Thursday May 07, 2020 @09:52PM (#23110568)
17,000 tons of uranium is less than a 10x10x10 meter cube of uranium.

The US already has a disposal site constructed in the desert, but we're not using it yet. Europe also has a dig in Finland. Most of it stays on site because there's so little of it to store.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:26PM (#23110767)
No, it stays on side because it's either not transportable (see Asse) or, as I said: there is no space for it.

FYI: Finland is not like an US state only because it's part of Europe. It's an independent country and they will not take foreign nuclear waste.

PS. those 17.000 tons are just the highly radioactive material. All together it will be 280.000 cubic meters when we're finished decommissioning.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by manfredo on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:37PM (#23110849)
What's hard about transporting it? The US manages to ship these just fine [1]. These casks can be transported via semi truck and shipping container [2]. Maybe Europe doesn't have as good waste container standardization.

1 https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-...

2. http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2015/ph241/avery-w2/images...

Replies in comment, since HN is limiting my work VPN or something like that.

> Is this a straw man or did you really not understand what I wrote?

From your comment:

> No, it stays on side because it's either not transportable (see Asse)

You explicitly brought up ease of transport.

> I also put something in there. This word in the brackets. You might have googled it up where you'd come upon pictures like that: https://media1.faz.net/ppmedia/aktuell/1203828188/1.3595409/.... Instead, you chose to ignore the complete rest of the comment and all the comments I wrote before and only wrote a completely irrelevant answer to something you did not understand. Congratulations for this derailment.

You claimed that transportation was a barrier to storing nuclear waste, by cherry picking one specific failure. And I refuted this claim by pointing out that plenty of the world's largest nuclear operators transport waste just fine. This isn't derailment, quite the opposite.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repo...

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_r...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:46PM (#23110893)
Is this a straw man or did you really not understand what I wrote?

Nobody want this shit. There is no place to transport it. None. We have to sit on it for millennia. Transport is not the issue here.

@your edit: >You explicitly brought up ease of transport.

I also put something in there. This word in the brackets. You might have googled it up where you'd come upon pictures like that: https://media1.faz.net/ppmedia/aktuell/1203828188/1.3595409/...

Instead, you chose to ignore the complete rest of the comment and all the comments I wrote before and only wrote a completely irrelevant answer to something you did not understand. Congratulations for this derailment.

EOD.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:24PM (#23111103)
Should have countered that with links to Castor, and pictures of the mass demonstrations we have, when those are rolling. You know, like people cementing their arms or legs into rail tracks, dangling down from bridges over the tracks, and the huuuuge mass of police escorting that convoy on foot, thereby essentially making the transportation pedestrian, speedwise.

edit: but probably he wouldn't get it, because AFAIK that Yucca Mountian is unused for the same reasons as here. Local opposition...

edit: I don't know what to make to your picture of the Asse. THAT just shows our incompetence to responsible handling of the stuff. Maybe they are only full of old "Putzlappen"?

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by ac29 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:28PM (#23111127)
> FYI: Finland is not like an US state only because it's part of Europe. It's an independent country and they will not take foreign nuclear waste.

For what its worth, this isnt too far off from reality in the US. Nevada is a US state, but they wont take "foreign" nuclear waste from other states (and they dont generate their own, in part because water is scarce in the state). Intermediary states dont want to have waste transported through their borders either.

edit: in case it wasnt clear, the US has a partially constructed waste depo in Nevada that was abandoned a decade ago for largely political reasons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_r...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by mhh__ on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:14PM (#23108976)
2038 is diabolically awful - the UK already goes thousands of hours a year without any coal power online, with a right-wing government that has no particular focus on climate issues.

Issues with storing nuclear waste are almost entirely (as far as I'm aware) idiot policy from past rushes to generate weapons material and NIMBY-ism.

Nuclear waste isn't harmless, but coal power stations kill people every day.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:29PM (#23109116)
Good for you! Congratulations!

Most of us in Germany would also love to see this happen earlier.

Unfortunately the exit date is a political decision based upon the fact that the regions where jobs in coal would be lost are already tending towards a really really right party here and they are very much pro coal. So going faster is not really an option here since you can be sure that them winning, would revert those decisions very fast.

> Issues with storing nuclear waste are almost entirely (as far as I'm aware) idiot policy from past rushes to generate weapons material and NIMBY-ism.

Well that's not true. As most of the times when downplaying nuclear waste is concerned.

The last time we chose a nice salty mine to store the stuff, it started having holes here and there with a nice groundwater inflow that now needs to be pumped out and as always with nuclear power: in the end it's the taxpayer who needs to jump in and pay it all. Isn't that nice? All that money that could be invested into renewable energy, expanding grids and other nice things is now being wasted upon fixing errors from an era where everybody believed nuclear is the way to go.

Good we're past that now.

PS. that "nuclear vs. coal" story the nuclear lobby is pushing so much lately is an ignorant myth because of the reasons I've outlined above. Not a single coal plant would have been turned off if we'd left nuclear run on and ignored the environmentalists who are against nuclear AND coal in this country so there is absolutely no reason to build arguments based upon this myth.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by duxup on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:51PM (#23107411)
Coal has waste that doesn't just go away too, not the same as nuclear, but way higher volume and it doesn't go anywhere... let alone all that carbon dioxide dumped into the atmosphere.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Krasnol on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:01PM (#23107537)
The thing is: it doesn't have to go anywhere. You grow nature on it and it's a hill in the end.

However nuclear waste HAS to go somewhere. It has to be taken care of ($$$) and probably for millennia to come by people and governments which can do stuff we can't imagine today.

Not even mentioning failed storage options we're face with today already like Asse...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by tialaramex on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:14PM (#23107715)
When they say it's "not the same as nuclear" they really don't mean it's just harmless rocks.

Waste from a coal plant is (somewhat) radioactive, it's full of metals and generally very toxic. If you're lucky you can find some actual use for it, e.g. as a constituent for some construction materials that will fix it in place, but you aren't going to get "a hill in the end" in a human lifetime by insisting it doesn't need to go anywhere, you just get a toxic heap of unstable black dust. If you try to grow plants on it, plants that do grow will be extremely toxic, because the heavy metals and other pollutants are drawn up into the plant.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by grecy on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:14PM (#23107709)
Everyone who says that should be forced to live without electricity or live within a hundred meters of a coal or nuclear plant for a year.

Out of sight out of mind has had some very large consequences.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by ldiracdelta on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:34PM (#23109650)
I live near a wind-farm and I think they are ugly. Rolling hills spiked with giant windmills instead of natural rolling hills. A true shame. I'm not opposed to to renewable energy and I doubt all the impending down-voters have installed two solar systems on two different houses, as I have.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by duxup on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:47PM (#23107363)
I wouldn't have expected that.

Thankfully the area I'm thinking about has since chosen to invest / had folks invest in wind power.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by beamatronic on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:46PM (#23109727)
And they cause cancer!
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Vysero on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:23PM (#23107097)
Two quotes from this article I really like, first the opener:

"TWO MILLENNIA after the ancient Egyptians dropped their solar deity, Ra, their descendants are rediscovering the power of the sun."

and then the closer:

“Why spend money taking fuel out of the ground and processing it rather than relying on God-given free sun and wind?”

Very well done, kudos!

I see renewable gaining momentum here in the US as well and it's very exciting to see. In fact, I have recently just invested in BEP, and while it's not a majority share of my investment portfolio, it's quickly become one of my favorite investments.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by jillesvangurp on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:05PM (#23108323)
https://www.forbes.com/sites/dominicdudley/2020/04/28/abu-dh... Abu Dhabi just secured a bid for a 2GW solar plant at a record 1.35 dollar cents per KWH.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Mizza on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:20PM (#23107071)
To quote the poet Christopher George Latore Wallace:

"Number four, know you've heard this before,

Never get high, on your own supply."

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by yaacov on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:31PM (#23105651)
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Vysero on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:23PM (#23107105)
Thanks for that!
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by dvirsky on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:02PM (#23108280)
I wonder how much usage of solar water heaters exists in these countries. It's a dead simple technology that works amazingly well in sunny areas, and saves tons of electricity when deployed at scale.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by mulderc on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:05PM (#23108325)
When I visited Turkey years ago I noticed that solar water heating seemed to be all over the place judging by what was on people’s roofs.

As a kid our house had a solar water heating system that eventually broke and we could never find anyone that could fix it. I briefly looked into if my current house could get one and have yet to find a local company that installs them.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Gibbon1 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:04PM (#23108900)
I think current economics favors using solar panels to power a hybrid electric water heater.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by remus on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:19PM (#23108489)
I'm not sure about the middle east but they're incredibly common in the Mediterranean (Greece, turkey, Spain etc).
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by dvirsky on Friday May 08, 2020 @03:17AM (#23112219)
Super popular in Israel, nearly everyone has them, unless it's a tall building where there's not enough roof surface area. It will pay for itself in electricity savings in a year or so.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kyuudou on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:39PM (#23109689)
Also Japan (along with whole-house solar power)
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Rochus on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:43PM (#23105793)
Then they can pump oil using solar energy.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by vmception on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:56PM (#23105940)
That's a good way to pay for the panels.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chickenpotpie on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:07PM (#23106102)
Could be used to solve the duck curve too. Use excess solar to pump oil in the day and then use oil for power at night.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Gibbon1 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:03PM (#23106862)
Using peeking plants mornings and at night seems like a no brainer stop gap.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by neonate on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:26PM (#23107131)
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:59PM (#23107511)
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by olodus on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:23PM (#23107106)
Sorry couldn't read it because of the pay wall, but I am interested - how do they solve the storage and transport problem? Always thought that was one of the troubles with solar for much of the region.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by greglindahl on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:44PM (#23107323)
What storage and transport problem? This is a region that has a lot of sun, a lot of empty land near cities, and a lot of electricity usage for air conditioning. They can install a lot of solar before they need to worry about storage and transport.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:53PM (#23107436)
Maybe the problem of transporting the energy produced there to China or the Netherlands or something? The problem with selling energy in Morocco or Egypt is that the people there are, by and large, poor, so they can't pay you very much.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by jillesvangurp on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:00PM (#23108259)
Easier to generate it locally, which people in both China and the Netherlands do.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:19PM (#23108492)
Indeed, and China has the Gobi, but the Netherlands' total solar resource is only a few terawatts, while hundreds to tens of thousands of terawatts are potentially available to be imported.

https://www.en-tran-ce.org/custom/uploads/2019/02/Renewable-... seems to say that last January the Netherlands had 4300 MW(p) of solar PV generating capacity, which produced 0.4 petajoules. If that's correct, the capacity factor of solar PV in the Netherlands averaged 3.5% that month, which is shockingly low, about three times lower than even Germany and nearly ten times worse than equatorial desert solar power plants — although January is one of the worst months, and eyeballing the graphs it looks like the year-round average is closer to 1.3 PJ per month, giving a deplorable 10% capacity factor similar to Germany's. Until and unless panel prices drop dramatically again, situating the panels somewhere sunnier will produce three times as much energy, enough to pay for constructing quite a bit of energy transmission infrastructure.

But what happens if panel prices do drop dramatically? Well, if this appalling 10% is a typical capacity factor for utility-scale PV in the Netherlands, the total solar resource is only 4.2 terawatts, of which about 900 gigawatts is available with typical 21%-efficient solar panels. This is an order of magnitude higher than the country's current energy demand, but of course that means that you'd have to cover about 10% of the countryside with solar panels to fulfill that demand from PV alone — and seasonal variability means you'd have to triple that if demand is constant year-round. Covering a third of the Netherlands with PV panels is probably not possible, and covering more than 100% of it is definitely not possible. So the new kinds of energy-intensive industry that will become possible if PV panels get cheaper still will be out of reach of indigenous PV production.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by jillesvangurp on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:05AM (#23112499)
These back of the envelope calculations are nice. But the underlying assumption of having just one source of energy to cover all needs is wrong. In the Netherlands we have lots of untapped potential in the form of wind, tidal, geothermal and imported hydro-electrical (from Norway). There are only 2 coal plants left (a lot of them were shut down in recent years) and quite a few gas plants and 2 relatively small nuclear plants that are very old at this point (i.e. likely to be shut down at some point).

Between all of those sources, I suspect that importing solar from north Africa or China is not going to be attractive from a cost or efficiency point of view any time soon.

Offshore wind is getting a lot of investment and dropping panel prices are going to cause a lot of homeowners to put these on their roofs. Lots of people put panels on their roofs already, which in most cases does not fully cover their needs but lowers their energy cost. I wonder if that is included in the report. Reports like this tend to focus on grid providers. A lot of solar generation is happening off grid. Home owners, businesses, EV charging stations, etc. are all use cases where solar panels are commonly used to lower energy cost.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 21, 2020 @07:24PM (#23266823)
As happened last time I conversed with you, you seem to have reinterpreted my words to mean something that is obviously wrong so that you can disagree with it, and then downvoted my original comment when I had the temerity to rebut you — this despite the fact that my comment explicitly disclaimed the absurd interpretation you imposed on it.

— ⁂ —

I didn't make an underlying assumption about having just one source of energy to cover all needs. I made an extensively-sourced, well-substantiated calculation that, out of all the sources of energy available in the Netherlands, two of them represent a large enough resource to support an order-of-magnitude increase in energy usage — enhanced geothermal and solar — and neither of these will be economically competitive with importing solar energy from elsewhere.

The absurd misinterpretation that underlies your comment is that I'm talking about what will happen in, say, 2021, 2022, 2024, or 2028. But it should be obvious that the Netherlands is not on a path to use an order of magnitude more energy in 2028, nor will solar power in Morocco and the like usher in "new kinds of energy-intensive industry" that quickly. So, as should have been obvious from my initial comment, I'm talking about a longer timescale than that; I think 2040 to 2060. You chose to ignore this and instead interpret my comment as patent absurdity.

— ⁂ —

Let's talk a little bit about this "lots of untapped potential" and "a lot of investment" and "a lot of homeowners" who "put panels on their roofs" you tout in your comment.

— ⁂ —

First, what about the homeowners? Well, putting panels on your roof doesn't improve your capacity factor relative to the utility-scale plants surveyed in the reports I cited; in most cases it worsens it, because it's too expensive to reorient the roof to the optimal angle, and most people just use whatever the roof's existing angle is instead of building an extra truss to support the panel. So a square-meter 200-watt (peak) solar panel on a Dutch roof is still going to generate only about 20 watts on average, maybe 15 watts if your roof is at an unfortunate angle.

Moreover, there isn't nearly enough roof for rooftop solar to meet a significant fraction of demand. Current marketed energy consumption in the Netherlands is about 60 gigawatts electric, 100 gigawatts total, about 5.6 kilowatts per capita — about 280 square meters of panels per person.

Nevertheless, the total solar resource in the country is, as I said, 4.2 terawatts, of which 900 gigawatts would be available with current mainstream solar panels. It should be apparent that Dutch residential rooftop solar can only ever be an insignificantly tiny fraction of even the total current demand. It is an irrelevant distraction.

— ⁂ —

Of the other sources you mention, three — wind, tidal, and hydroelectric energy imported from Norway — are also insignificantly small compared to the country's solar resource. The fourth, geothermal, represents a larger energy resource than the solar resource, but because it is more expensive to access, it will remain untapped until after the Netherlands starts to experience a scarcity of places to erect solar panels.

David MacKay's Europe-wide estimate of the wind power resource per person is 0.4 W/m² http://withouthotair.com/c30/page_232.shtml, which works out to 17 GW in the Netherlands' 42865 km². This is enough to supply about a quarter of current marketed energy consumption. You will note that this 0.017 TW is insignificant compared to the 4.2 TW of solar resource. This is true almost everywhere, not just in the Netherlands; MacKay cites a worldwide estimate http://withouthotair.com/c30/page_235.shtml of some 53000 TWh/year (6 TW) of wind resource, which you will note is comparable to the solar resource of just the Netherlands.

Current Dutch wind farms total some 6 TW of nameplate capacity and are growing about 10% per year. These produce about 2 TW of power on average, giving about a 30%–40% capacity factor, a bit low for wind but not unreasonable. This represents 2% of the Netherlands' current energy demand, potentially growing to 4% within a decade.

https://globalwindatlas.info/area/Netherlands gives much higher numbers: 500 W/m² at a height of 100 m. This is lower than the solar resource only by a factor of 2, rather than the factor of 400 from MacKay. To resolve the discrepancy, let's look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windpark_Noordoostpolder, in an area the Global Wind Atlas rates as having 600 W/m² resource. It has a nameplate capacity of 429 MW and generates 1.4 TWh/year, which is 160 MW, a 37% capacity factor. It occupies 8 km², thus giving 20 W/m² on average, halfway between the two numbers. This is a bit better than what you would get with current mainstream solar panels (200 W/m² with a 10% capacity factor gives you 20 W/m² of panel, but angled at 53° you get 12 W per m² of land).

But presumably if you blanket a large percentage of the country with windmills, the wind speed will go down.

Tidal power is about two orders of magnitude smaller than wind power; MacKay http://withouthotair.com/c30/page_237.shtml cites "Kowalik (2004)" as estimating a worldwide practically-extractable resource of 40–80 GW. The Netherlands, with its mere 1900 km of coastline, can't have more than 1% of that total, since it has about 0.1% of the world's total coastline of 1.6 million km.

Norwegian hydroelectric energy is almost tapped out, and certainly cannot provide an order of magnitude more energy than at present; there just isn't enough rainfall at high elevations. Moreover, it is a particularly expensive form of energy, not just in flooded upstream lands and the risk of dam breaches but also in construction. Historically it has been competitive with, even a bit cheaper than, fossil-fuel power plants; but it has not experienced the dramatic collapse in pricing that photovoltaic has over the last decade.

— ⁂ —

Historically, geothermal power has been limited to areas with subterranean water in near contact with magma near the surface. But modern hydrofracking approaches ("enhanced geothermal systems", also more straightforwardly called "hot dry rock") have demonstrated the ability to extract thermal energy from much deeper rock without the necessity for it to already be wet; almost anywhere in the world can do this, using drilling equipment similar to an oil well. An enormous amount of fossil energy is locked in the crust from the last several billion years of radioactive decay. For uses like electricity and transport, though, the trouble is that turning the heat into a useful form requires running that heat through the same kind of steam turbines that are failing to compete with PV in existing coal and oil plants. The resource is enormous, orders of magnitude larger than solar, but even if drilling were free, solar will be cheaper until we start running out of land. Unless heat engines suddenly get a lot cheaper.

The geothermal gradient is typically about 30°/km, so typically you need to drill 3 km to even reach boiling, and almost 12 km to reach water's critical point. Most of the heat is "fossil heat"; heat flow out of the earth is currently about 44 TW, but this has been going on for 4 billion years, and most of that heat is still there, several million yottajoules.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:51PM (#23107404)
The countries mentioned here are among the countries with the largest solar resources in the world.

— ⁂ —

It's important to understand the magnitudes we're talking about: world marketed energy consumption, excluding food but including non-electric energy uses like shipping, is² about 19 terawatts (160 terawatt hours per year or 14000 Mtoe per year); total terrestrial insolation is roughly 130 000 terawatts (at 1000 W/m², at ground level) to 170 000 terawatts (at 1361 W/m², above the atmosphere); and the Ghawar supergiant oil field contained a bit over 100 billion barrels of oil before the humans started extracting it³. At the standard value of 37 MJ/ℓ, 100 billion barrels is almost 600 exajoules⁴ ⁵; if you burned it all in one year it would also produce 19 terawatts. Total world oil "production" is about 81 million barrels a day⁶, which works out to 5.5 terawatts, more than a quarter of world marketed energy consumption (although a significant minority of that oil is made into asphalt and plastics rather than burned).

So current world marketed energy consumption is a bit over 0.1% of total terrestrial insolation, and oil is only able to supply a small part (≈20%) of world marketed energy consumption. The solar resource, like the enhanced geothermal resource and the fusion-fuel resource of the oceans, is truly immense, dwarfing fossil fuel consumption.

Morocco, to take one of the listed countries as an example, is 710 000 km² of mostly cloudless desert¹. If solar plants there get a 30% capacity factor (typical for temperate deserts, maybe a bit low for Morocco) and use low-cost 16%-efficient solar panels, they'll produce 48 W/m² (on average around the clock), which is 48 MW/km²; the country as a whole could produce 34 terawatts, about double world marketed energy consumption.

— ⁂ —

Historically speaking, the humans have burned fossil fuels because their photovoltaic panel manufacturing was too inefficient; until the 1990s, it took more energy to produce a solar panel than it would produce during its design lifetime of 30 years. Now low-cost solar modules cost €0.18 per (peak) watt⁷, following a dramatic fall in crystalline silicon PV module prices from €2.17 per peak watt in May 2009⁰ to €0.19 in December 2018, representing dramatic improvements in efficiency of some 22% per year; since then, a price-fixing cartel then announced at Davos has prevented further improvements in efficiency from further lowering wholesale prices. Still, their cost is now comparable to the cost of the heat engines and electric generators needed to harness fossil fuels for purposes other than raw heat, exclusive of fuel and other operational expenses.

It's commonly commented that the sun doesn't shine at night, so solar power only works at night if you have transcontinental power transmission lines (not yet existing, probably HVDC, perhaps a strategic vulnerability similar to Twitter) or utility-scale energy storage. The need for storage can make solar energy roughly as expensive at night as fossil-fuel energy, but during the day it's considerably cheaper in areas with large solar resources. If transcontinental HVDC becomes a real thing, the countries mentioned could become bigger exporters of solar energy than they ever were of oil energy.

— ⁂ —

One more note about Morocco: Morocco has a lot of Arabs, but it also has a lot of Berbers¹; it seems sort of flamebaity to describe it as an "Arab state"!

—

⁰ https://web.archive.org/web/20100722072720/http://www.solars...

¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morocco

² https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_consumption

³ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghawar

⁴ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barrel_%28unit%29#Oil_barrel

⁵ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density

⁶ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_produ...

⁷ https://www.solarserver.de/pv-modulpreise/

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by galuggus on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:23PM (#23108531)
Could you give more details about the price fixing cartel?

Who is in it?

What is the effect of this cartel likely to be on prices /progress?

Will it be elaffected by eu/us regulation ?

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:01PM (#23108872)
At least GCL System Integration Technology Co., apparently, and presumably most or all of the Chinese PV manufacturing industry, which is most of the world's:

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-davos-meeting-solar-gcl-i...

HN discussion at the time:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19002696

Like the DRAM cartel in the mid-1990s, it will probably hold prices constant for a while (the price freeze has lasted a year and a half already) before they start falling again. In the DRAM case they fell to the previous trend line, but in this case they might not; reducing panel costs much further would make them cheaper per square meter than things like window glass. Crystalline silicon photovoltaic panels have a minimum raw-materials cost per watt governed by terrestrial insolation and the mechanical fragility of silicon; this is different from the situation with DRAM where bits in RAM can be made arbitrarily small.

The US is currently imposing punitive tariffs on solar panel imports because the zombie bankrupt US solar panel manufacturer Suniva filed a lawsuit saying prices were too low — and won! So, whatever is going to happen with solar energy, the US will not be a participant for a few years, and maybe not ever. The EU certainly could make important moves, if they were to fund a venture to spin up PV production at prices that undercut China's, and certainly they are big PV buyers.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by colincooke on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:48PM (#23108121)
I'm curious, as you seem to be well read on this topic, what the effect of desert winds/sand are on panel longevitity and efficiency are?
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:55PM (#23108192)
I think what I've seen is that you can lose about 20% of efficiency temporarily to dusty panels (until you wipe them off) and about 10% permanently to abrasion increasing the reflectivity of the glass; but longevity is unchanged. I'd be interested in reading more solid studies.
[dead]
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by danans on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:13PM (#23106176)
Not sure what you're referring to:

Kamuthi: The world's largest solar power project

https://www.bbc.com/news/av/technology-39963455/kamuthi-the-...

How India's 'smart villages' are centralising solar power

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-36681112

Seeing the light: How India is embracing solar power

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-39844446

India doubles down on solar, gas at coal's expense as electricity use falls

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-india-solar/india-doubles...

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Tade0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:54PM (#23105921)
Its 6m panels produce 1.5 gigawatts (GW) of energy

This is one thing I don't get: why do journalists confuse units so often?

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:54PM (#23106741)
This is a case where journalists are, for once, not confusing units. A square meter of solar panels produces about 200 watts peak, 50 watts round-the-clock average†. A gigawatt is a billion watts, so that's about 5 million square meters or 20 million square meters of solar panels, depending on whether they're talking about peak or average power.

A journalist confusing units might have said something like "Its 6 million panels produce 3600 gigawatt hours," without bothering to tell you whether that's per day, per month, or per year. But it's perfectly correct to say that a panel or a solar plant produces some number of gigawatts.

† Yes, this depends on the type of panel and the location. Some panels are a little higher efficiency, some are a little lower efficiency, and the ones we use on satellites are a lot higher efficiency. And different places have more or less sun. Typical numbers are 1000 W/m² of "solar constant" nominal maximum insolation, 16%–21% efficiency (ratio of insolation to energy produced), and 15%–30% capacity factor (ratio of average power to peak power).

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by function_seven on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:39PM (#23109198)
The problem here is that the unit and the thing being measured don't agree in that sentence. As a reader, I have to guess if the author really meant:

> Its 6m panels produce 1.5 gigawatt[-hour]s (GW[h]) of energy [per year]

or

> Its 6m panels produce 1.5 gigawatts (GW) of [power]

With some reasoning, I can land on the 2nd one just fine, but a little doubt lingers, because I've seen similar errors where I had to do the first substitution to make the numbers work.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:26PM (#23109583)
I agree that some authors do make the first error you suggest, but the unit and the thing being measured definitely do agree; the first interpretation is just incorrect.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by function_seven on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:29PM (#23109606)
The use of "energy" when the author meant "power" is the point of confusion here. That's the unit/thing disagreement I'm referring to.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:14PM (#23109902)
Oh, hmm, I don't think it's actually wrong. I mean, it's valid to say that the cost of this bag of sand is US$1, or that the cost of the bag of sand is US$0.05 per kg. It's valid to say that I went 100 km of distance, or that I went 100 km per hour, of distance. It's valid to say that I poured 15 kg of flour into the bowl, or that I poured 1 kg per second of flour into the bowl. It's valid to say that I have 120 mph of groundspeed, or that I am accelerating at 1 mph/sec of groundspeed. It's valid to say that I'm at 22 meters of altitude, or that I am gaining 0.1 meters per second of altitude. Would you reject some or all of these as ill-formed?

A watt is just a joule per second, and a joule is a measure of energy, so I think that, in the same way, it's reasonable to talk about both "3100 joules of energy" and "200 watts of energy". I think it would probably be better to say "200 watts of power", but the other one isn't wrong. Is it?

Nearly every quantitative statement has an implicit denominator somewhere. Your server serves 50,000 requests per second, you say? Is that per core or per machine? Or maybe per rack? Occasionally there are implicit numerators as well: maybe those are 50,000 one-kilobyte requests.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by perilunar on Friday May 08, 2020 @01:47AM (#23111765)
> the other one isn't wrong. Is it?

Yes, it is. To use one of your examples, it's as wrong as saying you travelled a distance of 120 mph.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Friday May 08, 2020 @01:19PM (#23117140)
"An energy of 1.5 gigawatts" would clearly be incorrect, like "a distance of 120 mph", but "120 miles per hour of distance" sounds fine to my ear; does it not to yours? And what the article said was "1.5 gigawatts of energy".
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chickenpotpie on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:01PM (#23106008)
Probably because a lot of units are synonyms in normal English aren’t synonyms in science. If you look up synonyms for energy power is one of them. Just like mass and weight.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by leephillips on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:10PM (#23106144)
Most of them that I know have never taken a science course (aside from watered-down science for humanities majors courses) and are basically innumerate.

EDIT: except science journalists, of course, some of whom have a real science background.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by oh_sigh on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:37PM (#23106496)
I'm fairly sure 90+% of the population couldn't tell you exactly what a watt, vs a gigawatt, vs a kilowatt, vs a kilowatt hour is. For most people, these units are just opaque names with vague concepts associated with them(ie kilowatt hours measures how much power you used in your home). And journalists are just members of the population, so it shouldn't be surprising that mistakes occur.

A normal person's interaction with the electrical world is extremely limited, so there is little utility in having any kind of understanding of it. I'd be much more worried if journalists were confusing, say, distance measurements with weight measurements, or something like that.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Analemma_ on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:32PM (#23107189)
Before sneering at journalists you may want to double-check that you're not the confused one. That sentence is exactly correct.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by colanderman on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:00PM (#23108257)
I think the GP is referring to the use of "energy" vs. "power". Watts are the latter.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by etaioinshrdlu on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:00PM (#23108265)
I think they should have capitalized 6m to 6M and said 1.5 gigawatts of power, not energy. Then it seems to be accurate to me.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chakerb on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:13PM (#23106982)
A lot of solar panels were insalled where I live compared to none five years ago. However their only use case here is to pump water out of the ground. The prices of the panel don't make them good investment for home usage. And even the government don't provide enough incentives to invest in them.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by dwaltrip on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:22PM (#23107095)
Do you have numbers?
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chakerb on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:46PM (#23107352)
Well, we have only one company installing solar panels in a ~25 km radius. And they're installing around 3 installation per month, each have 8 large panels.I don't have the exact number of how many watt they generate. But they are capable of powering pumps that pulls 12 liters per second.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:57PM (#23107480)
You're probably mistaken [edit: no, I was wrong] about whether they're good investments for home usage and whether government subsidies would be needed, but maybe you live in a country where import tariffs make the panels cost a lot more than they cost on the open market.

By "large" do you mean something more like 0.01 m², 0.1 m², 1 m², 10 m², or 100 m²? Any of those is a "large panel" in some frame of reference.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chakerb on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:17PM (#23107740)
They're not a good investment due to high cost of the panels compared to the price of electricity. Which to be fair is heavily subsided be the state. I'm looking forward to install ones myself, but I'm in the 90th percentile of people in my country that can afford to write big check upfront for power for home usage. Again most of the usage now is limited to agriculture since it makes sense there financially.

By large I mean around 2m² each. Not sure the best size to capture the most out of the sun. But we're at the edge of the Sahara desert, so the climate is a little bit helping there.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:24PM (#23107839)
Interesting! Yeah, if electricity is heavily subsidized, you're probably right that solar panels are unprofitable. How much does electricity cost? Why don't the agricultural water pumping folks use the subsidized electricity instead of installing solar panels?
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chakerb on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:15PM (#23108979)
0.021 usd per kwh. Farmer are sparsely located, so linking them to the main grid is costly as they need to pay for it by themselves.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:23PM (#23109569)
Hmm, if we use €0.19/Wp as the price, US$1.08/€ as the exchange rate, and 30% as the capacity factor (I'm assuming it's a bit sunnier than Arizona, which has a 25% average capacity factor for utility-scale solar), the payback time is only 3.7 years. That seems like a pretty profitable investment even despite the subsidized electrical rate.

To be concrete, a 200-watt solar panel should cost about US$41, and produce on average 60 watts: 0.06 kWh/h, which is US$0.00126 per hour, US$0.03 per day, US$0.92 per month, US$11 per year. So in a bit less than four years, it pays for itself, unless the subsidized price of power drops by then or someone steals the panel. If we include a motor scooter battery and cigarette-lighter inverter so you can plug regular appliances into it, even at night, the payback time jumps up to maybe ten years.

Maybe you're mostly saying that US$41 or US$100 is a lot of money to invest up front, or maybe the problem is (as it is here in Argentina) that panel prices are wildly inflated by corruption.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by econcon on Friday May 08, 2020 @12:14AM (#23111329)
Last time I was installing panels, they were cheap even the mono ones, but there were other costs like mppt charger, batteries, inverter and DC wires (copper is expensive) when I summed it all, I got to the breakeven point in 10 years.

Now I am thinking about grid connected setup but still AC module isn't cheap if they were only $50-$100, like the enphase AC units embedded into solar panel itself, it would be worth it. But it nearly doubles the price so I've not installed any panel yet.