News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Tade0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:54PM (#23105921)
Its 6m panels produce 1.5 gigawatts (GW) of energy

This is one thing I don't get: why do journalists confuse units so often?

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:54PM (#23106741)
This is a case where journalists are, for once, not confusing units. A square meter of solar panels produces about 200 watts peak, 50 watts round-the-clock average†. A gigawatt is a billion watts, so that's about 5 million square meters or 20 million square meters of solar panels, depending on whether they're talking about peak or average power.

A journalist confusing units might have said something like "Its 6 million panels produce 3600 gigawatt hours," without bothering to tell you whether that's per day, per month, or per year. But it's perfectly correct to say that a panel or a solar plant produces some number of gigawatts.

† Yes, this depends on the type of panel and the location. Some panels are a little higher efficiency, some are a little lower efficiency, and the ones we use on satellites are a lot higher efficiency. And different places have more or less sun. Typical numbers are 1000 W/m² of "solar constant" nominal maximum insolation, 16%–21% efficiency (ratio of insolation to energy produced), and 15%–30% capacity factor (ratio of average power to peak power).

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by function_seven on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:39PM (#23109198)
The problem here is that the unit and the thing being measured don't agree in that sentence. As a reader, I have to guess if the author really meant:

> Its 6m panels produce 1.5 gigawatt[-hour]s (GW[h]) of energy [per year]

or

> Its 6m panels produce 1.5 gigawatts (GW) of [power]

With some reasoning, I can land on the 2nd one just fine, but a little doubt lingers, because I've seen similar errors where I had to do the first substitution to make the numbers work.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:26PM (#23109583)
I agree that some authors do make the first error you suggest, but the unit and the thing being measured definitely do agree; the first interpretation is just incorrect.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by function_seven on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:29PM (#23109606)
The use of "energy" when the author meant "power" is the point of confusion here. That's the unit/thing disagreement I'm referring to.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:14PM (#23109902)
Oh, hmm, I don't think it's actually wrong. I mean, it's valid to say that the cost of this bag of sand is US$1, or that the cost of the bag of sand is US$0.05 per kg. It's valid to say that I went 100 km of distance, or that I went 100 km per hour, of distance. It's valid to say that I poured 15 kg of flour into the bowl, or that I poured 1 kg per second of flour into the bowl. It's valid to say that I have 120 mph of groundspeed, or that I am accelerating at 1 mph/sec of groundspeed. It's valid to say that I'm at 22 meters of altitude, or that I am gaining 0.1 meters per second of altitude. Would you reject some or all of these as ill-formed?

A watt is just a joule per second, and a joule is a measure of energy, so I think that, in the same way, it's reasonable to talk about both "3100 joules of energy" and "200 watts of energy". I think it would probably be better to say "200 watts of power", but the other one isn't wrong. Is it?

Nearly every quantitative statement has an implicit denominator somewhere. Your server serves 50,000 requests per second, you say? Is that per core or per machine? Or maybe per rack? Occasionally there are implicit numerators as well: maybe those are 50,000 one-kilobyte requests.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by perilunar on Friday May 08, 2020 @01:47AM (#23111765)
> the other one isn't wrong. Is it?

Yes, it is. To use one of your examples, it's as wrong as saying you travelled a distance of 120 mph.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by kragen on Friday May 08, 2020 @01:19PM (#23117140)
"An energy of 1.5 gigawatts" would clearly be incorrect, like "a distance of 120 mph", but "120 miles per hour of distance" sounds fine to my ear; does it not to yours? And what the article said was "1.5 gigawatts of energy".
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by chickenpotpie on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:01PM (#23106008)
Probably because a lot of units are synonyms in normal English aren’t synonyms in science. If you look up synonyms for energy power is one of them. Just like mass and weight.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by leephillips on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:10PM (#23106144)
Most of them that I know have never taken a science course (aside from watered-down science for humanities majors courses) and are basically innumerate.

EDIT: except science journalists, of course, some of whom have a real science background.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by oh_sigh on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:37PM (#23106496)
I'm fairly sure 90+% of the population couldn't tell you exactly what a watt, vs a gigawatt, vs a kilowatt, vs a kilowatt hour is. For most people, these units are just opaque names with vague concepts associated with them(ie kilowatt hours measures how much power you used in your home). And journalists are just members of the population, so it shouldn't be surprising that mistakes occur.

A normal person's interaction with the electrical world is extremely limited, so there is little utility in having any kind of understanding of it. I'd be much more worried if journalists were confusing, say, distance measurements with weight measurements, or something like that.

Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by Analemma_ on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:32PM (#23107189)
Before sneering at journalists you may want to double-check that you're not the confused one. That sentence is exactly correct.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by colanderman on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:00PM (#23108257)
I think the GP is referring to the use of "energy" vs. "power". Watts are the latter.
Re:Arab states are embracing solar power by etaioinshrdlu on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:00PM (#23108265)
I think they should have capitalized 6m to 6M and said 1.5 gigawatts of power, not energy. Then it seems to be accurate to me.