News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jakearmitage on Monday April 06, 2020 @01:42PM (#22795888)
HomeDepot's ecommerce is a joke. Not only the shopping experience is poor, they treat logistics as if they were doing you a favor. And, on top of all that, you get damaged items. I made 7 purchases and all 7, in different periods of time, had to be returned or replaced.

Same for Lowe's. There's a reason people shop on Amazon. Other than BestBuy, no other retailer "gets" ecommerce.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by mauvehaus on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:42PM (#22796521)
I beg to differ. Rock Auto is where it's at for auto parts. The website is ugly as hammered shit, but it's fast, shows you the options grouped by rough quality level (economy/you cheapskate, daily driver, performance, etc), shows you what part to select so it ships from the same warehouse as the parts already in your cart and saves you shipping, and returns are painless (disclaimer: I've only ever done returns for core exchanges). I have never had a better online purchasing experience.

And the prices are a fraction of what you pay at a brick and mortar place. Especially for e.g. wiper blades.

Companies that "get" e-commerce are out there, but a lot of them are quietly and competently doing their thing in unsexy domains and aren't trying to eat the whole pie.

Rock Auto, for instance, isn't trying to serve every idiot on the planet with a car. If you can't keep your lefts/rights and fronts/backs straight when ordering e.g. brake hoses, you're going to find it a frustrating experience. Putting up a (small) barrier to entry to keep out the least clueful people probably helps keep their costs down.

Not affiliated, just a very happy repeat customer.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by dan_quixote on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:32PM (#22796981)
My nomination is McMaster-Carr (mcmaster.com) - They have a huge catalog of parts/tools yet somehow it's so intuitive to browse. I was a mechanical engineer in a previous life and McMaster's website was my bible. Step one for any new prototype design was to browse this site. Best case scenario, you could cobble together your prototype from various COTS (commercial off the shelf) McMaster parts. And if that wasn't an option, scan the catalog for necessary parts and raw materials. If they don't exist at McMaster, your design idea just got at least 10X expensive and lead time doubled.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by sambroner on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:52PM (#22797140)
I was always shocked by McMaster-Carr's delivery speed. I felt like the parts would arrive as quickly as I could have conceivably picked them up.

This was 10 years ago now, so sort of like Amazon Prime before it became ubiquitous, but for materials and tools. However McMaster was and remains much better organized and much better spec-ed.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by frandroid on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:12PM (#22799191)
That's because they already have to delivery that fast for car repair shops. Fast delivery has never been an extra for them, it's always been the core product.

What's interesting is that considering the existing logistics, none of these guys though of expanding into other ecommerce earlier. One of them could have been Amazon...

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by dan_quixote on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @04:37PM (#22816807)
I'm glad they didn't to be honest. It would have diluted their existing product.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jgust on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:59PM (#22797184)
I have a sneaking suspicion that Amazon is re-solving problems that traditional supply chain companies like McMaster-Carr solved 1-2 decades ago. It would be fascinating to read a case study comparing the two.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by lotsofpulp on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:57PM (#22798304)
Amazon is trying to shed all possible liability as a merchant and collect their 15% or whatever rent, since that’s where the margins are. That’s at odds with what I’m looking for as a buyer, which is a seller that will vet and stand behind their products.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jgust on Monday April 06, 2020 @09:35PM (#22799604)
As any reasonable, educated consumer would be.

I would like to know if a McMaster-Carr, Grainger, et al had fallen into the same traps Amazon has when it comes to supply chain and if eventually Amazon will be shaped into a similar company & business model.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by lotsofpulp on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @12:00AM (#22800243)
Amazon's actions make it clear that the company's goal is not to provide the customer with products of a minimum and consistent quality, nor is it to make it easy for customers to even purchase products from Amazon.com. Note how they hide the option to filter for only products shipped and sold by Amazon.com

Amazon knows that retail margins are tiny, a few percent at best, and that is not what they are interested in. It takes a lot of labor to provide high quality vetting and constant vigilance over suppliers. What they are interested in is high margins, which comes from being a platform.

I don't think McMaster Carr or Grainger ever had any intention of becoming platforms for resellers so they could take a top line cut of sales and outsource quality control.

If anything, I think Amazon is probably trying to reduce their shipped and sold by Amazon.com retail operations and focus on the high margin web services. Why compete with Walmart/Target/Best Buy/Home Depot/Lowes for <5% profit margin with huge liabilities when you can make 20%+ easy on super scalable web services?

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by btrettel on Monday April 06, 2020 @04:36PM (#22797552)
Once, circa 2006, I ordered some rubber tubing from McMaster-Carr in the morning. It was shipped it from New Jersey to western Maryland, where I lived, by that afternoon.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Guest42 on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:31PM (#22798977)
Same, gets there practically as soon as the call is hung up, their catalog has everything, and their websites search function is intuitive and efficient
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jbay808 on Monday April 06, 2020 @04:00PM (#22797187)
I like McMaster-Carr, but I often hear them being held up as a positive UX example when, in my experience, their website is endlessly frustrating. They often force you into choosing arbitrary categories too early, break tabbed browsing expectations, and have a frustrating mix of metric and imperial measurements that can't be escaped. Their pricing is also generally at quite a premium.

For example, let's say I want a piece of hollow metal cylinder (any metal, to be determined later based on cost and availability), with an ID of around 12 mm and a wall thickness of at least 5 mm, at least 150 mm long. It ends up being a needlessly frustrating experience even for such a simple item.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by smolder on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:15PM (#22797965)
I know what you mean, and I can say that most of the categorization, which may seem arbitrary, reasonably comes from how those items are manufactured and used historically. An example is pipe versus tube; they are measured differently and have differences in ranges of wall thickness, precision and so on, because different needs and processes developed between pipes that carry fluids vs structural tubing. Most but not all people are going to want one category or another based on intended use, and probably have a highly-available size/thickness in mind already, too.

Getting things custom made is expensive, so customers are pressured to use what's widely available. Stocking lots of things not widely purchased is also expensive. These forces have been working for a long time to give us a pretty wide selection that covers most uses.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jbay808 on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:35PM (#22798551)
I know that pipe and tube have different specifications and applications -- that's specifically why I picked this example. But those differences don't always apply to me. I'd prefer a UI with a check box for pipe, tube, or both, because sometimes I want my search to cover both things. Maybe I want to use a pipe as a paperweight or an art piece or whatever. If McMaster could accurately guess what I was going to use something for, my employer wouldn't need me.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by smolder on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:18PM (#22798875)
Intelligent search of physical parts is something I've thought a bit about before, in a different context. Often times people with a lot of car knowledge can point out interchangeable items that manufacturers don't come out and acknowledge as being interchangeable.

Examples: Oil filters are often differently sized but still interchangeable between models. You can use an Aisin-built airflow meter from a 90s Mazda to replace one in a Toyota, even though they're different housings, and it would work (if not perfectly) because it's essentially the same part with the same electronics. Brakes and suspension parts often interchange across many models, with the possibility of 'upgrading' to heavier duty parts from more expensive models.

Anyway, it'd be great if you could combine a lot of data and NLP to search off-the-shelf parts based on parameters of varying specificity. Anything from "made of metal and roughly x/y/z dimensions" to "shares the same bolt pattern as part # on a joining surface" could be made searchable in theory.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by btrettel on Monday April 06, 2020 @04:40PM (#22797608)
Having used McMaster-Carr for over a decade, I strongly agree about the filtering being non-ideal and also the prices being high. There's an interaction between the two as well: You can't sort by price. Often there are many items meeting the specs I want but I just want to see which ones are the cheapest. At the moment I skim everything, making notes about candidates, and them manually compare them on price.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jbay808 on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:38PM (#22798570)
Yes, this exactly. This causes searches to take hours for simple things. Sometimes if I look in "steel" expecting to find something cheap, the only part matching my dimensions is military-grade superalloy tool steel that costs a fortune, so I have to go back and look again in "stainless steel" where there's perhaps a reasonable price.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by SpikedCola on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:43PM (#22799344)
Unfortunately McMaster-Carr won't deal with Canadian companies they believe could be associated with the cannabis industry "due to US Federal Laws". I've been at two companies where we've placed an order with them, then had it immediately cancelled. Only after following up did I learn the reason.

When I tried to re-order through my personal company (not in any way cannabis-related) I was told I'm not a big enough company for them to deal with (and they cancelled the order).

From a CAD/dimensional standpoint, their website is a goldmine. I just wish they would take my money.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by fireattack on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:47PM (#22798221)
If we started to include McMaster-Carr I would also say I have very good experience with Digi-key and Mouser.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by mkl on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:32PM (#22798108)
My main experience with their site is the incredibly aggressive and trigger-happy bot filter. If you reload a page a few times due to a bad connection, they block you. Not "solve this captcha to continue", just "go away, we're not letting you in".
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by benboughton1 on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:42PM (#22798188)
Can anyone nominate an Australian equivalent to mcmaster.com ? I am prototyping something and would love to have a lost of available parts to troll through with prices.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Rebelgecko on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @11:17AM (#22803986)
I only ordered from the once but IIRC they don't tell you what shipping costs until AFTER you place your order. That seemed a bit crazy to me
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by senderista on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @01:34AM (#22800564)
The McMaster-Carr website is one of the finest examples of UX on the internet. Also they did next-day delivery literally decades before Amazon.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by aschatten on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @05:19AM (#22801632)
Can you use it as an i dividual or bussinesses only?
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by quasse on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:31PM (#22798102)
RockAuto's easily navigable catalog is what has gotten them $5000+ in sales from me over the years.

Autozone / NAPA try, but the catalogs are clunky and require many page loads to navigate to a given item. Once you find an item, it's a crapshoot whether the listing will be items that are actually for sale at a store near me. Half the time the first 5 items will be "generic" parts that don't actually fit my car anyway.

RockAuto lets you drill down to the exact part you need, compare 5+ different brands on the spot and add it to the cart without ever changing pages. It's a real triumph of slim web design.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by drewzero1 on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:31PM (#22798526)
I hope Rock Auto never replaces their website. Sure I have to scroll down the whole page to find my manufacturer in the alphabetical sidebar listing, and then open the nested categories like I'm looking for a folder in Windows 3.1, but once I get there I find a list of parts that I know will fit my car arranged so I can tell the quality vs. price trade-offs.

I used to look for parts on Advance and O'Reilly's sites, half of the time it seemed the search results would have parts that wouldn't fit my car. So I really like the way that RA's nested folder structure ensures the most important constraint (compatibility) is met during the search.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by grosswait on Monday April 06, 2020 @10:22PM (#22799814)
Overall I agree, but I've found it wise to cross-reference their part numbers as they are sometimes wrong for lower volume models. Eg: offering standard Ford Focus brake pads when the model searched is a Focus ST
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by basch on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:01PM (#22799135)
Try the search. Its phenomenal. And then when you click enter, the next search box that appears. And then the filter box. I dont ever have to scroll on the rock auto page.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by intrepidhero on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:43PM (#22798603)
I'll second Rock Auto. A dated looking website that Just Works (TM).

Parts-tree another great one, focused on yard maintenance equipment.

Ace hardware is kind of neat. I ordered some stuff as Christmas presents and the local store called me on the phone to ask if I was going to be home and where would I like them to put the items. I asked if they could stick them in the garage and maybe in some generic looking boxes to preserve the surprise (of being presents) and the boxes all showed up neatly hand wrapped in brown paper! Only one data point but definitely made me feel like ordering again.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by basch on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:00PM (#22799128)
I'll go a step further on the interface. It's one of the best shopping experiences online. Ive noticed this about auto part stores POS systems, but rock auto especially, is something special.

You can use the search to REFINE as you search. Start by typing Toyota Camry YEAR and 2.4L if you want. It will keep making suggestions but you can click enter. Then you have a tree to select from OR you can use the new search box that appears to keep searching just in that tree. Then when you get to a category, a third search box appears you can use to filter the results. It's honestly amazing how fast you can search for things. There was another comment about having to scroll a lot, but that's the slow way to use the site.

Rock Auto is one of those sites that will never work as well if it became "mobile first." Like craigslist and photoshop, and the old facebook, its beauty is in its density and how quick you can navigate and drill.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by keanebean86 on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:06PM (#22796770)
I've also had great experiences with Rock Auto. I've been ordering the occasional part from them for about 10 years. Shipping can be expensive but everything comes pretty quick.

Some parts are cheap but they're also inexpensive.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by mauvehaus on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:33PM (#22796987)
Yeah, I try to bundle things up to save on shipping. On the other hand, by the time I need anything, I probably also need wiper blades, and the price difference on just one wiper blade usually covers the cost of shipping.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by alharith on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:08PM (#22798802)
Also, one that many here should be familiar here with: Newegg.

Walmart shipping is pretty on point as well, and you don't need to pay 120$ a year for 2 day shipping.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Exmoor on Monday April 06, 2020 @11:32PM (#22800127)
Newegg has a good website, but their customer service and return policy is not up to par with other retailers and I have started buying from other vendors if the price is remotely close for this reason.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by rdtwo on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @12:23PM (#22804629)
Yeah I pay more for an amazon monitor or anything that could be defective. Newegg return policies are so bad I pay extra to go elsewhere
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by racnid on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:59PM (#22796696)
Their website is one of the clearest and easiest to navigate parts website I've ever come across. I just wish there was an equivalent for motorcycles.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by kube-system on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:02PM (#22796731)
Bikebandit's website isn't too bad after you figure out how to select your bike.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by hathawsh on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:38PM (#22797026)
This is why I read HN. Thank you for recommending a good retailer.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Fjolsvith on Monday April 06, 2020 @11:17PM (#22800051)
My favorite parts site is PartsGeek. Pretty easy to find what I want and every product has a picture so I can make sure it matches what I need. Never had a bad experience with them.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by solotronics on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:01PM (#22796718)
I like NAPA/Oreilly where you can see whats in a store and have them set the parts aside for you so they are there when you get there.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by mauvehaus on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:35PM (#22797007)
Advance and I believe Autozone also let you place orders for in-store pickup. At one point, Advance was putting a coupon code right at the top of the homepage that would save you 20% off your order if you did that.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Shivetya on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:18PM (#22796295)
Best Buy is great, especially for delivery.

Apple, CostCo, Ashley Home Funiture, Wayfair, Wal-Mart, and some minor players, have all performed well in my usage and those who I know also use them. Now with two I had a damaged item they did not want any part of returned, apparently this is common with free shipping deals as the return shipping for larger items can be ridiculous.

Home Depot I have to agree with assessments others have made, lost an item off their own dock and when recreating the order after two weeks of back and forth; UPS was getting annoyed too, they wanted to remake the order and charge full shipping again. Just really bad customer service. They really do act like all screw ups are yours.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by cpascal on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:07PM (#22796179)
> Other than BestBuy, no other retailer "gets" ecommerce

Target.com is a pretty solid experience.

Walmart.com is also surprisingly good.

Although I'm sure people can provide horror stories for both retailers.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by dawnerd on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:11PM (#22796221)
Walmart still suffers the same problem Amazon has with 3rd party sellers. Quality can vary greatly depending on who you're buying from on their platform.

Target and Best Buy definitely nailed it.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by wozniacki on Monday April 06, 2020 @09:29PM (#22799570)
Walmart has been spot on with both their delivery as well pickup-in-store items. I wish they installed FREEZER SILOS at all of their locations for their pickup-in-store FROZEN foods that can be ordered online. Right now only select places have them. You cant order frozen foods online at the rest of the locations. But otherwise they have been great with all of my orders.

HomeDepot and Lowes are a joke. HomeDepot.com even tried to sneak in a 'handling fee' at the checkout ( paraphrasing I forget what they called it ) for a small kitchen appliance though it said 'free shipping' at first glance next to the item description.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by gowld on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:01PM (#22798739)
If you have an ad blocker.

Target sells ad space to random 3rd parties.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by kube-system on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:58PM (#22796684)
I've personally had a lot of issues with Walmart.com.

Their inventory data seems to be a bit messy, I've seen a lot of product names/images/descriptions that are clearly messed up, and on more than a few occasions, I've received a single item when the listing said it was a multi-pack. Also, some of the inventory counts are a bit weird -- sometimes an item will show in-stock on the product page, but not in the cart, at the same time.

In the past I had a lot of issues with their shipping, but they seem to have mostly fixed those. Stuff like those huge stickers over important parts of the product, or improper packing.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by bluGill on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:30PM (#22796411)
We have been trying to use Walmart for groceries, it is okay, but too often they substitute what we don't want. There is a reason we ordered mild not spicy: the kids won't eat spicy hot foods.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by cglace on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:37PM (#22796476)
We have had great experiences with Krogers substitutions. Usually, the substitute with a greater quantity for the same price or better quality.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by whymauri on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:27PM (#22796386)
I'll toss Staples on to there. I ordered a chair two years ago. Relatively modern website, free delivery, and it arrived earlier than anticipated with no damage. Just make sure you unsubscribe from their newsletter.

I also think they'll price-match.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by notatoad on Monday April 06, 2020 @11:35PM (#22800141)
I've had nothing but excellent experiences ordering online from staples, although their email notifications leave something to be desired. I've learned to just trust that my package is actually on the way now, but usually I get the "your package has shipped" email some time after I actually get the package, if I get a notification at all.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by mortenjorck on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:25PM (#22799257)
I was surprised when I ordered from Staples.com a week or two ago. They have a top-tier e-commerce experience, fast shipping (I think my free one-day shipping was a temporary quarantine thing), and they seem to be better at packing than Amazon.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by caymanjim on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:38PM (#22796484)
newegg.com is great. They primarily sell computers and office equipment, but if I'm buying that stuff, it's my go-to. Fast delivery, fantastic customer service. If something is defective, they'll send you a replacement with a return shipping label, no questions asked. Been using them for nearly 20 years without a single complaint.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by rkagerer on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:49PM (#22796597)
10 years ago I used Newegg a ton, but with third party items now mixed into their store, I find shopping there a bit more of a dice roll.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by raegis on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:16PM (#22797976)
I always press the "Seller: Newegg" button. This way I never get counterfeit stuff. On the other hand, specifying the seller to be Amazon on Amazon.com sometimes yields third party products in disguise.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by caymanjim on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:58PM (#22796678)
Amazon suffers from that as well. I'm loath to buy anything from Amazon, Newegg, or any other retailer when it comes from a third party seller. As far as I know, that's always indicated on the product page. They don't hide it, but they don't aggressively inform you either.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by lotsofpulp on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:20PM (#22798896)
Since Amazon commingles inventory, it doesn’t matter if it says shipped and sold by Amazon since the item you get could still be supplied by a third party.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by rfeather on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:47PM (#22798220)
I have decent luck with Microcenter as a Newegg substitution. + if you live in some cities, they have brick and mortar
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by gowld on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:02PM (#22798742)
Hmm? Newegg is a Microcenter alternative if you live too far away.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by beamatronic on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:59PM (#22796687)
100 percent this. I dropped NewEgg when they added third party sellers.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by atlasunshrugged on Monday April 06, 2020 @04:31PM (#22797499)
I was just comparison shopping for an HDMI adapter across Amazon, NewEgg and Bestbuy. Out of the 3 I found NewEgg still to be the best even with the 3rd party sellers mixed in. Amazon the quality looked super sketchy for some of this stuff and for Bestbuy the website had loading problems, an unintuitive UI for store selection (and put me into a store in CA for some reason even though I'm nowhere near there and had no VPN).
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by mypalmike on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:01PM (#22797831)
Monoprice is a good place to go for adapters and cables and such.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by atlasunshrugged on Monday April 06, 2020 @10:37PM (#22799878)
Thanks, I'll check them out
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by parshimers on Monday April 06, 2020 @09:15PM (#22799512)
Their return policies are not good. Amazon will take things back, without fuss. Newegg will charge a very hefty restocking fee, or might not even take it back at all. It is very unfortunate to see this have happen, because I remember in the early 00's they built their business on providing the exact opposite kind of experience to that kind of nickle-and-dime technique that was commonplace at the time.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by shams93 on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @12:18AM (#22800310)
Yeah I got a pair of raspberry pie to play with running Kubernetes on bare metal while I’m stuck at home. No delay no extra shipping cost.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by sjg007 on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:05PM (#22798349)
Walmart has been quite reliable for grocery pickup. I’ve tried Hy-Vee and the experience wasn’t very good. Lots of stuff sold out or not picked. Target has given up on grocery curbside as well. But for household goods it works well. I’m trying our local supermarket curbside next so hopefully that will work out. I know we are in crazy times but I’d be really cool to get a dedicated grocery curbside / delivery operation with only warehouses and no stores. I think the UK has something like that.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Spooky23 on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:08PM (#22798367)
That’s crazy. Target smokes Amazon for most things these days, especially with pickup. Ditto for NewEgg and Walmart.

Amazon is increasingly overrated, they peaked a decade ago and have declined to a warehouse club/flea market.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by cschneid on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:30PM (#22798976)
Newegg and Walmart have fallen to the same thing Amazon has: allowing 3rd party sellers.

They're not as far along, but going down that path is what causes so many issues with counterfeits and generally poor experiences. I accidentally bought some thermal paste from a newegg seller who shipped it via slow-boat-from-china, and it took weeks to get to me. It was technically listed, but I hate any shopping experience that forces me to be on high alert not to get screwed (as minor as super-slow shipping is).

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by senderista on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @01:41AM (#22800589)
AFAIK Amazon is the only online retailer that commingles their own inventory with 3rd-party sellers, making it impossible to avoid counterfeits.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by reilly3000 on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @01:08AM (#22800483)
Target is getting into the 3rd party seller game through Target+. It appears they have a pretty tight process for what gets approved to sell and who gets to sell it. Target by culture is extremely intentional about what they allow on their shelves, and it appears they are following suit with their 'curated' 3rd party sellers.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by gregmac on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:58PM (#22799418)
I honestly don't understand the 3rd party seller thing.

I went from buying almost all PC parts from NewEgg (without even bothering to price shop), to pretty much avoiding the site entirely.

If you look at almost any of the 3rd party sellers' pages and sort by rating, you'll pretty much see the same pattern on all: a tiny handful of 4-5 star reviews, 1 star reviews by the bottom of page 1, and the remaining 80 pages of products have no reviews at all.

Is this really helping Walmart/NewEgg/Amazon/etc vs them just selling the same products directly themselves? Why do this -- are they just trying to avoid these sellers starting competing no-name e-commerce sites?

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by SifJar on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @03:19AM (#22801027)
> Is this really helping Walmart/NewEgg/Amazon/etc vs them just selling the same products directly themselves? Why do this -- are they just trying to avoid these sellers starting competing no-name e-commerce sites?

My thought would be this allows them to pivot from being a "logistics" company to being a "tech" company, providing a "platform" for others.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by rdtwo on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @12:26PM (#22804648)
Walmart website is still stuck in 08. I have to search for things 3 different ways and even then I can’t seem to get one search page to list products of the same type
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jasonjayr on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:40PM (#22799022)
I assist a small drop ship supplier listing their product in Home Depot. Their item management system is absolutely the pits, and requires the use of awful protected excel worksheets in order to get mass data in and out of the system. All the product syndication systems that they recommend are obnoxiously expensive for the amount of SKUs we need to maintain due to product variants.

Overstock & Wayfair are way easier to work with by comparison.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by powvans on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:15PM (#22796852)
I thought the same thing about Home Depot until this hit. I've had the opposite experience with them the last few weeks. Things come quickly, my cart is consistent wherever I am logged in, and I can just add pretty much as much stuff as I want and get it all delivered the next day for $9. I'm loving the express delivery. In general it would always be worth it for me to spend $9 to get stuff delivered from Home Depot. Pre-pandemic it's a solid hour or more in the car to cover the 4.3 miles there and back from my house.

Maybe I'm getting a better experience because I'm in Atlanta and there's a bit of a headquarters halo effect.

Their search and general catalog organization isn't great. I just use Google as my entrance to their site and that makes life easier.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by AmVess on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#22796444)
Nordstrom does it well. I buy shirts and things and they arrive reasonably packaged, and include a return print out ready to go. Returning an item is as simple as putting the print out on the outside of a box and leaving it for the mail collector.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by FridgeSeal on Monday April 06, 2020 @09:31PM (#22799578)
Chain Reaction Cycles for bike gear is unmatched, and outdoes Amazon by a mile.

Search, sorting and faceting features are unmatched: Looking for a pair of handlebars: you can filter by material, colour, width, diameter, rise, sweep, brand, stock level, price. Need some wheels, specifically a wheel set that has a 25mm internal rim diameter, for road biking, disc brake compatible, with 6 bolt disc mounts, 28 spokes, made of carbon fibre, in stock, and then arranged by discount level? Then want to buy it for an actual reasonable price, and receive it within a calendar week (pretty great considering I'm on the opposite side of the world), then CRC is literally unmatched.

Components etc are sensibly, correctly and consistently arranged by type and feature in a way that makes me wish every other online retailer would take several pages out of their book.

I've hunted for bike components on Amazon, it was a painful experience that resulted in a lot of manual searching, going between several pages trying to compare between half a dozen differently formatted and arranged spec sheets just to figure out which components were compatible, and even then the prices were not worth it.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by neosat on Monday April 06, 2020 @10:49PM (#22799932)
was looking for tires -the site looks great. Thanks!
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by fisherjeff on Monday April 06, 2020 @10:56PM (#22799965)
Personally, I applaud Home Depot and Lowes for so meticulously recreating the utter dysfunction of their brick and mortar stores online
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by munificent on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:17PM (#22799218)
> Other than BestBuy, no other retailer "gets" ecommerce.

Sweetwater for music gear. They are the only online company I've ever dealt with that I consider better than Amazon.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Someone1234 on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:37PM (#22796472)
I had a Home Depot order delivered recently, zero padding. It was just a cardboard box surrounding the product, and the product itself had little internal packaging (inc. Lithium Ion batteries). I'm surprised Home Depot hasn't started fires before.

Luckily the product I ordered worked fine, but I wasn't best pleased when I opened it. It was pretty obvious the manufacturer designed the product packaging for retail shelves only, and Home Depot just assumed it was shipping-grade protection.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by passthejoe on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:04PM (#22796745)
My favorite from Target was eight Contigo travel mugs (bought for holiday gifts) that came in a very large box with no padding. Even though they could have clanked around and gotten very scratched, they were all OK. Sort of a miracle, but it didn't give me much confidence in Target.com.

And you can't state quantities on the Target.com site when you select an item. You have to go into the cart and change the quantity. That's something most sites do better.

Also, I understand it's a difficult time inventory-wise, but don't let me put stuff in my cart if you can't deliver it and won't let me order anything until I remove them. Give me a "save for later" feature ... like Amazon does.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Spooky23 on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:13PM (#22798404)
One thing that’s weird about target is that they fulfill from stores. Usually when we get a shady packaging experience it’s shipping from a Target store from some unusual place.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by kbash9 on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:03PM (#22796145)
Never had an issue with costco.com where I've made some of my big purchases.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Someone1234 on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#22796446)
Just this week I had an issue with Costco.com.

Ordered an item, their delivery estimate was 3-5 days. 7 days passed and the item hasn't shipped. No updated ETA or any information/communication on how long it might take.

Decided to cancel and order from an alternative vendor (who would communicate better, frankly). Was unable to even cancel it online (cancel button was missing, in contradiction to their help docs).

Tried to use Online Chat to cancel, which was seemingly offline/broken for multiple days. Finally called their customer service number, and it was cancelled within the hour (which credit where credit is due was one of the best telephone customer service experiences I've had).

Took all of 10 days to NOT receive a 3-5 day item from Costco.com, the replacement item ordered elsewhere arrived in 48 hours. Still don't know how long the Costco.com item would have taken because they never communicated that.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by ethbro on Monday April 06, 2020 @04:26PM (#22797453)
From experience internally (not at Costco, but other t20 retail), here's what happened, from most to least likely.

1. Your order type fell into an edge cast that an incomplete batch system -> system transfer job choked on. Naturally, it silently failed.

2. Inventory count mismatch.

3. Incomplete transportation handshake.

Logistics looks simple from a customer perspective: (1) order, (2) ship, (3) receive. From a vendor perspective it's (1+) bulk source, (2+) distribute, (3) maintain consistent inventory counts, (4) receive order, (5) source order items from stock most efficiently, (6) orchestrate multi-sourced items, (7+) provision & batch transportation, receiving and reshipping at multiple legs, (8+) fulfill last mile.

All while stitching together 30+ year old systems for each of those. And the +'d items are all semi-outside of the company's control. (Ever wonder why there are so many transportation-abstraction companies?)

Which is to say, no excuse for bad service. But it's a bear of a problem.

Incidentally, why most retail has excellent customer support phone centers (usually onshore): they know their systems break a non-zero amount of time, and want the best touch when you need to have things fixed.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by coding123 on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:02PM (#22796138)
This is a key point. Especially for prime items, but largely to other items they sell that are not fulfilled by them. It just feels like there is more responsibility through the amazon platform than other websites.

I ordered a case of water through Amazon through a reseller. The shipment literally got lost. Amazon dispute, 20 minutes later, refund is done.

I am waiting for a resolution through Paypal from another website - off amazon - since Friday for toilet paper that will definitely not be sent. After looking at policies, etc.. they generally don't do refunds.

Though, I did have luck on one other site.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by croshan on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:11PM (#22796227)
Sure, but they handle it well.

I placed an order for a pair of 35lb dumbbells, and only one came, and the cardboard box around it was falling apart.

I called customer support, probably for the first time in my life, to ask wtf happened. And they explained the logistics issue (the dumbbells were shipped separately for some reason), and ended up crediting me half the cost of the dumbbells, even though the first wasn't really damaged.

Also their dumbbells were better and cheaper than Amazon's, so there's that too.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by lkbm on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:16PM (#22796276)
> (the dumbbells were shipped separately for some reason)

USPS limits packages to 70 LBs. There's probably some special option to get around this, but for the "normal" shipping, that's the limit.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by TylerE on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @02:33AM (#22800838)
If there is, it will cost 5x as much. They really don’t like special handling.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by sseagull on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:26PM (#22796378)
I imagine this is one of those things where everyone has different experiences. Or maybe it depends on location.

We recently moved into a new house (from an apartment) and needed lots of little things renters never worry about. I have ordered quite a bit of stuff from Home Depot, from a washer & dryer to a lawn mower to random small tools and paint. Never had any issue whatsoever.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by ravenstine on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:14PM (#22796252)
To be fair, the in-person shopping experience at Home Depot is exactly the same. They're staying true to their ethos. ;)
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Buttons840 on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:59PM (#22799123)
Even BestBuy has problems. I have an order waiting to ship I want to cancel/return (unopened) but they won't let me. Guess they'll have to go through the full return process rather than just let me cancel.

Meanwhile, Amazon can cancel items even after they ship most of the time.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by smichel17 on Monday April 06, 2020 @05:43PM (#22798192)
I've been pretty happy with newegg, and my recent electronics purchases have been split between it, Amazon, and direct from manufacturer (preferring direct unless there is a significant price difference, due to counterfeit-wariness).
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by unethical_ban on Monday April 06, 2020 @10:25PM (#22799829)
Lowe's shopping site is an abomination, a tome of anti-patterns to be researched in design classes on what not to implement in e-commerce. It is a shame, because I really would like to purchase more from non-Amazon sources.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Blackthorn on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @12:32PM (#22804703)
Zoro. Which is a division of Grainger, iirc.

Their website isn't the best for finding things, but I've never had any issues with an order from them, ever. And I've bought a lot of stuff.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by beamatronic on Monday April 06, 2020 @02:58PM (#22796681)
Target is okay although I often get cosmetically damaged packaging.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by arkades on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:09PM (#22798812)
Try mcmaster-carr. They beat the stuffing out of home depot, lowe's and amazon all when it comes to hardware.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by jakearmitage on Monday April 06, 2020 @09:24PM (#22799553)
Holy crap, this is awesome. I could find the EXACT pipe fitting I needed. How did I not know about this?
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by gbrown on Monday April 06, 2020 @11:06PM (#22800016)
I’ve had good luck ordering lumber and landscaping supplies from Home Depot. No problems in half a dozen orders.
Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by Fjolsvith on Monday April 06, 2020 @11:25PM (#22800090)
Another good one if you're in the midwest is Menards. They regularly have an 11% rebate which, for me, adds up quite a bit.

Pro tip for if you can physically go to one of their stores: If you make a purchase and they run their 11% rebate the next week, ask at the front desk for the pre-rebate adjustment, which lets you get it for your previous purchase.

Re:Amazon Isn’t the Only Shop Online by battery_cowboy on Monday April 06, 2020 @08:09PM (#22799178)
Target is pretty great, I replaced Amazon with Target for most things.