News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:04PM (#22613215)
I do believe these masks are also made in the US, but this situation highlights exactly why a country having its own major manufacturing base is not just an economic need but rather also a national security need. The US needs to invest in itself immediately to rebuild its lost manufacturing base.

In economic terms, under certain definitions and assumptions that are typical under modern economics, a trade war such as the current US-China trade war result in welfare losses. I believe, however, that when national security is taken into account (ie having the ability for the country to rapidly respond to productive capacity needs in a time of crisis), the trade war along with serious investment in expanding industrial capacity is likely net good.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ardy42 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:16AM (#22616257)
> I do believe these masks are also made in the US, but this situation highlights exactly why a country having its own major manufacturing base is not just an economic need but rather also a national security need. The US needs to invest in itself immediately to rebuild its lost manufacturing base.

3M and Prestige Ameritech are the only companies with the ability to manufacturing N95 masks in the US from US sourced materials.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/shortages-confusion-an...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/02/15/coronavir...

Totally agree with you on manufacturing. It's super important to have this kind of domestic manufacturing capability, because trade links break down in a crisis like this. The US is short on supply and can't import more (other countries are banning exports to conserve supply for domestic needs). If all the manufacturing capability had been outsourced, US healthcare workers would be in even worse shape.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mehrdadn on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:31AM (#22617017)
> 3M and Prestige Ameritech are the only companies with the ability to manufacturing N95 masks in the US from US sourced materials.

I'm confused about your italics. Why does it matter where the source materials you give them comes from? i.e. Why would other manufacturers in the US be only able to manufacture masks from non-US-sourced-materials, but fail on US-sourced materials? Is there something defective with US-sourced materials that if you gave them to US-based manufacturers, their machines would break or something?

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by afiori on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:04AM (#22617403)
It could be a matter of having the whole process happen in the US. In the sense that those 2 companies are the only one that have sufficient domestic supply chain for production, while all other companies need to rely on import.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mehrdadn on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:14AM (#22617515)
But if that's the case then you could get source materials from one of these companies and give them to another manufacturer who normally ships from overseas, right? Like I'm saying in that case the issue seems to be lack of sufficient source materials in the US, not US manufacturing capability?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ardy42 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:28AM (#22617673)
But in any case, the supply chains of companies that use overseas materials have been disrupted. With effort, they could probably switch to using materials from a domestic manufacturer, but those manufacturers may not have the capacity to satisfy the increased demand. Per the OP, it seems like the limiting factor in production is melt-blown fabric.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:38AM (#22615476)
> a country having its own major manufacturing base

American manufacturing output has grown since 1990 [1]. What it’s been losing is manufacturing employment.

Having more people making a similar number of things does nothing for national security.

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by blaser-waffle on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:03AM (#22617390)
The US is the 3rd largest manufacturer in the world, behind China and Germany. Wayyyyy behind China but, like, everyone is, at least when it comes to manufacturing.

We're also the number one exporter of food, and hold a few other top production laurels. Not the top producer, not the top consumer -- that's China -- but the top over-all exporter.[1]

As the above comment mentioned: most of that work is highly industrialized and automated. Less than 1% of the US is farmers but they produce enough to make US food exports #1. Much of the same is true for US manufacturing.

[1] https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/the-american-food-giant-...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by stjohnswarts on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:45PM (#22618599)
I think people are talking about masks, medical supplies, medicine manufacturing are all critical to the national security and should be brought back. This should be taken as a learning experience as well as a national disaster. Lest we forget in a year. Those industries can be subsidized as they are critical and we can't trust other countries for those supplies in pandemics and other world disasters.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by echelon on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:27PM (#22613331)
All the workers being replaced by automation and having to rely on "gig economy" work could pursue manufacturing instead. We have the workforce.

We can pay workers livable wages and give them meaningful work. Cost of goods could be reduced through greater efficiency. Research into robotics and automation could fuel a new decade of American growth.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jdietrich on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:05AM (#22614055)
>We have the workforce.

That's the problem - you don't. By definition, the kind of efficient, highly-automated manufacturing you're thinking of doesn't need many unskilled or semi-skilled workers, but it does need skilled and experienced engineers and machinists. It needs a massive and complex ecosystem of suppliers and support.

The depletion of America's industrial base has created a massive skills gap that would take decades to remedy. You can't create a new Silicon Valley with a bunch of bootcamp graduates and some wishful thinking; likewise, you can't create a manufacturing economy through sheer force of will.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by hguant on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:43AM (#22614229)
This reminds me of a conversation I had at a New Year's party not too long ago - a gentleman I'd never met before and I got to talking, and in the process of getting to know one another (however much you can know someone after 4-5 drinks at a black tie party you go to once a year), he bemoaned the issues he was having trying to open a US branch of his company. Apparently medium scale sheet metal forming operations in the States have all but disappeared - everything is either outsourced to China, or is small scale, high precision work that can't meet demand of more than N hundred pieces a week. It's a boring issue - "oh no, there's no one to subcontract this work to, you have to buy from China for X percent of what it would cost to do here" - but speak volumes as to the loss of a critical component of that manufacturing ecosystem.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by owenversteeg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:39AM (#22615905)
>Apparently medium scale sheet metal forming operations in the States have all but disappeared - everything is either outsourced to China, or is small scale, high precision work that can't meet demand of more than N hundred pieces a week.

I can personally confirm this. Very unfortunate, and I'm positive it's helping stifle innovation. Having to go to China for your custom sheet metal needs (with the communication difficulties and shipping times involved) can be -really- debilitating.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by rwmurrayVT on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:37AM (#22616480)
You can get custom sheet metal work, if you're willing the pay the price and possibly are in the right industry. Sheet metal, welding, carpentry, pipefitters, and pretty much every trade are in massive demand in shipbuilding/repair.

NNSY fails a significant portion of welder applicants just because they can't lay a proper weld. They pay... a lot of money.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by owenversteeg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:30AM (#22617010)
"the price" being something borderline extortionate, in many cases. And there aren't a lot of options. In China there's someone everywhere that can do what you want; in America, you'll have to search.

You can get lucky and find someone with some brakes and benders that does cheap work for farmers, but people like that are usually extremely hard to find and mostly in rural areas.

And yes, welders do make more than someone at McDonalds or doing landscaping, but the myth of the super-high paid welder is mostly that. I just looked up NNSY welder salaries - average of 49K, and that's with a lot people there being experienced and there for a long time.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by rwmurrayVT on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:44AM (#22617176)
Completing the welding apprenticeship at NNSY results in an hourly wage of $29.73. The overtime pay schedule at NNSY. The issue online is complicated because NNSY also has "shipfitters/welders". They are paid substantially less than production welders. Production welders at a repair yard like BAE/Colanna/Lyon make in the range of $27-$30. They also make significant overtime.

I agree that the myth of the super-high paid welder is mostly fabricated, but when it comes to shipbuilding at a nuclear yard it's a lot higher than you would expect.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ethbro on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:10AM (#22616819)
You definitely see it in defense-related locales.

Driving around Newport News, Groton, or even Birmingham is like being on another planet economically speaking.

But I definitely see the point, as most of the suppliers are sized for defense, not commercial industrial volume.

And from their perspective, I get the choice. Why risk expansion, when the trend has been towards free trade and offshoring? A 100x customer who decides to switch suppliers in a year isn't a win. At least DoD is a semi-reliable customer.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by rwmurrayVT on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:46AM (#22617194)
Driving around Newport News is like driving around a desolate shithole. There are very few nice neighborhoods in the area. Newport News and Hampton are the worst cities in the Hampton Roads area.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ethbro on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:00PM (#22621197)
That's what a shrinking population and economy does to an area.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by robotnikman on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:32PM (#22620354)
I've always wondered if the sheet metal used to build Naval ships was made locally in the states.

Makes sense, getting it made in China seems like a bad idea

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by brigandish on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:58AM (#22615280)
I got chatting to the bloke next to me on a long haul flight from the UK to Japan. He was going there to buy a printing machine (he was a printer) and when I asked why go all the way to Japan he told me that, basically, only Germany and Japan make printing machines any more. He even pointed out that the pulp he bought was from abroad.

I wonder if freight companies receive subsidies though - lots of airlines certainly get subsidies - that might change things in favour of more local producers. Maybe.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by pastage on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:08AM (#22615677)
Transport is one of the least taxed emission sources there are, in o e way thats subsidies.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:09AM (#22614826)
It's because people have been pushed to both sides of that; manufacturing used to be a comfortable middle class job, but it's shifted to the sides, being a high value, specialist job on the one hand, and a low education required job of handling incoming finished or half-finished products coming over from abroad.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by gauravjain13 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:18AM (#22614368)
This, exactly. America has manufacturing talent, but not at the scale required for a manufacturing economy. (Source: ~2 decades in global manufacturing.)
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by kilroy123 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:28AM (#22615159)
So what can we do as a nation to change that? Should we even try at this point?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by thu2111 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:12AM (#22616227)
Tariffs. The US has already started!
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jpindar on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:50PM (#22621599)
They've put tariffs on raw materials and sub-assemblies, which is making it less economical to manufacture things in the US.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by thu2111 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:50AM (#22626924)
Interesting. I wonder what the logic is; usually tariffs are chosen based on trade volumes with the targeted country. Maybe there's a sense that mining or other raw materials businesses need more help than firms higher up the value chain.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by leereeves on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:09AM (#22615093)
> The depletion of America's industrial base has created a massive skills gap that would take decades to remedy

All the more reason to get started immediately.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by JabavuAdams on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:33AM (#22615854)
While this might be true, in the same decades you could have a handful of skilled machinists teach the robots / AIs. The thing about AI anything is that each individual unit gets better with fleet upgrades.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Paperweight on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:50AM (#22614259)
Highly-automated, "clean" manufacturing is all well and good for billion-dollar highly-capitalized, politically-sheltered megafactories, but what about the other 90% of manufacturers?

Manufacturing is a dirty, dangerous, manual business. I think the small guys will tell you that environmental regulations killed manufacturing in the west, not labour costs. We've been living in lala land with it all offshore, out of sight. If US/EU-level environmental regulations got applied and enforced globally, we'd be sent back to the stone age. Not to mention the litigation risks, intellectual property risks, trade union cartels, needing to hire an electrician to change a lightbulb, etc. (All added up, it's hopelessly calcified, but whatever...)

Don't get me wrong - I really care about the environment - but most regs here are just to look good, not actually about stuff that matters. And pushing it into the third world, where they don't protect the environment at all, is counterproductive.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jdietrich on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:17AM (#22614628)
>Manufacturing is a dirty, dangerous, manual business.

It can be, but it can also be clean, safe and highly automated. Fly-by-night operators that run dirty and dangerous shops are not the basis of a sustainable manufacturing economy. China is just damned good at manufacturing. They have everything that is needed - skills, capital, logistics - at an immense scale. They don't offer a cheap but inferior substitute for western manufacturing. They offer speed, flexibility and scalability that western countries could only dream of.

Xi Jinping has a degree in chemical engineering. His predecessor Hu Jintao has a degree in hydraulic engineering. His predecessor Jiang Zemin has a degree in electrical engineering. That is the fundamental reason why China is a manufacturing superpower - for thirty years, the government has been run by people who actually know how to make stuff.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Dahoon on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:39AM (#22616491)
Unlike most other nations. I wish more people knew this and the impact it has. maybe we wouldn't see Trump win again then (as we will).
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jacobush on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:17AM (#22615366)
And now the US is run by people who know how to bully and hustle.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by piva00 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:11AM (#22614591)
Tell that to Germany, stricter environmental regulations and a very healthy, highly developed manufacturing sector. They might not have all of their supply chain made locally but Germany makes the machines that makes machines so if needed they could ramp up their internal manufacturing quite quickly, doesn't seem to be the case for the US.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wolfgke on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:24AM (#22615405)
Many Germans say that the fact that manufacturing it still rather strong in Germany is only a carryover from the decaying momentum of a much more glorious past (Wirtschaftswunder (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wirtschaftswunder...).
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Seanambers on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:57AM (#22615038)
Well Germany has been so fortunate as to be a member of a currency union, where they are the leading industrial base, thus giving them a artificial low currency as an advantage as well. This helps manufacturing quit a bit.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by bluGill on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:52AM (#22615257)
The US is a currency union and has been for longer. Most people forget that state originally meant the same thing as country
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jacobush on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:19AM (#22615377)
I agree on your first point, but not the etymology. Germany has a long federal history. The word "state" has been a little ambiguous for a long time.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by dotancohen on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:49AM (#22616588)
State was defined by political borders, country by geographical borders. For much of human history states were countries. The blurring of the meaning of these words I believe started around the 18th century as transportation, and thus the ability to rule further away, progressed.

I agree that in today's colloquial usage there is little distinction between the two.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by imtringued on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:24AM (#22615146)
That's completely insignificant compared to having the dollar as the global currency in the oil trade. Countries that sell oil for dollar can only spend those dollars on American products. It's as if the USA produced all the oil in the world and sold it for profit. Meanwhile Germany's unfair advantage is that it's prices on products are slightly lower than they should be.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by AdrianB1 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:58AM (#22615279)
It is actually the other way around: this keeps the US dollar artificially high, hitting on exports, and it is completely not true that these countries can only spend dollars on American products: they can spend on anything they want, the dollar is just a currency, you can use it to buy products from Russia, China or Nigeria.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mensetmanusman on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:18AM (#22616899)
Economists recognize Germany’s unique position that is overheating their manufacturing center. If the DM still existed, it would be ~50% more valuable than the Euro.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by bootlooped on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:32PM (#22613361)
How can you in once sentence say we can employ workers previously displaced by automation, and in the next sentence assert that we can produce these goods at a competitive price with automation?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by echelon on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:12AM (#22613553)
I should proofread and given examples. Lack of caffeine from WFH isn't helping me.

There are many types of automation. Grocery workers (cashiers, stockers) are replaced with robotics and self-checkout (which automates pricing and theft detection) that removes them from the equation. Automobile machinists and doctors are supplemented with robotics that let them do higher-precision work and avoid mundane and/or stressful tasks.

The gig economy is driven by automation (customer discovery, billing, payroll, etc.), but the industry is set up in a way that happens to produce negative externalities and push risks and costs onto workers.

We need the type of automation that reduces mindless repetition and extends human capability. Not the kind geared at removing people.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by arcticbull on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:42AM (#22613704)
I don't understand why we insist on keeping people in jobs that can be automated. Let them go pursue something that's fulfilling. Not automating something that can be just to keep people doing jobs we don't need done is a fascinating make-work project.

The displaced should be re-trained, provided meaningful opportunities, or yeah, paid basic income out of the money saved by them not going to work.

Why pay them to do a less efficient job, that they're not fulfilled by, to produce uncompetitive goods at an uncompetitive price?

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jyrkesh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:15AM (#22613841)
I agree with you generally, but the issue is really that we (in the US) replaced manufacturing with some combination of the perception and externalization of automation. We shipped it all overseas and said "we really don't care how you get it done, but if you can consistently do it at this price, you may as well be an 'automated' black box to us".

If it was fully automated today, we should be able to do it here. Build the same machines. Hell, buy the machines from over there, and set them up here. Then figure out how to pay everyone for the service/idea/artsy work. Whatever they wanna do, at least we can afford the masks when we need them, right? (And the healthcare, and the iPhones, and the whatever else is either absolutely necessary or has supposedly been automated.)

But it's not, so the conversation is really about how we can afford to pay people a living wage in a country with a higher cost of living when they're working as underpriced supplemental labor for not-quite-there automation.

And the reality is that we can't: we externalized that lower wage and we slapped an "automation" sticker on it so that everyone would jump on board. Then we realized that we don't own the automation AND we're eliminating the jobs that automation is replacing instead of retooling the existing jobs to ride the technology curve of said automation as its benefits start to grow.

Again, this is all a very America-centric view, but I think it applies to pockets of Europe as well. And if I was living in certain Asian countries, I think I'd be stoked as hell about the increase in wages that could continue to meet the cost of a rapidly increasing standard of living.

I should also say I'm very much in favor of free trade, and I think that mercantilism/protectionism is net negative for the global welfare of humanity. But I think there was an opportunity that a lot of short-sighted American manufacturing powerhouses missed when they agreed to sign up for the Chinese manufacturing equivalent of SaaS.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Gravityloss on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:58AM (#22616687)
It's remarkable what you can do with automation. There's a small factory that produces a large proportion of the world's manual industrial power switches here in Helsinki.

It's basically a few machines that crank them out like no tomorrow, and then the associated personnel to keep the machines running and doing some hard to automate jobs. (Some hundreds of people perhaps.) And sales guys.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by axaxs on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:18AM (#22613849)
Because to me, the consumer, I can't think of a single time automation replacing humans has been better. Self checkouts suck for anything more than a handful of items, especially compared to a well trained cashier/bagger combo. Automated call/IVR systems are hypertension inducing bad. ATMs are no replacement for tellers for most situations that bring one to the bank.

I'm not a complete luddite. In many systems, specifically manufacturing, robots outcompete humans and it makes sense.

The problem arises when anything requiring the least bit of thinking is attempted to be automated. Those are nothing more than cost saving measures, and bring down the quality of service to everyone involved.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by bostik on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:51AM (#22614508)
I agree that at current state almost all physical self-service systems suck. Royally. The only exceptions I can think of are petrol pumps, ATMs (please read on), and to a certain extent, ticket kiosks.

I would claim that ATMs are in fact a prime example of successful automation. For anything non-mundane you still need to go talk to a human, but that's the point: ATMs have removed the need to involve a human bottleneck for a bulk quantity of an extremely mundane task: withdrawing cash. I am old enough to remember when you had to go to the bank for that too.

This hits the nail on the head, though:

> The problem arises when anything requiring the least bit of thinking is attempted to be automated.

Humans are capable of judgment calls.[ß] Computers do exactly what you tell them to do, which is not necessarily what you want them to do.

ß: environments where humans are forbidden from making judgment calls are called bureaucracies.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by drdeadringer on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:01AM (#22614037)
I guess self-checkout is a matter of taste and/or opinion. Personally, I prefer it at the grocery store when I have the choice.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wtallis on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:54AM (#22614276)
It's not a matter of taste. It's a question of whether your preferred grocery store employs any experienced cashiers and baggers, and the degree to which their self-checkout machines are artificially dumbed-down and slowed-down.

In most cases, the customer-facing self checkout systems are objectively much slower and more cumbersome than the manned checkout systems that require some training and practice to use correctly. Paid cashiers never have to slow down their scanning because of a spurious reading from a scale in the bagging area. They get real keyboards to interact with the computer, and user interfaces that are far more responsive than the typical touchscreen UI's update latency.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by drdeadringer on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:34AM (#22617063)
Whiles some of that may be true, I can still get through via self-checkout faster than a manned station most of the time.

Then again, I'm not buying 57 individual items in a line 6 people deep who are all buying similar amounts of items. Perhaps you are. A matter of taste.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by katbyte on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:28AM (#22614403)
That’s you bud, I prefer the self check out every time, most visits to the bank are for the atm and if ai driven Uber cars were a thing I’d prefer them to. (I can agree about ivrs thou, those can die a fiery death)

We all have difference preferences so don’t attribute yours to others.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by eitland on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:40AM (#22614448)
> Because to me, the consumer, I can't think of a single time automation replacing humans has been better.

Let me mention one then: ATMs.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by satanspastaroll on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:01AM (#22616128)
Automation really is all progress made by humans. Chainsaws replace hand-saws, and is 'automated' sawing.

The less work is required to produce goods, the better it can compete (in price). This makes it so that you _don't have to_ work as much to achieve the same quality of life

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by dfc on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:19AM (#22616292)
I am really surprised you can't think of one time automation beats manual work. I could sit here all day:

Municipal water service versus hand pumped well

E-ZPass versus tollbooth attendant.

Festool Domino biscuit jointer versus me doing it by hand

Sheetrock versus plaster and lathe

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by axaxs on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:46AM (#22617909)
Fair points. I'd consider 1,3,and 4 more behind the scenes, lumped in with manufacturing. But you definitely got me on EZPass.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by zaphod12 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:08PM (#22619540)
Have you used home depot's self check out machines?

They are fantastic. Leaps ahead of every supermarket and CVS I've been in. When I was doing a lot of housework and was very used to them, I could get through a check out with a couple of items in under a minute. Really proved to me that these do not need to be awful

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by megablast on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:57AM (#22614774)
ATMs are huge, available 24 hours a day for most services you need. Postage lockers are great for the same reason.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by restalis on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:27AM (#22616378)
Areas involving human interaction may indeed risk a decline in the provided (or at least perceived) quality when automated, compared to its non-automated best case scenario. However, aside from possible technical issues (that may also affect human-involved setups), machines avoid a broad range of problems (some mentioned in sibling posts) that otherwise affect clients' interacting experience, and thus (more often than not) are the better choice.

P.S.: I don't miss nowadays the increase of human-induced Coronavirus infection risk when I experience human-free services.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by arcticbull on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:34PM (#22620374)
I mean, that just sounds like a matter of time does it not? Or a business opportunity. I can't imagine that there's some fundamental limitation to these devices that precludes a good experience.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by totony on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:03AM (#22614049)
amazon go is the self-checking next step and seems to be superior to cashiers altogether
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by tlrobinson on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:51AM (#22613747)
I’m not saying we should protect these jobs by law or anything, but I question whether work that can be automated can't be fulfilling.

I keep seeing these “Cafe X” robotic coffee bars in San Francisco. Surely some baristas find their job fulfilling, and some customers enjoy chatting with their human barista instead of a robot?

Personally I think I’d have a hard time feeling good about working on something that directly replaces human labor without much benefit other than profit.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by gmueckl on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:38AM (#22615902)
You picked an example where the Job includes social interaction, which is a fundamental human need. Let's consider an assembly line worker who fastens the same set of screws over and over again. Do you still come to the same conclusion? Is a dull, repetitive job psychologically harmful over long times?

There are jobs that greatly endanger people's physical health. Mining and construction come to my mind. If automation can make these jobs safer, go for it. For everything else, we will probably end up with a balance between heavy automation and niches where artisans hand craft similar products because they love doing so. It should ideally be a free choice instead if people getting preasured into low skill/low wage/high risk jobs because they need to eat.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by krillkkl on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:54AM (#22615017)
> I’m not saying we should protect these jobs by law or anything, but I question whether work that can be automated can't be fulfilling.

Thanks for writing this, I don't think it gets said often enough (or at all).

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by satanspastaroll on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:58AM (#22616097)
> self-checkout

A self-checkout is not automation, it's simply transferring the same amount of work from the paid employee to the customer

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by downerending on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:17PM (#22630111)
I'm not sure that we do have the workforce. The generation of workers I remember from childhood had a large array of skills crucial in manufacturing that are now withering or have disappeared entirely.

The people that are maintaining those skills and learning the new skills needed are increasingly elsewhere.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by BubRoss on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:32PM (#22613363)
Who is being replaced by automation and becoming forced to rely on the gig economy?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Camillo on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:45PM (#22613423)
"They were replaced by automation" is a vile anti-worker canard. The manufacturing jobs went to humans in China, not robots.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by pdelbarba on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:52PM (#22613459)
Haven't heard that definition of canard in a while...

As with most things, I'm fairly sure the truth lies somewhere in the middle and it varies industry to industry. Yea, a lot of stuff went to china, but a lot of workers were also replaced by automated systems. In a lot of cases, I'd even venture to say maybe a majority, it was both. It's not even close to factually true to say it's JUST china or JUST robots.

Also, do you mind elaborating on how that's specifically anti-worker? Either case can be construed as such depending on your position.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jacobush on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:41AM (#22614452)
Don’t forget robots in China
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by scalableUnicon on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:44AM (#22614236)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_h1ooyyFkF0 This episode on John Oliver's Last Week Tonight might help.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by nabla9 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:17AM (#22615364)
It's not true that US or any other developed country have lost their manufacturing base. The rest of the economy has grown faster than manufacturing.

Developed countries have moved into high-tech, high productivity, more capital intensive manufacturing with complex supply chains. If you want to bring back low productivity products into your country, you must accept wage decline, slower growth and lowering quality of life.

You can prepare for emergencies using other means and using relatively small adjustments. Post-industrial societies have higher productivity than industrial societies. Turning the clock back is not a good idea.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by coldtea on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:00AM (#22615612)
>Turning the clock back is not a good idea.

Might be a more liveable, more resilient, better for the environment, and for quality of life (which is not the same as "more gadgets") idea though...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:14AM (#22615727)
It's hard to see how lower paid jobs are more liveable or provide better quality of life, or how smaller scale and therefore less efficient manufacturing would be better for the environment. I just don't see how these outcomes are supposed to arise.

More resilient, ok maybe, but surely there are other ways that resilience could be achieved through e.g. rolling stockpiling or maintaining flexible manufacturing capability. We don't necessarily need to be able to make our own masks all the time, but have the capacity to make them if needed. there are a range of new technologies coming along that could provide this flexibility, such as 3d printing and flexible robotic assembly systems. That would come at a cost for sure, but could provide the needed flexibility at a much lower social cost than pushing people back into lower value long term employment.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by coldtea on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:47AM (#22615982)
>It's hard to see how lower paid jobs are more liveable or provide better quality of life

We had higher paid jobs (or more yield per job, a single working person could support a family, buy a house, send kids to college) in the 50s and 60s for example, so I'm not sure why "turning back time" means lower paid jobs (or less purchase capacity).

Give me necessities (house/rent, food, taking care of kids, college, etc) and more freedom/livable work, and I can live without 90% of modern "must haves", from smartphones to same-day-delivery from poorly-paid adults in wharehouses working 10-hour shifts in diapers to send me Amazon Prime goods made in China...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ethbro on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:56AM (#22616668)
> We had higher paid jobs (or more yield per job, a single working person could support a family, buy a house, send kids to college) in the 50s and 60s for example

So, your proposal is to bomb Europe and Asia's industrial base to increase America's relative competitiveness?

If we're talking apples to apples about the world economy of the 50s and 60s...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:26PM (#22621406)
Ok, that’s fine. It’s your life. If you want to go and work in a factory, good for you.

I had a conversation like this with a friend of mine a few years ago. He was complaining about the lack of manufacturing jobs here in the UK and that we needed real jobs for real people. So I pointed at his 5 year old son playing nearby and said ok. What sort of factory would he like his son to work in when he grows up? What sort of education did he plan for him that would best suit him for factory life? Silence.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by greedo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:36PM (#22619815)
The US economic boom in the 50s largely stemmed from the fact that the entire outside world had been devastated from WW2. US industry had a huge lead since the continental US was largely free on war damage.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by dls2016 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:11AM (#22617491)
preach
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by piokoch on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:48AM (#22616583)
"quality of life" what's that, that's a question. Does buying new car every 3 years is a condition for a good life quality? New iPhone every 2 years? Pair of shoes/trousers or fashionable t-shirt every month? Maybe people will just discover that driving older car does not really deteriorate their life quality and new iPhone does not really matter, it just allows Apple to put more cash on the huge pile they already have. Maybe Tim Cook will not afford new jet or yacht next year, but, frankly, who cares?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:21PM (#22621372)
Dude, if you don’t want a new phone don’t buy one. It’s ok. Nobody will get upset.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by coldtea on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:26PM (#22669458)
It's about the quality of life on a society that prioritizes gadgets and BS consumption, not about what one can do as individual.

Even if one doesn't "buy a new phone" it's still affected by a society hell bent on such trivia.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:02AM (#22615637)
300 to 800 factories yearly closed their doors in France since the introduction of the Euro. Italy faces a lesser but still steep industrial decline. In the meanwhile, industrial output boomed in the German hinterland of Eastern Europe.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by toyg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:06AM (#22616175)
Apart from the arguable “yearly”, that’s just efficiency in practice. When you look at the US, you see the same thing: there isn’t a large movie industry in each state, but there is one Hollywood (and one Broadway for theatre). Attracting all talent and capital from the entire continent allows for a level of economies of scale and quality refinement that makes it absolutely dominant worldwide. The same process happened for Silicon Valley / Bay Area, or even Detroit back in the day - it’s not like they were only making cars for Illinois and immediate surroundings...

I’m Italian and I can see our country becoming such a centre of attraction in certain fields (fashion and advertising in Milan, for example; food in Emilia; motor-racing in Romagna; tourism in Tuscany...). I’m not terribly worried that our widget-making capabilities have lowered - we are still paying the economic and social price of 60s-style industry in some areas (Taranto, Pozzuoli etc).

In the end it always boils down to this annoying tribalism - in a global world, thinking that French and Germans and Italians and Spanish must be separate and autonomous little tribes, is as silly as thinking that Nice or Lyon should be completely separate and autonomous from Paris and Calais.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:13AM (#22617501)
That's efficiency from a certain perspective. That's this wonderful efficiency that makes the world extremely sensitive to the current Covid-19 situation. That's the very opposite of antifragility. We need resilience, too.

This has absolutely nothing to do with isolationism or tribalism. Gee, I hate this sort of strawman argument.

Our globalised, ultra-lean, efficient world was built on a humongous influx of fossil fuels and other limited resources that destroyed our climate while being so "efficient". Fossil fuels (and phosphates) that will become scarce at some point or another.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by toyg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:31AM (#22617706)
Efficiency and resiliency are different things. If you want resiliency, you plan accordingly - left to its own devices, the capitalist market will always go for ultimate efficiency, that's a primary property of the system. This is not the Soviet Union deciding to do potatoes in one country and cars in another, people take smaller decisions that aggregate up to certain phenomenons. If you don't like those phenomenons, you have to intervene pretty radically.

> This has absolutely nothing to do with isolationism or tribalism.

This has absolutely all to do with tribalism. If industries had closed in France and opened in Belgium, making them operatively indistinguishable from French industries for all intents and purposes (as distance is negligible and half of them basically speak the same language), people would still go on about lacking French industry. Why? Because Belgium is conceptually "not France". Nobody complains (anymore) about a single factory serving an entire country, why should we worry about a single factory serving half a continent? Do you seriously think you should have a widget-making factory in every city or town, for each different type of widget...? "OMG the world might end, we need to be able to make Gucci shoes in every town!"

> fossil fuels and other limited resources that destroyed our climate

I do not disagree, but that's something that effectively started 300 years ago and is not going to end anytime soon, unless you enjoy riding horses and going to bed with the sun. We will find alternatives (in some areas we already have, effectively; they are just not equally distributed yet).

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:41PM (#22618547)
Sorry but no, the problem isn't of industry closing down in France and opening back in Belgium, you're misrepresenting things. There has been a long history of the idea that we Europeans don't really need to "make things", that we could relocate our industry wherever it's more "efficient" (i. e. cheaper, because mostly of lower environmental and social safeguards, and because nobody directly pays for the externalities -- that's good old imperialism, colonialism in new clothes IMO) and keep the know-how, engineering, and power for us while Chinese or others would do the dirty work for us. And this stupid idea began to crumble a few years back already, and is now suddenly proven dead to everyone (hopefully).

There is such a thing as sovereignty, and it doesn't matter at which scale it happens; sovereignty implies having control on whatever things you can't do without. Can Europe or the US be sovereign without steel mills? maybe. Car manufacturing? possibly. Chemistry and pharmaceutical production? not so sure. Oil? see our leaders grovelling at MBS' knees while he's butchering Yemen. Ah.

In the US, some top brass came recently to the realisation that the US can't make a war plane without Chinese input anymore. That may be a problem sooner or later.

Similarly, the impact of the transfer of industries and money across Europe isn't a problem per se, it's only a problem because nothing provides any equilibrium -- no transfers at any significant scales. So far Germany sends cars and machines across Europe, and gets paper in exchange. At times, some important German minister or another goes harping that someday, that TARGET2 balance will have to be cleared. Does this even make sense? Can we have a European money, but not a European industry? I don't think so. Something will have to give at some point or another.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by toyg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:58PM (#22621180)
You're mixing together a bunch of different issues. On some of them we don't even disagree. But they are different issues. And the issue of "sovereignty" is precisely the tribalistic attitude I was talking about.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Totoradio on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:14AM (#22615724)
>300 to 800 factories yearly closed their doors in France since the introduction of the Euro.

Have you got a source on that? The data I can find [1] says 600 total have closed between 2009 and 2018.

[1] https://bfmbusiness.bfmtv.com/entreprise/depuis-janvier-il-y...

from this source: https://fr.slideshare.net/dcousquer/2018-un-ralentissement-e... , slide 5.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:17AM (#22617545)
Here, 900 factories closed from 2009 to 2011: https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2011/12/28/pres-de-9...

This has been more or less the trend from 2001 to 2016. There was a slight upturn for 2017-2018, then it went down again in 2019.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by piokoch on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:59AM (#22616701)
That's pretty obvious. Germany has superior industry, yet thanks to Euro they are able to keep prices reasonably low. If Mark was still used, it would have cost 2 USD and others could compete at least in prices. This hurt even more Italy. Next, Germany managed to build a cheap suppliers chain out of former East Block countries (especially Poland).
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by stjohnswarts on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:48PM (#22618631)
People like to say post industrial and post information societies but neither of those are true. We rely on both quite heavily and should learn from things like this pandemic that we can't trust to outsource all our manufacturing to other countries especially military rivals like China who will naturally cut us off when we have a war over Taiwan when China really starts flexing.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by snowwrestler on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:41PM (#22613408)
No country has the manufacturing base to meet the demand for these masks under a pandemic, not even China. That’s what the article is all about. Your thoughts on the merits of trade wars are not applicable.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:17AM (#22613579)
Who defines what's applicable on HN? This article discusses Chinese supply chains and a manufacturing shortage for a specific need the result of which is decreased national security.

If there is another country (USA) which has relatively significantly diminished supply chains and manufacturing capacity and therefore has an even greater national security risk, why is that not applicable to be discussed? If, further, there is an opportunity and process by which that country (USA) could close that gap, why is it not applicable to be discussed?

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by PeterisP on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:48AM (#22615239)
Some countries have a sufficient manufacturing base that allows them to spin up mass manufacturing of (for example) masks over a month or two.

You don't need to keep spare capacity for everything, but you need to have local capacity (not necessarily spare) for building custom manufacturing machines and staffing them, so that you can divert it to manufacture arbitrary physical goods if needed. Some countries can do that, most don't - but some of these could and should build that capacity.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by makomk on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:55AM (#22615028)
The US is having trouble making enough masks to meet its normal day-to-day demand for them, let alone the increase from a pandemic, because almost all the mask production has been outsourced to China and they're redirecting the entire output to local use. That's an issue and it's a reason why the US might want extremely substantial tariffs or even quotas on mask imports in normal circumstances.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by vonmoltke on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:27AM (#22616376)
No, it wasn't. 3M has been making their N95 respirators in the US the whole time. It was cheaper masks (e.g., dust masks, procedure masks) that had their production outsourced.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by yourapostasy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @06:54AM (#22615264)
> ...not even China...

For N95 masks as the article points out, yes, no one has the melt-blown fabric manufacturing machines that are a precursor.

However, if everyone around you wears surgical masks, then everyone is blocking ingesting about about 80% of particulate matter [1]. For an emergency like the pandemic, we're also interested in the masks blocking what wearers breathe out to surgical standards, what the masks were designed for. That's a "not letting perfect be the enemy of good" level of "good enough" if your alternative is letting front line healthcare staff go without melt-blown fabric filtering PPE because everyone is scrambling for P95 or P100 masks.

The US military establishment after the pandemic is controlled will hopefully be given a hand in determining precursor tech tree bottlenecks like the OP article pointed out, and have Congressional authorization to perform economic disaster preparedness within its scope. Stockpile and maintain sufficient operational skills alongside key equipment, so our disaster preparedness is better than "duck and cover" (some interesting questions behind that door).

Some modeling suggests we need a minimum 3 month lockdown in the US to cut deaths in half [2], 18 months (or however long it takes for critical mass of population to develop immunity or vaccinated immunity) to approach a semblance of status ante quo death rate. I wish they would put their modeling source and data onto Github (or Wolfram Alpha?), so others can work with the model (I'm interested in its backtest results from previous epidemics). If we lockdown for even 3 months, then that's GFC effects; 18 months is Great(er) Depression.

[1] https://fastlifehacks.com/n95-vs-ffp/

[2] https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/s...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by bamboozled on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:32PM (#22613360)
A “superpower” who can’t seem make enough masks to protect its own medical professionals from a pandemic. It’s an interesting situation.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ardit33 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:38PM (#22613387)
Rome was a "superpower" militarily but it couldn't feed itself, and had to rely on grain from Egypt and the fertile crescent to feed its population.....

Here we can't produce some basic silly things... as it is not that economical during normal times... Perhaps farming subsides are not a crazy type of idea after all.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jplayer01 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:45AM (#22614729)
Am I taking crazy pills? The US and Europe subsidize their agricultural industries heavily and have done so for decades. They're fully or largely capable of feeding themselves - and yes, precisely because these places decided that food is a significant factor for the stability of a country and a national security issue. Hell, people bitch and moan about how agriculture gets so many subisidies (corn in the US? anything in the EU), but frankly, to outsource food production to the rest of the world would seriously threaten the cohesiveness of our countries.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by non-entity on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:19AM (#22615379)
I dont think the comment you're replying to was saying the US isnincaphle of feeding itself, but trying to make a comparison to past empires which had outsourced parts of their economies to foreign powers
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by bamboozled on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:35AM (#22613663)
Well two things come to mind here:

- People can learn from Rome's mistakes.

- Rome did at least some farming.

- Rome is no more.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by gdubs on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:52AM (#22613753)
I’m reminded of an old saying that there two hard things in Computer Science:

- cache invalidation

- naming things

- and off-by-one errors

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by bamboozled on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:30AM (#22613909)
In the spirit of good humor, I will not edit my comment :)
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by geekthattweaks on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:14AM (#22613827)
My favorite computer science joke by far!
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by agustif on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:49AM (#22614997)
Maybe it was an array of answers, lol
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:51AM (#22613995)
Farming subsidies for food. Not a bad idea. Subsidizing overproduction of ethanol is another issue.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by cultus on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:32AM (#22616428)
Farming subsidies for food systematically cause overproduction. This is problematic environmentally for land use and climate. It also accelerates soil depletion and salinification.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by agustif on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:50AM (#22615003)
On france you have their biggest billionaire owner of some big brand names reconverting all it's factories to produce that stuff
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by AdrianB1 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:05AM (#22615303)
At the time Rome was a military superpower and it did not have the capacity to feed itself, the agriculture was at a completely different level. Farming subsidies have no logical link to Rome 2000 years ago.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by danans on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:15AM (#22613836)
"Superpower" in the American context is largely about our ability to project our military and economic power upon other societies, not about our ability to provide for the well-being of all Americans.

You could even (cynically) look at it the other way, that part of our "superpower" is the projection upon the world of the disaffection and anger that we breed internally by not providing for the well-being of all our citizens (in ways far more severe than a dearth of N95 masks). You see that phenomenon much more clearly in dictatorships and autocracies, but to an extent it's here too.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by spyckie2 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:36PM (#22613378)
When the hard constraint is not losing profit, many things are difficult to do.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by snarf21 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:01AM (#22616131)
This is the conundrum. People want manufacturing here and also want it to be super high paying with skills learned in a few days. People also want to buy things at the dollar store. If all the things at the dollar store were made by US workers, there wouldn't be dollar stores. Dollar stores exploded after Clinton opened up trade with China. Want people really want is buying power even if they don't understand it. It is also why I personally feel we are better off with removing all wage taxes on the poor than trying to push minimum wage higher and higher. Rich people don't shop at Wal-Mart. If everyone there makes $20/hour, it just makes it more expensive for the same people who now make "more" money (and they'll pay more taxes). If costs rise just like wages, buying power doesn't increase and could actually go down even if someone "makes" more.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mehrdadn on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:12AM (#22616219)
> It is also why I personally feel we are better off with removing all wage taxes on the poor than trying to push minimum wage higher and higher.

Confused, are you under the impression the entirety of everyone's wages is taxed in the United States?

P.S. On your larger point: I'm not sure in what world you think 0% tax is a substitute for minimum wage. It certainly does not prevent you from earning atrociously low wages (and having correspondingly abysmal purchasing power). It only means the government won't take any of your measly earnings. Whereas minimum wage is designed to solve exactly that problem.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by snarf21 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:43AM (#22616530)
To be fair, I never said get rid of minimum wage. I was talking about pushing it up to things like $20. The point I was trying to make is that if you go too high, you cause people to just up tax brackets and higher costs at the places they shop because those workers are also making $20/hour now too. Some people think tools like EITC helps the poor more than pushing minimum wage up and I tend to agree. I don't think EITC goes far enough and I would remove all federal taxes for people who earn less than some $X/year.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mehrdadn on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:05AM (#22616761)
That still doesn't make any sense. Consider the federal case. Currently minimum wage is $7.25/hr or just above $15k/yr, whereas $20 minimum wage is like $40k/yr, or like $18.40 after federal tax (ignore FICA + states for now, they're beside my point).

You're complaining raising minimum wage to $20 is not the solution, but you want to raise it some, and make up for the rest with lowering taxes? So what mix are you imagining will give comparable results? Like say, raise minimum wage to, I dunno, maybe $10? In what world is lower taxes going to make up the $8.40 shortfall? Are your taxes going to be negative? Or are you suggesting you're comfortable raising minimum wage to $18.40 but the $20.00 is what you find overly excessive?

P.S. I wasn't even talking about EITC, but the standard deduction. Your first $18,650 of income as head of household are simply untaxed ($24,800 for couples)... period. That's exactly what you were proposing, and it's been already there, for a long time. In hourly terms that's $9/hr for heads of households ($12/hr for couples) of untaxed income. EITC is relatively obscure by comparison, so I'm confused why you would first think of that when replying... I'm guessing you might be confused about how standard deductions and tax brackets work? Or possibly unfamiliar with the US tax system?

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by kittiepryde on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:04AM (#22616752)
The higher tax bracket, only taxes the money that falls into that bracket, they will still have higher after tax incomes.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ry4nolson on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:29AM (#22617003)
It amazes me how many people don't grasp this.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jbn on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:21PM (#22623760)
You are so right, it's incredible how many people don't grasp this. Further, people in lower brackets think that the tax rate in higher brackets is unfair because it applies to the whole income (rather than just that bracket).

I guess a piecewise affine function is just too complicated...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mehrdadn on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:34AM (#22617061)
I didn't even realize this might be the cause of their misunderstanding until I read your comment! Thanks for pointing it out.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by mlrtime on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:18AM (#22615752)
This is correct and an answer I give to people on the coasts when they ask why the US govt pays farmers. It is imperative that a country can feed itself.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by cycrutchfield on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:35PM (#22613372)
Would be much less of a problem if we actually stockpiled enough masks like we were supposed to.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jhpriestley on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:37PM (#22613386)
Stockpiling essential medical equipment sounds a lot cheaper than autarky.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ckcheng on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:09AM (#22614584)
Stockpiling is good as part of the preparation but isn't enough.

e.g. "Five months worth of supplies were used by one hospital in six days" [1]

How's any country supposed to stockpile enough at that rate?

And stockpiles require upkeep and evergreening. Otherwise things like masks eventually expire [2]. Upkeep costs money too.

[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

[2] https://nationalpost.com/news/world/ontario-stockpiled-milli...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by lazyjones on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:40AM (#22614715)
> e.g. "Five months worth of supplies were used by one hospital in six days" [1]

Here in Austria we don't even have enough N95 masks for hospital staff and medical personnel. This is completely irresponsible and not impossible to fix. It should be part of any pandemic plan to stockpile these. Things would work much better if at least this was covered now, but sadly it isn't and people will die because of it.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by piokoch on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:06AM (#22616764)
Stockpile how? This is typical niche product, nobody assumes this will be needed in huge quantities. There was a post on HN about how difficult is to produce those masks (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22613061) and that setting up assembly line for needed materials takes 6 months (6 months in Germany, who are already producing this stuff).
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by olejorgenb on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:41AM (#22615493)
I've seen this a couple of places, but no-one has explained why the masks expire?

Also - it should be possible to design simple protocols to rotate the stock properly. Storage costs due to increased space is unavoidable ofc.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ckcheng on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:51AM (#22617977)
I found: "Over time, components such as the straps and nose bridge material may degrade, which can affect the quality of the fit and seal" [1]

Also, some filters are constructed from charged fibers and electrostatic attraction helps in the filtering [2]. I wonder if that electrostatic attraction can be lost in some way, which would help explain the expiry date.

Anyway, [1] also says using expired masks may be considered in a crisis, best for training and fit testing though.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/respirators-st...

[2] https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/2009/10/14/n95/

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:20AM (#22615761)
Like most non-organic things masks "expire" because the manufacture needs to not be liable after a certain date (after all, the manufacturer can't be realistically held responsible indefinitely) and the institutions buying the masks are unwilling to take on the responsibility of determining the quality of their own stockpile so they just trash them and buy more.

The military actively researches this kind of thing and knows exactly how long past it's expiration date many products are good for. I'm unaware of any other organizations that take on this responsibility.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by yourapostasy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:11AM (#22615332)
Once you go down this analysis rabbit hole, I believe the rational conclusion is to "stockpile" manufacturing capacity by keeping manufacturing under physical domestic control.

Otherwise you're always fighting the last war. Today it is a respiratory-oriented weakness in our supply chain. Tomorrow it could be fungal spores; do we have enough domestic manufacturing capacity to create fungicides at pandemic scale?

Another mitigation option is standardized international cooperation and automated data interchange on international acute public health matters when an issue rises to just the regional level. Improving the level of integrated data sharing in this age of data mining would accelerate research and development of responses. I was hopeful that a standardized data representation format already existed, and highly-granular patient data from around the world would be available to the entire public (not just institutions) to sift through. Instead, we're still exchanging data through papers. The source code and raw data of models or clinical trial analyses are not published. We do have genome sequences available publicly, which helps, though.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Arbalest on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:50AM (#22613989)
Fair comment really. People are taking the worst case and running with it. Really governments should have had more forethought to make preparations while things were still good. Attempting self sufficiency sounds more like a post apocalyptic requirement, which given the circumstance is an easy trap to fall into. Though there's always the blindspot: not all futures are predictable. Just that this one mostly was.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by dehrmann on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:23AM (#22613603)
> a country having its own major manufacturing base is not just an economic need but rather also a national security need

It's a strong argument for diverse suppliers, but unless you're a major international player, you don't really have the need, and having redundant manufacturing gets expensive. Just look at people balking at the cost of switching away from Huawei (that's a name I haven't heard for a few weeks).

> the trade war along with serious investment in expanding industrial capacity is likely net good.

But it makes war easier. You know who's not going to war? The US and China. If they did, they'd be economically screwed. Economic interdependence makes war a lot harder.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ralph84 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:49AM (#22613736)
> Economic interdependence makes war a lot harder.

Citation needed. The American Revolutionary War, The American Civil War, WWI, WWII, just to name a few, all involved belligerents with significant economic interdependence.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by swsieber on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:15AM (#22613834)
My first thought about this economic mess was that it clearly illustrates why it'd be a bad idea to have another world war, even if it were mostly economic or infrastructure based.

I now think that this is getting us prepared to have a world war.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sneak on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:21AM (#22613876)
A much simpler option would to stop seeing the world as “them” and “us” and de-emphasize the borders in general.

It would be great if it were illegal to control the flows of inputs to and outputs from manufacturing, but I doubt national leaders hellbent on playing the blame game and prioritizing some lives/prosperity over others simply based on the accident of birthplace would ever give up that sort of control they now exercise.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:46AM (#22613974)
The problem with the post-national view is that it has to be a consensus view globally. It's a classic prisoner's dilemma.

It has to begin with everyone respecting broadly the same general ethics and views on rights. As it turns out, there are countries where women aren't allowed to drive, where religious autocracies rule, where whole populations of religious minorities are imprisoned and enslaved and the people of those countries support it happily. Do you want people with those values having a say in how you live? I don't.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sneak on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:58AM (#22614026)
The problem is that values are not evenly distributed within a country. A nation is not a useful or even approximate proxy for values.

Most countries have a pretty big chunk of people in them that would be fine with a religious autocracy that enslaves those who don’t conform to the majority, the US included. It’s the same in every country.

There are, for example, a whole bunch of people in the US who are fine with some fiercely racist and inhumane federal policies, such as running concentration camps wherein many children are raped and otherwise sexually abused.

Do you want people with those values having a say in how you live? I don't.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:24AM (#22614387)
> A nation is not a useful or even approximate proxy for values.

I bet you anything that if you polled Saudi Arabians and asked "Would you be willing to be ruled by a monarch?" and then do the same for Americans, you'll get wildly different results. If you are willing to make the bet large enough, I will go to relevant polling organizations to pay for one to be conducted.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sneak on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:02AM (#22615636)
> I bet you anything that if you polled Saudi Arabians and asked "Would you be willing to be ruled by a monarch?" and then do the same for Americans, you'll get wildly different results.

To my point, you'd get the same results in both places: some people in each country would say yes, and some other people in each country would say no.

Assuming one's ideology based on their geography is entirely outmoded in the age of global information systems.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:26AM (#22617653)
If your point is "a variety of opinion can exist everywhere" then sure but that's not great evidence that nations aren't an "approximate proxy for values". If it's 90-10 in one country and 10-90 in another it's clearly a proxy and not a great argument.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by remarkEon on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:06AM (#22614056)
>A nation is not a useful or even approximate proxy for values.

What? Of course it is. Even if you went one level down, states in the United States itself are excellent proxies for the mean values that are held in a particular region. If your point is that every geographic region has groups of people on the fringe, then yeah fine. That's true. But that doesn't mean anything with regard to the usefulness of what makes up a nation or its borders - which are of course proving quite useful during a pandemic.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sneak on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:01AM (#22614309)
> states in the United States itself are excellent proxies for the mean values that are held in a particular region.

I don't think those are any more practically useful, correlated, or appropriate than the assemblage, unless you go down to states where the population numbers are so low as to be less than a really meaningful statistical universe.

Populous states such as California and New York do not have anything remotely resembling universal buy-in on important values. Even within places like San Francisco, a single city/metro, you have a wide array of mutually exclusive value positions.

As soon as you get people together in large groups, you are going to have a large diversity in values and priorities. These civil perimeters have very little utility; I think people just like mentally personifying groups/nations so that they seem easier to reason about, regardless of the fact that it's wickedly inaccurate and not actually useful for that purpose at all. This is reflected in the widespread practice of synecdoche/metonymy.

China is a perfect example of this, as is California.

(TBH, I think it's a leftover from serfdom, where the lords/regional owners literally held physical dominion over the persons, labor, and travel rights of the people who lived within their borders. The Pythons' sketch on the matter from MPATHG accurately sums up my opinions on even thoroughly modern political assemblages.)

Personally, I reject the validity of all group identities that are based on sets containing more than a million or so humans. They're just not useful for reasoning about the group constituents, at all.

> But that doesn't mean anything with regard to the usefulness of what makes up a nation or its borders - which are of course proving quite useful during a pandemic.

Ah! Now we see the violence inherent in the system!

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by adrianN on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:49AM (#22614255)
I think your parent wants to say that the mean is not a particularly useful measure in the space of values because there are many fairly distinct clusters. People close to the mean might be a tiny minority.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jopsen on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:55AM (#22614521)
> The problem with the post-national view is that it has to be a consensus view globally. It's a classic prisoner's dilemma.

We can and are doing this at a much smaller scale. We have trade organizations that mediates disputes. And the US has been successfully pushing variants of the DMCA everywhere.

A sovereign country could decide that copyright is no more (within its borders), but no developed country has done it. Most countries probably pay more in copyright royalties to other countries than they get in return.

Isn't copyright also a prisoners dilemma?

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by jplayer01 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:40AM (#22614713)
Except there are situations such as this one where it doesn't matter how cooperative countries are. Even China was unable to produce enough medical supplies for their own needs, much less for the entire world. The US and Europe absolutely need to rebuild their industrial capacity to be able to cover their own needs in crisis situations. Anything else is just insanity.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sneak on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:07AM (#22616783)
I think your comment illustrates just precisely what a huge amount of effort and time it's going to take to get people to reorient their thinking along these lines.

"China" doesn't produce anything; human beings standing on the landmass called China produce medical supplies, just as human beings on other landmasses produce medical supplies. Recipients of medical supplies need more than can be supplied by Earth's manufacturers right now, as well as supply/demand scoped within specific regions or countries. That has nothing to do with countries or regions, any more than it has anything to do with which US state or city a factory is in.

I do agree that we should avoid excessive centralization of the manufacture of certain essential items, medications and medical supplies (and advanced/low power CPUs, and passenger aircraft) among them, but not for nationalistic reasons—simply because the Earth is big, transport is wasteful and resource-intensive (even if economically cheap), and resources are sometimes scarce/precious, such as in emergencies or supply interruptions (e.g. melt-blown fabric producing machines are time-consuming to produce).

It's nothing to do with the nationality of the people who produce the supplies, or the nationality of the people who need the supplies.

Perhaps the UN or another international body could coordinate ensuring that a certain amount of manufacturing capacity for various and specifically enumerated essential things could be carefully maintained on each continent, to guard against planet-scale civilizational collapse in rare events. I think in the old model this would be termed something like a "national security stockpile" or "strategic reserve" but ultimately it's more of a "civilization continuity capacity". Essential medicines and equipment are essential medicines and equipment, regardless of which humans need them, or where.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by tomp on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:33AM (#22614182)
You saw what happened in the EU. No borders but also no shared decision-making and responsibility. It quickly deteriorated to a situation worse than in the US, with each country doing its own thing (including closing most borders), and very little cooperation and helping each other.

Trump might not be making the best decisions, but at least he's making decisions for the US! Noone is even trying to make decisions for Europe...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by polytely on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:50AM (#22616599)
Well healthcare isn't organized on an European level but on a country level, so that's why the policy is directed on a country level but that doesn't mean there isn't any communication between countries. It's just that you mainly care about the countries you have a lot of (border)traffic with and not really about countries on the other side of the EU. I just watched the technical briefing to the Dutch parliament and the head of the RIVM (Dutch CDC equivalent) said that they are in close contact with for example the Italian hospitals to see what works and what doesn't.

I would like the EU to take more control over manufacturing protection gear and ventilators, and distribute them as needed over the EU.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by TeMPOraL on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:51AM (#22616611)
EU isn't a federal government. It has very little practical ability to boss member countries around, and this is by design/democratic will of the member states (insofar you believe that this many levels of indirection still add up to a democracy).

If we wanted to turn EU into a federation, we would've done it. As it is now, member states cling to their sovereignty (IMO quite unfortunately).

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sgift on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:26AM (#22614667)
> Noone is even trying to make decisions for Europe...

Of course people are. The EU commission works on it, countries talk to each other. Is there a fully coordinated EU response yet? No. Is there cooperation? Yes.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by agustif on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:56AM (#22615032)
Well our female president Von Der Leyen snatched up a 80mill grant for cureVac in order to avoid Trump luring them to move and secure the covid-19 vaccine for US only.

Trump 0 Europe 1

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by raxxorrax on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:31AM (#22615444)
Ah, yes, she exists...

I think she is just half bad and predictable but I don't think it is the best argument for the condition of the commission.

This XY vs Trump shit isn't very convincing and I do believe that it is pretty though for people really caring about politics.

The cureVac thing is suspicious as there are conflicting reports.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by xienze on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:31AM (#22615837)
One such “conflicting report” is CureVac themselves[0]:

> To make it clear again on coronavirus: CureVac has not received from the US government or related entities an offer before, during and since the Task Force meeting in the White House on March 2. CureVac rejects all allegations from press.

Oh sure, the original articles have been updated, but still the myth remains. Funny how that works.

0: https://mobile.twitter.com/CureVacAG/status/1239535638359281...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by raxxorrax on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:34AM (#22616447)
Yes, that is what I was hinting at. Of course they could lie in the interest of a possible business relationship, but I see no evidence of this. I wonder how the rumor started.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by sgift on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:05AM (#22616758)
The majority owner of the company said it is the case and the German government said they are discussing counter measures. This tweet is damage control and tries to use a bit of weasel wording to make it look better: There never was a formal offer, so we can just ignore informal talks, right?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by raxxorrax on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:23AM (#22617616)
Maybe. Perhaps it is a PR-move to bring the company into the spotlight. Perhaps it was Trump wanting to be seen as capable. Perhaps we will never know.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by tomp on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:25AM (#22615804)
The EU commission was criticizing Trump for banning flights from EU, before banning them themselves a few days later.

It's a circus.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by DiogenesKynikos on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:43AM (#22614464)
Indeed, every new crisis shows just how fragile the EU is. It's great that Europeans can travel from country to country, live and work in whichever member state they want, and can use the same currency, but the second there's a serious crisis, it's every member state for itself.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by solatic on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:22AM (#22614644)
Yes and no. The economic benefits of globalized supply chains are real. The question is not whether or not supply chains should be globalized but how to ensure their safety in the event of a global disruption?

It's days like these that I'm really sad that more Americans don't do military service. Ensuring the long-term viability of large, generally dormant stockpiles is the core competency of the military in peacetime, because the military needs to spin up large numbers of resources on a dime when necessary and can't take several months or years to do so in the face of an imminent attack.

My argument is that the military should maintain large manufacturing capacity that is generally dormant during peacetime (when it is too expensive compared to a globalized supply chain) so that it can be spun up in the event of global supply chain disruptions.

In a day and age where security needs have more to do with economics than geopolitical control, it should arguably be the military's highest priority.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by lazyjones on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:37AM (#22614703)
> My argument is that the military should maintain large manufacturing capacity that is generally dormant during peacetime (when it is too expensive compared to a globalized supply chain) so that it can be spun up in the event of global supply chain disruptions.

Might be a good solution, but how about having some more generic production capacity instead that can adapt quickly to urgent needs? China is quickly converting whole factories, with some research perhaps this process can be simplified and improved with more expensive, but flexible production technology. 3D printing instead of die casting etc. ...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by AdrianB1 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:11AM (#22615327)
It used to be the case in some countries; for example in my country the tobacco processing plants had the dual-purpose to build rifle ammo as most of the packing equipment used ~ 7.62 diameter. My cousin that worked in such a plant said it took less than 2 weeks for a full conversion. In this particular example there was no dormant capacity during peacetime, it was actively used on alternative production.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:00PM (#22618764)
> "generic production capacity"

Much like the generic scientist/engineer in video games (imagine telling a chemical engineer that they're suddenly a electrical engineer), there is no such thing as "generic production capacity". Specific high-tech industries require specific hardware and specific expertise (like the melt-blown fabric mentioned in the article) that you can't just keep on standby indefinitely.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by lazyjones on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:13PM (#22620771)
> Specific high-tech industries require specific hardware and specific expertise (like the melt-blown fabric mentioned in the article) that you can't just keep on standby indefinitely.

This depends on the product design and one has to be flexible. Do you think it's impossible to build N100 filter cartridges without melt-blown fabric?

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by robotnikman on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:00PM (#22620651)
The US did this during WWII, I don't see why it can't be done again.

They also took some more complex designs which required skilled labor and hand working (the 40mm Bofors comes to mind as an example) and modified the design significantly so it could be easily mass produced. This was in the days before CAD when everything was done on paper too

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by megous on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:30AM (#22615439)
It also shows that starting trade wars is not a great idea, if you may need the other country's resources in unforeseen future emergencies.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:53AM (#22615563)
The argument for trade wars is that it encourages more local manufacturing and independence. That doesn't seem to be what's happened so far in the current dispute between China and the US though.

I suspect this is because the trade dispute has introduced so much uncertainty that nobody is willing to make long term investments in infrastructure and capacity, based on what may well be a temporary and constantly changing situation.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Ericson2314 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:33PM (#22613367)
Does one of the n95 cotton candy machines even exist in the US?

I would love to see the specs for them made free and open so anyone could attempt to produce one and then have it vetted.

Contributing to e.g. firmware code for the thing is like the only meaningful thing I could put my skills towards in this epidemic. It would be an honor to do so.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by AdrianB1 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:19AM (#22615376)
The problem is not the specs and firmware code with these machines, it is the precision and tuning it to get good quality output. In the physical world, working with sub-micron polymer products is not something you solve with software. They wrote in the article about some challenges, none is trivial and none is due to hiding the specs or writing bad code.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Ericson2314 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:35PM (#22621476)
The latency is due to those physical constraints, as you say and as discussed in the article. But that doesn't mean that IP constraints hinder the embarrassingly parallel scale out of multiple new machines put together by different people in different places.

Now, having 100 new machines ready in 5 months might be little better than 3 new ones in 5 months.

I don't mean to be one of those assholes that presumes software subsumes all problems, but my experience working with engineers is that they confuse a non-software hard part with a non-software critical path: even though software is the easy part, there are still gains to be had from making the easy part easier.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Inconel on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:38PM (#22613389)
The article mentions this Florida company as one of the suppliers of such machines. They have a reasonably informative website. http://www.hillsinc.net
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:36PM (#22613377)
I believe so, yes.

An interesting article here about some history: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/03/05/8113874...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by eru on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:06AM (#22627593)
> I do believe these masks are also made in the US, but this situation highlights exactly why a country having its own major manufacturing base is not just an economic need but rather also a national security need.

I might take your argument for the security need. But how does this highlight anything about an economic need? (Or am I misreading that?)

> In economic terms, under certain definitions and assumptions that are typical under modern economics, a trade war such as the current US-China trade war result in welfare losses. I believe, however, that when national security is taken into account (ie having the ability for the country to rapidly respond to productive capacity needs in a time of crisis), the trade war along with serious investment in expanding industrial capacity is likely net good.

Perhaps an optimally waged trade war might be? Not sure. But in practice, politicians use these highly theoretical arguments that might apply in very special cases to defend very crude behaviour.

Eg if you want to justify a trade war on national security grounds, your goal would presumably to weaken the other party?

One of the demands in Trump's trade war was that China open its markets more to American goods and services, and lower tariffs and restrictions on foreign commerce in general. That would only strengthen the Chinese economy, for all the orthodox reasons.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by KKKKkkkk1 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:21AM (#22613877)
When you say that the US needs to "invest in itself", what you really mean is that the US needs to divert investments from industries in which it has a comparative advantage into industries that developing countries have a comparative advantage in.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by function_seven on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:35AM (#22613934)
The current situation is showing us that the comparative advantage may not be as great as we thought it was for overseas manufacturing.

When doing the arithmetic, a term for “national security” may have been underweighted or entirely left out.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by remarkEon on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:01AM (#22614040)
The "comparative advantage" we enjoy is an artificial creation of deliberate policy choices. The traditional "well this is just econ 101" macroeconomic lectures describe scenarios as they exist, not how they should be. The "comparative advantage" that you think developing countries have is using cheap slave wage labor to produce an unending wave of cheap (mostly plastic) consumer goods that people are quickly realizing in this pandemic they don't really need. Not to mention non-existent environmental regulations.

I hope that this crisis makes people do a deep introspection of their consumption habits, and realize where these "goods" actually come from, and whether it was really worth it to stock our giga stores with this stuff.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by AdrianB1 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:22AM (#22615390)
You can die in a pandemic still singing the song about the "comparative advantage". Not to mention that there is no comparative advantage when you ignore the buzzwords and actually do the comparison seriously.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by creddit on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @01:32AM (#22613922)
If investment were somehow zero sum, yes that's a large part of what I would mean. Luckily, for my point to continue standing without being reduced to that, investment is indeed not zero-sum.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:07AM (#22614818)
Yes, but who would pay these companies just to stay in business? If China can produce these things for half the price (even after shipping), people will buy from them instead. That's how the free market works.

I mean you could mandate that certain essential products can only be made locally / cannot be imported from abroad, but who is going to pay for it? That would require a political revolution, and despite everything that's happened over the past years, that just isn't going to happen in the US just yet.

Besides, it'd make the US more communist, where the government controls the market and production and where people work.