I would claim that ATMs are in fact a prime example of successful automation. For anything non-mundane you still need to go talk to a human, but that's the point: ATMs have removed the need to involve a human bottleneck for a bulk quantity of an extremely mundane task: withdrawing cash. I am old enough to remember when you had to go to the bank for that too.
This hits the nail on the head, though:
> The problem arises when anything requiring the least bit of thinking is attempted to be automated.
Humans are capable of judgment calls.[ß] Computers do exactly what you tell them to do, which is not necessarily what you want them to do.
ß: environments where humans are forbidden from making judgment calls are called bureaucracies.
In most cases, the customer-facing self checkout systems are objectively much slower and more cumbersome than the manned checkout systems that require some training and practice to use correctly. Paid cashiers never have to slow down their scanning because of a spurious reading from a scale in the bagging area. They get real keyboards to interact with the computer, and user interfaces that are far more responsive than the typical touchscreen UI's update latency.
Then again, I'm not buying 57 individual items in a line 6 people deep who are all buying similar amounts of items. Perhaps you are. A matter of taste.
We all have difference preferences so don’t attribute yours to others.
Let me mention one then: ATMs.
The less work is required to produce goods, the better it can compete (in price). This makes it so that you _don't have to_ work as much to achieve the same quality of life
Municipal water service versus hand pumped well
E-ZPass versus tollbooth attendant.
Festool Domino biscuit jointer versus me doing it by hand
Sheetrock versus plaster and lathe
They are fantastic. Leaps ahead of every supermarket and CVS I've been in. When I was doing a lot of housework and was very used to them, I could get through a check out with a couple of items in under a minute. Really proved to me that these do not need to be awful
P.S.: I don't miss nowadays the increase of human-induced Coronavirus infection risk when I experience human-free services.
I'm not a complete luddite. In many systems, specifically manufacturing, robots outcompete humans and it makes sense.
The problem arises when anything requiring the least bit of thinking is attempted to be automated. Those are nothing more than cost saving measures, and bring down the quality of service to everyone involved.