News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by nabla9 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @07:17AM (#22615364)
It's not true that US or any other developed country have lost their manufacturing base. The rest of the economy has grown faster than manufacturing.

Developed countries have moved into high-tech, high productivity, more capital intensive manufacturing with complex supply chains. If you want to bring back low productivity products into your country, you must accept wage decline, slower growth and lowering quality of life.

You can prepare for emergencies using other means and using relatively small adjustments. Post-industrial societies have higher productivity than industrial societies. Turning the clock back is not a good idea.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by coldtea on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:00AM (#22615612)
>Turning the clock back is not a good idea.

Might be a more liveable, more resilient, better for the environment, and for quality of life (which is not the same as "more gadgets") idea though...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:14AM (#22615727)
It's hard to see how lower paid jobs are more liveable or provide better quality of life, or how smaller scale and therefore less efficient manufacturing would be better for the environment. I just don't see how these outcomes are supposed to arise.

More resilient, ok maybe, but surely there are other ways that resilience could be achieved through e.g. rolling stockpiling or maintaining flexible manufacturing capability. We don't necessarily need to be able to make our own masks all the time, but have the capacity to make them if needed. there are a range of new technologies coming along that could provide this flexibility, such as 3d printing and flexible robotic assembly systems. That would come at a cost for sure, but could provide the needed flexibility at a much lower social cost than pushing people back into lower value long term employment.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by coldtea on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:47AM (#22615982)
>It's hard to see how lower paid jobs are more liveable or provide better quality of life

We had higher paid jobs (or more yield per job, a single working person could support a family, buy a house, send kids to college) in the 50s and 60s for example, so I'm not sure why "turning back time" means lower paid jobs (or less purchase capacity).

Give me necessities (house/rent, food, taking care of kids, college, etc) and more freedom/livable work, and I can live without 90% of modern "must haves", from smartphones to same-day-delivery from poorly-paid adults in wharehouses working 10-hour shifts in diapers to send me Amazon Prime goods made in China...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by ethbro on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:56AM (#22616668)
> We had higher paid jobs (or more yield per job, a single working person could support a family, buy a house, send kids to college) in the 50s and 60s for example

So, your proposal is to bomb Europe and Asia's industrial base to increase America's relative competitiveness?

If we're talking apples to apples about the world economy of the 50s and 60s...

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:26PM (#22621406)
Ok, that’s fine. It’s your life. If you want to go and work in a factory, good for you.

I had a conversation like this with a friend of mine a few years ago. He was complaining about the lack of manufacturing jobs here in the UK and that we needed real jobs for real people. So I pointed at his 5 year old son playing nearby and said ok. What sort of factory would he like his son to work in when he grows up? What sort of education did he plan for him that would best suit him for factory life? Silence.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by greedo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:36PM (#22619815)
The US economic boom in the 50s largely stemmed from the fact that the entire outside world had been devastated from WW2. US industry had a huge lead since the continental US was largely free on war damage.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by dls2016 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:11AM (#22617491)
preach
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by piokoch on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:48AM (#22616583)
"quality of life" what's that, that's a question. Does buying new car every 3 years is a condition for a good life quality? New iPhone every 2 years? Pair of shoes/trousers or fashionable t-shirt every month? Maybe people will just discover that driving older car does not really deteriorate their life quality and new iPhone does not really matter, it just allows Apple to put more cash on the huge pile they already have. Maybe Tim Cook will not afford new jet or yacht next year, but, frankly, who cares?
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by simonh on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:21PM (#22621372)
Dude, if you don’t want a new phone don’t buy one. It’s ok. Nobody will get upset.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by coldtea on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:26PM (#22669458)
It's about the quality of life on a society that prioritizes gadgets and BS consumption, not about what one can do as individual.

Even if one doesn't "buy a new phone" it's still affected by a society hell bent on such trivia.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:02AM (#22615637)
300 to 800 factories yearly closed their doors in France since the introduction of the Euro. Italy faces a lesser but still steep industrial decline. In the meanwhile, industrial output boomed in the German hinterland of Eastern Europe.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by toyg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:06AM (#22616175)
Apart from the arguable “yearly”, that’s just efficiency in practice. When you look at the US, you see the same thing: there isn’t a large movie industry in each state, but there is one Hollywood (and one Broadway for theatre). Attracting all talent and capital from the entire continent allows for a level of economies of scale and quality refinement that makes it absolutely dominant worldwide. The same process happened for Silicon Valley / Bay Area, or even Detroit back in the day - it’s not like they were only making cars for Illinois and immediate surroundings...

I’m Italian and I can see our country becoming such a centre of attraction in certain fields (fashion and advertising in Milan, for example; food in Emilia; motor-racing in Romagna; tourism in Tuscany...). I’m not terribly worried that our widget-making capabilities have lowered - we are still paying the economic and social price of 60s-style industry in some areas (Taranto, Pozzuoli etc).

In the end it always boils down to this annoying tribalism - in a global world, thinking that French and Germans and Italians and Spanish must be separate and autonomous little tribes, is as silly as thinking that Nice or Lyon should be completely separate and autonomous from Paris and Calais.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:13AM (#22617501)
That's efficiency from a certain perspective. That's this wonderful efficiency that makes the world extremely sensitive to the current Covid-19 situation. That's the very opposite of antifragility. We need resilience, too.

This has absolutely nothing to do with isolationism or tribalism. Gee, I hate this sort of strawman argument.

Our globalised, ultra-lean, efficient world was built on a humongous influx of fossil fuels and other limited resources that destroyed our climate while being so "efficient". Fossil fuels (and phosphates) that will become scarce at some point or another.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by toyg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:31AM (#22617706)
Efficiency and resiliency are different things. If you want resiliency, you plan accordingly - left to its own devices, the capitalist market will always go for ultimate efficiency, that's a primary property of the system. This is not the Soviet Union deciding to do potatoes in one country and cars in another, people take smaller decisions that aggregate up to certain phenomenons. If you don't like those phenomenons, you have to intervene pretty radically.

> This has absolutely nothing to do with isolationism or tribalism.

This has absolutely all to do with tribalism. If industries had closed in France and opened in Belgium, making them operatively indistinguishable from French industries for all intents and purposes (as distance is negligible and half of them basically speak the same language), people would still go on about lacking French industry. Why? Because Belgium is conceptually "not France". Nobody complains (anymore) about a single factory serving an entire country, why should we worry about a single factory serving half a continent? Do you seriously think you should have a widget-making factory in every city or town, for each different type of widget...? "OMG the world might end, we need to be able to make Gucci shoes in every town!"

> fossil fuels and other limited resources that destroyed our climate

I do not disagree, but that's something that effectively started 300 years ago and is not going to end anytime soon, unless you enjoy riding horses and going to bed with the sun. We will find alternatives (in some areas we already have, effectively; they are just not equally distributed yet).

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:41PM (#22618547)
Sorry but no, the problem isn't of industry closing down in France and opening back in Belgium, you're misrepresenting things. There has been a long history of the idea that we Europeans don't really need to "make things", that we could relocate our industry wherever it's more "efficient" (i. e. cheaper, because mostly of lower environmental and social safeguards, and because nobody directly pays for the externalities -- that's good old imperialism, colonialism in new clothes IMO) and keep the know-how, engineering, and power for us while Chinese or others would do the dirty work for us. And this stupid idea began to crumble a few years back already, and is now suddenly proven dead to everyone (hopefully).

There is such a thing as sovereignty, and it doesn't matter at which scale it happens; sovereignty implies having control on whatever things you can't do without. Can Europe or the US be sovereign without steel mills? maybe. Car manufacturing? possibly. Chemistry and pharmaceutical production? not so sure. Oil? see our leaders grovelling at MBS' knees while he's butchering Yemen. Ah.

In the US, some top brass came recently to the realisation that the US can't make a war plane without Chinese input anymore. That may be a problem sooner or later.

Similarly, the impact of the transfer of industries and money across Europe isn't a problem per se, it's only a problem because nothing provides any equilibrium -- no transfers at any significant scales. So far Germany sends cars and machines across Europe, and gets paper in exchange. At times, some important German minister or another goes harping that someday, that TARGET2 balance will have to be cleared. Does this even make sense? Can we have a European money, but not a European industry? I don't think so. Something will have to give at some point or another.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by toyg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @04:58PM (#22621180)
You're mixing together a bunch of different issues. On some of them we don't even disagree. But they are different issues. And the issue of "sovereignty" is precisely the tribalistic attitude I was talking about.
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by Totoradio on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:14AM (#22615724)
>300 to 800 factories yearly closed their doors in France since the introduction of the Euro.

Have you got a source on that? The data I can find [1] says 600 total have closed between 2009 and 2018.

[1] https://bfmbusiness.bfmtv.com/entreprise/depuis-janvier-il-y...

from this source: https://fr.slideshare.net/dcousquer/2018-un-ralentissement-e... , slide 5.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by wazoox on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:17AM (#22617545)
Here, 900 factories closed from 2009 to 2011: https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2011/12/28/pres-de-9...

This has been more or less the trend from 2001 to 2016. There was a slight upturn for 2017-2018, then it went down again in 2019.

Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by piokoch on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:59AM (#22616701)
That's pretty obvious. Germany has superior industry, yet thanks to Euro they are able to keep prices reasonably low. If Mark was still used, it would have cost 2 USD and others could compete at least in prices. This hurt even more Italy. Next, Germany managed to build a cheap suppliers chain out of former East Block countries (especially Poland).
Re:Why N95 masks are hard to make by stjohnswarts on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:48PM (#22618631)
People like to say post industrial and post information societies but neither of those are true. We rely on both quite heavily and should learn from things like this pandemic that we can't trust to outsource all our manufacturing to other countries especially military rivals like China who will naturally cut us off when we have a war over Taiwan when China really starts flexing.