We have shifted to an economy that increasingly favors rent seeking in every field and land is quintessentially that. Even without that trend, land reform meets enormous resistance under any circumstances but given that shift, even more so now.
Note that we know people will endure housing conditions seen everywhere at all time up until the 20th century, and unless the people hurt[1] by this do something remarkably effective, that state of affairs is guaranteed to return: there is no invisible hand guaranteeing even one family per room let alone per unit.
[1] disproportionately wage earners and the young but also all paying rent and mortgage interest.
Saying land/housing prices are outpacing many other productive investments seems like a stretch. If you look at the performance of large US REIT ETFs versus market indices like the SPY the rent seeking behavior by real estate investors doesn't look so profitable.
And beside serious investors, for the typical individual, a home loan allows them to leverage funds that are unimaginably beyond what they could raise for investment with vastly more safety. Not that I suggest it would be better if half the population could and did buy stocks on unlimited margin or the like.
I just want to point out that even on this one particular issue, we gradually made policy and decided and made it such that one kind of loan is vital and the other insanely too risky. That at this point, this is so ingrained that it's hard to imagine any alternative. But I suggest we should probably try.
[1]: https://investor.vanguard.com/mutual-funds/profile/performan...
[2]: https://investor.vanguard.com/etf/profile/performance/vnq
This is a very important point. Buying real estate is the most accessible way for an average-income household to get leverage - at least in the US where heavily leveraged financial products like CFDs are not easily accessible (at least to my knowledge). But in my opinion this another argument against investing into real estate because lots of uninformed buyers are in the market with increasing amounts of leverage leading to rather dramatic boom and bust cycles (like in the housing crisis of 2008).
This is probably true. In the short-medium term housing will not be allowed to crash for the simple reason that homeowners vote. The soundness of the economy in general will be sacrificed to pump house prices.
This feeds a feedback loop that makes housing an even more attractive place to park capital, further driving up housing costs.
Of course eventually this gets so unbelievably ridiculous that we have some kind of revolution. Look for $2m starter homes before that happens.
There are two things you can influence either supply or demand. You're reducing supply but keeping demand the same or allowing it to grow. The answer is to increase supply and reduce demand.
The thing is, the places that are supply constrained have optimized themselves into being in extreme demand. They know they don't have enough housing but that doesn't stop them from building more commercial real estate to enable new businesses. Those businesses could have been founded somewhere else but why bother when the most suitable city still has enough room for you (but not for the employees)?
I don't understand why there aren't more employees demanding to move the company out of the state.
you are wrong and you do not know history. it will crash and then it will recover and then it will crash again. real estate is cyclical.
States, money and firms are now in a tight gridlock. Way more than before.
So will just pumping out more money. Fear the day "they" decide to flood the real market with money and not just stocks and shares.
So why are homes so expensive in urban areas, including now tier 2 and tier 3 cities, and not just NYC, DC, and SF?
Look at our population growth. In the 'good times' of the 1960s, we had 180M people. Now we have double that in two generations, or the difference between Boomers and Millenials approximately. In 1960, places like SF and Arlington, VA weren't rural farmland, they were still urban areas. We now have higher density in the large cities due to jobs having moved there, so we probably have 3x the number of people desiring homes in the same area as we had in 1960.
And families are smaller now. In 1960, you'd have a family of 5 in one house. Now you need two houses for the two 2.5 / person families.
So essentially we've probably got 4x the demand for the homes close to working centers, along with rising base prices due to far more women in the workforce. Add perpetual low interest rates, underreported inflation, and I'm surprised houses aren't at SF levels in every city yet.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_the_Uni...
The cost is directly related to the fact that it is defectors illegal to build new homes in the most economically vibrant zip codes.
Go back to the 70's, San Francisco was losing population. By the 90's it had dropped from a peak of 775K (1950) to 670K (1980). It's now ~880K, so only 14% higher than 70 years ago.
Homeland wars do amazing things to economies.
The difference is: Even if no one can afford housing: There doesn't have to be bust. For example: if there's only 9 houses on the market, there only need to be 9 people willing to buy in at that price. So, essentially, with a severe housing shortage, only the richest 0.1% need be able to afford the houses on the market and they can still maintain an extremely high prices.
Meanwhile the coping mechanisms are in full effect:
1. longer and longer commutes causing ever more CO2.
2. multiple generations living together
3. roomates bunking together, not having families, not having kids
4. decreased spending in other areas as every last dollar goes to housing
5. ever more louder cries for rent regulations which makes it even hard to build more supply thus resulting in a death spiral.
When will it all end? Not sure, but the way I see it, there's 3 ways things can play out...
1) It will not end, and we continue to accept runaway inequality, where housing/healthcare/education etc. become more and more unaffordable in comparison to normal wages. Only owners of capital will be protected (i.e. stocks/assets continue to get propped up).
2) We somehow turn ship and slowly fix our fiscal problems (not going to happen so long as we have deficits). This would mean accepting economical stagnation for a long while to essentially pay off our accrued debts
3) We let things start crashing
So far 1 is playing out...
QE has been horrific for banks. Net interest income has collapsed. it's less pronounced in the US, but in Europe where central banks have taken rates to 0 (or below) bank profits have all but been wiped out. Take a look at the share price of any European bank since 2008
Think about the Euro crisis as another example. Zero rates and ECB buying all the sov and fin debt bailed out banks that would have gone under.
If 30% of the banking system collapsed, then surviving institutions would probably have profitability consistent with historical rates.
But keep everyone alive, and bring rates to zero, and you squeeze margins both with excess competition, and compressing the diff between the rates they lend and the rates they borrow.
Nobody thinks SPY is going to keep increasing forever. The conventional wisdom is we're looking at a recession in the next 1-2 years.
Another way to look at it is that a gambler can’t do anything to affect the roulette wheel, but a recession can be brought about or deepened by all sorts of human action.
I purchase multi-family rentals to be short the US dollar. My assets slowly gain value (while cash flowing) as the Federal Reserve continues its stimulus efforts (currently called Not-QE), which in turn devalues the currency.
Rents are unlikely to decrease substantially, even if house prices do, since they've historically been much less volatile.
If rates go negative, house prices will likely increase A LOT. You're in for a HUGE windfall.
If rates stay low, house prices will likely track inflation. Even if they track inflation, you're leveraged. You still have a very high yielding bond.
If rates go up, you're stuck with the property, but you still have a decent yielding bond.
Another merit is positive cash flow is now. If I were to continue to enjoy financial deals like I negotiated for our first 4 doors, $600K is all that is needed for control over enough assets to bring in $8K a month in cash flow.
In the US, currently cash flow/investment returns can be received with a lower tax base than earned income, again making it more powerful. Subject to change, of course, but I work with what exists now and hopefully let the future work out how it will.
In high cost areas most of the value is in the land, not the house.
The key is: 1) companies first (with tax incentives they'll do or move anywhere). 2) jobs next 3) Where jobs go, people follow.
US home ownership rate is 65%, gotta be quite a few winners in there besides the bankers.
> In 2018, 396 homes were sold [in Silver Lake, Los Angeles], with 60% not intended to be primary residences.
[1]: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2019-10-23/airbnb-shor...
And you can’t just tax them on it, because they’ll just push that as increased rents on their tenants.
They must divest, and release the housing unit, and sell it to someone that will actually live in it. And they cannot be allowed to do some other shenanigans to circumvent the spirit of this law.
Imagine if entire neighborhoods could create such ordinances. Prices would surely begin to trend downward, providing access to home ownership in desirable areas, allowing those with normal incomes to purchase starter property and begin families.
I wonder why this isn't ever discussed.
How do you even purchase a starter home, when the starting price is $700,000?
And in the meanwhile, you have to continue to pay your $3,000/month rent.
The only sustainable way to deflate housing cost is to increase supply.
But for the rest of us, it has made life a living hell on Earth. A survival of the fittest.
Life is now a reality of Mad Max sitting behind the steering wheel of a Prius, driving for pennies a day, if you can even make a profit after all the hidden expenses.
Life is now a fierce competition for resources, where you can’t even make your rent, or afford to start a family, or even to have children.
Meanwhile, the rich just laugh at you: “Here’s a dollar for your tip, see I believe in trickle-down economics.”
The lucky ones were those in the right technology companies, or those with the right medical or professional certifications.
Because of QE, there is now more homelessness. Even with people who shouldn’t be homeless.
The rents are much higher, and have kept pace with expensive mortgages. The landlords raised the rents just because they can. The rents in some areas can easily exceed $3000/month. This squeezes the rest of us that couldn’t afford a house before 2007. And after the crash, nobody was getting any mortgages, after they locked down all borrowing. And now, the higher rents eats up our earnings, that reaching that 20% down payment is an elusive dream. How do you even save for 20% of a $700,000 house ($140k), while paying your rent and bills?
The price of a house seemed to have gone up on average about $50,000 per year, for the past 4 years! Can most people even save up this much money a year? The same house that was listed for $500,000 just 4 years ago, in 2016, is now listing for $700,000 today. And there wasn’t even any renovations done on it.
Because of QE, the interests are so low, that it jacked up prices for everything: housing, stocks, education.
If you had $100,000 sitting around in cash after 2008, and was daring enough to plow that money back into the stock market and sit on SPY, then today, that net worth would be $270,000. Not bad, you would’ve made a cool quarter million.
The problem is that the capitalist class had $10 million dollars sitting around in cash, and if they aggressively plowed all that money into stocks, then they would’ve netted $27 million instead!
And some may have done that with their own money. But the way the capitalist class did it instead, was through their companies, with the share buy backs. They took public money, easily printed by the Fed, at low interest, to buy back shares to reduce availability, to force a supply and demand run. The stock goes up, it looks nice on the quarterly balance sheet, and they pay themselves a very very nice bonus. Which they then use to buy up real estate assets, in the form of LLCs and special corporations. They were the fox guarding the hen house!
This is the key thing that is driving inequality. And with the refusal of cities and governments to build more housing, to meet public demand, then it forces this situation on the rest of us. The rest of us are forced to compete, when the game is rigged against us.
So to the question of who are the winners in this QE fiasco? It is certainly not the normal people. It is the capitalist class. The rich, the wealthy, and those that own the corporations, and make all the rules.
When will the normal people rise up with their pitch forks and torches, and realize what the capitalist class has done to them?
Oh well, I guess they’re too busy drowning their sorrows in their iPhones, Facebooks, YouTubes, and instagrams, to bother seeing what has been done to them.
If inflation doubles to ~5% (which is closer to the historic norm), interest rates will also rise to ~6% (again, a historic norm). Suddenly, people who could swing an $800K mortgage, can now only do $600K (keeping payments the same). That will have a huge impact on housing prices.
I doubt it will crash (50%+ drop in price), but no doubt we'll see some sort of slow burn, where houses drop 10-20% over a 5-10 year period.
Once income catches up with prices, we'll see a recovery.
2007 was not about high housing prices. It was about ridiculously easy mortgages and everyone was able to afford a house outside their genuine payback limit.
The symptoms can appear similar, with different causes.
What is with Americans who continually fail to understand that there's a world outside of America?
The link is about global housing, not just the US. That means an explanation can't rely on US-specific excuses.
What's your explanation for how US quantitative easing drives up house prices in Sydney, Hong Kong, and London but doesn't affect Singapore, Berne, or Munich?
QE is not a US-specific phenomenon, either in origin (other central banks have engaged in it) or in effect when the US does it (given the US dollar’s global role.)
Well, it is obvious when it will crash. It will crash when it becomes less worth it for people to pay those prices.
When other cities become hot-spots of high-paying jobs, people will leave San Francisco for those jobs and the price of housing will decline.
if you're looking for a 'black swan' economic collapse event, look for a lot of outstanding debt and the possibility of an interest rate spike on that debt
Student Loans. You need to make as much money as a doctor to afford housing. So did everyone become a doctor in the past 10 years?
Personal Auto Loans, although this seems rather localized.
Business Loans used for stock buy-backs, so executives could pay themselves a nice bonus. Can some of these businesses really pay back those loans?
Municipal bonds used for funding construction in areas with no economical viability.
Only in a handful of cities.
Also, the income difference is less than a factor of two for the same person. 57% of people in San Francisco have a college degree, versus 45% of people in Kansas City. So part of the difference in median income is due to the difference in education, not the difference in local salaries.
Plenty of people who aren't doctors can make doctor money now. Just look at tech.
> Plenty
Plenty of tech folks make north of six-figures and often do better than most, but neurosurgeons make $800k, and plenty of mid-level medical types can pull $300K+. I personally know a dentist making "in the ballpark of 400" (his words) in the Washington DC 'burbs.
There are certainly IT/CS gigs paying north of $600K -- they're discussed all the time here on HN -- but those don't really exist outside of SV and maybe a handful of other areas, and generally require a pedigree that, while not a Med School, are still fairly non-trivial.
Your ITT-Tech trained Active Directory Admin isn't going to make anything near GP or Dermatologist money -- most tech, even with real degrees and certs, wont.
Lots of doctors make under $200k. I would say the majority do, because the majority don't own their own practices (partly nor in whole). Most doctors in the US are just salaried internists.
I think more than 10% of SWE with experience in the US are making that much or more when you account for compensation that is not pure salary.
I live in a big US city. We have one large tech employer which pays engineers ~125-150k (they max out at 200k for principals in specialized areas). At almost every other company in town, the going salary for a developer is 80-100k.
The latter type of job is far more representative of engineering jobs in the country. We told everyone "go do STEM and make bank at Google!" Meanwhile there aren't enough of those top-end jobs to go around, and a lot of folks who didn't go to a name-brand university or have friends in the right places work for (comparatively) little money.
An Anesthesiologist makes over $250,000 annually. Try making that as a senior tech.
A Physician’s Assistant makes over $170,000 annually. Easily beating an average senior software engineer. And they’re not even medical doctors.
Nurses make over $125,000 easily, especially with their mandatory overtime schedules baked into their union agreement.
And here’s the kicker: because women make up a larger share of medical professionals, then you have a situation where doctors end up marrying other doctors or nurses. Which is good for them, but guess what they do? They buy up the expensive houses. And then they buy their second or third houses, thus pricing normal people out of that also.
Maybe in California, but most of the US is not union and most nurses do not make anywhere close to this. $30-40/hr is much more typical. That salary is far about the top 10% of nursing salaries (which is $106k).
That’s not a thing. The debt taken on for a stock buyback would depress the stock price as much as the purchase would increase the price.
But everything bounced back. With the support of TARP and other government assistance programs.
That's the difference here: The recovery.
The median first home purchase is at 33 currently.
Combine those two facts and you have demand for a first home peaking between 2035-2040. Add on top of that the older boomer generation peak dying or otherwise vacating homes and the effects of significant immigration backpressure and you have yourself a housing crash which will likely get priced into the market before these peaks happen.
That could well be round two as it is far enough in the future, the first round being the current global political breakdown and long running bull market reaching a tipping point.
<<cries in a Hong Kong dialect of Cantonese>>
1) Realize that this was back in 2007, when most people only dreamed of making $100,000 USD annually.
2) And housing prices were exceeding $500,000 USD in most of the state of California, because of all the shady house flippers borrowing on the ARM (adjustable rate mortgage) loans. So $800k was a significant percentage higher than most already over-priced mortgages at the time.
3) In order to qualify for a normal 30-year fixed-rate loan to buy a $500k house with 20% down, then you’d need to make an annual salary combined of $120,000. And since most people didn’t make that much, then you’d have to be dual-income to afford that mortgage.
4) And there was a saying at the time: House rich, but home poor. Meaning that these people bought an expensive house, but they were too poor to fill it with any furniture.
This is already having a huge impact on working in western Europe, and the more prevalent it becomes the more normal it will be to work from home, reducing the demand for proximal residence.
When the population decreases.
On top of that, I anticipate growing displacement due to climate change. This is not the time to slow down home construction.
Tech people crying foul about "the bankers" making them poor them is hilarious. Easy money is big reason the industry is booming; it's made you rich (by any reasonable standard).
I mean I'm sure some wealthy folks are but it's definitely not something that you "wouldn't bat an eye at".
The answer to when the big crash happens is in the population data. At some point population starts to decline.
As with everything, the boomers will ride in the sunset with bags of gold. In 30 years housing will be fundamentally different in the US and just about everywhere in the Western world. Outside of the major cities it won't even be much of an investment anymore.
If you buy a house today for $500k on a 30-year you'll spend close to a million dollars before you own it if you ride the loan out, and adjusted for inflation, you will probably take a loss on it. Possibly a large loss. Unless we see mass immigration the market 30 years from now is simply going to be smaller.
What's the basis for that conclusion?
Just like the last 30 years, some markets will decline, while others will appreciate. Not sure why you think things will be so drastically different.
It really depends where your $500k house is located. "Location, location, location" is the saying for a reason. If your home is in an area with continued economic opportunity and growth and it has not been destroyed by climate change related severe weather events, it doesn't matter that much what the macroeconomic housing market is doing; your property will be in demand.
While certainly the US population is aging and slowing in growth rate, I have not seen any predictions for a population decline by 2050 or even 2100.
You are right that further urbanization is expected and buying outside of cities may not be a good investment.
I think the boomers will trigger a sell off but as long as population grows due to immigration, there will probably never be a glut.
There is no indication I can see that these trends will reverse. If anything it seems like the rates of decline may accelerate more rapidly like they did in Japan.
Perhaps when the boomers die off the next generation will open the borders so someone can pay for their entitlements. Perhaps.
Back in 2007, there was a report of some guy spending an astronomical $800,000 USD for a house somewhere outside of Silicon Valley, like in Tracy, I think. This was bonkers back then.
But now, nobody bats an eye anymore, and thinks it’s perfectly normal to spend that much on a house in previously economically depressed areas.
QE has impoverished us all (except for the fat bankers).
What is the black swan event that will finally trigger the stock market melt down? The price of SPY has gone exponential. A look at it, and it appears to defy gravity. But yet, everyone is celebrating on the streets it seems, as if the good times will finally last forever.