Saying land/housing prices are outpacing many other productive investments seems like a stretch. If you look at the performance of large US REIT ETFs versus market indices like the SPY the rent seeking behavior by real estate investors doesn't look so profitable.
And beside serious investors, for the typical individual, a home loan allows them to leverage funds that are unimaginably beyond what they could raise for investment with vastly more safety. Not that I suggest it would be better if half the population could and did buy stocks on unlimited margin or the like.
I just want to point out that even on this one particular issue, we gradually made policy and decided and made it such that one kind of loan is vital and the other insanely too risky. That at this point, this is so ingrained that it's hard to imagine any alternative. But I suggest we should probably try.
[1]: https://investor.vanguard.com/mutual-funds/profile/performan...
[2]: https://investor.vanguard.com/etf/profile/performance/vnq
This is a very important point. Buying real estate is the most accessible way for an average-income household to get leverage - at least in the US where heavily leveraged financial products like CFDs are not easily accessible (at least to my knowledge). But in my opinion this another argument against investing into real estate because lots of uninformed buyers are in the market with increasing amounts of leverage leading to rather dramatic boom and bust cycles (like in the housing crisis of 2008).
This is probably true. In the short-medium term housing will not be allowed to crash for the simple reason that homeowners vote. The soundness of the economy in general will be sacrificed to pump house prices.
This feeds a feedback loop that makes housing an even more attractive place to park capital, further driving up housing costs.
Of course eventually this gets so unbelievably ridiculous that we have some kind of revolution. Look for $2m starter homes before that happens.
There are two things you can influence either supply or demand. You're reducing supply but keeping demand the same or allowing it to grow. The answer is to increase supply and reduce demand.
The thing is, the places that are supply constrained have optimized themselves into being in extreme demand. They know they don't have enough housing but that doesn't stop them from building more commercial real estate to enable new businesses. Those businesses could have been founded somewhere else but why bother when the most suitable city still has enough room for you (but not for the employees)?
I don't understand why there aren't more employees demanding to move the company out of the state.
you are wrong and you do not know history. it will crash and then it will recover and then it will crash again. real estate is cyclical.
States, money and firms are now in a tight gridlock. Way more than before.
So will just pumping out more money. Fear the day "they" decide to flood the real market with money and not just stocks and shares.
So why are homes so expensive in urban areas, including now tier 2 and tier 3 cities, and not just NYC, DC, and SF?
Look at our population growth. In the 'good times' of the 1960s, we had 180M people. Now we have double that in two generations, or the difference between Boomers and Millenials approximately. In 1960, places like SF and Arlington, VA weren't rural farmland, they were still urban areas. We now have higher density in the large cities due to jobs having moved there, so we probably have 3x the number of people desiring homes in the same area as we had in 1960.
And families are smaller now. In 1960, you'd have a family of 5 in one house. Now you need two houses for the two 2.5 / person families.
So essentially we've probably got 4x the demand for the homes close to working centers, along with rising base prices due to far more women in the workforce. Add perpetual low interest rates, underreported inflation, and I'm surprised houses aren't at SF levels in every city yet.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_the_Uni...
The cost is directly related to the fact that it is defectors illegal to build new homes in the most economically vibrant zip codes.
Go back to the 70's, San Francisco was losing population. By the 90's it had dropped from a peak of 775K (1950) to 670K (1980). It's now ~880K, so only 14% higher than 70 years ago.
We have shifted to an economy that increasingly favors rent seeking in every field and land is quintessentially that. Even without that trend, land reform meets enormous resistance under any circumstances but given that shift, even more so now.
Note that we know people will endure housing conditions seen everywhere at all time up until the 20th century, and unless the people hurt[1] by this do something remarkably effective, that state of affairs is guaranteed to return: there is no invisible hand guaranteeing even one family per room let alone per unit.
[1] disproportionately wage earners and the young but also all paying rent and mortgage interest.