News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:46PM (#21694618)
I live in Seattle where the IPA thing is just out of hand.

My uncharitable pet theory is this: A certain class of men (sometimes women, but it's almost always men) get interested in something and then desire to make it part of their identity. That in turn means they want to convey that they are more into it than other people. Their passion expresses itself as competition.

Most people that aren't really into beer don't like hops and bitterness. It is very much an acquired taste. So liking hoppy beers is a good signal that "look how much more into beer I am than you!" Even better — and this is always a good signal that bros have shown up to suck the fun out of your hobby — there is a number you can use to measure it. Menus show IBUs so a table full of dudes can pick their poison and show how hardcore they are.

I like some amount of hops, but I've had beers that literally just taste like hop tea. The flavor just dominates everything else and leaves little room to enjoy all of the fun nuances you can get from the actual brew.

Before IPAs it was porters with the darker the better. Or Belgian beers with competitions to see who can handle the highest ABV. It's always about getting the best score and not just, you know, enjoying some beer.

My favorite Tweet ever was someone who described this process that dudes do where they show up, take over a hobby, and drive all the fun out (and thus women) as "MENTRIFICATION". It is my new favorite word.

See also: Riding bicycles, listening to music (ugh audiophiles), metal guitarists playing 64th note scales, etc. I can't wait for the day that bros discover knitting and it becomes nothing but a race to see who can make the longest scarves.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Enginerrrd on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:09PM (#21694868)
I feel like this is reading into it a bit much. I'm not that into beer, but I really like hoppy IPA's and always have. Even in high school / college, if the only option was cheap beer, I just wouldn't drink it because I didn't enjoy it. I preferred microbrew beers, and found that I didn't really like belgians/red ales/porters/etc. But I loved my first sip of a fresh Lagunitas IPA. I noticed that not all batches were the same with them. Sometimes it would have a lovely crispness and fruitiness, and sometimes that wasn't there. Isn't it possible that people just like hoppy beers? They seem to have quite a range of flavors and aromas they can offer in and of themselves.

I mean, I like coffee too and picked up that habit right quick in high school. I didn't do it because I was trying to be "manly", I did it because it was the only way I could pay attention to classes, and I rapidly came to like it. Coffee is bitter. So are grapefruits, and brussel sprouts and a lot of things that some people just enjoy.

Not everyone has to agree, and it doesn't need to get labeled as some kind of weird virtue signaling.

I do like the "mentrification" word though! Although it sounds like we differ in what I consider the "fun" in a hobby.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by spike021 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:07PM (#21698300)
I don't think the person you're replying to is making a blanket statement that anyone who drinks IPA's don't drink them because they like them but because of the image.

I think they're just trying to convey that there is a decent sized subset of beer drinkers who seem to drink IPA's for a reason much different from yours.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:55PM (#21696612)
Sure, I didn't mean to imply that all people who like hoppy beers do this. (I like IPAs too sometimes.) Just that some do, and they are loud and vocal enough that they influence the entire scene in ways that are a negative for others.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by erikpukinskis on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @09:14PM (#21699043)
Yeah, I still remember the first time a had a Bells Two-Hearted. It was bliss. I think some people just like bitter and some don’t.

That said, I can’t eat a straight grapefruit, even covered in sugar. Love a grapefruit soda though.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by lordgrenville on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:19PM (#21696262)
I have a theory that every subculture attracts two types of adherents: people who are genuinely enthusiastic about it and love introducing their passion to new people, and those looking for a way to set themselves apart, who primarily want to gatekeep and condescend to those not "in the know". It's easy to tell the two groups apart by their reaction when meeting a curious outsider.

It sounds like your description would firmly fit the second group. (It doesn't need to be gendered, although it does usually seem to be men who act this way.)

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:57PM (#21696623)
> I have a theory that every subculture attracts two types of adherents: people who are genuinely enthusiastic about it and love introducing their passion to new people, and those looking for a way to set themselves apart, who primarily want to gatekeep and condescend to those not "in the know".

Yes, definitely.

There are some who feel that their membership in the group is all they have and thus the more people in the group, the relatively less they are. Insecurity is the root of gatekeeping.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by walrus01 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:48PM (#21694636)
As an enthusiastic road cyclist I don't think there has ever been a time in modern history when the cohort of people who ride 10,000km+ a year for general conditioning/cardio/training, and spend $2,000+ on road bikes, wasn't gender ratio skewed by at least 85:15 towards men.

It is kind of unfortunate because there should really be nothing gender specific about cycling.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by davidw on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:32PM (#21695121)
Something I saw road biking in Italy vs in the US is that there is a vastly bigger 'casual' set of people doing it in Italy. It seems like that's less prevalent in the US; you're either really into it or not much at all.

It seems like this happens, sometimes in the US... for years beer in the US wasn't that great, and then there was this craft beer explosion, whereas in, say, Austria where I lived for a while, they are still drinking their local beers which are pretty good but don't have so much variety and experimentation.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by hencq on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:59PM (#21696643)
That's one of the first things I noticed when I moved to the US. Not sure if it's specific to the US or maybe just the Bay Area or even just a sign of the times, but it seems like it's impossible for people to "kind of like" something. They immediately have to be really into something, be it beer, cycling, photography, to the point where it becomes their entire identity. It doesn't bother me too much. I'm still happy just enjoying craft beers without memorizing different hop strains, but it's definitely a little odd.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by justinator on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:02PM (#21694795)
I think it's more about conventional gender roles, the gender pay gap, the fact that many women are scared to do things outside alone, than anything specifically manly about it.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by ehnto on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:11PM (#21694890)
Funnily enough I see lots of women on mountain bikes. I think mountain biking has a really clear delineation between fun and competition. Most mountain bikers have pretty relaxed attitudes, and very few compete. The goal is usually fun foremost. Compared to road cycling where it is more common to lean toward competition, personal performance and comparing to peers.

That said, I see it happening there too. Once bike prices started skyrocketing and it became quite a bit more popular, you can occasionally come across a bad personality on the trails. Still fairly rare though.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by ehnto on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:55PM (#21699705)
Reading this back it might seem like I don't think women compete, on the contrary, women's MTB series seem to be just as popular and competitive as the men's series and they seem to get just as much television time. I remember being impressed by the coverage the first time I watched the Enduro World Series coverage online. My main point was just that MTB as a whole is much less competitive and more welcoming overall than other cycling disciplines.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by justinator on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:11PM (#21705027)
I think it may be more that road cycling has a rep on exclusion for anything different than the status quo - they made a book about it, poking fun of it:

https://www.velominati.com/

Plenty of women around here bike commute, mtb, etc. Women are very vocal in these part on cycling rights and livable cities in general.

There's a women-owned bike shop that caters specifically to people who want to find car replacements in their lives. I'm very proud of them, so I have to share:

https://bikeshopgirl.com/

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:52PM (#21695322)
The body-saddle interface is gender specific. That is a problem for a lot of potential riders.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by walrus01 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:04PM (#21695447)
The last time I looked into this, specific to road bike saddles, Specialized and a few others had developed whole product lines and various widths of saddle sit-bone positions specific for female hips and anatomy.

But no matter how good a saddle is, for a person just starting with a "real" road bike, who has not been on a bike for many months or years, there's going to be a couple of weeks of discomfort before your posterior anatomy toughens up and you stop feeling some discomfort.

A couple of weeks of riding 20km a day at a very leisurely pace should do it. Once you get past that wall, a properly fit saddle should cause no discomfort at all.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:21PM (#21696277)
No amount of marketing will change human physiology.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:17PM (#21696241)
If you're going to spend that much on a bike, then the saddle is really only there for test rides. You'll replace it with your preferred one as soon as you buy it.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by jiofih on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:21PM (#21695648)
That’s gonna be the top 20% of commute distances, but plenty of men and women doing 10k+/year in Europe.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by jiofih on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @06:57AM (#21701429)
Why downvoted? That’s a 12km daily commute.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by microtherion on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:37PM (#21695819)
> A certain class of men (sometimes women, but it's almost always men) get interested in something and then desire to make it part of their identity. That in turn means they want to convey that they are more into it than other people. Their passion expresses itself as competition.

Absolutely! I'm seeing the same thing in chocolate, where people chase cocoa %ages, and spicy food, where people brag about how many Scoville Units they can handle.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:59PM (#21696642)
Oh, those are great examples too. And, again, you see it happening clearly because they managed to conjure up some weird-ass numeric score for it.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by scrumper on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:26PM (#21696893)
It's a fun and clever little label for a trend that's quite obvious when it's pointed out!

Someone upthread mentioned stinky cheese, dry wine, and peaty Islay Scotch. Those things don't yet have absolute metrics - it'd be amusing to see what happens if they ever do.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:53PM (#21697176)
The future is now. For wine, there's the "Total Polyphenol Index":

https://www.decanter.com/learn/advice/tannin-scale-ask-decan...

For peat in Scotch, the "phenol parts per million":

https://www.theyorkshiregent.com/whisky/the-scotch-whisky-pe...

Not sure if someone's found a way to game cheese yet.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by microtherion on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:34PM (#21697574)
"Listeria per cubic centimeter" might be a bit overly edgy.

Occasionally, I'm rather fond of Vacherin Mont d'Or, which in its original, raw milk based, recipe, is kind of the equivalent of Fugu for the landlocked.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by scrumper on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:47PM (#21697696)
Well apparently it's a bacterium called Brevibacterium linens that causes the stinky. So say the renowned biochemists at Readers' Digest magazine.

I've never tried your Swiss gloop but I am intrigued. One online seller claims that, "with one taste, [it] commands spontaneous exuberance." I wonder what form the exuberance takes? I will look out for it.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by scrumper on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:16PM (#21697409)
Wonderful.

Wikipedia sorely needs a page listing quantitative metrics of comestible qualia.

Inspired by those two, I went on a hunt for a cheese metric but the search results got rapidly unpleasant ("Why does it smell like Swiss cheese behind my ears?" was what made me finally close the tab.)

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by stock_toaster on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:28AM (#21700076)
ppm (phenol parts per million) is usually a reference to a "pre-distillation measurement" though, not the resultant distillate or the final aged product. Different run cut points (head/tails) heavily impact the amount of peat flavors that make it into the final distillate, as well as age (barrel time), cask activity, and.. probably barrel char too?

So while there is of course a rough correlation with ppm to final "peatiness", some scotches with slightly higher initial ppm may not end up tasting quite as "peaty" as some with slightly lower initial ppm may.

It does seem like PPM is being used "as marketing" in a few places these days though, which is probably to your point, and possibly a sign of things to come. :/

----

A more common thing I see/hear is people bragging about scotch age and price. Older is not always better! Too old, and you can certainly lose some delightful peat characteristics present in younger ages, or get too much cask influence.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by victor9000 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:11PM (#21694892)
The abundance of hops in beer is a west coast thing, as east coast beers tend to be more mild. So that's something to look into if west coast beers don't appeal to your palate. However, assigning a regional flavor to some sort of bravado seems odd. Do people say the same thing about a dry wine, a strong flavored cheese, or an Islay scotch? Of course not, so this seems more like a personal issue than anything else.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by amyjess on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:28PM (#21695074)
Honestly, discovering east coast beers actually made me like hops.

My experience with west coast beers convinced me that hops were awful and that my ideal bear would have _just_ enough hops to prevent spoilage and that's it. Which is why I drank nothing but Scotch ales, Belgian beers, and milk stouts for a long time. Eventually, I even started moving away from beer as I finally decided to give wine a chance.

And then I tried a New England-style hazy IPA, and I fell in love. It's hoppy, but it's not bitter. Most have 40 IBUs at the absolute most, and 30 is pretty common (and when it's 40, it's balanced out by enough malt that the bitterness isn't detectable). They taste like alcoholic orange juice (less harsh than a screwdriver, though). So nowadays I will drink every hazy, juicy, and milkshake IPA I can get my hands on. (Edit:) So it turns out I actually do like hops after all; I just hated what west coast beers did with them.

And milkshake IPAs really make a mockery of the original concept of an IPA: not only are they not bitter, but they're actively sweet because they have added lactose (which is an unfermentable sugar and thus directly contributes to sweetness). They're great if you really want an IPA for people who hate IPAs.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:03PM (#21695440)
I've toured a lot of eastern breweries tried countless east coast ipas. There certainly are plenty of ~40ibu ipas around. However, from my experience, you're most likely to find those at restaurants that are following the beer trends, slowly, and supermarkets. It's only been over the past couple years that most of my local shops started carrying mass produced double ipas besides arrogant bastard.

By and large the best places to get a good dipa is at the brewery. Most of favorites see very limited distribution and very small runs. Finding a triple ipa is a task on its own. Quality, and consistency is all over the place between breweries and batches. I've bought cans that've spoiled on the shelf. Some breweries have purchase limits because enterprising folk have filled vans with cases of beer to resell in other states.

Sours, like hill farmsteads ales, but more tart, have seen a resurgence. Stouts are still waning in popularity. Pilsners have a place in most long running breweries list as a fallback for those with less experienced or more traditional palates.

I've grown fond of strong kombuchas >3% abv, goses, dry ciders, and randalled brews that have been cropping up lately. I've also had quite a few beers made with teas that have been great. Don't write off meads or gruits either.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:26PM (#21695711)
> The abundance of hops in beer is a west coast thing, as east coast beers tend to be more mild

I'm not sure about that. The "New England IPA" style comes from well, Vermont. And when done well is is a smooth, creamy intense hop milkshake.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by victor9000 on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @12:22PM (#21704304)
Sure, if a specific style calls for a pile of hops then of course it will end up very hoppy. But generally speaking, your average west coast beer will be more hoppy than its east cost counterpart.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2019 @03:30AM (#21710790)
A specific, extremely popular style that literally has "east coast" in the name.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by victor9000 on Thursday December 05, 2019 @09:18PM (#21718737)
Sure, but think outside the scope of a single style. If you compare two pale ales from each region, the west coast pale will undoubtedly be more hoppy than the east coast version. To the point where many west coast pales can easily pass for an east coast ipa.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by ljm on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:42PM (#21695218)
It feels a little cynical. You can enjoy beer and music and stuff without getting into a dick measuring contest. If all they want to do is one-up you then they’re not your friend. Find someone who listens to you.

If that’s their way of enjoying things, then what’s so bad about it? They presumably dislike a lot of the hobbies you enjoy, they’re not out there to ‘mentrify’ them. (Why this gendered insulting is okay when it’s aimed against men, I don’t know.)

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by paggle on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:08PM (#21696168)
Turning things into competitions often has extremely negative externalities. The desire to be the richest, or have the biggest house, or the fastest car, or drink the most alcohol, etc... destroys lives. And this kind of status scrambling is not exclusive to men.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:28PM (#21697532)
Competition is why our modern standard of living is what it is. People seeking to do things better, faster and cheaper in order to make a buck (or even just for the bragging rights) in order to improve their own personal standard of living gives us electric lighting, oranges in February, the massive amount of infrastructure it takes to get this comment from my fingertips to your eyeballs and every other part of modern life you don't notice but would notice if it were missing. Yes there's externalities but at a societal scale we do a pretty decent job of playing whack-a-mole as they become critical.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by shkkmo on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @10:31PM (#21699353)
> Competition is why our modern standard of living is what it is.

Yet you can say the exact same thing about cooperation. I would argue that cooperation is atleast as critical an ingredient here as competition. Indeed, the infrastructure that allows me to view the comment you posted depends on open standards, open source software and generally could not have existed without groups of people working together to accomplish goals.

I would personally say that cooperation, freedom and passion are more important than competition, greed and ego in terms of enabling the accomplishments of our society.

That is not to say that competition has no role to play, but it is part of a melange of human dynamics that are necessary. Specifically, competition works best between between groups of freely cooperating individuals, especially when those groups can periodically set aside that competition to cooperatively further the goals of their mutual passions and dreams.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Chris2048 on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @07:37AM (#21701620)
> cooperation, freedom and passion are more important than competition, greed and ego

These things aren't mutually exclusive. You can compete as a team and with the help of friends.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by ljm on Saturday December 07, 2019 @10:04PM (#21734115)
I see what you're both getting at and to me it's a case of the life you want to live.

Ego isn't going away any time soon, and you will never know anyone who has renounced their ego, because only ego wants you to share that.

Competition can be a lot of fun, so that's ok. As long as it's not driven by jealousy or envy.

Greed - we all have psychological impulses that make us think that one thing is not enough and we need more of it. Most of us do that now through our careers. Including me, I'm still pushing for the bigger paycheck.

Greed and ego can easily be symptomatic of unstoppable freedom and passion. We sometimes call that perfectionism and it's a curse.

All in all, it's not as simple as it looks unless your ego tells you that it's actually that simple for you. In which case...

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by shkkmo on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @08:45AM (#21702070)
Of course they aren't mutually exclusive. Did you read where I acknowledge that competition is an important and useful dynamic? I just think that competition is fundementally less important than cooperation.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Chris2048 on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:15AM (#21703424)
You also said "competition works best between between groups of freely cooperating individuals", but why? What's wrong with competing alone? It's still coeperation on a societal scale, e.g competing as an individual in a competition is still co-operating with the competition itself.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by shkkmo on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:45AM (#21703779)
> What's wrong with competing alone?

Nothing rong, per se, but there are limits to what individuals can do on their own. When you eliminate groups of cooperating individuals, there are much lower limits to what can be accomplished. Specifically when taking about the achievements of society, most enterprises require the efforts of cooperating groups. I feel like this is blatantly evident and doesn't require explanation.

> It's still coeperation on a societal scale, e.g competing as an individual in a competition is still co-operating with the competition itself.

I think you are mangling the definition of 'cooperation" here. It certainly is possible to compete and cooperate simultaneously (often by strictly limiting the scope of the competition and by sharing knowledge), but that doesn't mean that competing is cooperation. Even so, within that "societal scale" competition, the best results are achieved by groups that operate with either no or greatly limited internal competition.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Chris2048 on Thursday December 05, 2019 @07:22AM (#21711750)
> but that doesn't mean that competing is cooperation

If you take part in a competition, you are cooperating with its organisers in making the event happen.

> there are much lower limits to what can be accomplished

We are talking about small achievments though, e.g opening a brewery.

If I read a book about that, am I cooperating with its author? If not, plenty is possible without cooperation; If so, lots can be achieved via indirect cooperation.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:54PM (#21696602)
> You can enjoy beer and music and stuff without getting into a dick measuring contest.

Sure, and most do, across genders.

> If that’s their way of enjoying things, then what’s so bad about it?

Every act tends to have social/economic implications that affect how others participate, even if unintentional. Walk into a bar now, and often eight out of the ten taps are high IBU IPAs. Fewer choices for people that aren't into the hops competition.

Some people will be rude to others who don't want to play the competitive game.

> (Why this gendered insulting is okay when it’s aimed against men, I don’t know.)

Men collectively have enough power to handle a funny critical term without risk of being marginalized.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by CDSlice on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:16PM (#21696801)
>> (Why this gendered insulting is okay when it’s aimed against men, I don’t know.)

> Men collectively have enough power to handle a funny critical term without risk of being marginalized.

What does men collectively have enough power even mean? It's not like all the men in the world work together to decide the fate of all the poor, powerless women. Where is black men's power? Where is the homeless white men's power? And why should risk of being marginalized factor into it? Insulting a very large fraction of humanity for the actions of a small subset shouldn't be OK no matter who it is. Would insulting all Muslims for the actions of a few fringe sects be OK? I mean, they should collectively have enough power to handle it, they even run whole countries!

Decry the actions of bros all you want, but why expand that to saying all men do this as "mentrification" implies? Doing so is both inaccurate and hurtful to many people for no reason other than feeling smug that some man (who most likely isn't very privileged) finally got their comeuppance.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by vict00ms on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:46PM (#21697087)
I don't think it implies that all men do this at all. It also seems like a much more palatable expression/term than "dick-measuring contest".
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by guywhocodes on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:17PM (#21698723)
Is this the "men is short for bogeymen and thus not the same as any other collectivisation"-argument or an argument that they did not mean what they said?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by dropofwill on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @10:26PM (#21699334)
Seems like being a man is necessary, but not sufficient to be a part of mentrificafion. Just like gentrification doesn’t imply that all the gentry are involved in it.

But mostly it’s a pun.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by larnmar on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:01PM (#21697257)
But it seems to collectively place the blame on all men, rather than the minority who are interested in dick-measuring contests.

And not only is this unfair, it’s silly. Brewing has always been an almost exclusively male hobby, the rise of the hop nerd is nothing to do with sex at all, contrary to what the word might imply.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by mumblemumble on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:42PM (#21697648)
I would also be willing to believe that the, for lack of a better term, dick-measuring, isn't something that men inherently do more; we're just primed to see it that way due to sexist stereotypes. And/or they get away with it more easily 'cuz hegemony.

Evidences:

At quilting shows, numeric boasting is also common - number of hours, number of pieces, number of spools of thread, I've even seen a count of the number of broken quilting needles.

Carbon fiber knitting needles are a thing. I own some. The packaging talks about how carbon fiber is also used in aerospace. (In case, I dunno, you need to get those puppies moving through the air really fast, maybe?)

My grandmother's approach to baking Christmas cookies.

(That said, MENTRIFICATION is a hilarious term, I chuckled out loud, and I will be using it in the future, with only moderate fear that doing so will emasculate me or invert the patriarchy, and minor hope that people who like to complain about political correctness will be offended on political grounds.)

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by dropofwill on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:48PM (#21697707)
The point is that this is a general trend in culture not specifically brewing. That’s why they ended with the example of knitting, they even included the parenthetical disclaimer that it’s not always men.

Mentrification is just a clever play on words.

The actual observation definitely rings true for me. I remember as a middle schooler not wanting to admit i was learning guitar until i was ’good enough’.

I think this is definitely tied to identity. Something that you can work at and see demonstrable progress is comforting in a way, but i can see how it easily leads to passion as competition.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by whatshisface on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:09PM (#21696729)
I hereby exert my collective power and order you to stop using words that start with man, except for management and manual.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by eckza on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:46PM (#21697088)
Is that... mandatory?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by larnmar on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:55PM (#21697207)
> Men collectively have enough power to handle a funny critical term without risk of being marginalized

Even to the extent this is true, it’s a poisonous attitude, responsible for a lot of acrimony in society today, and I urge you to reconsider it.

The attitude of “you can punch up but not down” leads to a lot more punching, especially when members of the group you’ve declared as “up” start getting sick of being punched and decide to punch back.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Jamwinner on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:17PM (#21698731)
Everyone likes to feel like they are above some other class of people. 'Nazis', FWMs, and Politicians must not even be human, much less deserving of baseline human respect or rights, based on the comments I see here. Its a huge problem.

You can't 'hate on hate' without becoming the hater you hated.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by cowpig on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:08PM (#21694855)
I feel like I see all those same things and feel happy for the people involved, that they are finding something that they feel a passion for.

I also sometimes feel disdain and judgment towards other peoples' interests, (pop music, for example) but I feel more and more as I get older that that those feelings do not serve me (or anyone else) in any positive way.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by anm89 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:19PM (#21696828)
My uncharitable pet theory is this: a certain class of people who are deeply unhappy with themselves don't like to see other people enjoying things they don't like or understand because they themselves have not filled this void in their own lives. Because these people need to seek out confirmation from a larger group on everything they do to compensate for their own lack of of self perceived self worth, and because gender or race are the largest groups available, they need to frame everything in term of a group struggle regarding race or gender to guarantee there is a built in audience to cheer them on at every step and reaffirm their worth and place in the social hierarchy.

It's gross.

Also I hate IPAs.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by streb-lo on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:26PM (#21696322)
>My uncharitable pet theory is this: A certain class of men (sometimes women, but it's almost always men) get interested in something and then desire to make it part of their identity. That in turn means they want to convey that they are more into it than other people. Their passion expresses itself as competition.

So hacker news and technophiles? Good grief you sound worse than the people you are criticizing. Heaven forbid people like something.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by zrobotics on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:15PM (#21696792)
Liking a hobby/activity isn't a problem. The problem is when people start gatekeeping (such as "no real programmer uses Javascript", etc). For instance, I like whisky, but I actively hate most whisky aficionados because it often just turns into a competition of "who bought the rarest/most expensive bottle" rather than "I like this brand/year". This behavior definitely occurs in the tech sphere (I've been judged for using Windows, since no real programmer would possibly be able to use anything besides mac/linux), but this behavior is always obnoxious and drives people away from activities.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by abathur on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:38PM (#21697002)
I guess the inverse is: heaven forbid people like something without letting their passion curdle into possessive competition with other people who try to like it?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by uxp100 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:14PM (#21695566)
> My favorite Tweet ever was someone who described this process that dudes do where they show up, take over a hobby, and drive all the fun out (and thus women) as "MENTRIFICATION". It is my new favorite word.

So you think that less women ride bicycles and drink beer than 20 years ago?

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by SlowRobotAhead on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:58PM (#21696075)
Definitely the opposite.

Just as OP complains about bros getting to into things like beer as their identity, maybe the fail to realize that other people make their identities about real or perceived social injustices and how awesome they are to bring them up a every chance maybe not realizing that's more annoying.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by optimuspaul on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:21PM (#21696276)
This.

I definitely see a certain culture of men that glom onto things like beer or bicycles or coding and making that their identity. It is because of this that they are seen as "Mentrifying" those hobbies. I do think that there is some risk in those groups alienating those without the same passion from becoming involved in those hobbies. In fact one of the reasons I don't golf anymore is exactly this. Golf culture is intensly insular and full of arrogant people (not to say that all are this way or maybe it has changed since I last golfed).

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by meddlepal on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:21PM (#21698382)
I think the key to enjoying golf is to learn to play by yourself or play with people that aren't interested in competition.

I agree "golf people" are insufferable that's why I avoid them as much as possible.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by optimuspaul on Thursday December 05, 2019 @10:29PM (#21719047)
totally, but hard to get a course to yourself. To be clear it isn't the people I am playing with but the others on the course at the same time.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by jcims on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:52PM (#21698581)
There should be a scoring system for wokeness. That will really open the throttle.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by ratww on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:19PM (#21695614)
Oh, this applies to anything.

At my last job the competition for a few months was who had the largest vimfile. And if you used other editor you weren't manly enough, of course.

People will complain, but dudebros are able to suck the fun out of anything. And the professionalism.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by bagacrap on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:16PM (#21696233)
When exactly did dudes "show up" to "riding bicycles" and "drive all the fun out"?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by kalleboo on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:38PM (#21699617)
I don't know about "driving all the fun out", but whenever riding a bike comes up in conversations with Americans, they seem to assume that you need to go full-spandex, $1000 racing bike with all the accessories just for your commute. I always assumed this was because in the US, riding a bike is a weird, dangerous activity, so the only people who did it was complete weirdos, but I could also see it being a dudebro cultural thing ("making [your method of commute] your identity" as the other poster put it)
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by enra on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:04PM (#21694824)
As a personal preference, I do prefer IPAs just for the taste. I do drink other beers too but anything short of Pale Ale, feels weak and doesn't give similar weight.

There are lot of variance between different IPAs and Pale Ales, I prefer more citrus and mosaic ones. My favorite is Sculpin IPA and Wolfback Ridge IPA and my least favorite is probably Racer 5 even thought its generally highly rated.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by devchix on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:10PM (#21695538)
Amen! But don't say it so loud lest they call us poseurs. :) My favorite is one is called Resin, made by SixPoint Brewery out of Brooklyn. Just like the name, the nose is floral like pine sap, it's lovely. My other favorite is made by The Maine Beer Company, MO is a terrific, well-balanced Pale Ale, Another One (that's its name) is a 5% ABV IPA, also lovely. It's not just a west coast thing, good IPA brewers and drinkers are everywhere, and we don't just do it to out-men the men.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by rc-1140 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:59PM (#21695399)
I agree with the content of your message, as I have seen it happen many times myself first-hand, but I disagree with the way you're framing the phenomenon.

> My favorite Tweet ever was someone who described this process that dudes do where they show up, take over a hobby, and drive all the fun out (and thus women) as "MENTRIFICATION". It is my new favorite word.

I believe that this is a loaded word that does nothing but churn the online gender conflict machine propagated by places like (surprise) Twitter. It doesn't highlight a type of person as the cause, it highlights a gender. The Meaningness article concerning "mops", the "mop invasion", and the "sociopaths" that follow[0] is overall a more accurate representation of what happens when a hobby, craft, or culture is co-opted like this.

[0] https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:55PM (#21697200)
Yes, that's all entirely fair. But the word nerd part of me can't help but be delighted by the absolutely perfect pun of "mentrification". It just... it's like the second you read the word its meaning leaps into your mind. It perfectly extends the metaphor of "gatekeeping".
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by tonyarkles on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @06:20PM (#21697971)
Thanks for posting that! I was immediately reminded of that article but couldn't remember any of names of the groups or find the article.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by reitzensteinm on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @06:22PM (#21697991)
If we're going to draw arbitrary circles around groups of people, I think this is just as much of an American phenomenon as it is a male one.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by hirsin on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:03PM (#21697286)
Sample size a couple dozen only, but IBU on the menu has also been helpful to non-IPA drinkers I know, so they can avoid things they don't enjoy. It's also trended locally (Ballard) towards golf - see Reuben's releasing a zero-ibu IPA.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:17PM (#21698360)
Yeah, I agree listing the IBU is useful even for people who want low IBU.

But the reason that's even an issue in the first-place is because of grandstanding hop-heads pushing the upper limit so high that a casual drinker selecting a brew at random has an increased chance of getting something they'd find completely unpalatable.

It's like hot sauce. You didn't need to put the Scoville units on the menu until people started making hot sauces that would peel the lining off your digestive tract. But they didn't start making those hot sauces until people started measuring and talking about Scoville units as the only metric worth caring about.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by AareyBaba on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:40PM (#21696475)

  ABV = Alcohol by Volume
  IBU = International Bitterness Units
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by mc3 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:35PM (#21696978)
Yes this is definitely a thing. I haven't seen it in beer personally, but I have seen it in other walks of like.

Programming for instance "I worked on a 1M LoC system" "Mine was 10M LoC", or "I worked on a 1000 requests per second" "Aah that's nothing, we got 1M requests per second" etc.

Fitness is an obvious one. Especially now your can track your average minutes per mile and all that shit on your phone. It is much more enjoyable just going out for a jog and fuck the metrics.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by mersenne on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:12PM (#21699506)
Reminds me of that Monty Python skit about the Yorkshiremen competing on who grew up the poorest.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by hnick on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:11AM (#21700005)
I think spicy food (as in, more Scovilles) is an obvious analogue there too.

I don't judge since taste is subjective, but I made the decision to cut back on chilies a few years ago when I realised it was getting in the way of enjoying the food. Up until then it was almost a personal challenge just to see where I could push it, for no real reason.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by whatshisface on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:04PM (#21696684)
Is competition and quantitative thinking exclusive to one gender?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by regulation_d on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:56PM (#21698946)
I think an interesting counterpoint here is that people are doing different things with hops now than they were a decade ago. Most of the really hoppy stuff I've had lately has been heavily dry hopped with little bittering hops during the boil. The result is juicy rather than over-the-top bitter. I would wager that average IPA these days has much lower IBUs than the average IPA did 10 years ago.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by joe_the_user on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @09:01PM (#21698975)
Is "juicy" different from Citrus-y? Most of the IPAs I happen to taste lately taste something like bitter grapefruit soda but I'd be interested in trying something actually new.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by taneq on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @10:57PM (#21699450)
> That in turn means they want to convey that they are more into it than other people. Their passion expresses itself as competition.

You see the same with coffee. "I love coffee!" "Well I love it MORE so I don't put sugar in it." "Well I love it EVEN MORE so I drink it black." "Well I love it EVEN MORE THAN YOU so I only drink black espresso with six shots a cup!"

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by tomcooks on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:09AM (#21699994)
I wonder where women are allowed to compete, according to this world view of yours. Hair care and nail polish? Or cooking maybe? Ah no wait, knitting is THE TRADE for women in your opinion.

Maybe this thing you complain about isn't something that people do, not just (American)(young)(white)(rich) males.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by starpilot on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:19PM (#21696259)
https://brokeassstuart.com/2018/01/29/stop-pretending-like-i...

Taste is a weird thing. People hate bitter coffee, but seem to worship bitter beers.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by apr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:30PM (#21696362)
That's a broad and unsubstantiated statement about coffee. Personally I love bitter coffee.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by Smithalicious on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:33AM (#21701082)
I don't think "hipsters exist" is a particularly novel theory and I especially don't see how any of this is a gendered issue that requires some kind of anti-men rant.

I also think it's not very nice to accuse people of not actually enjoying their hobbies.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by afarrell on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:47PM (#21698550)
Note that its also possible to approach things as a competition without driving all the fun out of it. You just have to:

1) Admit that you're taking it farther than necessary because you get joy/fulfillment from the competition.

2) Appreciate and welcome the non-competitive hobbyists.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by golergka on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @12:48AM (#21699913)
I don't know much about beer, but this reminds me so much of whisky peat and record-breaking Octomore releases.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by asdf21 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:43PM (#21697655)
Let me frame that in a way that might make you feel less... disgusted apparently.

Men used to primarily compete at killing one another and general conquest -- these all seem like fairly harmless alternatives comparatively.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by tomatotomato37 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:49PM (#21696550)
A very similar theory to geek/mop evolution of subcultures:

https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by elhudy on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:20PM (#21698375)
damn you guys are really overthinking it. I just like drinking bitter, floral, piney beer.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by oh_sigh on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:49PM (#21695293)
Women don't listen to music because men shows up and liked music too much?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by ssully on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:11PM (#21696198)
I think the poster is more saying men come in and make liking the music a competition, which from my experience is a very real thing. I have absolutely run into people the poster is describing, and unfortunately was friends with people like that for awhile. It wasn't "liking music too much"; they would act superior about music and tried to lay down what was "good" music to play/listen to. It is an incredibly narrow minded view and it is even worse when they are competitive about it.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by oh_sigh on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:42PM (#21697037)
How does one subset of an audience viewing something as a competition affect other subsets of the audience? Has any woman ever said "Boy, I wish I could like show tunes more, but there are just too many men who view Norwegian speed metal as the only real music"
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by dnhz on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:16PM (#21698722)
The original example was not listening to music but audiophilia. The segment of music listeners that buy super-oxygen-free cables, tube amps, and expensive speakers seems to be heavily male-skewed.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by oh_sigh on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @10:54PM (#21699441)
Is there any evidence that women are being turned away from music in general or even audiophilia because of this?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by anewguy9000 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @07:01PM (#21698266)
daddy issues?
[dead]
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by walrus01 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:55PM (#21694729)
Making a neutral observation that various activities have a high proportion of dudebros, and declaring that only men should participate in said activities are two different things.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by rsync on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:43PM (#21695231)
Actually, your parent is correct: it is sexist.

It makes a distinction based on sex. It is sexism.

It is not, however, negative, as your parent implied.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by criddell on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:40PM (#21695860)
I've never heard sexist used to just indicate a distinction by sex.

Google tells me sexist means:

> characterized by or showing prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex

That sounds negative to me.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by rsync on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:15PM (#21696790)
I didn't ask google - I looked it up in the M-W dictionary:

1 : prejudice or discrimination based on sex

... and "discrimination" is what the op expressed. It is a synonym for "distinction":

Discrimination: 2 : the quality or power of finely distinguishing

Discrimination is not necessarily negative - I suspect you hold many discriminating views on all number of topics be they wine, television shows, musical groups, etc. I personally hope to continue to become more and more discriminating as I learn and grow.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by criddell on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:38PM (#21696996)
That's a real stretch...

Can you find a non-negative definition for prejudice?

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by homonculus1 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:57PM (#21696067)
It is negative. "Mentrification", just like "mansplaining" and "manspreading", is loaded, pejorative, and exists to define a behavior as bad and exclusively male. Play around with sexist attitudes if you like but let's not be coy about it.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by skyyler on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:57PM (#21694741)
Please include more substance with your allegations.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by oh_sigh on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:47PM (#21697112)
A challenge: Attribute in a comment any negative trait to a non-white, non-male group in a similar manner to OP to and see if your comment can stay non-grayed out.

In modern society, one is allowed to point out 'failings' of groups, such as low STEM enrollment rates for women, or high crime rates among African American males, but only if you also point out that these failings are the fault of whites/men. Whites and men are the only group whose failings are intrinsic and without some outside blame.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by seiferteric on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:52PM (#21694682)
How?
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by tasogare on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:01PM (#21694785)
> My favorite Tweet ever was someone who described this process that dudes do where they show up, take over a hobby, and drive all the fun out (and thus women) as "MENTRIFICATION". It is my new favorite word.

You seemed to have missed that part.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by seiferteric on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:06PM (#21694850)
I don't think it is inherently sexist to suggest that men or woman may exhibit certain behaviors more than the other. I am not sure when we crossed the line that making any such suggestion is inherently sexist.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by uxp100 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:26PM (#21695703)
"Mentrification" suggests that men enter women's hobbies and ruin them. It also suggests that there is a right and wrong way to engage with things (See conversations about how men and women engage with fiction differently, analysis vs elaboration, power rankings vs fan-fiction, etc).

Rather than saying the word "mentrification" is sexist, which is a complex question (like nobody is being hurt because someone on twitter comes up with a funny phrase), I'd rather say, if someone used mentrification in earnest, they're probably a shitty person and I don't want to hang out with them.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by seiferteric on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:52PM (#21695997)
I agree that Mentrification is not the right word. The OP was implying it can happen in hobbies already dominated by men, not just hobbies dominated by woman. Perhaps Brotrification would be better.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by scrumper on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:28PM (#21696910)
Which'd then lose the clever linkage to "metrification" which is what it's all about.
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by seiferteric on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:46PM (#21697099)
pretty sure it was a play on gentrification
Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by giggles_giggles on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:14PM (#21695570)
It's pretty sexist to imply that only men exhibit this particular form of gatekeeping or making men in the minority of some hobby group feel out of place, and then coining a term for it with "men" right in the name, as though women never do what is described.

Complain about some subset of the population who has made a lifestyle choice you don't like (bros) all you want. But "mentrification"? Give me a break. That's just a prejudicial slur.

Re:So You Think You Want to Open a Brewery (2014) by hnaccy on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:14PM (#21696782)
>I don't think it is inherently sexist to suggest that men or woman may exhibit certain behaviors more than the other.

Cue James Damore.