News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by mieseratte on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:15PM (#21065714)
For the life of me I don’t understand why government funded institutions run their own tribunals. Send it through the proper court system, if the accused is guilty you can expel them cleanly.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Lazare on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:40PM (#21066381)
If I run a startup, and one of my employees is making other employees uncomfortable, and he keeps getting accused of harassing other employees, and is generally just making some of my best engineers unhappy, hurting productivity, and ruining our carefully constructed culture...

...I can fire him. I mean, obviously I need to go through the proper HR procedures, follow local employment law, respect the terms of his contract, etc., but I have no obligation to keep him employed if I think he's a net negative to my company. Arguably I have an obligation to not keep him employed. And I certainly have no requirement to wait until he has been convicted of a crime; it's not even clear any of the above is a crime.

Similarly, if I run a resort, and one of the guests is so unpleasant they're driving away other guests, or if I run a restaurant, and one of the guests is making other guests uncomfortable, or I run an apartment building, and one of the tenants is behaving poorly.

A university is a business. People come and pay money in exchange for a service, and if someone is interfering with the ability of other people to receive that service, or making people reluctant to come and pay money, it's perfectly fine for them to be asked to leave. If what they're doing happens to be a crime, then by all means, also report them to the police, but it's kind of odd to suggest that you shouldn't expel students except if they've been convicted of a crime.

That being said, I think universities are doing a terrible job here, and I think that given the extreme importance of a university education in modern life, the disruption that being expelled entails, and the stigma that will follow someone if they are expelled, we need to be very careful about the process here. My local dollar store will ban you from the store if they think you shoplifted, and I assume they get it wrong sometimes, but it's fine, because being unjustly banned from a dollar store does not ruin your life. Being unjustly expelled from university could! Things are broken and need fixing. But a world where you can only be expelled on conviction of a crime makes no sense either. The discussion need to be about the correct amount of protection needed.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by ellius on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:33PM (#21067030)
"A university is a business."

This is a massive false equivalence. For one thing, most of the "employees" in your metaphor are eighteen to twenty-two years old. Not to mention the fact that students are regularly put through the ringer and expelled on the first accusation. It's hardly akin to the "repeat offense" scenario you outlined in your first example. And comparing being expelled for an alleged sexual assault to being asked to leave a resort for rude behavior? Come on.

This is a different situation than anything you described. Universities have much more of a guardian and stewardship role than an employer, and rape is a fucking crime. It should be handled by the mechanism we've created to handle crimes, i.e. criminal courts of law.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by lainga on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:31PM (#21067341)
Employees come to a business and exchange their money for goods and services?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by ellius on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:27AM (#21071089)
An apple is red, and your underwear are red, so you should eat your underwear.

The fact that two things share a superficial attribute does not make them equivalent.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by klipt on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:00PM (#21066499)
In the workplace dating coworkers is generally frowned upon.

At a university, dating other students is so commonplace that a large portion of people meet their spouses that way.

Title IX may want to treat dating at universities with the same disdain as in the workplace, but it's not going to be an easy cultural shift.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Lazare on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:13AM (#21067530)
> In the workplace dating coworkers is generally frowned upon.

And at a restaurant, being in a relationship with a fellow patron is quite common. Similarly, no legal or cultural ban against dating your room mate when you rent a house (much to the relief of married couples everywhere).

Students are (mostly) not employees of the university, but they are customers of educational services and (quite often) tenants. A university has a number of relationships to students, and a number of responsibilities, both to the (alleged) predators and to the larger student body.

I mentioned a startup situation in the hopes it would seem relevant to many here (surely we've all had at least one co-worker that was disruptive?), but trying to view this purely through the lens of employment law will get you nowhere.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by weberc2 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:04AM (#21070860)
Universities are paid largely by federal student loans and tax dollars. This is not a standard business/patron agreement. Expelling a student $50K in debt can ruin their life. The university owes them a fair trial. And there is no excuse for the overt discrimination or other shenanigans we’re seeing.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by closeparen on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:07AM (#21067777)
Not sure about the validity of the poll, but by at least one indication 15% of couples meet at work vs. 6% at school.

https://www.reportlinker.com/insight/finding-love-online.htm...

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Udik on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @06:32AM (#21069384)
The amount of couples forming at work before starting to work (i.e. while in college) is probably approaching zero.

This is to say that of course the poll at age 40 gives a very different result from the same poll at age 25.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by cameldrv on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:06AM (#21068446)
Weirdly, the situation is exactly the opposite of what you describe. You might say "hey, it's a private organization, they should be free to make their own rules about who they choose to serve." Many businesses before the civil rights act made exactly the same argument as they excluded African Americans as customers. This type of discrimination was made illegal.

The strange thing is that it is precisely this type of law that has created this situation. The Feds assert that if a university does not apply these extraordinarily dubious adjudication rules for sexual harassment and rape, then it is discriminating against women and is subject to losing any federal funding, including student loans, which effectively shuts down the university.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by learc83 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:00PM (#21066830)
Most Universities are non-profit, and almost all of them take Federal money. Classifying them as a business isn't accurate.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Lazare on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:19AM (#21067560)
> Most Universities are non-profit,

You're still a business if you're a non-profit.

> Almost all of them take Federal money

You're still a business if you accept government contracts.

> Classifying them as a business isn't accurate.

I mean, they act like businesses, and in most cases they very explicitly legally are businesses. They accept money in exchange for services. If not a business, what would you classify them as?

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by learc83 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:04PM (#21075446)
>and in most cases they very explicitly legally are businesses.

By that definition every nearly single non-governmental organization is explicitly legally a business, so stating that an organization is a "business" is meaningless.

A church, a soup kitchen, and fraternal lodge are also explicitly legally businesses as well, but it's not useful to classify them alongside for profit businesses.

Many very well off schools don't even charge students who make below a certain income, and the vast majority of their operating expenses come from donations--saying they charge money in exchange for a service isn't a very useful description of what they do.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by tomp on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:48AM (#21069204)
More importantly, people get paid to work for a business but pay to attend a university.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by _emacsomancer_ on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:19PM (#21067284)
Universities are not businesses. If they're being run like businesses...they're not serving a function as University any longer.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by kerkeslager on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:39AM (#21068306)
Universities should not be run like businesses, but that doesn't mean they aren't.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by oijqoiwejoiqwj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:53PM (#21067456)
>...I can fire him. I mean, obviously I need to go through the proper HR procedures, follow local employment law, respect the terms of his contract, etc., but I have no obligation to keep him employed if I think he's a net negative to my company. Arguably I have an obligation to not keep him employed. And I certainly have no requirement to wait until he has been convicted of a crime; it's not even clear any of the above is a crime.

This would be a valid comparison if the company in question were receiving massive amounts of federal funding, in which case, I would say yes the accused _does_ have a reasonable expectation of fair treatment. Why? Well the accused is also paying for the regulatory system in question.

It's not really possible to deny that these universities receive "massive amounts of federal funding" either, considering that receiving federal funding is the explicit motivation of performing these title IX tribunals in the first place.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by mlthoughts2018 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:43PM (#21066745)
What if employee A makes up lies about employee B, and the reason a bunch of other people feel uncomfortable or unproductive or unhappy around employee B is just based on perception from these lies?

Are you in the right as an employer to fire employee B without serious due diligence? To potentially ruin employee B’s life or reputation? Instead of letting it escalate to a real court case (if applicable)?

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by BearsAreCool on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @08:56AM (#21070277)
I see nothing wrong with asking guests to leave, and honestly not that much with expelling students as there are plenty of universities out there. At my local university I am attending I recently completed a mandatory course on plagiarism and it would supposedly dish out the following punishments:

-Failing you from classes you are in with 0 refund.

-Permanent mark on your academic transcript you supposedly can't escape.

-Having to report to future employers you plagiarized.

Which is essentially asking guests to leave and utterly destroying half a decade of their lives and tens of thousands of their dollars in many cases. This is the part I take issue with. The dollar store you shoplifted from according to one "witness" has now come into your house, took all the groceries in it, and beat up your fridge.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by weberc2 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:57AM (#21070800)
Public universities certainly don’t get to claim treatment as a business. Additionally, like you were driving at, it is dramatically more damaging to be expelled from a university than to be kicked out of a dollar general. And most importantly, if the business’s policy is clearly a thin veil of pretense that allows them to discriminate on the basis of gender (or any other protected category), they are not within their rights. We don’t tolerate businesses asking black patrons (or employees) to leave because a white patron claimed they felt uncomfortable, and we certainly wouldn’t tolerate it from a public institution. And we definitely shouldn’t tolerate it given that universities make students fundamentally more vulnerable than business patrons or standard employees by saddling them with debts that would take them their whole lifetime to pay off if not for a degree. Due process and equitable treatment is not too much to ask.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by analog31 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:28AM (#21067603)
>>> A university is a business

Most universities and businesses (corporations) are government chartered and entitled enterprises.

And students can already be expelled without being convicted of a crime, e.g., if they get bad grades.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by FakeComments on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:17PM (#21066607)
Universities aren’t always a business, they’re often government institutions.

A state organization is legally bound to offer certain equal rights and due process protections, which is one of the trade-offs of having state schools.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by scarmig on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:14PM (#21066590)
The court system is a very rigid structure. It's costly, and in the USA inherently has components that make it ineffective to addressing rape accusations, particularly the right to cross examine the accuser and how a good defense attorney will use that right. Oftentimes a victim doesn't want to go through that process and is mostly interested in not having to be confronted with their rapist every day.

That doesn't mean anything, one way or another, about how well these university tribunals work. It's just pointing out deficiencies in the existing court system.

Another way to think of it is balancing false negatives and false positives. The court system, ideally, errs on the side of minimizing false positives, because of how damaging they are for the accused. That inherently means more false negatives, and aspects of the process that are also much more burdensome for victims to navigate. Universities are trying to create an alternative system, where more false positives are accepted and consequences are less severe, and more focused on making sure the victim doesn't have to confront their rapist in day-to-day life than on life-altering consequences for the accused or protecting the public more generally from repeat offenses.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by ineedasername on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:32PM (#21066325)
Leaving aside the hot-button topic of sexual assault, there are plenty of sub-criminal or borderline actions that can occur that the college needs to deal with. Not all violations of a code of conduct are criminal violations. They'd much rather "sentence" an underage drinker to an alcohol education session than have all such students arrested. A lot of this is mission-driven: Schools honestly believe their role is to turn some of these types of things into a learning experience.

Now, you might disagree with this approach to any/all of the above, but this is the reason that answers your question.

Source: I work in higher ed technology, at times very closely with some of the disciplinary groups.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by ANPEQ-1 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:49PM (#21066436)
"Learning Experience" vs. "Permanent, intractable and public Scarlet Letter" :|
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by ineedasername on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:23AM (#21070497)
Again, I said leaving aside the controversial issue of sexual assault. For something like illegal drug or alcohol usage, except in very egregious circumstances, the goal is to avoid such a "Scarlet letter" by providing the student an opportunity to deal with the issue without involving law enforcement, e.g., drug/alcohol education programs, counseling or addiction services, and so on.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by tomp on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:50AM (#21069210)
Good point, but underage drinking is a victimless crime. I’d be pretty appalled if I was raped and the only consequence would be that the rapist was expelled...
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by ineedasername on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:47AM (#21070710)
Underage drinking in and of itself may be victimless in some sense, but schools want students to be responsible, and from a liability point of view they can't simply ignore it when they see it happening. But neither do they want to refer all such cases to law enforcement. So therein lies the desire for education programs and addiction counseling when it is indicated.

Sexual assault is much more complicated. If the accuser doesn't want to report it to law enforcement and press charges, the maximum penalty the school can inflict is expulsion. Historically this has been a problem in a variety of ways. First, schools have sometimes been accused of discouraging the accuser from going to the police. That problem has resulted in dedicated sexual assault response plans to avoid that sort of thing and work with the accuser to connect them to appropriate resources, counseling, etc. Beyond that, the school is in a bind: prior to either legal action or a school-based disciplinary hearing for violation of the code of conduct, it is punitive to inflict punishment like suspension or force schedule changes to avoid the accused coming into contact with their alleged victim. At the same time, if there was an assault, it can very much exacerbate the harm to the victim to keep things as they are. I don't know of a good solution to this. It often results in the accuser being the one that has to change their schedule or drop out to avoid coming into contact with their alleged attacker.

Again, I don't have an answer that both completely protects a victim from further trauma at the same time that it provides the accused with protection from penalty until they are found guilty. Personally, I think it helps the situation when the accuser is willing to go to the police because that opens up other options like a restraining order that can both protect the victim but also provides judicial review before the accused's rights and privileges are abridged. That is still far from ideal in many cases though. No easy answers here.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by drewrv on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:46PM (#21065979)
Ideally that makes sense to me, but unfortunately courts take a long of time and don't always pursue cases thoroughly. Given that reality, I don't know how an institution is supposed to handle the following scenario without their own tribunal system:

Student A and Student B have a class together. Their dorms are next door to each other. Student A rapes Student B. Is Student B expected to attend class every day with their rapist? To live next door to them? How could one expect Student B to maintain their academic performance in that sort of environment?

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by klipt on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:03PM (#21066525)
What if Student A and Student B both get drunk and have sex. The next day they both feel they were raped. Which one do you expel?

Currently the de facto assumption is whoever files a Title IX report first is the victim and whoever files second is the rapist. I'm sure you can see how this system can be abused: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/06/title-ix-i...

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jessaustin on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:46AM (#21067683)
This is an easy determination in a case of heterosex: the male is the rapist and the female is the victim. Other cases could be more difficult.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by tboughen on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:42AM (#21067967)
Perhaps not as easy as you think - female on male rape happens. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_by_gender
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jessaustin on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:28AM (#21070548)
Yes occasionally I need a reminder that sarcasm is not appreciated on HN.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:52PM (#21066446)
Your scenario and the scenario where someone is falsely accused are indistinguishable prior to a court proceeding. In the second case the victim is the person being falsely accused. Then you would have the same problem with the victim being unable to maintain their academic performance if you kick them out of school without due process.

Let's even admit that forcing a rape victim to live in the same dorm as their rapist is untenable. So that option is off the table and one of them should leave, but in that case it would be the same burden (of leaving) on each class of victim and the tiebreaker should be innocent until proven guilty. On top of that, it may be possible to live in a different dorm or take different classes while remaining at the same school, which is a lesser burden than an innocent victim being forced out of the entire school.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by wonderwonder on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:18PM (#21066610)
Your scenario fails to consider the main thrust of the article.

Student A and B have consensual sex and then student B regrets it and claims student A raped her. Student A is now considered guilty from the onset and is banned from attending class and given no opportunity to read the charges against him or to refute his accuser.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by nkurz on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:05PM (#21066540)
While that would clearly be an uncomfortable situation for Student B, I'm not sure how that is different than when someone accuses their non-dorm neighbor of rape. Is it reasonable outside of school to have to live next door to your rapist while the police and courts slowly do their job? While the hope would be that if the evidence is clear, the suspect would quickly be taken into custody, obviously this doesn't always happen. And obviously, sometimes the evidence isn't clear.

Outside of universities, we've decided on a particular balance between the rights of the accused and the psychological well-being of the accuser. Perhaps we should change the system everywhere to more greatly favor the accuser and to lower the standard for guilt in cases of sexual assault, but I don't see why universities should have a different standard than the rest of society.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by thefj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:06PM (#21066544)
What happens in that scenario when it's just two people living in the same building? Why are colleges different?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by sneak on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:27PM (#21065829)
The problem is that it is reasonable to expel people (and, indeed, to want to expel people) with a much much lower burden of proof than would be required to lock them in a cage.

There absolutely should be a different standard for “can continue to be in this school” and “can continue to walk down the public sidewalk”, and also decided by different people.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Sophistifunk on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:33PM (#21065863)
No, it's not. "Sneak was expelled from harvard for raping somebody" is not something you want people reading without getting your day in court.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by sneak on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:47AM (#21068932)
Well, you just wrote that and people are reading it and I seem to have no recourse as you describe. Which is it exactly that you are advocating for?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by BurningFrog on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:41PM (#21067390)
I can see expelling people for things that are not crimes, such as cheating on tests, or breaking any number of arbitrary rules

But having a lower standard of proof means expelling people who haven't actually done what you're expelling them for. That's a whole other thing, and I'm very hesitant about it.

Of course, when the expulsions almost only happen to members of one gender, on the say-so of members of the other gender, it gets extra complicated.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by claudiawerner on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:01AM (#21069008)
There's a great paper on this, Rape Culture and Epistemology[0] which, although provocatively titled, addresses why a lower standard of proof may be appropriate.

>We’ll argue that this sort of deference is mistaken, for at least two kinds of reasons. One is that, as anti-rape activists have often emphasized, law enforcement procedures themselves are deeply flawed when it comes to their practice of dealing with sexual assault. Another has to do with the connections between knowledge and action, and between knowledge and knowledge ascriptions. We also think that these disparate considerations are more closely interconnected than it may at first appear.

[0] https://philarchive.org/archive/CRERCA-2

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:21AM (#21070483)
> We’ll argue that this sort of deference is mistaken, for at least two kinds of reasons. One is that, as anti-rape activists have often emphasized, law enforcement procedures themselves are deeply flawed when it comes to their practice of dealing with sexual assault.

Totally agreed. That doesn't justify instituting another unjust system to somehow counterbalance the existing unjust system. This just shifts the injustice to another class of people, it doesn't eliminate it, and human nature being what it is, people will exploit it for selfish ends.

You can only eliminate injustice by specifically addressing the injustice, not by moving it around.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by claudiawerner on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:28AM (#21071092)
The presumption in your comment is that the system that replaces the legal system in these situations is equally or more unjust - however according to the authors, by realizing why the legal system is unjust, a university body may do a better job - after all, it is undoubtedly easier to change the laws of a university body than to change them in society as a whole, and the university body may not subject to the same cultural pressures the state is (according to the authors, this would be a patriarchal culture).
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:44AM (#21071248)
> The presumption in your comment is that the system that replaces the legal system in these situations is equally or more unjust

No, I'm actually presuming that injustice cannot be weighed and compared. Statements like "equally or more unjust" are fallacious. If injustice is demonstrable, then we know where the injustice is and so where to focus our efforts, since presumably our goal ought to be eliminating injustice.

How does creating a whole new system that introduces its own problems and its own injustice further the agenda of eliminating injustice? Now you have two unjust systems.

This is HN, so consider the question of when it's appropriate to throw out a buggy program and rewrite it all from scratch, as opposed to gradually evolving the buggy system to a better state. Rewrites are occasionally justified, but it's widely recognized that this is a rare exception, and I'd argue for many of the same reasons.

> after all, it is undoubtedly easier to change the laws of a university body than to change them in society as a whole

That's not a priori a good thing. Laws should be hard to change. Attempting to bypass this process ignores all the reasons why laws must be hard to change.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by claudiawerner on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:14PM (#21072138)
>If injustice is demonstrable, then we know where the injustice is and so where to focus our efforts, since presumably our goal ought to be eliminating injustice.

The central position taken by the authors comes from MacKinnon's Marxist Theory of the State which argues that such change cannot happen within the state as it exists, with all the relations which have constructed it - the argument being that sexist injustice exists prior to the law, and in the law's veneer of equality, it assumes that there is no fundamental injustice to be corrected - the dogma that justice is blind works against justice, not for it. A system in which justice isn't so poorly sighted, and which, according to the authors, starts from the recognition of injustice prior to the law of the state, would be a just one. I'm not convinced that it's fallacious to talk of being "more" or "less" just, since I'm comfortable saying that a Western European country's legal system is more just than Saudi Arabia's.

>as opposed to gradually evolving the buggy system to a better state

Critical legal theory takes the metalegal position that this gradual evolution is impossible given the totality of relations which determine the law. That is to say, the law is a reflection of the society it rules over, its relations of power, of property, of information, knowledge and other things.

>Laws should be hard to change.

It's hard for me to take that as a priori a good thing when laws as they exist in any system reinforce a likely unjust status quo. The law being hard to change seems like a bad situation to be in if you were a Saudi Arabian woman who wanted to drive five years ago. Nevertheless, it circles back to the main point: there are different standards for the law governing society and the law governing a university.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:41AM (#21107275)
> The central position taken by the authors comes from MacKinnon's Marxist Theory of the State which argues that such change cannot happen within the state as it exists, with all the relations which have constructed it

I've read many fallacious arguments with a veneer of plausibility, but in the end, speculation must explain the facts. The fact is that sporadic revolution followed by iterative refinement only is the only approach that has enjoyed any reliable measure of success in any sphere of human knowledge. The law is not exempt from this.

> Critical legal theory takes the metalegal position that this gradual evolution is impossible given the totality of relations which determine the law.

The clear evidence of social and cultural progress must be remarkably inconvenient for critical legal theory.

> That is to say, the law is a reflection of the society it rules over, its relations of power, of property, of information, knowledge and other things.

And the law only has power in so far as the governed consent to be ruled by it. If you attempt to change it too quickly, you will instead induce bloody conflict. Social and cultural inertia exist.

> Nevertheless, it circles back to the main point: there are different standards for the law governing society and the law governing a university.

I'm sure there are. I still don't see the justification for it, but thanks for the attempt.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by mc32 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:36PM (#21065885)
At the same time someone’s standing shouldn’t be in danger due to a malicious accusation.

This is a really hard problem because you want victims to be helped and not have to go through a grueling process for something they didn’t bring upon themselves, but simultaneously you don’t want to enable false accusations which would put undue burden on someone who didn’t bring that upon themselves either.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by aidenn0 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:22PM (#21066245)
A malicious accusation always puts ones standing in danger. If I were to accuse you of just about any crime, your odds of being wrongfully convicted of that crime go up, even if just a little. If I get this claim published widely enough, you will have a harder time finding a job, even if it the claim later proven false.

The question at hand is whether or not things have gone too far.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by nwallin on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:46PM (#21066420)
> The question at hand is whether or not things have gone too far.

I think it's fairly clear that it has, at this point.

1. Sexual assault is defined so broadly it's virtually impossible to legal have sex. "Can I hug you?" "Yes" "Can I kiss you?" "Yes" "Can I squeeze your butt?" "Yes" etc. Did you kiss their neck without asking for and receiving positive, enthusiastic consent? That's sexual assault.

2. There's no recourse if there's an accusation. Notification of a complaint is stated in the form of expulsion. Once expelled, there's no appeals process.

There can and should be an extra judicial system to expect offenders. But this is the wrong one.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by mc32 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:29PM (#21066293)
Agree. With social media it’s amplified and even opinions can have detrimental effects on people’s standing.

Asking whether it has gone too far is like asking if someone died too much. This problem currently has no good solution -barring a true “lie detector”, but even that is insufficient because people can believe things that didn’t happen as they recall, etc., you’d need something more like a “reconstruct the scenario do we the jury can interpret”

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by denkmoon on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:54PM (#21066046)
I guess it's a good thing that the judicial system is able to deliver many different kinds of judgement rather than just locking people in a cage, then.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by mieseratte on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:32PM (#21065855)
Why should they have a lower burden of proof?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by drewrv on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:54PM (#21066050)
Because attending Harvard is a privilege, walking down a public sidewalk is a right.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jayd16 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:39PM (#21065919)
For starters its a civil vs criminal distinction.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:00PM (#21066500)
The government is imposing penalties for criminal behavior. Classifying that as "civil" is a farce.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by throwaway2048 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:05PM (#21066538)
You can be sued in civil court for criminal actions.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:22PM (#21066633)
You can be sued in civil court for money. You're not held in prison or kicked out of school by government fiat in the meantime. And the damages (if any) are imposed after the court proceeding.

The exceptions are related to things like civil asset forfeiture, which are of questionable constitutionality and are similar to the rules we're discussing insofar as they are both worthy of contempt.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by throwaway2048 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:29PM (#21066672)
A university tribunal is not government fiat, and a civil court has more power than simply issuing fines.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:36PM (#21066705)
A university tribunal that operates as a result of federal requirements is government fiat, and a civil court is primarily concerned with awarding damages rather than imposing penalties. That they sometimes do other things is evidence more that the legal system is messy and flawed than that the exceptions should be the rule.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by throwaway2048 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:20PM (#21066949)
Its an investigative process with procedure and hearings, its no more a fiat than a court is.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by caseysoftware on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:16PM (#21067263)
Except - as noted in article - none of the people involved are trained investigators, the starting position it to believe accusers (instead of being impartial), the accused are not allowed legal representation, and they're often under a tribunal-imposed gag order. There is nothing "just" in that situation.

The protections afforded to both the accused and the accuser are to provide safeguards for everyone involved.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jayd16 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:19PM (#21067280)
It would be ridiculous to have every school policy passed by state and local legislation. That power is delegated to academic reagents.

Because it's not a law, it can't be ruled on in court.

Because it can't be ruled on, they use this form of arbitration to solve what would be a civil matter if the school was a private entity.

Its not nearly as unreasonable as you make it seem.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:00AM (#21092715)
> It would be ridiculous to have every school policy passed by state and local legislation. That power is delegated to academic reagents.

The point in this case is that it isn't. Both the policy and the procedural rules are imposed by federal requirements.

If it was actually a policy of the school then it would be non-uniform and students could avoid schools with unreasonable policies, or push for changes to the local policy that are more achievable than it is for an individual to change federal policy.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by hammock on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:38PM (#21065909)
The answer is in the article: Title IX requires them to. Specifically, the new federal guidance that was issued during the Obama administration.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by wahern on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:03PM (#21066527)
The Obama administration didn't change the rules regarding a schools obligation to investigate harassment. Here's the original guidance letter: https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/letters/colleague...

See footnotes 10 and 12, which lay out the precedent that sexual assault alone could create a hostile environment.

What apparently did change was that prior to the letter some schools applied a "clear & convincing" standard to adjudicating harassment complaints, while the letter demands (citing some precedent) that the proper standard is "preponderance of the evidence". See pp 10-11.

But I don't think that's the critical change. From what I can piece together, the Obama letter was basically a notice that regulators were going to put more effort into enforcing the existing law. This type of shift of emphasis is common. When that notice went out, colleges did as all large organizations do to show obeyance--they made a show of reviewing their procedures and requiring completion of more sexual harassment training by their personnel.

Coincidentally (or maybe not so coincidentally) there was some new "science" about the psychology of sexual assault that had begun to dominate the discourse. And one researcher in particular, Dr. Rebecca Campbell, gained widespread recognition and invitations to "educate" college administrators on matters of sexual assault. Dr. Campbell's ideas have since been roundly rebuked (if not completely rejected), but for a few years they figured heavily into how some colleges designed and applied their adjudication procedures. See https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/09/the-ba... for the long story.

But for this bad "science" making the rounds, I think the Obama-era increased enforcement would have mostly gone unnoticed, save for marginal changes in the speed and resolution of sexual assault complaints.

EDIT: And there it is in this article: "But she also described with astonishment a training session she had attended in which the concept of 'trauma-informed investigation' was taught." That's the Dr. Campbell research, likely presented by Dr. Campbell herself.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by mieseratte on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:39PM (#21065925)
I understand “why,” in that they are required to. What I don’t understand is why this is a thing to begin with. Government end-runs around standard systems of due process is odd.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by wahern on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:49PM (#21066780)
The requirement comes from the original Civil Rights Act. Say you're a minority student and some other students start using epithets to taunt you (as was common). Are you going to make a federal case out of it? Is it administratively efficient to require a student to make a federal case out of it, especially if all that's required is a firm rebuke from the administration to cease the hostile behavior?

Remember, the defendant as far as the law is concerned is the university, not the accused student(s). These rules are about requiring the school to provide procedures to address its own conduct; namely, permitting a hostile school environment. Which brings up another point: can a school even be considered to have permitted a hostile environment if they haven't been given the chance to remediate things before initiation of a federal lawsuit? Thus, these rules for internal, administrative adjudication are also about setting standards for judging whether a school has willfully or negligently permitted a hostile environment.

The problem is that in their zeal to avoid being adjudged as having permitted a hostile environment they've in some cases crafted administrative procedures that unfairly treat the accused. But the accused can also make similar claims against the university--that the adjudication procedures sexually discriminated against them. So there's back pressure, it just requires time for things to settle into an equilibrium. (See my post elsethread about the cause for the recent radical shifts.)

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:13AM (#21070424)
> The requirement comes from the original Civil Rights Act. Say you're a minority student and some other students start using epithets to taunt you (as was common). Are you going to make a federal case out of it? Is it administratively efficient to require a student to make a federal case out of it, especially if all that's required is a firm rebuke from the administration to cease the hostile behavior?

I'm confused, a student being racist against another student is not a crime as far as I know. A student raping another student is a crime. How are these remotely comparable?

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by wahern on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:05PM (#21074729)
Because a university isn't investigating to determine whether a crime, per se, has occurred, but to determine whether allegations of discriminatory (racial, sexual, etc) harassment are credible. If such harassment is occurring, or something equivalent which creates a discriminatory hostile environment for the student, a university has an obligation under these laws to end it.

A rape is a crime, but a rape followed by the ongoing presence of the rapist also equates (under legal precedent) to a hostile environment for the student victim, which is how Title IX comes into play.

The question was why are universities conducting these investigations. Rape plus ongoing presence of the rapist is considered a form of sexual discrimination by the university, in so far as the university willfully permits the rapist's ongoing presence. Thus the university is put into the position of judging the credibility of any allegations.

In this way it's also identical to the racial epithet scenario. Shouting racial epithets isn't a crime or even illegal, but a university that doesn't stop such ongoing behavior among its students is considered to be illegally racially discriminatory against the target of the epithets.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:23AM (#21107187)
> The question was why are universities conducting these investigations. Rape plus ongoing presence of the rapist is considered a form of sexual discrimination by the university

This doesn't follow. The sexes of victim and perpetrator can be changed arbitrarily without affecting the argument, in which case this has nothing to do with the sex of those involved. So in what way is this sexual discrimination, even if it is a "hostile" environment for the victim?

> Shouting racial epithets isn't a crime or even illegal, but a university that doesn't stop such ongoing behavior among its students is considered to be illegally racially discriminatory against the target of the epithets.

Except we come again to the fact that racial epithets are literal expressions of racial discrimination, but as per above, I don't see how the rape scenario qualifies under any defined legal term of sexual discrimination.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by denkmoon on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:50PM (#21066017)
Keep it contained. Keep it within your control or within the control of your cronies, and then you'll always get the outcome you want.

The people pushing this aren't in it for fairness or due process.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by gnusty_gnurc on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:08PM (#21066148)
You can trace this mentality about government back to the progressive era.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_branch_of_government

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by gedy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:44PM (#21066405)
From the article:

"This ideology is a successor to liberalism. It brandishes terms that superficially resemble normative liberalism—terms like diversity and inclusion—but in fact seeks to supplant it. This new regime, in which administrative power has been fashioned into a blunt instrument of deterrence, marks off a crucial distinction—between the liberal rule of law, and the punitive system of surveillance rooted in identity politics known as 'social justice.'”

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by nullc on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:33AM (#21069139)
That is essentially the subject of this article: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-09-09/free-s...

... but I felt that coverage was a bit thin and-- lacking a better phrase-- subjective. Perhaps the continuation of this series will be more substantive, it seems off to a good start.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by dmckeon on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:43PM (#21067089)
Institutions often want their own tribunals so that they can more strongly influence both the outcome of investigations and decisions, and the public messaging about them. The underlying goals are not justice and equity, but protection of and advancement for the institution itself. Consider universities, churches, and HR departments.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by shawndrost on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:32PM (#21066320)
I don't want to wade into the specifics of campus tribunals, but the broad mechanism here is very commonplace and uncontroversial, no? Eg if I work for an NSF grant recipient and I spit on my boss, and I get fired with no court ruling, would you find it confusing/objectionable?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:04PM (#21066532)
If firing you was a requirement to maintain the NSF grant? Yes, that would be objectionable, because then it isn't your boss (a private person/organization) but rather the government imposing the penalty without due process.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by shawndrost on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:32PM (#21067024)
Unless I'm missing something, the principle you find objectionable is generally legal, widespread, and uncontroversial. In point of fact, the NSF requires grantees (and their scientists) to follow many requirements, and imposes penalties upon them without due process. Movie distributors force the same things on Netflix and their employees via partnership contracts. An umbrella organization like Boy Scouts imposes membership conduct requirements on its independent affiliates and their members.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by AnthonyMouse on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:22AM (#21092946)
In this case the government isn't just allowing the school to use judicial procedures the government itself couldn't use without violating due process, it's requiring them to. That's different.

And movie distributors and Boy Scouts are not the government. And when a private organization deals unfairly with a private person, due process is still available in the form of a court proceeding (e.g. a suit for unfair termination), but in this case that would either be dismissed (e.g. because the school was following federal requirements) or put the school in an impossible situation where the federal requirements require them to use an unreasonable procedure that subjects them to legal liability by an innocent accused person.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jhbadger on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:37PM (#21066710)
Yes, that would be objectionable, and probably not even legal, unless your boss was a member of a protected class and it could be shown that what you were doing was a hate action against the class and not the individual.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by shawndrost on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:20PM (#21066948)
In the US, employers can fire employees for violating company policies (which presumably would forbid spitting on coworkers) even in cases where protected classes are not a factor. Is that the thing you think is objectionable, and maybe illegal?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by cadlin on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:54PM (#21067144)
You think it's literally illegal to fire someone for spitting on their boss?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jhbadger on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:57AM (#21069246)
The OP talked about getting fired "with no hearing". The days of bosses being absolute rulers that can just fire people instantly with a "You're fired!" isn't really true these days, even in places like the US with limited worker protection. Typically, hearings with HR are scheduled to see what and why things happened. This can result in the worker being fired, of course, but companies fear wrongful dismissal law suits that arise from bosses acting directly.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by iron0013 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @08:57AM (#21070283)
Okay, so how is that different from the campus sexual assault tribunals that everyone in this thread is objecting to?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Fellshard on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:17PM (#21065732)
My guess is that it enables them to spin up their own experimental judicial systems that they believe should exist. To them, relegating to proper courts would be giving up their stake in determining how things 'ought to be'.

Consider, for example, the premise of 'rape culture' which was popularized a few years ago. If such a claim concerning culture is to be made, then it implies the judicial systems external to the institution are reinforcing that culture, and the only way to prevent that from being a part of the institution is to override it with your own judicial system.

Similar logic could be used regarding other sociological claims made in private institutions that they must reinforce in this way.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by rubbingalcohol on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:12PM (#21066582)
Could you elaborate how it follows that the judicial institutions themselves would be reinforcing 'rape culture' in your example? Wouldn't it be more plausible that factors external to the judicial systems might be to blame?
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Fellshard on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:14PM (#21066588)
The reasoning being, 'if we let the external systems deal with it, they would not judge rightly by our standards.' If they believed it would judge rightly, they would have no reason to institute their own.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by rubbingalcohol on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:25PM (#21066653)
I don't think that follows. A civil court would not typically rule that a defendant who was found liable by a preponderance of evidence should be expelled from their academic programs. A criminal court less so. These systems are not equipped to handle the specific remedies that an academic disciplinary program should be designed around providing.

Zooming out a bit, I don't think the civil/criminal courts failure to be suitable for handling an academic complaint constitutes a reinforcement of rape culture or anything else. That's akin to saying "by not doing something about [some injustice] you're complicit" which is not necessarily true.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Udik on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:45AM (#21068337)
> A civil court would not typically rule that a defendant ... should be expelled from their academic program

True, but nothing prevents an internal committee from simply acquiring the results of the court and applying sanctions on that base. In fact you don't even need an internal committee, you just need a general rule that applies automatically.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Fellshard on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:22AM (#21067578)
I believe they would make that claim, again based on their own reasoning.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by joe_the_user on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:09PM (#21066156)
That ridiculous claims smacks of conspiracy theory.

Any number of institutions have their own committees to judge bad behavior - civil courts of all sorts multiply in a bureaucratic society and colleges just one example of a bureaucracy and one strongly connected to many others in this society.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by Fellshard on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:13PM (#21066584)
This is true that bureaucracy breeds judicial systems. My observation is more related to the /why/ of this particular common case. It does not take a conspiracy theory to observe what is said by those enacting Title IX policies and the ensuing results that follow as a natural consequence.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by paggle on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:54PM (#21066049)
Sometimes an organization needs to act with less power to punish, but also less standard of proof. For example, NFL player Ray Rice was caught on video punching his girlfriend unconscious. The NFL can’t put him in prison, but they did suspend him from the league, because he was a toxic brand even though his girlfriend did not press criminal or civil charges. These universities are government organizations, but also like to think of themselves as independent, so I can see the jam they are in.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by wnoise on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:05PM (#21066536)
Many of them are not government organizations. Even the ones that are, are state organizations, not federal.

They do all take federal money though...

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by paggle on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:21PM (#21077576)
The Supreme Court has held that most Constitutional protections from the federal government also apply to state governments.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by rplst8 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:45PM (#21066408)
It's one thing when there is incontrovertible proof, it's another when it's he said she said.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by jaccarmac on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:18PM (#21065736)
Sometimes you want to have people behave in a way which reflects higher ideals than mere legality.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by weberc2 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:26PM (#21065807)
As far as I'm aware, these "tribunals" are dealing with issues like rape and sexual assault, which are actually crimes. As far as I can tell, the generous interpretation for their foundation was that the legal system affords due process rights to the accused. The not very generous interpretation is that some powerful ideologues wanted a mechanism to discriminate against a particular protected demographic.