News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by BurningFrog on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:41PM (#21067390)
I can see expelling people for things that are not crimes, such as cheating on tests, or breaking any number of arbitrary rules

But having a lower standard of proof means expelling people who haven't actually done what you're expelling them for. That's a whole other thing, and I'm very hesitant about it.

Of course, when the expulsions almost only happen to members of one gender, on the say-so of members of the other gender, it gets extra complicated.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by claudiawerner on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:01AM (#21069008)
There's a great paper on this, Rape Culture and Epistemology[0] which, although provocatively titled, addresses why a lower standard of proof may be appropriate.

>We’ll argue that this sort of deference is mistaken, for at least two kinds of reasons. One is that, as anti-rape activists have often emphasized, law enforcement procedures themselves are deeply flawed when it comes to their practice of dealing with sexual assault. Another has to do with the connections between knowledge and action, and between knowledge and knowledge ascriptions. We also think that these disparate considerations are more closely interconnected than it may at first appear.

[0] https://philarchive.org/archive/CRERCA-2

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:21AM (#21070483)
> We’ll argue that this sort of deference is mistaken, for at least two kinds of reasons. One is that, as anti-rape activists have often emphasized, law enforcement procedures themselves are deeply flawed when it comes to their practice of dealing with sexual assault.

Totally agreed. That doesn't justify instituting another unjust system to somehow counterbalance the existing unjust system. This just shifts the injustice to another class of people, it doesn't eliminate it, and human nature being what it is, people will exploit it for selfish ends.

You can only eliminate injustice by specifically addressing the injustice, not by moving it around.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by claudiawerner on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:28AM (#21071092)
The presumption in your comment is that the system that replaces the legal system in these situations is equally or more unjust - however according to the authors, by realizing why the legal system is unjust, a university body may do a better job - after all, it is undoubtedly easier to change the laws of a university body than to change them in society as a whole, and the university body may not subject to the same cultural pressures the state is (according to the authors, this would be a patriarchal culture).
Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:44AM (#21071248)
> The presumption in your comment is that the system that replaces the legal system in these situations is equally or more unjust

No, I'm actually presuming that injustice cannot be weighed and compared. Statements like "equally or more unjust" are fallacious. If injustice is demonstrable, then we know where the injustice is and so where to focus our efforts, since presumably our goal ought to be eliminating injustice.

How does creating a whole new system that introduces its own problems and its own injustice further the agenda of eliminating injustice? Now you have two unjust systems.

This is HN, so consider the question of when it's appropriate to throw out a buggy program and rewrite it all from scratch, as opposed to gradually evolving the buggy system to a better state. Rewrites are occasionally justified, but it's widely recognized that this is a rare exception, and I'd argue for many of the same reasons.

> after all, it is undoubtedly easier to change the laws of a university body than to change them in society as a whole

That's not a priori a good thing. Laws should be hard to change. Attempting to bypass this process ignores all the reasons why laws must be hard to change.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by claudiawerner on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:14PM (#21072138)
>If injustice is demonstrable, then we know where the injustice is and so where to focus our efforts, since presumably our goal ought to be eliminating injustice.

The central position taken by the authors comes from MacKinnon's Marxist Theory of the State which argues that such change cannot happen within the state as it exists, with all the relations which have constructed it - the argument being that sexist injustice exists prior to the law, and in the law's veneer of equality, it assumes that there is no fundamental injustice to be corrected - the dogma that justice is blind works against justice, not for it. A system in which justice isn't so poorly sighted, and which, according to the authors, starts from the recognition of injustice prior to the law of the state, would be a just one. I'm not convinced that it's fallacious to talk of being "more" or "less" just, since I'm comfortable saying that a Western European country's legal system is more just than Saudi Arabia's.

>as opposed to gradually evolving the buggy system to a better state

Critical legal theory takes the metalegal position that this gradual evolution is impossible given the totality of relations which determine the law. That is to say, the law is a reflection of the society it rules over, its relations of power, of property, of information, knowledge and other things.

>Laws should be hard to change.

It's hard for me to take that as a priori a good thing when laws as they exist in any system reinforce a likely unjust status quo. The law being hard to change seems like a bad situation to be in if you were a Saudi Arabian woman who wanted to drive five years ago. Nevertheless, it circles back to the main point: there are different standards for the law governing society and the law governing a university.

Re:America’s New Sex Bureaucracy by naasking on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:41AM (#21107275)
> The central position taken by the authors comes from MacKinnon's Marxist Theory of the State which argues that such change cannot happen within the state as it exists, with all the relations which have constructed it

I've read many fallacious arguments with a veneer of plausibility, but in the end, speculation must explain the facts. The fact is that sporadic revolution followed by iterative refinement only is the only approach that has enjoyed any reliable measure of success in any sphere of human knowledge. The law is not exempt from this.

> Critical legal theory takes the metalegal position that this gradual evolution is impossible given the totality of relations which determine the law.

The clear evidence of social and cultural progress must be remarkably inconvenient for critical legal theory.

> That is to say, the law is a reflection of the society it rules over, its relations of power, of property, of information, knowledge and other things.

And the law only has power in so far as the governed consent to be ruled by it. If you attempt to change it too quickly, you will instead induce bloody conflict. Social and cultural inertia exist.

> Nevertheless, it circles back to the main point: there are different standards for the law governing society and the law governing a university.

I'm sure there are. I still don't see the justification for it, but thanks for the attempt.