I think people have forgotten what innovation looks like. Innovation, from the outside, looks like a huge gamble, and thats because it is. Tesla is a series of huge gambles, and the people pointing out 'hey what Tesla are doing could go terribly wrong' have a point. But they are also missing the point.
Thankfully I think Tesla have enough cars on the road now that if they do strike disaster, there will be enough momentum to have some sort of Tesla remnant to keep the fleet running. But the progress would stop.
When "we always did it that way" is a big corp disease, "we are doing it differently because we innovate" is just the start-up version of it. Tesla had, and still has, a great opportunity to disrupt the automotive industry. But not if they execute a lot worse then incumbents.
edit: interview is here: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-07-13/-the-last...
100% automation was a gamble that didn't pay off. They scrabbled around a bit, and got to more-or-less where they needed to be via a different route.
Tesla talks big about automating...but Toyota actually did it, without fanfare, and managed to do so in a manner consistent with the kanban manufacturing philosophy that has defined their productivity and quality achievements of the past several decades
NUMMI is also not the factory that Toyota shows off in its videos demonstrating the awesomeness of its manufacturing processes.
I also remember way back when steve jobs tried to automate the production of NeXT cubes and broke his company doing it. I think a lot of folks do this sort of "follow one philosophy" into ruin. They want to be amazing and lose sight of what's doable/affordable/realistic.
https://boingboing.net/2018/08/24/fire-breaks-out-at-tesla-f...
And there was another one in February this year.
edit: Here's some pics of the tent, and description of the large scale scrambling it took https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-25/the-futur...
"That startup has no idea what they're doing. Just last week they had to hire a bunch of new developers and they went all-remote and picked up a bunch of new management SaaS to do it. Look at IBM, they always know exactly how many developers they'll need for a project."
Tesla's got some significant problems, sure, but most of their problems seem to be the sort that a rapidly growing startup would have (including the lightning-rod CEO).
EDIT: That Tesla is still treated as a typical Silicon Valley start up and not an automotive OEM might be one of Elons greatest achievements.
Meanwhile, Ford and Toyota have videos of almost an entire car being constructed by robots on their production factory lines (their are parts where humans assist the robots but otherwise most of the work is actually done by the robots). There'a a famous Ford video from a decade or two ago showing one of their (now-older/discontinued) model sedans from being built and finished--entirely by robots-from frame to final painting touchups. And if you don't believe the videos, you can tour their factories and actually see their factory lines in action, live.
Ideas are a dime dozen, right? Execution is what matters is the start-up advice, right? And on that front Tesla is not looking good right now.
Not really. It's just a sign that their paint shop needs some work.
> And the first time pass rate is really bad compared to other OEMs.
For a few weeks in June. Great work taking isolated incidents and generalizing across the board.
Tesla's gotten better at managing their first-time pass rates, but they're still close to the bottom compared to their peers.
Compared to companies that have been in operation for decades, and in some cases a century? Sure, let's make sure to compare all start-ups to entrenched incumbents.
Peugeot - 1889
Daimler - 1890
Fiat - 1899
Renault - 1899
Buick - 1903
Ford - 1903
Rolls-Royce - 1904
General Motors - 1908
Alfa Romeo - 1910
Dodge - 1910
Chevrolet - 1911
Aston Martin - 1913
Maserati - 1914
Mitsubishi - 1917
Bentley - 1919
Citroen - 1919
Chrysler - 1925
Mercedes-Benz - 1926 (1883 if you include Benz & Cie.)
Nissan - 1934
Jaguar - 1935
Toyota - 1937
Jeep - 1941
Ferrari - 1947
Honda - 1948
Land Rover - 1948
Lotus - 1952
Suzuki - 1956
Subaru - 1958
Mini - 1959
Mazda - 1960
Tesla - 2003I didn't know Peugeot was the oldest of the gang!
Detroit Electric - 1907
The granddaddy of electric cars which out-produced everyone.Nissan finally caught up in 2010.
Tesla didn't outproduce it until 2012.
Regardless, you are trying to say that paint shop fires mean they just need a new paint shop. What I'm saying is that their entire manufacturing operation is amateurish compared to the rest of the auto industry.
For now.
When they have a solid product, and a lot more money in the bank, I'd expect them to be at the forefront of automation, and then it will pay dividends, they just tried to do it too soon.
Nobody went in the direction of landing boosters, despite rocketry existing for decades.
'Nobody is doing it', is more often than not, an argument for 'it' instead of against.
Often nobody's doing it, because "it" is truly stupid. What Musk is doing, is applying a formula for discovering when the majority are mistaken.
Of course they did, but they only wanted to do it on DoD money. When that wasn't further forthcoming they pivoted to other projects that were funded.
Landing rocket as a stalled idea wasn't due to lack of technical foresight, it wad a result of big companies lacking financial foresight. I give credit to Space X for making that business leap, even though landing their boosters was actually an ad hoc response to their initial failure to secure cheap Russian engines.
And now Arianne Space is having a serious look at it with Arianne 6.
They had decades of experience in the industry and the software guys (Apple and Google) drove them to bankruptcy.
Also look at SpaceX - he’s not a complete novice at complex manufacturing, and knows how to assemble and motivate a good team, and is used to competing against even more entrenched incumbents.
I’ll be interested to see how this works out but I think Musk was just too early and trying to do too much at once; he’s not wrong that automation is the future.
Also, building mostly single use rockets, reused boosters are pretty new even for SpaceX, in comparatively small number is totally different from building and running factories that spit out hundreds of thousands of cars. But I can understand why Elon might have thought he knew better. But drawing lessons from an industry like aerospace and rockets which had only a hand full of defacto state subsidized players to one as competitive as automotive was, it seems, a bad idea.
Yes, I fully agree that Elon wanted too early and too fast. And having the timing wrong still means you're wrong. And in that case this mistake and the underlying culture and way of thinking can very much doom the whole company. And that would really be a shame, wouldn't it?
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/26/mercedes-...
That's a very insightful and prescient statement -- thanks for that. Certainly food for thought.
The Internet in general, and HN lately, have become extraordinarily negative places full of comments trashing people who try to do things that are bold.
I wish people would have a little optimism, or at least just say things like "wow, I personally don't think it's possible, but damn it's going to be exciting to watch them try".
We need people who are working hard to build a better future, so lets not bury them in a pile of hate and negativity.
Musk and Tesla attract more than the average share of hate, but this sentiment feeds on itself and grows like cancer. Yesterday's thread on Eric Schmidt leaving Google was dozens of people competing to see who could trash him better.
Apart from the bad effects of negativity itself, it is also supremely boring. HN's comments are slowly going from being able to find tons of interesting ideas/reactions/perspectives to finding only different ways of trashing the same person/company/idea.
Cryptocurrencies, "smart" things or IoT, anything Google related, anything even slightly related to or made by Facebook (the other day Facebook released info on their rewrite of Facebook.com and zero comments were about the tech on HN, it was just a bunch of people arguing over how awful Facebook really is), and many things that deal with JavaScript (at least on HN).
Sadly I'm going to be adding Tesla to that list now, something I should have done years ago, at least on this website.
Every topic related to those things quickly devolves into a bunch of people just yelling at each other over semantics, and it's very hard to have any real nuanced discussion.
It's like people now come online to just loudly scream their opinion about something, then leave.
Whether a tech person likes or loaths Facebook is not really of interest or any gain to us as a community. Like you said, it would be massively interesting to learn exactly what tech and how facebook are re-writing their app, but those conversations don't even happen on HN anymore.
It's amazing to think what the state of automobiles and driving will be in 5 and then 10 years (which is really not far away at all), and yet every single discussion thread just argues about the demise of Tesla instead of discussing, planning for and building the future that is inevitable, with or without Tesla.
> Every topic related to those things quickly devolves into a bunch of people just yelling at each other over semantics, and it's very hard to have any real nuanced discussion.
As much as I hate censorship, I think the moderation team at HN would be wise to shadow ban (or just outright ban) accounts that post negative rubbish, or simply expose their opinion on a topic.
Maybe there should be a rule that a person's opinion is off-limits in HN discussions. Discuss the topic at hand, but don't just cram opinions down throats. (yes, I get the irony, I'm expressing my opinion here)
Uninformed optimism? Not so much. How about some charity and informed, insightful analysis?
We need people who are working hard to build a better future, so lets not bury them in a pile of hate and negativity.
Agreed. By the same token, we can ditch the hate and have more informed negativity when it's warranted. It's mental laziness to just slam the lever all the way up because you like the feel of "up," or to slam it all the way down, just because you think "down is cool." The difficult and valuable thing is to move the lever to where it needs to go through technique and good judgement.
I agree, that would be great. Let's analyze stuff instead of just screaming out our opinions.
> we can ditch the hate and have more informed negativity when it's warranted
How does negativity (even informed negativity) help us?
How does it increase our knowledge, or ability to do new exciting things, or our ability to "push the envelope"?
It doesn't. It's a waste of time and effort. Worst case, just say nothing at all rather than being negative about a certain topic.
When working on an extremely complicated problem the last thing in the world anyone needs is a bunch of people reminding them it's really hard and that nobody has done it before and that it's going to fail for reasons x,y,z.
Remember, every breakthrough that has ever happened had a long list of reasons why it was "impossible".
In any good discussion and healthy argument, it is critical to be able to understand your opponent's point, be able to restate it accurately in a way they'd agree with, before being able to point out exactly how it's wrong (or at least unlikely).
Instead, we often see pile-ons and other supremely mentally lazy attacks.
It keeps resources from being wasted that would otherwise actually contribute to our ability to "push the envelope."
It doesn't. It's a waste of time and effort.
When something which really is impossible or impractical is called out, then huge amounts of resources can be redirected to genuinely beneficial projects.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obS6TUVSZds
Are you advocating that we never doubt? Should we just "listen and believe" and somehow our positive energy will make things happen? Sorry, no. Scientific analysis has predictive power. That's what Elon Musk is all about.
Considering that one of the tenets of good engineering cultures is blame-free environments, this negativity around ambitious engineering goals astounds me.
Now, the comments are hardly worth a glance.
I really agree about the tone thing, these conversations are toxic and unproductive.
It might help if we stop referring to rich people as bold—it is honestly difficult to spend the type of capital Musk has access to, and he would have to intentionally give it away to be poor. What’s the risk? Not a risk most can empathize with.
I think it's way further off than that, like, 10+, and almost certainly not without extra hardware being added to Teslas
As of today, Tesla's autopilot page says "All new Tesla cars come standard with advanced hardware capable of providing Autopilot features today, and full self-driving capabilities in the future—through software updates designed to improve functionality over time."
This claim imo is at best overly optimistic, and at worst outright fraud. I'd be surprised if they don't get sued at some point over this. (their website used to be much more explicit about promising full self-driving too)
Full self-driving is 90% edge cases. Adaptive cruise control is not a few incremental steps away from full self-driving
Doubting like this is a pretty common view outside of Tesla, and we've heard it repeated many times here. They clearly disagree.
>Full self-driving is 90% edge cases. Adaptive cruise control is not a few incremental steps away from full self-driving
This they would completely agree with, as you can see from watching their recent autonomy day presentations. And they have an overwhelming lead in collecting edge case data, so... they're in good shape with that.
I remember with Amazon they were growing fast but the conventional analysts were saying but they make zero profit and then after a bit they are the worlds most valuable public company and Bezos the richest person. If Tesla keep up the growth it shouldn't be too hard to get finance.
Of course it remains to be seen if TSLA deliver the growth and self driving etc.
Then don´t buy the stock. Period.
I don´t like this idea of trying to protect every fool with 2 bucks. If you´re not qualified to make your own opinion about a stock then you shouldn´t be allowed to invest in the first place. Or at least, you loose your right to complain if you´ve not done your DD properly.
Some stocks are more risky than others; this is one of them. Hence why the returns might be amazing 10 years from now or be completely garbage. Pick a side and make a bet, or don´t. Either way, talking about protecting people from "risk" is a dead end.
The problem is he's saying or doing things that are typically considered crimes, like securities fraud.
>Musk often makes bold claims and sometimes misses his projected dates.
Or, to use normal language, he's a serial liar.
>Part of what makes a great innovator is being able to fail sometimes. Musk will continue to make bold claims, sometimes he will fail to fulfill it, but many times he will deliver.
Being willing to fail and being dishonest aren't the same thing. It's bizarre how the Musk Cult contorts itself to avoid any possibility of criticizing the Great Leader.
The going-private-at-420 thing was reckless, and he's paid the price for that.
But I don't think its accurate to brand him a serial liar. He's just doing what a CEO does.
I disagree. At a certain point, Musk turned the corner and became delusional. It's beyond simple boasting now.
You need to be optimistic and a little crazy to think you know better.
But that's the point, isn't it? We have a word for intentionally providing falsehoods to investors to get them to keep giving you more money.
That doesn't change the fact that he's produced a great car and seriously innovated in many areas.
I am rooting for them to succeed because I think what they are doing is important and good for humanity. I am hoping Musk does the right thing, and doesn't get in further trouble with the SEC, etc. And I am hoping that the company is able to survive the tumult of the markets -- that is, the costs associated with electric cars and the supply/demand of the market. Sometimes the best technology doesn't win. It happens often. It would be a huge loss if it didn't work out.
He just held an event for Tesla investors called "Autonomy Day" at which he went on at great length about how Tesla robotaxis will autonomously ferry passengers around, anywhere they want to go, as a running, regulator-approved, income-producing service, by next year. There is zero chance of this occurring and he knows it.
Edit: ok you got the word "by" right but... everything else... wow. But it's not just you... the crazy thing is how many people do the same thing.
Why is that? They've now got tens if not hundreds of thousands of cars running their FSD tech all the time comparing it to what the driver actually does and using that to get edge cases to add their every growing dataset to test and train their algorithms. The average American has a commute of 16 miles [0] which gives an estimate 13173 miles driven per car by the end of next year. At a low estimate of 10,000 cars, that would give them a subset of driving data for 131,733,333 miles driven. Presumably, they label these interactions with what should have been done and then throw it into a training/test pipeline. The US car fatality rate is just over 1 per 100,000,000 miles driven [1] so they should have a training/test suite multiple times the US car fatality rate and that's not even counting regular crashes. Granted, it won't actually be that large since they don't report back when the car is running fine, but I don't see why it is 100% impossible for them to get their FSD tech to human quality driving in certain conditions (like geofenced and only run during nice weather) at some point next year when they have that much data to work with.
[0]: https://itstillruns.com/far-americans-drive-work-average-744...
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_safety_in_the_U...
The problems just get harder and harder as you move from a nice controlled environment like a freeway and even there Tesla has shown there are many issues with the system where a driver needs to pay full attention for it to be safe.
From first hand experience with these problems and their complexity I fully expect a slightly better version of autopilot to be delivered and Musk to declare success despite it not being anywhere close to an autonomous fleet of Tesla robo-taxis and justify the difference with the caveats he quietly snuck in that he knew wouldn't make headlines.
That might be enough for his customers and investors so from a business sense it might pay off.
It has over $9 billion in debt. The future is bleak with these financials.
Musk has accomplished a lot, absolutely. But as a thriving business, it's a failure.
And lately, Musk's ego has really shown, and not in a good way.
Respectfully, I disagree. True, he has I think caused the spaceflight industry to think about re-usability again in a meaningful way. And arguably he has also generated a lot of hype for the battery electric car industry.
Having said that, his accomplishments often tend to be inflated by his followers. Tesla ultimately failed to deliver a $35k mass market affordable vehicle. Even Model 3, is out of reach for most people in U.S when the median household annual income is only $56k. At ~$40k, Model 3 essentially remains a luxury vehicle for most. Whereas the competition is quickly catching up. Arguably the Chinese electric vehicle market is now the global leader in electric vehicle market.
SpaceX still has yet to do a crewed launch to LEO. Rocket re-usability is great, but what we really need is a man rated launch vehicle. With the recent DM-2 anomaly, SpaceX won't be launching any people to orbit for at least a year.
Also, whilst propulsive landing looks very cool, it's been done before. SpaceX wasn't the first to do it successfully. Electric cars have been decades. Autonomous driving has also been conceptualized a long time ago, and hell, Tesla isn't even close to the leader in autonomous driving right now in terms of technology.
I don't care that I get a better car for my money! When Tesla is saying that they have the best selling car in its class, you see the Mercedes C-class and the BMW 3-series in the chart. How can they seriously call it a mass-market affordable car when these are the cars that they are competing against?
And while other companies are trying to play catch-up with them, they're testing their Raptor engine for a new rocket that will be dramatically larger than Falcon 9 but with a similar launch cost.
Name anyone who can do propulsive landing the way SpaceX does. They land their rockets on floating platforms in the ocean with amazing precision. Nobody else is remotely close to that kind of engineering feat.
> They are utterly crushing all competition in terms of price and launch cadence.
Launch market is not the entirety of the spaceflight industry.
"The share of launch vehicles is as small as 4 percent of the overall market of space services." - Dmitry Rogozin
And Blue Origin can do propulsive landing like SpaceX: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNRs2gMyLLk
Propulsive landing has been around for a while: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39cjZTCay24
Whilst it seems (and is!) very cool to see the boosters land, it seems to impress the laymen a lot more than the true technical worth of the feat. Here's an addon to the Orbiter spaceflight simulator with recoverable falcon 9 stages: https://www.orbithangar.com/searchid.php?ID=7091
More or less requires college level kinematics at the core of the control/guidance.
Also with the recent DM-2 anomaly, SpaceX is playing catch up with Blue Origin, not the other way round.
Do you mean DM-1? Anyway, I don't see how SpaceX is playing catch up to BO when BO hasn't even built an orbital rocket or man-rated capsule yet...
You are right that people overstate their accomplishments, but excessively downplaying them is actually the worse behavior.
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/average-car-prices-more-1-110...
These price levels do seem high relative to median income and many buyers are overextending themselves. But the market is what it is.
I spent $18k on what I still regard as a really nice car a couple years back, and it felt like a completely over the top extravagance.
I can't imagine what would compel me to spend 37k on a car...
A lot of people also seem to forget that it is in the very nature of outrageous statements to be challenged and criticized.
Musk was right with his predictions a few times, but the same could be said about his challengers.
You can also order the $35k model which is distinct from the $39k model. Yes, it takes a phone call, but it is available.
You do understand that they have made it tougher to buy 35k$ model 3 only because they can't make profit off it?
According to Tesla they have the cheapest batteries, the best AI chips, the most automated factories, the most advanced self driving technology, have a driverless taxi coming soon etc. But after all these advantages they don't sell these technologies individually. They only sell cars with shitty interior and paint, panel, and quality problems at luxury prices. And even though they have a fanatic fanbase, and a lot of positive PR, they still make a loss on luxury priced shitty cars.
My point was that $35k is the lowest.
The long tail can't be truly infinite. It is some very large quantity driven by the combination of many, many factors. Just that amount of analysis gives us some actionable insight.
It would be very easy to miss out on some of the factors, and be off by many orders of magnitude in either direction. The actionable insight, is that the analysis needs to be pinned down and made concrete. You'd better be damned right about it, or you're very likely going to be very, very wrong.
With regards to Elon Musk, the question is, how good do you think the analysis is. They got it spot on with rockets at SpaceX. They got batteries and motors in EVs right at Tesla. What about Tesla scaling production, automation, and AI? I'm less sure about that last one.
Things that are improving exponentially seem far off when you look at them with intuitions developed on linear growth. Autonomy may be far off... or it may be closer than we think.
I don't trust my own judgement to know the answer, but I suspect the people at Tesla have a better handle on it than you or I.
I'm sure they see things in their long tail data that we would probably never think of. Even top experts at other self driving tech companies don't know all of what Tesla is seeing in its long tail data... so I think Tesla has a few more clues than the rest of us.
I'm glad he's doing it privately though. If the government was spending the same amount of money (yeah, yeah, if the government was really doing it it would be 10x more expensive, slower, never gonna happen, etc.) and producing the same results I'm sure they would have pulled the plug already.
These companies could dramatically change the world and I'm glad he has the persistence and commitment to keep doubling down on these moonshots (or Mars shots).
What he has been saying about autonomy defies what anyone who works in the area knows about the state of the technology and is genuinely dangerous. People have died because he oversold autopilot.
https://gizmodo.com/tesla-autopilot-malfunction-caused-crash...
I wish he would just focus on building and selling great electric cars instead of pushing truth in areas where people's live are at stake.
My point stands
No. No no no.
Elon Musk has done some amazing things, but I am adamant his stance on Autopilot has led to unnecessary deaths and when anyone takes his side that they are actually close to true autonomy, you are undermining how dangerous it is to rely on Autopilot as anything other than advanced cruise control. As more time goes on, we find out more evidence about how Autopilot has been misrepresented, and while the NHTSA study being flawed cannot currently be directly tied to Tesla I cannot imagine that a governing body could be so incompetent without a corrupting influence from Tesla [1]. Elon Musk himself talks about how Autopilot requires driver attention when asked by critics, however when demonstrating the technology himself on national television he has his hands off the wheel and regularly is not watching the road [2]. He goes to great lengths to hide any negative data against Autopilot, as already referenced in [1] where it took 2 years to overcome the legal blockade just to get the data provided in a publicly released study, as well as getting Twitter to suspend someone's account for providing this spreadsheet of problems (including deaths) with Autopilot [3]. I absolutely believe an investigation, at the bare minimum for false advertising and personally I believe negligent homicide, should be brought against him because of it (I am not saying he is guilty, but there is certainly a need to find out).
How many people may have died because Elizabeth Holmes misrepresented (and in that case, quite obviously committed fraud) the capability of their product? I am not saying Musk and Holmes are the same, but people would not stop talking about how amazing she was until they found out she was just lying about everything.
Elon Musk is absolutely wrong about Autopilot. When lives are at risk, it is not okay to suspend disbelief just because of the hype.
[1] https://www.thedrive.com/tech/26455/nhtsas-flawed-autopilot-...
[2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jimmcpherson/2018/12/11/in-his-...
[3] https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ESnyJ4b7m96OCjs3GSQ6...
To me, that seems to indicate Autopilot is a net safety gain, despite not being perfect.
https://medium.com/@MidwesternHedgi/teslas-driver-fatality-r...
Here's one way. Highway driving is already significantly safer per mile than local roads,
> The grim statistics provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration also show that drivers on rural roads die at a rate 2.5 times higher per mile traveled than on urban highways. Urban drivers travel twice as many miles but suffer close to half the fatal accidents. [1]
That explains away Musk's "AP is twice as safe" comment. It's only twice as safe because people generally only activate it on the highway, which is already 2.5 times safer!
[1] https://www.npr.org/2009/11/29/120716625/the-deadliest-roads...
That has absolutely nothing to do with whether people have died due to false claims about the ability of Tesla's autopilot. The cars may be safer, but if 1 person died or 100 people died because Musk/Tesla lied about autopilot that is a problem. It doesn't matter how many other accidents their cars have or have not been in.
> - Musk often makes bold claims and sometimes misses his projected dates.
This strikes me as some serious euphemising for someone who lied about his company having a buy out offer and randomly accused a hero of terrible tragedy of being a pedophile. We should not excuse the complete lack of maturity.
Fixed that for you.
https://www.theverge.com/2016/3/31/11335272/tesla-model-3-an...
The tax-credit is gone, never to return... and the $35,000 car is no where to be found.
> 200,000 have been delivered to date.
Elon Musk promised 20,000 Model 3 Cars created / month in 2017. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/881757617416056832
In Q1 2019, the company created 50,900 Model 3 over three months, or 17000 Cars/month on the average.
This 20,000 / month number is important, it is estimated that 20k/month is roughly the profitability point for Tesla. Elon Musk is over a year late, the profits haven't come in yet, and they can't sustainably create cars at the promised rate.
-----------
I understand your optimism here. But this $1.5 Billion raise is more debt to a company that never has seen a yearly profit. It HAS to make money to survive, and Elon Musk has been wrong on every financial metric worth a damn.
If Tesla doesn't make a profit, it will run out of money, eventually. It can't just keep borrowing $1.5 Billion in loans every couple of years when they are late on these kinds of targets.
Where I live (CA), both Fed & CA tax credits are still valid. Go to tesla.com and configure your M3. I just did and it comes out as $33,250 (after tax credits) + $1,200 dest/doc fee = $34,450.
The above doesn't include the debatable "gas savings".
Just a few weeks ago, Elon Musk claimed $35,000 cars will be available without any credits what so ever. This isn't some long-standing promise that slipped off the schedule, this is something Elon Musk has REPEATEDLY claimed to come, but has failed to deliver.
Its a message he's been hammering since 2016: $35,000, before tax credits. The idea was for the M3 to compete against low $20,000 ICE cars.
I recognize that the goalposts have shifted. Maybe it wasn't possible. But maybe... just maybe... Elon Musk shouldn't have set $35,000 before he knew if it were possible to do. He's done incalculable damage to the brand, and is no longer able to raise prices to make the company profitable.
If Tesla could raise prices to $40,000 base or even $45,000 base, they probably would be in a far better financial situation than where they are right now. They can't do that because of the multiple years of price anchoring at $35k.
https://www.engadget.com/2019/04/12/tesla-35k-model-3-pulled...
My issue is mostly with the financial situation of the company. Its clear that the $35k M3 has been relegated as a "loss leader", and there's no work on actually making the car profitable at that price.
Again, perhaps its impossible to make a M3 profitable at $35k, and I would rather have the company make money than lose money. Its just that the years of $35k price anchoring really weakens Tesla's ability to set prices from here on out.
Doesn't it seem obvious that both processes and supply costs tend to improve over time? (this isn't Tesla specific actually)
A couple of simple examples:
- battery costs (they have been on a downwards trend for a while, and expected to keep falling)
- production/assembly line costs: initial hiccups are expected and costly, and as you fix them and learn to optimize your production, your costs also decrease. The rejection rate starts dropping, and rework costs also start dropping.
This is true of pretty much any production: you get better at it as you go, and generally your supply costs also decrease. As you get out of the ramp-up "hell" you start producing a lot more, which starts giving you economies of scale.
Lastly, innovation also offers improvements that can give you another knob. For example, the motors in the M3 are now being ported to Model S to improve the range. This gives an option to either offer a higher range, or keep the range the same but put in a smaller battery (where the savings are going to be). I expect incremental improvements in M3 to have a similar type of effect.
I consider all that "work". I imagine it will lower the production cost, given the same spec. That translates to profit, if the price point is kept the same.
There's a lot of things they did wrong to get to this point: changing the design of the M3 too much and too often, making it difficult to stock parts for repairs and all that... but ultimately, the vehicle is actually positive margin.
That doesn't make the company profitable. They spend $700 Million / quarter on their Supercharger network, their sales channels, salaries for employees, and other such "static costs". They need to get to the 5000 cars / week (or higher) point to become profitable.
That's all it come down to. They've got a positive gross margin car, its an issue of selling more of them. If there's a ton of customers waiting for a cheaper vehicle, well that was an error in Musk's marketing. Too many people are holding out waiting for a cheaper car. IMO anyway.
At ~$40,000, they make $8k per vehicle or so. If they raised average prices to $50,000 or so (assuming a base price of ~$45k), they'd only need to sell 1/2 as many vehicles to make a profit.
Edit: This 2017 PDF illustrates this well. While the 18% looks accurate for 2010 thought 2016 they are projecting that rate slowing down. Page 8 has a good chart illustrating how EV cars will soon be cheaper then ICE cars.
https://data.bloomberglp.com/bnef/sites/14/2017/07/BNEF-Lith...
Except for anywhere in snow or rain.
The "so what" is that it isn't really an automomous vehicle of it can't navigate the roads for a solid 50 % of the year in a good chunk of North America.
>Isn't it still totally mind blowing how far it's already come?
Not really, to be honest.
With neural nets, a lot of things just get learned. You don't have to specifically address them to get great progress. I'm not saying snow is 100% solved, and yes specifically addressing aspects like snow in the future will help make it even better, but autopilot has worked pretty great so far.
I've never yet seen a city with a taxi service which is reliable in heavy snow - things usually fall completely apart. (Not to mention buses, trains, planes, etc...)
Even if the robotaxis are shown to not be able to operate in snow, it's not necessarily an indictment of the whole robotaxi concept. If they can work in snow-free conditions, it's still covering the majority of time, in the majority of potential markets.
My point still stands for most of the rest of the world, though.
The only problem with little shenanigans is that its market manipulation- even if it appears to be legitimately accidental.
Capital is necessary but not sufficient for innovation.
Yes, this is true. My point was more that innovative products are profitable, not necessarily the novel tool we need. See: smartphones and walled garden app stores. Innovative for sure, but an objectively shittier scenario than one built around the tool people want to use.
I don't see innovation (as in, using market forces to push forward technology) as playing any role in collective problems. The regulated market's popular hope for fighting global emissions with market effects, the carbon tax, will do very little to slow emissions on a global scale. We need to think outside the market to have any optimism.
Thank you for writing such a crisp response covering all the right points.
I feel most people just piss on Musk/Tesla and his daring moves - actually IDK why but I don't care.
What I care about is trying to understand the other party. Where they come from. Why are they doing this. What are the risks involved. And in the long term, where are they headed.
Your post answers all of this.
More power to Elon Musk. We need more bold entrepreneurs like him who aren't afraid to be themselves and take world changing risks.
- Sure the CEO might be too active on twitter and at times say or do things typically considered inappropriate CEO behavior.
- Musk often makes bold claims and sometimes misses his projected dates.
However:
- Musk also is often right.
- He delivered amazing things with the model s. The Audi e-tron looks quite nice and I think competition is nice, but it still doesn't match the 2012 model s specs.
- He wanted the model 3 entry price to be $35k. Lots of peopple doubted he could do it, and many projected it wouldn't be available until 2020 or later. It looks like the base model 3 I can order is about $39k and with tax credit brings you downt to $35k and change.
- He promised autonomous driving 2 years from 2016, and honestly many people thought he was nuts. And his prediction was overly optimistic here, but there have been a steady stream of amazing incremental improvements to auto-pilot. On freeways, the tesla can now determine when to change lanes and does it. It can follow navigation within freeways, and it can warn you if a stoplight or stopsign is approaching. They demoed true autonomy, and I believe it's actually getting quite close. Given 1 or 2 more years of incremental improvements, your tesla would be capable of driving you most places I would think. He didn't make his 2 year prediction, but his team at tesla is still doing amazing innovation in this space.
- Part of what makes a great innovator is being able to fail sometimes. Musk will continue to make bold claims, sometimes he will fail to fulfill it, but many times he will deliver.
What he's doing is nothing short of amazing. He's doing things people keep saying can't be done. Re-usable rockets that land? Electric cars? Cars that drive themselves? I'm willing to tolerate a little shenanigans in exchange for this kind of innovation.