Re:Tesla is raising up to $1.5B through convertible note and...
by stcredzero on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:26PM
(#19809611)
It's not enough to have, 'Nobody is doing it.' If you want the full Musk analysis, you also have to do a 1st principles analysis of the true cost. Then you have to identify the factors holding things up across the entire industry. Is it that government regulation and meddling is distorting the pricing and scaring away competitors? Is it an entrenched industry with no motivation to innovate?
Often nobody's doing it, because "it" is truly stupid. What Musk is doing, is applying a formula for discovering when the majority are mistaken.
Re:Tesla is raising up to $1.5B through convertible note and...
by dingaling on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:29PM
(#19811704)
> Nobody went in the direction of landing boosters
Of course they did, but they only wanted to do it on DoD money. When that wasn't further forthcoming they pivoted to other projects that were funded.
Landing rocket as a stalled idea wasn't due to lack of technical foresight, it wad a result of big companies lacking financial foresight. I give credit to Space X for making that business leap, even though landing their boosters was actually an ad hoc response to their initial failure to secure cheap Russian engines.
Re:Tesla is raising up to $1.5B through convertible note and...
by hef19898 on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:16AM
(#19816761)
I once found a study from EASA, conducted in the early 2000s if I remember well, on reusing boosters. The result was, in a nutshell, technically feasible financially not so much due the low number of launches, costs to refurbish and such.
And now Arianne Space is having a serious look at it with Arianne 6.
Re:Tesla is raising up to $1.5B through convertible note and...
by hef19898 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:01PM
(#19809971)
True at first glance. But the better allogy would be a better way to process cheques in the case of PayPal. And in the case of producing cars ignoring the Toyota Production System, ignoring decades of experience in high volume car manufacturing is at best incredibly arrogant.
Nobody went in the direction of landing boosters, despite rocketry existing for decades.
'Nobody is doing it', is more often than not, an argument for 'it' instead of against.