If the operation doesn't make an economic profit, and if there isn't sufficient moat to defend the operation until it can become profitable, then I agree with you it's not worth anything.
But in fact, Uber does have a massive moat -- its network of drivers and riders in thousands of cities around the world. No competitor is even close.
It takes tremendous capital expenditure to build that network, and it will take tremendous capital expenditure to neutralize it.
It remains to be seen if Uber can make an economic profit, but with an operating loss of just 10% of gross revenue, it's not at all inconceivable.
Does it, though? Every driver I've talked to basically drives for "all of them". Several told me they try to find whatever apps are local for driving and they setup those alone with Uber and Lyft and simply take whatever pays the most / is more frequent.
Uber's software and network are solid but I don't think there is a whole lot of loyalty there. Anyone who can drive a wedge into a spot in their business could slowly erode it, IMO.
Now, they're too big to die quickly or anything like that. But it doesn't seem impossible at all to me.
Nobody holds an allegiance to Lyft or Uber - they pick whichever is currently a better deal for both driving and riding. Uber's recent loyalty program is the first thing that slightly moves this in favor of continuing to use Uber, but it's only a little incentive. Large swings in price still favor switching.
Their only moat comes from being able to undercut competitors with VC money in any market they appear in until the competitor is dead and Uber can then raise prices to be profitable.
It's probably a winner take all market. A SDC competitor would be a threat, but I'd be both impressed and surprised if Google could pull that off.
If you're a business traveler, you can Uber out of most airports without having to install the local application, and business customers are less price sensitive than local customers in general.
Definitely agree with your point about nobody having an allegiance for local rides, and it's not clear if Uber can defend against hyper local upstarts at scale.
That's not exactly true: I use Lyft exclusively because have anti-loyalty against Uber because of their greater level of past unscrupulous behavior and scandals.
Keybase could be this.
The main way to get people in would be a focus on event scheduling relying on twilio and sms for including users that don’t have accounts.
Make it cheap but not free ($1/month for people with more than 25 contacts) and advertise no ads or tracking ever.
Also having up to date contacts to stay in touch. Phone numbers and addresses change and it’s hard to know when that happens (and currently most people don’t put this on FB).
I’d want something simple.
what did you mean?
Not setting up your own locally hosted diaspora node.
FWIW I deleted fb 3 years ago.
I heard the same from drivers. It's the ultimate replaceable commodity. Drivers jump ship on an instant and so do I as user. I don't care if it's Lyft, Uber or anybody else.
I just don't see how Uber can maintain said network on the long run and still be profitable, not something I'd put my money in.
What Uber is doing would generally be described as predatory pricing on other sectors. On sufficiently unregulated markets such is Uber's it's extremely risky, no anti-trust legislation is needed to trump it, just a continuously low entry barrier, including lax regulation. For a more concrete, though only related example (rather than speculation as to Uber's future) see Dow's history.
It absolutely takes tremendous capital expenditure to build the network. Uber has an accumulated deficit of $20 billion precisely because they subsidized both drivers and riders to build the two-sided network.
It doesn't have to be winner-take-all. A duopoly in most medium to large cities is perfectly viable. But you won't see dozens of competitors because the drivers and riders would wait too long for a match in a sparse network.
Unless the ride-share commodity can be differentiated some other way, it would take large subsidies for a long time to make much of a dent in Uber.
It's like breaking trail: It's a whole lot of work for the person in front, but it's damn easy for everyone else.
Uber, being first mover, had to spend great heaping piles of money convincing people to become rideshare drivers in the first place. Because they had to sell people on the idea of driving folks for a living, and then get them to buy new cars that meet their standards, and then train them on how to be a rideshare driver, and all that fun stuff.
Everyone else just needs to convince a group of people who have already bought the car and learned how to drive it that it's in their interest to hedge their bets. Which, given how Uber has historically treated its drivers, is something that requires approximately zero convincing.
I always think some Uber drivers shall copy Uber and run a non-profit version of Uber to compete on pricing. What can prevent this?
Besides, companies only pay taxes on profits, so loss making companies don't pay any tax either. (And usually have some kind of ability to carry forward losses to reduce future tax bills)
Why would anyone work voluntarily for what would essentially just be a company that gave all it's profits to the drivers but expected them to work for free. Volunteers tend to work for causes they believe in for some ethical or moral reason, and while I sympathize with the drivers like I'm sure many do I doubt many would work for free so someone else can earn more.
Why would some people work for free so that drivers can earn more or riders could pay less?
Uber racked up a $20 billion cumulative deficit by subsidizing both drivers and riders.
Even if you cloned the Uber app and had people volunteer to do customer support, you'd still wind up with a service where riders pay more, or drivers earn less, or both.
That works for BlaBlaCar [0] that's true carpooling, without drivers trying to make a living on the platform. Riders pay less and drivers get paid less.
But if Uber is losing $4 billion a year at the current prices, it's hard to see how there would be a sustainable market where drivers make more and riders pay less.
100B pump/dump is a scam. Think about all the indices-tracking-ETFs/Funds that will pick up this overpriced stock(our hard earned 401ks). Sigh. Silicon Valley should not have pumped up what was originally a good idea. This has a high chance of ending badly
The point of investing is deciding what you believe in (financially speaking)! If you don’t like Uber, make some money on it! You can’t short in an IRA, or sell naked options, but you can sell futures or buy put options. All of these would express a bearish sentiment on Uber. So don’t feel like you sre being screwed, go make some alpha!
For the record I agree with you, and will short Uber the day it IPOs. I’ve already made some good money on shorting Lyft and expect I’ll do well on the same strat with Uber.
For the riders, Uber Rewards and Uber Cash (that actually forces you to reload if you have below whatever your current ride costs) also make the product quite sticky and make the rider less inclined to take other options on margin.
Small economic tools like these that exploit our psychological biases (e.g. loss aversion, gamification) may go a long way in protecting the moat in this commoditized, competitive environment, and Uber seems to be ahead so far.
(Of course, whichever player comes out with SDCs wins the whole pie)
But how many have they _stopped_ driving for?
If Lyft and Uber are so easily exchangeable, why is Lyft is still a minority in the US while spending more money?
There's something more interesting here.
So unless the incentives are massive, a driver will always look for the next ride by any means necessary. It's nearly never worth it to "wait for a better option".
Uber has a shallow moat around an ugly castle.
What I don’t understand with the gig economy is why the gig workers organize and cut out the platforms.
Do the drivers need uber/Lyft? Do renters need Airbnb? Let these companies take on VC build the tech platform, launch, verify the market...then fuck them, leave them holding their own bag while the workers ride off in the sunset.
Besides the Founders and VCs, who wouldn’t love to wake up tomorrow morning and read about all the uber drivers organizing, launching their own platform and getting equity?
They would need someone to do all the legal/compliance work, validate drivers, handle marketing, handle payments, detect and combat fraud, resolve disputes, and the million other things you don't think about when you use the service.
No Uber drivers are exclusive. In the US I see tons of cars with Uber AND Lyft stickers on. In SEA it was extremely common the same drivers had the Uber AND Grab app installed (before Uber gave up).
Bing is just a click away from Google.
Hulu is just a click away from Netflix.
My local grocery store is just one block away from a different grocery store.
Exclusivity isn't required to defend a large network. People are creatures of habit, and it would take a big innovation in the service or massive subsidies to dismantle that network.
None of those describe a 'moat'. Something like Facebook is a moat. Instagram. A messaging app. Anything where your participation increases the value of the whole offering and hence you'll be locked in, else you lose a lot of value (e.g. from all the contacts you made in the aforementioned networks)
It doesn't take tremendous concentrated capital, though. A bunch of independent regional competitors can fight for each city / country separately. Uber has a leg-up with short-term tourists, who already have their app installed, but for regular users, anyone with a decent app and some ad money can be a competitor.
Given Uber's financials, this still reads to me as, "Nobody in the world can burn money anywhere near as fast as we can."
It's not inconceivable that they could get into the black, but a year-over-year adjusted EBIDTA loss that's getting larger instead of smaller, and a revenue as a percentage of gross bookings that's doing the same, says that they've got no better idea than I do of how to make that actually happen.
Merely being ahead of competitors isn't a moat, it would have to be something that makes "entering into serious competition" difficult for any new entrants. Uber already lacks the monopoly power to raise prices significantly because of competition from Lyft and local providers.
TNCs do experience network effects, but it's nothing like e.g. operating systems or social networks.
No competitor can catch up without heavily subsidizing both drivers and riders. If no competitor is willing to spend billions to steal 20% of the market, then that's a pretty effective moat.
Any given market can't sustain more than a 2 or 3 rideshare services because splitting the network makes it too sparse for drivers and riders to match within a few seconds or minutes.
Uber has the #1 or #2 spot in virtually every market. That's an economic moat if I ever saw one.
I hope your read that link, which concurs that being number 1 by a large margin is not itself a moat. A patent on the key technology is a moat. The unwillingness of everyone to switch is a moat. “They’re number 1” is not a moat.
Ola in India, Didi in China... both are expanding internationally.
If Lyft somehow manages to offer riders consistently cheaper fares (say, 50% off the Uber fare for 1 month) people will switch in droves.
That's exactly what it would take.
A tremendous capital expenditure, sustained over time, to dismantle Uber's network of drivers and riders.
25% off would probably do the trick.
If there is significant regulation, like airport partnerships, that could be a good moat. Just like the taxis had
Their platform is a commodity to both drivers and riders. I haven't met a driver who only drives for Uber. Uber provides no incentives for loyalty to drivers, like actual employment as employees. As a user, I have no loyalty to Uber, either.
The network of drivers would be rendered obsolete by SDC
Whose switching costs are virtually zero. smh
If Waymo don’t make much of a dent in Uber’s market share in 3 years, Uber gets their SDC tech to market and problem solved. If they DO start making a big dent, Uber can likely raise enough money to simply drop prices to Waymo levels (with human drivers), and just bleed cash until they get the tech out to be profitable. Uber (and their investors) are well versed in this strategy.
Even if the profit is no longer negative, it should be near zero since there is not much moat, and it's not even clear whether Uber would be able to compete at all against Waymo (better tech) or even carmakers who own the cars.
The only thing Uber has is brand recognition, but Google Maps actually has even more brand recognition and that's where Waymo is going to be unless antitrust prevents it somehow.
But what if they're not actually significantly cheaper?
Let's say an Uber driver who works 60 hours gets paid $1,200 gross, or $20 per hour. Could the self-driving car drive the same trips with $1,200 lower cost?
Not a chance. Because the $1,200 paid to the Uber driver isn't just for the driver's time, it's also for the reduced resale value of the car, and for fuel, and tires, and repairs.
And those costs for the self-driving car will be much higher because the self-driving vehicle will be newer, and larger, and loaded with expensive computers and lidar.
The self-driving car will also require 24/7 realtime monitoring, and customer support, and a depot staffed with technicians, and a field service team.
The IRS rate for deducting business use of a vehicle is $0.58 per mile, not including the driver's time. I'd bet the cost of an autonomous car will be well north of that.
Prior to this week, Uber had a consecutive ride bonus for 3-rides in a row that would add $7 to 11. But the app would malfunction often or not alert you, and break the streak. Almost everyday I complained but Uber never conceded and never gave me the small bonus.
This week, the consecutive ride bonuses are gone. Replaced by a flat $185 bonus for 70 rides in 7-days to $305 for 120 rides. Previously the biggest ride bonuses would require you to drive 11 hours a day consecutively to hit. And if you did 25% or 50% you’d get 10-15% of the bonus.
My current rate is $23/hour minus roughly $5-6 for gas, depreciation, car and insurance. My rent in LA is $3000/month.
Perhaps $17-18 an hour is fair but Uber’s tactics seem incredibly malicious and ever-changing. I feel like they are exploiting drivers unnecessarily although it is nice to have income whenever I need it.
There’s also tons of bad drivers, they encourage you to use the Uber map system which is seriously flawed, doesn’t calculate traffic and is semi-dangerous. They don’t advise drivers how to do basic tips to navigate traffic.
It could be so much better but it’s weird corporate strategies mixed with bad execution. The negatively Uber generates is a serious problem for their brand and I can’t imagine they’ll exist in 10-years based on how they decide things.
Also uber could become profitable if they charged more. I've actually started taking taxi's again, since they are marginally more expensive than Ubers/Lyfts. However, if you pick them up from an airport, you don't have to wait staring at your phone for 5 minutes watching your driver just sit around in their car until they start moving.
The exception is SFO where Taxis cost 2x what an UberX costs.
The Taxi experience is still bad though - just yesterday in DC I had to listen to my driver 'joke' about why the Taliban should be able to fight for their country while also repeatedly pointing out and talking about women on the street.
The stabilization point is probably close to taxi service. I think that Uber/Lyft really solve for SF's taxi problem mostly.
> Men are disturbed not by things, but by the view which they take of them.
Epictetus
Yes
But aren't SDCs currently something veeery remote (e.g. even Tesla cannot currently drive autonomously even on technically "simple streets" like highways) and especially only as long as no active offensive social behaviours start to emerge (e.g. gang menbers standing in the middle of the street to stop a SDC to rob/kidnap the occupant and/or destroy the car etc...)?
Haha, that's an interesting grey zone I didn't think about (I'm swiss and usually non-direct/non-physical damages cannot be claimed here if they cannot be demonstrated/proven/tested). Hat off :)
They have $40B in gross rideshare bookings and $3B in real losses for 2018.
Let's assume 20% of their costs are fixed and 80% are variable.
What might happen if they raise prices by 10%?
Gross bookings drop by 20% / Revenue per booking increase by 10% => $35.2B in gross bookings
Variable costs drop by 30% (due to lower driver acquisition costs since they're oversupplied) => $24B in variable costs
Fixed costs stay the same => $8.6B
That nets $2.6B profit. My numbers are estimations, but it wouldn't surprise me if they could reach profitability without SDC's.
Realistically, Uber has a higher cost basis than a taxi because taxis cut down on insurance and fleet expenses through pooling. As such, Uber is not really able to beat them on price. There's no evidence to support the idea that people are willing to pay more than taxis to use Uber or Lyft. Customers have virtually zero loyalty and so do drivers. If Uber raised prices by 10% and Lyft didn't, wouldn't bookings decrease further? Why do you think it'd by just 20%?
Your napkin math makes sense given your numbers but we don't have any data to back them up.
Re: SDCs, didn't a leaked internal study of theirs a few years back indicate that SDCs wouldn't move their margins by more than 5%?
This was based off the "Core Platform Financial and Operating Model" chart in their S-1, which states 75% of gross revenue is attributable to driver compensation. So, I imagine 80% is the low end.
> I'm not sure why you think the elasticity figures are what you suggest they are
I'm not sure on the elasticity figures. It's a guess based on running many pricing tests for my own business in the consumer services space.
> If Uber raised prices by 10% and Lyft didn't, wouldn't bookings decrease further?
This could be solved by acquiring them for $20B (or less, now).
> Realistically, Uber has a higher cost basis than a taxi because taxis cut down on insurance and fleet expenses through pooling.
I don't have too much insight into the taxi business, but in San Francisco, Uber Pool is substantially cheaper (<50%) than taxi fares.
Again, I'm not saying my numbers are right -- only that it's plausible they can be profitable without SDC's.
But Uber's price / taxis' price is wider than Uber's revenue / Uber's costs. Uber addresses various problems with taxis:
- driver certification: the brokenness of taxi certification arguably created Uber, via unreasonable constraints on the number of taxis in many jurisdictions
- availability: Uber's surge pricing may suck, but it's more fair than random price gouging by drivers at odd times in weird places
- rider pooling: you don't have to pass a hailing rider to combine trips; there's an algorithm for that
- verification: fake taxis used to be a serious problem, but Uber (usually) gives you the license plate # of your driver
Also, with regard to fleet expenses, Uber is arguably taking advantage of decaying capital that would have gone to waste. The cost of a car is often quoted in cents per mile, but that's not quite accurate. A car that sits in a garage will eventually fail; the lifespan of a car is limited by time as well as distance. Many people weren't driving their cars as far as they could in the time that they had -- and in my experience, Uber drivers tend to drive in the machine-gentlest way they possibly can (sometimes annoyingly so -- but why wouldn't they?). The use of own cars potentially yields a significant savings over a dedicated fleet. (Likewise, Uber "pools" the cost of insurance on the taxi with the cost of insurance on the own car.)
Anything can be made profitable if you just invent numbers.
this analysis is... insane. your numbers aren't estimations, they're just nonsense. a state of oversupplied drivers is not at equilibrium, the drivers are going to leave until they're not supplied anymore. oops, now you have to acquire drivers again.
so, so much dunning-kruger
There's a difference between making it work for a small suburb area in Phoenix some of the times and making it work everywhere all the time. And the problem with ride-sharing applications is that unless it works everywhere nobody is going to use it.
Making it work everywhere for all circumstances is hard. Like really hard. There's a difference between an intervention-free ride and an actual ride that's both safe and comfortable. You could rack up your miles per safety intervention by programming a paranoid robot that sits at a highway ramp for hours without merging.
Is it possible? Maybe. It's nice that some deep models can magically (with no theoretical explanation) recognize a pedestrian, a vehicle, a bike. But would you trust it with your life? There's no theoretical safety guarantee unlike aviation where you can actually read and understand the proofs. I mean yes it could certainly work somewhere some of the time, but believing that it will eventually work everywhere all of the time is rather naive.
Also, your username is hilariously apt.
That doesn't seem to be true...
> 4. Uber expects that its users will stick to it over the course of years in the face of significantly cheaper competition.
What significantly cheaper competition?
The hypothetical Waymo SDC-based 'taxi' service
Furthermore, a completely robust SDC able to handle all climates and weather in which a human driver is at least nominally competent to drive is still likely a pipe dream. So this model may work well - if it works at all - for the Southern regions of the US, without coverage anywhere else.
From 2015: https://www.carscoops.com/2015/01/ford-ceo-says-driverless-c...
Uber don't get the income from the rides without the marketing so I don't get why you get to ignore that when working out if they are profitable or not.
FWIW from conversations with some of the scooter rental app devs, apparently the scooter / ebike on-demand rentals are extremely profitable.
Also, Tesla Autopilot is a joke compared to what Waymo or even Cruise has.
And yet they are the only company in the world to have shipped a workable level 2 system in mass quantities. Orders of magnitude greater than Cruise or Waymo's fleet size. That puts them miles ahead in terms of data collection, which is the real challenge.
The human driver still has a minute. It's not like we are talking about Semi Trucks that will primarily have to navigate interstates.
It's going to be a very long time before self-driving cars are cheaper than cheap cars with human drivers. It's very possible that Uber might reach an acceptable level of self-driving capabilities before Waymo's paid off its investment in its first crop of self-driving cars.
But with a self-driving car, operational costs like registration, maintenance, fuel/charging, and insurance, would all have to come out of Waymo's pockets instead of the driver's $30,000k. If the car is being driven 24/7, then maintenance costs will be much higher because of the increased wear and tear, and insurance for self-driving cars will be magnitudes higher than it is for human (commercial) drivers. Plus, there's the maintenance costs for the self-driving tech (LIDARs, software systems, etc.) The insurance alone would likely wipe out savings from eliminating human drivers, and the combined maintenance+insurance costs definitely will for the foreseeable future.
The average Uber drives a $30k-40k car (assuming it was purchased new). So you're looking at a $100k difference in costs in acquiring the car (using your $130k price). If the SDCs only last 3 years, that means you only have 3 years to make up the $100k difference, so each SDC would have to make $33k/year more than the comparable human-driven Uber car competitor to break even (since operational costs per car will cost the same or more as paying a human drive would have). $33k/year is roughly 3000+ additional rides/year assuming $10/ride average cost. Assuming 10 rides a day based on media reports, that would require Waymo to at least double the rides each vehicle does every day. And Waymo can't just increase the price on its SDC rides, since if it makes them much more than $10/ride, people will just drive cause it's much cheaper and faster, even including gas and parking.
And remember: in all of the numbers above, Waymo is bringing the costs in-house, except for the vehicles themselves, so there's no markup. Retail costs for similarly specced SDCs cars would be much higher because each respective vendors will want their profits.
So yeah, while I don't believe Uber will achieve self-driving, I think that it's going to be a long time before self-driving cars are cheaper than human-driven cars once all costs are taken into account.
coworker, works his normal shift five days a week. will uber when he gets off work for two to three hours each day and some on weekends. his claim is over six hundred dollars a week plus he claims fifty four cents per mile on his taxes.
he seems seriously happy with the arrangement. he does mention you get into some sketchy parts of town on occasion and will turn off the app after a drop in one and go live when he is in the clear but he has yet to have an issue. he does not expect to drive forever, he is simply piling away a down payment on a home.
This isn’t self-evident. Their services are unit profitable in core markets. And additional revenue streams increase the geographies in which they’re organically profitable.
So I'm not following this closely, but why is Uber unprofitable? I mean the app worked last time I was in the US and surely can't be that expensive to develop and maintain.
Can't they just get out of markets that are loss leaders and continue to operate in profitable markets? Note that they should but that's always an option if profitability becomes an immediate issue.
Uber vs Waymo will be inetersting for sure.
Just like in cycling, fast followers have it a lot easier in getting a % of the market share.
1. Uber is unprofitable and the only way it can become profitable is to get SDC's
2. Uber is significantly (years) behind Waymo in the SDC space.
3. Waymo will launch SDC taxi services first meaning:
- When it puts in an order for SDC components no one else is going to be buying in bulk and thus it can have effectively 100% of capacity of these specialized equipment makers
- It is going to be competing with other taxi/ride share services with all the cost advantages of SDC vehicles while its competitors are paying human drivers (and have basically no fat to cut from their current pricing)
- It will be able to improve its services so when someone else does launch their service will be inferior.
4. Uber expects that its users will stick to it over the course of years in the face of significantly cheaper competition.
5. Uber expects that it is going to be able to continue to use human drivers even while it competes against those same people with its SDC's (i.e. when your employer hires your replacement but expects you to train them).
I simply can't imagine how Uber is worth anything at the moment.