So my conclusion is exactly the opposite: while I am frustrated that I have to depend on Apple, because seemingly nobody else can get their act together and produce integrated hardware+software ecosystems that work, I am quite happy with the recent direction they've taken.
Uncertainty over the keyboards is precisely why I postponed replacing my laptop.
I'd probably use my iMac more if I could find a keyboard & trackpad combo in the same form factor as my laptop's. I want the trackpad flush and centered below the keyboard. I've used cardboard wedges to fake the arrangement, but it's not the same. And since Teleport has stopped working, I haven't figured out how to use my laptop's inputs across devices. (First world problems, I know.)
What models work with minimal fuss? What about updates? How do I know that an update won't replace/delete some kext that I need and brick it or break some required functionality?
I really wanted to do this a year ago - except there wasn't any hardware that seemed to answer those questions satisfactorily. In the end, the stability of knowing I can turn on the computer and start work every day without worrying about having to drop into a recovery console because an update f'd is worth more to me than a few grand.
Maybe things have changed?
It works reasonably well.
I have 2x27" 4K LG's and they comfortably fit.
The effective DPI may be higher on 5K at 27" than 4K at 27" but at a reasonable distance I fail to see any difference (approx 220ppi vs 170ppi at 3 feet).
Read more about it here: https://bjango.com/articles/macexternaldisplays/
I'm on Linux and I just use fractional font scaling (1.5 usually) and everything works fine and it has no performance impact I can discern across AMD RX at work, intel hd or rtx2080.
Meanwhile on macOS basically any app scales properly - I think I have never seen one that doesn't. You can use fractional scaling on a mac, but in that case your whole output will be rendered in 5K and scaled down to the target resolution, which is of course an intensive task - I wouldn't recommend it and instead always use true 2x scaling.
I used to have a 27" at 4K, and indeed you can fit 3 columns then, but the blurry/jagged fonts annoyed me. 4K really isn't enough for 27".
My conclusion was that I need exactly 5K at 27" (and not larger, because then you have to turn your head to see everything) for coding.
I agree with you about size though running two 27" (on VESA mount arms) is the max I'd want for comfort as it was I had to get a 80cm deep desk to sit slight further back.
https://i.redd.it/tctxa7hs16l21.png
That desk is 120x80 and the monitors still over shadow it.
I recently purchase a 13" air, despite the ancient design and shitty screen, because I refuse to buy something that I couldn't swap the SSD and battery. (And I couldn't find a suitable used 2015 mbp.)
I was just lamenting to my wife as I was browsing Apple's web site and the mess that is the Apple lineup: there's no way Steve Jobs would have put up with this shit. Yes, I know he was responsible for the G4 Cube, and some other silly things... but today's Apple lineup, shipping a brand new iPad with only Pencil 1 support? Cook would go to Jobs and say, "but look at the process efficiency" and Jobs would just say, GTFO! I'm sure of it.
Look I get that most consumers aren't opening their devices. But throw the pros a bone already. All Apple is making these days are Lamborghinis. That's not what pros want: just give us a really fast pickup truck! Please Apple?
https://www.amazon.com/Sintech-Adapter-Upgrade-2013-2016-201...
The first thing Jobs did upon returning to Apple is reduce the product line to exactly four products. Consumer and pro laptop, consumer and pro desktop.
Apple in 2019 with a market cap of ~1,000,000,000,000 is vastly different than Apple in 1997 a few months from bankruptcy.
Apple does a pretty good job supporting the needs of most people, in a slim clean form factor, with the iMac. It supports memory upgrades, and external monitors. There is a small group that needs nearly every component to be upgradeable or swappable, and they offer the Mac Pro for that use case. I don't see a scenario where the cost/benefit of adding removable graphics cards to an iMac would make sense. I would like to see the hard drive accessible like the memory is.
I'm not sure I buy this as an argument until the new Mac Pro is released.
Having said that, the Mac Pro is prohibitively expensive for a lot of people. I think a lot of people want something between a Mac Mini and a Mac Pro. Something that could be called Mac "Midi" that would allow for some commodity parts (ram, storage, gpu) to be used.
>> I don't see a scenario where the cost/benefit of adding removable graphics cards to an iMac would make sense.
In any case, this is probably a non-issue with TB3 and eGPUs.
(Technically Apple says the RAM isn't user upgradable, but it's still relatively easy.)
Upgradable/fixable everything is a feature of the $299 desktop machine you find at walmart or the $40 machine from goodwill. It doesn't start at $5000 that only 0.05% of planet earth can afford.
Edit: Holy shit it is much worse than I thought. The actual desktop option is basically a $700-$900 pc that starts out at 3-4K. It looks like they have ignored the mac pro for years but kept the humongous price.
If you actually want a capable machine you have to buy the imac pro option and if you actually select a fast processor its more like 8k for a machine wherein you could probably build an equivalent pc for 2.
Veblen goods is more like it.
> They aren’t going to boost their market share by adding swappanle graphics cards to the iMac or a j-mouse nub to the MacBook.
Wanting to add/replace DIMMs or SSD HDs isn't asking much.
Which was never popular with users, never good value for money, never sold very many, and hasn't been seriously updated since 2013.
"I would like to see the hard drive accessible like the memory is."
Allow hard drive and RAM upgrades for iMacs and Mac Book Pros, would instantly make all the performance sensitive customers much happier.
† I guess, if you were to operate a "Hackintosh OEM", you could sell the hardware build itself without actually doing the step of installing macOS onto it. You'd have a team that would continuously figure out what drivers + config would work best for each given macOS update (with a perfected DSDT, etc.), and then that team would package those patches up and hand them off to e.g. the UniBeast team, such that the regular Hackintoshing process that everyone uses would detect your build by the CMOS vendor+model ID, and just plop that OEM package in instead of requiring any config. And would also install an updater that would update your patch-package, and also delay macOS's own OS updates until a tested patch-package is available.
Whether through technical or legal means, I doubt Apple would sit around and let this openly thrive or grow into a viable option for the average consumer.
I think, these days, Clover does all the calculations and checks needed by itself. It used to be harder, but not any more.
Now, here's a real complaint: there's no Hackintosh driver to get the OS to treat an IBM-compatible PC speaker (you know, the one driven by an Intel PCH's onboard 8253 logic) as a sound device, so that I can configure the OS to play "System Sounds" through it, and thus have an extremely-tinny Apple "bwah" on start-up. What kind of loser OS is this? ;)
So same offer here, if anyone wants to go that route: https://www.matthewwegner.com/hp-z420-desktop-buying-guide/
To some, the point of using a Mac is to be able to develop and test software for Mac hardware using Apple's frameworks, and having to spend 3x the price tag just to get the hardware is something that makes little to no sense.
I mean, where on earth does it make sense to spend over 2k€ for a desktop computer just because you want to have more than 8GB of RAM?
But still probably cheaper than the value of your time spent building a Hackintosh and keeping it functional.
I don't bother with hackintosh any more as I don't have any use for MacOS, but my experience was pretty seamless. I used hardware that was sitting around unused and after installing a couple of custom kexts everything just worked (^). I never had anything break even when upgrading from one major version to the next.
^ networking, sound, XCode etc. Not sure about apple services like iCloud or some of the iphone features since I never used them. Good enough for a cheap build machine when I was tinkering with some iOS dev.
Is this not what tonymacx86.com provides via the buying guide / golden builds forum?
I’m willing to do that for one workstation that will live on my desk; I’m not willing to do it for a computer that’s going to be used by a relative who lives thousands of miles away, who I only see for a few days a year (and don’t want to waste those days building a computer.) Let alone several such computers, one per relative.
Whereas in the hypothetical I’m talking about, you order the computer pre-built from a website shipped to your relative, and burn macOS to a USB; and then, when you visit them, unpack the box, install the OS on the computer, and then forget about it.
I don’t know how that’s ever going to be viable though.. for that scenario you would already have a Mac mini there because there is no need for hardware to run like Crysis. And then it can have service, comes with keyboard and mouse, as well as manuals. Then I am not sure how cheap you want to have that hypothetical alternative to make it worthwhile.
Pre-built systems has been tried before, but Apple shut it down: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psystar_Corporation
I know because I tried to do this with a 2018 Mac Mini. Aside from the very lackluster GPU performance, it's a pretty speedy machine.
I had a fairly generous budget for a new computer. 32GB of RAM was about $200 from Crucial. The external SSD storage options were pretty crappy. Any sort of TB3 option was a few hundred dollars to start. I ended up settling with a USB3 2TB HDD. I then had to copy my Photo and iTunes libraries over to it and re-point the apps to the right spots.
For the external GPU, you're looking at about $500 at a minimum. And then you have to find a place for that to sit, and it's essentially the size of a small ITX PC case.
I ended up returning the Mini and just breaking down and building a vanilla hackintosh. A 8700K/32GB/1TB SSD/RX 580 ITX box with quality parts that's all in one small case (Fractal Design Define Nano S) in the same desk footprint as just the external GPU enclosure, and it's not a thermally-constrained dongletown.
Would I recommend it to anyone? No. But after an initially scary couple of hours, I have for all intents and purposes a normally-functioning macOS box that is noticeably quicker than the Mini for the cost of just the base Mini -- sans all the other junk I had to buy. The macOS install is vanilla, with SIP enabled, and no janky kexts in the OS install - NOTHING custom in the OS install. The bare minimum shoved in the EFI partition.
Everything works (sleep, audio, iMessage, etc). It was marginally more trouble than getting Windows 10 installed. Less trouble than getting Ubuntu installed.
God, it's glorious.
I don't really get the resistance about adding some external cables/cases to your desk. The desk has always been full of cables anyways (monitors, speakers, consoles, even my mechanical keyboard etc.) and I don't see any harm in adding a couple more for an external SSD and an eGPU. As mentioned by some other commentators, I'm pretty much past the days of having to constantly fight my main setup and just want to have everything working flawlessly most of the time.
I plan to get a Mac Mini soon and try it out. I think the performance should suffice for most of my use cases. If it seriously stutters I'll consider building a Hackintosh, or simply do those demanding tasks on another dedicated box.
As of today, the prices are higher than what I paid. If you're going to buy, monitor /r/buildapcsales on Reddit and buy your parts when they go on sale. I bought my stuff over a period of a couple weeks and saved substantial money.
Samsung SSD prices fluctuate by 10s of dollars. Other SSD manufacturers such as Intel and WD offer steep discounts at times. The RX 580 GPUs go on significant sales pretty often.
At some point, I need to finish my guide and publish to Github. I largely followed corpnewt's Vanilla Guide for Mojave [1], and followed the Coffee Lake train. It's important to follow each step closely.
Again, I do not recommend a hackintosh, but for me it worked out really well.
1. https://hackintosh.gitbook.io/-r-hackintosh-vanilla-desktop-...
This would be my choice over a hackintosh for parents or other family.
Sounds like something that could be 3D printed or
One big plus: it's quiet, so I can leave it on.
You may want to keep your eyes out for the new Mac Pro that's meant to release this year.
My current development machine is a Mac Pro, the little cylinder from 2013, and I had a couple of the aluminum box ones and my first was in a plastic case. I just couldn't see upgrading to a current Mac Pro ($5k to $13k). It's thin and looks cool, but I thought that I would want to use a different (wider) monitor and didn't think the cooling offered by the case was a good idea. Maybe the new Mac Pro that is supposed to be offered later this year will be just right.
As time goes on I find Mac loyalists more and more absurd
What purposes does your comment serve? It's not that hard to understand that he found the rest of the laptop valuable enough to spend 3.5k on it (despite the keyboard, which isn't that bad anyways).
His viewpoint isn't that uncommon either, plenty of businesses buy fully loaded MacBook Pros in bulk because it increases productivity. If you're using the laptop for work, you'll be connected to an external monitor and keyboard 90% of the time.
Apple specifically said in 2017 (before the release of the iMac Pro) that they messed up the 2013 Mac Pro, that they would make a new modular Mac Pro but it would take a long time to finish, and that the iMac Pro would be a stopgap.
It was a private press event, so the best source on this is probably Daring Fireball: https://daringfireball.net/2017/04/the_mac_pro_lives
Granted it was from some dude's homelab after he got laid off at Cray but still.
When you get up to that dollar amount I feel like there's just much sweeter shit out there.
One gripe is the thing is fucking massive and kinda unwieldy stuffed into a Coolermaster Cosmos II case...
Not sure those people were ever Apple customers.
Personally, I use Apple for their software. Having that software in an affordable, customizable, upgradable package would be very welcome. I can get beautiful hardware from most manufacturersand brands these days, so that isn't a unique selling point any longer.
> I'd love to see Apple make a system that supported upgradeable memory, SSDs, High capacity hard drives, graphics, and separate larger monitors
As I understand it, it isn't a customer support issue but a physical limitation issue for what processing power these machines get. They are built with soldered components which means no upgradeability with the flip side being that the performance is 5 years ahead of the direct competition. In other words...you can't upgrade but you won't need to like you used to. It's a paradigm shift.
Who are they five years ahead of exactly? And who told them to make the enclosure out of a garbage can?
Their base model comes in at 3k. They are well behind anything I would build for 3k, sans the garbage can case.
† The weirdest part of this is that there's an obvious high-value use case using exactly the same hardware: use that strip as a Dock replacement with app icons, so everyone can reclaim the bottom half-inch of their main screen.
It feels like these products are just an afterthought for the company.
They're standard issue at most companies in the valley, at least, with "open" x86 laptops being a distant second (maybe 10% of the population) split between Windows and Linux.
I've been programming since before the (Unix) dawn of time, and Apple devices have been good development machines for me since OSX was released 18 years ago. I'm comfortable on Linux, but the Apple iOS devices and computers are all over my home and integrate well with my development machines. Furthermore, the family does well with MacOS, and they don't need IT help with their email, iPhone, music, homework, printing, etc. like they used to under Windows.
I'd love to see Apple make a system that supported upgradeable memory, SSDs, High capacity hard drives, graphics, and separate larger monitors, but that doesn't look like that will ever happen. By locking down the hardware to just certain configurations, the very successful stores can handle problems (hardware, software, and user related) at locations all over the world.
Even if Apple can't make the machines more upgradeable because of customer support issues, the new machines don't seem to be well designed for me. They have become too thin and too sleek and overpriced because of features I don't want (over sharp display, touchbar) and issues caused by the pursuit of sleekness and style (crap keyboards, thermal limits).
Lenovo (Thinkpads) offers thin, light, somewhat upgradeable, good looking laptops that are light to carry and easier to grip with great keyboards. I wish Apple could start with something like one of those and equip it with an Apple touchpad and MacOS.
I've been waiting and waiting for Apple to improve its line up (I'm writing this on a Mac Pro from 2013 with a nice 34 inch ultra-wide monitor). It looks like I'll never replace it. I know there are alternatives, my home/office are littered with computers, Thinkpads running Linux, Microsoft laptops, Dell Servers running FreeBSD, and homemade PCs running Windows (for gaming); but I'm going to miss using MacOS as my daily-driver.