News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by montenegrohugo on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:54AM (#18647505)
Imagine you invest in a hedge fund, and get some amount of returns back. But then, years later, a lawyer comes and tells you to give him the profits because the fund was illegitimate (without you knowing this) and therefore they don't belong to you.

This is exactly what is happening to all these people.

Doesn't this feel unfair to anyone else?

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by pjc50 on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:10AM (#18647610)
It does feel somewhat unfair, but it's long-settled law on stolen goods: if you buy a car and it turns out to be stolen, or a house with an improper title, you don't get to keep it. In both cases the buyer is supposed to check and beware of "too good to be true" offers.

Note that they get to keep the principal, so they're not even out the money they might be if they bought a stolen car.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by njarboe on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:33PM (#18650071)
Public auctions are one way that this chain is broken. Must have been from the old days when movement of objects was more difficult, but something put up for a public auction can be inspected and claimed by someone as stolen, but afterwords people get to keep what they bought. Thus auctions for lost luggage, police stuff, car auctions, etc.

Also there is a special rule for cash. Stolen cash is not treated this way, so if a bank is robbed and has all the serial numbers, they can't take the money from you if you happen to get one of the bills in a transaction.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by TuringNYC on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:44PM (#18650156)
Curious if this approach was tried on behalf of those who lost BTC at Mt Gox -- could other BTC holders have their holdings taken away if it originated from the Mt Gox theft (or other theft.)

...or is BTC treated as cash?

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by latchkey on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:29AM (#18670279)
BTC was 'found' by Mark Karples (~200k). When the price increased, the custodian started selling it to lock in enough money to pay off the creditors [0]. Now the question is how to do the payouts due to the way Japanese law works [1].

  [0] https://www.mtgoxlegal.com/2017/10/27/press-release/
  [1] https://www.mtgoxlegal.com/2017/11/29/the-legal-advice-civil-rehabilitation/
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by hx2a on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:46AM (#18647814)
I agree. This also sets an important precedent that future investors in different funds must consider. If something seems too good to be true, there might be consequences for them. They are disincentivized to look the other way.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by skummetmaelk on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:07AM (#18647948)
Not really since they still get to keep all the profit they made off the stolen goods.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by tlrobinson on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:24PM (#18649982)
That's exactly what's not happening in this case.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by chuckkir on Monday December 10, 2018 @02:08PM (#18650335)
Actually, I think it is. It sounds like they're clawing back the investment profit, but it is likely those profits were invested in something else which also earned a profit. That additional profit is yours to keep as far as I can tell.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by adambyrtek on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:29PM (#18652653)
Alternatively, they could have spent the original profit or lost it on another investment... In other words the end result was similar to a loan. I'm curious whether the claw-back included a risk-free interest rate.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by russh on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:25PM (#18651284)
So they get to keep the profit they made off the profit but but not the profit itself?
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by ABCLAW on Monday December 10, 2018 @02:28PM (#18650497)
>It does feel somewhat unfair, but it's long-settled law on stolen goods: if you buy a car and it turns out to be stolen, or a house with an improper title, you don't get to keep it.

I agree with your first line, but wanted to nitpick the legal statement.

That's not the law on passage of title. Things are a whole lot more complicated than that.

The rules are jurisdiction specific and civilian and common law systems deal with this issue differently. Historical common law treats property as a series of tiered claims, not as a singular entitlement.

Sometimes there are brightline rules regarding registration requirements. Sometimes there are multiple sale good faith caveats. Sometimes there are confounding evidence requirements. etc.

Generally speaking, you never get to keep the item if you knew or ought to have known it was fishy. Beyond that, things vary.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:21AM (#18648052)
True if you buy a car in a private sale. But if you buy a car from a regulated professional dealer and it turns out to be stolen then things get a little bit more complicated than just you have to give it back. I would expect in that situation that the dealer makes everyone good (and possibly goes to prison).
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by klodolph on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:57AM (#18648759)
This isn't my understanding of how it works. I thought that if you bought a stolen car from a dealership, the police could still tow the car and give it back to the rightful owner. You would get your money back, and you would sue the seller if necessary. I don't see how buying from a dealership makes this any different, except a dealership is easier to sue and recover damages from.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by ninju on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:06AM (#18648373)
You mean like how Madoff went to prison
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by detaro on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:15AM (#18647638)
"I didn't know I was benefiting from a crime, so I should be able to keep the profits I made instead of them being used to repay people that actually lost money" doesn't feel fair either.

I think a somewhat useful comparison is trade in stolen goods: even if you didn't know that something you bought was stolen, you still can be forced to return it to the actual owner. This situation is actually better than with physical goods, since they're only going after profits (which arguably were stolen from others), whereas in the case of stolen goods the buyer can be left hanging trying to recover the money they paid.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by shaki-dora on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:16AM (#18647647)
As per the article, the mechanism here is clawing back "profits" from people who withdrew money from Madoff's fund over the years. It's literally reversing the basic mechanism of this Ponzi scheme.

I think your objection would be valid if, for example, they sued contractors that were paid to renovate Madoff's office (and being paid with customers' money).

But as it is, I think the veil of ignorance might serve as a guide. Consider: You are informed that, before his untimely death in a completely unnecessary re-enactment of Wilhelm Tell's apple-related stunts (only this time with LSD), your great-granduncle invested $10,000,000 of the profits made from his seminal literary addition to the comin-of-age canon into Madoff's funds. You do not know if he ever found the clarity of mind to withdraw any funds. Would you choose the $10 million, or prefer a 50% chance at $20 million?

(the diminishing marginal value of money also comes into play here).

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by SonicSoul on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:26AM (#18647700)
veil of ignorance

No.

I don’t know if any of the 10 investments i made in 2018 are Ponzi schemes. I have to rely on regulations and hope companies like Lending Club are legit, I don’t pour over their paper work or hiring private investigators to figure out how they do their business. It would be silly to confiscate my profits because Lending Club turned out to be shady. Me hiring a fund to produce returns on investment is no different than hiring a painter to paint a room.

update

all good points in replies. i stand corrected on my understanding of this issue :)

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by whack on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:54AM (#18647869)
You misunderstand what "veil of ignorance" is referring to.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veil_of_ignorance

> "It would be silly to confiscate my profits because Lending Club turned out to be shady"

It would be even sillier for you to lose literally everything because Lending Club turned out to be shady.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by bionsystem on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:32AM (#18648134)
> all good points in replies. i stand corrected on my understanding of this issue :)

Madoff's fund wasn't regulated, too. If you buy a house or stocks, you are into a regulated market.

Edit : by "regulated" I probably meant public. Not sure if the english term is correct ; one may want to check Shiller's course about hedge funds on youtube. My point being, those funds are only accessible to the very rich who will never spend their principal.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by CJefferson on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:46AM (#18647813)
Do you think if you buy a stolen good without knowing it is stolen you should get to keep it? If not, where do we draw the line?
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by leetcrew on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:22AM (#18648068)
I think it honestly depends. to make an admittedly weird example: suppose you go to a dealership to buy a used car. you decide on one that's going for close to the KBB value, do all the paperwork, and drive the car off the lot. a year later you find out the dealership owner is a shady guy and some of the cars he sold were somehow stolen. the business no longer exists and the guy is nowhere to be found. should you really be out $10k and your ride to work?

the case for returning the property in this situation is more practical than moral. that is, it's probably just easier to just find the guy with the car and take it than to extract money from a deadbeat car salesman who probably doesn't have it anymore. I find these sorts of legal things distasteful, but I guess I can see why we have them.

in an ideal world, I think there should be some sort of safe harbor protection for people who make a reasonable effort in good faith to check that a transaction is bona fide.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by jacobr1 on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:12AM (#18648871)
This is why a lender for a house purchase requires title insurance. The insurance kicks in to make you whole if it turns out the house was not the prior owner's to sell. I don't think the same things exists with cars, but requiring it in some way seems like a way to handle the problem in general. In state-level social fund equivalent. This happens with insurance too. One of the costs baked into premiums are state mandated contributions to common insurance solvency pools. If a carrier goes out of business, the insured is still covered by the common pool that is used to fund claims (that have now be transferred to a solvent firm or trustee).
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:56PM (#18650247)
The "safe harbor" is that you're not accused of stealing the car yourself.

Remember, you may be an innocent victim, but someone, somewhere, had the car stolen from them and they may not have had insurance on it.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by wahern on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:24PM (#18652626)
Someone has to eat the loss: the original owner or the last purchaser. The question is, between the two who is the "least cost avoider"? That is, the one who we can most easily incentivize in order to arrive at the best overall outcome.

In short, if the last purchaser got to keep the car, that means he would be less risk averse to buying from car dealers with risky reputations, effectively increasing the market for stolen cars. And this increase in the market would result in more stolen cars overall.

The existing default rule is, of course, based on a judgment that we won't be worse off in a world where people can fraudulently claim that their car is stolen and then get it back while also capturing the sale profit. Considering that most people are law abiding and have very good reason already to protect their car from theft regardless of which default rule we choose, it's not a bad rule on its face.

> in an ideal world, I think there should be some sort of safe harbor protection for people who make a reasonable effort in good faith to check that a transaction is bona fide.

It sounds like you may have a legal education given the language you're using. IIRC this is how the rule for real estate works in the presence of land registration systems. We flip the default rule to incentivize recordation. If two fraudulent sales are made by a seller back-to-back before title is recorded, it's the last purchaser who gets the property. This incentivizes each purchaser to record his purchase as quickly as possible, and to do so in a manner that closes the window for a fraudulent sale, such as by keeping payment in escrow until recordation is successful. (See, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bona_fide_purchaser)

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by leetcrew on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @10:34AM (#18655939)
no formal legal education, I'm just an armchair philosopher who occasionally reads about legal issues. thanks for sharing the bit about real estate, I will have to read more about the motivation for flipping the default rule there.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:22AM (#18648065)
If I buy the goods in a big box retailer and the goods turn out to be stolen I assume that the retailer will make the original owner good.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by detaro on Monday December 10, 2018 @02:00PM (#18650275)
The retailer is in jail and all their assets seized and redistributed already.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:18AM (#18648920)
> I have to rely on regulations and hope companies like Lending Club are legit, I don’t pour over their paper work

You...should probably do more diligence if you’re investing your money in Lending Club. Treasuries and CDS are the thoughtless investment option.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by mikeash on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:37AM (#18647765)
There’s a major difference in that it’s not possible to unpaint a room, but it’s trivial to undo a money transfer. A painter can’t be returned to his previous state, but an investor can.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by kbutler on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:49AM (#18647836)
Some Madoff-touched money is going to be invested at a profit, some at a loss, some spent, some beneficiaries will be dead with assets left to heirs, etc.

Unwinding /anything/ from a decade ago is non-trivial.

It's even possible (likely?) that some direct Madoff investors were also customers of the funds that have money being clawed back.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by shaki-dora on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:02AM (#18647921)
> that some Madoff investors....

They all are. That’s the point. This is taking Money from those who got out of Madoff’s fund soon enough, and giving to those later investors who paid for the imaginary profits.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by kbutler on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:19AM (#18648038)
>> that some direct Madoff investors were also customers of the funds

> that some Madoff investors.

You omitted the word "direct" (why?)

Person X invests in a fund Y that invests with Madoff and gets out soon enough. Person X then invests those gains "directly" with Madoff. Person X loses money with Madoff. How much does Person X deserve (or owe)?

Another example would be Person A who invests $N in the scheme. Takes out $10N principal & profits (as a test that the scheme is authentic). Invests that $10N and even more in the scheme, loses it.

How much do you claw back for (or from?) Person A?

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by IfOnlyYouKnew on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:40AM (#18648622)
Madoff's funds weren't exactly exchange-traded, generic investment vehicles. As mentioned in the article, part of the money is clawed back from "feeder funds". Those were sales or regulatory vehicles that passed 100% of their capital on to Madoff.

As to your examples:

Person X is irrelevant. You claw back the money from fund Y. Fund Y may, in turn, have arrangements with person X requiring them to return any money, but that's actually tangential. (this is like 1st-semester law again, yeay!)

Person A owes <total sum taken out> - <total sum put in> (this is like 10th grade math again. yeay!)

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by kbutler on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:11PM (#18649864)
So Person X makes off as a pure winner in the clawback (doesn't lose Fund Y profits, gets "made whole" of direct losses in clawback) Not "fair" but "legal". Yay!

In real-world experience, rather than 10th-grade story problems, the devil is in the details. Dates are important (you're eligible for recovery of losses from date range, you're liable for recovery from other date range), and Person A is likely to be vulnerable to clawback of earlier profits, even if reinvested and later lost. The profits from the scheme are separate transactions from the later losses in the same scheme. In this case, your simple math would be more fair, but probably not how the legal system would work. Yay!

You can see examples of this in capital gains taxes on people who made and lost a lot in cryptocurrency boom/bust cycles. Arbiters may have a lot of discretion in evaluating claims in these big cases, but I'd rather have the law on my side than relying on the discretion of an arbiter.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by jacobr1 on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:19AM (#18648927)
Sure, that simplifies things and is how the law treats it. But there is still complexity. You have some cases where a single true owner invested via a family office, via different trusts, via feeder funds all at different times with different amounts taken out and different profit and losses. Sometime the profits from one venue are compensation to another. In these scenarios, you can treat them all as separate cases, or you can pull them together and negotiate an umbrella settlement. My understanding is that this has been done when possible, including with some hedge-funds who have purchased a variety of positions and even feeder funds themselves.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by BonesJustice on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:18AM (#18647657)
Or course it’s unfair. There is no ‘fair’ outcome to something like this. Everybody got scammed. The entire ordeal is reprehensible, but what are you going to do?
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by mirimir on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:09AM (#18647966)
It's hard to say, from just TFA. As I read it, their goal is for everyone to at least get back their principal. But the only way to manage that is to claw back withdrawals.

Put another way, they've constructed a but-for world where everyone just invested, but took no returns. Then they distribute everything that's available in proportion to those investments. So as a result, everyone simply lost the same percentage of their investment.

Isn't that fair?

What's confusing, I think, is the idea that they're somehow punishing people who withdrew profits. Because maybe they should have known that they were too good to be true. But I don't think that's relevant. They're just unwinding the thing.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sokoloff on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:54AM (#18648738)
I don't think that is fair exactly as described. Someone who invested $1MM in 1988 should get back more than someone who invested $1MM in 1999, IMO, because their alternative investment would have grown substantially in the interim. IOW, on a then-present-value basis, the 1988 investor invested more.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by mirimir on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:56PM (#18652789)
If there were actual earnings to distribute, adjustments such as you describe would certainly be appropriate. However, it seems likely that, in the aggregate, all investors (as a group) lost. So maybe getting back X% of principal is the only workable approach. And I don't know specifics. Perhaps they're taking stuff like that into account.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by URSpider94 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @12:14AM (#18661561)
It doesn’t work like that. If their alternate investment had gone bankrupt, they would have lost everything instead. Nobody has a right to a risk-free rate of return, if they are chasing higher-risk return rates.

Giving everyone back their capital is about as even-handed as you’re going to get.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sokoloff on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:06PM (#18667769)
If I invested $100 in 1700 and you invested $100 5 minutes ago, my investment was a greater sum in today's money, IMO.

Doesn't matter if we both invested in T-bills (or war bonds), corporate bonds, or equities.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by Animats on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:51PM (#18649691)
Most of the claw-backs involve investors who were heavily involved with marketing the fund and got extra-high returns from it. Stanley Chais, Madoff's front man in Beverly Hills, Jeffery Picower, Madoff's front man in Palm Beach, and J. Ezra Merkin, Madoff's front man in New York's Fifth Avenue Synagogue were the three main individuals. They were not innocent victims.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by Nursie on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:21AM (#18647669)
Not really. The 'profits' were illusory, and effectively the proceeds of crime. What seems fairest here is to try to unwind the entire thing, and return as high a percentage of everyone's money paid-in as possible over the life of the scheme.

Unfortunately it's never going to work out well for everyone - it was a massive fraud.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by mikeash on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:33AM (#18647745)
It’s even more unfair to invest in a fund and get wonderful returns and then years later you’re told that the fund was illegitimate and all of your money is gone.

A crime was committed with numerous victims. It’s not possible to achieve a completely fair outcome for all involved.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by downandout on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:16PM (#18649401)
It is unfair, and may be financially devastating to some people. I would imagine that at least some of these people took their profits, invested them in other things that didn’t pan out, and now are faced with being sued by the trustee for money they no longer have, many years later, through no fault of their own. There should be legal limits on clawbacks in those cases where the target was unaware of the fraud and paying it back will cause them financial ruin.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by TheCondor on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:39AM (#18648177)
In light of how regulated hedge funds are, it doesn’t seem so bad.

I think that if you’re ever insentivized to be ignorant, then that suggests some ethical shenanigans. If someone like Madoff can live the charmed life he had and pay the price while other investors that profit from it can just keep the profits, it creates some very perverse incentives in the market.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by projectramo on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:04AM (#18647572)
Well, it is also unfair to invest in a fund and have your money go out as phantom profits to other investors to boost the very fund. (disclosure: I haven't been in either situation, to my knowledge).

So lets say it is unfair on both sides, but we want to come up with a policy that will optimize behavior in the future. What is the effect of this policy?

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by ABCLAW on Monday December 10, 2018 @02:43PM (#18650602)
Doesn't feel unfair to me.

This is a fairly straightforward application of the principles behind the law of restitution and unjust enrichment. Here, an early Ponzi scheme participant was enriched at the expense of a later Ponzi scheme participant. The remedy is to disgorge the profits of the first so as to make the second whole again.

Here we're upset because we don't believe that the act of investing was 'unjust', but functionally being 'unjust' in this area doesn't necessarily mean 'wrong'. It can mean unjustified, or lacking a proper basis.

Viewed in this way, one's timing within the ambit of a Ponzi scheme would need to be the justification to entitle early participants to outsized profit. Should our legal system lend force to this type of arrangement, or unwind them as best it can?

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by markbnj on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:11AM (#18648867)
It may seem unfair on the surface, but it's a lot less unfair than losing your principle to the same scam that paid out the stolen money as fake returns.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by dangerboysteve on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:53AM (#18649200)
Maybe some of these investors used the proceeds to invest in other legitimate funds, made a profit and benifited from an "interest free loan".
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by agotterer on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:28PM (#18649498)
Or maybe some of those investors used the money to send their kids to college and now they have to re-mortgage their house to cover the clawbacks.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by peteretep on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:28PM (#18653312)
Sure, that sucks. This is why Madoff is in prison. There's no particular reason you shouldn't get just as fucked as everyone else who was invested, just because you took profits at a certain time though.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by Dylan16807 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @01:41AM (#18653605)
Not no reason. You invested in a solvent fund. They invested in an insolvent fund.

You could have a similar thing happen without a scam.

Trying to get everyone back to their original investment is probably the best method overall, but it's a tradeoff.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by scandox on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:56AM (#18647885)
Every investment comes with responsibilities that are also part of the risk profile of the investment.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by paulpauper on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:37AM (#18649074)
it does seem unfair, and I think this is why crpyto currencies may see more adoption, because they are immune to claw-backs. Instead of keeping $100k in a bank, where creditors can take it, put in a crypto, although there is much more volatility.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by short_sells_poo on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:49PM (#18650194)
How exactly do you envision this to work? The government won't care where the client ferreted away the proceeds, they'll just want them back.

Unless the entire funding structure including the currency and all parties in the transaction are completely anonymous and it is impossible to trace the funds to any one person, but then this raises further problems.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by ganzuul on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:21PM (#18649437)
...A version of this is probably already happening in the criminal underground.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by ganzuul on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:14PM (#18649383)
People have bought stock in companies which violently subvert democracy and do irreparable damage to nature, with no consequence. It is good that accountability in finance at least comes this far.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:00AM (#18647541)
Deeply unfair.

The lawyers don't seem to have had to prove that the investors knew that the fund was illegitimate at. My understanding is that the fund was regulated so the assumption should have been that it was legitimate.

I would not be surprised if results in people losing their retirement funds.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by ubernostrum on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:19AM (#18647660)
The analogy to stolen goods is useful.

Generally, if you receive stolen goods, there are two possibilities: you knew they were stolen (read: a prosecutor can convince a jury you knew), in which case you lose the goods and get prosecuted. Or you didn't know they were stolen (read: prosecutors can't convince a jury you knew), in which case you merely lose the goods.

This may seem unfair from the perspective of the unknowing recipient of stolen goods, but letting them keep the goods is equally unfair from the perspective of the original victim, and would feel like the law giving its blessing to the theft (it would also encourage schemes to knowingly but with plausible deniability receive stolen goods). So there's no solution that is guaranteed to appear fair from all perspectives. But the law generally sides with returning the goods to the original owner, effectively undoing the original theft.

In this case, the "investors" who are being targeted by the suits are also getting to keep their own original capital; they're just being required to hand back the ill-gotten gains. So the remedy is effectively undoing the Ponzi scheme.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:15AM (#18648012)
If you buy the stolen goods from a big box retailer that is routinely regulated then this analogy might be useful. As it is it does not apply very well to this situation.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by Retric on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:29PM (#18652907)
Considering the amount of counterfeit goods sold on Amazon I suspect at least some of it was simply stolen. In such a case I would expect the items to be clawed back if possible. Though with the possibility of Amazon making the buyer whole.

That also seems like the correct approach here where anyone running a feeder fund should be on the hook.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @04:28AM (#18654123)
I don't think of a third party selling on Amazon as a big box retailer.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by Retric on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @06:35AM (#18654638)
I consider Amazon as a big box retailer, and commingling means buying from Amazon was identical to buying third party.

Though, I guess that changed over time and I now consider Amazon more a shady market stall.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sseveran on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:04AM (#18647927)
Hedge funds are not regulated the way you think. Mostly the SEC requires the generation of a lot of paperwork and various filings. The SEC does conduct inspections of funds but mostly this is not that big a deal. Remarkably the SEC did inspect Madoff Investments and did not conclude it was a fraud even though it obviously was. I will leave the reader to judge the competence of the SEC but if you are thinking that this was hard to see I would recommend Harry Markopolos's book 'No One Would Listen'.

Ultimately as a potential investor this would have been easy to spot as at least suspect. The first couple of due diligence questions to ask are about custody arrangements and their auditor. Understanding that if you are not an accredited investor you are not allowed to invest in hedge funds also makes it obvious that a fund willing to take your money may be acting fraudulently.

Finally it did result in people losing their retirement funds, for some people absolutely everything.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:14AM (#18648000)
> Remarkably the SEC did inspect Madoff Investments and did not conclude it was a fraud even though it obviously was.

> Ultimately as a potential investor this would have been easy to spot as at least suspect.

You think that even after the SEC failed to spot the fraud investors with far less power should be able to? I don't quite follow your argument here. A little more clarification would be nice.

> Finally it did result in people losing their retirement funds, for some people absolutely everything.

Taking money that people have received 20 years ago off people will also result in some people losing everything. (I know that they say that the people they are extracting the money from are keeping the original investments but what if some of the money has been spent?)

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sseveran on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:21PM (#18652006)
Sure. So simply asking who their auditor is and what the custody arrangements are will tell you a lot. Hedge Funds and other asset managers use a relatively small number of accountants to do their auditing. Madoff used a small family accountancy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_G._Friehling

This is not to excuse the SEC or let them off the hook. The SEC proved to be ultimately grossly incompetent at best, if not negligent or actually complicit. Investors should no more rely on the SEC to protect them than the hens should rely on the fox to protect the henhouse. This has been demonstrated repeatedly.

https://www.barrons.com/articles/when-chinese-stock-fraud-wa... https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB123577641445497313

Finally there is a statute of limitations when clawing back money that people received. I believe in Madoff's case it was two years. Additionally there were a number of lawsuits against a subset of investors that allegedly new about the scheme and profited from it.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-madoff-trustee-opinion/ju...

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @04:23AM (#18654105)
I guess what I am really asking is did the SEC not spot this because it was not their job or because it was their job and they didn't do their job properly?
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sseveran on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @11:36AM (#18656483)
It is probably considered their job but I don't have any confidence in the SEC to proactively investigate anything of real substance. However they did not even have to spot it since Mr. Markopolos turned up with a ton of evidence that it was a Ponzi scheme. They did not even do basic things like verify that he was actually trading.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:54AM (#18662617)
But in this case shouldn't the regulator assume some liability?
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sseveran on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:44PM (#18668021)
The courts in the US have long upheld that law enforcement (and probably by extension, regulators) are under no obligation to protect you.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by URSpider94 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @12:18AM (#18661574)
I listened to a good podcast series on Madoff a couple of years ago. There was good evidence that many of the investors knew that he was running a scam, and were looking the other way as long as they kept getting returns.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by gdfasfklshg4 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:53AM (#18662610)
If anyone can be shown in court to have know it was a scam then they should certainly have any money clawed back off them.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by Cthulhu_ on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:03AM (#18647563)
If the investors couldn't have known it was a scummy practice, then no; if it was approved by the SEC, then the SEC should be responsible for this money because they signed off on it. If the SEC or a similar organization wasn't involved however, then it was the investors' own risk and IMO law enforcement can seize the investments.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by michaelmrose on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:34AM (#18648147)
I cannot imagine how its possible for a regulatory body to be financially liable in place of the actual players for wrongdoing. The economics are wacky. The SEC doesn't get a portion of the profits how is it supposed to secure investors against malfeasance by the actual players?

You are basically asking for the government to insure that nothing bad ever happens and accept unlimited liability if it ever does.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by lifeisstillgood on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:46AM (#18647821)
Good point I guess - was Madoff regulated by any obvious regulator? SEC?