News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sokoloff on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:54AM (#18648738)
I don't think that is fair exactly as described. Someone who invested $1MM in 1988 should get back more than someone who invested $1MM in 1999, IMO, because their alternative investment would have grown substantially in the interim. IOW, on a then-present-value basis, the 1988 investor invested more.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by mirimir on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:56PM (#18652789)
If there were actual earnings to distribute, adjustments such as you describe would certainly be appropriate. However, it seems likely that, in the aggregate, all investors (as a group) lost. So maybe getting back X% of principal is the only workable approach. And I don't know specifics. Perhaps they're taking stuff like that into account.
Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by URSpider94 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @12:14AM (#18661561)
It doesn’t work like that. If their alternate investment had gone bankrupt, they would have lost everything instead. Nobody has a right to a risk-free rate of return, if they are chasing higher-risk return rates.

Giving everyone back their capital is about as even-handed as you’re going to get.

Re:Madoff’s Victims Are Close to Getting Their $19B Back by sokoloff on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:06PM (#18667769)
If I invested $100 in 1700 and you invested $100 5 minutes ago, my investment was a greater sum in today's money, IMO.

Doesn't matter if we both invested in T-bills (or war bonds), corporate bonds, or equities.