Generally, if you receive stolen goods, there are two possibilities: you knew they were stolen (read: a prosecutor can convince a jury you knew), in which case you lose the goods and get prosecuted. Or you didn't know they were stolen (read: prosecutors can't convince a jury you knew), in which case you merely lose the goods.
This may seem unfair from the perspective of the unknowing recipient of stolen goods, but letting them keep the goods is equally unfair from the perspective of the original victim, and would feel like the law giving its blessing to the theft (it would also encourage schemes to knowingly but with plausible deniability receive stolen goods). So there's no solution that is guaranteed to appear fair from all perspectives. But the law generally sides with returning the goods to the original owner, effectively undoing the original theft.
In this case, the "investors" who are being targeted by the suits are also getting to keep their own original capital; they're just being required to hand back the ill-gotten gains. So the remedy is effectively undoing the Ponzi scheme.
That also seems like the correct approach here where anyone running a feeder fund should be on the hook.
Though, I guess that changed over time and I now consider Amazon more a shady market stall.
Ultimately as a potential investor this would have been easy to spot as at least suspect. The first couple of due diligence questions to ask are about custody arrangements and their auditor. Understanding that if you are not an accredited investor you are not allowed to invest in hedge funds also makes it obvious that a fund willing to take your money may be acting fraudulently.
Finally it did result in people losing their retirement funds, for some people absolutely everything.
> Ultimately as a potential investor this would have been easy to spot as at least suspect.
You think that even after the SEC failed to spot the fraud investors with far less power should be able to? I don't quite follow your argument here. A little more clarification would be nice.
> Finally it did result in people losing their retirement funds, for some people absolutely everything.
Taking money that people have received 20 years ago off people will also result in some people losing everything. (I know that they say that the people they are extracting the money from are keeping the original investments but what if some of the money has been spent?)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_G._Friehling
This is not to excuse the SEC or let them off the hook. The SEC proved to be ultimately grossly incompetent at best, if not negligent or actually complicit. Investors should no more rely on the SEC to protect them than the hens should rely on the fox to protect the henhouse. This has been demonstrated repeatedly.
https://www.barrons.com/articles/when-chinese-stock-fraud-wa... https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB123577641445497313
Finally there is a statute of limitations when clawing back money that people received. I believe in Madoff's case it was two years. Additionally there were a number of lawsuits against a subset of investors that allegedly new about the scheme and profited from it.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-madoff-trustee-opinion/ju...
The lawyers don't seem to have had to prove that the investors knew that the fund was illegitimate at. My understanding is that the fund was regulated so the assumption should have been that it was legitimate.
I would not be surprised if results in people losing their retirement funds.