No.
I don’t know if any of the 10 investments i made in 2018 are Ponzi schemes. I have to rely on regulations and hope companies like Lending Club are legit, I don’t pour over their paper work or hiring private investigators to figure out how they do their business. It would be silly to confiscate my profits because Lending Club turned out to be shady. Me hiring a fund to produce returns on investment is no different than hiring a painter to paint a room.
update
all good points in replies. i stand corrected on my understanding of this issue :)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veil_of_ignorance
> "It would be silly to confiscate my profits because Lending Club turned out to be shady"
It would be even sillier for you to lose literally everything because Lending Club turned out to be shady.
Madoff's fund wasn't regulated, too. If you buy a house or stocks, you are into a regulated market.
Edit : by "regulated" I probably meant public. Not sure if the english term is correct ; one may want to check Shiller's course about hedge funds on youtube. My point being, those funds are only accessible to the very rich who will never spend their principal.
the case for returning the property in this situation is more practical than moral. that is, it's probably just easier to just find the guy with the car and take it than to extract money from a deadbeat car salesman who probably doesn't have it anymore. I find these sorts of legal things distasteful, but I guess I can see why we have them.
in an ideal world, I think there should be some sort of safe harbor protection for people who make a reasonable effort in good faith to check that a transaction is bona fide.
Remember, you may be an innocent victim, but someone, somewhere, had the car stolen from them and they may not have had insurance on it.
In short, if the last purchaser got to keep the car, that means he would be less risk averse to buying from car dealers with risky reputations, effectively increasing the market for stolen cars. And this increase in the market would result in more stolen cars overall.
The existing default rule is, of course, based on a judgment that we won't be worse off in a world where people can fraudulently claim that their car is stolen and then get it back while also capturing the sale profit. Considering that most people are law abiding and have very good reason already to protect their car from theft regardless of which default rule we choose, it's not a bad rule on its face.
> in an ideal world, I think there should be some sort of safe harbor protection for people who make a reasonable effort in good faith to check that a transaction is bona fide.
It sounds like you may have a legal education given the language you're using. IIRC this is how the rule for real estate works in the presence of land registration systems. We flip the default rule to incentivize recordation. If two fraudulent sales are made by a seller back-to-back before title is recorded, it's the last purchaser who gets the property. This incentivizes each purchaser to record his purchase as quickly as possible, and to do so in a manner that closes the window for a fraudulent sale, such as by keeping payment in escrow until recordation is successful. (See, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bona_fide_purchaser)
You...should probably do more diligence if you’re investing your money in Lending Club. Treasuries and CDS are the thoughtless investment option.
Unwinding /anything/ from a decade ago is non-trivial.
It's even possible (likely?) that some direct Madoff investors were also customers of the funds that have money being clawed back.
They all are. That’s the point. This is taking Money from those who got out of Madoff’s fund soon enough, and giving to those later investors who paid for the imaginary profits.
> that some Madoff investors.
You omitted the word "direct" (why?)
Person X invests in a fund Y that invests with Madoff and gets out soon enough. Person X then invests those gains "directly" with Madoff. Person X loses money with Madoff. How much does Person X deserve (or owe)?
Another example would be Person A who invests $N in the scheme. Takes out $10N principal & profits (as a test that the scheme is authentic). Invests that $10N and even more in the scheme, loses it.
How much do you claw back for (or from?) Person A?
As to your examples:
Person X is irrelevant. You claw back the money from fund Y. Fund Y may, in turn, have arrangements with person X requiring them to return any money, but that's actually tangential. (this is like 1st-semester law again, yeay!)
Person A owes <total sum taken out> - <total sum put in> (this is like 10th grade math again. yeay!)
In real-world experience, rather than 10th-grade story problems, the devil is in the details. Dates are important (you're eligible for recovery of losses from date range, you're liable for recovery from other date range), and Person A is likely to be vulnerable to clawback of earlier profits, even if reinvested and later lost. The profits from the scheme are separate transactions from the later losses in the same scheme. In this case, your simple math would be more fair, but probably not how the legal system would work. Yay!
You can see examples of this in capital gains taxes on people who made and lost a lot in cryptocurrency boom/bust cycles. Arbiters may have a lot of discretion in evaluating claims in these big cases, but I'd rather have the law on my side than relying on the discretion of an arbiter.
I think your objection would be valid if, for example, they sued contractors that were paid to renovate Madoff's office (and being paid with customers' money).
But as it is, I think the veil of ignorance might serve as a guide. Consider: You are informed that, before his untimely death in a completely unnecessary re-enactment of Wilhelm Tell's apple-related stunts (only this time with LSD), your great-granduncle invested $10,000,000 of the profits made from his seminal literary addition to the comin-of-age canon into Madoff's funds. You do not know if he ever found the clarity of mind to withdraw any funds. Would you choose the $10 million, or prefer a 50% chance at $20 million?
(the diminishing marginal value of money also comes into play here).