News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:17AM (#18457490)
Yep. Every time people say "Americans don't want to do these jobs" or anything else suggesting that there is a labor shortage in some sector I always mentally append the phrase "at the price you want to pay".
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by stevenicr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:52AM (#18457611)
Saw an article yesterday, some expert, something like "2 in X working age adults don't want a job / don't want to work" - also skill sets need updating and who should pay to train employees needs debating, maybe a fed subsidy..

Around the city I live in, the past 6 months wages have started to increase a bit, some chain restaurants now have banners out front "starting at $12/hour". Many places are short staffed and lose business because of it.

Problem is, the living wage here has increased to around $23 / hour.

I'm sure you could live in one of the slums for less, and you could be on the section 8 waiting list for 2 years hoping to live for less if you can couch surf and bridge sleep while waiting...

mit's living wage calc says an adult can living wage here for $11.24 / hour - I've tried to help people find cheap housing options in town several times the past two years and I just don't see how those numbers work out.

The calculator says 1 adult 1 child, $22.77 per hour - that seems more doable, although I think most people living here would be spending much more than $11,508 on housing, so at that rate they would be sacrificing healthcare and probably transportation or whatever to make it work.

People don't want to work full time and not be able to afford basic necessities.

Another problem is so many jobs say they drug test, but there is (at least not that I have found yet) not a job listing site or category for "Smiling faces" aka 'we don't test for weed in your system as long as you toke at home and don't show up with red eyes / moving slow with a bag of chips in hand.'

So yeah, try paying more for sure. Get more realistic with labeling jobs.

In some cases making transportation free would get you some excellent workers who can't afford $20 per day for ubers but want to work further from their apartment where you job is.

I've watched many here struggle to find rides to work and jobs that are $5 or under for uber to get there.

There is more that can be done for sure. As so many places try to not pay well, I see more and more that are closed when they should be open, or running slow and losing business because they are short staffed.

Certainly steak and shake could pay $20 an hour for third shift workers if it meant they could stay open and make many times that.

Things I've been noticing in this growing city are not indicative of the whole country / world - so whatever bias yeah I know.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by nostrebored on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:39AM (#18457769)
As someone who grew up in a house of 4 that spent multiple years living off of a single unemployment check, you'd be surprised at how easily you can fall into a very low spending pattern when you have to.

Slums in the US can be fine. If it's just surface level disrepair that's fine. The real issue is cultural, especially if you have kids.

You haven't said which city you're in, but I think the number of cities in the US where it wouldn't be possible to live alone on $25,000 a year is actually quite low.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by stevenicr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:41AM (#18458496)
I respect your experience growing up. I have had similar situations over the years including some growing up, and been close friends with many and watched how it can "work".

Living for years by skipping oil changes, hair cuts, dental health, bald tires, all those things - not good for the family or the community really, but it can be done.

Not sure how long ago it was for you and where, but I know that things are harder today money wise than they were when I was growing up, in several ways. Aside from gas being under $1 / gallon and food prices and such being different, there was not the need for broadband internet and some other modern day "staples" -

without getting into a debate about the need for $200/mth cable not being a need, and other things, the divide has greater effects socially / in schools etc I believe. You did mention the issue is cultural and these things are part of that I guess.

The city I describe is my experience in Nashville TN - before out last full term mayor, perhaps around the time you were growing up? - apartments near the airport area could be found around $600 /mth - they weren't the best, but they did not have gangs blocking the corners either.

A decade of hastened gentrification and it's hard to find decent apartments for double the old price. Gas, food, and other things have gone up - yet for many going from $8 /hr to $12 an hour is not going to get you far around here these days.

I think it's easier for me to think that guys would have an easier time living on $25k per year, and that many women would find the living conditions with that kind of money with today's prices around here to be tough to live with.

The few cheap places to live around the city, and even the next county or two over, are likely to be less safe than one of the gated communities down the road from Miley's or Taylor's places.

I've been expanding my searches to the middle of the state and looking at other states to find affordable places to suggest people consider looking. There are some trailers about 2 hours from here for about $400/mth - but the utilities will be high, especially this time of the year.

Of course people living two hours away are not likely going to come to the city to fill these jobs at $12 /hr.

So I guess those businesses who want to keep paying less than a living wage around here need to consider that the pool of people willing to work those jobs are people who can't get a better gig, so probably male, willing to live in sketchy places, likely can't pass a drug test or they would get a home depot gig or similar.

With such a small pool to draw from, some kind of perks will need to be advertised, like comped transportation, no drug tests, etc.

There are plenty of places around town that I walk out of or choose not to go to, knowing that the labor making the food, or cleaning, or watching kids, or all kinds of important things, is probably not the best choice for important things like food safety, etc.

I also get that this can be a cultural thing, and different strokes for different folks and all that. I'd really love to see the monthly spending budgets of lots of the people around here that work for under $22, it just doesn't seem possible in most parts around here, and certainly not sustainable long term.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by rorykoehler on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:07AM (#18458383)
Health insurance?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mooreds on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:41AM (#18458498)
Medicaid is an option, especially if you have kids. Google found this, which seems useful: https://www.policygenius.com/blog/a-state-by-state-guide-to-...
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by murph-almighty on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:43AM (#18459131)
>Another problem is so many jobs say they drug test, but there is (at least not that I have found yet) not a job listing site or category for "Smiling faces" aka 'we don't test for weed in your system as long as you toke at home and don't show up with red eyes / moving slow with a bag of chips in hand.'

I'm kind of shocked this doesn't exist yet, but then again, I can understand why a company might not want to openly advertise that they don't drug test.

In my (very) limited experience, employers will usually say they drug test but never really follow up on it. It usually took me a bit more effort to find out if I was going to get tested or not, and even then it's a bit of an awkward conversation to have because it implies there's a reason you want to dodge the test.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by stevenicr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:21PM (#18463473)
Ive been racking my brain how to make this, perhaps crowd source info.. scrape listing for a while. Then make it premium to advertise premium spots.

Mainly it would be good for society - saving people lots of time, and getting more people working, and more jobs filled.

I've noticed some employers do tests on application, then don't again for years. I've witnessed people losing jobs when they ran afoul of office politics, then suddenly a test was 'randomly' given.

I think some places around here use some kind of percentages thinking to say, 'if we drug test applicants, make them use an internet portal to apply, and give one of those personality quizzes before an interview' - we can be sure that 99% of our applicants will be white.

I can't say for sure that is what is going on at some places around here, I don't have any inside info saying exactly that - but, when you have a place that needs help doing oil changes and they put up all those hoops to jump through, you have wonder what their target worker market is and why. Maybe they just don't want 'white trash' people under cars getting greasy.

Anyhow, a "smile and work" portal would be beneficial to society imho. Maybe more so in busy cities.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:35AM (#18458481)
> not a job listing site or category for "Smiling faces" aka 'we don't test for weed in your system

Why's this called 'smiling faces'?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by stevenicr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:12PM (#18463386)
Because I've noticed that fast food places and similar use signage saying "now hiring smiling faces" - implying you just have to show up to work.

No experience required, not discriminating on your criminal history or ability to pass a drug test..

at least that's the way I've been seeing it. As opposed so other jobs; home depot advertises drug testing on the front door. Plumbing places have "all employees drug screened / background checked" - some places have "bachelors degree or equiv"..

Some places have no paper application, requiring you to have internet access to apply - and then computer "personality tests" to be considered for interview.

In my (admittedly limited) experience, many of these things are saying they are trying to discriminate in one way or another, but "now hiring smiling faces" is kind of the bat signal for the X in 10 people who don't fair well with drug tests and criminal background tests, etc.

If you are aware of a similar moniker or whatever, I'd like to know. I've been trying to help people get jobs around town for years and have seriously been considering crowd sourcing a green friendly job board - there are lots of decent people out there that want to work but have been repeatedly beaten down by so many time wasters out there.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:47PM (#18464635)
Sounds like a good idea, but I wouldn't market with this 'smiling faces' name as I have never seen nor heard of the concept and it took you five paragraphs to explain what it means :)
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by SQL2219 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:43AM (#18458782)
He might be referring to stock photo websites, you know the kind.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by grigjd3 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:00AM (#18459700)
Your town doesn't have a bus?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by stevenicr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:32PM (#18463582)
yes we have buses all over. Some cool maps and stuff for them too. But, the timing and such is limited. (also serious lack of sidewalks, bus stop covers and other issues)

recently... girl lives near the airport, has job at X big box store, 12 minute drive from here. Bus routes from here take you down to 'antioch' then back into the city, where you need to junction with another bus to get back a few miles south of city.

Depending on time of day, the scheduling puts it at 2 hours 20 minutes to get to work. When big box store needs you to be there at open, you need to leave for work at 3am... but no buses run at 3, so you have to leave at 11pm to get to work at 6am.

Getting home via bus is easier though.

admittedly the bus service does take care of certain 'economically challenged" areas better - if you live in Antioch you can jump on a bus to get downtown in much less time. If you needed to connect to go south again, it's still silly, but shaves about 30 minutes off (one hour fifty minutes).

I long for the day of smart voltron like buses, guess I should post about it since our city just cant get transport right.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mruts on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:39AM (#18458757)
Clearly the solution is just raise the minimum wage to $35/hr ala Elizabeth Warren
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sovietmudkipz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:07AM (#18459296)
I know you say this statement in sarcasm but I'd like to explore this world.

If minimum wage was $35/hr I bet quite a few things would happen.

Entrenched, successful businesses would support the change. Their competition struggle to afford competing. Businesses will close down, further entrenching the competition.

Jobs will disappear. Just like how the wage hike for New York car washers displaced workers though automation, many businesses will have an even higher economic incentive to replace workers with automation solutions.

Some jobs just won't pull in enough to make it worth it. Why pay someone $74,000/yr to take orders at a restaurant when you can pay for a $50,000 and ~$20,000/yr in maintenance.

Young workers will be out competed by older workers. If you're paying $35/hr, you want the best bang for your buck. Why take a risk on some 16 year old when you have retired 56 year olds who would be willing to pay for their medication working fast food. Or heck, why go into engineering when a basic job gets you above average pay? Where will the younger generation get a chance to develop the soft skillset that allows for future success in their careers?

Naturally, I'm failing to consider the long term economic effects. For example; harder earned skillsets will be paid much more than low skillsets. If the supply chain is paying massively for a work force, then the price of goods & services will go up dramatically. It's harder to puzzle this sort of stuff out!

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by JamesBarney on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:27PM (#18461851)
Just in case anyone reads this and gets the wrong impression. Elizabeth Warren wasn't arguing for a $35/hr minimum wage, but just making a point that if the minimum wage had increased at the same rate as the earnings for the top 1% it would be at $33/hr. She was actually arguing for a $10/hr minimum wage.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by gruez on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:15AM (#18459340)
>raise the minimum wage to $35/hr ala Elizabeth Warren

https://www.google.com/search?q=Elizabeth+warren+35+minimum+...

???

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by choot on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:06AM (#18457902)
I think once companies have got taste of cheap foreign labor, it becomes difficult to convince them to pay more.

They are always looking to do some complex maneuver to get foreign labor doing work cheaply for them. This is why they are complaining.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by amelius on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:33AM (#18458472)
Yeah, while you are working, your boss is busy trying to outsource your job.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by wolco on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:31AM (#18458706)
Everyone has a job
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by EForEndeavour on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:10AM (#18459306)
Until they're outsourced.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:14PM (#18463970)
> They are always looking to do some complex maneuver to get foreign labor doing work cheaply for them.

What kinds of maneuvers? The only way you can get foreign workers to work for you is to convince them to leave whatever it is they're currently doing.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by snarf21 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:28AM (#18459973)
I agree with you but I would also say these systems are complicated. Raising wages can also lead to raising prices and at the end of the day what people really want is more buying power. People want manufacturing jobs back in the US at $30/hour rates for people with no experience but then also want to buy these kinds of goods at the dollar store. These things are very incompatible. People always want it both ways. People also want the perfect job 5 minutes from where they already live (understandably) even though it may be cheaper to have people in WV do that same job.

Even thinking about more practical things like food harvesting, these jobs can pay ~$15/hour but they are REALLY hard work as that rate isn't guaranteed but rather performance based. If we had to pay even $25/hour to attract unemployed US workers to do these jobs instead of migrants, this would cause a likely doubling of the cost of all the produce you buy. We all have to ask, "Are we willing to pay double for fruits and vegetables to create decent paying jobs for other citizens?" I think the answer is that we are clearly not. The same question goes for services we use constantly like Amazon and Uber. The people doing the work are vastly underpaid and that is exactly where our savings come from!

For tech, I think the training path is the right thing. Employers do have to be careful to not spend tons training people just to have them leave. I firmly believe the right answer is apprenticeships. People do work as they learn and their wage rises slowly with the experience and ability to create value. The risk of them leaving is minimized as they have already created corporate value.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:39AM (#18460688)
I think what you're really hitting on there is the global competitive equilibrium. If we couldn't hire migrants to pick fruit, our farm businesses simply couldn't compete on price (also subsidies). But standard economic theory would say "don't compete then! do something else".
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by war1025 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:23PM (#18462929)
They had a piece on NPR a week or two ago where a vegetable farmer said he'd love to hire locals instead of migrants because you have to pay to house the migrants, which actually makes them more expensive. But none of the locals want to do the work.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:13PM (#18463962)
> But none of the locals want to do the work.

"...at the price he wants to pay".

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by war1025 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:23PM (#18464037)
More so the price the market would bear, but yes.

There is also no denying that people are less willing to do hard labor than they used to be.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:07PM (#18464343)
> More so the price the market would bear, but yes.

That really depends on the elasticity of demand for that thing. Usually when a thing costs more to produce than you can sell it for, we say that the market shouldn't produce that thing then, so there's nothing to complain about.

> There is also no denying that people are less willing to do hard labor than they used to be.

By which you mean "less willing to do hard labor as cheaply", presumably.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by war1025 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:43PM (#18464604)
No I mean strictly less willing to do hard labor. The social safety nets in America may not be great, but most people would prefer to deal with that rather than do back breaking labor. And if you are not in that situation, you would rather do a different job that would pay equivalently. It used to be that your options were do what you had to or starve. Not starving is a good motivator.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:08PM (#18465257)
> No I mean strictly less willing to do hard labor.

That isn't a thing, unless you're saying that there is no price whatsoever at which people would be willing to do hard labor.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by war1025 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:24PM (#18466111)
There is no point at which people would be doing to both do the labor and others would still buy the resulting product at an increased price.

You are dealing in a hypothetical where there aren't market forces at work.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Friday November 16, 2018 @11:57AM (#18469936)
> There is no point at which people would be doing to both do the labor and others would still buy the resulting product at an increased price.

Exactly! Which means the good or service shouldn't be produced.

> You are dealing in a hypothetical where there aren't market forces at work.

Erm, no. This is what market forces are. Market forces decide what is and what is not produced, via exactly this mechanism. This is the very essence of what a market is.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by devoply on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:27AM (#18457511)
There are many usually smaller sized businesses that simply won't work because of the nature of their economics and would cease to exist if you raise pay too much. There are though many other businesses of larger size that earn multiples on each employee and could afford to pay them much more and pay the shareholders and execs much less or nothing.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by CM30 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:33AM (#18457544)
Isn't the answer then that said businesses simply shouldn't be trying to hire too many new employees yet, or should shut down? Because at the end of the day, if your company can't function without underpaying employees, then perhaps it's simply not a sustainable business/not sustainable to hire that many employees yet.

If a company's business model doesn't work, then it shouldn't really stay open/continue to exist.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sinxoveretothex on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:41AM (#18458286)
I think the question you should be asking is why are people taking these "too low" wage jobs?

Companies do close down all the time because expenses are higher than revenues. Restaurants are a very well-known industry where that is super common (and it's not because restaurants tend to pay exhorbitant wages). It's literally a meme to accountants that having a restaurant as a client is a good way to never get paid (they may close down in the 30 days after delivery they are typically given to pay you).

Also, in a way, we already "shut down" companies that pay too little: you just can't even offer to pay someone 2$/hour. The question I'd ask is "who would take that job if it were allowed?"

In essence, having low wage jobs should never be an issue: if you're of the opinion that these companies shouldn't exist in the first place, you're essentially saying that those workers have better options already available. Do we really need to fire them to get them to go for those?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by FranzFerdiNaN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:36AM (#18458485)
Because capitalism forces them between a job that does not pay enough and no money to buy food and housing and clothing and such.

The solution is of course something like a basic income to liberate people and break the power of companies.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by minikites on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:27AM (#18458447)
>you're essentially saying that those workers have better options already available

If you're following the fable of capitalism, those people should start their own, more efficient businesses if none are available.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sinxoveretothex on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:17PM (#18463434)
Yes? Or just get hired by one? Or change field? Or move?

It's no fable. Some of us don't have what it takes to start their own company, that's true.

Probably there is no hope for some. I don't know how you'd show that there is a system that doesn't suffer from this problem. I mean, you'd have to show that even with less incentive to produce and more demand for products (since everyone is owed "decent living" or whatever it's called nowadays), there is no possibility for demand to exceed production.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by dingaling on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:59AM (#18457866)
Or they could invest in training instead of expecting perfectly-qualified staff to walk in the door.

Every week I see job ads with "${INDUSTRY_CERTIFICATION} essential". Companies are lazy and spendthrift and have some illusion of a vast labour market just itching to retrain themselves in MIG welding or whatever.

The last ad I remember that said "full training will be given " was for a bakery!

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by pytester on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:35AM (#18458262)
Training requires loyalty to work - if companies can't expect trained personnel to stay then the investment is pure overhead.

To be fair, it's corporate America that burned that bridge in the 80s with layoff culture, citing "economic efficiency".

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:55AM (#18458858)
Companies can still reverse that trend. I work for one where many of my coworkers measure their employment there in decades. You can imagine what I thought recently when I interviewed somewhere where the interviewers had a collective 3 years under their belt.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by watwut on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:57AM (#18459228)
On the job training within work hours is damm large perk. I don't get why you all talk about it as if people would run away from such companies.

Allow me to learn on the job and I will be reluctant to leave for company that don't.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ForHackernews on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:30AM (#18458460)
You could build some measure of "loyalty" into a contract:

* We train you for six months and pay you full salary.

* You have to work for us for two years past the end of your training period.

* If you leave before that, you owe us 50% of salary from the training period. (or whatever)

In a competitive market, you might even see other companies willing to buy employees out of their contracts.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by k_sh on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:26AM (#18458676)
This would be illegal in some (most?) places - labor laws ban employers from clawing back pay for almost any reasons.

In California, for example, you can't even dock someone's final paycheck if they fail to return a uniform - if someone worked the time to earn a wage and you don't pay them in full, you're going to find yourself in court.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by jeffasinger on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:53AM (#18459199)
Depending on the industry, if the training is somewhat universal (like in the mig welding example) it's possible employers could offer 0% interest loans for training, with forgiveness after some payback period as part an offer.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by rocannon on Friday November 16, 2018 @08:55AM (#18468731)
There are different ways of doing this, though. E.g. some law firms will pay off student loan debt as long as you're working for them: https://www.usnews.com/education/best-graduate-schools/payin...

It's kind of mental accounting for the employee, though. The law firm is basically giving you an extra $100 or whatever per paycheck. However, this $100 is earmarked to pay off your law school debt, so in effect the company is helping to pay for your training.

The nice part for the company is that they do not take on any risk paying for the training: the employee already shouldered all the risk for paying for law school. The company buys a little bit of loyalty by helping the employee pay off the debt over time. It probably makes the employee think twice before quitting or looking for other employment; it is similar to the health insurance benefit in that respect.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ForHackernews on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:54AM (#18458856)
I'm not familiar with CA labor laws, but money is fungible so it could be just be structured as "This is a three year contract, and if you quit early, you're in breach and owe us $X".

Then it's not "clawing back" pay, it's just a fine for breach of contract.

I do think laws should prevent low-wage employers from screwing over their employees for piddling stuff like uniforms, but I think that's different than something like a professional apprenticeship.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by nradov on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:22AM (#18459387)
That wouldn't be an enforceable contract. Contacts require some consideration on both sides to be legally valid. However if the training is provided by a third party then the employer may be able to pay for it as a forgivable loan with the balance being written off if the employee stays for a couple years.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by anticensor on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:35PM (#18462494)
That would be deception against the court of law. Very bad if caught.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ForHackernews on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:23PM (#18463489)
I'm still not clear why people are claiming this would run afoul of labor laws. IANAL, but sibling comment claims that a contract needs "consideration" on both sides, but surely the value of the training, and the value of a guaranteed term of employment are both considerations?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by siftikha on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:12AM (#18459808)
Repayable bonuses are legal in basically every state
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:40AM (#18458760)
>Because at the end of the day, if your company can't function without underpaying employees, then perhaps it's simply not a sustainable business/not sustainable to hire that many employees yet.

Do you think the employees would prefer being unemployed or being underpaid? The business closing doesn't magically create new, better-paying jobs for them. If better-paying jobs existed that they were capable of doing, they'd already be doing those instead.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:52AM (#18458842)
> Do you think the employees would prefer being unemployed or being underpaid?

Depends on how underpaid doesn't it? There's a line for everyone where all that work just isn't worth still not being able to afford a decent standard of living.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:31AM (#18459057)
>There's a line for everyone where all that work just isn't worth still not being able to afford a decent standard of living.

Then shouldn't this be up to the workers in question to decide? Closing their low-paying workplaces just cuts down their options, it doesn't create new jobs for them.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by androidgirl on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:58AM (#18459678)
Workers do decide on things such as the minimum wage, through voting. If a business wants to offer more pay to attract more employees, that's their call and their right.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:03AM (#18459727)
>Workers do decide on things such as the minimum wage, through voting.

That's a much weaker form of decide. A vote only means at least 50% of voters wanted it, so you can only say with certainty that there's a 50%+ chance that any given voter wants it. Whereas if a worker has chosen to work for a particular salary, there's a 100% chance he's chosen that as nobody else can make that decision for him.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by C1sc0cat on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:28AM (#18457992)
And rely of corporate welfare or working tax credits as its known in the UK - I don't mid my taxes paying for nurse doctor or teacher training subsidising Starbucks baristas not so much
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Delmania on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:28AM (#18458690)
> subsidising Starbucks baristas not so much

I'd recommend you read the Power of Habit. The author talks about the training program Starbucks puts its employees through to build willpower.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by NullPrefix on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:22AM (#18458430)
Should punctuation training come from welfare money?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by gpderetta on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:56AM (#18458866)
Welfare, no. Education budget, definitely.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by merpnderp on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:06AM (#18459758)
You perfectly make the point that the true minimum wage is $0/hour. Raising minimum wage has often reduced the number of jobs, often creating black markets of cash workers who often compete directly against people not allowed to legally work in US, further depressing wages.

The real question is if a worker and an employer agree to a pay rate, why do you get to call it "underpaying"? Are they not adults, ostensibly free to live their lives how they see fit?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by closetohome on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:16PM (#18462288)
This has always been the argument against companies who claim they can't survive without using undocumented immigrant labor.

If your business model relies entirely on not paying your employees reasonable wages, maybe your business model is a failure.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by txsoftwaredev on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:45PM (#18464193)
There will always be a need to employee low IQ individuals, developmentally disabled, etc. Would you prefer those types not have a viable option for employment?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by devoply on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:36AM (#18457558)
Maybe. From an overall perspective of entrepreneurship and job creation no. The reason being that many companies are bootstrapped on the backs of cheap labor until they reach a point where they can sustain jobs. You are basically saying that bootstrapping should never happen and you should always have investors to create companies... unless maybe if the founder can make a company based around a very small team work somehow who are working for next to nothing for equity.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by SimonPStevens on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:57AM (#18457632)
But where is the line? Can I import hundreds of people to manually have them dig coal out of the ground with their bare hands because I can't afford the machinery yet and claim I'm bootstrapping a mining business. We would typically call this exploitation.

Many types of business can't be bootstrapped. That is not unusual. Bootstrapping is primarily a popular approach now due to easy computer automation that makes a small subset of companies viable with the very small staff and no expensive hardware. It certainly isn't a default across all industries.

The labour pool is a market. You are not entitled to cheap labour just because you want it. If you can't find someone willing to do your work at the rate you want to pay it's because someone else is paying more for the same work, so you need to pay more to attract the labour.

Importing people from abroad is something that only exists as a solution because of the imbalance of development levels around the world right now. I expect that this is an anomaly that we are going to see correct itself in time once all countries reach a similer level of development. Where will you import your cheap labour from then?

In the UK we used to employ children to work in the mines and the mills. This was eventually realised to be exploitative and made illegal. I'd bet that all the business owners at the time complained how would they ever be profitable without the cheap child labour. But they either adjust or die, and I'm happy with that tradeoff. If a business is only viable with child labour I would prefer it didn't exist at all.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:50AM (#18457824)
> Importing people from abroad is something that only exists as a solution because of the imbalance of development levels around the world right now. I expect that this is an anomaly that we are going to see correct itself in time once all countries reach a similer level of development.

This has never been the case in the past; there is no reason to expect it in the future.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ben_w on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:20AM (#18458198)
Disagree. In the past, “abroad” was physically closer and in what is now the same country. Londoners can pay the Welsh less, but they can’t go on literal slave-gathering raids c. 999 AD.

It’s all a matter of degree. Degree of progress, degree of wage difference, etc.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:28AM (#18458230)
The definition of "abroad" is of no interest. The world has always been the same size. There has never been a time when all countries / regions / whatever-you-like were at a similar level of development, and there is no reason to expect that such a thing will or could happen.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by tremon on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:54AM (#18458542)
The world has always been the same size

Not in terms of travel distance or the speed of human movement (remember when "around the world in 80 days" was an actual accomplishment, worthy of fantasizing about?)

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sanxiyn on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:34AM (#18458479)
Less developed countries tend to have higher growth rate, so there is a reason to expect convergence.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by emiliobumachar on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:42AM (#18458769)
But there are large - sometimes huge - steps back, e.g. Venezuela. Any reason to think they'll stop happening?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sam0x17 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:47AM (#18459582)
There is every reason to expect it. Compare now with 20 years ago, 50 years ago, 100 years ago, 200 years ago. The graph is exponential.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:49PM (#18464655)
If everywhere develops at the same exponential rate, you can easily see that the gaps in level of development constantly grow over time. Exponential growth is not meaningful for this question.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sgt101 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:23AM (#18458663)
Well - the sharp and unexpected decline of fertility levels globally reported in the news last week : https://www.bbc.com/news/health-46118103

Also the improvement of economic conditions in some parts of the world will mean competition for labour globally.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Retric on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:27AM (#18458222)
Having a few poor countries is not enough to balance things. The global economy is currently balanced on having billions of very low wage workers, but low wage workers push an economy forward so it’s not a stable equilibrium. Either workers send money home via remittances, or work in their own country kick starting the economy.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sgt101 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:24AM (#18458664)
I think that rule of law and development of institutions (cf. Chinas progress vs Africa's progress) are the drivers of economic development.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Retric on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:57AM (#18460922)
Without the rule of law, you don't end up with large scale factories. Corruption is kind of a sliding scale, but factory workers take infrastructure in a way that oil does not.

That said some African countries are actually doing rather well. Botswana has seen real economic growth ranking in the top in terms of GDP PPP, just ahead of China, and that's without oil.

PS: Africa's population density is also much lower due to war and corruption. Overall, it's 1.216 billion over 11.73 million mi² vs say 1.339 billion in India in 1.269 million mi² so about 10x the population density. China at 1.386 billion over 3.705 million mi² is again 5x Africa

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by NeedMoreTea on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:47AM (#18457594)
Bootstrapped usually means cheap labour of the founders, as part of the risk they took founding the business. Not paying unreasonably low wages to all around.

Job creation comes after the business has become self-sustaining.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by starbeast on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:41AM (#18457781)
Recently got told by some founders doing a farming technology startup that nobody gets paid because "We don't even pay ourselves!", but if I would like to volunteer my time doing automation and robotics R&D, then that would be great.

I always think that you should account a startup as though you are going to be paying everyone properly even when you cannot, and then start to pay out based on a combination of need and who has the oldest outstanding credit, when money starts to appear.

If you do this, then your company accounts are actually useful documents that you can project costs off going forward and actually attract investment, rather than living in some optimistic dreamland where the numbers you have do not represent anything like the actual costs of running the business properly.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by imtringued on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:54AM (#18458096)
Those founders are getting paid by having 100% ownership in the business. If in 5 years the business becomes profitable then the original unpaid employees won't see any of that money.

The only way this payment structure can be morally sound is by treating every unpaid employee as a founder and giving them an equal share of the company.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:37PM (#18463628)
This is called "working for venture". I have seen it (once) explicitly stated as the terms of employment.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by consp on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:50AM (#18457826)
> Recently got told by some founders doing a farming technology startup that nobody gets paid because "We don't even pay ourselves!", but if I would like to volunteer my time doing automation and robotics R&D, then that would be great.

So they are saying you should do slave-labor? I hope they expected to give you plenty of equity (which is cheap as the company is worthless as there is no money being made yet), otherwise it would be idiotic to expect people to work without compensation.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by briandear on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:01AM (#18457645)
Businesses are bootstrapped on the backs of the founders who exchange high personal risk for potential reward. I have had a bootstrapped company and my employees always got paid first and correctly. I don’t hire people unless I can pay them what they fairly cost. Any shortfalls came from my pocket and savings and never on the backs of my team. Maybe I am an outlier. It seems to me that the Amazons and Ubers of the world are built upon “cheap” labor more so than bootstrapped companies. Those types of companies have a competitive advantage from their access to cheap labor that is magnified at scale. Your typical bootstrapped company isn’t at the scale where exploitive labor makes much sense.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by kristianc on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:45AM (#18457587)
You’re welcome to set up a company and pay yourself as little as you want - that doesn’t mean you can compel others to accept mediocre wages too.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Thiez on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:34AM (#18457748)
Not a native speaker, but doesn't mediocre mean average? Surely most people are working for a mediocre salary or less?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:48AM (#18457811)
In modern American usage, mediocre is a pejorative word. To Horace, aurea mediocritas was a good thing, but we translate that as "golden mean" because mediocrity is, by definition, bad. The sense of "middle" has been lost.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sam0x17 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:50AM (#18459614)
It goes deeper than that. Average is viewed as negative in American culture. When people say mediocre they are thinking "eww average" in the back of their mind.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by consp on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:47AM (#18457808)
Normally yes, but it is also used as a degenerate term, though in this case other words might have been a better choice.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by roel_v on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:05AM (#18457900)
Didn't you get the memo? Our goal is to pay everyone above-average wages! Anything else is a terrible injustice!
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:50AM (#18457607)
Businesses aren't bootstrapped on the back of cheap labor. They're bootstrapped on the back of high cost variance labor. They're paid in equity that may be worth nothing or may be worth a lot. You convince people based on the merit of your idea. They evaluate whether or not your idea has a sufficiently high probability of success to be worth their time. The labor isn't cheap, it's just not paid for with cash.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by adrianN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:11AM (#18457678)
I think historically a lot of businesses were bootstrapped on cheap labor.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by roel_v on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:08AM (#18457913)
If someone starting a business works many hours themselves for $2/hour, and asks their spouse/children to chip in, and calls in favors from family and friends to get things going - then that's bootstrapping on cheap labor, but nobody in their right mind would call that 'slavery'. When starting a business when you have nothing, you have to be frugal, yet you can't do everything alone - that doesn't mean all ways you can get work done at below-market rates are sleazy or immoral.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by rusk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:57AM (#18457855)
Not meaning to be facaetious, but this sounds like something an 18th Century sugar plantation owner might say.

Historically, there were slaves.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by adrianN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:30AM (#18457999)
That's exactly my point. A lot of the big companies today have at some point in their past exploited workers. Basically every manufacturing company started before WW2 or so.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Retric on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:30AM (#18458242)
Early factory workers where not exploited in terms of pay, they made more money than the average worker of their time period. Safty is a different story.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by rusk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:39AM (#18458036)
Sorry, do you mean your comment could be a candidate for the `/s` tag?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by woolvalley on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:52AM (#18457612)
Usually you get that cheap labor with lower experienced and younger employees. You do get what you pay for in many ways, but you do find those talented young people who can be really good for the first 1 or 2 years, or do things that many big companies refuse to do, like hire remote or give things like flexible work arrangements in exchange for cheaper pay.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:35AM (#18457549)
There are definitely businesses that wouldn't exist due to their inability to find labor cheap enough to make their unit economics work. We usually say "those businesses shouldn't exist, then".

For instance, you could make a version of AirBnB that was supported by ads alone, if instead of paying homeowners for the use of their homes, you simply compelled them to let you rent them out for nothing.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by vincnetas on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:05AM (#18458573)
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by PeterisP on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:10AM (#18458396)
That's one loop of the self-balancing process - if there's a scarcity of labor, wages go up, some businesses can't afford it and close down, that reduces the needed number of workers and solves/balances the scarcity.

And it's a beneficial process, as it moves these people from business where their labor is less valuable (as evidenced by the fact that it's not profitable to employ them at a slightly higher wage) to businesses where their labor is more useful. The least efficient businesses being forced to close is a good thing that allows the labor, facilities, land, materials, capital, etc to stop being used poorly so that they can be used better in the economy.

The other balancing loop is that higher wages in some field is motivation for people to get the skills needed for that field, either through choice of education for younger people or by transferring from another type of job. This balances the supply side in a beneficial way, but as it's much slower than the balancing loop above, the largest immediate impact comes from the demand-side balance.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by gronne on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:17AM (#18459861)
“And it's a beneficial process” only to an extend. To much volatility result in a net loss for the market and society.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Ar-Curunir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:27AM (#18457729)
Businesses that are only profitable because they short-change workers... should not exist. Businesses don't have a "right to labour".
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by dominicr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:23AM (#18457976)
Usually this is because customers have gotten used to paying less than reasonable prices. Paying people more is often hand in hand with customers paying more. But people like the first idea more than the second!

Companies will try to only pay staff more when they can justify that to the shareholders as being a way to make more money for the shareholders. A public company exists solely for the benefit of the shareholders and all actions stem from that.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mooreds on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:50AM (#18458533)
> A public company exists solely for the benefit of the shareholders and all actions stem from that.

Not sure about this.

First off, there's the principal/agent problem that causes many public companies to be run for the benefit of their upper management.

Second, this idea of the shareholder above all other stakeholders is a new phenomenon (since the 1980s). It's also primarily an Anglo Saxon idea (USA, Britain). Other countries include other stakeholders more explicitly. And the USA could as well, of the political will was there.

I agree with you that this is how American capitalism is structured now, but it didn't spring from the mind of God, it's a human institution that can be changed.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by jsmith45 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:58PM (#18463247)
Yeah. I've often said that in any business decisions there are the following stakeholders:

Upper Management, The employees, the board members, the shareholders, the customers.

Business decisions are almost always made looking at the perspective of perhaps 2 or three of these stakeholders. The employees are basically never considered in the US, often only the biggest one or two customer's desires are considered if any consideration is given at all, etc.

And way too much attention is payed to certain Wall Street types who get all upset when earnings exceed the company's own projections, but fall short of wildly optimistic estimates by third parties.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mikeschmatz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:37AM (#18459095)
Shall we legalize slavery then? Just imagine how many business models would become viable if labor was free
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by war1025 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:27PM (#18462958)
You still need to pay the slaves in the sense that since you own them, you are responsible for their upkeep, which takes resources.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by idontpost on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:54PM (#18461514)
I wouldn't say slavery is free. You still have to pay someone to beat the slaves.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sgroppino on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:38AM (#18457564)
In this case these businesses should invest in tools that make fewer workers more productive.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by tomjen3 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:52PM (#18463183)
Then they will have to adapt.

Here in Denmark we don't have greeters, we bag our own stuff and most of the time we have to put a coin in to get the shopping cart out, which will be returned when we return it.

Of course there will be businesses that can't adapt. These will die out and those employees will then, slightly, decrease salaries.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by tomjen3 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:46PM (#18463135)
But if the price you have to pay to get somebody to do the job, it would be true that no american wants that job, as the job wouldn't exist unless it cost less to hire somebody to do the job than it is worth to the one who pays.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ElBarto on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:30AM (#18457529)
Many of the jobs in that category are paid little because it's not really economical to pay more. Wages are constrained by productivity and what customers are willing to pay.

E.g. if you have to pay people a lot to wash cars then those jobs will simply disappear.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mpweiher on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:30AM (#18458700)
> if you have to pay people a lot to wash cars then those jobs will simply disappear.

Yep. Even back when I was growing (70s), a car wash in Germany was this big machine you drove into and your car came out clean the other end. You didn't leave the car.

When coming to California early 2000s, a car wash was this place that had someone take your keys, then some people did some prep, then the person who took your keys drove it through a similar but much smaller machine. To my great surprise, this machine didn't actually wash the car but really just made it wet. Then a bunch of people cleaned and dried the car by hand and called you when they were done.

I was...astonished.

I also remember American car companies struggling for profitability, and blaming wages. Except that German car companies at the very same time were paying their workers several times the amount (strong unions) and still raking in the cash.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Marazan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:36AM (#18457556)
Productivity has been increasing. Wages have not.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by adrianN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:13AM (#18457688)
How much has the productivity of low wage jobs increased? Are waiters today serving 2% more customers than two years ago?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Marazan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:31AM (#18457738)
They are serving people paying more for food.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by MoBattah on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:41PM (#18464159)
Really? Data?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by nradov on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:47AM (#18459584)
Wages haven't increased, but total employee compensation has increased when you factor in employer paid health insurance premiums. In effect our wage gains have been eaten by healthcare costs.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by rebuilder on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:07AM (#18457665)
Isn't that kind of what increased productivity implies?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:57AM (#18457852)
No. Productivity is essentially profit - not revenue - per employee.

The clear trend since the 90s has been for productivity to increase while compensation has remained more or less static.

Larger corporations absolutely can afford to pay more - much more. They choose not to, because the institutional narcissism of business culture in the US is set up to gouge employees to the maximum possible extent, not to consider employees as contributors/partners who deserve decent compensation for their contribution.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ElBarto on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:31AM (#18458004)
Productivity is not profit at all, it's the value produced so indeed ~revenue.

Wages are therefore constrained so that a profit is left after the worker has been paid. Ignoring other costs, profit is equal value produced minus wage paid.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by cies on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:11AM (#18457923)
Unions/strikes were the way to counter this trend. But where are they nowadays? People are too busy too, and very well entertained. Also there is a huge compensation diff between well-paid and low-paid workers, larger than it use to be, this ensures that the more "resourceful" well-paid workers (often freelance) are not compelled to strike/unionize.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sib on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:24AM (#18460532)
Productivity is literally defined is the ratio of the output (revenue) to the input being measured. It has nothing to do with profit.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mifreewil on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:59AM (#18457870)
Higher productivity, but stagnant wages means productivity is increasing, but labor is not capturing the increase of their productivity and is instead being captured by shareholders or management.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by cies on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:12AM (#18457929)
Only shareholders. Mgmt is just another expense.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by anticensor on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:39PM (#18462528)
Management is an expense just on the books. They create most of the value of that business for themselves and shareholders, by themselves.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by cies on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @05:31AM (#18501556)
Can you explain? Why/how does mgmt create most value for shareholders?

I understand how they create most value for themselves, they earn more than the other employees and are more likely to own stock options.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:33AM (#18457541)
> Many of the jobs in that category are payed little because it's not really economical to pay more. Wages are constrained by productivity and what customers are willing to pay

What do you mean by that?

> E.g. if you have to pay people a lot to wash cars then those will simply disappear.

What will disappear? The cars? Cleanliness? What I think you mean is that people will demand fewer car washes, which is true. But so what?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by chrismeller on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:23AM (#18458435)
I think you're being a little too pedantic, the meaning seemed pretty clear to me...

1) In some sectors and job roles pay is what it is because there are other hard costs involved, the quantity of labor required is prohibitively high, and/or customers are not willing to pay $75 for <insert name of item or service>. Customers are willing to pay $25 for <insert name of item or service>, so you take 25 and subtract all the other costs involved as well as a profit margin to make it worth your while, do some multiplication (or division, as appropriate) to figure out how many of <insert name of item or service> each person can complete in a given hour, and end up being able to pay each person working on <insert name of item or service> $10 per hour. Whether or not someone is willing to toil away 8 hours a day on <insert name of item or service> for $10 per hour... well, that's what we're talking about.

2) What will disappear? The manual carwashes, obviously. Whether they get replaced by automatic ones (which eliminates the prohibitively high labor cost at a marginal increase in hard costs that decreases over time) or simply by people washing their cars themselves (which eliminates all of the above) doesn't really matter, as we're talking about labor issues and in either scenario the guy washing the car is out of his job. So what? So nothing, except the whole topic we're discussing.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mifreewil on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:55AM (#18457847)
People will demand fewer car washes or they will start to use fully automated car washes that don’t require people, or they will wash their own car. High labor costs makes automation that may have been thought of as too expensive or complicated before to seem more viable.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ollie87 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:17AM (#18458988)
Automated car washes scratch the crap out of your car, so I doubt it.

They're more likely to just do it themselves.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:57AM (#18458351)
At the price "Americans" would do these jobs, the companies may not be able to earn a profit.

Because, otherwise, they probably would do just that.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by tuyiown on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:04AM (#18458367)
If you have no one willing to pay for your service, including actual labor price, your business is irrelevant, and certainly not entitled to any effort from the worker. It's just business management that suck.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:29AM (#18458696)
>If you have no one willing to pay for your service, including actual labor price, your business is irrelevant, and certainly not entitled to any effort from the worker. It's just business management that suck.

How much people are willing to pay for a service is connected to the value labour generates. If the minimum wage for cleaning was raised to $50/hour, many cleaning companies would close because few people were willing to pay at least $50/hour for a cleaner; the work done by the cleaner does not generate $50/hour of value. For any given individual at any point on time there is a ceiling on how much value they can generate, based on their knowledge and abilities. If somebody is capable of generating $10 of value, and the minimum wage is raised to $20 of value, anybody employing them would be losing $10/hour (paying $20 for $10 worth of labour). In which case it becomes much harder for that individual to find a job, and also to get a foothold for them to gain skills and experience that allow them to generate more value in future.

You might argue that such a worker is better off on welfare or some kind of basic income, but shouldn't that be their choice to make, not yours?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by state_less on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:50AM (#18458823)
> How much people are willing to pay for a service is connected to the value labour generates.

It's how much the market will bear. Business owners (shareholders) play a game of arbitrage between what people will pay for the service and the cost of producing the service (e.g. labor costs). I think folks are upset not so much at the cleaning services of the world, but the oligopolies, where you soak up the surplus value of the labor. Sometimes it's done illegally like in the wage collusion case in silicon valley, other times it's done legally through M&A. The wealthy have learned how to leverage their position for maximum profit, and many folks see it for what it is.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:27AM (#18459429)
> I think folks are upset not so much at the cleaning services of the world, but the oligopolies, where you soak up the surplus value of the labor.

These aren't the companies that minimum wage laws hurt. According to https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/5314-entrepreneur-salaries..., the average salary of small business owners in America is $68,000, which is much less than most software developers on this site seem to make. They're not exactly filthly-rich businesses gobbling up profit. Even a small increase in costs can be enough to put them out of business, leaving their employees jobless.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by akoncius on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:38AM (#18460675)
exactly the same applies to workers - if my work generates less money than it is neccessary for living, then it’s not worth doing it, why lose money?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by zjaffee on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:48PM (#18462626)
Except that's not the problem going on here, for non growth stock companies today, profits matter more than revenue expansion. So even if they would be able to successfully grow their business in nominal terms by raising wages for more employees, they are often obligated to only try and expand at the same or increasing levels of profitability.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by FranzFerdiNaN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:15AM (#18458410)
Guess those companies should not exist then. No company should exist if their workers end up in poverty or need help in the form of food stamps or any other kind of help. Any job should pay enough for a decent life.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:31AM (#18458707)
>Guess those companies should not exist then. No company should exist if their workers end up in poverty or need help in the form of food stamps or any other kind of help. Any job should pay enough for a decent life.

Killing such such companies doesn't magically create new companies able to pay more, it just converts their low-paid workers to unemployed workers. The minimum wage is always zero (no job).

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:07AM (#18467074)
That's only the case when profit margins are so low that the minimum wage extinguishes the marginal benefit of a worker.

At the bottom of the wage spectrum that's mostly not true. Profits would allow for higher wages, but the negotiating power of the employers is such that they can hold wages down. In these cases minimum wages do make sense and don't result in higher unemployment. And implementing minimum wage laws has shown that it does not affect unemployment in a big manner.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:46AM (#18458803)
So how much do you think the local pizza shop should pay my 16 year old son? Should they be giving him a “livable wage” or should they keep offering $7.25/ hour for him and his high school friends who are staying at home with thier parents?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by throwawayaway12 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:57AM (#18460914)
Do you want him to save and pay for college himself? If so, a livable wage doesn't seem too crazy with (US) college tuition.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:29PM (#18461262)
Most teenagers who work part time and live in middle class families aren’t really doing it for the money, by the time you take into account car insurance and another car payment, the parents could just give the kids money.

Most of the time the teenager is either getting a hand me down car from the parents and the parents buy a new car or they buy their kid a cheap car.

My son won’t be going to an expensive college. He will be going to a two year state school close to home, living at home and then transferring. We will be paying cash.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:10AM (#18467085)
When students acquire student debt to go to an expensive college, or get the same money from their parents, they do so because they expect to come out with a benefit over going to a state school.

And, maybe unfortunately, given some due diligence, that decision is still most likely the correct one. And yes, there are fraudulent schools and diminishing returns etc.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:05AM (#18467944)
They can expect a lot of things but if you are going into a field that doesn’t pay above average wages, it really is not a great decision to go to a more expensive school.

But the popular refrain on HN - which I don’t agree with - is that the purpose of college is not to get a job.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by throwaway2048 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:13AM (#18460414)
Lets open up a vast class of exploited workers who are adults with families because your son wants to work for pocket money in highschool.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:31PM (#18461291)
How much do you think unskilled work is worth? How much should he and his teenage friends get paid to flip burgers and make pizza?

And honestly, if you are competing with a 16 year old for a job, there are larger issues than the minimum wage.

Maybe the real answer is to make it easier for adults to get training for jobs that can’t be done by a 16 year old.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by throwaway2048 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:40PM (#18462533)
The problem is that one (keeping wages low) gets pushed, and the other does not.

Something tells me you would be perfectly happy if wages were kept super low, and the other things you said did not happen.

That is not a solution.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:54PM (#18462719)
There was just an article yesterday about the owners of 7-11 making a net income of $37K a year. Small business owners aren’t getting rich.

If you don’t think that businesses don’t “deserve” to exist if there business model can’t be profitable at “livable wages” that seems hypocritical to me since a lot of techies work for companies that only exist because of VC funding and if their company had to exist based solely on profitability they wouldn’t be working either.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:13AM (#18467102)
Whether a minimum wage in a certain situation makes sense or not depends on who is out of work and who is employed at below livable wages.

In an economy with high unemployment, a minimum wage should be lower. With low unemployment, it can be higher in order to put a lower limit on the employers' negotiating power.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Friday November 16, 2018 @01:34PM (#18470814)
If unemployment is low, the employer is going to have to offer higher wages anyway.

If the numbers don’t make sense, either the employer is going to automate or capital os going to move up market and to jobs that are out of reach for the unskilled.

If Apple bought iPhone manufacturing to the US for instance where it would be more expensive, they would invest in ways to automate more before they would hire the same number of people as FoxConn does.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:40PM (#18478908)
In reality, low unemployment did not lead to significant wage increases at the bottom end of the spectrum, probably because of the negotiating power of the employers.

It looks like wage increases are less of a factor in automation than labor shortages. Which is why Foxconn in China is automating like crazy.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:03AM (#18467065)
I'm talking about companies with difficulty hiring enough employees. Almost never are these the jobs close to a reasonable poverty standard.

So minimum wage is an entirely different topic. Increasing minimum wage will not solve any hiring problems, it only bolsters negotiation power for those at the bottom. Which is a good thing, but no solution to the stated problem.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by zjaffee on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:50PM (#18462649)
If only this were a practical view point for those living in developing countries too no? The entire modern economy as we know it is based on workers making what would be poverty level wages in the places the goods get ultimately sold in.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:21AM (#18458428)
Many small business owners are probably not quite so eager to close up shop because they lack a few employees.

The industries or professions where "living wages" is an issue are usually not the ones desperate for labor.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:20AM (#18458426)
So the market has spoken and the business is unsustainable
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:22AM (#18458431)
Nope, those businesses are sustainable, they just don't pay higher wages to hire more people because that would be unsustainable.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:27AM (#18458449)
If I put sawdust in the bread i make to "make my business sustainable" I'll end up in jail, why is exploiting my workers more acceptable than that?

"well yeah but the workers consented "

People do a lot of things when desperate, that shouldn't inform how we design our society

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:36AM (#18458740)
Killing such companies doesn't create better-paying jobs for the workers, it just leaves them unemployed. What gives you the right to "design" how these workers spend their time; maybe they'd prefer to be exploited than jobless? Ultimately the worker is payed by the company's customers, and if the law asks consumers to pay more than they're willing to pay for the workers' service, they'll simply go without the service.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:54AM (#18458853)
> What gives you the right to "design" how these workers spend their time; maybe they'd prefer to be exploited than jobless?

Jeeeeeesus christ, how am I designing how they spend their time?

How can you detect lack of freedom in saying "you can't work for unlivable salaries" but not in "I only pay unlivable salaries because if you dont want these crubs there's other more desperate people".

> Ultimately the worker is payed by the company's customers,

No, no, they are paid by the owners who decide what slice of the income to allocate to salaries. The customers pay the product and walk away, they don't know anything about the internal workings of a company

>and if the law asks consumers to pay more than they're willing to pay for the workers' service,

The law asks the boss to pay livable salary, the end price has nothing to do with the law. If the service cannot be offered at competitive prices while offering livable wages, it's not a sustainable business

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:28AM (#18459042)
>Jeeeeeesus christ, how am I designing how they spend their time?

They want to do some job for money and you're telling them "no, it pays too little, you're not allowed to do that job, you should be on welfare or find another job instead!".

>No, no, they are paid by the owners who decide what slice of the income to allocate to salaries. The customers pay the product and walk away, they don't know anything about the internal workings of a company

The income of the company is connected to the value generated by the workers it employs. An owner of a law firm can pays its employees much better than an owner of a fast food restaurant, because people are willing to pay more for lawyers than they are for fast food service. If the law forced restaurant owners to pay their workers as much as a law firm has to pay its workers, most restaurants would go out of business because people simply aren't willing to pay as much for restaurant service as they are for lawyers.

>The law asks the boss to pay livable salary, the end price has nothing to do with the law. If the service cannot be offered at competitive prices while offering livable wages, it's not a sustainable business

The maximum salary someone can expect is proportional to how much value they can generate for people. If the law requires someone to be paid much more than the maximuim amount of value they can generate given their skills/abilities at the time, then people will simply choose to forgo that service. If you had to pay someone $200/hour to clean your windows, would you do that, or would you clean them yourselves / let them remain uncleaned?

Minimum wage laws don't create jobs; the minimum wage is always zero (if nobody thinks someone can produce enough value to justify paying them the minimum wage, nobody will pay/hire them). Feel free to declare low-paying jobs "unsustainable", but note that the alternative to such jobs in many cases isn't livable wages, it's no wages, or welfare.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:59AM (#18459692)
> They want to do some job for money and you're telling them "no, it pays too little, you're not allowed to do that job, you should be on welfare or find another job instead!".

The idea that they need to be on some form of welfare ANYWAY doesn't bother you ?

> If the law forced restaurant owners to pay their workers as much as a law firm has to pay its workers, most restaurants would go out of business because people simply aren't willing to pay as much for restaurant service as they are for lawyers.

And if the southern states couldn't have slaves the economy would collapse and if people could strike, no business can survive and if you have to pay immigrants the same salary as locals, no business can survive and if they pass anti-sweatshop laws , no business can survive and if you can't fire them for unionizing , no business can survive and if you can't hire children , no business can survive and if you pay them for ONLY 40h per week , no business can survive and if you pay women equally , no business can survive

it has been the same excuse forever, if we give rights the market will crash, and yet every time instead of crushing it just keeps blooming... weird.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:13AM (#18459828)
>The idea that they need to be on some form of welfare ANYWAY doesn't bother you ?

Unless they want to live on subsistence, they need things produced by other people. They can either do something for other people (employment) in exchange for other people's things (usually in the form of money, which is more efficient than barter), or they can receive some form of charity/welfare from other people. What's wrong with it? Why should it bother me that the universe doesn't have an infinite source of everything such that anybody can fill all their wants without anybody having to work?

>it has been the same excuse forever, if we give rights the market will crash, and yet every time instead of crushing it just keeps blooming... weird.

Just because everything hasn't completely collapsed that doesn't mean things couldn't be better. That's like arguing polluting the environment is fine because the planet's still alive now. You can see this by comparing for instance Eastern Europe to Western Europe; Eastern Europe didn't collapse, but due to bad economic management it grew a lot more slowly and produced much lower living standards for its inhabitants than Western Europe.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @01:57AM (#18467047)
There is no objective standard for "exploitation". We design arbitrary ones, and even those have to be enforced (minimum wages, for example).

And you are right, higher prices lead to less consumption.

Basically any employee contract is a cooperation between two parties leading to a shared benefit of that cooperation. How that benefit is partitioned between the two parties is a matter of negotiation and negotiation power.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @01:44AM (#18466990)
Again, these businesses are sustainable, proven by the fact that they are surviving, even though they say they can't find enough workers to hire. They just don't see any benefit in increasing pay, maybe because that would make them unsustainable.

Wages below a certain standard of poverty are a different issue, and those aren't the jobs with hiring problems anyway.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Amygaz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:49AM (#18458529)
That would be true for businesses who’s motivation is to provide a lot of jobs. This would not be true for businesses who intent to make a few people rich. They have another motivation, and definition of higher wage.