News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:57AM (#18458351)
At the price "Americans" would do these jobs, the companies may not be able to earn a profit.

Because, otherwise, they probably would do just that.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by tuyiown on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:04AM (#18458367)
If you have no one willing to pay for your service, including actual labor price, your business is irrelevant, and certainly not entitled to any effort from the worker. It's just business management that suck.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:29AM (#18458696)
>If you have no one willing to pay for your service, including actual labor price, your business is irrelevant, and certainly not entitled to any effort from the worker. It's just business management that suck.

How much people are willing to pay for a service is connected to the value labour generates. If the minimum wage for cleaning was raised to $50/hour, many cleaning companies would close because few people were willing to pay at least $50/hour for a cleaner; the work done by the cleaner does not generate $50/hour of value. For any given individual at any point on time there is a ceiling on how much value they can generate, based on their knowledge and abilities. If somebody is capable of generating $10 of value, and the minimum wage is raised to $20 of value, anybody employing them would be losing $10/hour (paying $20 for $10 worth of labour). In which case it becomes much harder for that individual to find a job, and also to get a foothold for them to gain skills and experience that allow them to generate more value in future.

You might argue that such a worker is better off on welfare or some kind of basic income, but shouldn't that be their choice to make, not yours?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by state_less on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:50AM (#18458823)
> How much people are willing to pay for a service is connected to the value labour generates.

It's how much the market will bear. Business owners (shareholders) play a game of arbitrage between what people will pay for the service and the cost of producing the service (e.g. labor costs). I think folks are upset not so much at the cleaning services of the world, but the oligopolies, where you soak up the surplus value of the labor. Sometimes it's done illegally like in the wage collusion case in silicon valley, other times it's done legally through M&A. The wealthy have learned how to leverage their position for maximum profit, and many folks see it for what it is.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:27AM (#18459429)
> I think folks are upset not so much at the cleaning services of the world, but the oligopolies, where you soak up the surplus value of the labor.

These aren't the companies that minimum wage laws hurt. According to https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/5314-entrepreneur-salaries..., the average salary of small business owners in America is $68,000, which is much less than most software developers on this site seem to make. They're not exactly filthly-rich businesses gobbling up profit. Even a small increase in costs can be enough to put them out of business, leaving their employees jobless.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by akoncius on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:38AM (#18460675)
exactly the same applies to workers - if my work generates less money than it is neccessary for living, then it’s not worth doing it, why lose money?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by zjaffee on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:48PM (#18462626)
Except that's not the problem going on here, for non growth stock companies today, profits matter more than revenue expansion. So even if they would be able to successfully grow their business in nominal terms by raising wages for more employees, they are often obligated to only try and expand at the same or increasing levels of profitability.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by FranzFerdiNaN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:15AM (#18458410)
Guess those companies should not exist then. No company should exist if their workers end up in poverty or need help in the form of food stamps or any other kind of help. Any job should pay enough for a decent life.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:31AM (#18458707)
>Guess those companies should not exist then. No company should exist if their workers end up in poverty or need help in the form of food stamps or any other kind of help. Any job should pay enough for a decent life.

Killing such such companies doesn't magically create new companies able to pay more, it just converts their low-paid workers to unemployed workers. The minimum wage is always zero (no job).

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:07AM (#18467074)
That's only the case when profit margins are so low that the minimum wage extinguishes the marginal benefit of a worker.

At the bottom of the wage spectrum that's mostly not true. Profits would allow for higher wages, but the negotiating power of the employers is such that they can hold wages down. In these cases minimum wages do make sense and don't result in higher unemployment. And implementing minimum wage laws has shown that it does not affect unemployment in a big manner.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:46AM (#18458803)
So how much do you think the local pizza shop should pay my 16 year old son? Should they be giving him a “livable wage” or should they keep offering $7.25/ hour for him and his high school friends who are staying at home with thier parents?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by throwawayaway12 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:57AM (#18460914)
Do you want him to save and pay for college himself? If so, a livable wage doesn't seem too crazy with (US) college tuition.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:29PM (#18461262)
Most teenagers who work part time and live in middle class families aren’t really doing it for the money, by the time you take into account car insurance and another car payment, the parents could just give the kids money.

Most of the time the teenager is either getting a hand me down car from the parents and the parents buy a new car or they buy their kid a cheap car.

My son won’t be going to an expensive college. He will be going to a two year state school close to home, living at home and then transferring. We will be paying cash.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:10AM (#18467085)
When students acquire student debt to go to an expensive college, or get the same money from their parents, they do so because they expect to come out with a benefit over going to a state school.

And, maybe unfortunately, given some due diligence, that decision is still most likely the correct one. And yes, there are fraudulent schools and diminishing returns etc.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:05AM (#18467944)
They can expect a lot of things but if you are going into a field that doesn’t pay above average wages, it really is not a great decision to go to a more expensive school.

But the popular refrain on HN - which I don’t agree with - is that the purpose of college is not to get a job.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by throwaway2048 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:13AM (#18460414)
Lets open up a vast class of exploited workers who are adults with families because your son wants to work for pocket money in highschool.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:31PM (#18461291)
How much do you think unskilled work is worth? How much should he and his teenage friends get paid to flip burgers and make pizza?

And honestly, if you are competing with a 16 year old for a job, there are larger issues than the minimum wage.

Maybe the real answer is to make it easier for adults to get training for jobs that can’t be done by a 16 year old.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by throwaway2048 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:40PM (#18462533)
The problem is that one (keeping wages low) gets pushed, and the other does not.

Something tells me you would be perfectly happy if wages were kept super low, and the other things you said did not happen.

That is not a solution.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:54PM (#18462719)
There was just an article yesterday about the owners of 7-11 making a net income of $37K a year. Small business owners aren’t getting rich.

If you don’t think that businesses don’t “deserve” to exist if there business model can’t be profitable at “livable wages” that seems hypocritical to me since a lot of techies work for companies that only exist because of VC funding and if their company had to exist based solely on profitability they wouldn’t be working either.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:13AM (#18467102)
Whether a minimum wage in a certain situation makes sense or not depends on who is out of work and who is employed at below livable wages.

In an economy with high unemployment, a minimum wage should be lower. With low unemployment, it can be higher in order to put a lower limit on the employers' negotiating power.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by scarface74 on Friday November 16, 2018 @01:34PM (#18470814)
If unemployment is low, the employer is going to have to offer higher wages anyway.

If the numbers don’t make sense, either the employer is going to automate or capital os going to move up market and to jobs that are out of reach for the unskilled.

If Apple bought iPhone manufacturing to the US for instance where it would be more expensive, they would invest in ways to automate more before they would hire the same number of people as FoxConn does.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:40PM (#18478908)
In reality, low unemployment did not lead to significant wage increases at the bottom end of the spectrum, probably because of the negotiating power of the employers.

It looks like wage increases are less of a factor in automation than labor shortages. Which is why Foxconn in China is automating like crazy.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:03AM (#18467065)
I'm talking about companies with difficulty hiring enough employees. Almost never are these the jobs close to a reasonable poverty standard.

So minimum wage is an entirely different topic. Increasing minimum wage will not solve any hiring problems, it only bolsters negotiation power for those at the bottom. Which is a good thing, but no solution to the stated problem.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by zjaffee on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:50PM (#18462649)
If only this were a practical view point for those living in developing countries too no? The entire modern economy as we know it is based on workers making what would be poverty level wages in the places the goods get ultimately sold in.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:21AM (#18458428)
Many small business owners are probably not quite so eager to close up shop because they lack a few employees.

The industries or professions where "living wages" is an issue are usually not the ones desperate for labor.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:20AM (#18458426)
So the market has spoken and the business is unsustainable
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:22AM (#18458431)
Nope, those businesses are sustainable, they just don't pay higher wages to hire more people because that would be unsustainable.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:27AM (#18458449)
If I put sawdust in the bread i make to "make my business sustainable" I'll end up in jail, why is exploiting my workers more acceptable than that?

"well yeah but the workers consented "

People do a lot of things when desperate, that shouldn't inform how we design our society

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:36AM (#18458740)
Killing such companies doesn't create better-paying jobs for the workers, it just leaves them unemployed. What gives you the right to "design" how these workers spend their time; maybe they'd prefer to be exploited than jobless? Ultimately the worker is payed by the company's customers, and if the law asks consumers to pay more than they're willing to pay for the workers' service, they'll simply go without the service.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:54AM (#18458853)
> What gives you the right to "design" how these workers spend their time; maybe they'd prefer to be exploited than jobless?

Jeeeeeesus christ, how am I designing how they spend their time?

How can you detect lack of freedom in saying "you can't work for unlivable salaries" but not in "I only pay unlivable salaries because if you dont want these crubs there's other more desperate people".

> Ultimately the worker is payed by the company's customers,

No, no, they are paid by the owners who decide what slice of the income to allocate to salaries. The customers pay the product and walk away, they don't know anything about the internal workings of a company

>and if the law asks consumers to pay more than they're willing to pay for the workers' service,

The law asks the boss to pay livable salary, the end price has nothing to do with the law. If the service cannot be offered at competitive prices while offering livable wages, it's not a sustainable business

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:28AM (#18459042)
>Jeeeeeesus christ, how am I designing how they spend their time?

They want to do some job for money and you're telling them "no, it pays too little, you're not allowed to do that job, you should be on welfare or find another job instead!".

>No, no, they are paid by the owners who decide what slice of the income to allocate to salaries. The customers pay the product and walk away, they don't know anything about the internal workings of a company

The income of the company is connected to the value generated by the workers it employs. An owner of a law firm can pays its employees much better than an owner of a fast food restaurant, because people are willing to pay more for lawyers than they are for fast food service. If the law forced restaurant owners to pay their workers as much as a law firm has to pay its workers, most restaurants would go out of business because people simply aren't willing to pay as much for restaurant service as they are for lawyers.

>The law asks the boss to pay livable salary, the end price has nothing to do with the law. If the service cannot be offered at competitive prices while offering livable wages, it's not a sustainable business

The maximum salary someone can expect is proportional to how much value they can generate for people. If the law requires someone to be paid much more than the maximuim amount of value they can generate given their skills/abilities at the time, then people will simply choose to forgo that service. If you had to pay someone $200/hour to clean your windows, would you do that, or would you clean them yourselves / let them remain uncleaned?

Minimum wage laws don't create jobs; the minimum wage is always zero (if nobody thinks someone can produce enough value to justify paying them the minimum wage, nobody will pay/hire them). Feel free to declare low-paying jobs "unsustainable", but note that the alternative to such jobs in many cases isn't livable wages, it's no wages, or welfare.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by fifnir on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:59AM (#18459692)
> They want to do some job for money and you're telling them "no, it pays too little, you're not allowed to do that job, you should be on welfare or find another job instead!".

The idea that they need to be on some form of welfare ANYWAY doesn't bother you ?

> If the law forced restaurant owners to pay their workers as much as a law firm has to pay its workers, most restaurants would go out of business because people simply aren't willing to pay as much for restaurant service as they are for lawyers.

And if the southern states couldn't have slaves the economy would collapse and if people could strike, no business can survive and if you have to pay immigrants the same salary as locals, no business can survive and if they pass anti-sweatshop laws , no business can survive and if you can't fire them for unionizing , no business can survive and if you can't hire children , no business can survive and if you pay them for ONLY 40h per week , no business can survive and if you pay women equally , no business can survive

it has been the same excuse forever, if we give rights the market will crash, and yet every time instead of crushing it just keeps blooming... weird.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by logicchains on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:13AM (#18459828)
>The idea that they need to be on some form of welfare ANYWAY doesn't bother you ?

Unless they want to live on subsistence, they need things produced by other people. They can either do something for other people (employment) in exchange for other people's things (usually in the form of money, which is more efficient than barter), or they can receive some form of charity/welfare from other people. What's wrong with it? Why should it bother me that the universe doesn't have an infinite source of everything such that anybody can fill all their wants without anybody having to work?

>it has been the same excuse forever, if we give rights the market will crash, and yet every time instead of crushing it just keeps blooming... weird.

Just because everything hasn't completely collapsed that doesn't mean things couldn't be better. That's like arguing polluting the environment is fine because the planet's still alive now. You can see this by comparing for instance Eastern Europe to Western Europe; Eastern Europe didn't collapse, but due to bad economic management it grew a lot more slowly and produced much lower living standards for its inhabitants than Western Europe.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @01:57AM (#18467047)
There is no objective standard for "exploitation". We design arbitrary ones, and even those have to be enforced (minimum wages, for example).

And you are right, higher prices lead to less consumption.

Basically any employee contract is a cooperation between two parties leading to a shared benefit of that cooperation. How that benefit is partitioned between the two parties is a matter of negotiation and negotiation power.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by bayesian_horse on Friday November 16, 2018 @01:44AM (#18466990)
Again, these businesses are sustainable, proven by the fact that they are surviving, even though they say they can't find enough workers to hire. They just don't see any benefit in increasing pay, maybe because that would make them unsustainable.

Wages below a certain standard of poverty are a different issue, and those aren't the jobs with hiring problems anyway.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Amygaz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:49AM (#18458529)
That would be true for businesses who’s motivation is to provide a lot of jobs. This would not be true for businesses who intent to make a few people rich. They have another motivation, and definition of higher wage.