News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ElBarto on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:30AM (#18457529)
Many of the jobs in that category are paid little because it's not really economical to pay more. Wages are constrained by productivity and what customers are willing to pay.

E.g. if you have to pay people a lot to wash cars then those jobs will simply disappear.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mpweiher on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:30AM (#18458700)
> if you have to pay people a lot to wash cars then those jobs will simply disappear.

Yep. Even back when I was growing (70s), a car wash in Germany was this big machine you drove into and your car came out clean the other end. You didn't leave the car.

When coming to California early 2000s, a car wash was this place that had someone take your keys, then some people did some prep, then the person who took your keys drove it through a similar but much smaller machine. To my great surprise, this machine didn't actually wash the car but really just made it wet. Then a bunch of people cleaned and dried the car by hand and called you when they were done.

I was...astonished.

I also remember American car companies struggling for profitability, and blaming wages. Except that German car companies at the very same time were paying their workers several times the amount (strong unions) and still raking in the cash.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Marazan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:36AM (#18457556)
Productivity has been increasing. Wages have not.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by adrianN on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:13AM (#18457688)
How much has the productivity of low wage jobs increased? Are waiters today serving 2% more customers than two years ago?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by Marazan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:31AM (#18457738)
They are serving people paying more for food.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by MoBattah on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:41PM (#18464159)
Really? Data?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by nradov on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:47AM (#18459584)
Wages haven't increased, but total employee compensation has increased when you factor in employer paid health insurance premiums. In effect our wage gains have been eaten by healthcare costs.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by rebuilder on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:07AM (#18457665)
Isn't that kind of what increased productivity implies?
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:57AM (#18457852)
No. Productivity is essentially profit - not revenue - per employee.

The clear trend since the 90s has been for productivity to increase while compensation has remained more or less static.

Larger corporations absolutely can afford to pay more - much more. They choose not to, because the institutional narcissism of business culture in the US is set up to gouge employees to the maximum possible extent, not to consider employees as contributors/partners who deserve decent compensation for their contribution.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ElBarto on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:31AM (#18458004)
Productivity is not profit at all, it's the value produced so indeed ~revenue.

Wages are therefore constrained so that a profit is left after the worker has been paid. Ignoring other costs, profit is equal value produced minus wage paid.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by cies on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:11AM (#18457923)
Unions/strikes were the way to counter this trend. But where are they nowadays? People are too busy too, and very well entertained. Also there is a huge compensation diff between well-paid and low-paid workers, larger than it use to be, this ensures that the more "resourceful" well-paid workers (often freelance) are not compelled to strike/unionize.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by sib on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:24AM (#18460532)
Productivity is literally defined is the ratio of the output (revenue) to the input being measured. It has nothing to do with profit.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mifreewil on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:59AM (#18457870)
Higher productivity, but stagnant wages means productivity is increasing, but labor is not capturing the increase of their productivity and is instead being captured by shareholders or management.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by cies on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:12AM (#18457929)
Only shareholders. Mgmt is just another expense.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by anticensor on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:39PM (#18462528)
Management is an expense just on the books. They create most of the value of that business for themselves and shareholders, by themselves.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by cies on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @05:31AM (#18501556)
Can you explain? Why/how does mgmt create most value for shareholders?

I understand how they create most value for themselves, they earn more than the other employees and are more likely to own stock options.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by darawk on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:33AM (#18457541)
> Many of the jobs in that category are payed little because it's not really economical to pay more. Wages are constrained by productivity and what customers are willing to pay

What do you mean by that?

> E.g. if you have to pay people a lot to wash cars then those will simply disappear.

What will disappear? The cars? Cleanliness? What I think you mean is that people will demand fewer car washes, which is true. But so what?

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by chrismeller on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:23AM (#18458435)
I think you're being a little too pedantic, the meaning seemed pretty clear to me...

1) In some sectors and job roles pay is what it is because there are other hard costs involved, the quantity of labor required is prohibitively high, and/or customers are not willing to pay $75 for <insert name of item or service>. Customers are willing to pay $25 for <insert name of item or service>, so you take 25 and subtract all the other costs involved as well as a profit margin to make it worth your while, do some multiplication (or division, as appropriate) to figure out how many of <insert name of item or service> each person can complete in a given hour, and end up being able to pay each person working on <insert name of item or service> $10 per hour. Whether or not someone is willing to toil away 8 hours a day on <insert name of item or service> for $10 per hour... well, that's what we're talking about.

2) What will disappear? The manual carwashes, obviously. Whether they get replaced by automatic ones (which eliminates the prohibitively high labor cost at a marginal increase in hard costs that decreases over time) or simply by people washing their cars themselves (which eliminates all of the above) doesn't really matter, as we're talking about labor issues and in either scenario the guy washing the car is out of his job. So what? So nothing, except the whole topic we're discussing.

Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by mifreewil on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:55AM (#18457847)
People will demand fewer car washes or they will start to use fully automated car washes that don’t require people, or they will wash their own car. High labor costs makes automation that may have been thought of as too expensive or complicated before to seem more viable.
Re:Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more... by ollie87 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:17AM (#18458988)
Automated car washes scratch the crap out of your car, so I doubt it.

They're more likely to just do it themselves.