News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by consumer451 on Monday November 12, 2018 @10:36PM (#18438328)
I watch a decent amount of YouTube, but if it went away, I don’t think that it would be a net loss to humanity given what YT shows to children [0], and how YT radicalizes viewers [1]. It’s actually Patreon that pays my favorite creators, not YT, so they could protentially distribute videos via any other site. A new site for discovery would likely rise up, if Patreon didn’t do that themselves.

This is the entire platform vs publisher argument that tech companies have been hiding under for years. No one is responsible for content, and look what that’s gotten us. I would shed no tears if YT ended operation in the EU, where I live.

[0] https://www.wired.co.uk/article/youtube-for-kids-videos-prob...

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/10/opinion/sunday/youtube-po...

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/03/youtube...

https://www.thedailybeast.com/inside-youtubes-far-right-radi...

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:28AM (#18438820)
You're severely downplaying the amount of educational content that it has to offer. If youtube went down overnight, it -would- be a huge loss.

If you give your children unfettered access to youtube, that's your own fault as a parent. Youtube should be better about handling this but I think it's more of a communication issue.

Youtube is essentially a medium unto itself. A LOT of people use it so there's going to be good, and there's going to be bad. You can make the case of "radicalizing people" for just about any other medium that people consume.

In the end, it's basically what you make of it. You can find a wealth of diverse channels to watch and grow from, or you can watch drivel.

It isn't any different than the trash on tv or in pulp novels, except that individual people have more power and freedom to create things. If you think differently then you're just looking at older mediums with rose-tinted glasses.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by ben_w on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:39AM (#18439112)
I make heavy use of the educational content — 3Blue1Brown, applied science, bigclivedotcom, braincraft, CGP Grey, Computerphile, CrashCourse, … «continues alphabetically», … ViHart, Vintage Space, WDR (German language broadcaster “Westdeutscher Rundfunk”).

Most of them have other revenue streams. Patreon, or being a division of PBS, or day jobs. I’m not worried about their survival.

One of those videos was “This Video Will Make You Angry”. Meme-based economics are not your friend.

For extremist or propagandist content, unfortunately both those things mean it will continue even without YouTube or a clone.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:45AM (#18439371)
I'm not talking about content makers' survival. I'm talking about existing content being lost. Even assuming those people had everything backed up, it would be scattered all over the place.

This Video Will Make You Angry was a good video. No idea why it specifically is being discussed here.

> For extremist or propagandist content, unfortunately both those things mean it will continue even without YouTube or a clone.

Yes, this has nothing to do with youtube. Again, you can propagate charged content via other mediums, especially on the internet.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by ben_w on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:31AM (#18440768)
I was giving examples of the harm side of the equation. Up two levels, “YT radicalizes viewers”, your reply (by my reading) downplayed that harm.

If your primary concern is searchability, that is a surprise: YouTube is the second largest search engine after google.com, and I didn’t perceive any suggestion that the latter would be harmed by the copyright proposal. Even if it was, even rubbish search engines like iTunes’ Podcasts doesn’t stop me getting vastly more content than I have time for even if I took early retirement and listened at double speed.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by slededit on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:47AM (#18439597)
Like educational videos from the 50s, its neat to be able to go back and see them. But these subjects get continuously recovered. Sometimes just to spice it up, and sometimes the material does change. Its not the end of the world.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by sytelus on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:34AM (#18439764)
> If you give your children unfettered access to youtube, that's your own fault as a parent.

How do you propose to prevent the disasters described in this thread? YouTube have loose standards and virtually no demonstrated ability for enforcement. I'm specifically worried about giving locked down PC to kid with my best effort and still kids getting exposed to content that they are not yet ready to process. How does YouTube enables me to to make sure that kids are protected?

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:59AM (#18440094)
> How does YouTube enables me to to make sure that kids are protected?

It doesn't. I don't know why this expectation exists; youtube has not shown itself to be trustworthy in this sort of thing. Clearly an alternative needs to be used, like downloading youtube videos beforehand or using something else entirely.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by pluma on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:35AM (#18441203)
This is basically the all-American argument of "sure, the advertising is a complete lie but it's the consumer's fault for being gullible".

YouTube Kids presents itself as specifically for kids. You don't expect weird fetish porn on daytime kids TV and it's completely reasonable to expect a similar level of moderation for an app that positions itself as an equivalent of that.

Blaming the parents really understates how much YouTube has fucked this one up. YT relies on a wonky algorithm and crowdsourcing to moderate its content at scale but their dirty little (open) secret is that this is error prone and exploitable. In a typical Google way they thought they could eliminate paid humans from the equation and still deliver quality -- they can't, and it's entirely their fault.

If a company misrepresents a product in a way that results it to cause harm when used exactly as advertised, it's the company's fault.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:19PM (#18461775)
Daytime TV is at least somewhat regulated by the FCC. Youtube is not, to my knowledge.

> This is basically the all-American argument of "sure, the advertising is a complete lie but it's the consumer's fault for being gullible".

No, it's your fault for believing advertising in the first place. I only judge youtube through my personal knowledge and experience of using it for the last 6+ years.

Just because someone, or a PR team, says "it's for kids!" does NOT mean it's quality programming or acceptable content. That is your responsibility to determine, as a parent or guardian. Do not blame youtube when you know that it is a website where anyone can upload anything. And it's run by a company that thinks ML algorithms can filter videos adequately.

No, this is lazy parenting, just blindly trusting a corporation to actually do things right, when they're not even regulated adequately.

Nothing is stopping you from downloading videos beforehand, or finding better content platforms or content producers, like PBS. This is you throwing up your hands in the air and wanting to shift blame to a corporation when you didn't take the time or effort to screen things before putting your kids in front of a screen + opaque algorithm.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Lkjhmnbv on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:44PM (#18442940)
Your problem is then with YouTube kids, not YouTube.

Not everyone wants their content censored by dogmatists.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by pluma on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:00PM (#18444855)
What are you even talking about?

YouTube Kids is from YouTube and is advertised as a kids-friendly filtered version of YouTube. YouTube Kids however failed to filter tons of disturbing and inappropriate content. The entire raison d'etre of YouTube Kids is to provide a filtered YouTube experience -- it failed hard.

EDIT: I can't even begin to comprehend how you think any of this is about "dogmatists censoring YouTube". YT Kids only providing kids-friendly content is no different from YT Music only providing music. It's not censorship, it's filtering. You can still go to YouTube proper and watch everything.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Lkjhmnbv on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @11:45AM (#18451228)
Your problem is still with YouTube kids and not with YouTube.

Your entire argument is the filtration they tried failed. We agree. Great.

My point is that the conclusion you draw is that everything needs more censorship. We disagree. I think parents need to take responsibility and not blame a company for providing a product they don't like.

Its the equivalent of censoring the radio because think of the children. It was a dumb idea then, it's a dumb idea now, because everyone knows that's not where it ends.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by detaro on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @11:47AM (#18451247)
I don't see where you get the idea that that's the conclusion they draw. It seems like you arguing against something they never said.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Lkjhmnbv on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @12:02PM (#18451403)
How do you understand the arguments.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by detaro on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @02:43PM (#18453167)
That they're unhappy with how they handled YouTube Kids, nothing about censoring the main YT product.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Lkjhmnbv on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @06:23PM (#18455230)
And I said his problem is with YouTube kids not YouTube.

Not sure what part of that you disagree with.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by detaro on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @07:09PM (#18455585)
> My point is that the conclusion you draw is that everything needs more censorship.

That claim about their conclusion I do not understand, since I don't see where they are saying anything like that.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Lkjhmnbv on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:05PM (#18464334)
They believe YouTube kids is possible if only YouTube were to censor more content.

My argument is that more censorship won't help, because not everyone agrees on what is, and is not, kid friendly. So the entire enterprise is doomed to failure. The only solution I see is parents taking responsibility.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Aic1kuir on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:05AM (#18439899)
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by baldfat on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:12AM (#18440656)
I was just going to post this. This is the answer to most people's parental problems with YouTube. I use this with my 7 year old. There is no way to do this easily and never for an average parent. Common Sense Media is my friend as a parent, but I have to lock down YouTube just to keep him from seeing something that no kid should see.

I use OpenDNS and I have a few custom scripts so I can learn how often certain sites are being used. "Too much of a good thing is still too much."

I use history on my daughters YT account with a quick script that compares her computer's history on her computer. I don't run it all the time but I tell her trust but verify a lot. She is doing her school online and our biggest issue is she will watch videos and not do here work for a few hours.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by sureaboutthis on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:22AM (#18440410)
This is the same problem with "news" on the internet. There are too few places that edit themselves and vet their content and resources only to throw anything they themselves hear and read about online. News sources become unreliable and untrustworthy because you don't know who to trust as a source.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by AJ007 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:28AM (#18440742)
One thing that could be done is for the aggregators to require a video publisher to post a bond. This could apply not just for the EU copyright rules, but for any other weird country specific laws. If the video publisher posts something that breaks the law, then the money is removed, the regulator paid, and the publisher's license revoked.

This would allow a marketplace of editors. Someone who was making, for example, cooking videos, probably wouldn't have a couple of million dollars sitting around. Instead, their videos would be syndicated through an editor. An editor could make their own decisions on revenue share (if any at all) based on their own judgements of legal risk vs revenue opportunity. This could mean live streamers all have to go in to a closely monitored studio instead of doing it from home.

In a way this is similar to how the old network TV or print periodical marketplace worked, but adapted for the internet. Network TV had to pay big fines if someone said fuck or a nipple was broadcast live. Thus, they assumed legal liability for their guests behavior.

This still doesn't solve the core issue that the Youtube CEO described, which is when a bunch of people claim copyright on the same video. Solving that probably requires clawback provisions over lost revenue from making fake claims.

I don't think this approach would be ok in the United States, but it seems reasonable for the EU, China, and so on.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by sbov on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:25AM (#18439284)
> If you give your children unfettered access to youtube, that's your own fault as a parent.

Unfettered access, or maybe you turn your head for 5 minutes and your kid clicks a recommended video next to the one you set them up to watch and now mickey mouse is running around cutting everyone's head off oh god what is happeni...

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:51AM (#18439393)
Recommended by whom? An algorithm? Why is that any guarantee of safe or quality programming for young children?

Youtube does need to address these videos, but they're not omniscient gods either. There is too much content to humanly (or algorithmically, seemingly) to police effectively.

Why do you put so much trust in random recommended videos? What makes youtube so trustworthy? I'm asking because I genuinely don't understand this mindset at all.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:49AM (#18441308)
> Recommended by whom? An algorithm?

By YouTube; the choice to make the recommendation and the choice to use an algorithm (both in general and the specific algorithm chosen) as part of the recommendation process are human decisions made yb YouTube employees in the course of their duties.

> Youtube does need to address these videos, but they're not omniscient gods either.

While the second half is true, it magnifies rather than mitigates the firall it does is call out the hubris and irresponsibility at YouTube behind the current status quo.

> There is too much content to humanly (or algorithmically, seemingly) to police effectively.

The quantity of content on YouTube, and the fact that it is not constrained by their ability to effectively police it is also a product of human decisions made by YouTube employees in the course of job duties, not some kind for natural occurrence with which YouTube is beset. And the fact that any part of that corpus is subject to recommendation algorithms without being policed is also such a human decision.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:24PM (#18461818)
At the end of the day, it's the parent's/guardian's fault for knowingly letting their kids browse on a platform where anyone can upload anything.

You are putting way too much trust in an opaque corporation to provide adequate content for young children. Just because it's "Youtube" does not guarantee anything. In fact it makes it much more dubious of a site, knowing exactly how youtube functions and how google manages it (very badly—at least for children's content).

No one is forcing you to put your kids in front of youtube. Please stop shifting blame when it's your fault for trusting random recommendations from an opaque, broken algorithm to filter endless random content, run by an uncaring corporation.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by kristiandupont on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:19AM (#18439953)
It's not a "mindset" that there is an inviting "click here for the next recommended video" link when one is done playing.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:48AM (#18440050)
Then don't use youtube. Download the videos offline first, etc. What's the issue here? No one is forcing you to let your kid sit unattended on a website with questionable recommended videos.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by collyw on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:51AM (#18439611)
Tom and Jerry weren't far off that when I was a kid. Or the Roadrunner. I'll admit that I haven't seen any of the newer videos that people seem to be complaining about, but what is so much different about them from what we got 30 years ago?
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:16AM (#18439703)
Tom & Jerry was just a somewhat violent cartoon, but some of the mentioned videos are somewhat disturbing. You can just google elsagate. My opinion is that people exploited a captive market + youtube's positive feedback loop algorithm to create such videos.

FWIW, my brother and I grew up on old tom & jerry cartoons. I think they're great, other than the few episodes with plainly racist stereotypes.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by PavlovsCat on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:22AM (#18440409)
> I'll admit that I haven't seen any of the newer videos that people seem to be complaining about

Stop right there. You have no idea what you're conflating here. If you have a strong stomach and no history of being abused, look into it. If you don't, please, read good accounts of people who did... or at least have no opinion about it, but not "meh, it's prolly fine". It's not.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by collyw on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:25AM (#18440726)
That's why I asked.

I checked the wikipedia page as the other poster suggested and doesn't look that bad to me.

What do you feel is so much worse about them that the coyote being crushed under a huge rock?

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by PavlovsCat on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:40AM (#18441235)
What does "checked the wikipedia page" mean? Reading the linked footnotes? And what about "sexual situations, fetishes, drugs" says "Tom & Jerry" to you? Not that the overview on that WP page does it justice, at all. At one point it even said Elsagate "was" a colloquialism, heh.

It's hardly a full list of the themes that are repeated over and over and over again. It involves rape, pregnant infants, (there was one live action thing with Spiderman drugging and raping Elsa and her little child (played by an actual child, though with Elsagate you will also find plenty of adults in diapers or with pacifiers, or otherwise playing a child) as they are unconscious, then delivering both their babies in the form of plastic dolls, and Elsa and her child and Spiderman all being super happy and clapping in delight at the end), a LOT of kidnapping and bondage, children left behind, parents being evil for denying them sweets or staying up late or other things, parents getting hurt by their children or even murdered so children can get something they want, people generally murdering each other out of anger, including with automatic weapons, hands coming out of mirrors or mobile devices, children crying at a graveyard, hands coming out of graves, getting injections to get "made better" regardless of how silly that is (like eating a toy truck and getting an injection because of that), generally eating things and that having some kind of effect, a lot of binge eating, objects or people being crushed underfoot or under cars, a lot of leering at someone who is in danger, throwing people off roofs, jumping off roofs or committing suicide, a lot of confusion or anxiety about pregnancy (e.g. what gender it is, or whose kid is is), a lot of adultery, people forcing others to do things via hypnosis, drugs, violence or even poverty vs wealth, product pyramids, objects floating in swimming pools (god knows why), and of course the whole "color learning", "daddy finger" (jumping on the bed, wheels on the bus) stuff, the same song repeated 20 times while persons swap heads or colors.

All these themes repeat across various cartoon themes, live action and 3d animations, including Minecraft-style animations, and modded GTA 5.

Even all that isn't an exhaustive description, it's a joke compared to the content. But already I need to stop because hey, "who wants to read all that". Welcome to Elsagate, that's exactly what it is.

https://medium.com/@jamesbridle/something-is-wrong-on-the-in...

https://imgur.com/r/ElsaGate

https://www.reddit.com/r/elsagate (as I said in another comment, there's a lot of crap there, but historically also posts that offer real information, compilations, reports of parents, and so on)

https://i.imgur.com/MziRRQw.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/HfsdvWo.jpg

That's just thumbnails, very few in comparison to what is there, not the millions of hours of video, the countless demented 3D animations. Plenty of those involving syringes, too.

And that's not even taking the deceptive stuff into account, how they describe everything as family friendly (I remember channel names with phrases like "day care" in them), and all about learning, also offering unused social media accounts as contact address, to seem all above board to anyone who doesn't actually look. Just how the the vile content is often padded in a lot of harmless content, so parents that just take a short glance (or you) might not notice, and so on.

Who knows, if you enter "learn colors" or "minecraft monster school" and click around (and I don't just mean once or twice), you might find a lot that's currently being uploaded, or never even was deleted. I genuinely don't want to look because I've seen enough.

Among other things it's a DDOS attack on our attention, it exploits our desire to ignore such things, or rationalize them -- so that it looks fine at "first glance", or similar to something benign you already know and therefore benign, especially when watching zero of the X thousands of hours that make up the body of Elsagate; that's in the nature of the subject.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by collyw on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @05:17AM (#18448819)
Thanks for finally linking to some stuff that demonstrates what you are talking about. Its more convincing that shouting me down and telling me i have no idea what i am talking about.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by PavlovsCat on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:15AM (#18440381)
> You're severely downplaying the amount of educational content that it has to offer.

That cannout outweigh Elsagate stuff. Educational content could be on smaller platforms, and there even could be platforms to find it on those smaller platforms.

> In the end, it's basically what you make of it.

No, it's thousands of channels and hundreds thousands of videos designed to mentally abuse children, and for months and months, while parents begged YouTube to even take notice, autoplay beelined to this stuff from cartoons. That's what you get from algorithms designed to maximize "engagement".

> You can find a wealth of diverse channels to watch and grow from, or you can watch drivel.

We're talking about things aimed at toddlers. Oh, and initially also YouTube for Kids. When you talk about "unfettered access" and simply blame it on parents, it just shows you are downplaying something you might not even have looked into.

Apart from the Elsagate subreddit, which has a lot of crap but also important posts buried among it, you probably can still enter "learn colors" or "Minecraft Monster School" or a lot of other things into YouTube, and maybe click on some related videos of videos in the search results. I promise, it won't take long to find something that can ruin your day.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by intertextuality on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:13PM (#18461721)
I have looked into it. I don't have kids, but I would never allow them access to autoplay videos on youtube. Given my knowledge of Google, Youtube, and their overall ineptitude in this regard. Just because something from them is marketed "for kids", doesn't mean it's necessarily good.

I still blame the parents, especially after Elsagate. It takes some mental gymnastics to allow children to watch random videos on a site where anyone can upload anything, and a site run by a company that thinks algorithms can work by themselves to filter content correctly. There are other platforms that have content for kids. Youtube never was a correct option, unless you yourself download videos beforehand to ensure their quality.

Please don't blindly trust things just because they say "it's aimed at children". Its still up to you, the parent/guardian, to actually make sure that it's acceptable content. Trusting an internet titan of a company to actually care or get it right is an enormously stupid idea, in my opinion.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by pluma on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:32AM (#18441175)
I have yet to see an educational content provider that isn't primarily funded from Patreon, direct sponsorships ("This video is sponsored by..." lynda.com, Audible, Skillshare, etc etc) or produced by an entity that has relies on external streams of revenue (e.g. BBC, PBS).

Heck, even the "trash pop" part of YouTube (e.g. drama channels) don't seem to primarily rely on ad revenue anymore. And most of the gaming channels seem to actually prefer Twitch (but either want to editorialise their content rather than upload raw streams or only still use YT because they want a more diversified revenue stream).

YouTube's initial appeal was that it was a "marketplace of ideas" and everybody could upload videos of pretty much anything and build an audience and (eventually) earn a few bucks from advertising. Recently that marketplace has increasingly shifted to promote what's already popular and YouTube has actively brought in established content producers from TV while also algorithmically demonetizing "lesser" channels (note: this doesn't mean less-viewed channels or channels with fewer subscribers) with little to no means of appeal. The gold rush when it was actually financially viable to make a living off the ad revenue and fund your video production are long gone for the vast majority of creators.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by nathan_long on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @10:30AM (#18450563)
> It isn't any different than the trash on tv or in pulp novels, except that individual people have more power and freedom to create things. If you think differently then you're just looking at older mediums with rose-tinted glasses.

What makes it different is a recommendation engine that is deliberately designed to maximize the amount of viewing time and has no moral compass about doing so.

When a kid finishes reading Ranger Rick magazine, nothing prompts them to read anything else except their own interests and the pile of books their parents have purposefully made available to them. You don't have strangers popping in the window, tempting them to read something nasty, and if you do, you get that person arrested.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by consumer451 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:42AM (#18440835)
You made some very good points. I wrote my comment with much less thought than I should have. I mostly consume educational videos on YT myself, but I feel like that I am not a normal user. YT does spread all kinds of good knowledge, but I was thinking the content and views taken as a whole. I am really surprised my comment got that many upvotes here. I still do stand by my original thought, but it was just that, a thought - though poorly phrased.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by lake99 on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:29PM (#18438598)
I don't watch children's videos, so I'll leave that factor aside. All your citations are to opinion pieces written by people with an agenda to push, i.e. not fact, not by a long shot. I watch YouTube for education and entertainment. The loss of all the educational content, by itself, would be a massive loss to humanity. If YouTube were to go down, some educators will re-upload their content to other places. Moreover, radical activists would be the among the first to adopt YouTube's replacements, thereby solving nothing.

> No one is responsible for content, and look what that’s gotten us.

I suspect your views are coloured by the kind of things you watch. YouTube's algorithms have adapted to your viewing profile. Most of my recommendations are for science, math, and music pedagogy. From where I stand, YouTube has gotten us to a great place.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by zaarn on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:26AM (#18438808)
Let's not forget that the CEO calling the EU's proposal impossible is also an opinion piece written by someone with an agenda to push.

At the end of the day, I can't help but atleast partially agree with the reasoning behind the proposal; copyright is broken on the internet and it's nearly impossible to have it enforced on even larger sites if you're not one of the bigger players like music labels or hollywood studios or high profile game studios. And the current DMCA process deployed by most platforms is broken as well since all of the burden of proof lands on the creator with no repercussions for those who send them if it turns out to be fraudulent.

That needs to be fixed somehow, though the EU proposal is likely not a perfect approach.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by lake99 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:35AM (#18439095)
I agree completely. Copyright is badly broken, and it's broken in favour of the big players. Independent classical musicians are the most severely affected by it. A few of my favourite classical players have received copyright strikes by the likes of Sony, BMG, WB, etc. for their own live performances. And then there are cases such as the video of a guy strolling through a forest, which received copyright claims from the big bullies because of the live bird calls.

EU's proposal would only end up making the already flawed ContentID system more aggressive. Heck, I'd go in the opposite direction. I would be in favour of penalizing those who falsely claim copyright for works that they don't own the rights to.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by mcv on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:56AM (#18440563)
I totally agree. Claiming copyright over other people's work and using that claim to block other people's work, is a far more serious abuse than merely violating someone's copyright, because it actually takes something away from the victim. It's much closer to actual theft, because the victim loses their 'property'.

And yet there doesn't seem to be any punishment for that. I'd rather see the EU protect the rights of independent artists and regular citizens, than those of large corporations with a tendency to abuse their rights.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by DennisP on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:44AM (#18440513)
Maybe what needs to be fixed is our concept of copyright.

We've spent enormous resources creating a miraculous machine that does one thing: it makes unlimited copies of any information and distributes it all over the world, almost for free. But we can't use it to its full potential because we're stuck in a mindset that dates back centuries.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by jbigelow76 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:09AM (#18438756)
There should be the distinction or at least allowances for, is X "good" and is X a "net good", which a lot of responses to the GP aren't admitting.

I've watched plenty of Youtube, even the now cliched defenses of DIY home improvement stuff (sink de-clogging and drywall patching for me). But for as good and helpful as the pedagogical content might be there is still the other side that subsidizes all that, that fosters some crazed asshole shooting up a yoga studio and killing two people (YT ref'd in first paragraph)[1].

Is YouTube good? Sure. Is YouTube a societal net good? Absolutely not.

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hot-yoga-shooting-tallahassee-f...

edit: spelling

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by lake99 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:08AM (#18438983)
> there is still the other side that subsidizes all that

Connect the dots for me. How is the existence of crazy people uploading videos to YouTube subsidizing educational content? Advertising is subsidizing educational content because that's how the money flows.

If you were to put everyone literally in a straitjacket, you'd cut down on the number of crazy people shooting up random strangers too. If you want to build such a society, I will help you build it, and help you move there. I'm staying out. I think freedom is a societal net good.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by bllguo on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:11AM (#18439678)
Absolutely not? Strong opinion. Care to justify it? I'd be surprised if anyone was convinced by what you've written so far.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by ferongr on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:15AM (#18438781)
Nice subjective opinion presented as fact.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by kazagistar on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:51AM (#18439157)
Would that content be lost, or simply decentralized and demonopolized?
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by _ph_ on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:58AM (#18439635)
It would most likely to be lost, as most youtubers would not be able to set up and run streaming video servers on their own.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by kazagistar on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:22AM (#18441602)
There are options between "one giant YouTube monopoly" and "every single individual must run their own server". There is reddit, there are blogs, but where are the forums?
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by freeone3000 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @06:41PM (#18445951)
Those things, none of those things, host video. They link to YouTube. Ocassionally vimeo. Once MediaFire? Mostly YouTube. Video is EXPENSIVE. And any measure of cost sharing centralization runs into the same problems that YouTube is having very quickly.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by sieabahlpark on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:57PM (#18438715)
Khan academy started with YouTube videos I believe.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by behringer on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:14AM (#18438777)
Khan academy could have easily started with another video service. Archive.org had a free video service at the time I believe. There were others that took it's place when it shut down, including YouTube.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by andromedavision on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:06AM (#18439665)
> Khan academy could have easily started with another video service.

Not all video players are created equal. It's really hard to make a good video player. Case in point, look at all the crappy video players created by news sites that don't want to embed the YT player. Some can't even pause properly using the space bar or even let you select your preferred video quality.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by sharcerer on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:30AM (#18439998)
I think it would be a huge loss. I couldn't live without the educational content on Youtube. Sure, they could move it elsewhere. But, Youtube has enabled this network to thrive. It's the single biggest library of visual edu content. Channels like Ted-Ed,Crash Course, Physics Girl,Vsauce, Engineering Explained, Khan Acad, MITOCW, a16z, freecodecamp, 3blue1brown,asapScience, SciShow,Computerphile,Numberphile,Hak5,LiveOverflow, How stuffworks, Jacob Clifford, Derek Banas, sentdex,Corey Schafer,Minute physics,Tinkernut, Tom Scott, Y Combinator, oh and 2 Minute Papers.

Youtube bascially played a major role in democratizing creation of content :educational, creative etc. And by the way, it's still not clear how much profit YT makes. The infra costs etc are huge. It's Google's $$$ which subsidizes YT content. personally, when I see the amount of value I am deriving, I think I owe a decent amount of money to YT. I am a student right now, but will start giving creators money asap.

Of course, it would have been better if Youtube had started their Donate option sooner. I think they have failed to creatively monetize users and compensate creators. (i know about ads, not creative,but it works)

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by microcolonel on Monday November 12, 2018 @10:52PM (#18438434)
The Alternative Influence Network thing is based on outright fabricated data by the way. Becca Lewis draws direct links between people who have never collaborated or appeared on eachother's channels (the criteria described for the linkages), to draw the absurd conclusion that Richard Spencer and Tim Pool are part of some conspiratorial "network".

Anyone who takes the AIN report seriously either hasn't verified the claims, or agrees that these people should be misrepresented and smeared.

Your view of YouTube is myopic, and ignores the immense cultural resource that exists there. You have no idea what would be lost if the EU chased it away, but you're willing to find out just to spite some people you resent; and you resent them based on false information you accepted because it fit your lens.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by wccrawford on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @06:36AM (#18440227)
This is like saying that all the smut in libraries is ruining society and the world would be better off if all the libraries closed. Those educational books would still be available elsewhere, etc etc.

I use YouTube all the time to learn to do things around the house. My wife and I recently completed a bathroom renovation and the only thing we didn't do ourselves was the plumbing, including completely replacing the tile and patching the walls. It looks fabulous.

Sure, I could probably have eventually found that information elsewhere, but it was almost all on YouTube and very easy to find. I looked up multiple videos on each task and figured out what the best advice was and even got to see it done multiple ways.

Losing YouTube at this point would be a huge loss.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by candiodari on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:47AM (#18442402)
So you're saying either we can have a great resource, or we could destroy that resource entirely and let politicians get slightly less criticism ?

https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2016/09/20/berkeley-may-...

This is a general problem with many public efforts. Reality is that the only way to make everyone equal is to make everyone equally miserable. And this is generally what we do.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by HissingMachine on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:39AM (#18440478)
You have seriously confused things, the EU copyright law isn't targetting YT, it's targetting all platforms that users are able to publish their own content, so you really aren't left with alternatives for content creators to switch to paid by Patreon supporters or not. Even Hacker News is targetted under the law and has to pay link tax when linking to content. So you should reconsider your nonchalant attitude.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by consumer451 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:13AM (#18440658)
I am not defending article 11 at large, the link tax seem ridiculous.[0] I was likely “thinking out loud” far too much for HN, and my own good. I would certainly miss YT, article 11 is a mess, but I just came to my original comment’s conclusion and it honestly surprised me.

[0] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/10/eus-link-tax-will-kill...

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by HissingMachine on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:45PM (#18443571)
I understand it's just frustrating to hear dismissal of one platform or other from comments on EU copyright law when the fact is that it will govern everything that is going on the internet. It will affect everything as user interaction is a central and crucial part of what we do on the internet. GDPR did a number on what we consume for "the greater good" and while I do appreciate that I'm now more in control of what goes on with my data, I lost access to so many sources. And while I do have ways to protect myself where ever I go, I have been punished for the lack of care and awareness of internet users who simply didn't care then nor do they care now, collective punishment rarely does any great good for the whole. And yet again, I'm savvier so I can circumvent most of the blocks by VPN but the rest are now enjoying a worse experience. This ain't good in any metric, none of it is.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by mdonahoe on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:06AM (#18438742)
Not sure if this is what you meant, but if all the content disappeared today, it would be a huge loss.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by nradov on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:46PM (#18438664)
YouTube is quite useful when I need an instructional video on how to repair my leaking toilet.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by protomyth on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:59PM (#18438719)
YouTube is basically the ‘I need to do this, how can it be done’ website. Searching for the car you are looking at buying with word repair is an interesting way to see what you might need to do.

Crown molding was an amazing thing to learn from YouTube.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by drusepth on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:06AM (#18438975)
Absolutely. YouTube helped me build my first PC, taught me dozens of algorithms / data structures while I was first learning to code, helped me get started with software like PyTorch, Blender, Unity, etc, exposed me to a lot of philosophical thought/thinking and random education I'd never otherwise have stumbled upon, and so much more.

It's got plenty of entertaining stuff also, but the fact that YouTube allows anyone to share anything they know with anyone in the world in a simple, visual format is amazing. Other platforms can do that too, but YouTube is obviously the biggest player in the space right now and there is value in having everything together (see: the Walmart effect).

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by ginko on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:24AM (#18440414)
I'm actually rather annoyed that it's getting more and more common these days that instructions can only be found in video form instead of articles. Articles you can quickly skim to see if it's doing what you need. Add to that that many of these videos have stupid intros and presenters trying to be funny.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Skrillex on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:44PM (#18445204)
I think that the educational content on YouTube can definitely outweigh any and all of its issues, as long as we are seeing YouTube for what it is. I am incapable of describing the breadth of knowledge that can be accessed on that site, so I will not. I can definitely see the argument that YouTube is a net-harm for children under some circumstances, but I would definitely be sad to see that amount of useful information be unavailable for everyone because it is bad for children. It is not a babysitter, and no one should trust it to be. I reject these "think of the children" arguments for something that is not designed for children to begin with.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Pristina on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:53AM (#18439619)
It's like you have no respect for people's agency at all.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by taf2 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:22AM (#18440714)
‘I watch a decent amount of YouTube, but if it went away, I don’t think that it would be a net loss to humanity’

That is because you haven’t watched grubby playing Warcraft 3!

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by Mauricio_ on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:14PM (#18471176)
Why wouldn't patron have the same problem as YouTube?
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by sbr464 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:16AM (#18439945)
I apologize to general knowledge that this is the top comment.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by consumer451 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:14AM (#18440670)
Honestly, as the author of the comment, so do I.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by scoot_718 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @06:16AM (#18440155)
EU copyright laws are stupid.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by mcv on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:02AM (#18440600)
It's not a law yet. It's a proposal that cleared its first hurdles. Though with the overwhelming majority with which the MEPs supported it, it's not looking good.

There's an election in May. Maybe if we threaten to vote out everybody who supported this, they may change their opinion. It's going to be hard to mobilize that many people about such a complex issue, though.

Sadly, I'm unable to find a good overview of which parties or MEPs supported this and which didn't.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by ionised on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @05:48AM (#18448941)
Most copyright laws, globally, are stupid.
Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by liftbigweights on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:37PM (#18438633)
> I watch a decent amount of YouTube, but if it went away, I don’t think that it would be a net loss to humanity given what YT shows to children

The good old "think of the children" argument used by authoritarian puritans.

> and how YT radicalizes viewers

As opposed to TV? Cable news? Newspapers? Or any other media?

> No one is responsible for content, and look what that’s gotten us.

Where has it gotten us?

> I would shed no tears if YT ended operation in the EU, where I live.

As an american, I feel the same way. Why don't you guys create your own youtube and stop trying to censor everyone else? Oh you can't because of the EU onerous regulations. How ironic.

I hate the pro-censorship lobby that has reared its ugly head on hacker news. Everyday, there is a barrage of comments sneakily supporting and defending censorship. Strange.

And your "sources" are highly biased at best and "fake news" at worst. It's like asking the telegram company what they think of telephones or the horse what they think of cars.

Re:YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation fina... by hayd on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:28AM (#18439305)
Nonsense. What we need is a good old fashioned book burning...