News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A note to our employees by thoughtexplorer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:47PM (#18408147)
Serious question: Does the Chief Diversity Officer include diversity of ideas and experience? Or is it just skin deep like it sounds?

Edit: Lots of up and down votes. Why is this question so controversial? I'd like to see an argument as to why it's an invalid or flawed question.

Re:A note to our employees by williamaadams on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:19PM (#18409598)
I work for Microsoft, and the back of my employee badge says: Our Mission; Empower every person and every organization on the planet to achieve more.

To me, this implies that our engineering organizations, and entire company, need to have an appropriate amount of empathy across a broad spectrum of geographies, cultures, experiences, perspectives, and the like. You only get that by having a diversity of talent, and more importantly, inclusion in your engineering practices.

When I talk about diversity, I usually say; "There are two forms of diversity, DNA diversity, the stuff we usually talk about in terms of color, sex, etc, things you can see, and then there's diversity of perspectives and experiences. You need the diversity of experiences and perspectives. In some cases that's conveniently wrapped in some forms of DNA diversity, but is not exclusive to that".

I don't think the question is at all controversial, and we should not be afraid to openly talk about it.

Re:A note to our employees by shard972 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @08:56PM (#18411822)
So what would be the benefits in DNA diversity at all? If you can get a diverse views of perspectives, why bring in the DNA diversity which is going to lead to conflicts as people won't be able to talk as effectively as people who are more homogeneous?
Re:A note to our employees by DoofusOfDeath on Thursday November 08, 2018 @10:15PM (#18412093)
> So what would be the benefits in DNA diversity at all?

Well, this is a pretty contrived example, but IIRC a major company (HP?) made facial-recognition software that couldn't handle people with dark skin.

If there had been people like that on the dev or testing team, perhaps it would have been noticed earlier.

Re:A note to our employees by repolfx on Friday November 09, 2018 @03:50AM (#18413163)
That story is apocryphal. The software in question simply struggled with low contrast images like a dark face in a dark room, which isn't due to racism or employees forgetting that black people exist: it's an inherently hard image recognition problem.
Re:A note to our employees by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday November 08, 2018 @09:54PM (#18412025)
Are you seriously arguing companies should be entirely white and male because then there won't be sexism and racism problems?!

And are you aware that non-DNA differences also create divisions?

Re:A note to our employees by morgtheborg on Friday November 09, 2018 @02:27AM (#18412897)
> would be the benefits in DNA diversity at all

I would argue there's often correlation between these types of diversity

Re:A note to our employees by majewsky on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:40PM (#18411056)
> Our Mission; Empower every person and every organization on the planet to achieve more.

Did they think about what they said there before printing? Because there are plenty of organizations which we definitely do not want to achieve more (e.g. drug cartels, nazi parties).

Re:A note to our employees by jameslevy on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:52PM (#18411139)
I don't think the creators these mission statements are too concerned about the edge cases.
Re:A note to our employees by majewsky on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:30PM (#18411408)
Not really. PR is all about taking the edge off things. Which is why this struck me as odd.
Re:A note to our employees by aasasd on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:06PM (#18411239)
I may disapprove of one's views, but I'll commit my code for their right for better software!
Re:A note to our employees by fmitchell0 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:59PM (#18408270)
Serious response: Framing it as an 'Or' implies the two are mutually exclusive. They are not. Diversity is fact. The world is diverse in a variety of ways (skin, eyes, experiences, gender, language, nationality, etc.). Inclusion is the action. Equity is the goal.

In the OKR framework, being able to measure your progress towards the goal is important. The real question is, which aspects of people who work for your company do you measure to ensure proper decisions around inclusion to achieve the equity goal?

It's easiest to measure by 'skin deep' factors b/c that is what human beings most easily make poor decisions on (fear, bias, stereotype, self-segregation, NIMBY-ism, etc). It is also required for companies to report to the US government on these factors because of our history of poor decisions (to put it lightly). It is therefore easiest to use that as a metric.

Serious question: If implied in your question that the goal should be equity in 'thought', how do you propose that is measured?

Re:A note to our employees by Benjammer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:16PM (#18408439)
> If implied in your question that the goal should be equity in 'thought', how do you propose that is measured?

OP mentioned "ideas & experience," not "thought," which seems like an intentional framing as something unbounded and immeasurable.

Diversity of ideas could be measured by the average number of options/solutions that are seriously considered (and investigated/piloted) over the course of multiple projects for a team.

Diversity of experience seems somewhat obvious to me. But if you want clarity on this as well, the idea would be to value various types of experiences in the same way that companies value diverse outward traits like gender, sex, skin color, racial identity, etc. It's a balance. You could hire a person of each gender/skin color combination, but if they all grew up in the New England suburbs and all of them went to either MIT or Harvard, you are generally NOT going to have a diversity of experience, even though everyone _looks_ different. On the other end of the scale, you could hire one person from each type of school, big state school, small technical school, ivy league, "public ivy", liberal arts college, bootcamp graduate, etc. Hire people native to your country/culture, and people who come from a different part of the world. But if they are all white men, you are not going to realize as much benefit.

I think it's important to make an attempt to combine all of these concepts to come up with something that approaches the concept of "diversity of thought."

Re:A note to our employees by fmitchell0 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:26PM (#18408525)
I appreciate your response and respect your idea of trying to combine a lot of aspects to get the goal. I would challenge you on one point though:

> gender/skin color combination, but if they all grew up in the New England suburbs and all of them went to either MIT or Harvard, you are generally NOT going to have a diversity of experience, even though everyone _looks_ different

Unfortunately, there are many stories, points of evidence, and history that say people who look different, but come from the same place and education level DO have different experiences. Race and gender are exponentially powerful factors that can change a person's experience and outlook no matter how wealthy they are or what school they graduated from.

Re:A note to our employees by Benjammer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:40PM (#18409249)
You are correct, I should not have used absolute, either-or terms there ("you are generally NOT ..."). I meant to say that you would not have _as much_ diversity of experience.
Re:A note to our employees by wyattk on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:40PM (#18408688)
Well stated. Until I saw it, I did not realize how many people went from rich (interpretations vary based on your experience, so "comfortable") suburbs and homes to "good" schools to "good" companies and professions. This is my experience, but that tends to be a common path and results in little diversity of "thought" (meaning ideas and experience).

It's become apparent to me that diversity is an ambiguous terms and its interpretation can vary a lot over many factors and time. I am not discounting any definition of it. When it comes up, it feels like people are on different pages with it. It could more prudent to state the definition when it is said.

Re:A note to our employees by thoughtexplorer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:51PM (#18408797)
Precisely. That's what was embedded in the question. It doesn't matter what color people are. It's not meaningful diversity on its own.

What they seem to be doing is judging people based on surface traits, not the content of character. Their approach to diversity is a regression and not good for progress.

Re:A note to our employees by Benjammer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:44PM (#18409283)
I would caution you on taking such an absolute, "zero sum" stance here.

>It doesn't matter what color people are.

I hope you realize the absurdity of this statement in isolation...

Re:A note to our employees by ubernostrum on Saturday November 10, 2018 @12:43AM (#18420131)
What they seem to be doing is judging people based on surface traits

Do you believe that a poor black kid from Detroit is only different in "surface traits" as compared to a rich white kid from Orange County?

Or would you be willing to concede that there may be reliable correlations between some "surface traits" and diversity of life experiences and viewpoints? Demographic analysis of things like voting patterns in the US seems to suggest differences of such magnitude that I doubt you'd find another factor more strongly predictive.

Re:A note to our employees by prepend on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:43PM (#18409278)
“Equity is the goal.”

I don’t think this is a good goal. Unless you mean equity of opportunity. Equity of outcome is a ridiculously foolish goal in that outcomes will vary substantially and trying to have equity at the end on arbitrary human factors with easy to measure biases (gender, race, etc).

So the goal is not 45/45/10 for gender distribution for all roles. As that is obviously impossible as roles change and then people would need to be redistributed ad infinitum (eg, project managers have “perfect” gender diversity of 45/45/10 today but now the role is changes and split into product owner and product manager. Does this mean that the roles must include the same gender mix?)

Re:A note to our employees by skedaddle on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:45PM (#18411088)
Equity and equality are different. Equitable means fair, just, unprejudiced, considerate of all involved, etc. Equality means evenly balanced, identical on both sides, measurably indistinguishable.

I think we want an equitable outcome and that most people (regardless of any other opinion) would actually agree that equality of outcome is not necessary.

Re:A note to our employees by prepend on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:10PM (#18411269)
I appreciate you making the distinction, but I still don’t think outcomes are the place for equity. My gender example still stands using your clarified definition.

Is it fair that now a sub population has different gender distributions? Is it fair that 90% of programmers are male? Etc etc. I think it is counterproductive and too late to making meaningful changes based on outcomes.

Perhaps if you get to a high enough macro, but even then, I see logical weaknessss in opinions comparing income based on gender because outcome does not, necessarily, mean bias. It’s just easier to measure.

Re:A note to our employees by aaaaaaaaaab on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:30PM (#18409701)
Apologies for my ignorance but what does “45/45/10” mean?
Re:A note to our employees by CamTin on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:18PM (#18410133)
From context I'd guess he means 45% male, 45% female, 10% non-binary.
Re:A note to our employees by albertgoeswoof on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:33PM (#18410248)
Is that a real policy for anywhere? How / where do you find 10% non binary from? I don’t think there’s enough people to go around even if you hired every single non binary person in a given city.
Re:A note to our employees by prepend on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:13PM (#18411285)
I did mean 10% as non/binary, but my numbers were just notional. I should have been more clear.

I think, especially with improved technology, that 10% will be more common. Cynically thinking, it will be easier if there were some specific quota. Gender is probably the easiest protected class to change after religion, so it’s especially sensitive to outcome quotas.

Re:A note to our employees by aaaaaaaaaab on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:53PM (#18410398)
Oh, I see! I wasn’t familiar with this term.

So, this system is used in the United States, right?

Re:A note to our employees by meowface on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:17PM (#18410570)
The poster was suggesting a hypothetical situation where that is a policy. Very few places in the US have 50/50 gender quotas, and I doubt any have quotas which include non-binary people. I believe they were mocking the idea.
Re:A note to our employees by prepend on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:14PM (#18411298)
I was not mocking the idea, but giving an example where a reasonable quota led to bad outcomes. While I’m against outcome quotas, I’m firmly against discrimination (including mocking) of people based on who they are.
Re:A note to our employees by dannyw on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:18PM (#18410134)
Male, female, non-binary.
Re:A note to our employees by mebreuer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:25PM (#18409646)
With a high enough sample size, shouldn't equity of outcome reflect equity of opportunity?
Re:A note to our employees by naasking on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:38PM (#18410285)
Not at all. For instance, if there are innate gender dispositions to certain subjects, then those fields will have a much larger proportion of that gender. There's evidence this may be the case in STEM for instance, which would explain the so-called gender equality paradox.
Re:A note to our employees by prepend on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:16PM (#18411308)
Perhaps, but it wouldn’t be useful for companies since even google’s 20k population wouldn’t be big enough to clear out all of the confounding variables.
Re:A note to our employees by ed_balls on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:10PM (#18408379)
from all websites I'd expect HN to NOT read OR as mutually exclusive
Re:A note to our employees by rendall on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:06PM (#18409484)
"Does the Chief Diversity Officer include diversity of ideas and experience? Or is it just skin deep like it sounds?"

Well, to nitpick even further, those propositions are logically mutually exclusive.

"Does the Chief Diversity Officer include diversity of ideas and experience [as well as surface traits]?" Or is it [only surface traits]"

Abstracted, could be "(p and q) OR (p and !q)" which is literally mutually exclusive.

No, I'm not usually so pedantic, I just thought it was interesting.

Re:A note to our employees by PurpleBoxDragon on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:57PM (#18409950)
I think that English OR is Logical XOR and logical OR is English "A or B or both" or "A and/or B".

Oddly enough, my use of or seems to violates the very rule it is used to describe.

Re:A note to our employees by mrguyorama on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:48PM (#18409322)
OR being mutually exclusive is pretty typical in the english language, for better or worse.
Re:A note to our employees by fmitchell0 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:12PM (#18408405)
I see what you did there. Well done.
Re:A note to our employees by PavlovsCat on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:49PM (#18409877)
To the degree something is deep, it is not shallow, and vice versa. That something is easy to measure does not per se make it less or more shallow.
[dead]
Re:A note to our employees by ummonk on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:30PM (#18409158)
Or more accurately white, chinese, and indian males.
Re:A note to our employees by gizmo686 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:02PM (#18408301)
I don't have any experience with Google in this regard (beyond looking into the Damore case, which is a bit muddy because of the amount of public pressure Google was facing [0]). However, in my experience, diversity programs and officers tend to be about liability and checkboxes; and there is no legal checkbox for diversity of ideas.

Plus, surface diversity is much easier to measure; and you optimize for your metrics.

[0] Ideally a diversity officer would stand up for Damore. But I have no idea what went on behind the scenes of that decidion.

Re:A note to our employees by munificent on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:14PM (#18408427)
> [0] Ideally a diversity officer would stand up for Damore.

That claim depends entirely on how you interpret Damore's behavior. Tolerance does not and must not require tolerating intolerance [0].

I'm not stating a claim as to whether or not Damore's behavior should be considered intolerance. I don't have a take on that. But without having some opinion on that, you can't claim a priori that a diversity officer is obligated to enable his views.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Re:A note to our employees by gizmo686 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:27PM (#18408546)
I don't want to relitigate the entire Damore saga. But for the sake of conversation, I will state that my view was that he was engaging in good faith with the diversity program Google was running.

The statement I made in my previous comment does not actually require this however. Even if Damore was actually acting in bad faith, fireing him would still have a chilling effect unless it was thought by every Googler that he was clearly acting in bad faith.

Further, I would excpect a Chief Diversity Officer to understand how perception alone can create a hostile environment, so ignorance of this (or disagreemrnent about the facts of the case) is not a good excuse.

Re:A note to our employees by snowwrestler on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:48PM (#18410362)
> Even if Damore was actually acting in bad faith, fireing him would still have a chilling effect unless it was thought by every Googler that he was clearly acting in bad faith.

You can't help side effects. If someone is acting in a way that is detrimental to the company, you have to fire them, even if you know it will upset some other people in the company.

Re:A note to our employees by jerf on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:01PM (#18408898)
"Tolerance does not and must not require tolerating intolerance"

On the other hand, it's rather convenient how much intolerance can itself be justified by simply quoting that and just a bit of rules lawyering.

Re:A note to our employees by LanceH on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:11PM (#18408985)
I feel a proof by induction coming.
Re:A note to our employees by naasking on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:41PM (#18410305)
> Tolerance does not and must not require tolerating intolerance [0]

I honestly hate how often this is trotted out. Does no one realize that this claim is not based on any evidence whatsoever? Why prefer Popper's claim over Rawls' or Jefferson's?

This is typically used to justify yet more intolerance, and around and around we go.

Re:A note to our employees by uxp100 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:38PM (#18410709)
Especially since in the full context it's a bit more measured. This portion follows what is typically quoted:

"In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be unwise. But we should claim the right to suppress them if necessary even by force;"

Seems Popper would not have much issue with tolerating Damore, but tolerating things like Neo-nazi marches probably crosses his line.

Re:A note to our employees by naasking on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:49PM (#18410783)
> Seems Popper would not have much issue with tolerating Damore, but tolerating things like Neo-nazi marches probably crosses his line.

Probably not even then! Neo-nazis are a tiny minority that's suppressed by public opinion. Now if they were to suddenly start gaining political power, then we have a real problem.

Re:A note to our employees by claudiawerner on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:07PM (#18410887)
>Does no one realize that this claim is not based on any evidence whatsoever?

And yet it remains an interesting thought experiment, doesn't it? Didn't it work on Reddit, in which they found that driving hateful communities out raised the level of discourse? And a possible way to structure society. Hitler himself admitted that had the Nazis not been tolerated, they wouldn't have gained the foothold they did. Not only do I prefer Popper's claim, but I prefer the Frankfurt School's claim too[0]. Which, in my view, stands firmly in line with the democratic functions of society envisioned by such liberals as J.S. Mill for instance.

But it comes down to ideology; it is not a crime nor an intellectual failing to dismiss liberalism on ideological grounds.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18368318

Re:A note to our employees by naasking on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:31AM (#18413925)
> And yet it remains an interesting thought experiment, doesn't it?

Sure, but that doesn't make it a sound policy for real political discourse.

> Didn't it work on Reddit, in which they found that driving hateful communities out raised the level of discourse?

Or did it simply fuel a growing narrative of censorship and persecution which is driving the counter-PC culture and electing people like Trump? I don't think analyzing this as a closed system is faithful to the point I'm making, because these changes can and do have negative externalities.

> Hitler himself admitted that had the Nazis not been tolerated, they wouldn't have gained the foothold they did.

So basically, had the majority of the country not been sympathetic to Nazi principles, then Nazis wouldn't have gotten elected? That strikes me as absurdly tautological. A minority of people cannot be resist the wishes of a majority via intolerance, and if good people are the majority, then they can safely ignore the minority.

> Not only do I prefer Popper's claim, but I prefer the Frankfurt School's claim too[0].

This claim at that link is pure nonsense: "Tolerance is a democratic principle, since it relies on the idea that nobody has an absolute claim on the truth"

No, simply false. Tolerance is justified by the recognition that all people have intrinsic value ala Kant, that they are thinking feeling beings and that unless you wish to launch your own campaign for genocide against people with whom you disagree, then you should seek to convince them of your version of the truth using non-violent means.

The only time violence is justified is in response to violence. The far left and the far right are both guilty of violating this principle.

Re:A note to our employees by claudiawerner on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:58AM (#18414325)
>Sure, but that doesn't make it a sound policy for real political discourse.

I can't see why not.

>Or did it simply fuel a growing narrative of censorship and persecution which is driving the counter-PC culture and electing people like Trump?

No. And besides, on the logic that it might make people angry or convinced of their delusional views therefore we shouldn't do it is very poor reasoning.

>because these changes can and do have negative externalities.

In the same way that naive tolerance does?

>had the majority of the country not been sympathetic to Nazi principles, then Nazis wouldn't have gotten elected?

No.

"Only one thing could have broken our movement – if the adversary had understood its principle and from the first day had smashed with extreme brutality the nucleus of our new movement." (A Hitler at the 1933 Nuremberg Nazi Party rally)

"If our opponents had been clever, considering that political weapons were so unevenly distributed, they could have undoubtedly found ways and opportunities to make our success impossible." (J Goebbels, 1934)

"If the enemy had known how weak we were, it would probably have reduced us to jelly. It would have crushed in blood the very beginning of our work" (J Goebbels, 1934)

>Tolerance is justified by the recognition that all people have intrinsic value ala Kant

Not in democratic society; can you point me to which Kantian thinkers (including Kant himself!) whose thought formed the basis of any modern state? Tolerance as we know it emerged only with the emergence of widespread democracy after the French revolution beginning in Western Europe and the American revolution in the New World. Both republics founded on democracy (and therefore tolerance), not a Kantian maxim. As Marcuse said in 1965,

"Moreover, in endlessly dragging debates over the media, the stupid opinion is treated with the same respect as the intelligent one, the misinformed may talk as long as the informed, and propaganda rides along with education, truth with falsehood. This pure toleration of sense and nonsense is justified by the democratic argument that nobody, neither group nor individual, is in possession of the truth and capable of defining what is right and wrong, good and bad. Therefore, all contesting opinions must be submitted to 'the people' for its deliberation and choice. But I have already suggested that the democratic argument implies a necessary condition, namely, that the people must be capable of deliberating and choosing on the basis of knowledge, that they must have access to authentic information, and that, on this. basis, their evaluation must be the result of autonomous thought."

>The only time violence is justified is in response to violence.

I disagree, and as I said earlier, it's no crime to disagree with liberal dogma like this. But if we must go this route, what does violence say of structural violence, for instance?

Re:A note to our employees by naasking on Saturday November 10, 2018 @11:39AM (#18422068)
> No. And besides, on the logic that it might make people angry or convinced of their delusional views therefore we shouldn't do it is very poor reasoning.

Good thing that isn't what I suggested then.

> In the same way that naive tolerance does?

Define "naive" tolerance. Seems like you're either assuming the conclusion, or trying to persuade with loaded language.

> "Only one thing could have broken our movement – if the adversary had understood its principle and from the first day had smashed with extreme brutality the nucleus of our new movement." (A Hitler at the 1933 Nuremberg Nazi Party rally) > > "If our opponents had been clever, considering that political weapons were so unevenly distributed, they could have undoubtedly found ways and opportunities to make our success impossible." (J Goebbels, 1934) > > "If the enemy had known how weak we were, it would probably have reduced us to jelly. It would have crushed in blood the very beginning of our work" (J Goebbels, 1934)

Ah, so if they hadn't been sympathetic or they had been able to read minds so as to discern the intentions of Nazi party leaders. Well that's totally reasonable then.

Honestly, precisely what expressions of intolerance do you think would have prevented the rise of the Nazi party? Everything you've quoted is devoid of anything concrete.

> Not in democratic society; can you point me to which Kantian thinkers (including Kant himself!) whose thought formed the basis of any modern state?

Irrelevant. The question is whether Kantian principles entail the relevant conclusion. We are beholden not only to government law, but moral law as well. Or do you think it's ethical or virtuous to violate the spirit of a law while following the letter of the law?

Furthermore, my claim is not that all opinions are equally valid and deserving of equal attention. My claim is that changing opinions by non-coercive means is right. Doxxing, violence, and online mobs are not right way to change opinion.

> I disagree, and as I said earlier, it's no crime to disagree with liberal dogma like this.

Not a legal crime, but nowadays it's certainly a social crime enforced by mob rule.

> But if we must go this route, what does violence say of structural violence, for instance?

That it can and should be alleviated by non-violent means, taking into consideration social inertia, ie. that it takes time for a message to propagate and persuade enough of the public. As Per MLK, violence begets violence. All the most revered figures of effective social change advocated non-violent means.

There is considerable debate whether the terrorism perpetrated by the suffragettes actually helped their cause. They clearly turned much of the public against the cause, and at best, they gained publicity for the cause, which was clearly possible to do via other means.

Re:A note to our employees by 706f6f70 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:15PM (#18410099)
> Plus, surface diversity is much easier to measure; and you optimize for your metrics.

I think this is key. Until "diversity" becomes so absolutely fragmented that you get back down to the level of the individual (e.g.you need a non-Hispanic Latino coder, who is Christian but not Catholic, was born poor but still got into an Ivy League, must be over 6 feet tall, and her name must begin with "A"), we will continue to burn resources, mental energy, and time on ensuring that we can't get sued.

Re:A note to our employees by walshemj on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:57PM (#18410430)
Non Hispanic Latino ? isn't that a moot point at his point in history un less you ant to go back to the Spanish/French system of race classification
Re:A note to our employees by gweinberg on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:20PM (#18410585)
I think Non Hispanic Latino means Brazilian.
Re:A note to our employees by ianamartin on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:17PM (#18409036)
It's basically the same role that chief security officers fill at large companies. The point isn't to actually secure anything. The point is to avoid getting sued for not securing things.
Re:A note to our employees by Angostura on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:48PM (#18409857)
You need to get a better chief security officer.
Re:A note to our employees by atom-morgan on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:17PM (#18409581)
It's controversial because it's selectively applied and advocates for D&I know it.

There are plenty of Asians in tech (men and women) and yet we're always hearing about a "diversity" problem. This is why tech no longer uses the term minority - they use "underrepresented minority" instead.

Re:A note to our employees by danans on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:48PM (#18410363)
Why should the representation of Asians in tech reduce the concerns about the under-representations of Blacks and Latinos in tech?
Re:A note to our employees by edikit on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:54PM (#18410812)
Because factoring Asians (and Indians, for that matter) in to the equation changes the framing of the argument.

Asians are a minority group, but are vastly over-represented in tech, to the point that even white people are under-represented by comparison.

The concern about racial diversity tends to focus on the idea that white hiring managers are subconsciously selective against non-white applicants. This doesn't make sense though when you factor in the minority groups that are actually over-represented.

So what has happened is that the argument has shifted to ignore Asian representation and only focus on black and Latino representation, while still coming to the same conclusion that white hiring managers are subconsciously racist and that the company needs to take corrective action.

The representation of Asians and Indians in tech should not necessarily reduce concerns for other minorities that are under-represented, but should definitely change the way those concerns are framed. The fact that it hasn't suggests that some sort of tomfoolery is afoot.

Re:A note to our employees by stale2002 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:45PM (#18411086)
> The concern about racial diversity tends to focus on the idea that white hiring managers are subconsciously selective against non-white applicants. This doesn't make sense though when you factor in the minority groups that are actually over-represented.

Of course it makes sense. It means that instead of subconsciously being biased against the non white category, they are instead biased against non white non Asians.

That was an easy logical deduction there.

Re:A note to our employees by thoughtexplorer on Thursday November 08, 2018 @08:32PM (#18411712)
Not really, you can continue down that rabbit hole forever with groups and subgroups. What of the under represented people of [skin color][origin][gender] in [profession]?

Maybe it has less to do with bias and more do to with preference and culture and upbringing and other factors. Consider how much asian parents, for example, push their kids in education and toward certain careers. Or the over representation of black people in sports and music. Or the dominance of women in teaching and healthcare. Etc.

Re:A note to our employees by danans on Thursday November 08, 2018 @08:17PM (#18411655)
> The concern about racial diversity tends to focus on the idea that white hiring managers are subconsciously selective against non-white applicants.

The concern is far more nuanced than that. It includes concerns about the the rates of representation all through the pipeline, from hiring back through University CS programs to differences in access to high quality primary and secondary education.

The problems are largely understood as being systemic, arising from unequal opportunity and different social signaling to different groups, not solely from the decisions of hiring managers.

Re:A note to our employees by amanaplanacanal on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:31PM (#18411417)
Possibly. If you put everybody into two groups "white" and "brown", that could certainly fit.

If you take popular preconceptions/prejudices around "white" "black" "hispanic" "asian", etc, maybe it doesn't match as well.

Re:A note to our employees by Aqua on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:13PM (#18409541)
To me the notion of a need for diversity in a workplace is absurd. Seriously, whats the point? There are and always have been professions dominated by men and those dominated by women. From the perspective of an employer, gender, skin colour or political views should be completely irrelevant when it comes to making a hire/no hire decision. By introducing rules that aim to achieve a 50/50 distribution of e.g. each gender in any field, you're forming up an artificial construct that ultimately results in poorer overall performance (since you had to reject a number of candidates that likely were more qualified for the position in order to reach your equal distribution goals).
Re:A note to our employees by krapp on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:54PM (#18410402)
>There are and always have been professions dominated by men and those dominated by women. From the perspective of an employer, gender, skin colour or political views should be completely irrelevant when it comes to making a hire/no hire decision.

What you're missing is that many employers don't have the perspective whereby gender, skin color or political views are irrelevant. Biases against gender, race and religion are part of the reason that many professions have been dominated by certain races, genders and religions (although laws have attempted to counteract this effect.)

The point of diversity in the workplace is to force an implicitly prejudiced employment market to be less prejudiced than it otherwise might be, just as the point of labor laws and the minimum wage are to force companies to care more about their employees' welfare than they otherwise would.

Re:A note to our employees by meowface on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:19PM (#18410578)
>What you're missing is that many employers don't have the perspective whereby gender, skin color or political views are irrelevant. Biases against gender, race and religion are part of the reason that many professions have been dominated by certain races, genders and religions (although laws have attempted to counteract this effect.)

Yes, but you can mitigate those biases with gender/race-blind hiring practices. This seems like a much fairer and more reasonable option than enforcing quotas.

Re:A note to our employees by snowwrestler on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:43PM (#18410738)
Blind hiring techniques don't do much, for several reasons.

- They only work at the screening stages. Most hiring pipelines conclude with an in-person interview, and that can't be blind.

- People are very good at reading between the lines and can often infer race and gender from education and work history alone (or at least, infer deviations from their preferred norms).

- It doesn't address the problem of industry pipelines filtering against diversity before the applications ever get to you.

- A manager who doesn't want to hire women can just treat a blindly-hired woman badly until she leaves.

- It implies to the company that diversity is something that must be hidden rather than something that should be tolerated or celebrated.

- It implies to applicants that you have intolerant managers who need to be tricked.

Re:A note to our employees by meowface on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:46PM (#18410771)
There are certainly problems with this approach and it definitely isn't a foolproof way of stopping discrimination, but I'd argue there is a longer and more concerning list of issues with hiring based on quotas.

All I know is gender/race-blind hiring works fantastically for things like music auditions. For technology-based jobs where most of the interview process can be done in writing, over the phone, or over a shared virtual whiteboard or document (for coding or drawing diagrams), there's no reason why everything up to the in-person interview can't be as age, gender, and race blind as possible.

Re:A note to our employees by baddox on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:10PM (#18410064)
It may not have much value in a coal mine, but I suspect it is highly valuable even from a purely commercial/competitive perspective in industries and workplaces that are creating/maintaining products or services for a large or broad audience.

> you're forming up an artificial construct that ultimately results in poorer overall performance (since you had to reject a number of candidates that likely were more qualified for the position in order to reach your equal distribution goals).

That's precisely where I disagree. Again, in a coal mine you might just want to hire for simple traits that can be easily evaluated per individual (like physical strength). But on the types of teams I mentioned, the diversity of experiences and opinions across the team probably matters as much or even more than the sum of every individual's "talents." I would guess that this diversity becomes more important the larger the team gets and the larger the audience for their products/services gets.

To be clear, I also suspect that more diverse teams are more difficult to hire and manage effectively, and that's probably a big reason that some companies either don't care about diversity or actively resist the suggestion to increase their diversity.

Re:A note to our employees by zbentley on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:28PM (#18411396)
> There are and always have been professions dominated by men and those dominated by women.

Put in the most mercenary way I can think of:

There are and have always also been professions in which hiring decisionmakers screw their own organizations out of talent by ignoring or down-ranking candidates they were bigoted against. There similarly are/have been professions in which talented people with potential to add great value have been driven away by similarly bigoted leaders.

We don't know what might have been, what potential might have been achieved, because of the idiotic/cruel things we've practiced throughout history. Acting like ethical, compassionate, empathetic people seems like a way more pragmatic way than "well, it worked so far, let's keep being bigoted assholes" to see if we could do better in the future.

Re:A note to our employees by kaitai on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:04PM (#18410015)
You seem to be conflating quotas and diversity, and also conflating mechanisms and results. The point of a diversity office or officer is to provide a resource for discussing whether mechanisms of hiring and recruitment are fair, and trying to improve them if they're not.

Once all those studies that send out the same exact resume with the names John, Jane, T'yesha, Jamal, Xiaoying, and Shan Shan at the top find you get the same number of callbacks, then we'll actually be in a situation where people are being hired on their qualifications!

Re:A note to our employees by Aqua on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:07PM (#18410489)
Apologies, I should have been more clear as I intended to point out an example, not a fixed quota, because clearly if you consider diversity when making a hiring decision you inevitably have to end up aiming to hire more people of certain characteristics(and not necessarily qualifications) that fit your long term quota goals.

Besides, what do you mean by fair recruitment? Because personally in this context I view diversity and fairness as contradicting terms, since it would always be more fair to hire a candidate that has higher qualifications and is a good cultural fit over one that wasn't as qualified, but turned out to be a good match when it comes to meeting present quarter's diversity goals?

I believe that basing hiring decisions on physical appearance, race, religion, gender or political views is simply wrong. I recall there was a company that focused on distorting candidates' voices during phone interviews that effectively prevented the interviewers from distinguishing the interviewees' gender. If companies like Google want to actually be more "fair", perhaps they should move in that direction rather than introducing artificial quotas and justifying them with a vague "need for diversity"?

Re:A note to our employees by amanaplanacanal on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:38PM (#18411447)
You mentioned "good cultural fit". I have heard many hiring managers mention that they want somebody who is a good fit for the team. And it's very natural, I mean, everybody is going to have to work with this person, right?

This almost guarantees the perpetuation of inequality. We need to stop hiring for that kind of fit.

I'm certain that I have heard of research (by IBM maybe?) that determined that more diversity made teams more productive, but the people on the teams were less happy/comfortable.

Re:A note to our employees by tk75x on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:15AM (#18413872)
> more diversity made teams more productive, but the people on the teams were less happy/comfortable.

Maybe because nobody wanted to socialize with each other so they spent more time doing work?

Re:A note to our employees by repolfx on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:42AM (#18413588)
The resume problem is the inverse, isn't it? The studies I've seen where resumes were having names removed before being sent to recruiters showed a slight bias against white men which is why these schemes always get shut down - increasing fairness decreases (slightly) diversity.
Re:A note to our employees by dijit on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:43PM (#18410314)
This whole thread is becoming toxic; and I know my karma will be negatively impacted but I have to say:

Diversity of race or gender is not really important when it comes to working by itself.

Diversity of experience and thought is very important when it comes to working.

What I mean is a very middle-class white family and a very middle-class black family producing offspring in a house next to each other and sending their kids to the same school(s): are not going to be functionally diverse enough for what I'm about to say.

Why?: because people who are thinking differently to you are approaching problems from other sides than you are, if you can be civil then you can build your product in ways you could never do alone.

Now; people who were raised in a different kind of culture or social class than you are basically by default: thinking differently.

It doesn't have to be colour, but in the US (from a brit perspective) your class system looks like black people are sandwiched between middle-class white folk and very low-class white folk. So some people might see that 'hiring black folk would increase our diversity of thought'

or.. more likely, they're being judged on metrics and skin colour/gender is an easy metric to game for.

Giving people an equal shot is noble and we should aspire for it. The business incentives come in because your product will be better with divergent opinions and by increasing the talent pool the supply of coders will meet the demand.. (and then they can pay coders less in the longer term)

Re:A note to our employees by naasking on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:44PM (#18410331)
> To me the notion of a need for diversity in a workplace is absurd. Seriously, whats the point?

There are some advantages. For instance, people with different religions or cultural backgrounds will have non-overlapping holidays, so your office might be open on days that you might otherwise have to close.

Or consider if you're creating a dating app, you would absolutely want a woman's input on how to reduce harassment (see Tinder vs. Bumble).

Re:A note to our employees by bryondowd on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:54AM (#18413405)
I think the idea is to counter one artificial construct with another. It's been shown that otherwise identical resumes are less likely to be selected when the name is clearly female or minority rather than a common white male name. That would indicate a hiring bias that has nothing to do with ability. Since it's virtually impossible to fix that bias, a common solution is to introduce an opposite bias. Not perfect, but I've never seen a better solution posited. "Just have better hiring managers/practices" doesn't seem to scale.
Re:A note to our employees by snowwrestler on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:17PM (#18410571)
> since you had to reject a number of candidates that likely were more qualified for the position in order to reach your equal distribution goals

Your assumption here is that the status quo of hiring is an optimum that must be sacrificed for diversity.

The reality is that every hiring program already uses diversity as a criterion, but unless a measurable objective is set, it will invisibly optimize for the comfort of current employees, rather than job performance.

The purpose of measuring diversity in hiring practices is to remove or control a confounding factor, not to add one.

Re:A note to our employees by morgtheborg on Friday November 09, 2018 @02:29AM (#18412906)
I generally agree with you. Certainly 50%/50% is insane when the pipeline itself isn't giving you that percentage of qualified candidates based on objective measurements.

However, as other have mentioned, there are already biases to hire people "like you" and offsetting those biases is valuable. Often, I'd argue "culture fit" is an umbrella term used to keep people who are different out.

Re:A note to our employees by jimbokun on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:13PM (#18411286)
"There are and always have been professions dominated by men and those dominated by women."

And a lot of that was caused by pervasive discrimination.

Re:A note to our employees by chasing on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:44PM (#18409821)
I suspect it's controversial because HNers think you're referencing people like James Damore and/or people who wrap themselves in the mantle of "diversity of ideas" when they start making racist or sexist comments.

Is that the kind of "diversity of ideas and experience" you're talking about?

Re:A note to our employees by lawnchair_larry on Thursday November 08, 2018 @11:39PM (#18412368)
Calm down, nobody said anything racist or sexist. How do you expect to have a discussion about this when you attack people for words that you put in their mouth before they had a chance to even engage?

Damore didn't do that, by the way.

Re:A note to our employees by hrktb on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:17PM (#18410947)
Your question has so much baggage in so few words.

Your premise is that if the CDO’s role doesn’t include your vision of diversity it is “just skin deep”. Not everyone shares this premise, and focusing on this point also makes it sound like you dismiss all the other aspect his role could have (they’re just skin deep after all, right ?)

To get back to yor question, Google has offices all around the world, I find it hard to fault them for lack of diversity of experiences, nor do I think the thousands of people they employ all have the same ideas. I’d actually think it would be harder to find people all sharing all the same ideas.

Or do you have something a lot more specific in mind ?

Re:A note to our employees by rimliu on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:30PM (#18410648)
I don’t remember where I saw it first (reddit, likely), but: have you seen a msle diversity officer?
Re:A note to our employees by zbentley on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:31PM (#18411412)
Two, at two different companies. One had a male/female team, the other just had a guy.
Re:A note to our employees by 98codes on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:35PM (#18409743)
It's controversial because you're conflating diversity in who people are (that they didn't choose, and can't change), vs. what they choose (actions and ideas that can be changed if the individual so chooses).
Re:A note to our employees by goobynight on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:56PM (#18408248)
What's more important is if those values spread from the CDO down to teams, whether he holds them or not. From everything I hear as an outsider, that's definitely not the case.
Re:A note to our employees by leothekim on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:43PM (#18411473)
Doesn't sound skin deep to me. Why do you think it sounds like that?
Re:A note to our employees by Aeolun on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:19PM (#18410577)
It’s not an invalid question. It just tramples on a lot of peoples toes.
Re:A note to our employees by mattmanser on Thursday November 08, 2018 @05:33PM (#18410676)
It is as, unlike people, not all ideas and experience deserve equality.
Re:A note to our employees by mikekchar on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:24PM (#18411365)
How is this for controversial? Diversity of ideas and experience could also be interpreted as lack of direction. In truth, "ideas and experience" could cover anything from cultural issues to technical issues. However, I'll point out some ways that "diversity in ideas an experience" could be interpreted, just so you get a feeling for why someone might object to a non-specific label like that.

Elsewhere in the thread, people are talking about excessive drinking on the job contributing to harassment. In the culture where I currently live (Japan), drinking is virtually mandatory. In fact, I once got an official reprimand for not drinking at a company event. Within the Japanese culture, drinking allows you to relax the way your present yourself. If you are drunk, it is acceptable to clearly say what you think, even if it might be embarrassing for others. This may be the only time to provide feedback up the ladder. Additionally, people higher up in the organisation are allowed to be more familiar with those lower down, which is impossible in normal every day work. This develops an honest camaraderie up and down the organisation and without the social lubricant (or excuse is probably a better word) that is alcohol, the work culture suffers.

Now, perhaps we have several Japanese people who have experienced significant success with this corporate culture. Do we want to grant it a kind of equivalent status within our organisation? Or do we want to have a kind of veto that says, "Despite your previous experience and your cultural background, this is a no-go area for our organisation"?

Even when talking about technical rather than cultural issues, there may be times when we need to limit discussion. I may have hired someone with extensive C++ experience into my Ruby on Rails team. Having that experience is really valuable. The C++ programmer can see things from different perspectives and provide solutions that are different that what the average Rails developer has seen before. However, if the C++ programmer suddenly starts demanding that all string processing should be handled in C++, we might want to limit this discussion. The C++ programmer may have lots of wonderful tools and experience to help them with this task, but the bulk of the developers on the team are not going to be able to cope. Potentially every developer on the team has some niche thing that they would like to introduce. Do we really want to provide a stage for all of these ideas, or do we want to filter them first and work on the ideas that seem most compatible with the team?

It is entirely possible that you disagree with my standpoint. I certainly have met a few people who feel that giving every person in the company an equal opportunity to pursue all of their ideas is a good idea. I have not experienced a successful company that embraced that philosophy, however. Leadership is often about focusing on a few ideas and limiting discussion that appear to be going in incompatible directions. As much as I am frustrated when my ideas get shot down without much air time, I recognise the reality of this necessity.

It's also possible that you have a completely different point that you are hoping to make and it was lost on me due to the brevity of your comment. In that case, perhaps it would be better to try to explain your position in more detail.

Re:A note to our employees by cryoshon on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:49PM (#18408173)
i would say that at google there's a chance they're including diversity of ideas and experience.

at most companies, we all know that the skin-deep diversity is the only thing the HR department cares about because it's all they're terrified about getting sued over. however, given google's unique corporate culture, i think that they might be forward thinking enough to seek out different perspectives, but probably not in a quota-driven fashion.

Re:A note to our employees by georgeburdell on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:27PM (#18408545)
You’re getting downvoted because Google and many other well known tech companies are known not to be comfortable places to work if you’re a conservative. Political ideology, like skin color, should not itself be a diversity goal, but the former often reflects differences in mindsets that may be better suited for certain projects or job roles.
Re:A note to our employees by cryoshon on Thursday November 08, 2018 @01:55PM (#18408839)
there's a lot more to a person's perspective than their political ideology. i imagine at google it'd be advantageous to have people who approached problems with a plethora of cognitive approaches, however. it's difficult to measure such things, of course.

political ideology can't be a meaningful diversity goal anyway, nor should it be. there may not be a "best" ideology but promoting political ideology alone would be a terrible idea because in the current way that diversity is practiced it would require treating ideologies like nazism as on the same table as others.

Re:A note to our employees by tracker1 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @03:24PM (#18409637)
I find that the mindset can be dramatically different in many cases depending on one's own experience and background. The length of which a company may intercede or donate to a different pool of candidates, as a simple example depends on the makeup from its' leadership down to its' employees.

My parents have always been right-leaning, working class. I, myself am far more libertarian leaning, with a bit of pragmatism. I'm fairly certain that I wouldn't like the political culture present in Google, and do not feel like my ideas would be respected in that culture at all. It emphatically does not mean that my point of view is less valid, but would more often than not be aggressively dismissed in that culture. Not to mention that I'm a cis-gendered, white male, which seems to be looked down on overall in a few of the large, progressive technical companies by itself.

In the end, it does matter. Culture, for good or bad, influences the makeup of a company. I tend to only have literally a couple drinks a month, or less generally not at work. That said, I don't feel there's shame in having a beer/ale/wine at lunch now and then. It should be about personal responsibility and accountability. It also shouldn't turn into a witch hunt without investigation.

Like most things in life, it depends.

Re:A note to our employees by repolfx on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:49AM (#18413611)
Political diversity would come naturally if a company really is trying to get a diversity of backgrounds and experiences because those different experiences are the cause of political differences to begin with. In fact "political diversity" and "diversity of thought" are simply two ways to phrase the same idea.

The problem with trying to actually do it is that in recent times, one camp in particular tends to label the other as "Nazis" who must be crushed out of existence the moment they're spotted, although there are essentially no actual Nazis in the world today. In other words the side that preaches tolerance and diversity the most can't actually handle it and immediately tries to get rid of it by using the most overblown pastiches imaginable.