News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:32AM (#17934520)
> New tech companies are driving the rents up in the area higher and higher. The endpoint of this process can be seen in San Francisco, which once must have been a halfway livable city.

This is more the fault of NIMBYs and supply&demand-denialists who work hard to prevent new housing from going up. Yes, tech companies brought the demand because of good jobs, but last I checked, we wanted companies to offer high paying jobs, did we not? If the people need more housing, the solution is, shockingly enough, to build more housing.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by titzer on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:21AM (#17934950)
> This is more the fault of NIMBYs and supply&demand-denialists

I don't think you quite grasp the effects of a massive influx of hundreds to thousands of new individuals making $150k-250k. It increases rent across the board, which impacts all the people in an area. Sure, it might create a few new jobs for baristas and shopkeepers, a few bartenders and waitresses. But ultimately it just leads to gentrification and prices people out of the market. It negatively affects all renters and only benefits speculators and owners in the area.

You wonder why people are angry? It's because of tonedeaf responses from big companies pushing their agendas.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:32AM (#17935054)
> I don't think you quite grasp the effects of a massive influx of hundreds to thousands of new individuals making $150k-250k.

I'm from the bay area and pay close attention to land use/zoning issues, so yeah, I think I do. The bay area has had particularly extreme series of decades of rent increases precisely because of anti-housing policies. If the market was allowed to respond, rents would still rise, to be sure, but not nearly as much.

> Sure, it might create a few new jobs for baristas and shopkeepers, a few bartenders and waitresses. But ultimately it just leads to gentrification and prices people out of the market.

Anchor industries succeeding in a metro also raises wages for others in that metro. But, the catch is that the wage rise may not necessarily be enough to match the increase in cost of living. The bay area (and really all coastal California) is a good example of this. Wages for a lot of random job types are higher than normal, but housing is still too expensive.

> You wonder why people are angry? It's because of tonedeaf responses from big companies pushing their agendas.

Companies have a basic duty to run themselves ethically and obey laws and regulations. "You created too many high-paying jobs" is a silly thing to get upset at them for, when the problem is clearly a governmental failure. Liberal US cities are neither permitting the market to create new housing, nor are they creating large amounts of public housing themselves. Their attitude amounts to, "We've tried nothing, and we're all out of ideas!"

You want a solution? Look at Singapore or Vienna.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:57AM (#17935302)
> Companies have a basic duty to run themselves ethically and obey laws and regulations.

Externalities exist. Companies cannot pretend they operate independently of the communities they're based in.

They also can't shut their ears. Even if local zoning laws are at fault, these companies which spend lavishly on lobbyists at the national and provincial level, don't seem to be agitating for local change to improve housing conditions, which would better both their employees' quality of life and their own public perception.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:17PM (#17935473)
> Externalities exist. Companies cannot pretend they operate independently of the communities they're based in.

True enough, higher wages cause prices of goods and services to rise. But again, the externality in this case is a result of workers having more money: exactly what everyone in the country, right and left, wants to see. That's why getting upset at them for that is silly.

It's like getting upset at green energy companies for making coal miners obsolete by getting cheaper and more productive. Yeah, that's an externality, and it sucks for those miners. But ultimately, that's still what society wants to have happen.

> Even if local zoning laws are at fault, these companies which spend lavishly on lobbyists at the national and provincial level, don't seem to be agitating for local change to improve housing conditions, which would better both their employees' quality of life and their own public perception.

No, they absolutely do. For example, Google is in frequent contact with the Mountain View city council over land use, for example, and has been supportive of adding housing to the north bayshore area where their HQ is.

However, many residents, especially long-term residents, are skeptical or critical of big tech companies, so they can only throw their weight around so much. Putting too much pressure on local cities would just cause a political backlash. Yes, Google is rich, but ultimately residents voting is what brings about regulatory changes. Contrary to what many Americans seem to think, companies can't just directly buy new laws.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by carapace on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:37PM (#17935643)
I think you're a good person, and arguing in good faith, but I wish you could hear how you sound to "the other side", meaning the folks who just got themselves arrested for their silly stunt.

I'm not saying anyone is right or wrong, I'm just trying to point out how the same words can sound wonderful or insidious, friendly or patronizing, depending on the listener.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by evanlivingston on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:47AM (#17935205)
Or conversely, look at Portland for an example a place where keeping up with housing demand has not translated into preserving a quantity of affordable housing. Abstracted supply and demand alone does not result in ensuring housing at various price points
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:51AM (#17935246)
Portland still greatly restricts where denser housing may be built. When you concentrate most of the new stock in huge towers, it's harder to get anything affordable since huge towers are inherently expensive to build.

The point isn't that fewer restricts means housing prices won't climb at all, but that they won't climb as quickly. For the truly affordable segment, they're either served with old housing (like with cars), or with public housing.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by seucs on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:56AM (#17935295)
Or Vancouver. Singapore and Vienna is really a counter argument more than anything else. These are places were the government have significant control over, and are essentially undermining, the housing market. This isn't changing zoning a little bit. In Singapore the government acquired most of the land. And Austria is spending the equivalent of a defense budget each year on housing subsidies alone.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:21PM (#17935505)
Personally I'm fine with either the market or the government providing new housing, and ideally I think we'd have a lot of both.

> This isn't changing zoning a little bit.

It's true, fairly radical zoning changes are warranted. Or at least, radical by US standards. Although you probably wouldn't have to go quite as far as Singapore, since obviously US cities aren't as land restricted.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by mosdl on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:13PM (#17935934)
Except Vienna housing keeps getting more expensive as there isn't much stock available.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by sizzle on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:55PM (#17937183)
Conversely? Did I misinterpret your comment?

Rent has significantly increased in the Portland metro area and gentrification is in full effect. There are vacant luxury multi-tenant properties littering the city and many more in the planning stages. As more tech companies enter the Portland market, expect this trend to accelerate.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by evanlivingston on Saturday September 08, 2018 @12:48AM (#17939455)
Right, I'm agreeing with you. Portland has increased housing substantially without preserving affordability.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by true_tuna on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:54PM (#17937954)
Portland in no way kept up with adding new housing at the same rate it added jobs.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by ajross on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:40AM (#17935144)
Honest question: where would you prefer to put those thousands of individuals making $150-250k? I mean, they have to work somewhere, right? And they want to live in big, vibrant metropolitain areas for the same reason that YOU want to live in those areas (which is why you're upset about the rent in the first place).

Is there really a solution in your head where high-paid geeks are going to move to Boise or Zagreb or Perth[1] and be happy there vs. SF or Berlin or Sydney?

[1] Pause while residents of those places tell me how great they are.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by azinman2 on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:04PM (#17935377)
Sometimes there aren’t good answers. Prosperity for some displaces.

You can’t be surprised that those who aren’t rich, and we’re already here, are angry at the situation.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by ajross on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:18PM (#17935489)
There are good answers. But they're ones of housing policy and urban planning, not "#FuckOffGoogle", which serves literally no one.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:44PM (#17935698)
Telling angry people that they're irrational and not entitled to their anger is not a good answer, either.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by jschwartzi on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:38PM (#17936133)
That's not really what he's saying. What he's saying is that just being angry and flailing around about it solves nothing. What will actually solve this crisis is if Google starts listening to the residents of the neighborhood, and if the residents of the neighborhood can take what Google's representatives are saying in good faith, and finally they can both find a way to live in harmony.

Google not providing any information or responding to anyones' criticisms helps about as much as #FuckOffGoogle does.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by saalweachter on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:29PM (#17936987)
This is an incredibly condescending thing to say, and probably not helpful, but I'm going to say it anyway.

When my two year old gets angry and starts a screaming fit, I tell her she's not getting her way and screaming won't help, and practice taking deep breaths with her, and talking soothingly with her until she can calm down.

Being angry doesn't make a person right. A person being angry does not mean you should give into their demands. A mob of angry people is not more right for being large, scary and potentially violent.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:37PM (#17937042)
See, you misunderstand my point. When faced by an angry mob, you don't simply tell them they're wrong. That's not a smart tactic when people are emotional. Just stating facts won't cool anyone's passions or grievances.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by jupp0r on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:13PM (#17935939)
It's not like Google can influence Berlin zoning laws to build more apartments ...
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:08PM (#17936393)
Google could for example work with the locals to actually provide good for the quarter. The google campus replaces a space that was used for venues at least some of the time. For example it hosted a Christmas market every year for a weekend. Not much, but a bit of community involvement. Google could have worked towards making things possible, but google has, from what I heard even managed to anger other tenants in the building by steamrolling their wishes (such as attempting to cut fire escape routes for others offices that went through their space) and has generally been pretty tone-deaf in communication even within the building. It’s certainly not a guarantee that things would have gone smoothly, but it would have taken some edge off. I know for certain that quite a few people in the building (which is full of startups and IT-focused companies) sympathize with the protests.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by titzer on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:06PM (#17935878)
> Honest question: where would you prefer to put those thousands of individuals making $150-250k?

Well, tech companies, if anybody, should have figured out telecommuting, but they don't because of policies directly from the top. But failing that, tech giants are giant because they want to be giant and have a tendency to want to gobble up smaller companies. A less sharp growth rate and a more "small business-oriented" marketplace would soften the drastic swings brought by the giants throwing their weight around. But this is not what the market rewards, so you get consolidation, massive imbalances, and unsustainable growth.

Housing is on the forefront, but society has a secret grudge against the tech boom, for good reason, and it's starting to show. I expect this is just the first of several waves of backlash.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by ajross on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:47PM (#17936214)
> A less sharp growth rate

On the macro scale we're talking about, that means you want everyone to be poorer. You get that, right?

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by titzer on Saturday September 08, 2018 @03:59AM (#17939988)
You're assuming a whole host of things:

1. High growth creates durable wealth

2. Growth does not create waste

3. Trickle down economics

4. High growth doesn't create bust cycles

5. High growth doesn't ruin the environment

I mean, I could go on--it is a complex topic, after all--but your comment wanted to reduce it down to some kind of richer/poorer dichotomy, which is obviously false. And it was snarky, which is annoying.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:03PM (#17935363)
Many Californians have been moving to Boise.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:22PM (#17935517)
This is like those "heatmaps" that are really just population density maps. California is the most populous state, on average there's going to be more people moving from there to elsewhere than other states.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by mc32 on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:43AM (#17935163)
What are they supposed to do?

1. Not create good jobs

2. Collude to pay lower wages to ensure they align with regional prevailing wages.

3. Build out their own employee-only housing complexes?

4. Do the govts job and plan and build housing and set building and planning policies which align with the economics?

I understand people want their cake and eat it, but they have to be reasonable. Tax appropriately, govern apptopriately.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:58AM (#17935320)
They could try working with local governments to get more housing built. They already are involved in politics on matters like net neutrality and immigration. They can clearly pay for more lobbyists and lawyers.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by mc32 on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:05PM (#17935381)
I’m not sure about the sitch in Berlin, but here in the SF Bsy Area they do try to push for policies and development, they are seldom successful. They get lots of pushback.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:13PM (#17935435)
I'm wondering how hard they try relative to their other lobbying efforts. You don't see major news stories about tech execs appealing for more housing for their workers. Usually it's about building a new HQ, such as Jobs in Cupertino or Dorsey for the Market St. office.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by summerlight on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:28PM (#17935568)
Google have tried almost 10 years to provide housing for their workers in Mountain View. AFAIK, the city has consistently rejected its plan until a new pro-development mayor gets elected, presumably due to the current significant presence of Googlers. Now they have an approval for 9,100 units of housing in North Bayshore, but I guess it will take another 10 years for the actual planning and development.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by erentz on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:01PM (#17935840)
Berlin was having this problem before Google’s campus showed up.

The fact is the war ended. Berlin became the capital of a very large and wealthy country. If Berliners wanted to avoid displacing people they needed to start building lots of houses. And they needed to start a while ago because building houses takes time. But they NIMBY’d against the perceived “gentrification” of new houses so now they’re behind.

Avoiding the problem for longer by blaming tech companies isn’t going to somehow put the genie back in the bottle. Accept Berlin has changed and build houses.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by guiomie on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:34AM (#17935077)
Genuinely asking, what can big companies do? Lobby for laws to not pay people 150-250k?
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:49PM (#17935747)
Two cyberpunk ideas:

1. Build new communities entirely (see Night City)

2. No politically viable solutions to income inequality? Do it yourself! Implement your own local basic income program for non-employee residents. Would at least help with PR. Gives a new spin on the phrase corporate welfare.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by matchbok on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:01PM (#17935348)
Companies have no legal or moral obligation to fix the housing crisis.

Gentrification is, as a whole, a good thing. Nobody has a right to live in a specific neighborhood cheaply. Such social planning/engineering is destined to have countless side effects.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by deminature on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:51AM (#17935242)
Where are large tech companies supposed to put their offices? If they're in areas where the workers want to live and can reasonably commute to, they're accused of gentrification. If they're in areas where they're not upsetting the existing housing situation, they can't attract any talent to fill positions. These companies can't win.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:29PM (#17935577)
Embrace remote work and try harder to attract talent in secondary cities. They've got the money and the influence to make that happen, see Amazon's HQ2 bid.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by geezerjay on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:35AM (#17935088)
> I don't think you quite grasp the effects of a massive influx of hundreds to thousands of new individuals making $150k-250k.

It also drives up demand for new housing and thus urban renewal projects become viable, which contribute to create higher-quality housing suitable to modern needs, not to mention contributions to ancillary services like public transportation.

> It increases rent across the board, which impacts all the people in an area.

No it doesn't. It impacts those who don't live there but want to, and due to increased demand need to compete with more people for that privilege.

> Sure, it might create a few new jobs for baristas and shopkeepers, a few bartenders and waitresses.

Ah yes, because those who didn't had opportunities to enroll in an engineering degree deserve to have their occupations ridiculed, and shouldn't even have the right to a respectable job.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by sdenton4 on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:01PM (#17935350)
One of my favorite spots in Berlin is the Monsterkabinett. It's an underground dungeon full of giant animatronic creatures who dance and sing along with the industrial style music of their creators.

It's also a fantastic example of what's possible when you don't have to worry about rent. The space is part of an old squat, still filled with artists who now get a steady flow of tourists to sell to. And some of the artists, who don't have to worry so much about day jobs, had time to take a side project building these creatures along with software to drive them.

Berlin, and kreuzberg in particular, is full of artists and rebels who moved into a war zone because they had no where to go, found a blank canvas, and made something awesome of it. Bowie did some of his best work in that environment, and it's also given us great punk music, and was an incubator for techno and edm.

You can call it NIMBYism, but for Kreuzberg it's really more about fighting gentrification and displacement, and preserving a city at the edge of society. There's a fundamental difference between fighting development in the mission and presidio...

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:23PM (#17935532)
> You can call it NIMBYism, but for Kreuzberg it's really more about fighting gentrification and displacement, and preserving a city at the edge of society. There's a fundamental difference between fighting development in the mission and presidio...

SF tried "fighting" gentrification by blocking development, and it just made the problem twice as bad. Look at the results: do they look good to you? Why would you want to copy such an abysmal failure?

NIMBYs are the cause of much displacement, especially of the poor. In some cases this is because of ignorance, in other cases it's greed. Either way, it's not acceptable.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by sdenton4 on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:32PM (#17935606)
"We must burn the village to save it." New housing tends to be higher rent; if you want to increase affordable housing stock, mowing down older, lower-rent buildings isn't the way to do it. (Especially in Berlin, where housing is often already far higher density than you see anywhere in the bay area.)
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:40PM (#17935672)
> New housing tends to be higher rent

Yes, much like new cars tend to be more expensive than old cars. Is this...surprising to anyone? That used things are generally cheaper than new things?

> if you want to increase affordable housing stock, mowing down older, lower-rent buildings isn't the way to do it.

It actually can be, at least if you're increasing the total housing stock: http://cityobservatory.org/urban-myth-busting-high-income2/

Granted, for Berlin perhaps not always the case, and I think policies to that effect, that push for redevelopment to mean more total housing, would be a good idea.

And again, please don't ignore SF as a cautionary tale. SF tried the whole "let's not knock down buildings" thing, as hard as they could, in the face of overwhelming demand. Now: did it work?

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by dexen on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:08PM (#17935398)
There is no difference in kind between two hungry IT students developing better web search, and several hungry artists developing awesome dungeon of animatronics. Either start off poor, but once they get major traction, the money starts rolling in. Of course, the web search scales faster, but that's about it.

Point being, the artists' den would become expensive bohemian district of the city anyway, startups or not, as "new money" people learn of it and start moving in to bask in the splendor of the underground culture. Eventually pricing out the actual artists.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by 738472527784 on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:39PM (#17935656)
Are you saying any economically successful person is an artist, contributes to society and culture as art does?

Are you saying, some billions heavy foreign company should have the same "right" to influence a region as a local art collective has?

Because they are basically the same?

Are you serious?

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:36AM (#17934551)
There's no space in that area to build more housing. Pretty much all the space is being used to build offices for tech companies.

There's also the question of how people that do not work for one of those high paying tech companies are supposed to pay for their housing.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Killes on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:48AM (#17934642)
Always in Berlin the knee jerk response to what is going on "We have to keep the rents down!" in response to housing crisis....never "We have to raise pays!" Pay situation for many jobs in Berlin and to some extent most of Germany is just abysmal, even in tech in many cases.

If people here put half the energy in fighting for fairer remuneration for their work rather than whining about the raising rent and property prices that come with being a desirable city and country...

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:52AM (#17934685)
Hey, I'm all for "raise the pay for everyone". I just don't see that happening and I do see the issues arising from "raise the rents and keep the pay low" all around me. I'm even a part of the issue, since I'm on the "hey, I can afford the rent for that nice, freshly renovated flat." side of the equation. Good friends are on the other side. I could go and close my eyes and willfully ignore that, but I'm afraid that won't make the issue go away.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by close04 on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17934929)
Sure, raise the rent -> raise the pay. What happens to the people who don't work in the dynamic IT sector? Everybody gets a raise? Doesn't this just bring everybody to the starting block only with a little more inflation? Otherwise you create an imbalance where you have affluent neighborhoods and slums, something that you definitely want to avoid.

The solution is to build more housing to alleviate the pressure. This way you can keep the rents low without pumping up just a few salaries.

And in a city like Berlin the situation is vastly different from SF. Public transport and biking work like a charm so housing doesn't have to be smack next to the headquarters.

Companies want to reap the benefits of coming to a city with a qualified workforce but the disbenefits get to be "enjoyed" by everyone else around there. Tragedy of the commons. They should be supporting the housing market if they want a good reception.

Full disclosure: I'm saying this as one of the people who enjoys such benefits while some people around me bite the bullet.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by rlanday on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:33AM (#17935065)
You can't fit more people into the same amount of housing by raising everyone's pay. Either someone needs to start living with more roommates, or someone needs to get priced out and decide to leave.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:40PM (#17935668)
If pay was more equal, at least opportunities to stay in your local area would be more equal. I don’t think it’s the price as an absolute that makes people angry, it’s the feeling of being unable to compete for a beloved space.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:52PM (#17935773)
Things might be slightly better then, but if there's still X number of housing units, you're still only going to have Y number of people living there.

Giving people a more even chance at winning musical chairs is nice, but how about just making more chairs?

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:59PM (#17936318)
This is partially at least an emotional problem which you cannot only tackle with logic. The other problem that you’ll currently see is that even if you can convince people that tearing down their house and building a new one in the same spot, they’ll often still want to be able to afford one of the new flats - and that’s currently not a given. So people understandably prefer to stick what they have.

So a fundamental ability to compete is IMHO a basic requirement for building more chairs.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by mazesc on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:20AM (#17934938)
Sorry, but this argument is terrible. Look at the bay area and see how all the wages have risen. Nobody has to be homeless there because they can't afford housing anymore right?
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:36AM (#17935099)
> Always in Berlin the knee jerk response to what is going on "We have to keep the rents down!" in response to housing crisis....never "We have to raise pays!"

If salaries go up without housing being addressed directly, you get what's happened in SF: everyone middle-class and down being pushed out by high rent prices, because they're all competing for the same limited amount of space.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by ebikelaw on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:59AM (#17934737)
Part of the German economic success story has been keeping housing cheap, so they can keep pay down, so they can export. As soon as housing prices rise, pay rises, and the story falls apart.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by usrusr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:37AM (#17935115)
...and the secret sauce of keeping rents down have been conscious efforts at keeping second and third tier cities and towns attractive for business, which distributed demand and thus kept it somewhat in check in the naturally attractive metropolitan areas. E.g. most of those small, highly specialized industry (car and other) suppliers that are the backbone of the German industry are based in cities you never heard of, that's not a coincidence but the result of careful balancing.

In recent years (decades, actually), we seem to have dropped the ball in the counter-centralisation game, maybe as a consequence of reunification.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by chimeracoder on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:21AM (#17934940)
> Part of the German economic success story has been keeping housing cheap, so they can keep pay down, so they can export. As soon as housing prices rise, pay rises, and the story falls apart.

The only reason they're able to do this is because of years of fairly extreme mercantilistic policies combined with struggling economies in other parts of the EU (Greece, Spain, Italy, Portugal, and to an extent Ireland).

It works out for Germany in the short- and medium-run, but it's bad for the EU as a whole.

It's also bad for Germany in the long run, because even if extreme mercantilism were sustainable in a free market in the long run (spoiler: it's not), excess surplus means, by definition, that the government is underinvesting in public infrastructure. It takes a while for the effects of that to become evident, but Germany is starting to see hints of it already, and if these policies continue, it'll become much more pronounced.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Killes on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:23AM (#17934962)
Not so sure about that. Germany doesn't compete on firesale prices for its export products. Germany is amongst the top 5 richest countries whatever that means.

I simply see many good and skilled workers paid way too little. How am I earning as much as a med tech with 12 years experience after being in IT proper for 2 years ? The answer lays, admitted within my limited view, in the skilled labor force simply accepting middling pays. Which is maybe harder to pull off in the IT branch it attracting more workers not ready to simply accept lower pays for their work.

In the end I have colleagues with way more experience than me earning less than me simply because they asked for less...Somehow its more a kind of established cultural thing and companies / management taking good advantage of it. Lets not pretend C levels are badly paid in Germany XD.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by deanCommie on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:53AM (#17934696)
B.S. You just need to re-zone massive sprawling single-family zones into mid-rises.

The "american dream" of a massive house for every couple can't survive the 21st century without triggering a revolution.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:56AM (#17934716)
Have you been in the area? There's no single family housing there at all for quite some distance (I'd say a few kilometers in each direction at least). It's mostly densely built-up with 3-5 story apartment buildings.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by driverdan on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:10AM (#17934846)
3-5 story isn't very tall. Tear them down and go taller.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by titzer on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:28AM (#17935015)
This "tear it all down and just go higher" attitude pisses people off to an extent that is difficult to convey. People are sick of being mugged by economics and having their homes, neighborhoods, villages, streets ravaged by "more at all costs." People are sick of being priced out to the suburbs, displaced by rich corporations and all these rich young people.

Come to a European city and walk through streets with hundreds of years of history for some perspective. Then you can advocate to tear it all down and build it all up for some passing tech bubble fad straight to their faces and see what kind of response you get.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by visarga on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:02PM (#17936349)
> People are sick of being priced out to the suburbs, displaced by rich corporations and all these rich young people.

"these rich young people" are people, too

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by ant6n on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:21AM (#17934947)
Firstly, the higher you build, the more space you need between buildings, and the more space inside the buildings is used for infastructure. There are diminishing returns, and it runs out that areas with good coverage of 5 story buildings can have very high density, often more than areas with high rises.

Plus, Berlin likes to protect their heritage; often tearing down and rebuilding whole neighborhoods turned out to be a very bad idea.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:28AM (#17935007)
> Plus, Berlin likes to protect their heritage; often tearing down and rebuilding whole neighborhoods turned out to be a very bad idea.

As I mentioned further downthread: This is especially pronounced in Kreuzberg, the whole district was supposed to be torn down and turned into a planned utopian living quarter. The Kottbuser Tor was supposed to be turned into a highway crossroad and the buildings there stem from those plans.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by pixl97 on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:53AM (#17935271)
>often tearing down and rebuilding whole neighborhoods turned out to be a very bad idea.

Reminds me of this

http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/03/16/book-review-seeing-like...

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by usrusr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:54AM (#17935282)
After the big pan-european city teardown of the mid-twentieth century that was mostly invented in Berlin, people have grown kind of fond of the surviving buildings. If anything gets torn down in Berlin to build new highrises it will be existing, unfashionable highrise. Plenty of those available for teardown, just not at popular locations. Not popular precisely because they are not surviving pre-war stock.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by bogomipz on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:37PM (#17937044)
Please walk us through how "Tear them down and go taller" works in practical terms? Do you just throw those occupants out on the street? Families, the elderly etc?

If not where and how do you relocate them? Where does that money come from? How about the apartments that are privately owned? How does that work?

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by cameldrv on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:09PM (#17936868)
I used to live a couple of blocks away from the Umspannwerk. The area is almost entirely built up with 5-6 story buildings. Due to the latitude of Berlin, building higher would mean lower floors don't get any natural light in the winter. This is not something that people in California see as a concern, but it's extremely important for people's mental health that live in northern latitudes. In the eastern parts of Berlin that have high rise housing from the DDR time, the buildings are spread out so that the buildings don't make shadows on each other that last all day. Then you end up with these islands of people separated by big open areas. The density isn't much higher overall, and you don't get the cozy feeling of Kreuzberg where it's continuously built up, and there is street level retail on the ground floors.

As it is, Kreuzberg, the district we're talking about, the population density is 15,000/sq km, about half the density of Manhattan, and about twice the density of San Francisco as a whole.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by gradys on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:08AM (#17934823)
I think one of you is talking about San Francisco and the other Berlin.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:11AM (#17934853)
I'm talking about Berlin since the whole thing is happening in Berlin. How things are in SF is of no relevance.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17934921)
Did you not read my comment?
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by expathacker on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:16AM (#17934891)
Fully agreed. I spent most of my life in San Francisco, and the past 5 years living abroad has been eye-opening. Many people move to SF from the 'burbs / New York / Dallas and think that the answer to the housing problem is Manhattanization. The reason they think this, is that they have never been to a well-designed city like Barcelona. 3-5 story units, at max, cover most of San Francisco. It could be just as lovely as a city with 6-10 story buildings, and without being as ugly or unlivable as New York. We would just have to have sane zoning that didn't hamper new housing with antiquated parking requirements.

SF is home and I love it, but not all of it is as worth protecting as my nimby friends think. The Richmond, the sunset, ingleside, bayview / hunter's point, South SF .. Most of that wastes space, and could easily be rebuilt to be as dense and beautiful as Paris or Barcelona, but it would require courage and a more social government than what we actually have.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by bogomipz on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:29AM (#17935029)
It sounds like you have never even been to Kreuzberg then.

There are no "massively sprawling single-family zones" in the area.

Maybe you could do just a modicum of research before you call "B.S." on people.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by deanCommie on Thursday September 13, 2018 @04:17PM (#17982137)
I was talking about San Francisco, but it got lost
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by usrusr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:10AM (#17934849)
Lack of highrise developments is what makes those areas attractive in the first place. Berlin has plenty highrise residential, yet Google and the like are decidedly avoiding those areas. Converting more of the cityscape into the kind of area where neither Google nor the protestors would want to be would make the situation worse, not better.

Also, it's quite possible that you widely underestimate the existing density, this is no single family sprawl we are talking about.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17934923)
One of the problems in Berlin is that dense residential areas cluster at the edges of the town and office space tends to cluster at the center. So now, if you want to have an office in Berlin and are a company that has more than a handful of employees, people will come from all sides of town, so you'd preferably want office space in the center - which gradually eats up all space that could have been used for housing in the center. Old buildings that could have been refurbished into flats are turned into offices since that's currently more profitable. There's little really high-density living space in central Berlin.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by usrusr on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:02PM (#17935361)
Berlin has a center? Last time I checked (Sunday), it was still more like an eye of the storm kind of void. But that's perfectly consistent with your finer point, if you could somehow restrict your employees to roughly one quadrant, many things would be much easier. That will never happen of course.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Xylakant on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:11PM (#17935422)
Well, Berlin has a geographic center. It doesn’t have a center in any kind of sense that the social life happens around there, you’re right in hat regard. There’s also the mystic “Innerhalb des S-Bahn-Rings”.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by checkyoursudo on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:36AM (#17935093)
> Lack of highrise developments is what makes those areas attractive in the first place.

Why? Aesthetics? Google-type people don't want to live in high-rises?

I don't think I've ever heard anyone say they aren't willing even to live near high-rises. That's a new one to me.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by brewdad on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:01PM (#17935843)
In the neighborhoods of Portland, residents are absolutely flipping out over mid-rise developments.

In many areas, single family homes on corner lots are being torn down and replaced by 3-4 story apartment buildings. Neighborhood associations are very much up in arms against these developments that alter the "character of the neighborhood". Often these new buildings are shorter than the trees around them, but still they are considered "out of place".

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by checkyoursudo on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:55PM (#17936278)
And I would assume those people wouldn't want a multistory office building being built in their neighborhoods as well?

What I don't understand is, as the parent comment seems to suggest, that a company like Google wouldn't locate near a locale with existing high-rises? I realize I may be misunderstanding.

I fully understand that there are plenty of people who don't want development in their neighborhoods. I've just never heard the idea that some critical mass of employees would not want to live in or even work near already existing high rises such that a company would deem locating in such a place to be unacceptable.

Does that make sense? Like, would a lot of potential Google engineers not take high-pay, high-prestige jobs at a Google site that is located in the middle of a bunch of high-rise apartments in a boring city? Or are all Google engineers just really super cool and fun and adventurous while also only tolerating low-slung buildings? I'm really curious--not at all being sarcastic.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#17935624)
If people want it to be illegal for Google and similar companies to move in there or redevelop it, that's possible. I'm not sure that's such a good idea, but it can be done. Getting mad at Google for doing something that's a good idea for their business, is entirely within the law, and is generally ethical behavior (unless you think opening new offices or redeveloping urban areas is generally unethical somehow) is silly.

Like, the government has the power to change how something is zoned, do they not? And the government is elected by the people. And it's not like anyone thinks that no new buildings should ever go up in cities, so the clear solution here is for people to vote/apply political pressure to protect this particular area. That's the government's job.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by 21stio on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:47AM (#17934633)
Unfortunately, it's more profitable to speculate on the rising property prices than selling them to home builders...
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by carapace on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:31PM (#17935593)
No, the data do not back that up: https://www.theurbanist.org/2016/05/27/rents-in-san-francisc...

In order for new construction to materially affect rent rate we would have to build more housing faster than it has ever been done before, for decades to come.

Leaving aside the question of whether it is desirable to convert SF into another Manhattan, we could actually do it: there are modern methods to build entire new apartment buildings in forty days, etc. We could, in theory, convert the Richmond and Sunset districts from mostly single-family homes to three- and four-story apartment buildings, and do it quickly enough that rates rise slowly. Not fall, or stay static, just not rise as quickly as they are now.

But still, how do the people not earning $100,000 or more afford to live there?

Just building the buildings would require a sizable portion of the entire California construction industry. Where does that army live?

How do all these people get into and out of the SF peninsula? You're talking about eventually two or three million people just in SF, South SF, and Daly City.

How long before those teeming millions forget how much we value nature and start eyeing the Marin Headlands, or all that beautiful land south of Pacifica? San Francisco is the largest city with the most wild land around it in the world.

Anyhow my point is, enough with the "Damn NIMBYs!" rhetoric already. This is a big ol problem that will take decades to sort out and the ocean will rise before that can happen, so please stop insulting your neighbors for liking their neighborhood, eh? One way or another it's not going to last, so why not let them enjoy it. You work in tech, right? You can afford to move up/inland early, beat the rush, no? You've got just enough time to stay and let your kids deal with it for you. Forgive me if that sounds harsh, I'm keeping it real: We have bigger problems than folks not liking new housing. San Francisco is at sea level.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by throwaway34241 on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:54PM (#17937179)
How do people not earning $100,000 afford to live there? They commute 2 hours each way (for real).

I think it's unreasonable to expect a live-and-let live attitude to NIMBYs on online forums, while NIMBYs are pricing out the people who work in their neighborhoods through housing policy.

Sure there are other issues like global warming but it's not like having a place to live is a trivial issue. It's more than reasonable for people to care or be upset about it.

I'm talking mostly about the Bay Area here which I'm most familiar with, where a rule allowing you to build if you follow every law to the letter was shot down (building anything is a guaranteed long political fight), and minor things like having one apartment level above a shop are fought tooth and nail.

I actually can somewhat respect the position, that young people should just move away and other places in the country need to deal with growth. But I think to do that properly, you should still zone for a proportionate amount of housing as you do office space (jobs). And if you don't want growth, do little of either.

But approving lots of jobs, not zoning/approving the necessary housing, and then making excuses/blaming others as there's a shortage and prices/commutes go up - it's hard to see it as anything other than a massive political failure. Maybe calling this policy combination NIMBY is painting NIMBYs with a broad brush. But whatever you call it I think it's reasonable to be upset by it.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by carapace on Saturday September 08, 2018 @12:45AM (#17939446)
> They commute 2 hours each way (for real).

But that's garbage. Have you tried it? It sucks.

> NIMBYs are pricing out the people who work in their neighborhoods through housing policy.

Well no, you're wrong and that's my point. Wages drive rent rate increases according to the data going back 70 years.

If all the people you call pejorative names suddenly saw things your way and we all changed the zoning and laws and such overnight AND all the construction companies in the entire state came to the Bay Area and built nothing but apartment buildings all day every day for the next fifty years then MAYBE rents would level off, or at least rise more slowly.

Please stop calling your neighbors names for liking their neighborhood. It's not nice and it doesn't win arguments. And you're wrong anyway.

We could build at the fastest conceivable rate and it would not solve the problem.

> But approving lots of jobs, not zoning/approving the necessary housing, and then making excuses/blaming others as there's a shortage and prices/commutes go up

Whoa dude. Who is this super-human political dynamo who has done all of this?

> a massive political failure

Yes. And calling people names won't help. Not even a little bit.

> painting NIMBYs with a broad brush

More like painting with a hose.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by throwaway34241 on Saturday September 08, 2018 @04:01PM (#17942467)
I'm not calling you names or even talking about your political views (since I don't know them). I'm talking about the actual housing policies of many cities in the bay area, which are extremely against adding new housing, most commonly characterized as NIMBY. It looks like you view this term to be offensive, I didn't realize.

My key point was about the ratio of jobs to housing. It may not be desirable or realistic to expand the overall population of the area past a certain amount. But I think it is realistic to zone/approve enough housing, to match the amount of jobs that are zoned/approved (through office space). Overall, the bay area has been adding much more jobs than housing, and I think this is a major factor in the housing problem aside from wages. And the result of this is that more and more of people's paycheck goes to housing, they have to commute long distances, etc.

Rather than opposing housing when there is a shortage, I'd rather see more effort put into opposing new office space instead, and when housing has caught up cities could facilitate a public dialogue about what residents want with regards to growth etc.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by carapace on Saturday September 08, 2018 @05:00PM (#17942759)
Parent comment I was originally responding to opens with:

> This is more the fault of NIMBYs and supply&demand-denialists...

The term "NIMBY" is used IMO to caricature and demonize people who have done nothing worse than own their own homes and desire some control over their neighborhoods, towns, and cities. Land use is hard enough to figure out without painting our neighbors with a pejorative brush.

> the actual housing policies of many cities in the bay area, which are extremely against adding new housing

I agree.

> most commonly characterized as NIMBY

That's the idea I am decrying. Please don't do that.

> It looks like you view this term to be offensive, I didn't realize.

I do. Worse, it's actively working against mutual comprehension and effective political solutions. We have the technology: "Four-story Berkeley building built in four days" https://sf.curbed.com/2018/8/6/17656118/fast-apartment-resid...

The solution we need is political and getting mass cohesion at the level required takes positive uplifting values, not name calling and caricatures.

> My key point was about the ratio of jobs to housing. It may not be desirable or realistic to expand the overall population of the area past a certain amount. But I think it is realistic to zone/approve enough housing, to match the amount of jobs that are zoned/approved (through office space). Overall, the bay area has been adding much more jobs than housing, and I think this is a major factor in the housing problem aside from wages. And the result of this is that more and more of people's paycheck goes to housing, they have to commute long distances, etc.

Yes, absolutely! It's been easier and more profitable for developers to build skyscrapers and office buildings for decades, so that's what we've got.

I'm not denying that there are folks who don't look much farther than their own backyards when it comes to their votes on land use issues. I'm saying that, in order to make any real progress, we have to understand each other and work together.

> Rather than opposing housing when there is a shortage, I'd rather see more effort put into opposing new office space instead, and when housing has caught up cities could facilitate a public dialogue about what residents want with regards to growth etc.

Legend has it that SimCity was developed to explore the ideas of Christopher Alexander's Pattern Language. I think we should play a giant, realistic simulation of the city, region, state, biome, nation, continent, globe, all together in a MMORPG.

By the time we have hammered out what we want the future to look like the robots will be able to build it for us in a twinkling. I estimate ~30 +/- 15 years if the weather remains (relatively) stable.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Saturday September 08, 2018 @05:46AM (#17940242)
On the other hand: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-09-07/rental-gl...

> Tenants are gaining the upper hand in urban centers across the U.S. as new amenity-rich apartment buildings, constructed in response to big rent gains in previous years, are forced to fight for customers. Rents are softening most on the high end and within city limits, Terrazas said. Landlords also have been losing customers to homeownership as millennials strike out on their own, often moving to more affordable suburbs.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by carapace on Saturday September 08, 2018 @05:26PM (#17942862)
From my POV that's due more to a glut of cheap-inside luxury-outside condos and apartment buildings. I mean the word "glut" is in the title. A couple of years ago I was considering buying a condo in the Bay Area. I was surprised to find that, although there are tons of places if you can afford them, you have to look very carefully to find a well-built, well-managed building. The real estate market in the Bay Area has been so hot that it has attracted a lot of questionable development and investment.

A very typical pattern was a new, physically beautiful building with shoddy design and construction, so that it looks like luxury housing but the walls are thin and you can hear your neighbors, for example. Often the front office is staffed with perky young ladies who have no authority or ability to do anything other than sign up new tenants. They are not the building managers, other than in name, they're salespeople. Any problems you might have require you to call a call center on the East Coast. One place I looked at was owned by a huge corporation that had ~$2B debt and a bunch of weird holdings. Basically someone's pet company had bought the building as an investment, with all the problems for the tenants that you might imagine that entails: regular and steep rent increases, minimal staff and maintenance, cost-cutting everywhere.

So yeah, I am not surprised that the bottom feeders (of the high-end) are scrambling for marks and suckers. The quality buildings are easy to spot, I eventually figured it out. Can you guess the marker? [1]

But they still aren't renting to the folks who make ~$100,000 or less, eh? This article describes a correction, but the overall trend is still up, no? Or maybe this is some kind of inflection point in the 70 year trend, and the burst of construction combined with people moving out of hot city centers has fixed the problem?

In the meantime, it's easy to find a place in SF if you can afford $4000 a month, but almost impossible if you can only afford half of that. Calling that "the upper hand" is a bit rich.

[1] They have long waiting lists.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by Apocryphon on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:57PM (#17935804)
Not to mention, earthquakes. All that tech in SF in Seattle, located at tectonic hotspots.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by arez on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:30AM (#17935039)
sure we want good jobs with high salaries, but these jobs are just for a minority and they will pump up the prices in the whole area. There're lots of unemployed and people with low paying jobs in berlin, some artists, students etc. they make the city vibrant, fun, adventurous, but they can't stay if you have to pay 1200€ a month for a decent flat.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:41AM (#17935151)
> sure we want good jobs with high salaries, but these jobs are just for a minority and they will pump up the prices in the whole area.

Higher-paying-than-average jobs are for a minority pretty much by definition. Do you just want to outlaw paying people different amounts of money?

> There're lots of unemployed and people with low paying jobs in berlin, some artists, students etc. they make the city vibrant, fun, adventurous, but they can't stay if you have to pay 1200€ a month for a decent flat.

Agreed, which is why pro-housing policies are necessary. Make it easy for the market to build reasonably-priced housing, and have the government build housing itself.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by visarga on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:06PM (#17936381)
> they make the city vibrant, fun, adventurous, but they can't stay if you have to pay 1200€ a month for a decent flat.

But they can also leave and make another city vibrant, fun and adventurous.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by bildung on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:16AM (#17934894)
> If the people need more housing, the solution is, shockingly enough, to build more housing.

I know this is a popular opinion, but is there empirical evidence for this? Isn't this solution based on the assumption that there was a one-time surge of people, leading to a one-time rise in demand for housing?

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by geezerjay on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:21AM (#17934944)
Even if if there was a surge in demand, that doesn't mean that increasing available housing does not contribute to deflate housing prices. It makes no sense to pretend that supply has no impact on housing availability, and that the only factor worth vilifying is a secondary factor affecting demand.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:46AM (#17935190)
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by bildung on Saturday September 08, 2018 @10:57AM (#17941071)
Thanks for the link. That article only links to a single correlation study, and that study only shows what we know: if high income earners rent much of the given supply, rents for low income families increases, too. That doesn't help with the question of more housing lowering rent prices. My point was: If more housing gets built, what does high income earners prevent from moving to town and renting that, too?

The article makes a fundamental error with that car market analogy, BTW. Cars are consumables that get bought to be driven by the buyer. Houses in cities are investments that are built to be rented out. Completely different market dynamics. That the author makes a grave error like this while blogging about urban planning is a bit scary.

What I meant are real longitudinal studies that track rent price development and increasing supply over time, preferably in Europe, where the rent market works quite a bit differently than in the US. The vast majority of housing in Berlin is for rent.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by DoofusOfDeath on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:22AM (#17934951)
> This is more the fault of NIMBYs and supply&demand-denialists who work hard to prevent new housing from going up.

I wonder if the supply-and-demand model you're referring to is insufficient in this scenario. It sounds like political factors are at play here as well.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:40AM (#17935139)
I mean, in the case of SF, yes you're right. It's the laws that prevent supply & demand from working normally.

Of course, even with liberalized zoning regulations, housing prices would still be higher than normal in SF. But they wouldn't be horrendously bad like they are now.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by thatfrenchguy on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:45AM (#17934616)
Sure enough adding more housing when there is speculation works as we’ve seen in Vancouver.
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:48AM (#17935213)
According to this, average 1br rent in Vancouver is only $1500/month, which seems pretty reasonable to me for a major city, especially one that's seen as very desirable like Vancouver: https://www.rentjungle.com/average-rent-in-vancouver-bc-rent...

If we could get SF down to 1500/month I'd be ecstatic, that's less than half the current price.

Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by spuz on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:11PM (#17935423)
Is that USD or CAD? Also, according to that site, there has been a 32% drop in prices since last year. I wonder what the reason for that is?
Re:Berlin Google Campus occupied by TulliusCicero on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:26PM (#17935553)
That is strange. I could see that being currency value changes, except the 2br price has been relatively stable.