News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dev_dull on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:39PM (#17689541)
> It’s 85 degrees outside the Terry Thomas building; inside it’s 78 degrees

In other words, no better than working in a shaded outdoor area. That’s too hot to work in my opinion. I think they can do a lot better.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by snegu on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:10AM (#17689613)
I would love this. I have to dress for two different climates on summer workdays - skirt/shorts and short sleeves for outside, jeans and sweater (plus a sweatshirt over it) for inside. It's absurd how overly air-conditioned office environments are.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dnbgfher on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:46AM (#17689716)
Meanwhile you have people like me. I'm are already uncomfortably hot no matter how I'm dressed (or not) at 78. Even in shorts and a tshirt, most offices are warmer than I'd prefer.

This may be my own biases at play here, but it's really not that hard to warm up by dressing warmer. You don't have that option for cooling down unless you want to wear a vest full of icepacks or something. If the goal is to maximize comfort, it seems like the thermostat should be set lower rather than higher.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by slavik81 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:24AM (#17690473)
> it's really not that hard to warm up by dressing warmer

I cannot use my keyboard while wearing winter gloves, so there are limits. Sadly, I have tried.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by upofadown on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:20AM (#17690961)
There are fingerless gloves that can help. Ultimately for warm hands in cold conditions you need to maintain a reasonable core body temperature. Otherwise your extremities will be cold no matter what you do. That is harder to regulate if you are just sitting.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by jwcacces on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:17AM (#17690947)
Don't use winter gloves, get a pair of silk gloves. They're warm and super thin
[dead]
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dang on Monday August 06, 2018 @02:10AM (#17695407)
This is egregious. If you continue to violate the site guidelines like you have been, we are going to ban you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by bumholio on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:48AM (#17690086)
Or we can simply ignore the vocal minority that demands temperatures below 78F/25C, and thus maximize subjective comfort. They are fucked anyway, they need to visit the outside world to get to work.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dang on Monday August 06, 2018 @02:11AM (#17695412)
Please don't post flamewar comments to Hacker News. We're trying for better than that here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by lovich on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:18AM (#17690169)
I don't think 78 is a temperature that only a vocal minority is uncomfortable at? It's not hard for people to start sweating at that temperature with even mild effort and most people don't like having sweat stains or sweaty armpits at work
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by erik_seaberg on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:14AM (#17690308)
Most cars have air conditioning (a lot of trains do too), and most people commute well before and after the hottest part of the day. If your office is a sauna for three months and you won't fix it, everyone who isn't unemployable will probably quit.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by kayoone on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:42AM (#17690835)
funny, here in Germany many offices and most homes don't have AC. Granted it's usually not that hot during the summer, but right now it has been around 85 since April and a lot of people are suffering at work, but nobody would quit because of that.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by felix_nagaand on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:08AM (#17690914)
They would if the only difference with a competitor was the presence of ac. Assuming all other variables are essentially equal.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by lowercased on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:22AM (#17690977)
if no other companies they could go work at have ac either... what would be the point of quitting? people generally don't quit out of protest to just... do nothing, but they'd quit to go work someplace else.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by kayoone on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:30AM (#17691798)
who would seriously just switch jobs because of AC ?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by rovr138 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:56AM (#17691907)
All other conditions equal, I’d say a lot of people.

That’s the same as asking, “Who would seriously just switch jobs because of more money?”

It’s a quality of living thing. If you don’t loose anything but can gain something, why not do it?

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dnbgfher on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:46PM (#17694813)
I'm not sure why you wouldn't. You're spending a significant chunk of your time at the office. If you are uncomfortable all of that time it's a significant issue.

I mean if your job only allowed you to sit on a small unpadded stool, wouldn't that motivate you to find a new job?

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by sneak on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:41PM (#17693420)
It is plenty hot enough in summer in Germany to warrant AC.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by mrep on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:43AM (#17689711)
On the flip side, there is only so much clothes I can take off before it becomes illegal where as it is easy for people to put on more clothes if they are cold. Granted, there are ways I can help cool myself down such as having a fan which I do have at my desk but it would be ridiculous to bring that with me to meetings and stuff.

To flip back around to your point though, I definitely understand it as my girlfriend has raynaud's so I'll be in my apartment with the fan on still hot while my girlfriend will be next to me freezing with her hands turning white because she is cold. We are hoping our future kids will even out our weird temperature imbalances and be normal.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by randomfool on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:31AM (#17689862)
No matter how many layers I bundle my idle torso in that arctic stream of AC just freezes my nose and fingers.

For most office spaces it's not so much the temp that freezes me it's the breeze while I'm sitting in a chair typing.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by mrep on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:53AM (#17689907)
Do you have raynaud's because that sounds exactly like it and my girlfriend says the airflow is definitely a big part of the problem (also stress).

If so, then I would talk to your coworkers to see if you can get switched to a better desk location for your medical condition.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by craftyguy on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:01AM (#17690278)
Not GP, but my desk is under a damn air vent. It is very likely to be 5 degrees (or more) warmer down the aisle from me. I don't have raynaud's, I just hate being blasted with cold air when it's literally not cold outside (which is a serious plus where I am located)
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by bornabox on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:23AM (#17690588)
Have you considered switching your desk with someone who likes it colder? I, for one, would jump at the opportunity. Maybe some of your co-workers would too..
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by felix_nagaand on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:10AM (#17690917)
They could also use an umbrella to deflect the air current
[dead]
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by craftyguy on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:57AM (#17691912)
Not possible, there's a long waiting list to get desks at work.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:51PM (#17694439)
Would medical advice help?

I'm one of those who would kill to be under a vent.

Alternatively, file a grievance through your shop steward.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by mrep on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:04AM (#17689782)
To add on, I also have to do the 2 dress types but for the winter because I get extremely uncomfortable in jeans in the office and so I'll wear those to work once it gets unbearable to wear shorts, and then I just switch to shorts once I get to the office.

So, pick your poison and while it may be just that the grass is always greener on the other side, I would definitely prefer to run on the colder side than the hotter side especially since I prefer to wear jeans and a sweatshirt/jacket over shorts and a t-shirt.

Edit: My girlfriend said she would rather be like me and be too hot than be too cold so maybe it is just the grass is always greener on the other side.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by jon_richards on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:25AM (#17689652)
>skirt

It's because offices are stuck air conditioning to a level that makes suits comfortable. There was a big brouhaha about it in England a couple years ago.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by patriot_prayer on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:38AM (#17689697)
there's no article of clothing one can put on to become cooler, so it makes sense that the prevailing temp would be cooler.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by eigenstuff on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:46AM (#17691573)
If anywhere in the world has figured out how to dress for heat and humidity, it's the Indian subcontinent, and all I'm saying is the sari involves bare midriff for a reason. I live in the southeast and spend a lot of time outside. To cut down on my sunscreen bill, I've started wearing loose, long sleeve white cotton button ups with the last few buttons undone so I can tie the ends up around my waist.

You catch a breeze wearing that, and it's like wearing a weightless AC unit on your back. Hand to God.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by craftyguy on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:02AM (#17690286)
NASA has a wardrobe that contradicts you.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by skriticos2 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:39AM (#17690644)
I think GP meant reasonably acquirable. You can't exactly order a NASA space suit on Amazon, can you?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by lowercased on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:24AM (#17690987)
perhaps not a real one, but... it's amazon:

https://www.amazon.com/Charades-Astronaut-Space-Costume-Jump...

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by felix_nagaand on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:11AM (#17690920)
Is walmart adding that to next year's summer line?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:24AM (#17690004)
Your arms will still sweat to your desk if you don’t have great typing skills regardless of how naked you are. Offices are kept at or below 70F because productivity peaks at that level in ways that clothing can’t help.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by prolikewh0a on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:25PM (#17692363)
I've been in Seattle for almost 3 years now and the temperature the AC gets set at is like 64F. When I lived elsewhere it was always set @ 72F. It's so cold in my office downtown that I have a fall/winter jacket I'm often wearing on the hottest days and dresses/skirts end up causing me to be uncomfortably cold the entire day.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by lowercased on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:20AM (#17690965)
i worked in a call center years ago. the thermostat was in the 'executive office' hallway, where 4 people worked. it controlled the temp for the whole side of our building, affecting 130 people. One of the execs 'liked it cold", and would turn it down. The airflow was a problem - to get it to 73-74 for him, the rest of the larger callcenter room would be closer to 68-69. My shared office space with 5-6 others was off that larger space, but was one of the airducts feeding everything else. I came in one morning, and the digital thermostat on my desk clock said it was 62f at my desk. I couldn't type after an hour. I went and brought in a small space heater, and got a slight reprimand (non-company equipment, etc). It was odd - the rest of the guys in my space said "yeah, it's cold" but claimed to be OK - I couldn't move my fingers to type/mouse without some pain after an hour or so of being in 62f.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by syshum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:33AM (#17691509)
ohh I would be in heaven to have an office at 62f....

BTW 73-74 is not "like it cold" that is standard temp most offices should be at for the balance.

62f is liking it cold, and I like it cold. I have been known to wear short sleeves, and shorts outside in 45-50 degree weather.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by lowercased on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:54PM (#17694233)
I probably should have said "he liked it at 73" - that was his thing. If anyone moved it, there was a lot of hell to pay (or so I'd been told). The preferences of one person (who was not even necessarily in that building a full/regular 40 hours per week) outweighed the comfort of 120 other people who worked early morning to late night.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by briandear on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:51AM (#17689744)
In my office, I have a lot of hardware. With my door shut, it gets to be an oven even with air conditioning, with the door open it’s still hot, even though the hallway temp is 68. I actually like it cold inside. You can always wear more clothes, but there is a limit to how much you can take off. It’s pretty unfair to impose hot temperatures on people since there isn’t much that can be done after you’ve stripped down to the bare essentials of clothing. But colder temperatures — it’s easy to wear a light sweater.

78 in the building along with hot computers means you are quickly going to have a rather uncomfortable situation.

The fact this company has to adjust work hours to accommodate their “progressiveness” means they actually haven’t solved anything. It’s just virtue signaling. They could just as easily have their team work nights to get the same effect — but then they wouldn’t get media attention for just how innovative they are. Windows open in California means you also subject yourself to wildfire particulates, smog and other pollutants that HVAC systems mitigate. “Fresh air” is nice — when it’s actually fresh, and in most cities, it isn’t. Even Paris has had serious air quality situations. City air just isn’t all that clean. In Beijing, “fresh air” is downright toxic. I am not sure how eliminating air conditioning is considered an innovation. Air conditioning was one of the most important inventions, anyone that says otherwise never spent any time in an un-air-conditioned New Orleans house with box fans creating a cross breeze of 100% humidity. The nostalgia for the good old days is felt by those that never had to live through those days.

This story reads to me like nonsense. Seattle, while it can get “hot” is positively frigid when compared to much of the rest of the country. Try that in Atlanta, Houston or Arizona. This story is the equivalent of a Miami building being built without heating — it isn’t any kind of groundbreaking innovation. When a building in Minnesota is built without heat, then I might be interested.

What’s really innovative is how Apple Park handles fresh air and HVAC. Apple Park isn’t 78 degrees inside — it’s much cooler; they went far beyond the “innovation” in this Seattle building. This sort of innovation can be done, but being proud of a 78 degree internal temperature is like being proud when someone’s kid stops wetting the bed at age 12. It’s only a big deal to those who are experiencing it, but to the rest of us, it’s just self-congratulatory bullshit of the most mundane sort: big deal, you designed a building that isn’t quite at hot as the outdoors using groundbreaking technology that is equivalent to an open window.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by txcwpalpha on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:28AM (#17690016)
All of your comparisons to buildings or temperature or air quality in California, Paris, Beijing, etc are irrelevant, because we aren't talking about a building in those places, or even a building with an environment similar to those places. This story is about a building in Seattle.

I don't know why you seem to be so riled up about this building. Why can't you read an article about a building that is achieving sustainability in an interesting way without being triggered by it? Sure, it has it's characteristics that some people might not prefer, but it's nothing to get so upset over.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by greedo on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:55PM (#17692529)
What's sustainable about this building? We don't know the TCO through its lifecycle, nor its energy usage. And all those inefficient desktop fans can't help.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by txcwpalpha on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:46PM (#17693985)
Did you read the article? It says it uses about half of the electricity of a normal office building.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by greedo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:35AM (#17707557)
And it has less usable space for an office building. And is it comparing an office with AC turned to 78 degrees, or a standard office set to 68...
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by hinkley on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:12AM (#17689965)
Get yourself one of those fans that can point straight at the ceiling. Stick it near your door, but out of the way, and you can siphon in a bunch of that cold air from the hallway. Cold air sinks.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by selimthegrim on Sunday August 05, 2018 @09:39AM (#17691256)
Checking in from an un-airconditioned New Orleans house with a window unit or two. Missing the transoms that got taken out in the renovation. Good thing I'm moving out.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by userbinator on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:22AM (#17689644)
Yes, 85 is well beyond "constant sweating even when not moving or doing anything" temperatures for me, and I wouldn't want to be in a room of coworkers doing the same either. 78 would be at the edge of idle sweating.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by electrograv on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:47AM (#17689725)
And for some of us (myself, for example) 68 without a breeze is my threshold of constant idle sweating. I have to set up a tower fan under my monitor at work to be comfortable (this is with office AC set to low 70s, which is way too hot for me), and at home I have AC set to 65-68 pretty much all the time.

People who complain about having to put on a sweater have no idea how miserable it is for those of us who have to sit for 8+ hours in an environment sweating profusely when it gets too hot.

This is why office AC is the way it is. You can put on a sweater. I cannot take off my skin.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by scarejunba on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:30AM (#17690023)
And there's some of us who turn into a pile of red and brown goo at anything over 25 F. I'm much more comfortable in the nude with snow packed onto my torso than I am at this furnace of 68 F.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by Filligree on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:29AM (#17690191)
Ah. Found the Finn.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by stephengillie on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:00AM (#17691638)
Also Seattlites.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by syshum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:01AM (#17689927)
It is even worse when the office is set to 75 because some people continually complain "its too cold" and you have a dress code of Long Pants, Collared Button down shirt, etc....

Like fucking roasting all day...

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by unethical_ban on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:26AM (#17691776)
This is a question out of ignorance, I mean it sincerely: Are you overweight, or a thyroid issue, or something? IANADoctor but to be sweaty at idle at 68F seems very unusual.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by adenadel on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:48PM (#17689564)
To be fair, the average daily high in Seattle during the summer is 75F. You would only have to deal with temperatures like that for 2-3 weeks per year. Seattle is currently having a heat wave, which is the reason for the temperature in the article.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by kranner on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:49PM (#17689566)
That’s 25 degrees Celsius. Hardly too hot. With the right clothing, most people should be able to adjust.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by electrograv on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:42AM (#17689708)
There’s a reason offices are air conditioned the way they are, trust me. While some of you lucky people can tolerate these temperatures comfortably, a significant percentage of the population sweats profusely in anything beyond 70 degrees Fahrenheit (I’m one of them).

Those of us who suffer from this would LOVE to trade places with the people who complain of the terrible effort of “putting on a sweater in the summer time” when it’s a bit too cool inside.

Unfortunately, we do not have the luxury of peeling off our skin when we are sweating uncontrollably in a 78F room, that some say is “not too hot”.

It’s important to recognize that humans are very diverse creatures, and office environments have to deal with the complex task of accommodating a wide range of physiologies.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:09AM (#17689804)
Do you think people were terribly uncomfortable at ambient temperatures due to their physiology before AC was invented?

In natural conditions, I'd expect people who sweat more to actually be more comfortable with natural airflow causing evaporative cooling. Unfortunately, in modern well sealed buildings with little air flow, this adaptation would be counterproductive.

It sounds like this building was an experiment aimed at rediscovering what a natural air flow would feel like in an office environment. I love my AC, personally, but I'd still be curious to see what 78 feels like in that building, it might not be so bad. I do enjoy working outside on the patio when it's warm out with a nice cool breeze.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by electrograv on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:20AM (#17689826)
> Do you think people were terribly uncomfortable at ambient temperatures due to their physiology before AC was invented?

Absolutely, unquestionably, YES! (Certainly for some people). Those sufficiently uncomfortable would migrate to climates better suited to their physiology, if their physiology didn’t adapt to the environment; for example, my ancestors were from extreme cold environments, and I am without a doubt FAR more comfortable in 50 degree F weather in a T shirt than I am in 70 degree weather. And to me with the right clothing, everything down to and even below freezing is quite pleasant.

Prior to much modern technology, just surviving and staying alive as a human was a miserable, painful experience.

We have it so, so good today, compared to our ancestors just a hundred years ago, let alone thousands. Virtually every measure of human suffering (extreme poverty, starvation, sickness, death, etc) is dramatically lowering with each generation.

It is a wonderful thing that modern advancements allows us to be comfortable, which then further frees our minds to pursue even greater and more wonderful endeavors.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by irrational on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:35AM (#17689872)
> Do you think people were terribly uncomfortable at ambient temperatures due to their physiology before AC was invented?

Isn't that like asking "Do you think people were terribly uncomfortable using the outhouse in the middle of winter before indoor plumbing was invented?"

Uh, yeah. Life before AC, indoor plumbing, electricity, refrigeration, etc. sucked hard.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:58AM (#17689920)
I lived in a cabin in Fairbanks, Alaska with no indoor plumbing and an outhouse. My wife is from Siberia and her house didn't have plumbing until the 90's. Going to the outhouse at 50 below in the middle of the night wasn't terribly uncomfortable, because I put on a jacket and gloves. A bit inconvenient, but not terrible.

Neither me or my wife feel like that lifestyle "sucked hard", although it certainly had challenges. Now we have a nice house in an affluent suburb and have plenty of luxuries, yet this lifestyle also has its challenges. Whether or not it sucks seems largely a matter of mindset and perspective.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by toomuchtodo on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:44AM (#17690224)
A car not starting in slightly below freezing weather is a challenge. You’ll be hard pressed to find someone in the developed world who doesn’t think going to an outhouse at 50 below isn’t “sucking hard”. Without speaking for others, there isn’t any scenario I’d consider where running water and flush toilets aren’t available and within where I reside.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:23AM (#17691759)
Having my car not start in Fairbanks was much, much more challenging than the outhouse. It took a lot of vigilance to make sure the battery stayed warm enough to hold a charge. I had to install heaters on my battery, engine, and transmission and remember to plug them in every single time I stopped the engine. If there was not a place to plug in, we left the car idling. If the car died, we were risking injury or even death from frostbite or hypothermia. That was a very serious challenge to have to deal with on a daily basis.

The outhouse, on the other hand, was almost zero maintenance. The only cleaning I had to do was occasional sweeping. It was nicely made from cedar wood with plenty of natural ventilation (no door), it never smelt terrible or felt disgusting. It takes a lot of work and money to make an indoor bathroom stay as nice as my outhouse was naturally.

I agree that you will find very many people in the developed world who think that going to an outhouse at 50 below would probably suck hard, but relatively few of them have first-hand experience so that's a hypothetical situation for them.

In Alaska you can certainly find plenty of people who voluntarily live this way. Not out of poverty or being a total recluse, but because the negative parts simply don't turn out to be as bad as it might seem before you've tried it, and the positive experiences associated with living closer to nature are deeply rewarding.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by phil21 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:28AM (#17690492)
> Do you think people were terribly uncomfortable at ambient temperatures due to their physiology before AC was invented?

Yes, absolutely. I grew up without AC and now I jokingly tell my fiance my entire career has been motivated to ensure I maintain access to AC the rest of my life.

I grew up in a very cold place (MN) compared to most - the cold didn't matter much to me. I'm a t-shirt in 40 degree weather sort of guy. The hot summer months were absolute utter hell though, even with fans and sleeping in the basement/etc. To this day I think this had a huge effect on my sleeping patterns and thus other health problems later on in life.

I do think one of the elephants in the room is the obesity issue. I certainly have noticed I get a lot hotter with 40lbs extra on me. When the average American is overweight I'm sure this has moved the "herd preference temperature" down a couple degrees the past few decades.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by syshum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:57AM (#17689915)
Do I care if "people were terribly uncomfortable at ambient temperatures due to their physiology before AC was invented?"... No, No I do not.

We have AC now, lets use it

I do not have the desire to Sweat all day every day in my office while I am attempting to use a computer or do my work

I do not have the desire to have my body be cooled by "natural airflow causing evaporative cooling" caused by my profuse uncomfortable and unsightly sweating over everything

I do not have the this desire, what I have a desire for is Air Conditioning, a modern convenience that human invented so we would no longer need to use "natural airflow causing evaporative cooling"

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:22AM (#17689999)
So do you just stay inside all day because of AC? I blast the AC all day long at the office, in the car, and at home, but on the weekend I feel like getting out! I like going for a hike, or on a bike ride, or going swimming. Yeah, I sweat, then a breeze hits and it feels awesome. This evaporative cooling business isn't total bullshit.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by expounded on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:57AM (#17690111)
Not the person you asked but yes, yes I do.

For me anything above 21 C (~70 F) and sunny is uncomfortable miserable for me. I am serious. Everybody seems to enjoy the sunlight and talk about how depressed they get in the winters when it’s dark but I have the exact 100% opposite. During the summers I can’t go outside. Like, it’s not physically impossible and I can tolerate going outside long enough to walk to the store and so on, but the thought of “enjoying my time outside in the warm summer sun” elucidates the same thoughts that you’d get if I asked you to stick your hand inside a garbage disposal. I’m not even being hyperbolic right now. The thought of being outside when it’s sunny and 21+ degrees seriously shuts me down entirely. I’m basically depressed all summer and spring because of the sun, because of the temperature. I’m depressed because it means I cant go outside and enjoy the things I enjoy in the fall and winter: going on long bike rides, trail running, hiking and camping, etc.

For whatever reason, the moment the bright sun shines in my face or the first bead of sweat beads up on my body I just 100% shut down. Nothing is fun anymore. Nothing is enjoyable anymore.

I’ve spoken with several therapists to try to get some help with this and nothing people say or tell me has helped. It doesn’t help that everybody things I’m just being a big baby either.

But come fall and winter, I f-king love live. I love waking up before the sun rises and getting in a nice 30 minute run in the dark. I love getting into work when it’s dark and leaving work when it’s dark. I love walking around town or visiting nearby cities (Europe) in the winter because I’m not sweating the entire time. I love feeling the super cold wind hit me as I’m cycling long 20+ km rides. In the spring and summer I love being outside on the days when it’s overcast, gray, raining aka “depressing weather.” It doesn’t bother me at all. I love looking outside my office windows or my living room window and seeing gray clouds all day every day. In the winters I can wear T-shirt’s down to ~5 C, and I can wear just a hoodie and jeans down to the negatives as long as I have gloves.

I would love it if I could stand being in the sun, being in the warmth, but I can’t and I’ve tried. Like a lot of people have wrote: you can always wear more clothes. You can always light the place up. You can always use an umbrella. What can I do when it’s unbearbly hot and sunny and I’m already wearing shorts and a T-shirt? Absolutely nothing.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by skriticos2 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:32AM (#17690808)
Sounds like you are a bit on the far end of the spectrum, but I can definitely relate. I tend to feel miserable too when it's getting too bright and warm.

I don't personally mind short warm bursts when I'm sitting in a sauna and getting a frigid soaking afterwards, but I do tend to sweat and it's really very annoying having to wear cloth during an office day that that are soaked - and my skin also hates me for it. I also tend to feel immediately miserable when I get direct sunshine on my head, which is why I tend to wear a hat - though that makes the sweating issue worse.

I kind of enjoy the time of my commute the most where I can set the AC as I please and put on some fairly dark driving sunglasses while listening to a book. Peaceful and comfortable time that is.

I also got a set of office glasses with some 50% shading and a blue light filter for those places that insist on 1500 Lumen/m2 brightness.

I concur about the lack of understanding of a lot of people for these issues. "Sun is good, stop whining" is really irritating. People are different, not every one likes ice cream, bright light/sun, waking up early, etc.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @11:52AM (#17691888)
Thanks for taking the time to share your experience, it does help to understand and empathize with the breadth of human experiences.

I don't think the point of the building in this article was to force warmer temperatures on everybody. It sounded more like an experiment in increasing airflow. I think it would be most beneficial if they could work out a way to keep temperatures lower without sacrificing the air flow.

As an engineer, I firmly believe that innovation is driven through the process of starting with an experiment, discovering weak points, and steadily iterating to mitigate the weaknesses without sacrificing the advantages. But this process must be firmly grounded in a deep understanding of experiences of end-users who interact with the product, and the core objective should be improving quality of life, accounting for the variability in what that means to different people.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by orhmeh09 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:55AM (#17690415)
What are your thoughts on the environmental impact?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by expounded on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:29AM (#17690609)
I separate all of my trash and recycle everything I’m able to. Food waste is composted. I haven’t used plastic bags in years and I’ve been asking for no straws since before it came into the news now. I don’t own a car. I ride my bike everywhere I’m able to and otherwise I take public transit. I’m a vegetarian for environmental reasons. I don’t own a clothes dryer because the sun works just as well.

As I said I think it’s wasteful especially cause I can’t seal my windows. But if you read my post then you’d see that my limit of caring stops when I’m sweating in my bed at 11pm at night because it’s still 30+ despite me being on the ground floor.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by orhmeh09 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:41PM (#17692114)
Thank you for your response. Not that I’m an arbiter or these things but I think you are perceptive of your impact and what you can do to minimize it to a much greater degree than most, and we’d all be better off if more of us in the developed world were as thoughtful.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by spacehome on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:54PM (#17694448)
OK.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by spacehome on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:02AM (#17690547)
Are you overweight?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dang on Monday August 06, 2018 @02:15AM (#17695422)
This violates the site guidelines. Please review them and follow the rules when posting here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by spacehome on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @04:09AM (#17714013)
Which one?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dang on Thursday August 09, 2018 @02:11AM (#17721960)
For starters, "Be civil."
[dead]
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by llampx on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:15AM (#17690938)
To be fair, there was a question and not an assumption. An assumption would be, "I bet you are overweight."
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by greedo on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:00PM (#17692553)
The implications of the question were pretty clear.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by spacehome on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:09PM (#17694694)
It's certainly true that overweight people tend to run a little warmer. It's just a brute consequence of more insulation. We are not abstract thinking machines, but rather embedded in the physical world. My weight has fluctuated over the years, and when I'm carrying more pounds, I definitely notice that temperatures I used to feel comfortable at now cause me discomfort.

As for the implication. I really didn't imply anything. I have no idea of expounded's weight. Being overweight would be one explanation of his experience, but not the only one. I didn't know, so I asked. It certainly seems to be a touchy subject for him or her.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by syshum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:21AM (#17691441)
For the most part yes I stay indoors.. I do not like going for a hike, or a bike ride in the summer months when it is above 80 degrees out... This is one of the reasons gyms have all kinds of Stationary bikes, treadmills, etc so people do not have to be out in the heat while still being able to exercise..

Swimming well I am in cool water at the point does sweating is not really needed.

Further I am not in Business Causal attire when I am hiking, and hiking or other outdoor exercise is an activity where one is expected to be sweating, however in a office environment one is not expected to have sweat dripping from the face, have their shirt soaked in sweat, etc.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:20PM (#17692328)
The specific Terry Thomas office build that's the topic of discussion is atypical, that's the point of the article. It sounds like they'd accommodate attire appropriate for the temperature... it's Seattle, wearing outdoor clothing to work is totally normal.

And we have a very mild climate, so it would only be this hot in late afternoon for a dozen days or so each year. On such days I'd just say "I'm uncomfortable so I'm going to WFH the rest of the day." I'm pretty sure that would be acceptable for this architecture firm. It's never been a problem that I leave work early due to traffic from baseball games near my downtown Seattle office, for example.

I totally understand that you have a different heat tolerance and physiological reaction to heat than I do. I'd go crazy exercising in a gym when it feels so much more stimulating overall to be outside, whereas mid-80's temperature with low humidity is just mildly unpleasant to me. But I respect that other's feel differently about it.

However, the difference between 78 and your ideal temperature is probably not so great, especially compared to many other parts of the country with much higher temps and humidity. I wouldn't entirely discount the possibility that this Terry Building might not be as uncomfortable for you as it sounds. And if it did turn out to be unbearably uncomfortable for you, I wouldn't discount the possibility of working together with your team and management to find an agreeable solution.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by syshum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:50PM (#17693141)
I dont think I ever stated my "ideal" temp, I stated what is tolerable to me as I am aware that I work in a building with others so compromise is a must

When I have my own office with my own AC Zone/Controls it would be set to 62 Degrees. That is a significant difference from 78.

My current office building has shared zones and sets the AC at about 73, it is bearable most days provided I do not need to do anything more than use my computer, even then I have a desk fan blowing air at me continually while at my desk. I am not however sweating or overly uncomfortable, the fan is able to mitigate 90% of my comfort.

However it does not take much physical work in that environment to push me over the edge in to sweating.

as to "accommodate attire appropriate for the temperature" the thing is some people might like wearing shorts, sandals, and a beach shirt to work, I do not even own these things. I don't wear suits, but I wear long pants, I wear a button down shirt and that is it. I do not believe an office environment should look like everyone is going to the beach. I am sure that is old fashioned thinking however, i believe Professionals should dress professionally.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:53PM (#17693468)
I've worked in a number of professional environments, and attire ranged from steel-toed work boots and rugged clothes covered with mud, to full suit-and-tie, and a range of in-betweens (but never beach gear). So I never associated attire with professionalism per se, although it is important to wear something suitable to the task at hand.

What has not been so variable are things I'd consider more core aspects of professional behavior:

* caring deeply about customer needs and expectations, exercising grit, determination, and ingenuity to satisfy them

* understanding business concerns like cost management and delivering value to both investors and customers, striking a balance between competing demands

* understanding and caring about teammates, working effectively with a team to achieve above 2 objectives. maintaining a solution oriented mindset.

Here's how I might apply my interpretation of professionalism to the hypothetical situation that you were a capable coworker at Weber Thompson who felt uncomfortable due to the approximately 16 degree temperature excess on a hot day: propose partitioning off a space and installing air conditioning there for those who want it.

I don't see any inherent technical obstacles or insurmountable business concerns in that solution. It would balance the desires of some employees for connection with outside air, without causing discomfort to others who for one reason or another have a different preference. Customers might appreciate the flexibility to make the space suitable for a wider variety of preferences, and ask if we can do the same for them.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by greedo on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:02PM (#17692565)
They say shorts etc are fine, but in the picture, I see a guy in a suit and tie. It's an architectural firm; do you want to meet customers with pitstains on your shirt? I'm sure some customers wouldn't mind, but most businesspeople who are looking for a firm expect a certain level of professional attire.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tangentspace on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:21PM (#17692972)
I see a guy with a shirt and tie, but no suit jacket. A few other people have long sleeve shirts. I couldn't speak for them as to whether they are uncomfortable and sweaty, but based on personal experience hiking with long sleeves to avoid sunburn, high quality shirts can be very breathable and comfortable at temperatures around 78-80.

I admit the possibility that this whole article is a puff piece meant as PR for this firm, and in reality they're all miserable inside but maintain a charade of happiness to hide from potential customers the fact that their heat chimney was in fact an engineering disaster.

The simpler explanation, which jibes with my personal experience as a longtime Seattleite, is that it's just not that big of a deal to do without AC here as long as its a relatively small building and you get the airflow right.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by TylerE on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:31AM (#17690197)
And the computers and displays aren’t helping - they’re little space heaters
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:30AM (#17690020)
Yes, of course. If you want to experience that, just go and work in China where many offices in the north lack AC and many in the south lack heat. Your productivity will simply plummet in either case (you can’t code very well with freezing fingers or sweaty arms). I think in the ost they just took the oroductivit hit in stride (well, white collar work wasn’t as common).
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by kwhitefoot on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:12AM (#17690150)
American offices are always too cold for me, and I live in Norway. I often have to take a light pullover with me to the US even in the summer just to wear in the office when it is 40 C in the shade outside.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by fpoling on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:09AM (#17690296)
In Norway electricity is cheap and I have found that people heat their houses to higher temperatures than in neighboring countries during long cold time. But then lower office temperature is uncomfortable.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by s_trumpet on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:32AM (#17691501)
This is something that varies wildly with which part of the world you're in. For me, anything below 65F is "too cold" with 85 being a comfortable temperature.
[dead]
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dang on Monday August 06, 2018 @02:13AM (#17695419)
Please don't do this here.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by cup-of-tea on Monday August 06, 2018 @05:36AM (#17696235)
Sorry, what? What are we supposed to do here? Use euphemisms like "big", or maybe technical terms like "overweight" or "obese"? Do we deny that fat people have a different experience to regular people? Do we deny the existence of fat people altogether?

I really don't understand what your problem is with this.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by fyfy18 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:02AM (#17689928)
I’m usually a cold lover, but this summer I’ve had to suck it up. I’ve been working in London, UK in an office where it’s usually above 25c (no proper AC and south facing windows) and my apartment is often the same temperature when I go to sleep (one night it was 29c/84F).

A few observations I’ve made:

- Even when it’s this temperature, a fan blowing air over you really helps to increase comfort. Too much airflow is also uncomfortable (messes with the NC on my headphones), and most desk fans are too powerful even on their lowest settings.

- I’ve started eating less which seems to reduce my metabolism causing the heat to effect me less. It’s a trade-off as if I eat too little I can’t work as effectively, but there’s a local optimum vs being too uncomfortable from the heat.

- Shorts and t-shirt everyday. Even then I’m still sweating for the next hour if I do anything strenuous outside.

- People who are always cold don’t seem to understand the discomfort people experience from heat. In my home country in the depths of winter it often gets to 15c/60F or less in old buildings. I’d much rather that with lots of layers and hot drinks, than be too hot. Maybe they feel the same about the heat though, can anyone comfortably work in an office environment that is 35c/95F?

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by Aeolos on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:24AM (#17690330)
35C is way too much, but my optimal working temperature is 22-25C. I find anything below 20C too cold to work in, even with extra layers of clothes. I am incessantly surprised by people putting AC down to 16C or 14C.

This may have to do with the climate you grew up in. For example, I absolutely love outside temperatures between 28-35C, provided a dry climate and access to water (sea/river/lake).

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by GuB-42 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:57AM (#17690706)
78F (25.5C) is not that hot.

On my A/C unit, 25C is the factory default setting in cooling mode (20C for heating). I don't know why but in the US, people tend to set their A/C to arctic mode.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by mcphage on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:58PM (#17693184)
25C but dry (what you get with an A/C) is a lot more pleasant than 25C and humid.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dahdum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:14AM (#17689625)
78 with Seattle’s high humidity sounds like a constant slight discomfort to me.

I can handle the heat and humidity and be comfortable, but not while wearing business casual.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by loeg on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:17AM (#17689635)
Seattle is usually either 85 or humid; not both. Hot summer days have moderate/low humidity compared to most places I've been.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:36AM (#17690038)
I wish. Swamp coolers still aren’t very effective in Seattle st 85+f. It’s AC or bust if you want to stay cool.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by paulcole on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:22AM (#17689645)
High humidity compared to Phoenix maybe. If you’re uncomfortable in Seattle’s humidity god help you if you ever visit anywhere in Florida.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by cm2012 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:31AM (#17689675)
I work from home and keep my office at 60. I would die at 78, hah.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by Johnny555 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:05AM (#17689785)
I think they can do a lot better

Without electricity?

78 is tolerable with a breeze (and moderate humidity).

I live in the Seattle area without AC and it's fine. Open the windows at night with a window fan to bring in cool air (I don't have a breeze-inducing courtyard), close the windows and the blinds in the daytime to keep out the sun.

Even in 90 degree weather outside, the bedrooms on the third floor stay under 75 degrees and by bedtime it's typically cooler than that so the fan keeps it cool.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by syshum on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:03AM (#17689934)
>>78 is tolerable with a breeze (and moderate humidity).

Maybe for you.... over 75 is not tolerable to me, I can not sleep at over 72 even if I have an industrial fan blowing over me....

My AC is set year round in my home to 68-70 and that is pushing it for me, In the winter my heat is set to 60-65

I love the cold, this is why I live in the Northern US and not Florida

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:34AM (#17690033)
I live in the Seattle area without an AC, it’s fine but I can only code at home in the morning and at night, I’m not going to use my computer between 12 and 6PM during a heat wave without a huge ass fan next to me, and even then it doesn’t work out well.
[dead]
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dang on Monday August 06, 2018 @02:14AM (#17695421)
We've asked you several times in the past to stop violating the site guidelines. If you continue to post like this, we will ban you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by cup-of-tea on Monday August 06, 2018 @05:42AM (#17696260)
Is this a culture clash? In my part of the world my post would have been considered perfectly acceptable and civil. Have you ever watched a British debate? We don't all pretend to like each other and put on a false overly agreeable facade. We're allowed to disagree with people and it's great.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by DanBC on Monday August 06, 2018 @09:38AM (#17697381)
You should have left out "you should be ashamed of yourself".
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by raverbashing on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:40AM (#17691041)
While you might have a point, there's no need to gatekeep

Also while physical labor is definitely hard under the heat, intellectual work can grind to a halt depending on the temperature

To the point where I'm really skeptical of places that don't offer any kind of climate control where it is needed (and apparently that's quickly becoming "everywhere")

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by cup-of-tea on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:02PM (#17692231)
Gatekeep? What's that supposed to mean? What am I gatekeeping?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by tomcooks on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:36AM (#17691027)
> That’s too hot to work in my opinion. > in my opinion. > my opinion. > opinion
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by zavi on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:46PM (#17689560)
> You forget how hardwired humans are to really enjoy the natural environment," she said. People get respite from being connected to nature, she said, "even in an urban environment like a city"

Um, no I don't think I'll enjoy working @ 78F much.

Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by aurelian15 on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:53PM (#17689581)
Why? 25°C is absolutely fine for working inside, at least for me. A little cooler and I need a sweater and long pants. This summer I've mainly worked at home (no AC, Southern Ontario), because I don't want to bring my winter clothes to work. Combine a room cooled to 20°C, the AC breeze, and me sitting at a desk without a scarf and I have a sore throat in under two hours.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by mindcrime on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:05AM (#17689602)
78°F is at least 10° too hot for me to be comfortable. I'd go nuts if I had to work in that kind of heat all day.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by colordrops on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:18AM (#17689638)
Even in short clothing?
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by dnbgfher on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:49AM (#17689732)
For me, yes. Even at 65 I'm very happy wearing shorts and tshirts.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by mindcrime on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:09AM (#17689805)
Yep.
Re:An office building in Seattle that doesn't have air condi... by loeg on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:20AM (#17689642)
It's a fine temperature for remaining completely sedentary, but I like to be able to walk to the bus or cafe, or up and down stairs, without breaking a sweat.