News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:52AM (#17141945)
Hey all – Brian from Instapaper here. We worked really hard to try to avoid a service interruption in the EU, but unfortunately we were unable to. We continue to work hard to ensure that the service interruption is as brief as possible.

Let me know if you have any questions...

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:59PM (#17147731)
I feel like you’re making a bigger deal out of this than necessary, unless you’re doing some shady stuff with our data.

From what I can tell from various legal advice that I’ve read, as long as you’re working on implementing the changes, and have been following security best practices, nothing really changes on May 25th, and you’ll be able to take your time to become fully compliant, as long as you can demonstrate that’s what’s happening. In other words, good faith and best practice will get you far.

Your current reaction seems like a huge and unnecessary over reaction that is just harming your users, and unlikely to have any material impact to your legal risk.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by pembrook on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:11PM (#17147874)
Instapaper is owned by Pinterest. Pinterest is a large high profile company with millions of European users and would be a potential target of regulators looking to establish precedents of enforcement with a big name.

I highly doubt this decision was made lightly and was probably informed by actual legal professionals with knowledge of the regulators in question and not the 3rd party opinion of some guy on the internet who "feels like its not that big of a deal."

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:18PM (#17147980)
But he's spot on about contacting the regulators because they already know they won't be in compliance.

Now would be a good time to do just that, and if the actual legal professionals thought it was a good idea to ban EU citizens but keep their data then maybe they should get better lawyers because that certainly won't work.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Normal_gaussian on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:11PM (#17148452)
hmmm...

If I had an instapaper account it would be interesting to submit a GDPR request tomorrow, and see what kind of reply I got. Now I don't, but I'm sure there are plenty of other interested people around.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:39PM (#17149133)
In all likelihood, the answer from most companies would be "sorry we don't yet have the ability to provide that data, it's on the roadmap, you'll have to wait".
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by oldcynic on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:43AM (#17150679)
At which point the data subject can report them to the regulator. Hopefully everyone receiving such a response will do so. Companies have had 2 years warning.

For most small business and startups this is no big deal as 1 or 2 reports to the regulator isn't going to trigger anything. For those companies of a certain size, the regulator might take note of 1,000 reports in the first week. I imagine some of those will have the regulator check if they have had a self-report from the company for non-compliance. Maybe then an email to colleagues at other ICOs across Europe.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by smueller1234 on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:04AM (#17151537)
I keep reading the "two years warning" notion on HN. While that might be technically correct, the real problem was that nobody UNDERSTOOD what GDPR meant (including the legislators) and so to this day, its practical implementation will to no small part depend on the iterative conclusions and learning various implementors (eg. companies) made in an arduous process since.

In other words, the first to think they were GDPR compliant might have had to redo a ton of work to adjust to more recent interpretations.

And let's not forget, for large orgs with complex infrastructure, this is a behemoth of an effort. There's been year long projects in the two large tech companies I've had insight to since.

And while I'm at it, let me comment on the frequently expressed notion of "if you've respected your users in the past, you'll be fine!". Just to pick one counter argument: the right to be forgotten. That can only be implemented thoroughly and in the way the users expect it to work (ie. delete everything but what you're legally required to retain) by finding a way to connect all user data so you know what to drop if need be. That is exactly the kind of action that's caused public outrage at big tech to begin with and it's not only potentially a huge effort, it also increases risk of abuse.

This all being said, I still think GDPR is a good idea at least in principle. And believe it or not, while everyone around me is really of compliance work, GDPR seems widely considered a good idea in principle across engineering in big tech.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by oldcynic on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:40AM (#17152217)
> the real problem was that nobody UNDERSTOOD what GDPR meant (including the legislators

There we have to disagree. It's not like this is something new and untried.

GDPR is a development from long-standing, and now very well understood, Data Protection. The legislation seems mainly intended to modernise some of the definitions and scope (eg adding biometrics to PII), catch some newer practices, and make very plain and explicit that it doesn't just apply to EU companies.

In 1996 and 97 in the run up to the 1998 Data Protection Directive I recall a couple of common confusions and misunderstandings. Nothing like the ridiculously poor and simply incorrect reporting we have for this.

Any large org should have been fully compliant with DPA for years. They have to add extra mechanisms for explicit opt-in or deletion and get a little less time to retrieve full data and can't charge. That doesn't seem to need a "behemoth of effort", but not to say it's necessarily entirely trivial.

In other words they survived DPA with no apparent effect, yet it's >80% of GDPR with the same definitions. No one should be iteratively fumbling toward an unclear target at all. Even reading the UK ICO's old guide to 1998 Data Protection from a few years ago gets you most of the way there including understanding personal data.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by DanBC on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:06AM (#17151547)
But there are not massive differences between the laws we've had for many years - for a UK example PECR and DPA implement EU regulations and contain many of the same principles around lawful basis, limiting the amount of data that's held and the length of time it's held for, etc.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by krageon on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:49AM (#17151737)
Anything that doesn't say "We will do just that! It might take up to 30 days" and asks for up to two extensions afterwards is not compliant, so this would be an exceptionally dumb response.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by slededit on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:47PM (#17149185)
This is ridiculous, its not like they didn't have notice.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Grollicus on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:01PM (#17149278)
But that's the reality. At least they're working on it and the fact that a lot of companies massively overreact means they at least take data protection serious now.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by slededit on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:09PM (#17149308)
You don't ignore a law for 2 years and then just after it comes into force say "at least we're working on it". Honestly I thought the GDPR was a bit of an over reaction when it came out 2 years ago but seeing how little respect companies have for our data over the last few weeks I've been convinced it was necessary.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Operyl on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:28PM (#17149931)
As an engineer, with as much else is going on on a day to day basis it's not surprising. A lot of the vagueness around the GDPR still hasn't been resolved, nobody wanted to get a head start just to be told "oops, we actually meant this" and have wasted countless engineering/lawyer hours as a result.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by slededit on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:43PM (#17150005)
You would only take that liberty if you didn't have much respect for the law and its ability to touch you. I suspect companies are a lot more careful with each years new IRS rules even though they don't yet have case law and are often issued on much shorter notice.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Operyl on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:46PM (#17150013)
Companies directly lobby the laws that affect the IRS on a year-to-year basis and have a lot more knowledge about it. It is hardly as vague as this was. I very much do respect the laws when I can, but I'm a US citizen, and my projects don't make enough money for me to ultimately care about the GDPR/EU. I just blocked them for .. ever, probably. You're really targeting people here, sorry I disagree?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by slededit on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:06PM (#17150097)
I am not speaking of you specifically because this is about the behavior of companies and not personal projects.

There are companies, OP being one (a subsidiary of Pinterest) that have presence in the EU and are essentially playing chicken with the regulators. Blocking users but keeping their data is not compliance, nor are dialogs telling users you plan to carry on as normal. Companies do not do this with the IRS because they would be afraid of the consequences.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by DanBC on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:52AM (#17151235)
> You don't ignore a law for 2 years

And that's only GDPR. We've had PECR (in UK) since 2002 and DPA since 1995.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by grey-area on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:29PM (#17149058)
Most other companies haven't made the same decision, what's different about Instapaper?

Do they share reading habits with multiple third parties perhaps?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:47PM (#17149195)
This is increasingly my suspicion. I'd expect that they could have solved any technical issues around disabling tracking or letting users opt-in/out by now, which leads me to suspect that they have their business model based on being able to share certain data. It's very possible that they've A/B tested GDPR compliant flows/messaging, and found that their metrics/revenue dropped enough that they feel they have to do something more drastic. Although the argument against that is the fact they have literally just disabled access for European users.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by matwood on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:25PM (#17149921)
GDPR has basically turned the lights on all of the companies doing questionable things with user data. Shutting down or turning off the EU is a huge red flag.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ggg9990 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:15AM (#17150558)
No it’s not. The way big companies are dealing with the GDPR is to ask their lawyers what to do. The lawyers define compliance very expansively since they’re not the ones doing the work and they are the ones who will be blamed if the EU comes after the company. So they say, “every single trace of anything related to user data must be purged.” So the company asks every engineering team to fill out a 200 point checklist about what they are doing with user data.

So, unless you’re saying that “Pinterest’s site reliability team can’t answer question 192 about how user data is deleted from the incident management system logs when an event is traced” is a “huge red flag” then you are exaggerating the issue.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by celticninja on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:38PM (#17149125)
Probably worth reading this.

https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria

EU agencies would prefer compliance over fines and would work with businesses to help them. As the article suggests, prosecution/fines will come when all other avenues are exhausted not the starting point.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by downandout on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:42PM (#17149146)
Says some random dude on the Internet that seems to be a tremendous fan of GDPR. I prefer to base my understanding of laws on the text of the law. This one says that no warnings are required and that fines can be up to 20M EUR.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by YeGoblynQueenne on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:57AM (#17150970)
>> Says some random dude on the Internet that seems to be a tremendous fan of GDPR.

Let's be a little self-conscious here, shall we?

Of all the articles on HN that discuss the GDPR that I've read, I've found one that you didn't contribute to and your contributions never show an "understanding of laws based on the text of the law". For instance, you have consistently claimed that there will be 28 (btw, not 27) different interpretations of the law, completely disregarding entire articles devoted to the consistent application of the Regulation- which, as a regulation, does not need to be made into local law and is applicable across the bloc.

You are clearly on a warpath against the GDPR, which is perfectly fine of course; yet at the same time you accuse jacquesm of being a "tremendous fan of the GDPR". If you can express your opinion despite having an agenda, so can he - and he seems to be much better informed of the law than you are.

Edit: Just to clarify, I don't have some axe to grind against you. You're one of the few users whose handle I recognise because your comments in GDPR threads stand out so much in their fervour and because there are so many of them.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by downandout on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:20AM (#17151358)
I’m not on the warpath, but I will consistently dispute rosy predictions about the “good natured enforcers” (a direct quote from Jacques) of GDPR. No law or regulation this easy to violate, with fines this large, that claims extraterritorial powers, has ever not been abused, and this will be no exception.

With regard to your claim that it will not be subject to unique interpretations in each country within the EU, that simply isn’t true. Each country will have its own enforcement agencies. They’ll enforce it in different ways, and to different degrees. Since this regulation is so vague, it simply isn’t possible that they will all interpret and enforce it in the same way.

You seem to be in Jacque’s corner, claiming that our new self-appointed privacy overlords will be perfectly coordinated and “good natured”. As someone with quite a bit of experience dealing with government agencies, I can tell you that few of those that seek out relatively low-paying government jobs where the primary perk is having power over other people are “good natured”. There will be abuses.

The good news is that D-Day is here, and now we can all stop arguing and watch to see whose predictions come true.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ggg9990 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:19AM (#17150581)
Neither of you are right. The EU is not going to go out guns blazing with $20m fines for small companies. They’re also not going to host a drum circle for companies to harmoniously join the movement towards better user privacy. They’re going to get some big fines out there on big companies (who doesn’t love free money) and also go after smaller companies actively doing bad things with user data. Yes, they could, but in the same way that the person standing at the bus with you could punch you in the face. It might happen, but realistically, it probably won’t, and you’re probably not actively prepping for it.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by tluyben2 on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:28AM (#17150849)
As Jacques and me as well have said; that simply means panic and it is not needed. You maybe do not live in the EU but the letter of the law is not such a thing here as it might be in the US (and although punishment is harsher and often far harsher than it is here, US also looks at intent). The EU is not going to punish any company that has the intent to offer its users privacy under this law, but made some mistakes or forgot things. They made this especially vague simply because a) we know they are not going to blanket destroy all violators anyway (we have many crazy vague laws for many decades; no one cares) b) if someone is clearly violating (and I am looking at you, obfuscating user tracking ad companies who, until now, got around pervious regulations by moving servers to other countries and other tricks) they want to be able to enforce, no matter what. This is all very clearly based on user intent, not letter of the law. It might be incredibly hard for litigious country citizens to understand, but we have been living all our lives (and it differs per country as well) with this.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by guelo on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:53AM (#17150948)
That's the recipe for political enforcement of draconian laws. It's especially dangerous for big foreign american companies which are perfect for politicians to demagogue about. I would not bet the business on any extra-legal grace from their beuracracy.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by olivierduval on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:09AM (#17152760)
"political enforcement of draconian laws"... like: how the US use their extra-territorial law to fine US Business's competitors (banks, industry...) ? ;-) It's funny to see how the US way of mixing law and business is terrifying when others may use it too, no? Anyway: it hasn't been how Europe worked until now, so relax. French Regulator said, for example, that it won't enforce strictly the regulation ... because... well... EU companies aren't more ready than US ones. And they'll have to.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Chris_Jay on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:53AM (#17153692)
The US paving the way for such practices is not exactly reassurance. If the laws are so complex nobody is capable of operating within them, the result is a police state. Being subject to arrest at any time because the law of the land explicitly gives the government that power or because it is so byzantine that nobody can know all of it works out to the same thing in the end.

Your argument seems to be that a police state where the authorities have a lighter touch is preferable. That's obviously true compared to a draconian police state, but it's a police state either way.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by vertex-four on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:39AM (#17150654)
Under existing law companies can be fined somewhat ridiculous amounts for data breaches and essentially never are, so why exactly would the enforcement strategy change for the GDPR? Maximum sentences just aren’t an EU thing, nobody gets them unless they’re wilfully causing damage to people and this isn’t their first time. I don’t know if America does things differently, but based on what I know, it doesn’t - maximum fines and sentences are essentially never passed out there either.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by celticninja on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:46AM (#17151202)
Where do you see the "no warnings are required"?

Article 58 says that fines can be issued along with, or in place of, other enforcement action. That isn't "no warnings". Plus if you read the text of the law you would note that it is very clear that the size of the fine is dependent on 11 factors, many of which revolve around future compliance and efforts made by the business to resolve the breach and showing willingness to conply.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:38PM (#17149123)
My "feels like its not that big of a deal" is based on my own companies approach, legal advice I've seen, and internal training.

I realise that Pinterest is large and I'm sure they have sought legal advice, but that doesn't stop this coming across as an overreaction, if one assumes that they _aren't_ using the data in ways that explicitly violate the rights granted by the GDPR.

Now if they are explicitly violating those rights, that's another story! I'd rather attribute it to ignorance than malice though.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:18PM (#17148507)
> would be a potential target of regulators looking to establish precedents of enforcement with a big name.

Shouldn't law apply equally to everyone? One could have thought that setting an example "to show them!" wouldn't have occurred in a civilised country.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bearcobra on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:23PM (#17148539)
In a world of limited resources, it makes sense that regulators would pursue enforcement against entities that impact a large number of people.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kodablah on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:54PM (#17149236)
In such a world, it would make more sense to limit the scope of the law until enforcement can catch up. Minimally enforced laws that are enforced subjectively are problematic regardless of why.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Tyrek on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:04PM (#17149582)
Are you suggesting that the US government suspend income tax while they hire enough people in the IRS to go through every individual's tax return?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kodablah on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:11PM (#17149867)
No, I'm suggesting they don't add any more compliance rules with new punishments unless they staff up.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by xevb3k on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:39PM (#17150241)
Minimal enforcement can be used to make everyone a criminal. You then selectively apply the law against people you don’t like.

Taxation (I would hope) is not minimally enforced.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by YeGoblynQueenne on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:44AM (#17150918)
It's a union, not a country and it definitely won't go after big players with any kind of prejudice. It will go after those who flaunt the regulation, big and small.

Because it's the EU and not some other Union.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:43PM (#17148715)
Regulators only have so many hours in the day. Prioritizing high visibility infringers can persuade lower visibility infringers to get into compliance.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:46PM (#17148744)
Not sure how they could persuade if they won't go after lower visibility infringers? I can't follow your logic.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by EpicEng on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:56PM (#17148822)
No one said "they won't go after small timers". Hitting the big players hard makes everyone wary of violating and they will absolutely catch some small fish as well.

It's just silly to expect any enforcement body to go after everyone equally. It doesn't even make sense; company A has data on 1.5B people, company B has data on 27 people and the owner's mother. Why would you go after B before A?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:44PM (#17149169)
They have said this.

a) they have said they don't want to punish companies for the sake of it, they want to use it as an incentive to fundamentally change the approach to the handling of user data. This means not suing tiny companies for more money than they are worth.

b) they have said that the standards will roughly increase with the size of the company and resources it has. A company with 27 users (and few employees) would not be expected to have a data protection officer, or many of the control processes that a company with data on 1.5B people.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:49PM (#17149508)
I think everyone is talking about the UK 's ICO, which is just 1 of the 28. We have heard nothing from others and its best not to make assumptions - the ICO may be following different rules in a year.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Saturday May 26, 2018 @04:59AM (#17160985)
True, some of this is more from the UK ICO, but some is from the official guidance from the EU.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:04AM (#17151540)
> This means not suing tiny companies for more money than they are worth.

Which effectively kills that company even if court finds their violation was minimal.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:55PM (#17149817)
I never said they wouldn't. But showing that they're willing to go after infringers is easier when you use high visibility cases to do it.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by celticninja on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:40PM (#17149138)
https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria

Setting an example is how the US regulators work, not so much the EU.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by downandout on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:50PM (#17148781)
I feel like you’re making a bigger deal out of this than necessary, unless you’re doing some shady stuff with our data.

Seeing this completely false sentiment repeated over and over again is getting exhausting. Only a tiny fraction of the companies avoiding EU traffic due to GDPR have any intention of “doing shady stuff with your data”.

GDPR is highly complex, and as of tomorrow, allowing EU traffic invites massive liabilities that most companies outside the EU won’t be willing to take on. While Instapaper likely will eventually relaunch in the EU because of its footprint there, the reality is that EU residents are going to be blocked from a large percentage of the world’s websites. The liability is just too great and the rewards too small for most companies outside the EU. You guys chose to make your traffic radioactive. These are the consequences.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by drusepth on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:03PM (#17149291)
>I feel like you’re making a bigger deal out of this than necessary, unless you’re doing some shady stuff with our data.

This sentiment and the hilariously large fines (regardless of company size, even) on relatively-ill-defined requirements make the whole GDPR process feel like it was designed to bully businesses into compliance.

Some pieces of GDPR are definitely for the benefit of the end-user (at the expense of companies, who happen to be providing those users other benefits). It all feels really heavy-handed, though.

Not to mention a little reminiscent of the problems that occur with other "bans" (which, this effectively is). When you put heavy legal restrictions on doing X (where, in this case, X is storing and processing data that you assumedly use to provide a service for users), you're effectively hurting the legitimate businesses most (_especially_ small ones) while the real "bad guys" that are actually doing bad things with our data are going to continue ignoring the law. There might be some value in-between, but I doubt there's much.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jdietrich on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:03PM (#17149581)
>This sentiment and the hilariously large fines (regardless of company size, even) on relatively-ill-defined requirements make the whole GDPR process feel like it was designed to bully businesses into compliance.

>Some pieces of GDPR are definitely for the benefit of the end-user (at the expense of companies, who happen to be providing those users other benefits). It all feels really heavy-handed, though.

The GDPR isn't vastly different to the old Data Protection Directive, which has been in force since 1997. The panic over GDPR suggests that a lot of companies had simply been ignoring the DPD. If a bit of bullying is required to get businesses to obey the law, then so be it.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by noncoml on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:30PM (#17150205)
> “bully businesses into compliance“

I am not sure I understand this sentence. That’s what laws do. “Bully” you into compliance. I think you might have meant something else?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by guitarbill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:28PM (#17150193)
> while the real "bad guys" that are actually doing bad things with our data are going to continue ignoring the law.

This is already happening without the GDPR (carders, dumps, etc), so I don't buy it. The black-market analogy (e.g. illegal drugs) also doesn't hold when applied to companies.

> the hilariously large fines (regardless of company size, even)

Oh no, proportional fines! How socialist!

The whole point is to make it somewhat independent of the company size, so bigger companies won't just swallow the fines. This is typically what Google et al do, they just factor it in to the cost of business. The GDPR wasn't written in a vacuum.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by drusepth on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:06AM (#17151017)
>The whole point is to make it somewhat independent of the company size, so bigger companies won't just swallow the fines.

Ironically, it's the bigger companies that can still just swallow the fines and the little companies that just effectively vanish into bankruptcy.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by a3_nm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:46PM (#17149775)
> You guys chose to make your traffic radioactive

Er. I vote in an EU country, but I don't feel like I "chose" anything. GDPR was mostly developed by institutions (Council of Europe, European Commission) formed of people that were not directly elected by European voters. In any case, given that personal data management issues are not a prominent part of the political discourse (even in the EU), I'd be surprised if any of the people in charge were elected because of their position on data protection.

It so happens that European institutions have come up with GDPR, but I don't think it is fair to see it as a conscious choice from EU voters.

> the reality is that EU residents are going to be blocked from a large percentage of the world’s websites

I'd be interested in seeing supporting evidence for this rather surprising claim. I'd conjecture that the "vast majority" is the long tail of small websites who haven't heard about GDPR or don't care about it; so I'm not too worried.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by sambe on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:24AM (#17172253)
Let's stop peddling the misconception that the EU operates significantly differently than any other Western democracy. The civil servants answer ultimately to the MEPs, who are elected. Most people either do not vote or do not engage, as is the case to a lesser extent in their national elections. You can still lobby your MEP when an issue was not part of their platform.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:12PM (#17148945)
"Only a tiny fraction of the companies avoiding EU traffic due to GDPR have any intention of “doing shady stuff with your data”."

Says who? If they weren't doing shady stuff, they wouldn't be pulling out of the EU. The excuses of being complex are just that, excuses.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by downandout on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:22PM (#17149021)
Says who?

Says anyone with common sense. What percentage of sites do you think employ data scientists or would even know where to go to sell your data? Most sites do nothing more than throw GA on their website, and maybe some Adsense. You people decided to paint that as something evil.

That’s your decision to make, but just understand that most of the rest of the world wants no part of $20M potential fines and will simply take their ball and go home. This law will have the net effect of creating two Internets - one for the EU and one for the rest of us.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by eveningcoffee on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:05PM (#17149848)
>Most sites do nothing more than throw GA on their website, and maybe some Adsense

That actually is a problem. GA is a clear violation of everyone privacy.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:54PM (#17149812)
"Says anyone with common sense."

Where "common sense" means "agrees with downandout, not the more traditional definition of "common sense".

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mort96 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:11PM (#17149321)
Well, Instapaper is owned by Pinterest. Pinterest strikes me as a company of such a size that they'd have no problem finding some way to monetize the data gathered from their users.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by rcxdude on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:16AM (#17153899)
Have you seen some of the lists of where your data goes that some sites have posted? It's frankly frightening how far your data gets dispersed after signing up for just one website.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mikekchar on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:28PM (#17150192)
If you get a request today, you've got a month to comply, so in a way you're right. However, it really depends on how big your company is and how little you have prepared. Your absolute minimum is to have a statement that says that you are going to use the data you gather for contract purposes and to list the 3rd parties that you need to send that data to for contract purposes.

But then, if you are using data for other purposes, it's a bit complicated because you'll have to refrain from doing so until you are compliant. It doesn't necessarily have to be shady stuff. Even if you aren't sure if what you are doing is contract basis or not, it can be a pain. It's not necessarily massively difficult, but if you woke up yesterday and thought "OMG! We haven't done GDPR! What are we going to do?", then I can see this.

I've written earlier about how the company I'm working for now has changed what it is doing with data, even though I don't think they were doing anything shady previously. But it's more like, "Do we really want to list a lot of things and piss off the customer?" So now there are heated discussions of what 3 (or whatever other small number) of things we might collect data for because we believe that's the kind of limit that the customer will tolerate.

All of these discussions take time -- especially in a large organisation. And you can see in discussions on HN, there is going to be a large backlash of "Why do we have to do this anyway? Can't we just ignore it?" which wastes a lot more time.

Sounds like they want to be compliant, but are just not ready yet. A miss on their part, but hopefully they will get things in order quickly.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by justboxing on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:44PM (#17149160)
> Your current reaction seems like a huge and unnecessary

It's most likely action based on what their suits (Lawyers) recommended, and not a reaction.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by danpalmer on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:49PM (#17149206)
Possibly, although other lawyers are saying other things, and my understanding of the official guidance suggests this is an overreaction.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by programmarchy on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:08PM (#17150101)
You seem to be presuming guilt before innocence. Most strong advocates of GDPR seem to have this attitude. Perhaps the regulators will, too.

Using that line of reasoning, Pinterest is making a very prudent decision.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by princekolt on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:28PM (#17147418)
You know that you're still liable for European customer's data, even if you're offline, right? Going offline won't change anything. You can't effectively grab the database and run away.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by dmix on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:17PM (#17147953)
It still seems like the safest option given the massive risk this legislation is exposing companies. Especially low margin per user businesses like Instapaper. From The Verge:

> because it’s not entirely clear right now what information residents will request, what format that information needs to be in, how to locate it and package it, and whether new infrastructure needs to be created to manage this request pipeline.

So in the meantime they can at least stop the flow of new data from the EU into their system until they are 'compliant' and have systems in place to deal with the existing large amount of EU users/data they already have.

It makes sense to me to be cautious here, plus it has the dual benefit of drawing attention to the real costs/risks the bill has on smaller firms without teams of lawyers and internal human resources (developers, CSRs) to deal with the new obligations imposed on them.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Hamuko on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:27PM (#17148082)
>It still seems like the safest option given the massive risk this legislation is exposing companies.

The safest option was actually to comply with the GDPR during the two years it has been in force now. I refuse to believe that the changes required were impossible to perform in two years.

I'd love to know when exactly did Instapaper start looking into the GDPR.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by dmix on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:33PM (#17148144)
The founder has said that he underestimated the amount of work it was going to take. Anyone who has ever worked on software knows how this stuff happens. You don't truly know how long something is going to take until you dig into the hairy details of implementation.

Plus there are still tons of unknown variables at play with GDPR... even among companies who did spend sufficient time beforehand, as I quoted from the article above. So additionally, the non-obvious requirements further makes the underestimation make sense.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by greedo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:18PM (#17148508)
Marco Arment is the founder of Instapaper. He sold it after building it into one of the first successful iOS applications/services.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ianamartin on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:03PM (#17150085)
The founder hasn't said a damn thing about it.

The requirements are clear enough to figure out a solution in the last couple of years. What takes time is if you're trying to skate as close as you possibly can to the legal line and not go over it.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mbesto on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:11PM (#17150341)
> The founder has said that he underestimated the amount of work it was going to take.

Source?

Pinterest which owns Instapaper (2 years ago mind you!) has raised $1.47B to date. There's no legitimate excuse here.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:21PM (#17148524)
If there is so much ambiguity and interpretations what kind of manager would risk getting into doing such project if a risk of failure is equal to not doing it at all?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by dmix on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:15AM (#17150799)
Courts are not black/white in interpretations of law. Demonstrating you put significant effort into being compliant is not for nothing. Plus you can't really figure it out until you try. Especially with something as complex as this and how the implications of the law will be different for different companies.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:01AM (#17151529)
I don't think that makes a difference, perhaps it depends on the country. Some EU countries are hostile towards entrepreneurs and wrong action or inaction would get the same treatment.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ucaetano on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:49PM (#17150028)
What would the regulators do? Block the service?

But that is one part which is confusing to me, from the UK ICO:

The GDPR applies to processing carried out by organisations operating within the EU. It also applies to organisations outside the EU that offer goods or services to individuals in the EU.

Additionally, the GDPR does not apply to actions taken before and during the transition period (which ends now).

In this case, Instapaper does not offer goods or services to individuals in the EU. It actively blocks any user inside the EU.

Does that mean that Instapaper is no longer subject in any way to the GDPR?

In other words, if you had a company that had operations in the EU, but left the continent 2 years ago, and no longer has any activities with any EU individuals, does the GDPR suddenly apply to you?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by vertex-four on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:44AM (#17150681)
If you continue to hold data from EU residents, it’s somewhat likely that the GDPR applies, or that a court will decide it does some way down the line. If you employed a competent lawyer for about an hour they’d ask you why you’re storing that data if you’re never going to use it again, given the risks.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ucaetano on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:46PM (#17155473)
Holding the data or not is irrelevant, the tricky part is compliance.

If the GDPR applies to you, you need to hire a DPO based in Europe, as well as having a EU contact that will be responsible for any fees that you incur.

If you did business in the EU but no longer does, do you now have to hire a DPO in the EU and have a local contact responsible for any liabilities?

Managing the data is the easy part.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by vertex-four on Saturday May 26, 2018 @05:36PM (#17164371)
There’s no obvious reason why you’d have to, provided you delete all data related to EU residents.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ucaetano on Monday May 28, 2018 @11:22PM (#17176234)
You didn't read GDPR. Deleting isn't enough, if GDPR applies to you, you need to follow all the compliance requirements, including hiring people, providing proof of deletion if investigated, etc.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by aeorgnoieang on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:49PM (#17148773)
This is a good point I haven't run into before (which is itself frightening). So what could they do instead? Could they retain the actual 'read later' content, associated with their EU users, but delete all of their own personal data for now?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by princekolt on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:04PM (#17148890)
Not much. If you're not compliant, you're not compliant. However, that's not the end of the world right there. GDPR takes ill-intent into account, and it also requires warnings before any punishment is applied. They should instead have started working on compliance before they actually did.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by EpicEng on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:57PM (#17148833)
Yes, I'm sure their legal team missed that one...
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by tomatotomato37 on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:30PM (#17155996)
Just because a law is written to apply to effectively the whole planet, doesn't mean it can be enforced as such. I just don't see the current US administration complying with a EU charge against one of its companies that did go the blocking route, let alone any of the shadier countries that host companies in violation
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by tathougies on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:26AM (#17154596)
Instapaper isn’t based in the eu. The eu can’t prosecute individuals on foreign soil. I mean they can try, but good luck getting anyone to show up
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by abiox on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:48PM (#17150023)
based on my understanding, i think if you're not marketing to eu visitors, data doesn't fall under the gdpr. does the gdpr retroactively apply to data from the past?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by justincormack on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:36PM (#17148169)
Presumably they deleted all the EU data just now...
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by grey-area on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:56PM (#17148825)
Let me know if you have any questions...

Which parts of GDPR do you think you're in violation of?

Why do you think removing access for users currently in the EU puts you in the clear legally?

What are you doing with European users data currently, have you deleted it all?

A lot of other companies have navigated the changes to the law without significant changes to their service or privacy policy, just by tightening up how they hold data, and making sure they are clear on permissions with users.

Are you sure you have good legal advice on this?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by orangecat on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:34PM (#17149961)
Which parts of GDPR do you think you're in violation of?

Answering those questions in a public forum would be extremely foolish. ("Do you know why I pulled you over?")

A lot of other companies have navigated the changes to the law without significant changes to their service or privacy policy

And how many of them are actually in compliance?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by grey-area on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:25AM (#17152114)
Answering those questions in a public forum would be extremely foolish

Perhaps asking for questions was foolish?

And how many of them are actually in compliance?

If you're not in the business of selling customer data to third parties, it's not very hard to comply, just requires some discipline on how data is stored and who it is shared with, and a point of contact for enquiries about data.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by apricot13 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:34AM (#17143306)
my question - why am I finding out about this on HN and not through the email supposedly sent out?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kevingrahl on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:36PM (#17149109)
I did not receive any email notification about this either, just double checked all Spam folders..
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Animats on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:12PM (#17150349)
You had two years to get ready. Why wasn't this announced months ago.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mantas on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:27AM (#17142137)
Are you hard-banning or is it possible to use it over VPN or in some other way? Asking for a friend!
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:29AM (#17142402)
The ban will be an IP-based ban for IPs from countries in the EU.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Hamuko on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:37PM (#17148174)
And how hard are you going to be dropping EU users' data?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jazoom on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:45AM (#17143037)
I'm curious what an example of a "hard ban" might be?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mantas on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:58AM (#17143113)
Freezing account if it seems to be owned by EU citizen? GDPR applies to all EU citizens regardless of their location after all.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by latk on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:07AM (#17144699)
GDPR applies if (1) the Controller or a Processor is “established” in the EU, or if (2) the Subject is in the EU. Citizenship doesn't matter, and geoblocking is the legally correct solution. As an example: U.S. tourists on a trip to Paris are protected by the GDPR, but a Polish expat in California is not. (See Art. 3 GDPR https://gdpr-info.eu/art-3-gdpr/)
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kevingrahl on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:43PM (#17149152)
I really don’t think your example holds up.

> US tourists on a trip to Paris are protected by the GDPR

That’s not entirely correct. They’d fall under GDPR if they do business with a company doing business in the EU (eg by buying something off of amazon and sending it to their Paris hotel address. They would however not benefit from GDPR if they were to order something from amazon but sending it to their US address instead.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mantas on Thursday May 24, 2018 @01:51PM (#17146471)
Huh. This is interesting. People were talking it'd be the other way. That EU citizens would be guarded no matter where they're.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by typicalbender on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:30PM (#17148124)
That's incorrect.

"If the Data Subject, moves out of the EU border [...], or goes on holiday then their personal data processed under these circumstances is not covered by the GDPR and they are no longer a Data Subject in the context of the GDPR, unless the organisation is “established” in the EU"

Source: https://cybercounsel.co.uk/data-subjects/

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by johnaoss on Thursday May 24, 2018 @02:38PM (#17146971)
I'm sure that's what the policy makers originally wanted (protecting the rights of all EU citizens). That being said, it would be nigh-on-impossible to implement.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by detuur on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:40PM (#17147556)
Websites would run into the same situation as banks: anytime you open an account at most banks in Europe and probably around the world, they specifically make sure that you're not American, because then they have to comply with American laws if they don't want to get blacklisted.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by shkkmo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:07PM (#17148910)
How is geoblocking a solution? How does it absolve the company of their compliance obligations? Does using a VPN mean that Data Subjects in the EU are not covered by GDPR?

Is geoblocking sufficient on its own to show that the Controller/Processor is not doing business in the EU? Even when the Controller/Processor still provides localization to EU languages?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by joering2 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:54PM (#17148319)
Don't feel bad. The law is ridiculous and most startups cannot even afford salary for another programmer not to mention GDPR-law compliance officer. Hopefully if enough services get interrupted, bureaucrats at EU will rethink the law.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by orf on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:40PM (#17149744)
If you believe GDPR requires you to hire a dedicated compliance officer then you don't understand or have not read the law you're so vehemently against.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by sveme on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:07PM (#17148422)
So which part of the law is ridiculous? Disclaimer: I believe the principles that are applied within the law, data autonomy, data ownership, usage-binding of data etc., are sound. And just because people have aggregated any data on people that they could get to better manipulate them into buying crap for so long that it‘s hard to change track today, doesn‘t mean it‘s wrong for lawmakers to enforce parting ways with the past.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:17PM (#17148498)
- IPs are personal private infromation

- You need opt-in consent for all (ad) cookies, including non-tracking ones. Basically,advertising is optional in EU sites as of today.

- I could argue the right to download your data is superfluous, mostly because it creates potential holes for data leaks/phishing etc.

The law is confusing "privacy" with "invisibility".

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:09PM (#17148924)
"- IPs are personal private infromation"

IPs combined with other user data could be PII.

"- You need opt-in consent for all (ad) cookies, including non-tracking ones. Basically, advertising is optional in EU sites as of today."

Wrong. You need opt-in consent for non personalized ads, but this can be the "soft consent" type where you only present the "Accept" button. Advertising is no more optional tomorrow than it was today.

"- I could argue the right to download your data is superfluous, mostly because it creates potential holes for data leaks/phishing etc."

Knowing what you have on me is not superfluous; it's my data.

Seriously, the FUD around this law is getting tiresome.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by davorak on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:21AM (#17150592)
> IPs combined with other user data could be PII.

1) Bob signs up for a service and is logged

2) Bob than asks for his account to be deleted. Account details are deleted, but the ip logs are retained.

3) Bob signs back up for a new account allowing the data processor to make the link from his new account to his ip old logs with the first account.

This seems like a likely violation, if so you would have to treat ip address like personal information.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by boomlinde on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:19AM (#17151356)
The personal information here is the IP-Bob tuple, not the IP on its own. Bob might as well be assigned a new address from DHCP on a daily basis. His friends might be using his address. He might have used the address of some public network in the first place. All or these are pretty likely scenarios. The IP is only interesting given the context of who uses it and when, so as to separate Bob from Alice, and Bob's favorite cafe and Bob's workplace from Bob's home, and to figure out if Bob is ever visiting Alice.

So if Bob asks for his personal information to be cleared and the system leaves Bob-IP tuples behind, it clearly didn't do what he told it to do.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by davorak on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:30AM (#17154042)
That is playing dice while dealing with potentially personal information though right?

It depends on Bob using DHCP, that his DHCP switches often enough, and there are enough people on the same network that the link can not be made.

The above is not always true, other mitigating factors are not always true. Which seems to make some of IP logs personal information. Or at least you are safest if you treat it that way.

I am basing some of my reasoning off an article that I was pointed to earlier: https://www.whitecase.com/publications/alert/court-confirms-...

Where, to my understanding, IP address are considered personal information only if you can link it to some other identifying info.

I think a regulator is unlikely to go after a company for not deleting IP logs in the current climate. As far as I can tell GDPR gives them the power to however.

Until there is some case/enforcement history it is understandable if people are cautious.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:54AM (#17151496)
- Ips in general are not bound to some specific person. It's only because laws require that ISPs keep PII allocation data that they become personally identifying. Perhaps it would be easier to plug that leak right there.

- ah, well google suggests you ask consent even for content-based ads

- 99% of the sites show you what they have on you when you use them. The provision could be to have a separate download page when that is not the case. If every business must have an unauthenticated download page, it becomes easier to get other people's data via phishing.

its not fud. this is the internet. lets talk again in a few months.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Tomte on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:24PM (#17150385)
Advertising can be done without cookies. It‘s a simple <img> tag.

Unless you mean user-tracking advertising.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:45AM (#17151460)
i mean content-based (still requires cookies)
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:24PM (#17148550)
Then you'll have all sorts of disputes for example someone could claim their cat stepped on a touchscreen and consented without the user knowledge or someone consented whilst being completely drunk - such consent is not valid. That means potentially companies are keeping the data illegally thinking they comply.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:28PM (#17148575)
i don't follow, do you mean that's a possible scenario? That's the last thing you need to worry about yet. I expect first random emails from hackers demanding coins for 'not reporting you' in the first awkward month.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by LoSboccacc on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:07PM (#17148911)
the weirdest scenario is if people inadvertently leak medical data on a unsolicited email.

"I've a motor impairment do your hotel have accessible rooms?"

say you have your hosted email system, now you're in a huge mess.

people downvoting this should really hear a lawyer about gdpr.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by olivierduval on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:51AM (#17153143)
email is not covered by GDPR but by the local communications acts. It will be some new EU laws in the next 2 or 3 years... So there's no problem in THAT case. But if this email is copy/pasted in a reservation system THEN it might be covered by GDPR.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:45PM (#17148737)
There is also a thing when user closes consent popup and the site won't redirect to invalid ip address. I have seen plenty of sites where you can close the consent popup and continue to use the site - that means they collect your data without your consent. Grotesque.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:49PM (#17148772)
how do you know they collect your data?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by merinowool on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:59AM (#17151515)
Because they say that in the popup.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by celticninja on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:46AM (#17151204)
You don't need a new employee, just someone who is assigned the task to deal with queries that come in. For a small start-up this is not likely to amount to many requests, and even then the requests from the public first go through the regulator. So many requests will be weeded out at that stage with the aim of reducing the burden on businesses, only requiring them to act when the regulator has identified a breach. At this point they have to fix it, if they don't fix it, or don't try to fix it (fizimg it is usually by deleting the customer data) then they are open to prosecution. If they fix it the regulator isn't then going to seek huge fines, they are aimed at non-compliance firms who have no intention of complying (e.g because it is their entire business model).
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:06PM (#17148904)
If that's the case, then perhaps that startup shouldn't be sucking up all the user data it can.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by anonymouz on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:01PM (#17149275)
Did you delete all EU users' data?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mtaksrud on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:32PM (#17149082)
Maybe something like this will be of help to you https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/resources-and-support/d... ?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by icedchai on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:06PM (#17149851)
You could've just done absolutely nothing. That would've avoided service disruption.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by redwood on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:11PM (#17149869)
Extremely bizarre move frankly. I assume this was some kind or vigilante decision rather than based on recommendation of counsel.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Angostura on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:04AM (#17142013)
> Let me know if you have any questions...

It sounds as if you're unwilling to talk about the issues that you're facing. So what can you say? The only reason I can think of that you can't say is that are trying to get some infrastructure suppliers to be compliant and those talks are confidential. Correct?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:08AM (#17142036)
The email we sent to EU users (quoted in linked article) has the important details regarding the service interruption in the EU.

Additionally, I can say that our privacy policy is concise, clear, and accurate with respect to the types of information we collect and how the data is used: https://www.instapaper.com/privacy

If you have other specific questions, I will do my best to answer them.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Angostura on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:33AM (#17142163)
Well, as The Verge says in the article: 'While we don’t know exactly what’s holding up Instapaper'

I'm naturally curious as to what's holding up Instapaper.

As you say, your Privacy Policy is very good, other than the disclaimer that says 'we may pass your personal data to others - who knows what they do with it eh?'. I imagine that this is the issue which is holding you up.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:33AM (#17142433)
The scope of work for GDPR was underestimated by me, we were not able to complete that work for the deadline on Friday, and this was the required alternative.

We are working very hard to minimize the service interruption.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Dayshine on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:22PM (#17147349)
Have you received genuine legal advice that recommended that you shut down business instead of continuing to work towards compliance?

The agencies that can enforce the GPDR want you to be compliant, not to fine you... If you're actually working towards compliance past evidence shows they won't fine you.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by sdhgaiojfsa on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:40PM (#17148202)
I've heard this line a lot, but even as a government loving liberal it doesn't sound very compelling to me. The law says, comply or face fines up to 4% of global revenue. It doesn't say, "make a best effort to comply, or face fines up to 4% of global revenue." I'm very reluctant to trust people who can fine me for that much money that they won't do so. This is especially the case because it appears to some of us foreigners that the EU particularly loves to fine foreign companies for large amounts despite what appears, from our perspective, to be a good faith attempt that to comply with the law.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Dayshine on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:28AM (#17152918)
https://gdpr-info.eu/art-83-gdpr/

>2When deciding whether to impose an administrative fine and deciding on the amount of the administrative fine in each individual case due regard shall be given to the following:

> any action taken by the controller or processor to mitigate the damage suffered by data subjects;

>the degree of cooperation with the supervisory authority, in order to remedy the infringement and mitigate the possible adverse effects of the infringement;

>the manner in which the infringement became known to the supervisory authority, in particular whether, and if so to what extent, the controller or processor notified the infringement;

>where measures referred to in Article 58(2) have previously been ordered against the controller or processor concerned with regard to the same subject-matter, compliance with those measures;

>any other aggravating or mitigating factor applicable to the circumstances of the case, such as financial benefits gained, or losses avoided, directly or indirectly, from the infringement.

So, a whole bunch of very explicit things that are to be used when deciding if whether to impose a fine (at all).

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Tomte on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:49PM (#17148283)
The EU regularly fines domestic companies huge amounts in anti-trust enforcement.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mtaksrud on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:04PM (#17148884)
True that the text doesn’t say this, but several of the privacy authorities in the different jurisdictions in Europe have been stating this publicly in interviews. The last one I saw was the ICO in the UK today on BBC Click saying exactly this...
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by sdhgaiojfsa on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:08PM (#17149597)
The text is what matters. You cannot defend yourself in court with the content of interviews.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by markus92 on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:28AM (#17151646)
Actually, you can in Europe. Context of law is more important than letter of law, as opposed to the US.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by krageon on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:51AM (#17151743)
Of course you can. Otherwise what would be the point of them in the first place?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mtaksrud on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:31PM (#17149072)
...and maybe you should take a look at something like this https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/resources-and-support/d...
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mtaksrud on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:15PM (#17148970)
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by celticninja on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:45PM (#17149175)
I would be interested in seeing examples of large fines that have been handed out to business by the EU that don't first of all meet the general conditions mentioned in this article.

https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by downandout on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:47PM (#17149188)
The agencies that can enforce the GPDR want you to be compliant, not to fine you.

Says who? The only perfectly clear parts of the GDPR revolve around the massive fines.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ggg9990 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:24AM (#17150604)
The EU actually loves levying huge fines against rich US tech companies. Why do you think they prefer compliance to fines?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Angostura on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:35AM (#17151682)
Well, let's take a famous example. The €4.2bn fine given to Google in 2017 for abuse of its market position in pushing its own shopping results.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/jun/27/google-brac...

Shocking stuff.

Except the Commission actually gave Google quite detailed advice over 5 years earlier about what it needed to do to be compliant.

https://www.ft.com/content/564a284a-a334-11e1-8f34-00144feab...

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by pmontra on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:52PM (#17148300)
Shutting down means you're probably not gathering any further data but what if one of your EU users sends you mail now asking for all the data you have about him/her? How does the shut down protects you about that?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by celticninja on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:44PM (#17149159)
The law says you need to work toward a solution, it isn't a cliff edge thing where you are immediately legally liable. Are you just not wanting to risk it or do you not read the law in this way?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by x0x0 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:33PM (#17147461)
The GDPR fines based on global revenues.

I'd bet Pinterest is very risk averse given how little money they make from Instapaper.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kevingrahl on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:45PM (#17149174)
Global revenue of the parent company!
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by yoz-y on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:26AM (#17142133)
Weirdly enough I am an European citizen, haven't received the mail and the service is working.

Not complaining, I prefer it this way. Hope you will sort the issues quickly.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:30AM (#17142415)
The ban will be IP-based for IPs in EU countries, and it goes into effect at approximately 2PM Pacific Time.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kingosticks on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:48AM (#17142230)
Me too. And I can see I am definitely subscribed to "account update" emails. I'm not sure how they would decide if I was European or not, can't see a tick box for that in the profile page.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by pkaye on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:35PM (#17148653)
Where are you located?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kingosticks on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:31PM (#17149075)
The UK.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by balls187 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:06AM (#17150530)
Thanks to Brexit, there is going to be a similar GDPR law for the UK.

Interesting times these are.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kingosticks on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:55AM (#17151247)
Why is brexit relevant?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by balls187 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:59PM (#17200203)
Post brexit, GDPR will no longer apply to the UK.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kingosticks on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:08PM (#17200298)
Right. So without brexit there is this and with brexit there will be something very similar. Thank god for brexit.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by balls187 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:44PM (#17224154)
Just got back from a road trip throughout Ireland, and occupied Ireland. I wonder what will happen to those two countries post brexit.

As I refer to my first comment: interesting times.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bo1024 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:48PM (#17150025)
Ironically, I am unable to read that page without enabling javascript for a third-party domain (amazonaws.com)...
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:05PM (#17147802)
I'm sorry, I don't buy it.

(1) you still hold the data, you are still required to comply with the law and cutting off access does not change that one bit.

(2) the period for a response is long enough that once you would receive requests you could handle them in time even if you processed them manually.

(3) you have been - or should have been - aware of all this for a very long time, either you failed at estimating the impact of the law or you do not know what you have or you changed strategies internally recently and now you're not going to be ready in time because you started way too late.

So in all, all you've managed to achieve with this action is to get the spotlight on you, and it is a 100% certainty that at least Instapaper will be solidly violating the GDPR come tomorrow.

If I were in your shoes I would use my designated representative to contact the authorities for guidance after explaining in detail what the problem is before I would let my end users pay the price for my own incompetence.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by pembrook on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:24PM (#17148055)
Last I heard Instapaper has 3 employees.

Some smaller companies and lower-profile groups within big companies are going to need more time to sort this out, and some may decide it's not worth the risk of the massive fines no matter how compliant they think they are and will block European users. Nobody knows how aggressive regulators will be in enforcing this so far, nor is their any precedent for how the law will be interpreted by actual courts. Calling people incompetent isn't going to change that.

This is one of the negative consequences of enacting complex regulation targeted mostly at giants like Facebook and Google and then applying it to every side project and business in the entire world no matter how big or small. Sorry.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:26PM (#17148074)
Nonsense. Instapaper was acquired by Pinterest.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by pembrook on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:35PM (#17148163)
And how much revenue does the Instapaper service generate for Pinterest?

Lower profile groups within big companies are probably most likely to shut off their services to European users because they have the cautious legal departments of the large company without the important profit center designation which would make compliance a priority.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:40PM (#17148211)
> And how much revenue does the Instapaper service generate for Pinterest?

Who cares? That's not a factor in whether or not you should comply with the law.

> Lower profile groups within big companies are probably most likely to shut off their services to European users because they have the cautious legal departments of the large company without the important profit center designation which would make compliance a priority.

Well, that may be their strategy but it won't work because it is the company that is violating the law, not the lower profile group.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by LoSboccacc on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:58PM (#17148850)
> That's not a factor in whether or not you should comply with the law.

speaking generally here, you know laws aren't always right? we had plenty bad laws to draw from to challenge this particular point, from racial to abortion laws.

gdpr isn't as draconian as these but still has plenty trash in it between the vague wording, the moving target 'state of the art' represents and the weird requirements and absurd implications of the 'right to be forgotten'.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:04PM (#17148891)
What's that got to do with it?

It's the law, it was created by a democratically elected body. Racial and abortion laws are on a different plane altogether, and are not typically the playground of globally acting corporations.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Kiro on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:49PM (#17148282)
> it is the company that is violating the law, not the lower profile group.

I work in a company that was acquired and we're still our own legal entity. Would our owner be affected if we violate GDPR?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jimnotgym on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:15PM (#17148491)
That would depend on what kind of ownership structure you have. Do they exercise management control, have seats on the board etc?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:53PM (#17148311)
No, in that case the owner is just a shareholder. But if the original legal entity no longer exists (which I believe is the case with Instapaper) then it doesn't matter that you've been acquired, you are now part of the mothership.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by ryanwaggoner on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:36AM (#17150641)
But if the original legal entity no longer exists (which I believe is the case with Instapaper)

Unlikely. "Instapaper Holdings, Inc." is right in their footer.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zitterbewegung on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:18PM (#17150369)
So a LLC with owned by a larger company would that allow for the owner to be a shareholder ?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by product50 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:40PM (#17149745)
Weren't you the one previously saying that don't panic (https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria) because of GDPR back in the day? And now you are advocating that they should have already complied with GDPR given its impact!

Make up your mind.

And this is exactly why this is such a shitshow. Stop attacking people who haven't complied because small developers have other things rather than trying to figure out whether they have to redo their logs if a user asks their data to be deleted. This is almost bullying behavior.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:46AM (#17151203)
> Weren't you the one previously saying that don't panic (https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria) because of GDPR back in the day?

Yep.

> And now you are advocating that they should have already complied with GDPR given its impact!

Obviously yes, because today the law becomes enforceable. Not having done the required work is just plain dumb.

> Make up your mind.

I made up my mind well over a year ago, spent the time required to be compliant (a couple of days) and that was that. Instapaper being as small as it is would not have had to spend more time than that unless they are doing something they shouldn't be doing, are unable to plan or changed tactics in the last 2 days. After all, if they weren't going to make the deadline they had a very long time to announce that, instead they announce it the day before the law becomes enforceable. That's just not ok. At a minimum they should have had their export facility up and running.

> Stop attacking people who haven't complied because small developers have other things rather than trying to figure out whether they have to redo their logs if a user asks their data to be deleted.

I suspect you are in the same boat?

> This is almost bullying behavior.

Right. Well, sorry, it really isn't, it's the perspective of someone who has been in business for a very long time and who feels that the GDPR addresses some fairly urgent matters. Companies have been running roughshod over users' privacy rights for decades and it is one of the worst things to come out of the internet. The level of tracking and data brokering that is going on is utterly disgusting.

If you weren't doing anything you shouldn't be doing the GDPR is going to be a pretty simple affair if you're a small company. Larger companies will have some more work but have more resources.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by always_good on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:22PM (#17149904)
He's also the same guy who said, and I quote, "compliance is easy, just read the law."

It surprises me how much this community tolerates such combative cluelessness.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:50AM (#17151226)
Have you read the law?

Did you start working on compliance in a timely manner or did you become aware of this a few weeks ago?

Does your company have a clue about what it is doing in general?

Do you take a user centric approach to data ownership?

If those are all 'yes' then compliance is easy. If you don't care, do illegal stuff, are clueless or don't care about your users then compliance is going to be hard, that's what the law intends because those companies should change their ways.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by nickpp on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:35AM (#17150881)
His posts were clearly politically motivated, zealot-type propaganda. Either self-interest or useful-idiot.

For some reason he is such a fan of this legislation that he is willing to overlook its glaring problems. No objectivity there, I am afraid.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:55AM (#17151250)
> His posts were clearly politically motivated, zealot-type propaganda.

Oh my. Terribly sorry for putting up a political manifesto.

> Either self-interest or useful-idiot.

Take your pick. No third options? Such as a genuine desire to take some of the heat off for SMEs, of which I own several and participate in several others?

> For some reason he is such a fan of this legislation that he is willing to overlook its glaring problems.

Yes, I'm a fan of this legislation. I also was a fan of its predecessor and it's a joy to see companies that don't have their house in order make all kinds of panicked moves. I have a pretty good behind the scenes view of what goes on with respect to privacy abuse by corporations due to the nature of my work. Those companies that do illegal stuff, don't give a damn about their users and that in general are clueless (and which in turn increases the chances of their online properties being compromised) will be the ones that run into the 'glaring problems' The only thing that I see as troublesome with the law is the lack of reciprocity and enforcement across borders. The EU picked a complex and for really small companies expensive way to resolve that and that's something that I see as a real issue.

> No objectivity there, I am afraid.

I think you mean to say you don't agree with me.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by guelo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:18PM (#17147967)
I don't know if (1) is true but the data was collected under previous laws. In my opinion laws like this should not be retroactive. Retroactive laws, especially when affecting billions of dollars of commerce, are unfair and draconian.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by 317070 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:23PM (#17148041)
It is not retroactive, the law has been there for 2 years, becoming _active_ in 40 minutes. Secondly, it is not the collection of data, it is the storing of data. So if you store the data without user confirmation in 40 minutes, there might be a problem. The action which is the problem is the storing of private data.

There is nothing retroactive here.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by freeone3000 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:02PM (#17148383)
Is three year old data covered? Sounds retroactive to me.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by 317070 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:39PM (#17150237)
If you bought designer drugs 10 years ago, the act of buying was legal, even though storing it today no longer is. Same here, collecting it or using it 10 years ago might have been legal. Storing it today is not. You might be confused which action is covered by the law, and that action is "storing". You can decide to stop doing that action today, so it is not retroactive at all.

I don't really see where the age of the data you store comes into play.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:34PM (#17148642)
Yes, three year old data was already covered by the DPD.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:20PM (#17148000)
The law has been on the books for two years, it just wasn't enforced and for a long time before that there was another law with much the same effect. So even if the data was collected under previous laws there is not much that would convince me that denying the users access to their data or to the legally mandated data life-cycle features is the right thing to do.

In fact that attitude goes exactly against what the law is trying to achieve in the first place.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by fiter on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:59PM (#17149559)
> In fact that attitude goes exactly against what the law is trying to achieve in the first place.

I think this is an important realization for any regulator.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by mikeklaas on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:08PM (#17148425)
The law doesn't make it illegal to have collected the data in the past. However, it introduces new rights for people for which you have collected data. I don't think this is unfair
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by outside2344 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:32PM (#17148142)
The general global legal principal here is that you can't charge someone for something that happened before the law came into effect.

So you are not correct on #1.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:34PM (#17148157)
The law has been in effect for two years. And before that one there was another one.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by nickodell on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:42PM (#17148711)
>The law has been in effect for two years.

"It was adopted on 14 April 2016, and after a two-year transition period, becomes enforceable on 25 May 2018."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regula...

>And before that one there was another one.

Yes, but that was a different law. It required different things.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:45PM (#17148739)
The law came into effect on the 14th of April. The 'enforceable' does not mean it comes into a effect, it means that regulators have their powers unlocked to go after offenders.

> Yes, but that was a different law. It required different things.

It actually required a lot of the same things, but because companies decided to ignore it it was revised.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by Hamuko on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:33PM (#17148148)
The regulation came into effect two years ago and I don't really believe that Instapaper hasn't been processing data for the past two years.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by davidgould on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:48PM (#17150269)
By that standard, if you had purchased a child porn magazine in the 1970s when it was legal to do so, you would be in the clear if the police searched your house and found it. I am not a lawyer, but that doesn’t seem likely.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:38PM (#17148681)
> will be solidly violating the GDPR come tomorrow

how do you know that? i mean technically he says they re violating it today, just like we all did the past 2 years because it wasnt enforceable. what changes with their ban tomorrow?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:44PM (#17148728)
That they are still violating it tomorrow and they are giving their users an excellent excuse to contact the regulators because they cut off communications. This is about as dumb as it comes.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kodablah on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:02PM (#17149281)
I was under the impression that of you don't do business with EU users, you are not subject to the rules. This seems like the only reasonable way to not do business with EU customers. Other thoughts aside, if they wanted to stop doing business in the EU, how should they?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:28PM (#17149411)
> Other thoughts aside, if they wanted to stop doing business in the EU, how should they?

Erase everything.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kodablah on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:21PM (#17149899)
I suppose for most thinking rationally, it seems like "stop doing business in the EU" is different than "make it like you've never done business in the EU". Taken to its conclusion, which Instapaper surely won't, it's not going to be easy to punish a business that has cut ties with the EU because of what they collected before. Granted it appears that with the law, like its predecessors, practicality of reasonable enforcement takes a backseat to intent.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:05AM (#17153802)
The rational approach to legislation is to make a (timely) effort to comply.

When you're told the highway near your house has a new speedlimit you can either obey the speed limit, use a detour (which will still be slower on account of it being longer) or you can take your car off the road in huff.

The first one is the only solution that makes sense.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kodablah on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:10PM (#17156410)
If we're going with these analogies, there are other approaches if you disagree with the speed limit. You might protest the speed limit if you lived there (hopefully without being berated while you do so) or if you don't live there you might avoid the place with unreasonable speed limits.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:47PM (#17148752)
sounds like a technical reason to me. what provision of gdpr does it break? contact the regulator about what?
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:48PM (#17148764)
The ability of users to access their data, to edit their data, to delete their data and to export their data.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by zerostar07 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:53PM (#17148798)
is there a requirement that this ability is 24/7/365?

I mean , knowing GDPR , i would guess at best the provision would be something like "a reasonably long amount of time but not long enough to be unreasonable based on appropriate considerations of data subject's patience"

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by jacquesm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:02PM (#17148870)
It certainly isn't a provision in the law that if you feel that you won't be able to deal with your users legitimate requests that you have the option to lock them out entirely.

I can imagine something to the effect of stopping further gathering of data (to stop digging the hole deeper), to give your users the option to request what is their right through some kind of form and to park those requests until you're done with the implementation and in the meantime give them continued access.

After all, the law already has a provision in it that you have 30 days to respond, and another 2 months after that if you are for some reason technically incapable and need an extension.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by yani on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:28PM (#17150397)
Epic fail