I highly doubt this decision was made lightly and was probably informed by actual legal professionals with knowledge of the regulators in question and not the 3rd party opinion of some guy on the internet who "feels like its not that big of a deal."
Now would be a good time to do just that, and if the actual legal professionals thought it was a good idea to ban EU citizens but keep their data then maybe they should get better lawyers because that certainly won't work.
If I had an instapaper account it would be interesting to submit a GDPR request tomorrow, and see what kind of reply I got. Now I don't, but I'm sure there are plenty of other interested people around.
For most small business and startups this is no big deal as 1 or 2 reports to the regulator isn't going to trigger anything. For those companies of a certain size, the regulator might take note of 1,000 reports in the first week. I imagine some of those will have the regulator check if they have had a self-report from the company for non-compliance. Maybe then an email to colleagues at other ICOs across Europe.
In other words, the first to think they were GDPR compliant might have had to redo a ton of work to adjust to more recent interpretations.
And let's not forget, for large orgs with complex infrastructure, this is a behemoth of an effort. There's been year long projects in the two large tech companies I've had insight to since.
And while I'm at it, let me comment on the frequently expressed notion of "if you've respected your users in the past, you'll be fine!". Just to pick one counter argument: the right to be forgotten. That can only be implemented thoroughly and in the way the users expect it to work (ie. delete everything but what you're legally required to retain) by finding a way to connect all user data so you know what to drop if need be. That is exactly the kind of action that's caused public outrage at big tech to begin with and it's not only potentially a huge effort, it also increases risk of abuse.
This all being said, I still think GDPR is a good idea at least in principle. And believe it or not, while everyone around me is really of compliance work, GDPR seems widely considered a good idea in principle across engineering in big tech.
There we have to disagree. It's not like this is something new and untried.
GDPR is a development from long-standing, and now very well understood, Data Protection. The legislation seems mainly intended to modernise some of the definitions and scope (eg adding biometrics to PII), catch some newer practices, and make very plain and explicit that it doesn't just apply to EU companies.
In 1996 and 97 in the run up to the 1998 Data Protection Directive I recall a couple of common confusions and misunderstandings. Nothing like the ridiculously poor and simply incorrect reporting we have for this.
Any large org should have been fully compliant with DPA for years. They have to add extra mechanisms for explicit opt-in or deletion and get a little less time to retrieve full data and can't charge. That doesn't seem to need a "behemoth of effort", but not to say it's necessarily entirely trivial.
In other words they survived DPA with no apparent effect, yet it's >80% of GDPR with the same definitions. No one should be iteratively fumbling toward an unclear target at all. Even reading the UK ICO's old guide to 1998 Data Protection from a few years ago gets you most of the way there including understanding personal data.
There are companies, OP being one (a subsidiary of Pinterest) that have presence in the EU and are essentially playing chicken with the regulators. Blocking users but keeping their data is not compliance, nor are dialogs telling users you plan to carry on as normal. Companies do not do this with the IRS because they would be afraid of the consequences.
And that's only GDPR. We've had PECR (in UK) since 2002 and DPA since 1995.
Do they share reading habits with multiple third parties perhaps?
So, unless you’re saying that “Pinterest’s site reliability team can’t answer question 192 about how user data is deleted from the incident management system logs when an event is traced” is a “huge red flag” then you are exaggerating the issue.
https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria
EU agencies would prefer compliance over fines and would work with businesses to help them. As the article suggests, prosecution/fines will come when all other avenues are exhausted not the starting point.
Let's be a little self-conscious here, shall we?
Of all the articles on HN that discuss the GDPR that I've read, I've found one that you didn't contribute to and your contributions never show an "understanding of laws based on the text of the law". For instance, you have consistently claimed that there will be 28 (btw, not 27) different interpretations of the law, completely disregarding entire articles devoted to the consistent application of the Regulation- which, as a regulation, does not need to be made into local law and is applicable across the bloc.
You are clearly on a warpath against the GDPR, which is perfectly fine of course; yet at the same time you accuse jacquesm of being a "tremendous fan of the GDPR". If you can express your opinion despite having an agenda, so can he - and he seems to be much better informed of the law than you are.
Edit: Just to clarify, I don't have some axe to grind against you. You're one of the few users whose handle I recognise because your comments in GDPR threads stand out so much in their fervour and because there are so many of them.
With regard to your claim that it will not be subject to unique interpretations in each country within the EU, that simply isn’t true. Each country will have its own enforcement agencies. They’ll enforce it in different ways, and to different degrees. Since this regulation is so vague, it simply isn’t possible that they will all interpret and enforce it in the same way.
You seem to be in Jacque’s corner, claiming that our new self-appointed privacy overlords will be perfectly coordinated and “good natured”. As someone with quite a bit of experience dealing with government agencies, I can tell you that few of those that seek out relatively low-paying government jobs where the primary perk is having power over other people are “good natured”. There will be abuses.
The good news is that D-Day is here, and now we can all stop arguing and watch to see whose predictions come true.
Your argument seems to be that a police state where the authorities have a lighter touch is preferable. That's obviously true compared to a draconian police state, but it's a police state either way.
Article 58 says that fines can be issued along with, or in place of, other enforcement action. That isn't "no warnings". Plus if you read the text of the law you would note that it is very clear that the size of the fine is dependent on 11 factors, many of which revolve around future compliance and efforts made by the business to resolve the breach and showing willingness to conply.
I realise that Pinterest is large and I'm sure they have sought legal advice, but that doesn't stop this coming across as an overreaction, if one assumes that they _aren't_ using the data in ways that explicitly violate the rights granted by the GDPR.
Now if they are explicitly violating those rights, that's another story! I'd rather attribute it to ignorance than malice though.
Shouldn't law apply equally to everyone? One could have thought that setting an example "to show them!" wouldn't have occurred in a civilised country.
Taxation (I would hope) is not minimally enforced.
Because it's the EU and not some other Union.
It's just silly to expect any enforcement body to go after everyone equally. It doesn't even make sense; company A has data on 1.5B people, company B has data on 27 people and the owner's mother. Why would you go after B before A?
a) they have said they don't want to punish companies for the sake of it, they want to use it as an incentive to fundamentally change the approach to the handling of user data. This means not suing tiny companies for more money than they are worth.
b) they have said that the standards will roughly increase with the size of the company and resources it has. A company with 27 users (and few employees) would not be expected to have a data protection officer, or many of the control processes that a company with data on 1.5B people.
Which effectively kills that company even if court finds their violation was minimal.
Setting an example is how the US regulators work, not so much the EU.
Seeing this completely false sentiment repeated over and over again is getting exhausting. Only a tiny fraction of the companies avoiding EU traffic due to GDPR have any intention of “doing shady stuff with your data”.
GDPR is highly complex, and as of tomorrow, allowing EU traffic invites massive liabilities that most companies outside the EU won’t be willing to take on. While Instapaper likely will eventually relaunch in the EU because of its footprint there, the reality is that EU residents are going to be blocked from a large percentage of the world’s websites. The liability is just too great and the rewards too small for most companies outside the EU. You guys chose to make your traffic radioactive. These are the consequences.
This sentiment and the hilariously large fines (regardless of company size, even) on relatively-ill-defined requirements make the whole GDPR process feel like it was designed to bully businesses into compliance.
Some pieces of GDPR are definitely for the benefit of the end-user (at the expense of companies, who happen to be providing those users other benefits). It all feels really heavy-handed, though.
Not to mention a little reminiscent of the problems that occur with other "bans" (which, this effectively is). When you put heavy legal restrictions on doing X (where, in this case, X is storing and processing data that you assumedly use to provide a service for users), you're effectively hurting the legitimate businesses most (_especially_ small ones) while the real "bad guys" that are actually doing bad things with our data are going to continue ignoring the law. There might be some value in-between, but I doubt there's much.
>Some pieces of GDPR are definitely for the benefit of the end-user (at the expense of companies, who happen to be providing those users other benefits). It all feels really heavy-handed, though.
The GDPR isn't vastly different to the old Data Protection Directive, which has been in force since 1997. The panic over GDPR suggests that a lot of companies had simply been ignoring the DPD. If a bit of bullying is required to get businesses to obey the law, then so be it.
I am not sure I understand this sentence. That’s what laws do. “Bully” you into compliance. I think you might have meant something else?
This is already happening without the GDPR (carders, dumps, etc), so I don't buy it. The black-market analogy (e.g. illegal drugs) also doesn't hold when applied to companies.
> the hilariously large fines (regardless of company size, even)
Oh no, proportional fines! How socialist!
The whole point is to make it somewhat independent of the company size, so bigger companies won't just swallow the fines. This is typically what Google et al do, they just factor it in to the cost of business. The GDPR wasn't written in a vacuum.
Ironically, it's the bigger companies that can still just swallow the fines and the little companies that just effectively vanish into bankruptcy.
Er. I vote in an EU country, but I don't feel like I "chose" anything. GDPR was mostly developed by institutions (Council of Europe, European Commission) formed of people that were not directly elected by European voters. In any case, given that personal data management issues are not a prominent part of the political discourse (even in the EU), I'd be surprised if any of the people in charge were elected because of their position on data protection.
It so happens that European institutions have come up with GDPR, but I don't think it is fair to see it as a conscious choice from EU voters.
> the reality is that EU residents are going to be blocked from a large percentage of the world’s websites
I'd be interested in seeing supporting evidence for this rather surprising claim. I'd conjecture that the "vast majority" is the long tail of small websites who haven't heard about GDPR or don't care about it; so I'm not too worried.
Says who? If they weren't doing shady stuff, they wouldn't be pulling out of the EU. The excuses of being complex are just that, excuses.
Says anyone with common sense. What percentage of sites do you think employ data scientists or would even know where to go to sell your data? Most sites do nothing more than throw GA on their website, and maybe some Adsense. You people decided to paint that as something evil.
That’s your decision to make, but just understand that most of the rest of the world wants no part of $20M potential fines and will simply take their ball and go home. This law will have the net effect of creating two Internets - one for the EU and one for the rest of us.
That actually is a problem. GA is a clear violation of everyone privacy.
Where "common sense" means "agrees with downandout, not the more traditional definition of "common sense".
But then, if you are using data for other purposes, it's a bit complicated because you'll have to refrain from doing so until you are compliant. It doesn't necessarily have to be shady stuff. Even if you aren't sure if what you are doing is contract basis or not, it can be a pain. It's not necessarily massively difficult, but if you woke up yesterday and thought "OMG! We haven't done GDPR! What are we going to do?", then I can see this.
I've written earlier about how the company I'm working for now has changed what it is doing with data, even though I don't think they were doing anything shady previously. But it's more like, "Do we really want to list a lot of things and piss off the customer?" So now there are heated discussions of what 3 (or whatever other small number) of things we might collect data for because we believe that's the kind of limit that the customer will tolerate.
All of these discussions take time -- especially in a large organisation. And you can see in discussions on HN, there is going to be a large backlash of "Why do we have to do this anyway? Can't we just ignore it?" which wastes a lot more time.
Sounds like they want to be compliant, but are just not ready yet. A miss on their part, but hopefully they will get things in order quickly.
It's most likely action based on what their suits (Lawyers) recommended, and not a reaction.
Using that line of reasoning, Pinterest is making a very prudent decision.
From what I can tell from various legal advice that I’ve read, as long as you’re working on implementing the changes, and have been following security best practices, nothing really changes on May 25th, and you’ll be able to take your time to become fully compliant, as long as you can demonstrate that’s what’s happening. In other words, good faith and best practice will get you far.
Your current reaction seems like a huge and unnecessary over reaction that is just harming your users, and unlikely to have any material impact to your legal risk.