News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by drewg123 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:22PM (#15543898)
When I was at Google, I was asked if I wanted to make a recruiting trip to my alma mater. I was excited until I found out they were talking about my grad school where I got my MS, and not UB, a large state school where I got my BS. I told them I'd be happy to take a trip to recruit at UB. I got mostly crickets back from that reply. However, I ended up getting signed up for a series where they had a panel of a few HR (sorry, "people ops") folks and a SWE or two talking over Google Hangouts to auditoriums full of kids at FIVE different schools which they called "Long Tail". (and UB wasn't even one of them)

I think they are missing an incredible amount of talent this way. In my circle of friends, there were 3-4 other people that Google would have been lucky to have, and two of them were women They just don't understand that some people like me, who can get into the (mostly private) elite schools choose to go to a "long tail" school for a variety of reasons (financial, family obligations, etc). There are lots of similar schools all over the country.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by viewtransform on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:57PM (#15545202)
When a recruiter contacted me for a position at Google in 2012, I happened to be also taking Daphne Koller's Coursera class on Probabilistic Graphical Models (PGM).

I was puzzled why the recruiter wanted to know my SAT score. He also wanted to know the college and high school I went to and my GRE score and my undergrad GPA ... Keep in mind that I have a BS, MS, Phd in three different engineering fields and over a decade of work experience at well know companies in the Bay area. For a 40 something engineer it seemed odd he would ask me information from two decades ago but I went along assuming he was filling in some boxes for HR.

The first assignment in the Probabilistic Graphical Models class was to predict the likelihood that a candidate would be a good fit for a job given prior Bayesian probabilities for ivy league school attended, SAT score, GRE score, all forming nodes of a decision tree.

I looked at the problem assignment and the recruiters questions and realized what was going on. Some Stanford grad at Google had convinced HR that they needed an objective way to evaluate hundreds of candidates and what better way than to use the same methods that they had learnt from Daphne Koller at Stanford.

I quit the PGM class 'cause it seemed like a tool I would never use. I decline interviews at Google since I don't have the right Bayesian probabilities that would trigger a positive outcome for their PGM model.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by samstave on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:16PM (#15545695)
Its like a real-life implementation of that life-score episode of Black Mirror (and what the chinese government is looking to do to their entire population.

When I first interviewed with google, it took three-freaking months of panel interviews.

Then they said I scored really well, and that I'd have an offer the next day.

I got the call the next day and said, in fact, no offer was coming. No reason given.

Then they attempted to recruit me for the same position for the next four years on three separate occasions.

I told them the story of my first experience, and then they'd say "yeah let me check..." then get back to me and say "sorry, we wont interview you for this position", again, no reason given.

Then they called me one more time, for same damn position. I told them "Ill make this simple, just give me the damn job or stop freaking calling me"

They finally stopped calling me.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ganeshkrishnan on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:29PM (#15546102)
Warms my heart to know that I was not the only person/startup given this treatment.

I was invited to pitch my startup to google startup team twice (For their launchpad AI studio and Gradient ventures).

Got an email two months later that I made it to the next round and requesting more information about the startup.

I sent the emails and then... crickets. Followed up via emails and linkedin and there is just no response. No negative, no waiting, no request for more information. Just a cold dead silence. Very demoralizing.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by cyberpunk0 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:48PM (#15546194)
You placed your hopes in someone other than yourself and we're disappointed when it didn't go well?
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Fnoord on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:06AM (#15548566)
Its not the outcome which matters. The outcome is what it is, you move on. Its the way the outcome is communicated which is a complete disregard of social norms. Its considered impolite to flat out ignore someone. You only do that if you seriously dislike that person, and want to burn your bridges to them, or if you lack communication skills. Consider you might have an appointment with a possible customer on Thursday at 2 PM at Starbucks, but you'd verify it because you are also busy. You never follow up on it. They phone you at 1 PM, but you don't pick up. You don't reply to the missed call either. Now, consider how your potential customer felt at Wednesday evening and Thursday morning. They wonder what's up. They'd like to plan their time as well.

I know, I know, corporations are psychopaths [1], but a hint of humanity or compassion would've at least kept the façade somewhat up. Actions like these can harm your faith in corporations and humanity, and that might very well be the goal. It can be extremely demotivating, and if Google doesn't buy the startup its generally in Google's interest the VC doesn't get bought by the competitor. So from that PoV it makes sense.

But we are talking about real humans here, with startups, with limited resources, and a lot of stress. Is it too much to ask for a response you've been declined preferably also with a honest mention of "because of reason X or Y"?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Corporation_(film)

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by samstave on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:23PM (#15546375)
Screw this logic. Ok the company who is one of the biggest data--based companies in the world is trying to "make the world a better place" - and we are all one big family blah blah gives no data back, so as to literally stomp on some dream rather than to foster growth.

So, to the VCs out there, you have a moral obligation to tell people why you don't want to invest/work-with or hire.

Otherwise you stick the idea of "vulture capital" aren't helping people get better.

Look at some from the ashes type teams, like WhatsApp - might find more of them if you weren't to crush them out early.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Karunamon on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:00AM (#15550660)
I don’t know whether to be disheartened or comforted that their approach to hiring is basically the same as their approach to customer service.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ganeshkrishnan on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:25PM (#15546385)
Not really. I am disappointed that there was no response from the reps. Usually VCs do not respond when your startup is so bad it's cringe worthy.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by trebuhd on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:31AM (#15548199)
I had a similar experience interviewing at Wikia.

I was straight out of uni and the interview was a three-part, month-long process.

At the end, HR called me and gave me an offer, "welcome to the team" included and so on.

I was just told to wait a week for the CEO's formal approval, which was to be "standard procedure" for every new hire.

A week became two weeks, then another two weeks, then another. During that I was still assured the job was coming.

In the meantime, I found another job, a pretty good one.

A month later, I got a call from HR at Wikia saying that maybe I should start looking for a different job.

At the time it was a real disappointment for me, but it taught me to be never be sure until I'm holding the signed contract in my hand.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by gadders on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:08AM (#15548316)
>>At the time it was a real disappointment for me, but it taught me to be never be sure until I'm holding the signed contract in my hand.

Always this. And don't stop interviewing and applying until it happens.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by kyle-rb on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:26PM (#15545746)
Sounds like callback hell :)
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:52PM (#15546490)
That story sounds very familiar. :-)
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nojvek on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:01AM (#15547353)
I've had the worst interviewing experience with google. It seems like they just don't give a shit about the people they're trying to hire. In my phone interview, my interviewer never came. I got rescheduled. In my next interview, the lady thought I was someone else and was reading someone else's resume. She apologized and then I did a binary tree search problem in google search.

The recruiter wanted to do a full on-site panel. I had already offers from several companies at that point. Google was just so bad and careless that I decided to there was no point moving forward. I called it off and chose another company with a sane hiring process.

Google is big and has an insane amount of money in the bank. They can have the shittiest interview process but the input to the pipe is so large that their hiring funnel still works out.

Although I am convinced the reason why google has such a bad male:female ratio of engineers compared to Microsoft is possibly due to their hiring process.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ifhd on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:40PM (#15546716)
I went and did the phone screens and in person. Took 2 weeks to reject me. I don't really mind a rejection, I thought the interview was pretty meh on my part.

Decided to try again a while later. They had me start at the phone screen stage again, then wanted me to do a second. Almost did it, called it off because I decided it just wasn't worth the trouble.

I've been rejected by other places but google just really annoyed me. I think it was the overwrought, slow, unpleasant process which produces high false negative rates but that they are also seemingly extremely proud of. Only place I wen to where they told me multiple times about how common it is to interview 2-3 times before getting in. I'm sure that happens at other places but they seem to treat it more as a flaw then a feature.

Anyway, I hate jumping through hoops. I'm hoping next job I can leverage people a bit more and maybe move through things a bit more quickly.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Joeri on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:03AM (#15548548)
If they have enough candidates it makes sense to not care much about false negatives, only about false positives. Anyway, the way a company treats applicants strongly correlates to the way they treat staff, so a bad interview process is a red flag. It can be tough, but it must be respectful.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ifhd on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:06PM (#15553137)
It really doesn't if you have any interest in a good process. They seem to engage in a lot of back patting about how great their process is.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by sharemywin on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:53AM (#15549613)
Wonder if they watch the movie Gattaca and think yes the perfect society.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nether on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:33PM (#15545429)
Then we've got this 2013 article saying that Google doesn't care about GPA and test scores: http://www.businessinsider.com/how-google-hires-people-2013-.... Maybe things have changed since your experience.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by FreakyT on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:04PM (#15545622)
I believe they did -- from what I've read back in the day it was quite common for Google to demand college transcripts from all applicants, even seasoned professionals.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by user5994461 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:06PM (#15545632)
That would be to check that the degree is real. There are people who pretend to have one while they don't. It's normal due diligence, assuming it's after you are hired.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by throwaway76543 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:49PM (#15545879)
No, it wasn't. They also used to ask for high school transcripts if you didn't graduate college -- even for senior folks with decades of experience.

Google's interviewing process used to be extremely absurd. They have reformed it somewhat since around 2013.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by GauntletWizard on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:07PM (#15546285)
I never gave my high school transcripts to my Google recruiter. I worked there for four years as an SRE (2010-2014), without having graduated college.

I'll admit I was an outlier - Most people around me had fantastic college resumes (And I was very lucky to have them to learn from to shore up places where I had weaknesses). There may also have been a different hiring track and bar for SREs. I didn't find it a problem then - But, given the known fickleness of HR (At my office, our best recruiter was forced out because she spent too much time hanging out with engineers outside after-hours) and the way Google has gone downhill since then, I'd not be surprised if this was now the case

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nitrogen on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @11:23PM (#15547202)
...our best recruiter was forced out because she spent too much time hanging out with engineers outside after-hours...

What might be the rationale for that? At every company I've worked at, the best results came when people worked across divisions between boundaries. I once asked a VC what grassroots indicators they looked at inside of companies, and they said a collaborative environment without a lot of silos. I'd never heard of companies actively punishing this kind of thing, but I totally believe you that it happens. Why would they do that?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by GauntletWizard on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:52PM (#15556226)
Politics. The HR Lead didn't like that she was technically competent and friendly with engineers. This was even cited - She was written up for taking up engineers time.

It's a sad story, but what can you do?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nitrogen on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:22PM (#15565458)
I know it's water under the bridge in your case, but if anybody else happens to read this, there are some protections in place for employees. Coordinating with other employees might be protected by your local labor laws, so talk to a local labor agency office. I know someone who was fired illegally for talking to other employees about things like their employment conditions, and the employer was required to compensate them.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by bane on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:06PM (#15546542)
Companies don't ask for transcripts because there's already services they can use to verify degree (and even enrollment).
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by xigency on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:16AM (#15550808)
That's doubtful. In 2015 they called me back to clarify my college GPA after an onsite interview. The next week they gave me a rejection.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eropple on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:44PM (#15544130)
> They just don't understand that some people like me, who can get into the (mostly private) elite schools choose to go to a "long tail" school for a variety of reasons (financial, family obligations, etc).

Agreed--I was accepted everywhere I applied save one and I ended up going to the University of Maine. I've never hurt for work and I paid off my student loans by the age of 25. Google sniffs around now (aside: recruiters, even if it's Google maybe you shouldn't assume I want to talk to you and tell me to sign up for a phone call to talk to your sainted ass?) and I have no interest, but the first time I interviewed, when a guy at Google gave me noticeable shade for my filthy state school degree? They could've made a decent bit of money off of me and now that door is likely closed.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by drewg123 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:50PM (#15544182)
I ended up at a no-name school because I got a terrible financial aid package at an elite school that I'd applied to early decision. So bailed and went to a state school for almost free.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by protomyth on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:07PM (#15546290)
Hey, at least you got a response. I got no return mail, not even a rejection letter. 3 tracked mails sent, 3 money orders totaling $120 (a princely sum for 1987), and no return mail. It was like a torture session picking up the mail at the box everyday (I had a break between high school classes, so I was the mailbox keyholder). Luckily, I also applied at the state school and got a pretty good package. Would have been better if my high school had filled out the paperwork on time. Makes me wish I didn't spend so many months studying the SAT & ACT because I was worried that we didn't have the classes that would cover the material at my high school.

Oh well, the local community college classes were only like $15 per credit hour for high school seniors (paid by the high school), so I started college as a sophomore. Gotta take the good with the bad I guess.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by wallace_f on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:04PM (#15546534)
>the local community college classes were only like $15 per credit hour for high school seniors

One of the beautiful things about softwars tech is that it has offered people opportunities to self-teach and build a portfolio of their own credentials, by their own determination. This has given ordinary people the opportunity to build things that benefit others.

On the other end of the spectrum, we have privileged rich kids attending Harvard, many of whom go on to work in finance or consulting, and who knows what they produce that is useful in the world.

I would really love to see the idea that we need to open up on the limitations of world-class educations and credentials become part of the mainstream discussion.

There is almost no reason the first two years of, which are often filled with gen-ed requirements often taught in laughably huge lecture halls by uninterested staff, not be open to everyone in the world. We need a new model that promotes this--Harvard classes should be open to everyone and that includes the tests and credits as well.

And why not? The War on Poverty in America has spent trillions of dollars with little to nothing to show for it in terms of reducing poverty. Of all this money spent, one of the first things I would have done would have been to ensure everyone has the greatest opportunities available to them. There's no good reason to hold them hostage, unless you care about profit or prestige more than increasing opportunity and reducing inequality.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Muuuchem on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:20PM (#15544904)
Got paid to go to state school lets get it
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jboggan on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:35AM (#15547492)
Absolutely a great way to do it. I got paid to attend a great state school (above and beyond room and board), had several travel grants, and was sent to 20 countries and Antarctica! I've never had any student loans and it really helped me take some riskier career moves earlier on.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by humanrebar on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:33PM (#15544526)
Same here.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mathattack on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:51PM (#15544677)
I can't find the link but I recall reading (via Freakonomics or Jeff Selingo?) a study that showed that once you control for SATs and income, attending an elite school doesn't confer as much benefit as merely applying to one.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by gaius on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:58PM (#15544757)
Dropping out of an elite school carries as much if not more social cachet than graduating. "Harvard dropout" is an archetype for a reason.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by untog on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:23PM (#15545360)
maybe you shouldn't assume I want to talk to you and tell me to sign up for a phone call

Urgh, this a hundred times over. I get a form e-mail every six months or so from a Google recruiter that says something along the lines of "sorry we missed each other! Find a slot in the attached Google Calendar for us to set up a call"

...no. That attitude straight off the bat makes me not want to go anywhere near the process of applying for a job at Google.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by guelo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:14PM (#15544371)
If the biases start with the university imagine how deep it goes.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ronilan on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:47PM (#15545121)
It's hard to imagine, but it can still be concluded, with certainty, that if they start earlier they go deeper.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nerpderp83 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:25PM (#15545374)
Google should probably interview my preschool teacher, would be a good predictor of Googleyness.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by KGIII on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:26PM (#15544957)
I wonder if there is a competitive advantage to be had there? UMaine is a pretty good system. When I retired, I taught math at UMF for a little while, so I got to see the system from the inside.

UMF has one of the best teaching programs in the country. They even have a CS path that is judged well.

Maybe recruiting at the small State universities is a potential edge?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Spooky23 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:36PM (#15546139)
Please don’t. Our hiring pipeline is almost completely from these schools.

You get great talent that big tech companies won’t interview!

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eropple on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:09PM (#15546833)
And you can underpay them, which is a nontrivial part of my concern.

No insult intended, I would rather they benefit and not you.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Spooky23 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:01AM (#15549324)
Not really. We don’t operate in an insanely overpriced metro, so a grossly underpaid person probably takes Home more than the average tech company person out of college.

Nobody is making the big money that elite engineers make though.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by tareqak on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:05PM (#15546276)
Moneyball for college grads?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moneyball

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nnd on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:55PM (#15544722)
From my personal experience, Google recruiters appear to range from absolutely horrible to incredible, so are the interviewers.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by tomtang0514 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:21PM (#15546063)
I second this, but most google recruiters are pretty terrible. Some are so disrespectful that I have to tell someone to put my profile into google blacklist so they don't bother me anymore.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by wallace_f on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:14PM (#15546581)
Would you be able to offer some examples?

I don't know what the deal is with some recruiters--I mean, in general. I attended a recruiting event from the US gov near graduation, approached one booth and introduced myself. A friend came over and inquired about a job to which she said "oh, well that's for the creme de la creme" and turned away without asking him anything about himself!? I found that incredibly rude.

Geeze, I wish I had her psychic powers /s.

Personally I think it has to do with the problems of giving people power and authority over others...

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by tomtang0514 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @11:24PM (#15547208)
In the first year after graduation, I get emails from (different) google recruiters pretty much every month. One thing I see multiple times is they include a "best work place ranking" link and google is ranked #1. One time, after I said I'm not interested, the recruiter replied something like "why don't you give this a try? Best case scenario you work at the best company in the world. Worst case scenario you stuck at your current position." I remember she did use the word "stuck" and that just triggers me.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by cynicalkane on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:06PM (#15544809)
Google's interviewing process is incongruously uneven compared to the rest of the company, which is top-notch. I recommend giving it another thought. (Disclaimer: ex-Googler.)
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eropple on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:54PM (#15545167)
Google can't offer me anything I want anymore. They could have when I was less experienced, but I have enough in my toolbox that ending up stuck in a Google ecosystem for years and losing my edge would be a net negative.

(I guess there's always the wheelbarrow of money, but they don't really even do that anymore, at least here in Boston.)

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eradicatethots on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @11:36PM (#15547248)
If you work at google the little shits on the internet can’t say “LuL ur just not good enough” anymore.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Bahamut on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:54PM (#15547062)
There are plenty of other great big tech companies that don’t have as terrible of an interview process and comparable pay.

I don’t know if I’ll ever try applying to Google again, especially after landing at one of their largest competitors & the company investing heavily in the area I am working in.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by walshemj on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:53PM (#15546214)
Why is that I have worked for a big multi national tech company and unless you had passed a 3 day course you where not allowed to interview candidates.

I would have thought that googles Hr would have a better proccess

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:05PM (#15546535)
My theory: Google started by hiring only new grads from Stanford and then a few other top schools.

1. They're only interested in new grads, so experienced people are treated funny; they're outliers.

2. They're only interested in top schools, which act as a pre-filter. Anyone interviewed is probably a good hire anyway, so it doesn't matter whether your process is goofy.

3. We are talking Google. Anyone under the age of 30 is slobbering all over themselves to work for them.

Keep this up for a few generations and their hiring process is permanently wacky.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by exelius on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:51PM (#15546759)
Yeah, that ride is over. Google's rep is fucked with a lot of top schools anymore. Don't get me wrong; it's still a good company to work for, but getting a job at Google in 2017 is like getting a job at Microsoft in 2007. And the recruiting process is so stupid that the best candidates don't bother.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by walshemj on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @06:23AM (#15548888)
Ah so they don't have a HR director who can impose better practices no wonder they are having problems with being investigated for pay discrepancies.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by taneq on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:33AM (#15548207)
I'm curious how you reconcile these two facts, given that the rest of the company presumably joined via the interviewing process. Does this uneven process produce consistent results or do you simply weed out the less-than-top-notch hires quickly after hiring them?
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by sharemywin on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @09:00AM (#15549680)
It's hard to be elitist if you went to a state school.

Think of all the extra brainwashing needed.

It's way cheaper to start with a kernel than expand from there.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by skybrian on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:46PM (#15544625)
A Google interviewer definitely shouldn't be doing that. Sounds like you got a bad one.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by TallGuyShort on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:19PM (#15544900)
I've had a different one contact me repeatedly every 6 months like clockwork for the last 5 years. Of the ~10 I've had one that listened to WHY I wasn't immediately interested and factored that into his future communications. The rest of them came off exactly as the parent comment to yours described.

edit: to clarify what happens, every 6 months it's a new recruiter, and they always ping me multiple times until I respond and tell them what I've told all of them, and they usually (with 1 exception so far) keep pinging the same way.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by skybrian on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:13PM (#15545296)
To clarify, I meant that the person doing the tech interview shouldn't care what school you went to and definitely shouldn't be throwing shade since that just distorts the evaluation.

The early part of the recruitment process is basically a process to get possibly qualified candidates to interview. What it's good for: if you ever want try interviewing at Google again, you can get an interview. I wouldn't expect anything more from it than that; it's pretty impersonal. :-)

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eropple on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:29PM (#15545406)
> To clarify, I meant that the person doing the tech interview shouldn't care what school you went to and definitely shouldn't be throwing shade since that just distorts the evaluation.

Of course they shouldn't. (I know plenty of people at Google, I've gone through the process a few times, I have an idea.) But...that doesn't mean it doesn't happen and that it isn't cultural.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dangerlibrary on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:51PM (#15544678)
Based on the other comments here, it sounds like he got a thoroughly average one.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by robotresearcher on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:11PM (#15544844)
But they hired the recruiter from a top school!
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by yongjik on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:41PM (#15545478)
There's selection bias. Many good developers who met good recruiters/interviewers would have been hired, so they won't be complaining here.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:06PM (#15546546)
In theory, theory and practice are the same thing....
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by fossuser on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:27PM (#15544476)
I agree - and this is even more true at state schools than the slightly more selective schools (like RPI that I went to).

State schools have people that got into MIT, but didn't go for financial reasons or family reasons. Nobody at RPI got into MIT because if they did they would have gone to MIT (maybe some rare exception exists, but this is generally true).

School admission is obviously not a perfect indicator of ability, but I suspect while the average and median may be higher (and more tightly distributed) at a school like RPI, a state school will have a lot more outliers.

Everyone is fighting for students from the super selective schools and state schools are largely ignored - students either need referrals to get interviews or jump through a ton of hacker rank like hoops.

This is even ignoring the 'diversity' angle - a lot of really great people are missed because it's hard to break in without knowing someone or having the right credentials.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by CWuestefeld on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:50PM (#15544672)
Nobody at RPI got into MIT because if they did they would have gone to MIT (maybe some rare exception exists, but this is generally true).

One exception at least. One of my fraternity brothers at RPI came to beautiful Troy, NY when he had the option of MIT.

There really are good reasons for such a choice. The schools that are so famous for their top-end research are achieving that research success by having those elite professors doing research, and that comes at the expense of teaching. Going to a merely "most selective" school rather than "Ivy Plus" is an decent solution to that problem.

(of course, there are other reasons to not go to RPI, but that's a different conversation)

EDIT: I just noticed that you referenced RPI as "slightly more selective". At the time I was there (mid-80s) it was ranked as most selective. I'm aware that its reputation has slipped a bit. While it's not that big a deal to me, as my 30 years experience outweighs all that, I wonder what effect changing reputation has on past students.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dsharlet on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @11:44PM (#15547284)
> There really are good reasons for such a choice. The schools that are so famous for their top-end research are achieving that research success by having those elite professors doing research, and that comes at the expense of teaching. Going to a merely "most selective" school rather than "Ivy Plus" is an decent solution to that problem.

One of the points of going to good research universities is to immerse yourself in exactly that environment: research. Good students probably don't need good teachers to learn. The reason to go to a top research university is to get involved in exactly that research. Especially in computer science and engineering, this is part of the pipeline to the really interesting jobs in industry.

I completely missed this when I was in school, and I regret it.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by fossuser on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:38PM (#15545041)
> The schools that are so famous for their top-end research are achieving that research success by having those elite professors doing research, and that comes at the expense of teaching.

There's no guarantee that the less selective schools are any better at teaching. From what I've seen CMU and Stanford both had smaller class sizes and better teachers than RPI, but that was just from quick touring.

There are some schools with a strong focus on teaching (Harvey Mudd), but that seems to be unusual. I think in most cases if you get into a super selective school you should go if you can.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by hexane360 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:27PM (#15546090)
The Wall Street Journal had an article a while ago where they tried to find schools with great research as well as teaching.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/where-great-research-meets-grea...

Can't get behind the paywall now, but it was a lot in line with your arguments.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:11PM (#15546567)
Most of the best professors I have had were researchers teaching they favorite subject. Most of the worst were "CS education" types who should have been good teachers.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by peoplewindow on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:21AM (#15548362)
How are you judging "best professor"?

I had professors at my school that taught their pet research topics. They all sucked at teaching, partly because their research areas were utterly irrelevant for undergrads who were still struggling to learn programming. RDF, anyone?

The best profs were the ones who had been working developers in industry. They found ways to make the classes engaging and fun, vs just lifelessly reading their notes out loud (often in impenetrable accents).

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:59PM (#15551802)
Best professor:

1. Actually know something about, and be interested in, what they are teaching.

2. Being able to explain the subject without making a complete hash of it.

3. Being able to explain the subject without leaving me comotose in my desk-thing.

Extra credit for including tips and tricks that don't get covered in textbooks and are only known to people involved in the field. Plus, background and amusing stories about how the goofy nomenclature and such got the way it is.

On the other hand, when and where I was an undergraduate, if you were "still struggling to learn programming" after the first couple of semesters of programming and data structures (taught by aforementioned "CS education" people), then you were pretty thoroughly hosed. (There were, however, 1-course hour classes in individual programming languages, if you couldn't pick up those yourself.)

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by internetman55 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:16AM (#15550284)
I definitely agree on this.

Mathematical logic class taught by logician? Awesome

Automata class taught by expert in complexity theory? Fantastic

Rudin class taught by PDEs expert - amazing

The worst class I had was an introductory algorithms course taught by someone who specialized in teaching.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by azinman2 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:23PM (#15544929)
I toured it in ‘99. I don’t remember the exact stats but the avg HS GPA at the time was around 3.3, it’s SAT’s not very high, and admission % decidedly higher than everywhere else I applied.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by CWuestefeld on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:33PM (#15545001)
At the time I went, I chose RPI above Dartmouth and Johns Hopkins. Times change, I guess.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by erichmond on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:33PM (#15546113)
Meh, I got into CMU SCS, and chose Tufts, because I was equally interested in comp sci and music, and Tufts had a much superior music program.

Early on in my career I'd get questioned about my CS degree from Tufts, and I'd jokingly mention "I'd gotten into CMU SCS, but I preferred to be a well rounded individual. I can send you the acceptance letter if you'd like."

I think people choose schools for all manner of reasons.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ifhd on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:47PM (#15546745)
I'd be worried about that coming off as "I'm better than you".
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by tdeck on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:49PM (#15544655)
I would assume that schools like RPI also have a lot higher concentration of peers who are applying to places like Google, carrying around copies of Cracking the Coding Interview, returning from internships, and sharing knowledge of the industry and how to prepare for your career. Whether that actually makes someone better prepared to do the job is an open question, but it certainly seems like it would make people appear better prepared to do the job, since they'd know what interviewing companies value.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by logfromblammo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:39PM (#15544572)
I didn't get in to MIT, but if I had, it's unlikely I would have attended, due to financial reasons. I went to a state school, and had a handful of scholarships to help me out.

In retrospect, I would have been better off applying to UIUC, Purdue, or CMU, but quite a lot of the decisions I made when young would have turned out differently if I knew then what I know now.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jtmcmc on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:46PM (#15545514)
I don't know when you applied but my understanding is that MIT http://news.mit.edu/2008/tuition-0307 this is from 2008 presumably that number has gone up (stanford is now free for families earning under 125k for instance)
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by logfromblammo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:12PM (#15545675)
It would have been around 1994 and 1995. Historic data say that my 4-year (sticker price) total would have been just a bit over $90k (equivalent to $133k in 2017 dollars) for tuition alone. I don't have the receipts, but I think my parents only had to pay about a quarter of that, including non-tuition expenses, to a markedly less prestigious school.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Spooky23 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:46PM (#15546182)
Plenty of people decide against MIT or leave early.

It’s a pretty hostile environment for many people.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by KGIII on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:47PM (#15547042)
I'm not sure I'd call MIT 'hostile.'

I admit I'm heavily biased, but I'd say it is demanding. If universally demanding excellence is 'hostile,' then I guess I can agree with you.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by rodgerd on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:27PM (#15545391)
> This is even ignoring the 'diversity' angle - a lot of really great people are missed because it's hard to break in without knowing someone or having the right credentials.

That is literally the diversity angle.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by hueving on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:06PM (#15546538)
No, the 'diversity' angle is frequently tied to things like skin color, sex, ethnicity, heritage, etc. You can have two people that match in all of those categories but one chose to go to a state school because of a family issue and then they will be ignored by Google.

This is not something any diversity program I know of in the big companies is trying to address.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by peoplewindow on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:22AM (#15548367)
In the UK this would be called classism. It's the same thing but in the US setting.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by ringaroundthetx on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:22PM (#15546628)
> but one chose to go to a state school because of a family issue and then they will be ignored by Google

A person with a family issue probably still has a family issue incompatible with working for a corporation across the country.

Ever think their process of selecting unencumbered elitists might be by design and super effective?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by wavefunction on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:53PM (#15547061)
>probably still has a family issue

Probably? That seems to be an expansive assumption, to be charitable.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dba7dba on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:18PM (#15545705)
It is the diversity angle, considering many smart students of minority groups choose to go to public school because many come from families that cannot pay for tuition of the top 5.

Very much a diversity issue.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:26PM (#15545747)
Top 5 universities (and elite private schools more generally) are usually much cheaper than public universities for students with limited means because they have deep pockets for need-based financial aid while public schools have little if any additional campus aid.

Now, awareness of this fact may be not widespread enough, skewing the applicant pool toward the outcome.you describe because of perceived cost, but it's much more likely that a student wouldn't be able to afford a public college than an elite private one.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Spooky23 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:50PM (#15546198)
That’s a common myth.

They usually weasel word the scope of their generosity, treat loans as gifts, etc.

The sticker price is always negotiable, but state schools are usually ahead.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:01PM (#15546252)
> That’s a common myth.

Since I personally experienced it, I'm pretty sure it's not.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dba7dba on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:23AM (#15547447)
I'm sure you and few others experienced it. But I'd say it's not that common. Just look at the make up of study body at the top 5 schools.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jasonx1e on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:30AM (#15547743)
>> But I'd say it's not that common.

Then you should look at the actual university policies outlined on their website. At top of line elite schools (Stanford, Princeton level), if your family income <$65-75K, both tuition and housing are free, and <$125K tuition is free.

I know for a fact that state schools like UC Berkeley and UCLA aren't that generous with housing.

>> Just look at the make up of study body at the top 5 schools.

Students from wealthier backgrounds tend to have more access to academic and educational resources and are thus more qualified and more likely to be admitted.

Not a judgement suggesting that a less fortunate child would not succeed in a similar environment; many of them just don't have one.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:37AM (#15547770)
That reflects more the effects of family educational background and socioeconomic class on pre-collegiate academic achievement and, even with good achievement, inclination to even bother to apply to elite schools (in part, again, because of lack of awareness that headline price isn't the whole affordability story.)
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:40PM (#15546154)
No. They're cheaper for people with nearly no means.

The people with some means (aka the "middle class") can stretch their budget to afford state school.

Most states also have transfer programs that let you go from a 2yr at a CC into the equivalent 4yr at state school which takes a huge chunk out of the cost.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by whipoodle on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:32PM (#15544519)
I didn't even understand the whole world of prestige and specialization among colleges when I was 16 or 17 and trying to pick a school. I didn't know that some schools were where the "good" people go. I just knew I was supposed to go to college, so I visited the local Penn State campus and people said "don't come here". Then I visited another state school and people seemed to like it, so that's where I went.

I wonder if people realize how rare it is to even understand these things. If you don't have people in your family who went to college you are unlikely to be initiated into all this. If you do have a lot of people in your family who went to college, that's a serious leg up.

Now I work in a fancy startup where everyone went to Stanford, MIT, Harvard. It's a very weird feeling.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by wpietri on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:20PM (#15545333)
> If you don't have people in your family who went to college you are unlikely to be initiated into all this.

Absolutely. The number 1 reason I'm in tech is that my dad was a programmer. The reason he's in tech is that his dad was high enough up at an insurance company to swing my dad a job back when computers were new and nobody knew what to do with them. And that probably worked out because the generation before that was reasonably well off due to some lucky choices.

But I still grew up with little idea how to play the elite educational game. My family valued learning a great deal, but the jockeying for social advantage was never given much consideration. It's a very specific set of knowledge and skills.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by stuxnet79 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:38PM (#15545044)
Things ended up working for me overall but I can relate to this post so much ...

The assumption that it's 'obvious' that knowledge of how the system works is widespread is just wrong. It's only recently that I clued in to how the industry works, if I had all this knowledge handy years ago, if somebody told me, I don't know what position I would be in right now.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by gbrown on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:56PM (#15545192)
This even goes for high school counselors. I grew up in a suburban family with all of that knowledge of the system. My wife went to a similar high school, but is a first generation college student. She found out that she was supposed to take the ACT from a fellow student mere days before the deadline. Her counselor told her to ask her mom about college visits.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by _raoulcousins on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:36PM (#15545443)
Yep! I chose a local state school over my top choice.

State school was free with financial, extrapolating my financial aid package I would have graduated from the top choice with ~$60,000 debt.

I didn't understand the prestige differential because literally everyone I knew at best went to that state school. One of my high school teachers even told our class that we should not aim higher than the state school, because everyone who ended up going somewhere better flunked out and at best eventually graduating from the state school. At least he was telling us a state school was achievable?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jakub_g on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:06PM (#15545260)
Thanks for writing that. Sounds very similar to my experience in Europe.

I started high school at 15 and it didn't even cross my mind (and would not have been financially possible) to look for one outside of my town, while I had a reasonable one 5 min walk away from my place. There was one school known to be the top in the state, in a big city 50 km away, but it had a reputation of people going on meth to be able to keep studying 24/7 - not so great.

Then I started the local university at 18 - I happened to go to CS because I didn't see anything matching my skills better, but I didn't even write a line of C before that (did a bit of webdev and PHP though). No one in my family and none of my friends had anything to do with CS before me.

Since then I moved country twice for study/work, but I still don't see myself changing country or even state back then at 18. (At that time, I barely started having fixed internet connection at home, didn't even know something like MIT exists, and what's all the fuss about Silicon Valley).

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:15PM (#15546586)
"what's all the fuss about Silicon Valley"

No idea.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by srj on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:17AM (#15547676)
This was my experience as well. I knew and admired schools like Berkeley as the home of Berkeley UNIX, but didn't recognize that the people who went there were considered the upper crust or that colleges were widely categorized into tiers until later on. As none of my family had gone to college, the goal simply seemed to be to get into a "4 year school".

I can appreciate now that these schools offer stellar educational opportunity in contrast with many others. It's just that this should still be seen in the context that a person attends for a brief time when they're young and that perhaps it's not the be-all and end-all of intellectual ability that cultural attitudes (especially seemingly here in New England) might suggest.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jldugger on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:52PM (#15544201)
> They just don't understand that some people like me, who can get into the (mostly private) elite schools choose to go to a "long tail" school

Can you really expect any different from a company founded from within the halls of Stanford, and then staffed primarily from there?

On the other hand, I bet if you sat down and ran the numbers, recruiting from state schools isn't productive. For better or worse, school selectivity is tied with rankings -- for every Anthony topping the charts of state school is a graduating class of Anthonys at the elite schools. Cherry picking your one Anthony per school is likely harder than showing up to Stanford where they picked cherries 4 years ago.

Moreover, Google recruiters are likely already flooded with new grad applicants from non-elite schools, while every year GoogFaceAmaple is pushing forward their recruiting funnel earlier than the competition. Eventually, I imagine they'll simply interview candidates the summer between receiving their college acceptance letter and fall semester freshman year.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Bartweiss on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:15PM (#15544879)
> Cherry picking your one Anthony per school is likely harder than showing up to Stanford where they picked cherries 4 years ago.

An interesting idea: pulling from state schools isn't a problem because they're short on talent, it's a problem because recruiters and interviewers are bad at identifying talent.

Colleges get a transcript, SATs, and essays to make a decision on, then do four years of further sorting. That's far from perfect, but given the track record of job interviews (stunningly poor), picking the best state candidates may not just be time-consuming but basically impossible.

If you simply can't tell who's good, then outsourcing that decision becomes an obvious choice.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Manishearth on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:45PM (#15545850)
Of course, this means outsourcing the decision back in time, too. You're basically hiring for "the best students by <questionable metric> from four years ago" the moment you factor the college into the question.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Anderkent on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:19PM (#15546343)
You're basically hiring for intelligence, but you're not allowed to ask about IQ, so you use bad proxies like the school someone attended.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by vacri on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:14AM (#15548600)
Not 'intelligence', but 'capability'. There are plenty of intelligent-but-not-capable people out there, and plenty of capable-but-not-highly-intelligent folks as well.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by rsynnott on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:09PM (#15544342)
I’ve worked for startups where nearly all of the early employees were from one university, because it’s easier to recruit that way for a small startup. But they grew out of it after a few years. It’s stranger to be still doing much the same thing decades down the road.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by CalChris on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:26PM (#15544467)
Another variation is when a significant cohort comes from another company. Similar to how people from the same school speak the same language, people from the same previous company speak the same language.

This is neither good nor bad. It makes recruiting and onboarding easier early on. But it is a thing which a company will eventually grow out of.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mathattack on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:54PM (#15544716)
This "hire a batch from one company" works in small cases but doesn't scale. A great manager can cherry pick 5 or 6 top talents, but a B level manager won't. It also can create cliques in the company.

I suspect the same exists in making the wrong first hire from a school.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by wpietri on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:21PM (#15545344)
> Can you really expect any different from a company founded from within the halls of Stanford, and then staffed primarily from there?

Yes, I can. The whole point of education is to rise above your biases and intuitions.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by nerpderp83 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:32PM (#15545426)
If I can't reinforce my bias to show, no prove I am amazing, then what do I have to live for? I cannot afford to be objective, I be normal or even worse, normal.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by peoplewindow on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:26AM (#15548383)
That's a very noble view. I'd say the point of education is primarily money: for the teachers/profs who teach and the students who study. Academics in the humanities in particular like to claim that listening to them lecture for a few years will grant someone a better soul and make them intellectually superior for life, but there's no evidence of that and indeed, I sometimes suspect it's the opposite.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by kbos87 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:47PM (#15545521)
It isn’t just about finding “good” candidates. It’s about finding a diverse set of candidates.

Having spent a lot of time hiring over the past few years, I can tell you that the candidates we see from “top tier” schools are almost always “good”, but also incredibly homogenous. I’d rather take the bit of extra effort to find people with different backgrounds and world views that are also “good” at what they do.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by home_boi on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:26PM (#15546387)
That depends on what metrics you use for 'diverse'. Diversity is more than skin deep. The candidates are very culturally diverse.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by s73ver_ on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:32PM (#15544989)
"On the other hand, I bet if you sat down and ran the numbers, recruiting from state schools isn't productive."

I would not buy that for a second.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by sopooneo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:30PM (#15546406)
I tend to agree with you. But with the intense competition for talent, why aren't maket forces sorting this out?
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by s73ver_ on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:53AM (#15551150)
You're assuming the actors are all rational. In other words, "No one ever got fired for hiring from Stanford"
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mypalmike on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:00PM (#15545593)
Interesting. When I pushed a bit at (well-known tech company), I managed to get a couple of high-GPA CS students from my state university into the internship interview pipeline. These students were personally recommended to me by the school's top (IMO) CS professor. I was particularly excited for one of them, who had a 3.9-something GPA, and who seemed pretty solid technically when I spoke with him on the phone. Unfortunately, he didn't pass the online coding test in order to proceed to the next step. The others did miserably on this test.

Compare that to the students I interviewed for internships from top 5 engineering schools. Among them was one of the best candidates I'd ever encountered, regardless of experience level. He came up with a unique (and quite good) solution to a problem I'd been using as an interview question for years. As someone who had done fairly well in state school, I was floored by how much more well-prepared these students were than I had been.

My story is anecdotal, and there are many factors that can explain what I perceived. But I suspect the top companies have figured out that they get best results in hiring based on a) recent grads from top schools and b) great resumes from experienced devs who maybe didn't start out at top schools & top companies.

On the plus side from a diversity standpoint, the students I interviewed from these top schools were both male and female, and from a wider variety of ethnic backgrounds than I usually see in the hiring pipeline.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by kobeya on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:05PM (#15545624)
Or the top schools prepare their candidates for the test. I think I’m a pretty decent coder, thank you very much, but I suck on those blackboard interviews. I could see that being fixed with practice though, and maybe the big schools format their classes and labs such as to practice for that?
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by tomtang0514 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:26PM (#15546082)
I graduated from a top 5 CS program, and no we don't do that.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by kobeya on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:40PM (#15546156)
I don’t mean explicitly. Small team group work and revision sessions with the TA might be sufficient. Non tier 1 schools don’t have this luxury.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by zaptheimpaler on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:59PM (#15547091)
I went to a top 5 school.. sorry to say there is no secret sauce the school gave us, no interview prep classes, and not a lot of TA sessions either - at least not with small sizes.

Definitely nothing at all targeted towards interviews - even the algo courses were very theoretical and they expected us to get comfortable with the code on our own time. In fact they are all about teaching CS and not about teaching you how to get a job or trendy technologies.

What did help me and some of my friends more than anything was just grinding interview questions - going through CTCI 3-4 times until I could solve it in my head, doing random questions off glassdoor etc..

People love to paint rosy pictures of easy lives for top 5 candidates. The truth is college was insanely hard, many people were extremely stressed/depressed, we worked our asses off and sacrificed a lot. Ultimately to learn a lot more in 4 years than someone else, you have to put in a lot more time - there is no way around it.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jon_richards on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:36AM (#15547984)
>the algo courses were very theoretical and they expected us to get comfortable with the code on our own time. In fact they are all about teaching CS and not about teaching you how to get a job or trendy technologies.

This was very much my experience as well. A couple classes had "make your own final project!" things that usually encouraged front-end like an app or a website. I bombed those pretty hard because I had no idea what I was doing.

Most of my classes only touched code occasionally for a homework. Everything else was either math, short answer, or running algorithms by hand.

I don't know how all this compares to other schools, but it could be a massive advantage in interviews. Most interviews are asking you to come up with an algorithm and implement it. I can't tell you how many interviews have come down to the "linked list indexed by a dictionary" data structure that I had to figure out for my first CS midterm. Nobody asks about logging stacks or Oauth2 or caching in new-grad interviews.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dsharlet on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @11:53PM (#15547324)
Maybe I'm misinterpreting your point, but: doing small team group work with supervision that leads to being effectively able to solve problems sounds like a thing that makes someone actually a good candidate, not just good at interviewing.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eastWestMath on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:37PM (#15545811)
Every professor I know who’s involved with programming contests is pretty open that it’s about passing programming tests.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mypalmike on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:23PM (#15546068)
Companies too realize that the process is a highly imperfect proxy for overall developer capability.

But it's also infinitely better from the company's perspective than having no data whatsoever on each candidate's current capabilities.

Combine this with the fact that false negatives (good programmers who perform poorly on 45-minute blackboard programming tests) are not a measurable problem for a company, and you end up with what we now have.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by plasticchris on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:41PM (#15546451)
Worth noting that "not measurable" doesn't mean it's not a problem, but that there is no easy metric.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by bane on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:19PM (#15546612)
Like many people on HN, I've been through the Google recruitment cattle grinder a few times - the usual observations about absurd process that leads to terrible fit apply. I'm even open at the beginning about various conditions of employment if they want to move forward...such as a desire not to move. They always move forward anyways and then at the end ask if I'd be willing to move to whatever office location has the position.

At this point I tell them not to bother if I get contacted or I just ignore the recruiter. It's effectively a pretty big waste of time 98% of the time and they're just making some kind of internal metric so that positions can be claimed to have been offered fairly.

I think what really bothers me about this process in general, and it applies to a great many companies, is that they contacted me. In that they sought me out. I didn't apply. So a little courtesy on that front would be helpful.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Chathamization on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:31PM (#15546109)
> They just don't understand that some people like me, who can get into the (mostly private) elite schools choose to go to a "long tail" school for a variety of reasons (financial, family obligations, etc).

And how about people who couldn't get into an elite school at 17, but end up learning a lot at the state school? It seems odd to be so preoccupied by what someone's capability was when they were in high school, rather than what it is now.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by habosa on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:57PM (#15544239)
I work at Google and have done some university recruiting (not a ton, but some) and I have not had this experience. Recently I saw a list of hundreds of schools of all sizes and locations that we were committed to sending reps to, so I think Google is actually way out ahead of the field when it comes to not only looking at Ivy League / Stanford / MIT.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by eropple on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:09PM (#15544340)
That was not the case two years ago. And maybe that's changed, but there's some prove-it here.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mcguire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:30PM (#15546675)
http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/05/23/tech_comp... (2014)

How many of those schools have you never hired anyone from, vs how many are hired every year from Stanford?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by internetman55 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:35AM (#15550437)
I attended a state school where we had presentations each semester from Google recruitment, including advice from alumni Google employees on how to schedule your classes and choose extracurricular activities if you wanted to be a strong applicant. I don't doubt that top school folks have some resources that others may not, but Google had some presence at my school (East coast state school with quite strong mathematics department and a relatively strong CS department).
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by rsynnott on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:07PM (#15544321)
The odd thing is, the university I went to, not in the US, is ranked a bit higher than UB in the international rankings, but definitely the same general area. And it gets lots of attention from Google recruiters and those from similar companies, I believe. The interviews are still fairly hard work, I hear, but they seem less fussy about universities outside the US.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by smm2000 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:30PM (#15544502)
Rankings do not fairly represent quality of students when compared internationally. Very very few people will go to UB if he/she was accepted to Harvard/MIT so very few top students in US ends up in UB. University of Country (ranked the same as UB internationally but the best in that country) gets almost all smart students from that country.

Quality of education itself is mostly irrelevant - difference is small and it's good enough pretty much everywhere now.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by learc83 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:45PM (#15544145)
We had an alum make a recruiting trip for Google to our large, not particularly well ranked state school when I was in my last year there.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by cm2187 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:18PM (#15546338)
You can see it both way.

My experience is that in any school / college / organisation, there is a distribution of smart / switched on / less switched on / absolute idiots. The difference between the better universities and less prestigious ones isn't that every student is excellent or bad (I have seen enough falling in the last category above in prestigious universities), just that there is a higher concentration of better students.

So it does make sense for companies to target these schools / universities, it's a matter of efficiency for their marketing efforts.

It doesn't make sense for companies to make it hard for non target schools as they are cutting themselves from lots of potentially excellent candidates (I suspect certain companies to automatically reject applications on their websites if the university isn't one of a list).

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by SolaceQuantum on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @02:56PM (#15544228)
I’m a current UB student. There are some more visits from the top here, but only Bloomberg has any real recruiting events... I think google and Facebook appear sometimes but more to give talks and in smaller/tucked away areas. It’s quite hard to get seen by anyone.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mathattack on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:56PM (#15544741)
I would think one benefit of hiring there (vs say CUNY) is it isn't hard to convince people to move.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by mseebach on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:08PM (#15544827)
> In my circle of friends, there were 3-4 other people that Google would have been lucky to have

Don't they have a referral bonus scheme pretty much exactly for this?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Bartweiss on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:17PM (#15544888)
Interesting point - referral schemes are almost always cheaper than using professional recruiters, but they're particularly well-tailored to picking up candidates who are hard to find by resume alone. They'll miss a lot of clusters who never get that first Googler in the door, but past that point they're a highly efficient fix.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by twentythree on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:00PM (#15545215)
> they're particularly well-tailored to picking up candidates who are hard to find by resume alone

Interesting -- can you explain more what you mean here? Referral programs are often criticized for reinforcing biases, since people refer other people with similar backgrounds to them (and, likely, similar resumes). I've held a negative view of referral programs for that reason; do you have data or anecdata about referral programs finding candidates who would otherwise have been missed?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Bartweiss on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:58PM (#15546790)
Yes, certainly - I think the thing I mean doesn't conflict with the thing you mean.

Referral programs will pretty obviously bring your hires similar to the hires you already have, with all the attendant problems. College insularity, but also demographics and even specializations. What I was thinking about was more specifically finding strong candidates from populations that don't look great.

Maybe State University has a weak CS program, but a handful of really good candidates. (This is probably the case for any weak program of sufficient size.) Those candidates probably won't be obvious on paper unless they're hyper-motivated, because weak programs lead to limited opportunities and uninformative grades.

But if Jess from State University does Google Summer of Code and makes something awesome, maybe she gets a job. At that point, Google hands her the referral form and she can pick out her strongest classmates better than any recruiter could, even if they haven't done anything flashy. (My experience, at least, was that the top students are at a minimum aware of one another.)

So it's not going to solve a demography problem; if your direct hires are 50% Stanford, your referrals will be too. But a lot of those Stanford referrals might be people you'd reach anyway, so referrals are valuable in inverse proportion to the ease of other recruiting. The harder it is to spot which candidates are good, the more benefit you gain from asking their peers.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by chaostheory on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:26PM (#15544464)
Didn't Jeff Dean come from a 'long tail' school for undergrad?
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by cycrutchfield on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:48PM (#15544645)
If you consider the University of Minnesota to be "long tail", then sure. I wouldn't, though.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by Spooky23 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @07:31PM (#15546108)
Did that change recently?

I interviewed with them recently and I didn’t get any condescending comments about my SUNY education like I did a few years ago — from a recruiter who was reaching outbound to me!

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by busterarm on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:10PM (#15546565)
UB has(/had?) a pretty decent CS department too. Bioinformatics as well.

Dropping out of that place was still one of the best decisions I've ever made though.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by kobeya on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:01PM (#15545596)
UB?
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by leesalminen on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:17PM (#15545699)
Shout out to a fellow UB undergrad. Fun times and you’re right, lots of talented young folks.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by andreaferretti on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:34PM (#15544534)
Unrelated, but please remember that not everyone here is a native English speaker. It is hard to make head or tails of your comment with all these abbreviations
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by strictnein on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:37PM (#15544557)
I don't know what UB is (I'm assuming it's a university).

BS = Bachelor of Science

MS = Master's of Science

HR = Human Resources

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by felipemnoa on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:49PM (#15544650)
I believe UB stands for University at Buffalo [1] or more precisely State University of New York at Buffalo.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_at_Buffalo

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by stevenwoo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:14PM (#15544872)
as someone who grew up in Texas, I was wondering WTF UB meant and how so many people seemed to know what it was. RPI I knew because I they sent me literature while I was in high school 30 years ago.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by twic on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:25PM (#15545379)
UB = undefined behaviour

RPI = Rob's Pairing Interview

I understanding wanting to avoid the former, but the latter is pretty good.

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by jdminhbg on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:49PM (#15544654)
UB is presumably the University of Buffalo in New York state.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by codeonfire on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @10:11PM (#15546846)
They understand perfectly. They are hoping for rich, well connected kids from rich families that can bring in money and power into the organization. They may have tried some "ordinary" people before and were befuddled when it did not bring in $100 million dollars and several political contacts.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by codeonfire on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:41AM (#15547525)
Downvoted for truth. I don't like it either, but the world is not fair.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by dominotw on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:02PM (#15544286)
>They just don't understand that some people like me, who can get into the (mostly private) elite schools choose to go to a "long tail" school for a variety of reasons

why stop here though, couldn't you just extend this argument to people who go community colleges or online schools or even people don't go any school ?

Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by s73ver_ on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:35PM (#15545010)
Yeah, you kinda could. A lot of those things select for people with money.
Re:If you care about diversity, don't just hire from the sam... by wolco on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @03:52PM (#15544697)
Yes and google would be better off. I would employ a community college programmer over an average harvard grad. More experience and more focused brings better results.