Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by dang on Thursday August 03, 2017 @02:36AM
(#14917421)
This breaks the HN guideline against using titles to editorialize. If you want to say what you think is important about an article, or give your interpretation of it, the place to do this is in the comments, on a level playing field with everyone else.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by kyledrake on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:00PM
(#14914601)
One of my biggest criticisms of most media sites is the lack of audio normalization. It's a bad user experience to be listening to a playlist and then suddenly get blasted with audio at a much higher volume.
I used to just run one on my computer, but it usually involves installing a pretty hacky/custom audio takeover program and isn't really accessible for most people.
Purists will probably complain about the audio being modified. I suppose you could either (optionally) enable it dynamically, or you could store separate tracks for the unchanged and changed audio. But I suspect that most people would prefer their audio to be normalized. I like to throw in a good multiband compressor when I have one too, but that may be a little too opinionated for the general use case.
This would be very simple for soundcloud to do. Also, I don't bother listening to tracks with soundcloud because its autoplay feature isn't able to understand that if I'm listening to instrumental piano versions of video game music, then please don't blast me with some super loud chiptune music next.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by alsetmusic on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:47PM
(#14914983)
> Purists will probably complain about the audio being modified.
As a SoundCloud user, I would argue that a great number of the target audience (musicians) would be turned off by having a carefully crafted mix altered. Anyone who has spent large amounts of money on the tools of their trade has an investment in achieving a particular result from their hard work. The listener is (IMO) secondary to the artist in this case.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by alsetmusic on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @08:50PM
(#14916066)
I have always viewed musicians as SoundCloud's primary customers. That's who brings listeners. The site is built first for hosting, second for streaming. The streaming audience is a consequence of artist utilizing the platform.
I would revert to hosting my music only on my own sites if I learned that SC was altering my audio.
Edit: imagine if github altered code when hosting public repositories.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by _wmd on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:15PM
(#14915189)
The problem is simple enough that it could be solved client side, with some precomputed metadata from the server (an 8-bit integer for e.g. ReplayGain). That could be implemented as a little checkbox that twiddles the volume control from JS
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by disantlor on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:56PM
(#14915055)
thats fair but I always found soundcloud's stream compression to be pretty bad. I think maybe it got better recently but there was a long time where it sounded like ~128kbps or less, particularly on stuff with cymbals, etc
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by badlucklottery on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:11PM
(#14914691)
>I used to just run one on my computer, but it usually involves installing a pretty hacky/custom audio takeover program and isn't really accessible for most people.
If you're on a windows box, most audio drivers (at least in the last few years) have some form of system-wide volume normalization. Of courses it's hidden in some oddly named tab under the audio device properties.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by dsl on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:01PM
(#14914608)
The nail in the coffin for me was when they started wiping out the massive collection of mashups that had been uploaded. Once they got in bed with the record labels and started taking down anything that even remotely resembled another song it all went to hell (things that, mind you, existed just fine on YouTube).
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by tomcam on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:17PM
(#14914744)
How could they do it without violating copyright? And I wonder if artists would prefer to have control over what mashup's are made with their own music? Not trying to be snarky. These are sincere questions
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by danso on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:16PM
(#14914740)
It's too bad this is being framed as a Soundcloud-reaps-what-it-sows/karma thing, because a volume control flaw was meaningless among the factors that threatens Soundcloud's existence, because I'd really like to know what the design justification is for not having a volume control. There wasn't any justification given in the 2-year-old thread as far as I can see:
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by azinman2 on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:45PM
(#14914968)
I actually wonder how many people care, and if it wouldn’t be net negative if they did put it in to due conclusion about its volume vs the OS.
To me, the computer sound is really the one that you want to modulate, know how to modulate, and likely have hardware buttons on your keyboard to change. If audio is properly normalied, then in what scenario are you allowing any random computer sound (such as the OS’s beep) to blow away your ears but you selectively want to do extra work to make SoundCloud play lower?
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by wlesieutre on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:56PM
(#14915053)
It's useful because I have something important to listen to like Mumble/Discord playing at my system volume setting, and I want the music quieter than that so I can hear people talking.
iTunes 1 (16 years ago) had a volume slider to facilitate this. It seems like a perfectly reasonable thing to include even if some of their users like for music to always be the loudest thing on their computer.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by rhizome on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:26PM
(#14915248)
Since when doesn't the web player have a volume control? I'm looking at one right now, it's to the right of the playbar, to the left of the "Now Playing" section, second element from the right. Hover over the speaker icon.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by danso on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @07:48PM
(#14915739)
I don't have a Soundcloud account (i.e. I'm not logged in) and don't use it other than seeing it as an embed player, but I don't see a volume control on the embed version. I did just now notice it on the dedicated page (on the very bottom):
The OP forum post seems to be complaining about the embed version:
> *I'm not sure if this is a bug or just major oversight, but I can't seem to find the volume control on the web player. When I open a site that has your player, I tend to have to close it quickly while I gather myself and turn the volume down on my PC.
Now that I see that the complaint seems to be about the embed version, I can see there's more of a tradeoff due to the embed version's tighter real estate.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by dexterdog on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:00PM
(#14914606)
I don't get the complaint over a volume control. I really just want a mute button, but given that in this case it's only audio there should just be a pause because why would I let a non-live sound file play without listening to it? I like all of my sound sources to play at full volume and then I just control the global sound with my system's volume control.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by wlesieutre on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:16PM
(#14914741)
If you have two sound sources in the same application you can't do this on Windows. Music from SoundCloud and a video call on appear.in or similar, for example.
If you're using a Mac there isn't a system volume controller with adjustments for each application, only a single global control and software is expected to provide its own local slider. Literally every audio source I've encountered has one except for SoundCloud.
EDIT: Might be a bad example, I'm not sure if appear.in has a sound volume slider. But the point stands for every media player I've ever used, whether online or native.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by bjeanes on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @08:38PM
(#14916010)
> If you're using a Mac there isn't a system volume controller with adjustments for each application, only a single global control
True, but for those looking for a solution like this there are options. I personally use SoundControl 2[1] ($10) but there is also a free open source app[2] and a few other options out there.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by djeikyb on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:36PM
(#14914886)
yes. or playing a game. or listening to text (book, screenreader, etc). or using any number of programs where sound is part of the ux (like voice navigation, or bash).
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by CocaKoala on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:06PM
(#14914650)
Having a volume control on the soundcloud player doesn't preclude you from playing all sound sources at full volume and controlling the global sound with your system's volume controls.
It does, however, preclude me from turning down the Soundcloud player while keeping something else at a consistent volume.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by acchow on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:40PM
(#14914916)
Why does the Soundcloud iPhone app have ZERO social functionality?
I can't read comments, post comments, see which of my followings liked this track too. I can't even see the date a track was posted, or read its description.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by Strom on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @07:07PM
(#14915489)
To me the bigger lesson here is that they have a prewritten reply (by a bot?) asking the feedback giver to e-mail it to somewhere else. How hard could it be to subscribe to the thread with their feedback e-mail? Asking people to do stuff is a bad idea, no one likes more work.
Thus it's not so much about this specific complaint about the volume control [1], but more about the systematic failure to collect user feedback.
--
[1] The volume control is a bit hidden indeed, although I've always managed to find it myself.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by protomyth on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:30PM
(#14915271)
I thought it was just me being an idiot or some ad blocker screwing with their player. As soon as I saw it (after the first time), I just stopped playing anything from the site. I mean, after play and pause isn't volume the exact next feature?
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by whipoodle on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:08PM
(#14914661)
I don't like how they monkey with the "download" button. If you want volume control (among other things), you can just copy the download URL and paste that into your audio player (Quicktime is fine for this), but that's hard to do if they obscure the download link.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by cyberferret on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:00PM
(#14914599)
In a similar vein, they have had an issue with their 'Spotlight' tool causing crashes in Chrome browsers whenever you try to drag and drop the play order in your profile.
I (and many others) reported this bug almost 2 YEARS AGO, but even as of a month ago, it was never fixed. I have no idea what their front end devs are up to, but when issues like the OP posted, and a simple drag/drop causes your entire browser to permanently lock up, then it doesn't bode well for the reputation of the development team.
EDIT: I believe 'Spotlight' is a paid for feature too (? Not 100% sure, but I have been a paying user of SC for years), so the fact that they may be ignoring bug fix requests for a feature used by revenue generating customers is even more perplexing.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by r3bl on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:10PM
(#14914685)
I mean, we are talking about a company that, for some reason, takes over two years (I think) to switch to a new design completely, so I don't see why you are surprised.
In fact, they still haven't done so, and, for example, if you go to Settings -> Connections, an old design page opens in a new tab.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by pmoriarty on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @08:19PM
(#14915911)
Web-based players are usually garbage, no matter what site hosts them. This is one reason I prefer to just download the media and use dedicated, standalone players instead. They tend to be much more feature rich, stable, and configurable.
Fortunately, youtube-dl can download from Soundcloud, so I just use that.
Soundcloud has a much bigger flaw than its player: Soundcloud's ditching of groups. Without groups their site next to useless for music discovery. This is why I, as a music producer have stopped uploading content there, as it will just sit there with zero plays, compared to when groups were around, when at least some people interested in the genre could discover them. Now Soundcloud is borderline useless, except as a music storage site.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by dvt on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:01PM
(#14915092)
Lol, this was so so SO annoying when Soundcloud first started gaining traction. It was an insane pain in the ass to go to Volume Mixer -> Firefox -> Drag down the volume. And then drag it back up when I switched over to Youtube.
It seems like such a common-sense obvious simple-to-implement feature, it blows my mind it took years until we got a volume slider.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by Dirlewanger on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:42PM
(#14914933)
Some time back, I remember reading from either a Soundcloud or Bandcamp employee (same issue) that they didn't include volume control because they didn't want users to hang around on their site habitually and treat it as a player. They wanted people to buy the music instead. A little odd, but it's not too far-fetched.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by Tommah on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @07:15PM
(#14915536)
Everyone on that page is reacting to the post that says "Yes, we meant that the feature is not available not that it's broken." But they are quoting the post before that one.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by rocky1138 on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:58PM
(#14915071)
I don't care at all about the online music player having its own volume control. I can just turn down the volume for Firefox or Chrome. What's the big deal?
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by devwastaken on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:59PM
(#14915081)
Convenience of functionality? Proper UI? A dozen reasons for why any player should have its own volume control when the application its hosted in can have dozens of other different players at the same time.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by wavefunction on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @07:03PM
(#14915470)
I've "rough mixed" two Soundcloud tracks by opening them in different tabs. It was just to get an idea of whether they would complement each other in a mashup but it was useful as a quick POC.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by coldtea on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:24PM
(#14915236)
First, there's no built-in way (at least on OS X) to just "turn down the volume for Firefox or Chrome". From a quick search this looks to be a Windows feature.
Second, I don't want to affect the volume for Chrome or Firefox overall (e.g. I might be playing an online game with sounds). I just want the SoundCloud stream to be louder or less loud.
Third, if I run my audio through an audio interface, like lots of musicians (which SoundCloud supposedly caters to) do, there's not even a system volume setting I can apply. I need to use the interface's custom "mix control" application to change the volume, or turn the physical knobs on the interface or mixer or monitors. Again, affecting other sound sources too.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
I used to just run one on my computer, but it usually involves installing a pretty hacky/custom audio takeover program and isn't really accessible for most people.
Purists will probably complain about the audio being modified. I suppose you could either (optionally) enable it dynamically, or you could store separate tracks for the unchanged and changed audio. But I suspect that most people would prefer their audio to be normalized. I like to throw in a good multiband compressor when I have one too, but that may be a little too opinionated for the general use case.
This would be very simple for soundcloud to do. Also, I don't bother listening to tracks with soundcloud because its autoplay feature isn't able to understand that if I'm listening to instrumental piano versions of video game music, then please don't blast me with some super loud chiptune music next.
As a SoundCloud user, I would argue that a great number of the target audience (musicians) would be turned off by having a carefully crafted mix altered. Anyone who has spent large amounts of money on the tools of their trade has an investment in achieving a particular result from their hard work. The listener is (IMO) secondary to the artist in this case.
Good luck with that.
I would revert to hosting my music only on my own sites if I learned that SC was altering my audio.
Edit: imagine if github altered code when hosting public repositories.
If you're on a windows box, most audio drivers (at least in the last few years) have some form of system-wide volume normalization. Of courses it's hidden in some oddly named tab under the audio device properties.
I wonder if artists would prefer to have control over what mashup's are made with their own music?
This is called "moral rights" and US copyright law does not have them.
https://soundcloudcommunity.com/soundcloud-on-your-computer-...
To me, the computer sound is really the one that you want to modulate, know how to modulate, and likely have hardware buttons on your keyboard to change. If audio is properly normalied, then in what scenario are you allowing any random computer sound (such as the OS’s beep) to blow away your ears but you selectively want to do extra work to make SoundCloud play lower?
iTunes 1 (16 years ago) had a volume slider to facilitate this. It seems like a perfectly reasonable thing to include even if some of their users like for music to always be the loudest thing on their computer.
http://i.imgur.com/Vj9YKC6.jpg
https://www.propublica.org/podcast/item/how-a-reporter-pierc...
The OP forum post seems to be complaining about the embed version:
> *I'm not sure if this is a bug or just major oversight, but I can't seem to find the volume control on the web player. When I open a site that has your player, I tend to have to close it quickly while I gather myself and turn the volume down on my PC.
Now that I see that the complaint seems to be about the embed version, I can see there's more of a tradeoff due to the embed version's tighter real estate.
Chalk it up to commentator's oversight.
If you're using a Mac there isn't a system volume controller with adjustments for each application, only a single global control and software is expected to provide its own local slider. Literally every audio source I've encountered has one except for SoundCloud.
EDIT: Might be a bad example, I'm not sure if appear.in has a sound volume slider. But the point stands for every media player I've ever used, whether online or native.
True, but for those looking for a solution like this there are options. I personally use SoundControl 2[1] ($10) but there is also a free open source app[2] and a few other options out there.
[1]: https://staticz.com/soundcontrol/ [2]: https://github.com/kyleneideck/BackgroundMusic
It does, however, preclude me from turning down the Soundcloud player while keeping something else at a consistent volume.
I can't read comments, post comments, see which of my followings liked this track too. I can't even see the date a track was posted, or read its description.
Come on, Soundcloud.
Thus it's not so much about this specific complaint about the volume control [1], but more about the systematic failure to collect user feedback.
--
[1] The volume control is a bit hidden indeed, although I've always managed to find it myself.
I (and many others) reported this bug almost 2 YEARS AGO, but even as of a month ago, it was never fixed. I have no idea what their front end devs are up to, but when issues like the OP posted, and a simple drag/drop causes your entire browser to permanently lock up, then it doesn't bode well for the reputation of the development team.
EDIT: I believe 'Spotlight' is a paid for feature too (? Not 100% sure, but I have been a paying user of SC for years), so the fact that they may be ignoring bug fix requests for a feature used by revenue generating customers is even more perplexing.
In fact, they still haven't done so, and, for example, if you go to Settings -> Connections, an old design page opens in a new tab.
Fortunately, youtube-dl can download from Soundcloud, so I just use that.
Soundcloud has a much bigger flaw than its player: Soundcloud's ditching of groups. Without groups their site next to useless for music discovery. This is why I, as a music producer have stopped uploading content there, as it will just sit there with zero plays, compared to when groups were around, when at least some people interested in the genre could discover them. Now Soundcloud is borderline useless, except as a music storage site.
It seems like such a common-sense obvious simple-to-implement feature, it blows my mind it took years until we got a volume slider.
You can simply click on the song name to get to the Soundcloud website where there is a volume slider.
It does now. My memory isn't perfect, but I'm 90% sure that it didn't always. Note that the post is from 2 years ago.
Second, I don't want to affect the volume for Chrome or Firefox overall (e.g. I might be playing an online game with sounds). I just want the SoundCloud stream to be louder or less loud.
Third, if I run my audio through an audio interface, like lots of musicians (which SoundCloud supposedly caters to) do, there's not even a system volume setting I can apply. I need to use the interface's custom "mix control" application to change the volume, or turn the physical knobs on the interface or mixer or monitors. Again, affecting other sound sources too.
http://i1-news.softpedia-static.com/images/news2/kde-plasma-...