Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by jacalata on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:15PM
(#14915191)
Then give the artist tools to fit a normalized audio experience, or build a business that doesn't need listeners.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by interfixus on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:43PM
(#14915348)
"The customer is secondary to the manufacturer".
Good luck with that.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by alsetmusic on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @08:50PM
(#14916066)
I have always viewed musicians as SoundCloud's primary customers. That's who brings listeners. The site is built first for hosting, second for streaming. The streaming audience is a consequence of artist utilizing the platform.
I would revert to hosting my music only on my own sites if I learned that SC was altering my audio.
Edit: imagine if github altered code when hosting public repositories.
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by _wmd on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @06:15PM
(#14915189)
The problem is simple enough that it could be solved client side, with some precomputed metadata from the server (an 8-bit integer for e.g. ReplayGain). That could be implemented as a little checkbox that twiddles the volume control from JS
Re:One of the lesser reasons Soundcloud deserved its fate
by disantlor on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @05:56PM
(#14915055)
thats fair but I always found soundcloud's stream compression to be pretty bad. I think maybe it got better recently but there was a long time where it sounded like ~128kbps or less, particularly on stuff with cymbals, etc
As a SoundCloud user, I would argue that a great number of the target audience (musicians) would be turned off by having a carefully crafted mix altered. Anyone who has spent large amounts of money on the tools of their trade has an investment in achieving a particular result from their hard work. The listener is (IMO) secondary to the artist in this case.