News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by pnathan on Friday April 28, 2017 @05:49PM (#14223369)
This is very, very wasteful compared to actual mass transit. A subway network is much more effective at delivering people.

If he's looking for mega-good, Musk would do significantly better to drop a full subway network.

edit: tunnelling is a broadly solved problem. It's difficult, expensive, slow, etc. But there's no engineering reason why a hole in the ground can't happen. Musk might be able to drive some significant improvements there. No idea. But tunneling itself is not a reason to knock an idea beyond the cost and geoengineering involved.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by whack on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:05PM (#14224387)
You're asking the wrong question. There are over a hundred million Americans who commute long distances in their car. Mostly because they live/work in areas that aren't dense enough to have good last-mile public transit, and they don't want to deal with transfers. You can lecture them all you want, but ultimately, these people aren't going to downgrade their lifestyle just to fit your ideas of engineering efficiency.

The real question is: is this new solution more efficient than the current alternative of driving on the highway?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by jaredklewis on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:39PM (#14224526)
If places aren't dense enough to support mass transit, they are certainly not dense enough to financially support car-trains tunnels. The depicted tunnels have the same costs as building subways, and I imagine similar maintenance costs. On the other hand, they can only serve a fraction of the riders a traditional subway can, which means the cost per rider is huge. Not to mention it still requires owning a car, so the traditional capital and insurance savings from mass transit don't apply.

But to answer your question: maybe, but it doesn't matter. American cities are already bankrupting themselves in road maintenance. Adding a series of super car tunnels for an efficiency benefit? Out of the question.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by XorNot on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:27AM (#14225465)
Why does everyone lack imagination on this topic?

Problem: if you drive to the subway, then take the subway, then you have two problems: where do you park your car, and how do you get to your destination once you get off the subway if it's not walking distance?

Currently - people just drive. And the surface streets get progressively more crowded. We could drill more regular roadways - but it's notable that one reason we don't is controlling emissions and safety is difficult with human drivers.

So, taking that back to the video: replace the subway with general purpose transport stations that provide a mix of subway-like transport of passengers, or entire vehicles, powered electrically.

No vehicle emissions (huge problem with tunnels) and no endpoint transport issues - the subway becomes an extension of the road network, and if it's cheap enough to do, hopefully a very scalable one.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by unityByFreedom on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:53AM (#14225528)
> We could drill more regular roadways - but it's notable that one reason we don't is controlling emissions and safety is difficult with human drivers.

Also cost. Drilling car tunnels is more expensive per passenger served than a mass transit system

> if it's cheap enough to do, hopefully a very scalable one

That's a big unproven if, and a hope that's almost out of a science fiction novel. If Musk has ideas about how to solve those problems, let's hear them.

We already understand that tunnels with electric cars would be great. Everything we do has a cost and if we're going to work together on something as a society, let's do something that benefits more of us than luxury car owners

Re:The Boring Company [video] by whitemale on Saturday May 06, 2017 @06:52AM (#14279652)
> Why does everyone lack imagination on this topic?

You are right, I imagine that we should just have teleporting gates!

> if you drive to the subway

How about not driving to the subway? how about having local buses or that can take you there?

> where do you park your car

Car parks next to the station?

> how do you get to your destination once you get off the subway if it's not walking distance?

Buses or trams.

> Currently - people just drive.

Not everywhere, look at London for example.

> We could drill more regular roadways

No we can't, tunnels are expensive and bring a whole new set of problems like how do you handle an accident, how do you get to the surface etc.

> subway-like transport of passengers, or entire vehicles

That is horribly inefficient in terms of space and weight, average car weight is ~2 tons.

> powered electrically

Having it electrically powered does not mean that it's clean energy.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by jaredklewis on Saturday April 29, 2017 @11:19AM (#14226917)
I understand those benefits, and think they are marvelous, but also very expensive.

American cities are already spending more than they can afford on road maintenance. Are these underground trains going to be cheaper than above ground roads? Public money for this doesn't seem all that likely.

Here in Tokyo, the Yamanote above ground train serves a million riders daily. Costs a couple dollars to go 10km. The boring concept looks much more expensive than that, as it is underground, but those costs are spread out over many fewer people. Private money seems hard, too.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by deanCommie on Saturday April 29, 2017 @10:43AM (#14226788)
The two problems you discuss are both easier to solve than LONG DISTANCE BORED TUNNELS.

Solution for problem 1: Park and Ride. Giant multi story parking lots. Cheaper to build even underground than the tunnel Solution for problem 2: Local transit like Tram, bus, or bikeshare.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by vinay427 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:39PM (#14228310)
I think a far better solution to #2 is taxis or other on-demand transportation that can take you directly from subway stops to your destination. Trams and buses have the same last-mile problem as subways, but to a lesser extent, and often require passengers to wait longer for the next tram/bus. Bicycles have practicality limitations such as luggage storage, cold weather, and physical ability.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by dnautics on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:58PM (#14224606)
This solves the last Mile problem
Re:The Boring Company [video] by jaredklewis on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:28PM (#14224707)
So does having train stations every few corners. The reason we don't have that now is cost, which is the same reason we won't have car-train tunnels.

Obviously having a network of underground express tunnels for cars would be amazing. It's just economic nonsense when municipal governments are racking up huge debts in normal, above ground road maintenance. If it's not publically subsidized, drivers will be exposed to the true cost, which will be enormous. That high cost cannot be supported will prevent mass adoption.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by closeparen on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:07PM (#14224640)
So do big parking garages at suburban train stations.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by mirimir on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:57PM (#14224962)
> Mostly because they live/work in areas that aren't dense enough to have good last-mile public transit, and they don't want to deal with transfers.

Well, suburbanization was a totally dumbass move. Maybe instead of building tunnels, we could be rebuilding cities. We could be designing them to be attractive enough that people would want to live there.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by clarkmoody on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:08AM (#14225000)
You'd have to get the government to stop building roads...

which of course is seems crazy to most people. But the consequences are all around us.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by mirimir on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:28AM (#14225052)
Yeah. Going from rail to roads was another dumbass move.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by nickjarboe on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:40AM (#14225214)
When a city in America is destroyed by a nuclear explosion, Americans will re-learn why suburbia was so popular. Hopefully this won't happen for a long time and we will have a good stretch of city living. I love cities, but having millions of people concentrated enough to be killed by a single device; this is very different world than the one humans evolved in.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by obmelvin on Saturday April 29, 2017 @02:45AM (#14225358)
That's such a terrible reason not to live in a city. I don't see how it is significantly more likely for only a single incident like that to happen. If we really have a catasophre or act of war it will likely effect larger regions than just a single city.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by mirimir on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:57AM (#14225253)
Sure, maybe that was part of it. Interstates were, for sure. But then, the Soviets were building huge warheads, which could take out metro regions.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by leadingthenet on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:00AM (#14225549)
Are you serious?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by pnathan on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:12AM (#14225147)
> : is this new solution more efficient than the current alternative of driving on the highway?

No.

Because - the exurbs and beyond simply don't have the density numbers to make this kind of investment pencil out without something like a 1000x class drop in costs, which would be wildly optimistic for physical equipment cost savings. Some suburbs might be able to handle it; Bellevue in the Puget Sound comes to mind immediately, but it's only a suburb in the context of Seattle; it'd be a major city in its own right in most of the US.

Further, you're not even getting to the fun part of driving a car - the wind, the sights, the open road. You've got a dang tunnel there. I'd get mildly claustrophobic and probably nauseous: subways already do that to me a little bit.

It's probably much more effective public policy at the federal level to focus on densifying American cities and reversing sprawl: this generates a nice sequence of network effects related to funding and infrastructural improvements. Among those would, eventually, be the demand for nice buses and nice trains with a regular security presence.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by dippyskoodlez on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:21AM (#14225174)
>Further, you're not even getting to the fun part of driving a car - the wind, the sights, the open road. You've got a dang tunnel there. I'd get mildly claustrophobic and probably nauseous: subways already do that to me a little bit.

I sure do love the wind, the sights, the open road of stop and go traffic every day.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by ensiferum on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:07AM (#14225403)
Avoiding driving for ours in congestion would sound like an upgrade to me...
Re:The Boring Company [video] by melling on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:11PM (#14224408)
if you'd create 124mph transportation from 20-60 miles outside and through the city into the city, you wouldn't need to drive into the city. Most commuter trains average less than 50 so it's worth trying to drive. The average speed of the NYC subway is less than 35 mph. Light Rail?

Low-speed maglev: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8SqDVUdMtY

Re:The Boring Company [video] by rpedela on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:26PM (#14224475)
What about waiting time between transfers? You need a certain population density to have almost continuous trains. In Bay Area, you have to wait an hour between Caltrains unless it is rush hour. Caltrains could go 500mph, I would still drive to avoid the wait between trains.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by floatingatoll on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:30PM (#14224894)
Demand for Caltrain is standing room only during rush hour, with 33% of traffic living in Palo Alto and working in SF.

Caltrain has two primary constraints, neither population-linked: diesel trains accelerate badly, and freight track scheduling.

Diesel trains are theoretically being swapped for electric, which will permit the trains to stop and start more efficiently. They predict one additional train during peak rush hour per day for this improvement, iirc.

Freight traffic consumes a fixed amount of rail time, focused primarily on the "one hour between" segments of the schedule. Increasing frequency can only occur within existing scheduled route times, and cannot disrupt that freight traffic.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by nostromo on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:08PM (#14223530)
The video shows some sort of shuttle using the track. Those could be small busses or even public transport.

http://imgur.com/a/Wv8YD

In effect, this is a subway system. It's an underground rail system. The major difference is that you have a mixture of public and private passenger vehicles and smaller vehicles.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by djsumdog on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:25PM (#14223652)
It's still incredibly wasteful compared to a real subway. The amount of people a real mass transit system can move is orders of magnitude above tons if individual little cars:

http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-sol...

..not to mention all the energy required to move each of those vehicles compared to a train that can move hundreds of more people in a similar space.

Americans need to get over all their train/bus hate. Other countries love mass transit. Many Americans try to shoot down any attempt to even put in a small system (small systems can grown) and kill off attempts to grow existing systems (see the Seattle Green Line).

Self driving cars can work great in Europe, where there is tons of transport and you just need to solve the last leg (or where self-driving trucks are rented just to move large items). In America we have massive gridlock due to a lack of rails and that needs to be fixed before self driving tech will fix anything.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by closeparen on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:52PM (#14224581)
>It's still incredibly wasteful compared to a real subway.

Because real subways have miserable sardine-can standing room conditions during commute times. Public transit is dead in the water in the US because its advocates use terms like "incredibly wasteful" to describe making systems anywhere near as comfortable as private cars.

For most people, the most comfortable chair they own is their driver seat. For many, the commute is the only time they get to be alone, meditative, and in complete control of their environment (cube farm or open office at work, children at home, etc).

When the CIA forces people to spend hours with their arms fully extended over their heads while bombarding them with 100db noise, there's a Senate inquiry. When BART does it, it's a regular Tuesday at 9am. (Yes, this is an extreme comparison, real stress positions are much worse, but your average Midwestern suburbanite used to his Toyota Camry is in for a real shock).

If you want Americans to get over their train/bus hate, then don't advocate such drastic reductions in the quality of our lives or the livability of our cities. Your average SUV-driving Wisconsin soccer mom has been to Manhattan as a tourist and decided that her one accidental peak-hours train ride was enough for one lifetime.

That, or densify the environment. We might put up with transit if the rides were shorter.

(I am a daily BART rider, and public transit dependence is the #1 reason I want to GTFO of the Bay Area).

Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:42PM (#14224752)
I personally find trains to be dramatically more comfortable than cars. Feel free to disagree, but a) not having to pay attention, b) not facing any congestion, c) not dealing with the motion sickness and dizziness that comes with doing anything in a car, d) not being stuck in a cramped cage, e) not worrying about getting into an accident, throwing away a boatload of money and potentially hurting randoms strangers or myself for reasons that may be entirely out of my control—all of these things make trains WAY WAY WAY more comfortable to me than cars ever can be.

Have you ridden on systems that are better than our crappy one before? Riding in cities like Singapore and Hong Kong is a wonderful experience.

The real problem is that we have nowhere near to as much capacity as we need, and nowhere near to as much coverage either. And that's 100% a result of political incompetence and a lack of funding for something that almost certainly would improve the livability and productivity of this city.

Coupled with how filthy San Francisco is and how pitifully little we do to address affordability and the resulting, predictable homelessness and mental illness crisis we see here, you get an uncomfortable transit experience.

Our lack of a robust, functional public transit network is a big reason I want to GTFO of the Bay Area.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by fapjacks on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:54PM (#14224954)
Yeah, compare the BART to the subway in Stockholm and it's night and day. Nice public transport is absolutely possible. I remember the first time I lived in the Bay Area they were building BART and I had these expectations... And then years later when I rode it for the first time, I wondered why public transport this close to the center of the tech universe was so shitty. I mean, the trains in Europe have wifi and are clean and beautiful and comfortable and quiet. They're also secure, mostly because of how they handle as a society the kinds of people that make public transit a bad experience. It is astonishing to me that we don't have and can't have nice things in the United States.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by selectodude on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:54PM (#14224953)
If subways are already as tight as sardine cans, how would giving everybody in that train a full car full of room even be the slightest bit possible? There just isn't enough physical room in the tunnels for that.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by closeparen on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:59PM (#14224973)
Running at the proposed 100+ mph should provide the necessary throughput (and actually require seating - have fun with those gs while standing).
Re:The Boring Company [video] by saosebastiao on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:42AM (#14225222)
The problem is that there are diminishing throughput returns to velocity. You need massive amounts of duplicated track for that to be feasible...on and off ramps for every entrance and exit. On and off ramp lengths grow exponentially relative to target velocity. That might be fine for long distance travel, where on and off ramps can be concentrated in few locations...urban travel not so much.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by wcoenen on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:59AM (#14225543)
> On and off ramp lengths grow exponentially relative to target velocity

Centripetal acceleration on a curve with radius r is (v^2/r) so it seems that it grows quadratically, not exponentially.

Exponential growth would mean that the v appears in an exponent in the formula.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by danderino on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:08PM (#14228473)
Saying we shouldn't be wasting a ton of resources on private cars is a "drastic reduction in the quality of our lives"?

Quite frankly, I would much prefer to not have the costs and issues of owning a private vehicle.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by petra on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:41PM (#14223746)
One weakness of all public transportation is the lack of personal space. Maybe if someone would have solved that either by more space or some deep psychological insights, it would become more popular among Americans?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by distances on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:03PM (#14223883)
I disagree. Europe has many countries with at least the same wish for personal space as the US, and public transport works just fine. I'd suspect a big reason is the car-centric culture, which also gives rise to the image of public transport being only for those who can't afford a car. It's a cultural problem that'll be hard to straighten.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by chejazi on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:59PM (#14224365)
> Europe has many countries with at least the same wish for personal space as the US

Maybe this is me being ethnocentric, but it seems the American way of embracing diversity (through political correctness, affirmative action, etc) has come at the cost of craving for isolation and independence from each other.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by Fricken on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:49PM (#14224565)
The loudest voices I hear against big city life and cultural diversity come from those who have little experience with either. They don't need to try Green Eggs and Ham to know they don't like it.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by imesh on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:53PM (#14224586)
You think people in Iowa are driving because of the huge amounts of minorities?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by taysic on Saturday April 29, 2017 @02:16AM (#14225305)
I don't think those policies have anything to do with how close people want to stand to each other in a subway. Americans simply like space and tend to have a lot of it.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by imesh on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:52PM (#14224582)
That's hilarious. Affirmative action created a car culture, not the fact that cars came around when America infrastructure was bring created or that people live far away from where they work. I get it though, you personally crave not being around minorities.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by closeparen on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:57PM (#14224603)
Try any "excellent" public transportation system during commute hours. The lack of personal space isn't misperception. Systems are explicitly planned to have standees, and lots of them, in close quarters. We've gotten acclimated to something much more comfortable, and we get to vote.

It's not clear how public transit advocates will convince us to vote to downgrade our lives. Maybe the bicyclists and pedestrians in cities will be able to block suburban drivers from entering.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by stale2002 on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:12PM (#14224834)
OK, but that's like saying "nobody goes to Times Square anymore. It's too crowded".

If there was more public transportation, the problems you bring up about personal space would go away.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by closeparen on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:35PM (#14224906)
The problem stated here isn't "public transit has insufficient ridership," it's "some people don't want to use public transit."

When the problem you're trying to solve is "some people aren't in Times Square right now," you might need to engage with the fact that it's crowded.

More public transportation, sure, and I'll vote for it every time.

Less car infrastructure, and there is no pressure for public transportation to be comfortable or effective because the only way to opt out of it is to move away.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by cstejerean on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:29PM (#14224890)
I will gladly vote for trains because it takes people off the roads and reduces traffic which makes it easier for me to drive to and from work.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by geofft on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:25PM (#14223995)
I find that I have plenty of personal space on mass transit as long as there's enough transit. If I'm taking the 2/3 subway (in New York) or the 27-Bryant bus (in SF) at 9 AM on a weekday, it's totally fine. If I'm taking Caltrain southbound at 9 AM on a weekday or the 4/5 towards the Upper West Side at 5:30 PM, it's miserable.

That is to say, there's a known solution already: funding.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by komali2 on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:20PM (#14224449)
For me the main disadvantage is that it takes an hour, comes once an hour, has inaccurate timetables, costs 13$, and stops running at midnight. Hence why I drive from mountain view to San Francisco rather than bother with Caltrain.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:53PM (#14224779)
It's too bad Caltrain electrification is getting screwed over... But it's even worse that BART was blocked from just going down the peninsula, to the point that we literally went the other way around the bay to get it down to San Jose. Criminally dumb.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by snotrockets on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:41PM (#14227705)
Having the fine people of the peninsula share the cost of transportation with the hoi poloi of the East Bay is unamerican, hence they opted out of it.

Same for the North Bay (original plans had the BART go almost all the way from Petaluma to Gilroy).

Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:09PM (#14223910)
Doing some googling I found this as one of the links:

http://www.lamag.com/driver/l-s-subway-cars-will-definitely-...

It's a shame. Public transportation would be so awesome if it weren't for the bad press.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by jv22222 on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:53PM (#14224349)
Is it really wasteful? It seems like it is an ever moving system. In terms of people capacity it seems it would carry more by being always flowing vs a stopping starting transit system.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:51PM (#14224774)
The amount of people that can fit in 1 car is roughly maxes out at 4-7 people, depending on the car. There needs to be enough spacing between each car so that in the case of a failure, cars have space to brake to a stop without catapulting the people in it, or causing them to become overly nauseous. So there's going to be a decent amounnt of spacing between each car.

The number of people that can fit on 1 bus can hit in the ballpark of 50 people, so we're getting a roughly 10x capacity boost here. You lose the "ever-moving system" benefit doing this, but I highly doubt some stopping and starting would lead to an order of magnitude slower speed.

Now, the number of people that can fit on 1 SF BART train is in the realm of 10 cars * 200 = 2000 people per train. The spacing is not going to be on the order of 100x longer than in the individual car case, and the starting-stopping speed is going to be not a bit slower than the bus case.

I'll let you work out the math on that, but it's not even orders of magnitude close. Don't need to be a "visionary" to see that.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by Retric on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:29PM (#14224892)
A well managed train system can manage 1 car per line per 5 minutes. 2000 * 60 / 5 = 24,000 people per hour. Highways can handle 2,000 - 2200 vehicles per lane or so at the low end 1/12 but that's very much an edge case. Most lines are closer to one train every 20 minutes and you can average 3 people per car which makes them equivalent.

The real issue is not highways, but what happens when people try and get off or onto them. It's possible but rare to do this well.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by tigershark on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:54AM (#14225108)
Do you mean a shitty managed train system, right? In London at peak time there is one train every two minutes, in Moscow one per minute. One train every 5 minutes is the off peak frequency in London when you are actually complaining that you are waiting too long.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by Retric on Saturday April 29, 2017 @06:59AM (#14225968)
At the peak times for the most used stations there is a car that frequently sure, but if use look at the overall system they don't send anywhere close to 60 * 24 = 1440 trains past every station in each direction per day. Further trains going to different stations often share the same track because you need more throughput in the city center than at the furthest stations. But, just because the edge stations get less use does not mean the track is cheaper to construct.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:33PM (#14228596)
The max throughout is the number that we should care about - they provide fewer cars per minute not because they're physically incapable of doing it, just because there isn't demand. And it would be the same in a car-centric situation as well - lower throughput in off hours.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by Retric on Sunday April 30, 2017 @09:26AM (#14231395)
Having the ability to send 1 billion people from A to B is useless unless there is actual demand to send 1 billion people from A to B. Similarly, not all stations get anywhere close to the same demand, but you need to build a large network or the peak demand is less. Thus, measuring the network is what's important not the 'best case' subset of a few most heavily used stations.

Further, roads and bridges do get used from 2-4 AM when subway systems are generally not operating, so it's the use over the full day that's important not just peak usage.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:36PM (#14228611)
It's less of an edge case than you may think, given solo ridership numbers here in the USA. 75% commute alone.

https://www.census.gov/hhes/commuting/files/2014/acs-32.pdf

Re:The Boring Company [video] by Retric on Sunday April 30, 2017 @09:28AM (#14231408)
The average over the full US is kind of meaningless as most areas don't have traffic problems. It's only large city's that actually matter in this assessment.

On page 4, 2006: 80% used a carpool or single occupancy car. 2013: 76% used a carpool or single occupancy car which is counter to their narrative. Further, metro areas are rather large, I commute less than 3 miles on secondary roads in the DC metro area from just outside the beltway to just inside of it and encounter approximately zero traffic.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by mljoe on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:12PM (#14224836)
According to the DOT, a train is only about 33% more energy efficient then driving.[1]

In addition a subway or bus system has to run on a schedule even when the train is mostly empty. The train and bus is always starting and stopping and causing all it's passengers increased delay to serve the needs of the few entering or leaving.

Public transport is the token ring networking of transportation. It's just inherently less efficient compared to a P2P routing system that only operates when there is a need and with the minimum number of stops (which is exactly 1).

[1]: https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/pu...

Re:The Boring Company [video] by jonas21 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:11AM (#14225004)
First of all, the most recent data in the document you linked to shows Amtrak at 1,629 BTU/passenger-mile vs 3,877 BTU/passenger-mile for cars -- a 58% reduction in energy consumption, or alternately 2.4x better energy efficiency for trains over driving.

But it's also important to note that the numbers for Amtrak are averaged across the entire system -- and most Amtrak routes outside the Northeast Corridor operate way below capacity, despite it being very inefficient to do so. If you look at rail systems where this is not the case, like in Switzerland (716 BTU/passenger-mile) or Japan (534 BTU/passenger-mile), you end up with 5.4x and 7.3x improvements energy efficiency over driving, respectively.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transport...

Re:The Boring Company [video] by kartickv on Saturday April 29, 2017 @11:53PM (#14230090)
This is something I've never understood — why can't those trains operate with fewer coaches, perhaps all the way down to one, in rural areas, or at off-peak times (for metros)?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by c22 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:30PM (#14227652)
On the other hand, the train runs on a schedule which can give you a pretty accurate idea of when you should leave and when you will arrive at your destination. The car might be faster sometimes, but sometimes it is slower and you can't always predict which it's going to be.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by proyb2 on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:49PM (#14224564)
It's not a wasteful when US has huge land and those fuel vehicles need to travel a long distance may encounter car accidents e.g. fatigue, winter, floods, would be benefits from reduce air pollution in the these concept tunnel, in contrast, the size of Singapore is a lot smaller.

The tunnels could use solar energy which is not wasteful.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by labster on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:10PM (#14224651)
Uh... if the solar energy could be better used elsewhere, you're still wasting energy. We're not post-scarcity yet.

Actually it's the land use on roads and parking which is most wasteful. Maybe we could solve half the problem with this, even if it is boring.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by _jal on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:11PM (#14224410)
But... a subway for cars? This strikes me as significantly less efficient use of resources than everyone switching over to printing out their emails/IMs/photothings and faxing them to each other.

Edit: I mean, sure, great science fiction fun to think about!

Re:The Boring Company [video] by elif on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:47PM (#14224553)
yeah, the disparity in cross-sectional air displacement per capita is quite substantial. It is kind of funny to think about as an inefficient train. However, it does not need to replace trains or train commuters in any way. It only needs to contend with normal car travel.

The drag:person inefficiency is a price we still consider worth paying presently, even when it also requires an inefficient decentralized gas-burning energy conversion.

Add in reduced vehicle wear, and of course the time advantage, and with some of the efficiency gains like centralized power/reduced friction/huge electromagnetic actuators/maybe partially evacuated tunnel, it could still conceivably be profitable at a bargain on gas travel.

However, i think the advantages permit it to be sold for more than we are paying for gas travel. People already pay daily just to use a special lane which is nearly the same hassle with only slightly reduced traffic.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by gsnedders on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:15PM (#14223587)
But can you get a moving block signalling system such that they can follow each other with minimal separation? Until you can do that, a real train will always win at people/hour due to the fact that you can have more people per consist as ultimately the signalling challenges are comparable and you can therefore have comparable separation.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by kolinko on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:20PM (#14223623)
With all my sympathy for metro - in many American cities it will never be good enough due to extensive suburbs.

In places where land is cheap, and there are single family houses, cars will be the most efficient way to commute for years to come. We'll switch to self-driving electric cars, but still.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by gsnedders on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:42PM (#14223754)
But ultimately you aren't going to have tunnels dug by the Boring Company out into the extensive suburbs either. The question ultimately becomes whether it makes sense to give up large amounts of space (even if underground) in the centre for parking (for everyone commuting from the suburbs), or give up space further out where land is cheaper and less dense for large car parks at stations. (Obviously there's a cost in changing mode of transport, but that somewhat applies to the pods too.)
Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:06PM (#14223893)
> But ultimately you aren't going to have tunnels dug by the Boring Company out into the extensive suburbs either.

The point of the boring company is to make excavation of tunnels an order of magnitude cheaper. [1] And if he succeeds, I suspect demand for the tunnels will push them out to the burbs.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Boring_Company

Re:The Boring Company [video] by ryanbrunner on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:41PM (#14224531)
But if you can make tunnel digging orders of magnitude cheaper, why not just run subways to the suburbs?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by Reason077 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @07:20AM (#14226034)
In Elon's world, nobody wants to walk or ride a bike that last mile from suburban subway station to their suburban house.

Nor, presumably, transfer from an autonomous taxi or bus to a subway train at that station.

Maybe he's right? Think of this as a subway for cars!

Re:The Boring Company [video] by eli on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:26PM (#14223655)
Commuter rail is a thing. DC's metro goes a dozen miles outside the city in all directions and the MARC train goes further.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:44PM (#14223764)
64 LA subway cars cost $176 million [1]. That seems really high to me, at about $3 million per subway car.

Also people per hour is not really the metric the average person cares about. It's travel time to destination.

[1] http://www.lamag.com/driver/l-s-subway-cars-will-definitely-...

Re:The Boring Company [video] by geofft on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:33PM (#14224034)
Those subway cars are used at all hours that the system is in operation. If you're trying to compare costs with Boring, note first that a personal car is used much less and second that Boring involves these weird platform things which will also cost money, so the equivalent is more than just the price of the Tesla that sits on the platform.

Also, each LA subway car can fit over 50 people seated and probably three times that standing. $3M divided by the price of the cheapest Tesla is about 85. So the number doesn't seem high at all.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:51PM (#14224124)
> If you're trying to compare costs with Boring,

Actually I'm not. I just want to point out that public trains cost huge amounts of money for investment, they need special infrastructure which many US cities don't have, and the only way they work feasibly is if the population density is high enough so the taxes will support them.

In other words, there's a huge upfront cost to even considering building a system that most cities/governments will choose roads over rail.

A bus on the other hand is $300,000, holds around 60 passengers, and uses the same infrastructure the city already has, and doesn't incur the need to have right of way fights with land owners.

What would you realistically do given the choice?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by tptacek on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:43PM (#14224324)
That seems orthogonal to the point 'geofft was making, which seems like if you're going to spend the resources to dig tunnels, it makes more sense to fill them with trains than with personal cars.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by geofft on Saturday April 29, 2017 @11:56AM (#14227124)
A bus without special bus lanes is a pretty bad public transit system, the sort of thing that makes people conclude that this whole public transit idea was a mistake in the first place and we should just invest in better car infrastructure. And getting special bus lanes is pretty politically difficult in its own way (although it's a different sort of fight than right-of-way fights).

If I had the choice of spending $3 million to buy 10 buses, or to do nothing at all, I'd save the $3 million and wait until it's feasible to develop something that the city will keep wanting to fund.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by gsnedders on Saturday April 29, 2017 @10:57AM (#14226833)
> 64 LA subway cars cost $176 million [1]. That seems really high to me, at about $3 million per subway car.

That seems high to me, full-stop. The London Underground S-Stock order came to around £1 million per car (though was a much, much larger order); even smaller orders of Bombardier Movia family trains have come far closer to that than the $3 million per car.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by megablast on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:24PM (#14224253)
This is still completely ridiculous and wasteful.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by theptip on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:03PM (#14224627)
> tunnelling is a broadly solved problem

As rockets were before Space X?

It costs a billion dollars per mile to dig a subway tunnel. If the costs could be brought down, it would change a lot about the way we build mass transit systems.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by tigershark on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:21AM (#14225171)
What? Are you serious??? If it's true then in US you are getting ripped off big time. The whole crossrail project is 73 miles with 14 miles of tunnels and 40 station and it has a cost of 15B£ (19B$ with today exchange rate). I cannot find the total cost of the tunnels, but apparently for 1.25B£ you can have 18km of tunnels: http://www.crossrail.co.uk/news/articles/crossrail-awards-ma... That is 1.6B$ for 11 miles. Basically an order of magnitude less than your figure of 1B$ per mile. If really Musk wants to improve by an order of magnitude over that figure then he is late, the crossrail tunnel have been completed 2 years ago.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by theptip on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:19PM (#14227589)
Those Crossrail numbers give $0.2B/mile, including a lot of miles of track that aren't tunnels. After digging a bit I found this, which is a good summary:

https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/us-r...

It seems that $1B/__km__ (not mile, you're right) is sadly par for the course in the US, and Crossrail passes that threshold too. Projects elsewhere are below that threshold though.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by tigershark on Sunday April 30, 2017 @02:25AM (#14230391)
No the total number include the tunnels, the tracks outside and 40 (FORTY) underground stations. The specific figure of 1.25B£ is taken from the official documents for 18km of tunnels alone. So do you think that an unknown blog that throws some figures without any reference must be more accurate than the official figures, reported in public documents accessible to everyone, that explicitly says that 18km of tunnels ALONE have been built for 1.25B£. Next are you going to post a link from some chem-trails website?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by theptip on Sunday April 30, 2017 @03:52PM (#14233484)
No need to get stroppy, calm down.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by pnathan on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:03AM (#14225129)
If Elon can develop an massively more efficient boring system that the rest of the USA can use; fine, he can have his personal car-way network under his house while I ride around on the highly gridded subway network in Seattle or Austin or Boise. I won't grudge him that.

Also, fwiw, I think cut and cover is a much better approach, despite the street level disruption. Ce la vie.

The question is if he can drop those costs substantially. I certainly wish him the absolute best in doing so. But, if he's going to propose building transportation systems with huge operational costs (SOV tunnels), they had better be efficient in the cost per rider mile and competitive with other technologies.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by theWatcher37 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:11AM (#14225007)
Except the monoculture here doesn't account for just how terrible buses and trains are.

Mass transit is fundamentally superior and realistically inferior. The second any rational actor has the economic advantage necessary to not ride in a box packed with people of questionable hygiene they'll chose option #2 no matter the negative externalities.

I love this place but people aren't packets in your stream, they actively decide against your well designed "optimal" systems and opt for less efficient "luxurious" options as soon as they possibly can.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by zmmmmm on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:52AM (#14225246)
Have you ever ridden on a really good train system?

I get the train to work each day and 99% of the time I get to sit down with space to comfortably work on my laptop and I get through a bunch of stuff each way. When I think of the alternative - spending 20% less time but dealing with the risk and frustration of driving and getting nothing done in return - driving myself seems positively toxic.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by pnathan on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:57AM (#14225115)
> The second any rational actor has the economic advantage necessary to not ride in a box packed with people of questionable hygiene they'll chose option #2 no matter the negative externalities.

:: raises hand :: I can easily afford to drive and park. I bus to work instead. No time difference. A number of people are like me.

(the fact that buses allow people who aren't very well house trained on board is a matter that needs to be addressed, no question about it)

Re:The Boring Company [video] by Operyl on Saturday April 29, 2017 @10:09AM (#14226643)
I mean, where I lived I _tried_ to use public transit. But with a 50/50 chance of getting passed by the single bus running that route, it just wasn't making sense anymore. And that route ran every 60 minutes .. and also didn't run on Sunday's.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by Noos on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:25AM (#14225458)
It's not even hygiene. When you ride a train, you cede control of your life to it: you have to plan things by schedule, if it's delayed you are delayed, and you don't even have the luxury of silence. people don't usually vote to let other people have immediate control of their lives like that.

There seems to be this weird thing where people are embracing things that strip autonomy from them.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by phlakaton on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:46PM (#14224097)
Reports I read on this a month or more ago suggested that yes, part of his goal is to improve the speed/cost of building tunnels, so that it's feasible to go build a whole bunch of them quickly.

(That being said, building a bunch of tunnels in the bosom of San Andreas strikes me as hubris... But having lived in LA and its traffic for many years, I'm willing to be convinced. :-) )

Re:The Boring Company [video] by naravara on Friday April 28, 2017 @05:58PM (#14223454)
Hilariously so even. This is basically a subway system, except you have to provide your own seats. All this is succeeding in doing is making Musk look hilariously out of touch.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by stupidcar on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:11PM (#14223924)
He may well be out of touch, but at least Musk's suggesting a real solution to current transit problems, even if it's impractical. On the other hand, whenever I read stuff by politicians and engineers with real knowledge and influence in this field, I'm astonished by the total lack of vision.

Even in London, where you have a major, successful transport engineering project (Crossrail) completing, and an entire city dependency on, and supportive of, public transport, you only hear the most anemic plans for future expansion.

For example, TFL is pushing a "New Tube For London" plan that consists of little more than trivial improvements. Some new trains, platform edge doors, etc., scheduled to be delivered in 2050 or so. But absolutely nothing with real ambition, like entirely new lines, that would actually solve London's insane congestion problems.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:28PM (#14224012)
The problem is not that they cannot imagine the concept of adding new lines, it's just that the costs, both monetarily and politically for doing so, are enormous in the Western world. The eminent domain, permitting, and labor issues around these things paralyzes the development of cities, especially in the United States.

If you want to see ambition in infrastructure, check out China. Being a technocracy bent on having world-class infrastructure, combined with the ability to remove people from their homes for the greater good with little repercussion, they've built some of the most thorough infrastructural improvements ever seen on the planet. For instance, the first line of the Shanghai Metro was opened in 1993; today, it is the longest metro in the world, with 14 lines. And this rapid growth can be seen not just in the megacities like Shanghai, but in countless smaller ones throughout the country—not to mention their incredible construction of their thorough long distance high speed rail network. And on top of that, since their system is so modern, the trains are a hell of a lot safer and more reliable than any piece of infrastructure in the USA.

I think they've made mistakes with how car-oriented the streetscapes are, the generic architectural styles throughout that country, overbuilding before demand arises, and a lack of mixed-use neighborhood zoning, amongst other things; but when it comes to imagining an integrated, efficient commuter rail network, they've killed it.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by linkregister on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:35PM (#14224288)
> the ability to remove people from their homes for the greater good with little repercussion

I think you underestimate how poorly compensated the relocated people are. Unless it's an outcome of "Weird China" reporting, which is very possible, I've seen plenty of reports of people being forced out of their houses in exchange for flats with smaller floor space and property in an inferior location.

I'm not saying what Chinese infrastructure officials isn't impressive. I'm just saying it has massive costs for the people being displaced.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by EmployedRussian on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:24PM (#14224876)
I think you are in violent agreement with the parent post: "ability to remove people ... with little repercussion" literally means: they (authorities) can order people move, and it costs them (authorities) little or nothing at all.

It costs the moved people a great deal, but the government doesn't care.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by linkregister on Monday May 01, 2017 @02:26PM (#14240104)
Hah! Thanks for pointing that out. I didn't catch it.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by osdiab on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:28PM (#14228572)
Exactly, thanks for clarifying :)
Re:The Boring Company [video] by tigershark on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:31AM (#14225196)
What? TfL has no ambitions? The crossrail is the biggest construction project in the whole Europe, and it is still not finished and they are already planning for the crossrail 2 that will be started in the next 3-4 years. These are huge projects, much more important than Musk proposal that in London would have been simply ridiculous given that the crossrail alone will move 200 million people per year. If they went for the proposal discussed here instead London congestion would have exploded given the abismally low capacity of this boring company project.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by astrange on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:26PM (#14224001)
Opening new lines, like building new roads, might hurt everything due to induced demand.

You can reduce demand by not needing everyone to go the same place every day. Why does everyone have to work in London and why don't they already live where they work?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by Robotbeat on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:25AM (#14225044)
Induced demand means people are now able to practically get places when they couldn't before. It doesn't mean "hurt everything."
Re:The Boring Company [video] by roywiggins on Saturday April 29, 2017 @02:07AM (#14225283)
And more people moving more places means more growth, probably. If everyone stayed at home not much would get done.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by Anechoic on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:38PM (#14224296)
> He may well be out of touch, but at least Musk's suggesting a real solution to current transit problems, even if it's impractical.

He's proposing the transportation equivalent of a personal computer with perfect security, completely crash free, 1000x faster than current PCs that cost lesss tha. We have today. It's not impractical, it's laughable.

> On the other hand, whenever I read stuff by politicians and engineers with real knowledge and influence in this field, I'm astonished by the total lack of vision.

If you want to see total vision, come to a Transportation Research Board annual meeting. Or an APTA annual meeting. Visions are out there. The political support is not.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by dirtyaura on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:02AM (#14225127)
Visions have to be shared with the public, make people excited about them, to get politicians to support them
Re:The Boring Company [video] by pnathan on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:48PM (#14224107)
paralysis via NIMBY is the key problem in the US. many urbanists would be happy to grid every city with subways. we talk about it, wistfully.

but we don't have the political leverage today, and the little we have is with the Democrats, not the Republicans.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by 6d6b73 on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:03PM (#14224167)
"real solution" =! "it's impractical"

Decide which one is it.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by closeparen on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:56PM (#14224791)
Getting to provide your own seats might just be what convinces drivers to use a subway system.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by puranjay on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:39AM (#14225630)
Isn't Musk's track record simply to shoot for the moon (or heck, Mars), then temper things down?

He misses all his deadlines for precisely this reason.

Right now, it's just a video mocked together over two days. It's just a very, very broad "idea".

Things will change over time. Why knock something so early in the development phase?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by wcr3 on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:16PM (#14223594)
hilariously.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by contravariant on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:05PM (#14223515)
>But there's no engineering reason why a hole in the ground can't happen.

Well, unless you count damage to whatever happens to be in the way of the tunnel and buildings on top of tunnel. This might be more of a problem in Europe than in the U.S. though.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by djsumdog on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:28PM (#14223667)
Look at the Seattle viaduct replacement problem. Bertha came to a standstill for years due to engineers not taking care of a well pipe they thought they removed.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by namlem on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:33PM (#14224031)
I think the video was just to look flashy and show off the Model 3 design. I imagine most of the tunnel boring will be for mass transit.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by imron on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:44PM (#14224543)
> tunnelling is a broadly solved problem. It's difficult, expensive, slow

And now Musk is trying to solve for those three factors

Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:16PM (#14223590)
>Musk would do significantly better to drop a full subway network.

In the same way a road offers private and public transportation, a tunnel can do both. Why can't the car be a bus, say?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by hk__2 on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:46PM (#14223772)
Because that’s hugely inefficient compared to a subway network.

I live in Paris, France. 100% of its inhabitants have at least one of the 300+ subway stations under 1 km (0.6 miles) of their home. The subway system transports 5M people every single day. That’s twice the city population. That’s also 1.9B per year. During the peak hours you can have up to one train every 90 seconds for a capacity of 700 people each.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:33PM (#14224036)
> Because that’s hugely inefficient compared to a subway network. I live in Paris, France. 100% of its inhabitants have at least one of the 300+ subway stations under 1 km (0.6 miles) of their home.

That's actually pretty awesome, but you may have noticed that Americans don't really care about efficiency.

Once the tunnel is built, you can put anything you want into it. But I suspect we would still choose cars over trains.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by Caprinicus on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:53PM (#14224132)
People in general don't care about efficiency, and it's not even irrational. Transportation planning tends to treat people as little AI zergs that are going to take the most collectively efficient route to their individual destination. It's best to have a system that's as agnostic to how people want to get where they're going as possible, but I have no idea whether tesla's idea is good.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by robocat on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:29AM (#14225608)
Paris isn't on top of the San Andreas faultline!
Re:The Boring Company [video] by glenneroo on Monday May 01, 2017 @07:05AM (#14236714)
Elon already responded to this concern: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/824300186834898945
Re:The Boring Company [video] by Tiktaalik on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:19PM (#14223614)
Because cars, which are relatively wasteful spacewise, create negative externalities on the public transportation by causing congestion, which resultantly makes public transportation less efficient.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by kolinko on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:22PM (#14223635)
Not an issue in automated underground systems really.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by djsumdog on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:30PM (#14223677)
Yes it is. Cars don't even begin to match the capacity of trains. Look at London or Singapore where trains arrive less than a minute apart at peak hour. Many of London's trains are autonomous and all of Singapore trains are fully autonomous. There is no way individual cars could even come close to matching that kind of people-moving ability.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by ShannonAlther on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:15PM (#14223584)
> But there's no engineering reason why a hole in the ground can't happen.

Depending on the specific location, there may very well be. Underground tunnels are vulnerable to earthquake-inflicted damage, for instance, and you would want to avoid repair as much as possible.

Similarly, there may be environmental or conservatory reasons not to build tunnels, or reasons related to cost, or obstacles not yet encountered (that last one is less likely though).

Re:The Boring Company [video] by cbisnett on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:23PM (#14223642)
This is Elon's response to a Twitter users similar comment about earthquakes. I don't know enough about physics to say if he's just throwing things out there or if he already did some research.

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/824300186834898945

Re:The Boring Company [video] by ShannonAlther on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:27PM (#14223662)
Mmm, so I spoke too soon on that front. In my defense, I've said this a lot to people who are advocates of Hyperloop construction (vacuum tubes are far too easily ruptured to be used in conjunction with transportation), but Musk is correct.

Are subways targets for terrorism the same way that airports are?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by iraklism on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:50PM (#14223803)
Re:The Boring Company [video] by baq on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:33PM (#14223685)
All public transportation is.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by djsumdog on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:27PM (#14223658)
Just look at the Big Dig. One small mistake (using the wrong glue or fasteners) can put the safety of the entire safety into question.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by badosu on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:13PM (#14224421)
Re:The Boring Company [video] by bb88 on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:05PM (#14224171)
But those exist for above ground systems too, right? Earthquakes damage roads, bridges. Road and rail impact the environment as well.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by roywiggins on Saturday April 29, 2017 @02:10AM (#14225291)
The Seattle viaduct is a good example of transportation infrastructure that is very vulnerable to quakes. They're replacing it with a tunnel, so I assume they have worked out how much damage an earthquake will do. At least the tunnel can't fall on anyone, unlike the viaduct which would pancake and render the waterfront inaccessible.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by pnathan on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:46PM (#14223777)
broadly, a generic hole is doable, it's been done many places.

just like software is doable. :)

sometimes you can't do it. but generally... you can. :)

Re:The Boring Company [video] by mmanfrin on Friday April 28, 2017 @05:59PM (#14223462)

  If he's looking for mega-good, Musk would do significantly 
  better to drop a full subway network.
Like Hyperloop?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by makomk on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:24AM (#14225601)
Hyperloop was a completely infeasible design that Musk quite openly had no intention of building. It mainly seemed to exist as a tactic to attack actual planned public transport expansion in the Bay Area, which Musk compared it unfavourably to based on figures that didn't add up.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by stevep98 on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:22PM (#14224238)
I bet this tunnel boring idea was inspired by the lack of an economical path for hyperloop to get to downtown LA. The hyperloop concept took a lot of heat for that.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by idlewords on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:02PM (#14223490)
This is to subways like hyperloop is to high-speed rail. A stupid overelaboration of an existing, proven idea.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by mmanfrin on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:06PM (#14223519)
Hyperloop is a 'stupid overelaboration of an existing, proven idea'? I was not aware we had so many proven 600mph high speed rails.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by astrodust on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:13PM (#14223571)
They exist. The problem is getting approval to build them anywhere near residential areas is problematic.

https://www.slashgear.com/japans-new-maglev-bullet-train-is-...

That's 600km/h. For 600mph you'd need Hyperloop to prove they can do that speed first.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by ryanwaggoner on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:06PM (#14224391)
So...they don't exist. The fastest ones are actually 40% slower.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by astrodust on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:58PM (#14224797)
Show me a working 600mph tube train and then you'll have a case of a superior technology. Until then it's just an idea on a napkin.

China is building new, high-speed maglev trains and there's many lines already open for business.

Maybe one day Hyperloop will get built and will be open for passenger travel. When that day comes it's possible that surface rail may have already achieved the same speed because third or fourth generation maglev trains are in service.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by ryanwaggoner on Saturday April 29, 2017 @10:40AM (#14226776)
Anything is possible, but you were making the claim they they exist, which they definitely do not. They might theoretically someday exist, but so might Hyperloop.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by astrodust on Monday May 01, 2017 @12:15AM (#14235535)
The idea of a 600mph train running in evacuated tunnels is about as old as the idea of trains itself: http://io9.gizmodo.com/5731620/in-an-alternate-universe-ther...

China is looking at building something like that: http://www.zdnet.com/article/china-developing-600-mph-airles...

Note that it's an above-ground system because the costs of building underground are utterly ridiculous for long distances.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by alexbecker on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:20PM (#14223620)
The high speed is the "overelaboration". High-speed rails in many countries can reach 200mph. A 600mph train may be 3x as fast, but the marginal utility is pretty low to me compared to increased cost and reduced capacity.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by idlewords on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:08PM (#14223907)
We don't have any proven Hyperloops at any speed.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by elihu on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:16AM (#14225018)
Cars and mass transit both have major problems. Cars aren't scalable, and mass transit is often slow when you have to wait for trains/buses to come. (It's worse when you have to change buses or trains.)

The video looks more like a high-speed form of personal rapid transit [1], which is a sort of hybrid system that tries to achieve the best of both. It's like a bus or train system, except the vehicles are smaller and don't operate on a timetable. Instead, they pick you up when and where you want and they take you where you want to go.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_rapid_transit

Re:The Boring Company [video] by CamperBob2 on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:08PM (#14223533)
edit: tunnelling is a broadly solved problem. It's difficult, expensive, slow, etc

Well, which is it? Solved, or difficult/expensive/slow?

Re:The Boring Company [video] by zaphar on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:48PM (#14224108)
It's all four, They aren't mutually exclusive.
Re:The Boring Company [video] by leoh on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:51PM (#14224123)
> If he's looking for mega-good, Musk would do significantly better to drop a full subway network.

Agree, except that while many ridiculously wealthy people would be willing to help pay for private access to some tunnels — _perhaps_ subsidizing a system that is later available to others — many fewer wealthy people would help pay for a subway.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by monk_e_boy on Friday April 28, 2017 @06:04PM (#14223500)
What? You could put trains on those tracks.

I think it's neat. I like London, but it'd be sweet to have my car while I was there.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by JusticeJuice on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:34PM (#14224284)
Yeah, like you can't use the car transport floats without a car? Why?
Re:The Boring Company [video] by dingo_bat on Friday April 28, 2017 @10:55PM (#14224787)
> If he's looking for mega-good

I doubt it. I think he's looking for the same thing as everybody else: mega profits.

Re:The Boring Company [video] by spectrum1234 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:24AM (#14225181)
Yes Musk only works for the $$$
Re:The Boring Company [video] by jaimex2 on Friday April 28, 2017 @11:17PM (#14224853)
why not both?