News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:21PM (#13523661)
Production cost is a problem, and technology has made it worse. Look at that long, long list of animators and technicians at the end of any effects-heavy film today. A cast of thousands.

In the late 1990s, when I was working on physics engines for animation, I was talking to a major Hollywood director. He'd done some of the first films that had both live and photorealistic CGI characters. He wanted to get the cost down, so he could make $20 million movies. At $20 million, he could direct; at $100 million, he was running a huge operation that had to have everything pre-planned in great detail.

His model was the early CGI cartoon, "Reboot". Reboot was a weekly half hour cartoon made by a staff of about 30. He wanted to get to that level of productivity at theater quality - make a 2 hour film in a month with 30 people.

That didn't happen. Not even close.

It's been tried. "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" started as a low-budget picture rendered on Macs. In that film, if nobody touches it, it's CG. Ended up costing $70 million. Worldwide box office $50 million. Fail. "Iron Sky" was made for €7.5 million. Worldwide box office $11.5 million. Fail.

There were successful low budget directors in the past, Roger Corman being the prime example. (His autobiography is titled "How I made a hundred movies in Hollywood and never lost a dime".) It's harder to do that today. Viewers today expect incredible production value. Most TV shows have more production value today than 70s movies did. Hollywood has so many people on set because they bring a team together on short notice to do a job, then disband the team. They need many competent people with different skills to make that work. If you cut corners, it looks like Youtube crap.

On big movies, we've mostly replaced set painters and carpenters with people who sit at workstations and do the same job with CG models. "Big" is now cheap, but "detailed" remains expensive. Procedural visual content generation can generate good landscapes and vegetation now (check out SpeedTree), but as yet, nobody has been able to procedurally generate one convincing block of a city street seen at ground level. Making GTA V cost $265 million. Not seeing an incoming reduction in production cost.

Netflix has no huge advantage. HBO is in the same position - they make content to sell to their own customers, and know exactly what sold. Data collection is retrospective. Trying to figure out what movies will be box office failures in advance remains hard. That's why Hollywood generates so many sequels - predictability.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by paganel on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:46PM (#13524854)
> Viewers today expect incredible production value.

Not really, no. I expect interesting movies, and I'd say being an interesting movie doesn't have anything to do with CGI. I'm a film buff through and through and it almost literally pains me when I see that people involved in the movie industry don't seem to understand what their problem is: they don't make films for grown-ups anymore.

The only outlet that has provided interesting movie-like content in the last 10-15 years was television. There's almost no CGI in shows like The Wire, The Sopranos, Black Mirror (to just name a few), shows that have made me casually think about them while I was riding the tramway and the like years after I had last seen them.

I miss great movies.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by racl101 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:37PM (#13525277)
Agreed.

I don't think there's any CGI in Pulp Fiction (1994) and it cost around $9 million to make in 1994 dollars. It made around $200 million worldwide. Whiplash (2014) , a more recent movie with little to no CGI, cost $3.3 million to make and made around $49 million worldwide.

The point is that people want interesting, well written movies with great stories. If that warrants CGI sure, but it's not a requirement.

A boring movie is not good. But a boring and expensive movie is terrible and that's what's mainly being put out: boring and expensive movies.

As far as movies with huge production budgets for every great movie with a justified fair amount of CGI there's tens of crappy ones many that break even or don't make their money back.

Creatively speaking there's probably never been a worse time for big Hollyood movies.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonhohle on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:24PM (#13525639)
Pulp Fiction was one of the first movie that came to my mind as well. It's a beautiful movie (visually), and could be made today for the same cost as it was in 1994.

Looking back at movies from several decades ago, the credit scroll had a few hundred people at most. Now there are a few hundred animators for something like Arrival. Interestingly, Arrival's credits list about the same number of people as Terminator 2. Both excellent movies, but one is small and intimate, and the other grand and explosive - same size crew, much higher balance on visual effects in Arrival vs. practical engineering and effects in T2. Would Arrival have been significantly different or less effective if made with 1991 technology? Probably not.

"[They] were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should."

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by baddox on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:17PM (#13526000)
How "accurate" are credits lists though? Couldn't it be that the credits simply list every employee of every company that did any contract work for the film? It seems plausible that many of the people listed didn't even work a full day on the film.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by pfranz on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:28PM (#13526050)
Credits aren't accurate at all. When you "subcontract" out something, it usually includes a fixed number of credits no matter how many people worked on it.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by cdtwigg on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:10PM (#13526910)
While this is possible, longer credits mean more filmstock to be duplicated and fewer showings per theater screen, so there is an economic incentive to keep them as short as possible. I know when I worked in the VFX industry an artist had to clock a certain number of hours on a given show to be given credit for the work.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by baddox on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:24AM (#13528227)
Surely the difference is nearly negligible. With the exception of movies with popular after-credits scenes, I assume people leave when the credits start anyway, and I suspect the employees can begin cleaning when people clear out even if credits are still running.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by vacri on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:40PM (#13526451)
However, Pulp Fiction wasn't created at a time where home movies were so widespread. If a movie is character-driven, there's not a lot of benefit to seeing it in a cinema these days, as opposed to the comfort of your own home. Big effects on the other hand, they benefit from the cinema experience.

> The point is that people want interesting, well written movies with great stories.

If they did, then these films would be the blockbusters. Whereas Adam Sandler's films were routinely panned for being crap, yet routinely pulled in 8 figures.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by combatentropy on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:07AM (#13528147)
I slightly disagree with everything you said.

    > Pulp Fiction wasn't created at a time where
    > home movies were so widespread
VHS: 1976

Pulp Fiction: 1994

I'm not sure what you mean, then, by "home movies." If you mean "home theater," well, even middle-class people were spending loads of dough on big-screen TVs and hi-fi surround sound.

By "home movie" do you mean the ultraconvenience of streaming Netflix, Amazon, and Youtube? Then you probably have a point, even though it wasn't that hard to drive down to Blockbuster.

  > If a movie is character-driven,
  > there's not a lot of benefit to seeing it in a cinema these days
  > as opposed to the comfort of your own home.
  > Big effects on the other hand, they benefit from the cinema experience.
I think seeing a movie in a theater is more social than technical.

  >> The point is that people want interesting,
  >> well written movies with great stories.

  > If they did, then these films would be the blockbusters.
  > Whereas Adam Sandler's films were routinely panned for being crap,
  > yet routinely pulled in 8 figures.
I think you two are talking past each other. He's talking about Star Wars and Lord of the Rings, which check all the boxes in Joseph Campbell's The Hero with a Thousand Faces. But you think he means The Remains of the Day or some other literary adaptation that nobody really likes. So as a contrast you pull out low-brow comedies, the cinematic equivalent of going out and getting drunk. But those same audiences also went to see Lord of the Rings.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by vacri on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:36AM (#13528783)
> VHS: 1976

"were so" != "nonexistent". Compare the home movie experience of 1994 to that of 201x. 'On-demand' wasn't even a pipe dream in 1994.

> I think seeing a movie in a theater is more social than technical

Maybe for teens who gather in cliques, but otherwise we're just going to disagree there.

> He's talking about Star Wars and Lord of the Rings,

The Star Wars middle trilogy was schlock. They were terrible stories. They sold on hype, colour and motion, and brand recognition. The first one even had a damn half-hour advert for a podracing videogame in the middle of it. And Lord of the Rings was an adaptation of the most successful fantasy novel ever (the genre-defining one at that); not exactly a typical datum. How many times can you do that?

Don't get me wrong, I'm of the opinion that hollywood should spend a million less on special effects and a million more on screenplay, but the whole "people prefer good stories" just doesn't pan out when it comes time to open their wallets. For example, Lord of the Rings had been done a couple of times before in movie and TV form, and it wasn't that popular in that form... until it had mindbogglingly massive special effects and money thrown at it.

Anyway, if you think that the Star Wars prequels were good stories and that pulled the punters, I strongly recommend you watch Plinkett's reviews of them[1] - the voice is annoying, the reviews are mostly funny, but really he eviscerates the exceptionally poor storytelling in them. In there there's even an excerpt from an editor's session where Lucas and Co. are talking about a problem with the ending, where they have the viewer rotating through four very different emotions from four different plotlines in only 90 seconds, none of which can be excised as they're all concluding at the same time... and the mood is very much "we've fucked this up".

[1]http://redlettermedia.com/plinkett/star-wars/

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @10:10AM (#13531130)
It's not spending, it's culture - or lack of it. Adult audiences are tired of getting beaten around the head by constant explosions, emotionally empty CGI, childish plots and scripts with breathtakingly bad writing, and tuneless Zimmer-esque BWAAAAAARRR!!!! scoring.

It's not that Hollywood has stopped making movies, it's more that it's taken to making the same movie over and over, using the same (expensive) visual cliches and script tropes. After a while the spectacle stops being spectacular. Incredible CGI turns into "Well, that's just CGI" visual filler.

LOTR was an exception because it was already well known. I'm fairly sure a Generic Fantasy Movie with similar effects would have crashed and burned.

If studios want to survive, they need to diversify by becoming less like corporate waterfall-management giants, and more like try-this-and-see experimental startups.

For the price of a single blockbuster, Hollywood could fund an entire generation of new directors/producers/writers.

Find ten or so promising YouTube shorts, give the production team a small budget and some prosumer equipment, get out of their way, and see what they do on a shoestring.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by nikdaheratik on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @07:10PM (#13546775)
It isn't just about culture. It's like the form of entertainment has changed from being something like a theater production with deep and interesting characters to something like an amusement ride with friendly but not terribly interesting cliches.

As much as you want the movies to go back to the first, the people who are paying to go to the theater now are looking more for the second. Television has taken over most of the role that used to be for movies because it allows viewers even more time with interesting characters than a two hour movie.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by combatentropy on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:48PM (#13537753)
No, I didn't mean the prequels.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by adventured on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:06PM (#13526595)
Add Good Will Hunting to that list. It was made for around $10 million and generated $225 million at the box office.

Also My Big Fat Greek Wedding (got solid reviews at the time). $5 million budget, $368 million box office.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by olavk on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @12:05PM (#13542462)
You mention two movies which made their budget back more than 10 times. It is safe to say that if there was a formula for creating movies which made the budget back 10x without the large financial risk the "tentpole"-movies with lots of expensive CGI carry, then Hollywood would do nothing else. But the fact is movies like these are the exception and cannot be manufactured.

It like saying to the gaming industry they should just write games like Tetris: Can be written in an afternoon and makes billions.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by caycep on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:19PM (#13527569)
For an even more fascinating look for someone who is working the way he wants to work, in a budget that he can work with, see this keynote by Joe Swanberg at SXSW a couple years ago....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNDMo0ax17E

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jedberg on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:45AM (#13528341)
12 of the 20 top ROI movies of all time were made after 2000:

http://mentalfloss.com/article/68552/20-most-profitable-movi...

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by bennesvig on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:59PM (#13527799)
CGI and visual effects are one way to attempt to mask the lack of a compelling story.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by wvenable on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:26PM (#13525186)
I think the real issue isn't that those movies don't have value to consumers, it's that anything other than an "event" movie doesn't get people into theatres. We can happily watch visual media with complex stories and characters from our living room.

Then, of course, there is the whole point about international distribution mentioned in the article. Movies for grown-ups literally don't translate well into other languages.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by flukus on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:17PM (#13526001)
Why do we need to get people into theatres? I think half the reason they still exist in any great number is because they get time limited exclusivity. Now that a lot more people have huge TV's and decent sound systems theatres are even less compelling.

I'd much rather much just about any movie from the comfort of my couch, sitting in my undies (depending on company), with popcorn I made for 20c and the sound not drilling into my skull.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by wvenable on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:28PM (#13526049)
Theaters used to be the only way to watch movies, then they became just the best way, and now they're just an experience separate from home viewing.

Theaters exist because they're the biggest consumers of movies and, because they're the biggest consumers, studios give them limited time exclusivity exists to benefit their continued existence. It's a bit of a catch 22 and change is slow.

I watched Rogue one in a regular non-3D theater and the projection was not great. The black levels were horrible. The actual 24fps (x2) frame rate bothered me. I expect to watch it again at home, streamed from Netflix, and have better viewing experience.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by hermitdev on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:48PM (#13526143)
> Theaters used to be the only way to watch movies, then they became just the best way, and now they're just an experience separate from home viewing.

When I can choose between going to a theater and paying +$10 just for the ticket and extremely marked up prices for popcorn and a soda (close to another $20) for a single individual, or I can wait 3-6 months, watch it in the privacy of my home without people bringing crying babies to an R-rated movie, talking during the movie, texting or otherwise using their phones during a movie, yeah, I'm going to wait until I can get it at home. The reasons movie theaters suck basically boils down to: 1. it's expensive, and 2. other people suck, are assholes, are completely self-centered and common courtesy no longer exists.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by lsh on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:03PM (#13526585)
And they eat like pigs at a trough. I don't go to the cinema anymore, I can't endure the 'human' element in between the quiet moments on-screen.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by clintonb on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:46PM (#13527717)
Go to a matinee. I see most movies at 10 or 11 AM on Saturday and Sunday mornings. The theaters are usually no more than half-full. The ticket prices are about half-off, so I have over-priced popcorn for breakfast.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Alex3917 on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:57PM (#13524919)
> they don't make films for grown-ups anymore.

In NYC there is an entire indie film district with four or five theaters within a few blocks. There is still good stuff being made, just not by Hollywood.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by aswanson on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:15PM (#13525092)
Is there a distro channel you can recommend to get access to some of this work?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ajmurmann on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:40PM (#13526108)
Check out mubi and filmstruck. Mubi has 30 movies at any given time. Every day the oldest drops off and a new one gets added. I've watched many movies there that otherwise would have been on my to watch list forever. I've discovered incredible, small movies because of it. Filmstruck has an enormous catalog of indie and old movies. Unfortunately both services happen to end up buffering much more frequently on my devices than the big streaming services do. Might be my connection though.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by rockostrich on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:58PM (#13525428)
Look for indie movie theaters in your area. I'm a little spoiled in that the town I grew up in had an amazing indie film theater (Cinema Arts Centre) and now I live in NYC where I can go to the IFC Center or Sunshine Cinemas to see indie films.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by adamqureshi on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:07PM (#13525494)
Cinema Arts Centre In Hton? i live here and its great! lol
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by hisham_hm on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:09PM (#13525512)
Just look for French and Italian movies, for starters.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ekianjo on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:42PM (#13526458)
Bad recommendation. French movies also have their own industry just as poisoned as Hollywood.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by dgfgfdagasdfgfa on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:32PM (#13526403)
Of course, unless you prefer an independent community that does not revolve around French and Italians movies. :)
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by npsimons on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:16PM (#13534169)
> they don't make films for grown-ups anymore.

This right here is the truth, and it's been known for a while:

> " Adults were treated as adults rather than as overgrown children hell-bent on enshrining their own arrested development."

> "That leaves one quadrant—men under 25—at whom the majority of studio movies are aimed, the thinking being that they'll eat just about anything that's put in front of them as long as it's spiked with the proper set of stimulants. That's why, when you look at the genres that currently dominate Hollywood—action, raunchy comedy, game/toy/ride/comic-book adaptations, horror, and, to add an extra jolt of Red Bull to all of the preceding categories, 3-D—they're all aimed at the same ADD-addled, short-term-memory-lacking, easily excitable testosterone junkie."

> "the degree to which children's genres have colonized the entire movie industry goes beyond overkill. More often than not, these collectively infantilizing movies are breeding an audience—not to mention a generation of future filmmakers and studio ecutives—who will grow up believing that movies aimed at adults should be considered a peculiar and antique art. Like books. Or plays."

From http://www.gq.com/story/the-day-the-movies-died-mark-harris which was written in 2011.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ganley on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:20PM (#13525133)
The best movie I've (finally) seen in recent months was El Mariachi. He made that for like $8K. Assault on Precinct 13 (the original one): $150,000. The list goes on and on. The Way of the Gun, a more recent favorite of mine with a bunch of big actors in it: $8.5M.

Another factor might be exorbitant star salaries. However, I think that's a symptom, not the disease. The real problem is that Hollywood is greedy. They won't touch a $10M film with no big stars in it because it's not likely to make an 8-figure profit.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by dragonwriter on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:21PM (#13525148)
Sounds like the real problem is that audiences disproportionately respond to big stars, so Hollywood disproportionately favors them.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by mark-r on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:12PM (#13527214)
Not really. It's just that spending that amount of money on a movie makes you really risk averse; you go for the actor with the good resume rather than the brilliant newcomer with no track record.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:14PM (#13525985)
> The Way of the Gun

I'm fairly surprised that they were able to make that one so cheaply. Not only is it full of well known names, it was extremely well done (it's also a favorite of mine). I imagine most people involved didn't take their normal rate (or worked on residuals).

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by AnimalMuppet on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:54PM (#13524899)
Great movies require great writing, and then good-to-great acting. CGI? None is fine, but if there is any, it also needs to be good-to-great.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by mortenjorck on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:12PM (#13525062)
Indeed, bad CG can ruin an otherwise great movie. My go-to example is the high-concept 2008 Mexican Sci-fi thriller Sleep Dealer - had the director simply chosen to have the biggest action setpieces happen off-screen or be otherwise implied, it might have been enough of a success to make back its modest 2.5M investment, but the abysmal CG they were able to get on that budget brought the whole film down.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by flukus on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:21PM (#13526019)
I enjoyed babylon 5 a couple of years ago which has poor special effects by today's standards. The bad CGI did not detract from it at all.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Keyframe on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:36PM (#13526421)
Hey, it had poor visual effects by its day's standards as well! Great writing though.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by flukus on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:23PM (#13526983)
I thought they were cutting edge at the time,everyone else was still using scale models weren't they?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Keyframe on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:00PM (#13536256)
It wasn't cutting edge at the time. I started doing pro VFX about that time. What was revolutionary with their VFX though was that they were using Lightwave (and Amigas, presumably PCs later too) which cheapened their VFX workflow by a significant margin. Workstations and software at the time were a significant cost. Like, REAL SIGNIFICANT.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Merad on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:24PM (#13527282)
It was cutting edge technology, but looked inferior to the physical models used by shows like Star Trek TNG or DS9 (I say sadly as a huge B5 fan).
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by pluma on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:46AM (#13529429)
I was a Star Trek fan back in the day and the effects were one of the reasons I never gave the show a fair chance. It just looked so low quality compared to the practical effects in other shows.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by npsimons on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:24PM (#13534256)
> Great movies require great writing, and then good-to-great acting.

I would argue against that last part; great movies do require great writing, but you can get good to great performances out of mediocre actors if you have a great director. No amount of good acting will overcome a bad director.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kn0where on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:11PM (#13526263)
Depending on the episode, Black Mirror uses tons of CGI, but it's usually subtle and the focus is always the story, which is simply served by the effects, not the other way around.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by joe_the_user on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:57PM (#13525421)
> "I expect interesting movies"

I'd say you want an interesting but expect incredible production values

Which is to say I don't think it's a situation of expect in the sense of demanding but rather "expect" in the sense of "habituated to".

Production values might not be the explicit choice of that many people but a good proportion of people would choose X movie with high production values over X movie without. And that's something that's reliable. Things like plot, character and dialog are hit-and-miss if you are looking for quality. Not that they can't sell but they can't reliably sell.

Altogether, "grooming" gets added to everything because it can reliably move people's choices a little bit. Other factors may influence people more, other factors may be what people say they want but a lot of these factors are less reliable, there are a lot of factors where a change might turn as many people off as it attracts but surface unambiguous can be added. And there-in lies the secret of the mass-market surface appearance arms race (similar to the music "loudness wars").

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by bostik on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:34AM (#13528288)
> I'd say you want an interesting but expect incredible production values

Smoke was an interesting movie, and cost $7M. (It didn't make much more but it wasn't a failure.)

Moon was a fantastic movie, and cost $5M. The little CGI it had was pretty obvious but didn't affect the viewing experience. (It also made near-zero returns.)

Requiem for a Dream was - and remains - an outstanding film. It flopped in box office but must have made pretty penny on home sales.

Dead Man is an interesting movie, and still one of my favourites. It works on the audience for the same reason Apocalypse Now does: episodic films in general are considered "artsy" and hard to chew, but turn them into thoughtful road movies and the audience enjoys the experience.

Pan's Labyrinth is just damn good. It cost €13.5 to make, and grossed $37M. Home sales must have added even more since then.

All the films above are both interesting and, in terms of bloated Hollywood budgets, were cheap to make. I would take any one of them over the perfumed sewage that floods the film theaters. And for reference, I did see Doctor Strange in a cinema so I do have a metric for calibration. My opinion stands.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by RodericDay on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:59PM (#13524936)
Snowpiercer was stellar. 40 million.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by vlunkr on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:03PM (#13524981)
But what percentage of viewers do you represent?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Throwaway23412 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:15PM (#13525098)
A pretty small percentage, obviously. The top grossing movies of 2016 were Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, Finding Dory, Captain America: Civil War, The Secret Life of Pets, and The Jungle Book. All of these movies would be impossible to do without CGI.

Viewers want movies to be spectacles. If we're watching something in a theater, we have high expectations of the production value. Otherwise, why even waste the time and money going to a theater? We can watch the "good", low production value movies at home.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by aswanson on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#13525202)
I think the home is starting to turn into the movie theater. It's fairly common to see 4k 55" TVs in people's homes; I'm wondering how far they can take the sizes for a residential area. The accompanying sound systems for these home theaters are high quality as well. I guess it's an arms race to out-spectacle what you can get out of an increasingly performant screen from Samsung, et al.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by vlunkr on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:38PM (#13525288)
This is a good point, the experience at the theater used to be drastically different that what you'd get at home (VHS, non-widescreen, stereo audio, etc), but the gap is certainly closing. Combine that with highway robbery concession prices, being surrounded by a bunch of strangers... the theater is starting to look less appealing.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonhohle on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:31PM (#13525705)

    > Rogue One: A Star Wars Story… would be impossible to do without CGI.
It's a prequel to a movie that had exactly one computer generated element in it, which was a wireframe model that took so long to render that they couldn't re-render it when the final design changed.

They _chose_ not to make it without CGI. It wouldn't have been impossible.

edit: I'll just leave this right here - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0034928/

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by flukus on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:19PM (#13526008)
The original still had big budget special effects, only the technology changed. So I think that's being a bit pedantic.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonhohle on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:21PM (#13532756)
My point was that they would not have been impossible without CGI. All four of those movies could have been made prior to the mid-80s, with different technology. I chose Rogue One and Jungle Book because one comes from a family of movies that excelled in practical effects, optical compositing, and modeling and the other has a version which was made in the 1940s.

Decades ago, Finding Dory would have been hand animated (though, even that had moved begun moving to computers in the late 80s). I haven't seen Captain America, but I would guess similar types of movies existed before hand (the 80s and early 90s are full of over the top action movies and practical effects; some of which still hold up today).

Visual story telling doesn't require CGI. It might be the most pragmatic way to do things now (due to time, cost, complexity, etc.), but it's not the _only_ way.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by dragonwriter on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:35PM (#13525736)
> It's a prequel to a movie that had exactly one computer generated element in it

Well, no, it's a prequel to the 1997 version, not the 1977 version you describe.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonhohle on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:38PM (#13527058)
In what way? It didn't contradict the 1977 version in any way (that I'm aware of). It's been nearly 20 years since I've seen the 1997 version (we watch the 1993 version at home). Had you never seen the special editions, rogue one would not appear out of place.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by alanh on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:24PM (#13527285)
He's saying that the original move we've all seen had its special effects upgraded over the years :)
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonhohle on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:24PM (#13532804)
I understood his point; mine was that _I_ don't watch the 1997 (or later) version of Star Wars (though I've seen it). My children have only seen the 1993 release of Star Wars. If my son was old enough, he'd watch Rogue One and have no issues having never seen the "upgraded" releases.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by sametmax on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:10PM (#13525052)
It hursts. But you are right.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by aswanson on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:14PM (#13525085)
I'll take low-effect, nice plot Ex Machina over pretty much every over-CGI'd, Power Ranger plot scifi/superhero Hollywood film in recent memory.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by santaclaus on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:32PM (#13525236)
Ex Machina had hella CGI, it won an academy award for their visual effects!
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by justinjlynn on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:49PM (#13525841)
If it's done right, CGI disappears.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by RileyKyeden on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:33PM (#13527032)
I didn't realize how much of the sets in Game of Thrones are done on computer until I watched a making-of for one of the seasons. Even knowing, I can't tell when watching.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by hueving on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:12PM (#13525965)
But the costs certainly don't. :)
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by objclxt on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:10PM (#13526259)
Ex Machina's budget was around $15 million, that's extremely low.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by bananaboy on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:26PM (#13526696)
"Zodiac" is a great example of that[1].

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-sZS8OVyVr4

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by lmm on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:17PM (#13525999)
Ex Machina had huge amounts of effects. CGI is a case of "When you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all."
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by sago on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:14PM (#13526291)
One of the three principle characters had a transparent body through much of the film. It amazes me people could think it was light on GGI, or not be sure anything had been done.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonknee on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:02PM (#13526579)
But it had a tiny ($15m) budget, which is opposite of what this thread is saying is possible (lots of CG, not much money).
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by amelius on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:16AM (#13529265)
You're right. But I did enjoy movies like The Martian (2015), and Gravity (2013).
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ouid on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:18PM (#13527558)
if you expect anything but production value in a movie, you haven't been watching movies recently.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Ericson2314 on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:06PM (#13525485)
Lol, winter oscar-bait season is supposed to be their offering to that market. Too bad all those movies are the same too.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by cowardlydragon on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:24AM (#13528226)
CGI exists for international viewers...

Who can't appreciate nuanced localized plotlines.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:34PM (#13523775)
> but as yet, nobody has been able to procedurally generate one convincing block of a city street seen at ground level.

This is an interesting point. In the past, we had the Hollywood backlot. Maybe we need the digital equivalent in the future. Instead of each production company making chunks of New York in CGI, what if there was a shared one that production companies could take as a base and alter as needed? I'm not sure what incentive structure would work best for something like this, but as long as studios don't get greedy about adding their work to it and expecting money back (which might be a tall order), open source might work.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by WorldMaker on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:43PM (#13524341)
I was joking that if Sony ImageWorks doesn't already have a relatively complete digital backlot for just about all of Manhattan between the Spider-Man and Ghostbusters franchises alone, then what have they been doing...

The interesting/tough part would presumably be inter-effects house sharing/community work. I'm almost surprised that there doesn't seem to be a company focused entirely on reuseable digital backlots because that does seem like a niche that someone in Hollywood would already be exploring.

You could also see it coming from an outside direction, too. If I was Rockstar and already throwing hundreds of millions of dollars at digital open world simulations, I'd probably be shopping that around as the basis for digital backlot work. "Filmed 'on location' in GTA V's Los Santos" sounds almost silly right now, but I've got a feeling it won't for much longer. (Also, I would suspect it's Vancouver-based genre television that would be in the market for this before films.)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:52PM (#13524891)
There is some model reuse, but the economics of piracy work against it: if it's just a copy of something that's been seen before, nobody wants to pay anything substantial for it. One reason I stopped working full-time in film was the constant pressure to slash my prices. I was able to make enough to stay afloat for a decade or so, but not to grow my business. by investing in a large stock of equipment or hiring permanent staff of my own. No matter how good you are you are constantly being asked to work for free or below market rate, because distribution income is like a black hole; production money goes in but it's not obvious where it comes back out. In the indie world the typical distribution deal covers the costs of production, legal etc. and only that. So your film gets distribution - yay! - but you won't see any revenue from it until the production cost has been paid off and the distribution company has made a profit, so possibly never. Once you get distribution the project is dead and has to be forgotten about other than as a line on your resume - the fact that you can mention the existence of a distributor tells potential investors that they have a better-than-even chance of getting their money back if they spend it on you.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by viewtransform on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:32PM (#13526729)
Sony Imageworks had a reusable digital library for the buildings in Manhattan. The fire from GhostRider also saw reuse. These models are tied to the production pipeline at Sony: the shaders, data formats, texture pipeline, effects pipeline etc. A reusable backlot company does not exist because a standard studio production pipeline does not exist.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by WorldMaker on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @11:33AM (#13532060)
This is an interesting point. As an outsider to all of it, I'm curious if the open source work Pixar started and Disney has continued in standardizing various asset pipelines is helping, or at least might eventually help the landscape here.

Again as a relatively pure outsider, it is interesting to watch the internal competition between Disney Feature Animation's renderer [Hyperion] and Pixar's RenderMan, and similarly have been curious about how much of that externally visible open source standardizing work on at least the pipelines leading to the renderers contributes and/or constrains the friendly seeming internal rivalry. Similarly with Disney now owning ILM, if ILM has or has not been building on top of some of the same production pipeline standards...

Historically, a lot of the benefit to the Hollywood studio system was that a lot of the parts were standardized and interchangeable between studios. While a lot of studios did experiment with innovations in camera technology, very few studios had to reinvent the camera from scratch.

Given how many special effects houses work on a blockbuster level film these days, I would imagine that the efficiencies in shared asset pipelines between corporate boundaries would eventually win out. It seems silly (at least as an industry outsider) that every company working on, for one example, an Iron Man film would have a different set of models/textures/shaders for Iron Man. (I get that on the one hand it's a bit like stunt work in that you don't need your A-list actor in every stunt or B-roll shot, but on the other hand, digital "actors" don't get fatigued or injured and can be in multiple places at once, they don't need body doubles/stunt actors...)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by viewtransform on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:52PM (#13535092)
There has been standardization in many areas since the days of Toy Story: Autodesk Maya, Houdini, Nuke are now standards in the industry.

It took a while for forward thinking technical managers to convince studio executives that open-sourcing some internal tools and data formats would benefit the studio by making it a standard within the industry. OpenEXR (image format, ILM), Alembic(data format, Imageworks), OpenSubdiv(subdivison surfaces, Pixar), Ptex(texture mapping, Disney) are examples that were quickly adopted across studios. It helps that artists and engineers tend to move across studios bringing with them ideas about what worked best at the previous studio.

In general, the software teams at the studios fall under the line item of "Overhead" in a producers financial spreadsheet. There is pressure to reduce this overhead by adopting standardized tools and not reinventing things in-house.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:44PM (#13524836)
You really need a whole city's worth. People's expectations are really really high in this area, and their intuition is also pretty good - I can generally ID a composite shot before I even know what I'm supposed to be looking at, in much the same way as you can tell you're looking at a flat before you recognize what it's meant to depict. Eye candy is what people pay $$$ for, it's a lot harder (though not impossible) to get paid for a personal story that doesn't require any special effects.

There used to be a joke in the no-budget world - what's the difference between an indie movie and a studio film? In the indie movie you end with a car crash. In the studio film, the car explodes at the end of the first act.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:24PM (#13524192)
There's some model reuse. Pixar does it as a joke; the truck from Pizza Planet in Toy Story shows up in other movies. It's a minor business, like clip art. What can be a low-resolution detail in one application may need much higher detail in another, depending on how the camera moves.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jdironman on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:44PM (#13523861)
I smell a startup. Leased CG sets.

(Just realized 'leased' may not be the correct term here, don't hold that against me I am not an entrepreneur by any means.)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:59PM (#13524942)
^^^^ This is why you research an industry before you go into it unless you want to lose your shirt. If you build or own something physical, people will pay to rent it from you. If it's something virtual, they'll put the same value on it that you put on completed movies as a consumer, a few bucks that bears no relation whatsoever to the effort you had to invest.

In hollywood you are nobody until you have some credits, and you don't get any credits until you have done some work, and you don't get hired if you're a nobody so you'd better be prepared to give it away and keep giving for a while until people come looking for you, at which point you practice saying 'no' a lot and meaning it. One of my more memorable gigs was on a film that I turned down because the pay was too low. So they went with someone else but he did such a bad job they dumped him and came back to me offering twice as much midway through the production. Sadly the film never got released, as they tried to cheap out on everything the same way, resulting in injuries, some unusable footage, and an absentee director who vanished rather than get sued. Oddly enough I got a lot of follow-up gigs from that disaster - suffering builds bonds and boy did we suffer on that job.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:41PM (#13525783)
> If it's something virtual, they'll put the same value on it that you put on completed movies as a consumer, a few bucks that bears no relation whatsoever to the effort you had to invest.

I would think there's a clear difference between consumer and B2B solutions here. As a business, it's a clear trade-off, pay X for the base models I can presumably get for some percentage of X, or just pay someone X dollars to do it, and presumably that percentage is well under 100% because the company has already done (and hopefully used) the work once, so it's just a way to monetize and existing resource. For a consumer, I don't really have the option of making a movie myself rather than paying for it. B2B products routinely cost tens of thousands of dollars.

Now, if you're saying specifically that industry will value it that way because of the way they are, well, that might be true. Sounds like you would know better than me. At the same time, may a service like that isn't marketed towards the studios, but towards the special FX houses, and they just factor it into their costs, bids, etc.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:33PM (#13526069)
You may think whatever you'd like, but you'll be underbid while you're making your value proposition. Of course people pay for CG services but the money is in content creation+. If your offering is too obviously recycled then it will be devalued in proportion. It's worth thinking of every film as a startup spun off by a studio, with a correspondingly short-term view of revenue cs. expenses.

+ by which I mean every director and producer want something nobody has ever seen before, which is the surest route to $$$.

That leads to a very zero-sum approach to negotiations; if you do not have some sort of existing contract (eg by virtue of union or guild membership and the resulting standardized pricing agreements) then as a new entrant to the market you will be asked to work for nothing. Even if you're well-established this is a big problem. A good example of this was when highly-esteemed CFX house Rhythm & Hues went bankrupt a few years ago: http://variety.com/2013/film/news/rhythm-hues-bankruptcy-rev...

As a more prosaic real-life example, I once earned myself a nice cash bonus for recovering all the footage from a project after the primary and backup drives both failed (or so it seemed to the less technical people). Had I proposed making the same investment in data protection up front, I guarantee the answer would have been No. While you do expect to work with the same people again, often over many years, every individual project is its own financial entity and producers' primary job skill is to hoard cash and minimize obligations.

This isn't just because they're jerks (although being a jerk is a necessary job skill, which is why I'm bad at being a producer lol), but because when you're in production the scarcity switches from money to time. Actors have other commitments, the weather can't be controlled, locations are rented for very short durations with large overages if you exceed the rental period and so on. So the basic business strategy notwithstanding scale is to hang on to as much money as you possibly can until you go into production, at which point you start spending money like water and trying to save time instead. Obviously an unscrupulous person can exploit that phase transition profitably, but doing so deliberately will tarnish your reputation, and your personal reputation carries far far more weight than your work product, unless your work product is really world-class and people take the time to evaluate it. Of course I'm simplifying, but consider the thousands of people who have credits on a big movie. You can't exhaustively evaluate the quality of their individual contributions when you're hiring at that scale, and most producers have limited technical and even aesthetic ability anyway, so a thumbs-up from someone they've worked carries far more weight.

I'm not trying to scare you out of participating int he industry, because in many ways it's really great and really does function on a meritocratic basis - if you're smart and innovative you can go a long way in a short time. But don't bank on a rational strategy, because the film industry manufactures dreams. Our work product is literally an escape from everyday reality that can be easily reproduced and distributed. In that sense it's kinda like doing business with a drug cartel - you can make a lot of money, but you have to approach each deal like it's the last one you'll ever make.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:59PM (#13526208)
That's why I got out of animation software. Either they're in development, and their credit card transactions bounce, or they're in production and they want a new feature yesterday.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by cowardlydragon on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:41AM (#13528321)
So, the economics aren't different for Netflix et al?

maybe you need to get back in with them

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:03AM (#13528415)
I fully accept your take on this, I'm just wondering if the downsides could be mitigated by targeting a layer back from the production itself, and instead towards the graphics houses, and not making it a pay for work service, but a pay for access library, similar to scientific journal access (a loaded comparison, but imagine a less controversial system than Elsevier). If it's access to thousands of models of various levels of detail for a flat price, and it's always growing, then maybe it gets treated by Adobe CS or MS Office for those places where it's useful. You pay for it because it's cheaper than the alternative, and since you are doing paid work and running a business, pirating it isn't worth the risk.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by sandebert on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#13525197)
You do realise that we need to hear more about that story, right?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:45PM (#13526130)
Which part - the broken bones of the actors trying to run up a rain-soaked grassy hill in clogs? The 35 hour shifts in shitty weather? The time we almost killed the lead actress and he boyfriend spend the rest of the week sleeping in the communal toilet? That was one of those jobs where the production work was a lot scarier than the actual script :-D

I joke about it now but in all seriousness bad producers are always trying to cut corners and this sometimes comes at the price of human lives, and even when people go to jail over it the costs are distributed inequitably - see this example of a director getting a 2 year sentence for causing the death of a crew member in an entirely predictable way: https://petapixel.com/2015/03/10/director-gets-two-years-in-...

At the low-budget end you have to be willing to threaten to quit on the spot no matter where you are, because you will be asked to put your safety at risk. I've never worked on a project where anyone died, but I've come close a few times. That's one reason I have such strong opinions about labor codes and safety regulations - I'm used to working outside them :-/

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by dvtv75 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:48PM (#13546640)
I've worked in the low budget end of TV. Studio stuff mainly. The number of close calls I've seen are unbelievable, but nothing quite on that scale.

We did have one guy get a minor electric shock because the producer had him changing a light. He was on top of a five foot ladder but with no spotter ("Health and safety BS!") and the producer never bothered to tell him that it was still carrying current, even when the fader was right down. That's not the only time someone's fallen off a ladder, or had a shock. Not once was it reported to the health and safety people, either.

There were also cable loops standing up from the ground (we used short pieces of carpet offcuts to hold them down, never worked and people would trip up. The business manager would never authorize the cash to have flush-mount patch panels installed in the floor (a legal requirement). Also not reported.

One memory is how we had a strict uniform requirement, which often resulted in inappropriate dress for a location. There were a couple of location shoots in below-freezing conditions - in one place, three staff came down with hypothermia because they were clad in sweatshirts and jeans, another it was just one guy in a shirt and dress pants standing outside for seven hours while ice formed on car windows. That particular day, the lucky staff indoors were exposed to unsafe sound levels, with no protection, for the whole shoot. None of these incidents were reported, nor was it reported that the guy who drove the equipment truck back to the studio had been smoking pot for the whole night, in front of the senior staff at the location. Maybe he shared the joint.

Chuck in some 12+ hour shifts without breaks, people working on scaffolding who had no clue how to operate safely, or the guy who replaced an old monitor only to accidentally drop the failed unit, and ended up hauled in front of the Production Manager to account for his "unsafe" actions.

Equipment was never maintained: if something broke, it was the person using it at the time, not the 20-year-old tripod with broken spreaders and worn out fastenings. (Last time I saw that particular tripod, the spreaders had perished and were being held together by duct tape on three sides, and the tape was four or five years old.)

Oh, the stories I could tell... no, wait, that's actually a good summary right there!

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by sandebert on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:33AM (#13528526)
Yeah, that part! Pile it all together into a script and make a movie out of it. I'd watch it! :)

(Note to folks at HN: if behind-the-scenes movies are your thing, check out Living in Oblivion with Steve Buscemi and Catherine Keener. Good stuff.)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by cowardlydragon on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:40AM (#13528319)
Based on the article, he shouldn't be talking to Hollywood, he should be talking to Google/Amazon/Netflix/Microsoft/Facebook.

They don't give a rats ass about reputation if you deliver what they need.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by royjacobs on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:11PM (#13525058)
Companies like Stargate Digital are doing exactly this. They've created things like a virtual New York and Chicago that was used by shows like Nurse Betty and ER. Saves those shows from flying their cast out of LA for location shooting and usually nobody really notices anyway.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by apercu on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:22PM (#13524641)
"licensed"?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by philippnagel on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:25PM (#13524676)
SaaS (Sets as a Service)?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by curun1r on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:19PM (#13524615)
I wonder whether this could be an area where Google has a huge head start on everyone else. They've literally got images of millions of city streets around the world at ground level for the Street View feature of Maps. And they're not exactly lacking in AI talent. If anyone is able to generate realistic CGI models automatically, it would be them.

I could see them offering Hollywood a service that would allow production assistants to scout locations in Maps and then, after choosing one, get back detailed CGI models which allow all filming to happen on a green screen for a fraction of the current cost of filming on location.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by RileyKyeden on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:47PM (#13527103)
Microsoft is working on this too: https://twitter.com/RileyReverb/status/825146383745351681

I was surprised when I opened the map app and it had 3D imagery of the little barely-known city I live in.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by gamblor956 on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:12PM (#13525543)
In the past, we had the Hollywood backlot.

We still have the Hollywood back lots, and studios still use LA, New York, and Chicago streets as their sets. A lot of times, it's cheaper to just pay for a filming permit than it is to recreate the real world in a computer.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by petra on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:13PM (#13525071)
>> Netflix has no huge advantage.

Netflix has better data about what and how viewers watch, That gives it some advantage. than, a netflix one-hour episode cost about $5-$10 Million.Breaking Bad did costs $3M/ep. That's $5-$15 for a movie of content. About the cost of Iron Sky.

Than instead of spending a lot of money on marketing, they use their algorithm. And even if they do spend some money marketing online, it's easier, because consumption can be immediate and measured.

Than you have the favorable economics of TV series - it's basically a 20-30 movie sequels with very good customer loyalty. And there are no time limits - people can watch whenever they like, and the content has some value over years/decades.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jonahrd on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:56PM (#13523983)
> If you cut corners, it looks like Youtube crap.

I wonder where series like Louie and It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia fit into this mix. They're pretty low budget and do look pretty Youtubey, especially the earlier seasons. But for some reason that doesn't detract from the quality of the show at all.

Do audiences actually need high production value if they have great acting, writing, directing?

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by yoodenvranx on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:14PM (#13524117)
> Do audiences actually need high production value if they have great acting, writing, directing?

No.

I'd rather watch 90 minutes of random "Whose line is it anyway" segmentd in 360p Youtube than the latest Transformers rendered in 8K.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ghaff on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:18PM (#13524142)
For mainstream audiences? Pretty much yes.

Downton Abbey would not have been a hit if it had 1980s BBC production standards. Nor would the rebooted Battlestar Galactica have been as popular if it had the production values of the original.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by tomjen3 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:46PM (#13525342)
Downton Abbey had a pretty formularic script for at least the first 3 seasons though. A season based arc to try to save it, then it get fixed just for a new peril to start the next season.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by santaclaus on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:44PM (#13524832)
Necessary but not sufficient for many genres. Guardians of Galaxy wouldn't have been nearly as fun without the amazing visual effects (imagine the raccoon guy as a muppet), but would have been Transformers slop if the writing and characters hadn't been interesting.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by fredsir on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:12PM (#13524095)
Probably not in It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, but in Game of Thrones, poor production detracts.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by acchow on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:52PM (#13524407)
> Do audiences actually need high production value if they have great acting, writing, directing?

La La Land was made with a $30M budget and has grossed >$220M already.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ghaff on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:07PM (#13524525)
$30M may not be big budget by Hollywood standards but it's hardly "low budget" and, from what I've seen, La La Land looks like a fully professional Hollywood production.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by duncanawoods on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:12PM (#13524100)
Last I heard Louie CK was in debt after self-funding his last series. Could have been different production values / unusual business model though.

http://variety.com/2016/tv/news/louis-c-k-millions-horace-pe...

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by slg on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:47PM (#13524369)
That whole story was a case of reporters not knowing what they were talking about. Every television/movie production is in debt at that point of the process. All the money is spent up front and it takes a while to recoup those losses and turn a profit (the whole long tail thing). The difference was this was self financed so the debt was his and not some studio's.

It is very similar to what happens at startups. No one expects revenue from day one but the losses can start immediately. Louie CK basically founded a startup and decided not to take any VC money. That means when it came time for his IPO (the digital streaming deal he signed with Hulu), all the money went directly to him making the entire endeavor profitable.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by bisby on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:31PM (#13524248)
horace and pete was great, but it was definitely not for his core audience. it's not comedy or really a show. It's more like a filmed stage performance. A lot of people I know bought the first 1-2 episodes thinking it would be hysterical and never bought more after they realized what it was, and never even gave it a chance since it caught them off guard.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by krrrh on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:38PM (#13524297)
One of the things that caught my attention watching the credits for Louie was that Louie CK himself was listed as editor in addition to his other roles.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by magic_beans on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:28PM (#13524217)
I love the real-life quality of shows like Louie and Broad City.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by drewrv on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:38PM (#13524299)
Your examples are comedies, which can get away with it as the audience isn't expected to take things seriously.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ghaff on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:14PM (#13524119)
>Viewers today expect incredible production value.

Great point. I'm always a bit shocked at the level of effort put into lighting etc. for even simple corporate talking heads sort of video. Technology has driven down the costs associated with good cameras, editing software, and CGI. But expectations have risen at least as much. (HD is also a lot less forgiving.)

There are some genuinely low-ish cost hits but they're very much the outliers.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by fulafel on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:41PM (#13524322)
Maybe it's a supply-side effect: Movie-making is an attractive field, like computer games and rock bands. Those also enjoy high investment compared to payoff. People keep doing more of them even though they often lose money.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by curtis on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:01PM (#13524010)
...but as yet, nobody has been able to procedurally generate one convincing block of a city street seen at ground level...

I'm wondering if technology might also make it much easier to shoot on location. For example, given modern digital camera systems it might be possible to shoot in low-light conditions (late in the day, overcast, etc.) and correct the lighting in post to appear like broad daylight. I've also wondered if it would be possible to shoot in 3d (i.e. using 2 cameras in a parallax setup) then use the 3d data to selectively remove foreground or background parts of the image which can then be replaced with CGI. So we can continue to use the real world to provide detail, while using CGI just for the parts that give us the most bang for the buck.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:15PM (#13524131)
The reverse has been done. In "The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen", the dark, rainy look of London was added in post.

Removing backgrounds is more manual than you may expect. There are commercial "clipping path services" in low-wage countries. Even when green screens are used, the boundaries may need a bit of touch-up. It's a possible application for deep learning.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by pixel_fcker on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:47PM (#13525835)
You can't make overcast look like broad daylight or vice versa because the nature of the shadows change dramatically.

That doesn't mean people don't do it all the time, it just looks like garbage.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by vilya on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:50PM (#13524391)
The term you're looking for here is a depth matte. It's a technique that's been in use for many years now, but of course it's only as reliable as your depth data so it's just one of the many tools in a compositor's tool belt.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by dijit on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:47PM (#13524371)
RE: Shooting on location in low light;

Yes, it was done in 28 Days later on the Westminister bridge over which Big Ben looms.

Shot at night, with a camera which had a large aperture.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by probably_wrong on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:47PM (#13524861)
> "Iron Sky" was made for €7.5 million. Worldwide box office $11.5 million. Fail.

To be fair, Iron Sky is terrible. I mean, it has a lot of "so bad it's good" value, but let's not pretend the CGI (which is actually awesome for a script this bad) was the only problem.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Already__Taken on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:10PM (#13525048)
If anything that's a terrible film with shockingly good production values. It has no right being made as well as it was. Here I thought that was part of the joke.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by pikzen on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:52PM (#13525386)
I don't see anything terrible in black-made-white-brainwashed-jetpacking space nazis.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by pluma on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:51AM (#13529456)
The premise is good, alas that is not enough to make for an entertaining movie.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ansible on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:02PM (#13525906)
Production cost is a problem, and technology has made it worse. Look at that long, long list of animators and technicians at the end of any effects-heavy film today. A cast of thousands.

I predict the hordes of animators and motion capture will be going away for all but the biggest productions within a decade.

Check this out:

http://www.goatstream.com/research/thesis/index.html

If you can combine this with more detailed physics simulations of the entire world, that will drastically cut down the amount of animation required.

This, combined with being able to easily capture objects and environments in 3-D via scanning it from a video file (SLAM[1], basically), and add in some basic mo-cap in-world via VR controllers. We can have much higher quality productions with Reboot-level (or machinima) levels of staffing.

Someone (not me!) needs to start putting this all together in an easy-to-use package.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simultaneous_localization_and_...

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by iampliny on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:20PM (#13524628)
Small, but important distinction: Studios don't make content. Studios made deals.

Film production is a smiling curve: on the left you have "development"; on the right, distribution. Actual content creation is 100% farmed out to production companies and their vendors (like VFX houses, et al).

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ck425 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:49AM (#13529158)
True, but the author makes a solid point about the new distribution systems being created by people who value efficiency and are experts at disrupting inefficient industries. Netflix and Amazon might currently be just buying content but I'd be surprised if soon they don't experimenting with making it themselves.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by notdan on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:35PM (#13527339)
"Making GTA V cost $265 million" <-- Your point probably still stands but this number isn't completely true. The total was $265 million but 'only' $137 million was development cost. The rest ($128m) was marketing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_expensive_video_g...
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by NamTaf on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:50AM (#13528368)
It blows my mind that approximately half the total costs of a game are marketing, especially for a series as big as GTA which presumably markets itself pretty well.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:26PM (#13523702)
> "Iron Sky" was made for €7.5 million. Worldwide box office $11.5 million. Fail.

I wish I could "fail" by making 53% profit on millions over what is likely less than a year. :/

Edit: Actually, I see pounds and dollars now. I would guess it was about even?

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by pixel_fcker on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:57PM (#13525888)
Trying to guess at whether a film made money or not is a very murky science. Reported budgets are rarely accurate and do not include interest on loads taken to fund the production, or marketing costs (can be 50% of the production budget again for a global blockbuster release). These costs are offset by subsidies and tax breaks from filming or posting in certain locations, and from product placement and licensing deals - licensing alone can entirely cover the cost of main production for some big "event" movies.

Then, as others have said, the theatre takes a cut, then the distributor takes a cut, and so in the end a movie that takes twice its budget at the box office may still be in the red as far as the production company is concerned.

This is all made even more opaque by all the accounting trickery to minimize tax exposure and make sure that the studio has to pay "points" (contractually agreed percentage of profit/revenue after some break-even) to as few people as possible.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by gribbly on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:15PM (#13524125)
You also forget that box office money is shared between the distributor and the movie theatre, from what I've gathered the domestic cut is typically 55-60% in favour of the distributor, and some 25% in the foreign box office.

So it has to do about twice the production costs at the box office in order to break even, that said there's that whole 'Hollywood accounting' aspect to consider.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:47PM (#13525834)
When I worked at a movie theater as a teenager, the manager explained it like so: The first 5-6 weeks, the studio make 85%-90% of the box office profits, after that the percentages start changing, to the point that at 10 weeks or so and past, the theater makes a much higher percentage. Long running movies are thus fairly profitable for theaters.

If this holds up (since it's entirely second hand info), I would expect the total split you quoted to likely be for large blockbusters that stay in the theaters for a long time. For a small movie, or one that doesn't make much money and is forced out to make room for more popular movies, I would expect that percentage going to the studio to actually be much higher.

Corrections from someone with actual knowledge is welcome though.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:39PM (#13523818)
€ is the Euro symbol.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by michaelmrose on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:29PM (#13523724)
Also would think you have to win by more to cover all the losses.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ouid on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:26PM (#13527602)
euros
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by hondo77 on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:28PM (#13526051)
> That didn't happen. Not even close.

Oh please. Sin City: budget $40 million, box office $158.8 million. A good director who knows how to squeeze the most out of a budget can get the job done in a cost-effective way. Just ask Mr. Rodriguez.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by davvolun on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:44PM (#13534465)
Monsters (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsters_(2010_film)) is my response to that. The problem with "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" wasn't that it was low budget, it was that it decided part-way through to become (relatively) high-budget. A carefully constructed film with $500,000 budget made $4.2 million back on good, but limited, effects. The problem is Hollywood's approach; instead of making a handful of single-A movies, it's all either B movies or AAA.

Video games were (?) having the same problem, so-called "indie" developers have largely stepped in to make single A-quality titles.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by whyenot on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:14AM (#13527881)
The film Tangerine was shot entirely on the iPhone with a budget of $100k. It earned $794k at the box office.

It's still possible to produce commercially successful low budget films with lower production values. The trick is to tell an interesting and engaging story.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by mvindahl on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:45AM (#13528832)
> "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" started as a low-budget picture rendered on Macs. In that film, if nobody touches it, it's CG. Ended up costing $70 million. Worldwide box office $50 million. Fail. "Iron Sky" was made for €7.5 million. Worldwide box office $11.5 million. Fail.

I know very little about the film industry, but is the box office the end of it? I was presuming that there was always some kind of long tail of modest cash flow from stuff like video rentals (days of yore) or online streaming services (present day). Is this a wrong assumption?

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by nerfhammer on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:40PM (#13524311)
I felt like I could see this in Rogue One: different parts of the film were done by completely different production companies, results varied, and they had to go with whatever they had by the ship date.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by maxxxxx on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:45PM (#13524356)
I remember listing to a radio interview someone from Pixar and he said one of their biggest advantages is that they have stable teams that keep working together from movie to movie. Whereas other movies are being made by teams that get assembled for one movie and after finishing go their own way.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Brakenshire on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:00PM (#13525442)
I was hearing today about the Dogme manifesto today, seems like it could be relevant:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogme_95

It's basically a set of rules to cut down the cost and complexity of film production, to give power back to directors. I wonder whether you could have a category of films like this, aiming specifically to exist outside the normal Hollywood system.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by MichaelMoser123 on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:40PM (#13524800)
> That's why Hollywood generates so many sequels - predictability.

Does it have anything to do with the size of the studios/companies? Look at Disney/Pixar, can it be that they are just too big in order to come up with anything original?

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by viewtransform on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:09PM (#13526903)
It has more to do with risk management coming out of the finance dept.

The studio knows that a sequel will have a guaranteed $ minimum return just because it is a sequel. Hence they can estimate how much to sink into production to guarantee a profit. Then they green light the movie production for that budget.

Same goes for the cast. The studio finance dept can look at previous years data and predict that $ million will be guaranteed to be made just because the movie stars Jennifer Aniston or Adam Sandler. Irrespective of the what the movie is about. Just because people see the name and wander into the theatre while on a date or buy the DVD for $15.99 at the grocery store. This provides a target production budget for green lighting the movie. Then they hire a director and try to figure what the story will be about.

The China market also affects cast and story. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8R-FQTY4KJk

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by tomjen3 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:43PM (#13525316)
I don't know why Iron sky returning ~50% is not considered a success, but it is a pretty funny movie. Also if budgets are what we go buy, the Blair Witch project, which grossed nearly a 1/4 billion at a budget of 60k.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kristianp on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:48PM (#13525353)
Two different currencies: cost in Euros, returns in dollars.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by ktRolster on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:11PM (#13525057)
"Iron Sky" was made for €7.5 million. Worldwide box office $11.5 million. Fail.

That sounds successful to me, actually.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by legodt on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:26PM (#13523701)
To be fair, both movies you listed as low budget flops are in the same niche genre, I think that's more of a trend of people not being interested in that sort of movie right now.