Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over
by AnimalMuppet on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:54PM
(#13524899)
Great movies require great writing, and then good-to-great acting. CGI? None is fine, but if there is any, it also needs to be good-to-great.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over
by mortenjorck on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:12PM
(#13525062)
Indeed, bad CG can ruin an otherwise great movie. My go-to example is the high-concept 2008 Mexican Sci-fi thriller Sleep Dealer - had the director simply chosen to have the biggest action setpieces happen off-screen or be otherwise implied, it might have been enough of a success to make back its modest 2.5M investment, but the abysmal CG they were able to get on that budget brought the whole film down.
I enjoyed babylon 5 a couple of years ago which has poor special effects by today's standards. The bad CGI did not detract from it at all.
Hey, it had poor visual effects by its day's standards as well! Great writing though.
I thought they were cutting edge at the time,everyone else was still using scale models weren't they?
It wasn't cutting edge at the time. I started doing pro VFX about that time. What was revolutionary with their VFX though was that they were using Lightwave (and Amigas, presumably PCs later too) which cheapened their VFX workflow by a significant margin. Workstations and software at the time were a significant cost. Like, REAL SIGNIFICANT.
It was cutting edge technology, but looked inferior to the physical models used by shows like Star Trek TNG or DS9 (I say sadly as a huge B5 fan).
I was a Star Trek fan back in the day and the effects were one of the reasons I never gave the show a fair chance. It just looked so low quality compared to the practical effects in other shows.
> Great movies require great writing, and then good-to-great acting.
I would argue against that last part; great movies do require great writing, but you can get good to great performances out of mediocre actors if you have a great director. No amount of good acting will overcome a bad director.