News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:34PM (#13523775)
> but as yet, nobody has been able to procedurally generate one convincing block of a city street seen at ground level.

This is an interesting point. In the past, we had the Hollywood backlot. Maybe we need the digital equivalent in the future. Instead of each production company making chunks of New York in CGI, what if there was a shared one that production companies could take as a base and alter as needed? I'm not sure what incentive structure would work best for something like this, but as long as studios don't get greedy about adding their work to it and expecting money back (which might be a tall order), open source might work.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by WorldMaker on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:43PM (#13524341)
I was joking that if Sony ImageWorks doesn't already have a relatively complete digital backlot for just about all of Manhattan between the Spider-Man and Ghostbusters franchises alone, then what have they been doing...

The interesting/tough part would presumably be inter-effects house sharing/community work. I'm almost surprised that there doesn't seem to be a company focused entirely on reuseable digital backlots because that does seem like a niche that someone in Hollywood would already be exploring.

You could also see it coming from an outside direction, too. If I was Rockstar and already throwing hundreds of millions of dollars at digital open world simulations, I'd probably be shopping that around as the basis for digital backlot work. "Filmed 'on location' in GTA V's Los Santos" sounds almost silly right now, but I've got a feeling it won't for much longer. (Also, I would suspect it's Vancouver-based genre television that would be in the market for this before films.)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:52PM (#13524891)
There is some model reuse, but the economics of piracy work against it: if it's just a copy of something that's been seen before, nobody wants to pay anything substantial for it. One reason I stopped working full-time in film was the constant pressure to slash my prices. I was able to make enough to stay afloat for a decade or so, but not to grow my business. by investing in a large stock of equipment or hiring permanent staff of my own. No matter how good you are you are constantly being asked to work for free or below market rate, because distribution income is like a black hole; production money goes in but it's not obvious where it comes back out. In the indie world the typical distribution deal covers the costs of production, legal etc. and only that. So your film gets distribution - yay! - but you won't see any revenue from it until the production cost has been paid off and the distribution company has made a profit, so possibly never. Once you get distribution the project is dead and has to be forgotten about other than as a line on your resume - the fact that you can mention the existence of a distributor tells potential investors that they have a better-than-even chance of getting their money back if they spend it on you.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by viewtransform on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:32PM (#13526729)
Sony Imageworks had a reusable digital library for the buildings in Manhattan. The fire from GhostRider also saw reuse. These models are tied to the production pipeline at Sony: the shaders, data formats, texture pipeline, effects pipeline etc. A reusable backlot company does not exist because a standard studio production pipeline does not exist.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by WorldMaker on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @11:33AM (#13532060)
This is an interesting point. As an outsider to all of it, I'm curious if the open source work Pixar started and Disney has continued in standardizing various asset pipelines is helping, or at least might eventually help the landscape here.

Again as a relatively pure outsider, it is interesting to watch the internal competition between Disney Feature Animation's renderer [Hyperion] and Pixar's RenderMan, and similarly have been curious about how much of that externally visible open source standardizing work on at least the pipelines leading to the renderers contributes and/or constrains the friendly seeming internal rivalry. Similarly with Disney now owning ILM, if ILM has or has not been building on top of some of the same production pipeline standards...

Historically, a lot of the benefit to the Hollywood studio system was that a lot of the parts were standardized and interchangeable between studios. While a lot of studios did experiment with innovations in camera technology, very few studios had to reinvent the camera from scratch.

Given how many special effects houses work on a blockbuster level film these days, I would imagine that the efficiencies in shared asset pipelines between corporate boundaries would eventually win out. It seems silly (at least as an industry outsider) that every company working on, for one example, an Iron Man film would have a different set of models/textures/shaders for Iron Man. (I get that on the one hand it's a bit like stunt work in that you don't need your A-list actor in every stunt or B-roll shot, but on the other hand, digital "actors" don't get fatigued or injured and can be in multiple places at once, they don't need body doubles/stunt actors...)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by viewtransform on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:52PM (#13535092)
There has been standardization in many areas since the days of Toy Story: Autodesk Maya, Houdini, Nuke are now standards in the industry.

It took a while for forward thinking technical managers to convince studio executives that open-sourcing some internal tools and data formats would benefit the studio by making it a standard within the industry. OpenEXR (image format, ILM), Alembic(data format, Imageworks), OpenSubdiv(subdivison surfaces, Pixar), Ptex(texture mapping, Disney) are examples that were quickly adopted across studios. It helps that artists and engineers tend to move across studios bringing with them ideas about what worked best at the previous studio.

In general, the software teams at the studios fall under the line item of "Overhead" in a producers financial spreadsheet. There is pressure to reduce this overhead by adopting standardized tools and not reinventing things in-house.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:44PM (#13524836)
You really need a whole city's worth. People's expectations are really really high in this area, and their intuition is also pretty good - I can generally ID a composite shot before I even know what I'm supposed to be looking at, in much the same way as you can tell you're looking at a flat before you recognize what it's meant to depict. Eye candy is what people pay $$$ for, it's a lot harder (though not impossible) to get paid for a personal story that doesn't require any special effects.

There used to be a joke in the no-budget world - what's the difference between an indie movie and a studio film? In the indie movie you end with a car crash. In the studio film, the car explodes at the end of the first act.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:24PM (#13524192)
There's some model reuse. Pixar does it as a joke; the truck from Pizza Planet in Toy Story shows up in other movies. It's a minor business, like clip art. What can be a low-resolution detail in one application may need much higher detail in another, depending on how the camera moves.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by jdironman on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:44PM (#13523861)
I smell a startup. Leased CG sets.

(Just realized 'leased' may not be the correct term here, don't hold that against me I am not an entrepreneur by any means.)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:59PM (#13524942)
^^^^ This is why you research an industry before you go into it unless you want to lose your shirt. If you build or own something physical, people will pay to rent it from you. If it's something virtual, they'll put the same value on it that you put on completed movies as a consumer, a few bucks that bears no relation whatsoever to the effort you had to invest.

In hollywood you are nobody until you have some credits, and you don't get any credits until you have done some work, and you don't get hired if you're a nobody so you'd better be prepared to give it away and keep giving for a while until people come looking for you, at which point you practice saying 'no' a lot and meaning it. One of my more memorable gigs was on a film that I turned down because the pay was too low. So they went with someone else but he did such a bad job they dumped him and came back to me offering twice as much midway through the production. Sadly the film never got released, as they tried to cheap out on everything the same way, resulting in injuries, some unusable footage, and an absentee director who vanished rather than get sued. Oddly enough I got a lot of follow-up gigs from that disaster - suffering builds bonds and boy did we suffer on that job.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:41PM (#13525783)
> If it's something virtual, they'll put the same value on it that you put on completed movies as a consumer, a few bucks that bears no relation whatsoever to the effort you had to invest.

I would think there's a clear difference between consumer and B2B solutions here. As a business, it's a clear trade-off, pay X for the base models I can presumably get for some percentage of X, or just pay someone X dollars to do it, and presumably that percentage is well under 100% because the company has already done (and hopefully used) the work once, so it's just a way to monetize and existing resource. For a consumer, I don't really have the option of making a movie myself rather than paying for it. B2B products routinely cost tens of thousands of dollars.

Now, if you're saying specifically that industry will value it that way because of the way they are, well, that might be true. Sounds like you would know better than me. At the same time, may a service like that isn't marketed towards the studios, but towards the special FX houses, and they just factor it into their costs, bids, etc.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:33PM (#13526069)
You may think whatever you'd like, but you'll be underbid while you're making your value proposition. Of course people pay for CG services but the money is in content creation+. If your offering is too obviously recycled then it will be devalued in proportion. It's worth thinking of every film as a startup spun off by a studio, with a correspondingly short-term view of revenue cs. expenses.

+ by which I mean every director and producer want something nobody has ever seen before, which is the surest route to $$$.

That leads to a very zero-sum approach to negotiations; if you do not have some sort of existing contract (eg by virtue of union or guild membership and the resulting standardized pricing agreements) then as a new entrant to the market you will be asked to work for nothing. Even if you're well-established this is a big problem. A good example of this was when highly-esteemed CFX house Rhythm & Hues went bankrupt a few years ago: http://variety.com/2013/film/news/rhythm-hues-bankruptcy-rev...

As a more prosaic real-life example, I once earned myself a nice cash bonus for recovering all the footage from a project after the primary and backup drives both failed (or so it seemed to the less technical people). Had I proposed making the same investment in data protection up front, I guarantee the answer would have been No. While you do expect to work with the same people again, often over many years, every individual project is its own financial entity and producers' primary job skill is to hoard cash and minimize obligations.

This isn't just because they're jerks (although being a jerk is a necessary job skill, which is why I'm bad at being a producer lol), but because when you're in production the scarcity switches from money to time. Actors have other commitments, the weather can't be controlled, locations are rented for very short durations with large overages if you exceed the rental period and so on. So the basic business strategy notwithstanding scale is to hang on to as much money as you possibly can until you go into production, at which point you start spending money like water and trying to save time instead. Obviously an unscrupulous person can exploit that phase transition profitably, but doing so deliberately will tarnish your reputation, and your personal reputation carries far far more weight than your work product, unless your work product is really world-class and people take the time to evaluate it. Of course I'm simplifying, but consider the thousands of people who have credits on a big movie. You can't exhaustively evaluate the quality of their individual contributions when you're hiring at that scale, and most producers have limited technical and even aesthetic ability anyway, so a thumbs-up from someone they've worked carries far more weight.

I'm not trying to scare you out of participating int he industry, because in many ways it's really great and really does function on a meritocratic basis - if you're smart and innovative you can go a long way in a short time. But don't bank on a rational strategy, because the film industry manufactures dreams. Our work product is literally an escape from everyday reality that can be easily reproduced and distributed. In that sense it's kinda like doing business with a drug cartel - you can make a lot of money, but you have to approach each deal like it's the last one you'll ever make.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:59PM (#13526208)
That's why I got out of animation software. Either they're in development, and their credit card transactions bounce, or they're in production and they want a new feature yesterday.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by cowardlydragon on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:41AM (#13528321)
So, the economics aren't different for Netflix et al?

maybe you need to get back in with them

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by kbenson on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:03AM (#13528415)
I fully accept your take on this, I'm just wondering if the downsides could be mitigated by targeting a layer back from the production itself, and instead towards the graphics houses, and not making it a pay for work service, but a pay for access library, similar to scientific journal access (a loaded comparison, but imagine a less controversial system than Elsevier). If it's access to thousands of models of various levels of detail for a flat price, and it's always growing, then maybe it gets treated by Adobe CS or MS Office for those places where it's useful. You pay for it because it's cheaper than the alternative, and since you are doing paid work and running a business, pirating it isn't worth the risk.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by sandebert on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#13525197)
You do realise that we need to hear more about that story, right?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:45PM (#13526130)
Which part - the broken bones of the actors trying to run up a rain-soaked grassy hill in clogs? The 35 hour shifts in shitty weather? The time we almost killed the lead actress and he boyfriend spend the rest of the week sleeping in the communal toilet? That was one of those jobs where the production work was a lot scarier than the actual script :-D

I joke about it now but in all seriousness bad producers are always trying to cut corners and this sometimes comes at the price of human lives, and even when people go to jail over it the costs are distributed inequitably - see this example of a director getting a 2 year sentence for causing the death of a crew member in an entirely predictable way: https://petapixel.com/2015/03/10/director-gets-two-years-in-...

At the low-budget end you have to be willing to threaten to quit on the spot no matter where you are, because you will be asked to put your safety at risk. I've never worked on a project where anyone died, but I've come close a few times. That's one reason I have such strong opinions about labor codes and safety regulations - I'm used to working outside them :-/

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by dvtv75 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:48PM (#13546640)
I've worked in the low budget end of TV. Studio stuff mainly. The number of close calls I've seen are unbelievable, but nothing quite on that scale.

We did have one guy get a minor electric shock because the producer had him changing a light. He was on top of a five foot ladder but with no spotter ("Health and safety BS!") and the producer never bothered to tell him that it was still carrying current, even when the fader was right down. That's not the only time someone's fallen off a ladder, or had a shock. Not once was it reported to the health and safety people, either.

There were also cable loops standing up from the ground (we used short pieces of carpet offcuts to hold them down, never worked and people would trip up. The business manager would never authorize the cash to have flush-mount patch panels installed in the floor (a legal requirement). Also not reported.

One memory is how we had a strict uniform requirement, which often resulted in inappropriate dress for a location. There were a couple of location shoots in below-freezing conditions - in one place, three staff came down with hypothermia because they were clad in sweatshirts and jeans, another it was just one guy in a shirt and dress pants standing outside for seven hours while ice formed on car windows. That particular day, the lucky staff indoors were exposed to unsafe sound levels, with no protection, for the whole shoot. None of these incidents were reported, nor was it reported that the guy who drove the equipment truck back to the studio had been smoking pot for the whole night, in front of the senior staff at the location. Maybe he shared the joint.

Chuck in some 12+ hour shifts without breaks, people working on scaffolding who had no clue how to operate safely, or the guy who replaced an old monitor only to accidentally drop the failed unit, and ended up hauled in front of the Production Manager to account for his "unsafe" actions.

Equipment was never maintained: if something broke, it was the person using it at the time, not the 20-year-old tripod with broken spreaders and worn out fastenings. (Last time I saw that particular tripod, the spreaders had perished and were being held together by duct tape on three sides, and the tape was four or five years old.)

Oh, the stories I could tell... no, wait, that's actually a good summary right there!

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by sandebert on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:33AM (#13528526)
Yeah, that part! Pile it all together into a script and make a movie out of it. I'd watch it! :)

(Note to folks at HN: if behind-the-scenes movies are your thing, check out Living in Oblivion with Steve Buscemi and Catherine Keener. Good stuff.)

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by cowardlydragon on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:40AM (#13528319)
Based on the article, he shouldn't be talking to Hollywood, he should be talking to Google/Amazon/Netflix/Microsoft/Facebook.

They don't give a rats ass about reputation if you deliver what they need.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by royjacobs on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:11PM (#13525058)
Companies like Stargate Digital are doing exactly this. They've created things like a virtual New York and Chicago that was used by shows like Nurse Betty and ER. Saves those shows from flying their cast out of LA for location shooting and usually nobody really notices anyway.
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by apercu on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:22PM (#13524641)
"licensed"?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by philippnagel on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:25PM (#13524676)
SaaS (Sets as a Service)?
Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by curun1r on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:19PM (#13524615)
I wonder whether this could be an area where Google has a huge head start on everyone else. They've literally got images of millions of city streets around the world at ground level for the Street View feature of Maps. And they're not exactly lacking in AI talent. If anyone is able to generate realistic CGI models automatically, it would be them.

I could see them offering Hollywood a service that would allow production assistants to scout locations in Maps and then, after choosing one, get back detailed CGI models which allow all filming to happen on a green screen for a fraction of the current cost of filming on location.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by RileyKyeden on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:47PM (#13527103)
Microsoft is working on this too: https://twitter.com/RileyReverb/status/825146383745351681

I was surprised when I opened the map app and it had 3D imagery of the little barely-known city I live in.

Re:Hollywood as We Know It Is Over by gamblor956 on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:12PM (#13525543)
In the past, we had the Hollywood backlot.

We still have the Hollywood back lots, and studios still use LA, New York, and Chicago streets as their sets. A lot of times, it's cheaper to just pay for a filming permit than it is to recreate the real world in a computer.