News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by Pfhreak on Sunday January 29, 2017 @11:49AM (#13514982)
Uber undermining the taxi strike [1] yesterday was pretty visible -- at least in my social circle here in Seattle -- and when Lyft made this announcement we all deleted our Uber accounts.

Will that have a material impact on anyone's bottom line? Who knows, but I'd love to see the graphs for new account signups/account deletions.

[1] Taxis were not servicing JFK in support of those who were being detained there.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by mozumder on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:00PM (#13515040)
Here's the great & intense statement from the New York Taxi Workers Alliance on their JFK strike:

"NYTWA STATEMENT ON MUSLIM BAN:

Professional drivers are over 20 times more likely to be murdered on the job than other workers. By sanctioning bigotry with his unconstitutional and inhumane executive order banning Muslim refugees from seven countries, the president is putting professional drivers in more danger than they have been in any time since 9/11 when hate crimes against immigrants skyrocketed.

Our 19,000-member-strong union stands firmly opposed to Donald Trump's Muslim ban. As an organization whose membership is largely Muslim, a workforce that's almost universally immigrant, and a working-class movement that is rooted in the defense of the oppressed, we say no to this inhumane and unconstitutional ban.

We know all too well that when government programs sanction outright Islamophobia, and the rhetoric of hate is spewed from the bully pulpit, hate crimes increase and drivers suffer gravely. Our Sikh and other non-Muslim brown and black members also suffer from anti-Muslim violence.

Today, drivers are joining the protest at JFK Airport in support of all those who are currently being detained at the airport because of Trump's unconstitutional executive order. Drivers stand in solidarity with refugees coming to America in search of peace and safety and with those who are simply trying to return to their homes here in America after traveling abroad. We stand in solidarity with all of our peace-loving neighbors against this inhumane, cruel, and unconstitutional act of pure bigotry."

From: https://www.facebook.com/nytwa/posts/1562624543751719

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by justinpombrio on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:50PM (#13515455)
I hate asking about downvotes, but I'm really confused why this comment has been pushed to the bottom. Why?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:16PM (#13515669)
Well, it's not a "Muslim Ban" for starters. Look up the countries with the highest Muslim populations, then cross ref to the list of countries that have a 90 day (to start) ban.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by lifeformed on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:31PM (#13516428)
It is a Muslim ban. It's just how you do it politically. You start with the goal of banning Muslims, then you see how to implement it in a way that gives you plausible deniability. You couldn't get away with just saying, "No Muslims allowed." That is way too overtly racist and illegal. So you look for existing groupings of countries that align with your goals.

You find a list of countries banned on the visa waiver program made by the previous administration, and it covers many Muslim nations that are in the international spotlight right now. They're hot topics and it fits your criteria well. (Also they conveniently don't intersect with your business interests, so that's another plus.) You ignore Indonesia and India because they aren't in the news for terrorism, so it doesn't fit your narrative. Now you can get away with banning these "previously chosen" countries, by saying it's for national security, while you wink to your more explicitly racist supporters. You achieved their racist goal, de-facto, while having a non-racist "legitimate" excuse.

This is how institutional racism works. You have a racist goal in mind, and you implement it through actions that are under the guise of something more reasonable. It has the same effect as if you just made some overtly racist policy, but you can do it legally and with plausible deniability.

Also, if it helps, Rudy Giuliani said on national TV that Trump told him to do literally exactly this.

[dead]
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by mozumder on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:30PM (#13517495)
I agree that we should ban whites from this country, since they commit the vast majority of murders here in America. So many innocent lives have been lost to white murderers that own guns.

I mean, if we're going to be bigoted and ascribe negative traits to entire groups based on the actions of a few, shouldn't we do that to protect our safety by ascribing whites as murderers based on them committing the vast majority of the 17,000 murders that happen in our country every year?

America needs to defend themselves against whites, who are placing carnage into our peaceful country with their murderous ways.

If whites can't find a way to make peaceful journey in the world, then they have to go. Moderate whites need to step up and completely denounce their violent sub-groups. COMPLETELY DENOUNCE -- not quietly bolster or nod knowingly to.

(this is how bigotry works, and remember, it can go both ways. Do you want this kind of bigotry to happen to whites? I get that it's hard to not be bigoted when it's so much easier mentally to associate a race with the actions of a few, but that's what it takes to be smart- you have to actually think instead of being mentally lazy)

Relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/385/

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:09PM (#13517671)
Why equate an ideology to skin color?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:23PM (#13517711)
I think the point is comparing stats of violence across demographics in the US, in particular comparing Muslims with other groups. Replacing whites with Christians will likely provide similar results for stats within the United States. I think it's reasonable to compare threats if that's a motivating criteria for supporting the ban.

There are a lot of orthogonal issues involved in the discussion of immigration, its effects on society, violence, identifying direct and indirect causes. And they touch on a lot of sensitive topics. So much of the discussion gets politicized and shrill. It's difficult to trust each other enough to have the nuanced discussion that's required.

Look at the language being used in this thread. Are people legitimately trying to understand each other? Or telling each other what the truth is? How subtle are the points being made? How much of it is expressed in absolute, general terms?

'battlebot is claiming that Islam, a violent ideology, is harming American citizens, and that there have been many attacks, and that they're fine with the Muslim ban.

'mozumber is claiming that most violent attacks in the US are perpetrated by white gun owners.

'jakeogh (you) are claiming further upthread it's not a Muslim ban

'lifeformed is claiming it's a crypto Muslim ban Trump is trying to slip in.

One could roughly put the four of you into two groups in terms of who each is arguing against (note, not who they agree with) Yet I really don't see any of you talking with each other, trying to find some understanding of each other, if not agreement. There doesn't appear to be any faith that the others may actually be rational people who have different values and reasons for their positions, even if they don't agree. No attempt to honestly understand another's position.

And I'm probably misunderstanding all of you, to boot!

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by mozumder on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:46PM (#13517818)
Because actions happen on individual people, and not on an ideology.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:57AM (#13529200)
Opposing an ideology necessary involves individuals. Pretending it's skin color that motivates this will continue to result in endless defeats on the 'everyone is welcome' side you appear to be trying to defend.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:54PM (#13517604)
http://imgur.com/a/HEOWO

By your logic, the ban will not be temporary. Correct?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:50PM (#13515852)
"Rudy Giuliani said Donald Trump came to him for guidance on implementing a so-called “Muslim ban” and from that, he helped construct the controversial order crippling international travel from predominantly Muslim countries."

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/rudy-giuliani-trump...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by somebehemoth on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:35PM (#13515760)
"President Donald Trump on Friday banned nationals of seven Muslim-majority countries from entering the United States..."

http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/28/politics/text-of-trump-executi...

Trump’s campaign in 2015 said it wanted “a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what is going on.”

https://www.donaldjtrump.com/press-releases/donald-j.-trump-...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 3JPLW on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:28PM (#13515727)
It's a Muslim ban when it affects majority-Muslim countries and has a minority exemption. That's pretty clear to me.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:39PM (#13515783)
The top 6 countries [1] with the highest Muslim populations are not (temp) banned, yet somehow it's a "Muslim Ban".

[1] http://www.pewforum.org/2015/04/02/muslims/pf_15-04-02_proje...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tacomonstrous on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:50PM (#13515849)
This is semantics. It was imposed with the intention of being a Muslim ban, but with plausible deniability. See Giuliani's comments here: http://nypost.com/2017/01/29/trump-asked-me-how-to-legally-c...
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 551199 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:29PM (#13516058)
DHS picked the countries to ban when Obama was still the President[0]. I'm being flagged for stating the inconvenient truth that this isn't 'muslim ban'. Most muslim countries aren't even affected.

[0]https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs-announces-further-tr...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:16PM (#13516329)
I think you're being flagged for being needlessly argumentative and uncivil.

The DHS list of countries on that waiver ban is indeed the same as those listed in the Executive Order. I haven't seen a reference that this list was indeed the basis for the countries listed in the Executive Order. If you know of one, please do share. I'm happy to be corrected.

Guiliani is widely reported in an interview on Fox News just yesterday to have confirmed that at least initially the goal was to create a Muslim ban:

http://thehill.com/homenews/administration/316726-giuliani-t...

I’ll tell you the whole history of it: When he first announced it, he said ‘Muslim ban,'" Giuliani said on Fox News.

"He called me up, he said, ‘Put a commission together, show me the right way to do it legally.’"

Giuliani said he then put together a commission that included lawmakers and expert lawyers. "And what we did was we focused on, instead of religion, danger," Giuliani said.

"The areas of the world that create danger for us, which is a factual basis, not a religious basis. Perfectly legal, perfectly sensible."

Giuliani reiterated that the ban is "not based on religion."

Perhaps the claim that resulting Executive Order is indeed purely based on risk assessment is true. I think reasonable people can understandably question whether this is indeed the case. To deny that it at least initially was motivated by the desire to create a Muslim ban is disingenuous at best. Accusing people of relying on "fake news" if they bring this up is clearly unfair.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 551199 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:44PM (#13516506)
Giuliani 'It's based substantial on evidence people are sending terrorist into our country'[0]. If christian terrorist would be coming in to US with evil intention from certain countries I don't think anyone would oppose them being banned temporarily while their organisation is taken care of. Trump is looking to attack ISIS in the next 30 days if someone wasn't paying attention and wants to lower risk of attacks happening by people coming in. It's easy to misrepresent what someone is saying as we have seen the last year.

Obama has been bombing these countries killing innocent people and now people are upset that Trump doesn't let army age men to come from these countries while he is taking care of the terrorist Obamas action created? Where were the marches against Obamas warmongering policies?

[0]https://youtu.be/NF2k11QQW0g?t=4m00s

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:54PM (#13516581)
You're cherry-picking one quote from Giuliani rather than looking at the larger conversation he had during the Fox News interview. And then shifting the discussion to Obama.

The fact that people didn't protest more about Obama is a separate argument. The fact that Bush invaded Iraq is a separate argument. The fact that the US supported the mujahideen during the Soviet Afghan war is a separate argument. The fact that the US helped overthrow the Iranian government and install the Shah in 1953 is a separate argument. The fact that European powers divvied up the Middle East following World War I is a separate argument. Want to go back to the Crusades? Abraham?

Or you can tie them all together. They're all ultimately related. Which do you want? Where do you want to draw the line? What do you want to take responsibility for? Drawing in all manner of related topics doesn't help us move forward. I don't think any of that is useful.

What people are discussing now, today, is Trump's Executive Order, and what to do about it now.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 3JPLW on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:53PM (#13516205)
Again, semantics. It's being called a Muslim ban because it _only_ affects Muslims. Sure, it doesn't affect _all_ Muslims, but it still singles out one religious group.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by dragonwriter on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:19PM (#13517697)
It's being called a Muslim ban because Trump called for a Muslim ban, shifted the definition many times, and then issued this order with similar justification and overlapping provisions to many versions (though not identical to any version) of the Muslim ban.

It neither effects all Muslims nor (since it includes a temporary complete ban on all refugees) only Muslims, but it's still overtly targeted first and foremost at Muslims.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 3JPLW on Monday January 30, 2017 @12:48AM (#13518976)
Ah, yes, thank you. I appreciate the correction.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tacomonstrous on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:35PM (#13516106)
Are you saying that Giuliani is lying?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 551199 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:02PM (#13516243)
Are you saying Obama wanted a muslim ban? Most muslim countries aren't even affected so if you read it's a muslim ban you have been reading fake news.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tacomonstrous on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:08PM (#13516274)
One person said they were implementing a Muslim ban, and the other... well, he didn't (not to mention his policy was materially different from the current one). I don't need to read fake news to understand the difference.
[dead]
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by sctb on Sunday January 29, 2017 @04:11PM (#13516690)
We've already asked you to please stop using HN primarily for this kind of political battle. We have to ban accounts that continue to abuse the site this way.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by rashkov on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:00PM (#13515048)
I think there's a pro-Uber case to be made here. Uber suspended surge pricing at a time when many people were trying to get to the protest at the airport, and while the airtrain was shut down which is what connects the subway system to the airport. Furthermore Uber offered to compensate its drivers who are affected by the ban, if they get stuck outside of the country.

Edit: Maybe Uber mis-stepped by honoring requests for rides FROM the airport, but given the above I don't think they're doing this to grab money. It's actually a little sad to see the knee-jerk response by people lashing out at a company that is trying to help, in this instance.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by awolf on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:11PM (#13515134)
Travis Kalanick, Uber's CEO, made public statements indicating that Uber must work with the Trump administration. Four days later Uber stepped up as scrubs while the rest of the New York's taxi service protested Trump's deplorable racist actions. It's hard to pretend this is a coincidence.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by magarathea on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:15PM (#13515658)
I have heard this called racist a few times and at risk of sounding like a pedant or an apologist I respectfully object.

Creating abusive policy targeted at people from certain countries seems xenophobic, isolationist, draconian, cruel, stupid.

Racism is a far more evil concept than any of those.

Abusing and rationalizing the abuse of people because you have made a generalization based on their geography, ideology or culture is certainly wrong.

Abusing and rationalizing the abuse of people because you believe they are genetically inferior is on a different level of depravity.

When we use "racism" as a catchall term for all bigotry and bias, we do it at the peril of diluting its power when that particular flavor of shitheaded thinking needs to be classified.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by scarmig on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:47PM (#13515831)
Question: when the USA refused to take in many Jewish refugees from Hitler's Germany, was that merely isolationist and cruel? Or racist too? After all, anti-Semitism was rife in the 1930's USA--plenty of businessmen like Henry Ford were more than happy to republish the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, which certainly played a role in American willingness to help the Jews.

Or does it even matter? I don't see how you can try to create a ranking of "minor evil" or "far more evil."

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by r00fus on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:19PM (#13516000)
This is a strawman. People call Trump racist, but this is an unconstitutional action with clearly racial motives.

Arguing against this being called "racism" is completely missing the point.

What Trump is doing is unamerican and unconstitutional. Arguably an impeachable offense.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by battlebot on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:06PM (#13517350)
There is nothing in the Constitution that supports your assertion. You have been tricked--a radical, violent ideology, wrapped in a religion is out to harm all those who will not submit to it. How many Christians, non-believers, and generally alternative people have to be murdered until you figure this out? Also, Islam is not a race.

And please, un-American? Our self-preservation is now un-American?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by ujal on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:57PM (#13515889)
"Abusing and rationalizing the abuse of people because you have made a generalization based on their geography, ideology or culture is certainly wrong." --

What kind of generalization is it though?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by rashkov on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:16PM (#13515182)
I'm not denying that, and I feel weird defending Uber at all, but then you'd also need to account for why they offered to compensate their drivers affected by this travel ban, and why would they lower their surge pricing. I'm okay with saying that they're trying to play both sides of this.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by alphonsegaston on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:40PM (#13515379)
Which in the context of a strike, isn't possible. The purpose of these kind of labor actions is to force a clarification about with whom one holds solidarity, in this case refugees and immigrants.

Breaking the strike is breaking the strike. They did not hold with refugees and immigrants, even after the taxi drivers explicitly asked them to do so. Everything else is just trying to mitigate damage to the point where people forget/engage in apologetics to obfuscate the choice they made.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by Neliquat on Sunday January 29, 2017 @04:30PM (#13516810)
With us or against us is some bullshit logic. This is not a binary issue.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by emilsedgh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:40PM (#13515380)
Get some free PR by condemning the EO while actually offering support to Trump administration by removing pressure by nullifying the strike.

Now that's being a hypocrite on a grand grand scale.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by dllthomas on Monday January 30, 2017 @12:15PM (#13522998)
Turning off surge reduces supply. That's not "nullifying the strike" - quite the opposite. It's weaker than it could have been, but it's also exactly what Lyft did.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pm90 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:24PM (#13515709)
Well, I'm glad you said what you said even though, as you admit, you feel weird defending Uber. Actions are much more louder and substantive than words and if Uber does good things, I am glad that this forum still has members who will rightfully point that out (instead of it devolving into an echo chamber)
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by stephancoral on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:10PM (#13515123)
Everything uber does is about money and they aren't afraid to flout the law / custom and "disrupt". They swooped in during a strike. They are scabs. They are obviously doing it to grab money. Their CEO is buddy buddy with Trump.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pfarnsworth on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:05PM (#13515584)
Is Elon Musk buddy-buddy with Trump as well, because they're on the same advisory board? Are you going to rant against Tesla too?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by r00fus on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:21PM (#13516011)
Considering that Musk is competing against the entire petroleum industry (major supporters of Trump) with SolarCity and Tesla, I'd be surprised if the "friendship" was anything other than convenience.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pfarnsworth on Sunday January 29, 2017 @11:54PM (#13518791)
Cognitive dissonance at its finest.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pjc50 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:23PM (#13515698)
HN seems unwilling to confront this issue. People are complaining about Thiel, but Musk has been a darling for years.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:27PM (#13515723)
HN seems unwilling to confront this issue.

Please don't throw out generalizations like this, particularly as you're a member of the HN community yourself. If you feel strongly about this particular issue, write up a blog post making your case, and submit it to HN, or have someone submit it for you.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by rashkov on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:13PM (#13515155)
How much money can they make during a 1 hour strike? Lowering their prices seems like the opposite of making money to me
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by stephancoral on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:17PM (#13515191)
A one hour strike at one of the busiest airports on the East Coast with NO taxis available? Probably a lot.

The point is you hold a strike to STOP work, not work for less money. That's called scabbing and is the opposite of solidarity.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:39PM (#13515372)
Should the company decide on behalf of the workers whether they must join a strike? Shouldn't Uber drivers be the ones to make that decision?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by sundaeofshock on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:57PM (#13515512)
Drivers are only allowed to turn down a limited number of rides before they are no longer allowed to be uber drivers for the day.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by loeg on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:13PM (#13515641)
Can't they just turn off the app for an hour?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by bmpafa on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:23PM (#13515702)
I think this sort of protest requires organization. Uber's surge pricing (which I assume drivers didn't know would be suspended in time to plan a protest) basically guarantees seamless scabbing, so the opportunity cost of the protest becomes unreasonable.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:00PM (#13515542)
It was an one hour strike. Surely they could have driven far from the airport (to avoid getting tagged by the algorithm) for that time.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by emilsedgh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:43PM (#13515402)
This is not about how much money they can make.

This is about showing their support to the government, their allies.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by EthanHeilman on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:04PM (#13515071)
The taxi strike was part of the protest at the airport. Offering reduced pricing was a way to hurt the taxi workers who were losing money to show solitary with the protest.

If Uber was trying to help, they should have said so.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by rashkov on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:14PM (#13515164)
edit: Re-reading this, and I realize I missed your point. You're absolutely right -- they did not say "we are cutting surge pricing in support of the protest".

This was my original post for posterity:

"They did say so. This was their tweet:

'Our CEO's reaction to immigration order: "We'll compensate drivers impacted by the ban pro bono for next 3 months." http://ubr.to/standingup'"

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pikzen on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:41PM (#13515382)
They're helping their own workers. While a good thing, the rest of ther message is complete PR and sending ubers to JFK undermines the strikes, because it's such an easy way for them to make a profit.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:23PM (#13515703)
Turning off surge pricing sends fewer Ubers to JFK! They make less money, not more with surge pricing off! Makes no sense!
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by rashkov on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:38PM (#13515779)
Someone else in this thread pointed out that the headlines would be really bad for Uber if they said something like "Uber surges 500% while breaking airport taxi strike". It seems like they were trying to cover themselves, while not outright joining the strike, as if to triangulate towards the center.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:46PM (#13515824)
If you mean the third option was to disable all service from JFK?

Though I don't think the regular taxi companies or Lyft did that either.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by EthanHeilman on Sunday January 29, 2017 @05:25PM (#13517145)
That is exactly what the Taxi strike did.

>"NO PICKUPS @ JFK Airport 6 PM to 7 PM today," the union wrote in a subsequent tweet that was retweeted over 10,000 times. "Drivers stand in solidarity with thousands protesting inhumane & unconstitutional #MuslimBan."

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/the-scene-at-jfk-as-taxi-d...

The objection is not that Uber didn't join the strike but that Uber reduced their prices to undermine the strike and get new customers.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:02PM (#13517646)
> That is exactly what the Taxi strike did.

No it's not. The union encouraging != the taxi companies somehow forcing it.

The union and the taxi companies are not the same thing.

> Uber reduced their prices to undermine the strike

Uber reducing prices to normal levels means fewer drivers anyway! Fewer rides! This makes no sense! Why would Uber even bother with some Machiavellian scheme to get a hundred or two extra rides? Makes no sense!

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by EthanHeilman on Monday January 30, 2017 @12:19PM (#13523037)
>Why would Uber even bother with some Machiavellian scheme to get a hundred or two extra rides?

Getting that first install is critical, because once someone installs the Uber app they are unlikely to go back to taxi cabs. 200 extra riders might not be a big group, but they tell their friends and family and it spreads. This is especially true if the rides are discounted since everyone loves to talk about how much money they saved by taking an Uber instead of a taxi. Think of the ride sharing market in NYC, more than half the cars on the roads are taxis.

tl;dr Uber has employed viral marketing like this for years and it works.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:28PM (#13515726)
Offering normal pricing means drivers get paid less, reduces opportunity cost of joining in strike. Or, drivers who participate in strike get paid $0 either way so it doesn't affect them. Uber drivers who don't participate in strike will get sent to JFK less often because of lack of extra incentive due to surge pricing.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pduszak on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:52PM (#13515472)
"A strikebreaker (sometimes derogatorily called a scab, blackleg, or knobstick) is a person who works despite an ongoing strike."
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by rashkov on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:05PM (#13515586)
Things were moving so fast at the time, I guess I had my doubts that Uber was even aware of the strike, but I suppose that may be naive and that the taxi association probably contacted Uber about this.

I'm definitely coming around to the idea that Uber is simply playing both sides of this, and that it gives them too much credit to assume good intentions of them removing surge pricing.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by loeg on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:14PM (#13515650)
They lowered prices in response to the strike. They were aware it was going on. If they had left surge pricing in effect that could be argued to be ignorance of the strike, but they didn't.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by CodeWriter23 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @05:16PM (#13517088)
The whole Uber paying drivers stuck outside the country came after the perhaps well-intended surge pricing debacle. To me, that move is textbook Crisis Management. And having driven for Uber, their SOP is to never do anything that favors drivers. They don't even think of drivers, who pay to use their network, as customers.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tn13 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:59PM (#13515893)
> Uber suspended surge pricing at a time when many people were trying to get to the protest at the airport

That means less people could travel to airport for protests. Suspending surge pricing reduces availability of cabs. You understand that right ?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jamalex on Sunday January 29, 2017 @11:52AM (#13514995)
For convenience, here's a link to the Uber help page for deleting your account: https://help.uber.com/h/24010fe7-7a67-4ee5-9938-c734000b144a (They even give you a nice box to explain why)
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jasonbarone on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:06PM (#13515085)
For convenience, here's a link to the Lyft help page for deleting your account: https://help.lyft.com/hc/en-us/articles/223281567-Delete-My-.... Unforunately, it's not possible to do yourself.

Both Lyft and Uber didn't suspend service to JFK last night because both are 24/7 platforms for anyone to drive and make money. Uber lowered/suspended surge pricing to make it affordable in/around the protests, while Lyft did not.

Worth noting is that active drivers on both platforms were likely protesting at airports all over the world.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by banku_brougham on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:10PM (#13515121)
could you post the account setup page please? i've never used lyft, i assume its basically the same service?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by gumby on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:24PM (#13515249)
Doesn't operate in as many locations, but pretty much the same, and often the same drivers. Informally it appears drivers I've talked to have preferred Lyft (have asked even when they were driving for Uber). Most of course demur, but I've never heard a driver say something nice about Uber while I have had several praise Lyft.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by praneshp on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:52PM (#13517594)
Just to give you a counter point, I was in India recently, and most drivers I spoke to loved Uber. That could be a combination of the alternative sucking, general employer treatment of employees not being great, etc.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by thesmallestcat on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:14PM (#13515161)
It's an inferior service: Much longer waits for a ride, higher fares, tipping, awkward interactions, fewer ride options, buggy (in my experience) phone apps.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by inverse_pi on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:09PM (#13515110)
I don't get it. How about other people that were not part of the protest and were trying to get home/get to the airport? How about the Uber drivers trying to make a living? Just because they were not part of your protest you'll give them hate?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by scarmig on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:22PM (#13515234)
Question: during the Civil Rights movement, people of all sorts disrupted white people just trying to eat breakfast; just trying to get an education; just trying to get to work.

Is that "giving them hate"? Should MLK have made fastidiously sure to go to cordoned off areas where no one would have been inconvenienced in the slightest?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:46PM (#13515425)
The question asked wasn't whether the Civil Rights protesters shouldn't have inconvenienced people. It's whether a company should force its workers to join a protest.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by ajamesm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:51PM (#13515460)
How many companies donate to super-PACs, the DNC, RNC, etc.?

In this case, the mechanism of political action is constricting the labor supply instead of giving cash to politicians.

It seems crazy for a company to force workers to join a protest, until you think about how they force workers to turn a profit and then donate to politicians that would happily oppress those same workers.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:54PM (#13515498)
So two wrongs do make a right? What other abuses of worker's rights should we demand they do, for "good reasons"?

Companies also collectively fire people to bolster their profits, maybe we should demand they do some mass firings for a good cause. Trump supporters, maybe?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by ajamesm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:05PM (#13515590)
I'm not offering a moral judgment, or making a statement about the efficacy of those tactics. I'm saying it's nothing new.

(On a related note, there are some regulations around mass layoffs: https://www.doleta.gov/programs/factsht/warn.htm

American companies will run a series of layoffs JUST below the limit to avoid the reporting mandates! Kind of like structuring deposits of $9,999 to avoid the reporting requirement at $10k. Interesting.)

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by baddox on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:16PM (#13515662)
You're asking an unrelated question. The morality or advisability of engaging in disruptive protests is completely separate from the morality of Uber allowing its drivers to choose to work while taxi drivers are protesting.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by scarmig on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:52PM (#13516194)
How is it unrelated? The comment I was replying to said, "How about other people that were not part of the protest and were trying to get home/get to the airport?" Implying that Uber shouldn't be condemned for scabbing and helping them get to the airport because the protests were disruptive and they were just providing a public service by making them less disruptive.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by danharaj on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:42PM (#13515396)
All protests should be relegated to government sanctioned free speech zones /s
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by cf on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:20PM (#13515216)
A lot of people from Iran and other countries were also trying to get home that day. They couldn't call an Uber.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by kungfooguru on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:13PM (#13515152)
Yes, it undermines the strike. Strikes are supposed to disrupt.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by skybrian on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:27PM (#13515279)
Yes, but that doesn't necessarily mean every disruption on our side deserves our unconditional support. It's worth discussing whether disrupting travel further helps or hurts the cause.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:20PM (#13515215)
Strikes are intended to disrupt. They are not entitled to disrupt. There is a huge difference.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pikzen on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:44PM (#13515411)
In most professions, there's a feeling of unity. Taxi companies and drivers will either stand with striking drivers, or be respectful enough to not disrupt their action.

Then comes Uber, the vulture that swoops in all in the name of disrupting the market. They're allowed to do it, sure. Whether it's morally right is another thing.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:58PM (#13515529)
It is definitely morally right. Calling Uber a vulture ignores the reality that the world doesn't stop just because some protesters are unhappy.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by eropple on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:24PM (#13515706)
"Some protestors are unhappy" is a really interesting way of phrasing "the federal government is embarking on a concerted attack on 1.7% of the population for reasons at best murky."

Be better, please.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:29PM (#13515730)
Come on. Trump is doing lots of bad things, but if he weren't people would still be striking. The largest protest in American history happened before he even took office. Let's not pretend that people's emotions are less of a driving factor than the facts. Get over yourself.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by couchand on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:06PM (#13515933)
Or maybe you should "get over yourself". If you care so much for the facts perhaps you should make sure to get them right. I suppose you're referring to the Women's March, which took place the day after Trump assumed office.

And it's remarkable if your claim is that without Trump's Muslim Ban there would still be protests at JFK this weekend. Are you really arguing that?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:30PM (#13516068)
It is interesting that you say that, because I read about that protest in the Friday paper (from the 20th). The paper of course became available many hours before Trump was sworn in. Stop pretending that it was a reaction to anything he did in office.

I don't know exactly how different protests would have played out if Trump took different actions in office, but it is overwhelmingly obvious that the protests are the result of emotion, not facts.

Also, you seem to be confused about the phrase "get over yourself" means. It targets self importance such as "be better please", it makes no sense whatsoever as a response to my comment.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by couchand on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:52PM (#13516191)
That's a skillful evasion of facts you just executed, going from your previous claim that the protest occurred before the inauguration to just that it was planned before then. Well played.

Your dubious claim about the motivations of large groups of individuals is not at all "overwhelmingly obvious."

Get over yourself.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:25PM (#13516386)
Is it an evasion of facts to focus on facts that are relevant? If a protest was planned before Trump took office, that logically excludes actions taken by Trump as motivation for the protest. That is "overwhelmingly obvious" to anyone who isn't confused by the concept of causality.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by couchand on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:46PM (#13516529)
I don't think anyone claimed that the Women's March wasn't planned before January 20th, that would be absurd. However it was still clearly a reaction to Trump's words and actions, and that doesn't require him being a sitting president first.

But it's worth noting the difference between that protest and the one at JFK, which I think it's pretty clear was a direct reaction to a specific policy created by President Trump. Using the Women's March as some sort of catch-all "haters gonna hate" dismissal of the valid concerns that many Americans have about the sitting president's actions is, to put it simply, a remarkable argument.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @04:02PM (#13516621)
I never used the women's march as a "hater's gonna hate" dismissal. I never even dismissed the concerns of protesters. My point was that protests are based on emotion. I only felt that need to make that point because eropple took some weird offense to me saying that the cause of protests was people being unhappy. It is fine with me if you want to defend him, but don't pretend that context doesn't exist.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by eropple on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:44AM (#13528564)
I took offense to your cavalier dismissal of some real shit as "being unhappy". You trivialized it, and you knew what you were doing, and it was lousy behavior. And you shouldn't do that and you should be better.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:31PM (#13515740)
Cutting surge pricing means fewer drivers, increased wait times. Does not convenience anyone.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by danharaj on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:19PM (#13515204)
Everyone's trying to get on with their lives. However, everyone getting on with their lives crucially depends on other people doing their jobs. When a grave injustice is being committed the purpose of a strike is to say "we refuse to keep an unjust society running". A strike is an act of solidarity between people and the point specifically has to be to disrupt daily life. If a strike does not inconvenience anyone, then it isn't a strike.

By undermining the strike, Uber is saying that their profits are more important than the injustice being protested. They are saying that they are perfectly happy to help society function while it is committing such a grave act of injustice against a vulnerable minority. It is organizations and people like Uber who are perfectly willing to make money and let life go on as authoritarians destroy the lives of their fellow citizens that allow evil to persist and thrive. It is people who get on with their lives while those of their neighbors are being disrupted and destroyed that most threaten freedom.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by toomuchtodo on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:20PM (#13515211)
"Apologies for the inconvenience while we try to fix our country".
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by cls59 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:29PM (#13515293)
I don't get it either. Given the status of Uber drivers as independent contractors, I'm not convinced it's Uber's place to call an action like a strike. Such a decision should come from the drivers. On the taxi side it sounds like there were unions who clearly have the representation to make this sort of decision.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by notatoad on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:59PM (#13515532)
>How about other people that were not part of the protest and were trying to get home/get to the airport?

Inconveniencing those sort of people is exactly the purpose of protesting. It's supposed to make regular everyday people who aren't directly affected by Trump's actions feel their impact. If you disagree with the protesters that's one thing, but complaining about it affecting "normal people" is really missing the point.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by malloreon on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:06PM (#13515080)
I'm a bit confused by the backlash at Uber. I saw the tweet saying they were suspending surge pricing to JFK. To me that make trips there less likely since drivers would make less.

Wouldn't that be a show of solidarity with the temporarily striking taxi drivers union?

I guess my question is, how does suspending surge pricing to JFK suggest Uber supports the executive order?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 010a on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:10PM (#13515122)
They could have disabled all pickups at JFK in true solidarity.

I don't think disabling surge pricing is a show of solidarity. With Taxis striking, surge pricing would have skyrocketed. This feels more like Uber just wants to preempt an inevitable news story about how surge pricing hit 10x or something during the taxi strike, which would be bad PR.

The article did say that Uber is working with its affected drivers to provide legal assistance. So, again, they're just protecting themselves. The company has practically no moral compass.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:51PM (#13515463)
Did their workers agree to share that solidarity? Or are you saying they should have forced their workers to join the protest? Were taxi companies prohibiting drivers from picking up passengers?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by notatoad on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:02PM (#13515563)
This is a great point that should be made more loudly: the taxi strike was, as far as i can see, the action of the drivers and the union. No taxi company, including uber, was disallowing traffic to or from JFK.

If Uber's drivers declined to participate in the strike, that's on the drivers, not Uber.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by licyeus on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:42PM (#13516140)
Uber has actively fought against allowing its drivers to unionize. The drivers' inability to organize and participate in strikes (esp. on such short notice) is in large part because of these actions.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by baddox on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:21PM (#13515692)
I would have liked to see solidarity, but I am extremely uncomfortable vilifying any individual or company for simply choosing to not participate in a protest.

I heard about the SFO protests yesterday, and I largely support the cause, and I could have made it there in time to join. I didn't. Do you question my moral compass? Did I do something wrong? I know people who largely support the issues of the women's march, yet did not attend, or attended only part of the rally or march. Should they be vilified?

I think this is a scary idea. Not everyone can or has to actively join every protest to "prove" that they support the platform or "have a moral compass."

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jasonbarone on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:26PM (#13515268)
Did Lyft or any other services disable all pickups at JFK in true solidarity?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by gotchange on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:15PM (#13515167)
Kalanick spoke out against that EO and condemned it but I think people are angry at him because he was on Trump's advisors team to lobby the admin for favorable economic policies for his interests.

He miscalculated and discounted all the far-right baggage that comes with the Trump admin and therefore he has no one to blame for this misstep except himself.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by koolba on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:10PM (#13515118)
Drivers don't know where they're going till the ride starts. I also don't think they can refuse to go to a destination without repercussions (i.e. Getting kicked out of Uber).

If anything, disabling surge pricing lessens the impact of a taxi strike as going to/from the airport is more affordable and convenient then having zero or pricier options.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by stephancoral on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:13PM (#13515149)
It's not a show of solidarity - it is in fact the opposite. It's called scabbing.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by makomk on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:26PM (#13515263)
It doesn't matter whether Uber actually supported the executive order any more than Lyft did. The idea is out there that they did, well-connected people are loudly talking about how they deleted their Uber accounts and you should too, and going against that marks you out as an evil Trump supporter. Welcome to post-truth politics. Even other claims that're clearly and unambiguously untrue has been winning out over the truth if it fits the narrative better. (For example, as someone pointed out on HN the list of countries elsewhere in favour of explanations that are outright contradicted by it like Trump's business interests.)
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by itsdrewmiller on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:11PM (#13515135)
A taxi strike is intended to inconvenience people. Uber reducing prices for riders directly contradicts that. (But if I had to guess, I would guess that they were just trying to avoid stories like "Uber profits from Muslim Ban", not making any kind of political statement about it.)
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by vthallam on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:17PM (#13515187)
> Uber profits from Muslim Ban.

Yes, This may well be the most important reason they did that. That PR would have far more disastrous for Uber.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:29PM (#13515294)
No it doesn't. Uber reducing prices means that less drivers will be available, making it harder to get a ride.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by Larrikin on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:11PM (#13515630)
There's supposed to be zero drivers available during a strike
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by baddox on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:25PM (#13515714)
Zero taxi drivers, if it was a strike organized by taxi companies or taxi unions. The presence of Uber drivers, or bus drivers, or train engineers, etc. does not contradict or minimize a taxi strike. And a taxi strike does not obligate or even sugges that all other employees in the human transportation industry should strike. And lastly, Uber choosing to not strike does not imply that Uber or Uber drivers do not support the taxi strike or the cause of protesters.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:13PM (#13515647)
There is no "supposed to". A strike is just people expressing there opinion through action. It is admirable, but there is no guarantee of success or support just because you a striking.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by dingaling on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:01PM (#13515909)
Zero union drivers.

No-one outside their club needs to comply.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pfarnsworth on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:07PM (#13515596)
I don't see why Uber needs to be beholden to a taxi strike, since they're not taxis, that holds no meaningful purpose except hurting a large number of people trying to get to and from the airport. Since when do taxis get to unilaterally dictate what the moral way to protest is?

Will taxi companies join Uber and help financially support the taxi drivers who are stuck out of the country because of Trump's ban? Are they immoral if they don't follow Uber's lead?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:25PM (#13515258)
So protesters are entitled to hold people hostage for an arbitrary amount of time, just because they are unhappy? Give me a break.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by danharaj on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:35PM (#13515337)
It doesn't matter if they're entitled or not, they did it, and then Uber did what they did, and people are now evaluating those actions based on the facts and their values. You don't have to agree with every protest. There isn't a universal rule that says all protest is good. But every protest can be judged on its merits, which is what people are doing, not reducing the motivations to "just because they are unhappy".

Implying that this protest was started "just because they are unhappy" is disingenuous and refuses to engage with the issues in good faith.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:42PM (#13515391)
My point isn't whether this particular protest is "good" or "bad". Even knowing relatively little about this protest, I think that I would likely agree with the protesters. My issue is that I don't see any reason why Uber should be obligated to stop service just because there is a protest going on. A lot of people in this thread seem to feel that having a protest entitles you to ruin other peoples' day and anyone who helps the people you are screwing is a bad guy. I see no good argument that supports that mentality.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by danharaj on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:50PM (#13515451)
The history of direct action and protest which disrupts daily life is argument enough: It works. History also shows us that when people ignore injustice and just get on with their day, that allows the injustice to grow and fester. The greatest crimes in history have been perpetrated while the majority of people who could have stopped it did nothing.

The word entitlement is so charged and vague, what do you mean by it? No one is legally entitled to disrupt peoples' lives, but the reason why people choose to protest and disrupt society until their demands are met is because they believe that society does not deserve to go on undisrupted while it allows some injustice to continue.

Let's be real. If no one protested this ban on muslims, very few peoples' lives would be disrupted. It would be a slight hiccup to just discard these people from society and replace whatever function they played. We are all disposable. That is why people protest, because otherwise injustice would go unpunished.

The abstract reasoning is this: If society is structured in such a way that an injustice can occur and persist with no disruption to society, then people are morally obligated to disrupt society when that injustice occurs in order to remedy it and prevent it in the future.

The justification is empirical: Evidence demonstrates that when most people can go about their day without hindrance while atrocities are being committed, they will gladly get used to and accept those atrocities as a fact of life.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:55PM (#13515501)
If you want to claim that the justification is empirical, you are going to need some real empirical evidence.

With respect to the word entitlement: I mean ethically. When someone is angry (like the people in this thread promising to delete Uber) that something didn't happen, then it seems like they felt entitled to have it happen.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by closeparen on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:34PM (#13515332)
We could say the same about the government (in fact, the protesters were saying that).
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by dagw on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:00PM (#13515544)
Where the bus services out of JFK also cancelled?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by baddox on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:26PM (#13515721)
If they weren't, then the people who condemn Uber for not striking should also condemn the bus drivers for not striking.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by empath75 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:01PM (#13515550)
When you have an administration whose stated goal is to tear the fabric of the country apart, don't be surprised when that is what happens.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pikzen on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:47PM (#13515430)
Yes. You've realized the point of a strike. You may also notice that they usually don't happen too often because the goal is to make you realize that either their current situation isn't livable anymore, or because there's a message to be spread. Do it too often and people turn against the protesters.

It lasted one hour. Get over it. Social change doesn't happen without inconvenience.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:00PM (#13515543)
The people who need to get over it are the people who are angry at Uber for doing their jobs. I am doing just fine.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:44PM (#13515407)
Freedom of assembly is a hell of a thing.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:47PM (#13515431)
You seemed to have missed the point. They are free to assemble, but I see no reason why it is wrong for someone else to help the people getting screwed by a protest.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by giaour on Sunday January 29, 2017 @05:45PM (#13517243)
I deleted my account, too, but I wonder if that was the most effective way to register my discontent with Uber. It was estimated in December that Uber spends about $1.55 for every dollar of revenue they take in [1], so refusing to use Uber isn't exactly hurting their bottom line.

On the other hand, I've yet to talk to an Uber driver that doesn't also accept fares via Lyft, and if we can convince drivers to abandon Uber by shifting our consumer dollars to Lyft, then the Uber brand and platform will lose value.

[1] https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/21/uber-losses-expected-to-hi...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tn13 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:00PM (#13515896)
Kudos to Uber and Lyft both here. I had to travel to SFO yday and I managed to find an Uber. Despite protests and all, we need transportation people. I donated money to ACLU.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by reacharavindh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:56PM (#13515505)
I wonder if UBER could do anything evil with its location dara from customers and drivers... like identify who is joining protests and where etc.