News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by justinpombrio on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:50PM (#13515455)
I hate asking about downvotes, but I'm really confused why this comment has been pushed to the bottom. Why?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:16PM (#13515669)
Well, it's not a "Muslim Ban" for starters. Look up the countries with the highest Muslim populations, then cross ref to the list of countries that have a 90 day (to start) ban.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by lifeformed on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:31PM (#13516428)
It is a Muslim ban. It's just how you do it politically. You start with the goal of banning Muslims, then you see how to implement it in a way that gives you plausible deniability. You couldn't get away with just saying, "No Muslims allowed." That is way too overtly racist and illegal. So you look for existing groupings of countries that align with your goals.

You find a list of countries banned on the visa waiver program made by the previous administration, and it covers many Muslim nations that are in the international spotlight right now. They're hot topics and it fits your criteria well. (Also they conveniently don't intersect with your business interests, so that's another plus.) You ignore Indonesia and India because they aren't in the news for terrorism, so it doesn't fit your narrative. Now you can get away with banning these "previously chosen" countries, by saying it's for national security, while you wink to your more explicitly racist supporters. You achieved their racist goal, de-facto, while having a non-racist "legitimate" excuse.

This is how institutional racism works. You have a racist goal in mind, and you implement it through actions that are under the guise of something more reasonable. It has the same effect as if you just made some overtly racist policy, but you can do it legally and with plausible deniability.

Also, if it helps, Rudy Giuliani said on national TV that Trump told him to do literally exactly this.

[dead]
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by mozumder on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:30PM (#13517495)
I agree that we should ban whites from this country, since they commit the vast majority of murders here in America. So many innocent lives have been lost to white murderers that own guns.

I mean, if we're going to be bigoted and ascribe negative traits to entire groups based on the actions of a few, shouldn't we do that to protect our safety by ascribing whites as murderers based on them committing the vast majority of the 17,000 murders that happen in our country every year?

America needs to defend themselves against whites, who are placing carnage into our peaceful country with their murderous ways.

If whites can't find a way to make peaceful journey in the world, then they have to go. Moderate whites need to step up and completely denounce their violent sub-groups. COMPLETELY DENOUNCE -- not quietly bolster or nod knowingly to.

(this is how bigotry works, and remember, it can go both ways. Do you want this kind of bigotry to happen to whites? I get that it's hard to not be bigoted when it's so much easier mentally to associate a race with the actions of a few, but that's what it takes to be smart- you have to actually think instead of being mentally lazy)

Relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/385/

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:09PM (#13517671)
Why equate an ideology to skin color?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:23PM (#13517711)
I think the point is comparing stats of violence across demographics in the US, in particular comparing Muslims with other groups. Replacing whites with Christians will likely provide similar results for stats within the United States. I think it's reasonable to compare threats if that's a motivating criteria for supporting the ban.

There are a lot of orthogonal issues involved in the discussion of immigration, its effects on society, violence, identifying direct and indirect causes. And they touch on a lot of sensitive topics. So much of the discussion gets politicized and shrill. It's difficult to trust each other enough to have the nuanced discussion that's required.

Look at the language being used in this thread. Are people legitimately trying to understand each other? Or telling each other what the truth is? How subtle are the points being made? How much of it is expressed in absolute, general terms?

'battlebot is claiming that Islam, a violent ideology, is harming American citizens, and that there have been many attacks, and that they're fine with the Muslim ban.

'mozumber is claiming that most violent attacks in the US are perpetrated by white gun owners.

'jakeogh (you) are claiming further upthread it's not a Muslim ban

'lifeformed is claiming it's a crypto Muslim ban Trump is trying to slip in.

One could roughly put the four of you into two groups in terms of who each is arguing against (note, not who they agree with) Yet I really don't see any of you talking with each other, trying to find some understanding of each other, if not agreement. There doesn't appear to be any faith that the others may actually be rational people who have different values and reasons for their positions, even if they don't agree. No attempt to honestly understand another's position.

And I'm probably misunderstanding all of you, to boot!

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by mozumder on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:46PM (#13517818)
Because actions happen on individual people, and not on an ideology.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:57AM (#13529200)
Opposing an ideology necessary involves individuals. Pretending it's skin color that motivates this will continue to result in endless defeats on the 'everyone is welcome' side you appear to be trying to defend.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:54PM (#13517604)
http://imgur.com/a/HEOWO

By your logic, the ban will not be temporary. Correct?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:50PM (#13515852)
"Rudy Giuliani said Donald Trump came to him for guidance on implementing a so-called “Muslim ban” and from that, he helped construct the controversial order crippling international travel from predominantly Muslim countries."

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/rudy-giuliani-trump...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by somebehemoth on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:35PM (#13515760)
"President Donald Trump on Friday banned nationals of seven Muslim-majority countries from entering the United States..."

http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/28/politics/text-of-trump-executi...

Trump’s campaign in 2015 said it wanted “a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what is going on.”

https://www.donaldjtrump.com/press-releases/donald-j.-trump-...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 3JPLW on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:28PM (#13515727)
It's a Muslim ban when it affects majority-Muslim countries and has a minority exemption. That's pretty clear to me.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by jakeogh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:39PM (#13515783)
The top 6 countries [1] with the highest Muslim populations are not (temp) banned, yet somehow it's a "Muslim Ban".

[1] http://www.pewforum.org/2015/04/02/muslims/pf_15-04-02_proje...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tacomonstrous on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:50PM (#13515849)
This is semantics. It was imposed with the intention of being a Muslim ban, but with plausible deniability. See Giuliani's comments here: http://nypost.com/2017/01/29/trump-asked-me-how-to-legally-c...
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 551199 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:29PM (#13516058)
DHS picked the countries to ban when Obama was still the President[0]. I'm being flagged for stating the inconvenient truth that this isn't 'muslim ban'. Most muslim countries aren't even affected.

[0]https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs-announces-further-tr...

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:16PM (#13516329)
I think you're being flagged for being needlessly argumentative and uncivil.

The DHS list of countries on that waiver ban is indeed the same as those listed in the Executive Order. I haven't seen a reference that this list was indeed the basis for the countries listed in the Executive Order. If you know of one, please do share. I'm happy to be corrected.

Guiliani is widely reported in an interview on Fox News just yesterday to have confirmed that at least initially the goal was to create a Muslim ban:

http://thehill.com/homenews/administration/316726-giuliani-t...

I’ll tell you the whole history of it: When he first announced it, he said ‘Muslim ban,'" Giuliani said on Fox News.

"He called me up, he said, ‘Put a commission together, show me the right way to do it legally.’"

Giuliani said he then put together a commission that included lawmakers and expert lawyers. "And what we did was we focused on, instead of religion, danger," Giuliani said.

"The areas of the world that create danger for us, which is a factual basis, not a religious basis. Perfectly legal, perfectly sensible."

Giuliani reiterated that the ban is "not based on religion."

Perhaps the claim that resulting Executive Order is indeed purely based on risk assessment is true. I think reasonable people can understandably question whether this is indeed the case. To deny that it at least initially was motivated by the desire to create a Muslim ban is disingenuous at best. Accusing people of relying on "fake news" if they bring this up is clearly unfair.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 551199 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:44PM (#13516506)
Giuliani 'It's based substantial on evidence people are sending terrorist into our country'[0]. If christian terrorist would be coming in to US with evil intention from certain countries I don't think anyone would oppose them being banned temporarily while their organisation is taken care of. Trump is looking to attack ISIS in the next 30 days if someone wasn't paying attention and wants to lower risk of attacks happening by people coming in. It's easy to misrepresent what someone is saying as we have seen the last year.

Obama has been bombing these countries killing innocent people and now people are upset that Trump doesn't let army age men to come from these countries while he is taking care of the terrorist Obamas action created? Where were the marches against Obamas warmongering policies?

[0]https://youtu.be/NF2k11QQW0g?t=4m00s

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by grzm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:54PM (#13516581)
You're cherry-picking one quote from Giuliani rather than looking at the larger conversation he had during the Fox News interview. And then shifting the discussion to Obama.

The fact that people didn't protest more about Obama is a separate argument. The fact that Bush invaded Iraq is a separate argument. The fact that the US supported the mujahideen during the Soviet Afghan war is a separate argument. The fact that the US helped overthrow the Iranian government and install the Shah in 1953 is a separate argument. The fact that European powers divvied up the Middle East following World War I is a separate argument. Want to go back to the Crusades? Abraham?

Or you can tie them all together. They're all ultimately related. Which do you want? Where do you want to draw the line? What do you want to take responsibility for? Drawing in all manner of related topics doesn't help us move forward. I don't think any of that is useful.

What people are discussing now, today, is Trump's Executive Order, and what to do about it now.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 3JPLW on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:53PM (#13516205)
Again, semantics. It's being called a Muslim ban because it _only_ affects Muslims. Sure, it doesn't affect _all_ Muslims, but it still singles out one religious group.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by dragonwriter on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:19PM (#13517697)
It's being called a Muslim ban because Trump called for a Muslim ban, shifted the definition many times, and then issued this order with similar justification and overlapping provisions to many versions (though not identical to any version) of the Muslim ban.

It neither effects all Muslims nor (since it includes a temporary complete ban on all refugees) only Muslims, but it's still overtly targeted first and foremost at Muslims.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 3JPLW on Monday January 30, 2017 @12:48AM (#13518976)
Ah, yes, thank you. I appreciate the correction.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tacomonstrous on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:35PM (#13516106)
Are you saying that Giuliani is lying?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by 551199 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:02PM (#13516243)
Are you saying Obama wanted a muslim ban? Most muslim countries aren't even affected so if you read it's a muslim ban you have been reading fake news.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by tacomonstrous on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:08PM (#13516274)
One person said they were implementing a Muslim ban, and the other... well, he didn't (not to mention his policy was materially different from the current one). I don't need to read fake news to understand the difference.
[dead]
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by sctb on Sunday January 29, 2017 @04:11PM (#13516690)
We've already asked you to please stop using HN primarily for this kind of political battle. We have to ban accounts that continue to abuse the site this way.