News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by inverse_pi on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:09PM (#13515110)
I don't get it. How about other people that were not part of the protest and were trying to get home/get to the airport? How about the Uber drivers trying to make a living? Just because they were not part of your protest you'll give them hate?
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by scarmig on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:22PM (#13515234)
Question: during the Civil Rights movement, people of all sorts disrupted white people just trying to eat breakfast; just trying to get an education; just trying to get to work.

Is that "giving them hate"? Should MLK have made fastidiously sure to go to cordoned off areas where no one would have been inconvenienced in the slightest?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:46PM (#13515425)
The question asked wasn't whether the Civil Rights protesters shouldn't have inconvenienced people. It's whether a company should force its workers to join a protest.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by ajamesm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:51PM (#13515460)
How many companies donate to super-PACs, the DNC, RNC, etc.?

In this case, the mechanism of political action is constricting the labor supply instead of giving cash to politicians.

It seems crazy for a company to force workers to join a protest, until you think about how they force workers to turn a profit and then donate to politicians that would happily oppress those same workers.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:54PM (#13515498)
So two wrongs do make a right? What other abuses of worker's rights should we demand they do, for "good reasons"?

Companies also collectively fire people to bolster their profits, maybe we should demand they do some mass firings for a good cause. Trump supporters, maybe?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by ajamesm on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:05PM (#13515590)
I'm not offering a moral judgment, or making a statement about the efficacy of those tactics. I'm saying it's nothing new.

(On a related note, there are some regulations around mass layoffs: https://www.doleta.gov/programs/factsht/warn.htm

American companies will run a series of layoffs JUST below the limit to avoid the reporting mandates! Kind of like structuring deposits of $9,999 to avoid the reporting requirement at $10k. Interesting.)

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by baddox on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:16PM (#13515662)
You're asking an unrelated question. The morality or advisability of engaging in disruptive protests is completely separate from the morality of Uber allowing its drivers to choose to work while taxi drivers are protesting.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by scarmig on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:52PM (#13516194)
How is it unrelated? The comment I was replying to said, "How about other people that were not part of the protest and were trying to get home/get to the airport?" Implying that Uber shouldn't be condemned for scabbing and helping them get to the airport because the protests were disruptive and they were just providing a public service by making them less disruptive.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by danharaj on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:42PM (#13515396)
All protests should be relegated to government sanctioned free speech zones /s
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by cf on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:20PM (#13515216)
A lot of people from Iran and other countries were also trying to get home that day. They couldn't call an Uber.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by kungfooguru on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:13PM (#13515152)
Yes, it undermines the strike. Strikes are supposed to disrupt.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by skybrian on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:27PM (#13515279)
Yes, but that doesn't necessarily mean every disruption on our side deserves our unconditional support. It's worth discussing whether disrupting travel further helps or hurts the cause.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:20PM (#13515215)
Strikes are intended to disrupt. They are not entitled to disrupt. There is a huge difference.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by pikzen on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:44PM (#13515411)
In most professions, there's a feeling of unity. Taxi companies and drivers will either stand with striking drivers, or be respectful enough to not disrupt their action.

Then comes Uber, the vulture that swoops in all in the name of disrupting the market. They're allowed to do it, sure. Whether it's morally right is another thing.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:58PM (#13515529)
It is definitely morally right. Calling Uber a vulture ignores the reality that the world doesn't stop just because some protesters are unhappy.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by eropple on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:24PM (#13515706)
"Some protestors are unhappy" is a really interesting way of phrasing "the federal government is embarking on a concerted attack on 1.7% of the population for reasons at best murky."

Be better, please.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:29PM (#13515730)
Come on. Trump is doing lots of bad things, but if he weren't people would still be striking. The largest protest in American history happened before he even took office. Let's not pretend that people's emotions are less of a driving factor than the facts. Get over yourself.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by couchand on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:06PM (#13515933)
Or maybe you should "get over yourself". If you care so much for the facts perhaps you should make sure to get them right. I suppose you're referring to the Women's March, which took place the day after Trump assumed office.

And it's remarkable if your claim is that without Trump's Muslim Ban there would still be protests at JFK this weekend. Are you really arguing that?

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:30PM (#13516068)
It is interesting that you say that, because I read about that protest in the Friday paper (from the 20th). The paper of course became available many hours before Trump was sworn in. Stop pretending that it was a reaction to anything he did in office.

I don't know exactly how different protests would have played out if Trump took different actions in office, but it is overwhelmingly obvious that the protests are the result of emotion, not facts.

Also, you seem to be confused about the phrase "get over yourself" means. It targets self importance such as "be better please", it makes no sense whatsoever as a response to my comment.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by couchand on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:52PM (#13516191)
That's a skillful evasion of facts you just executed, going from your previous claim that the protest occurred before the inauguration to just that it was planned before then. Well played.

Your dubious claim about the motivations of large groups of individuals is not at all "overwhelmingly obvious."

Get over yourself.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:25PM (#13516386)
Is it an evasion of facts to focus on facts that are relevant? If a protest was planned before Trump took office, that logically excludes actions taken by Trump as motivation for the protest. That is "overwhelmingly obvious" to anyone who isn't confused by the concept of causality.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by couchand on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:46PM (#13516529)
I don't think anyone claimed that the Women's March wasn't planned before January 20th, that would be absurd. However it was still clearly a reaction to Trump's words and actions, and that doesn't require him being a sitting president first.

But it's worth noting the difference between that protest and the one at JFK, which I think it's pretty clear was a direct reaction to a specific policy created by President Trump. Using the Women's March as some sort of catch-all "haters gonna hate" dismissal of the valid concerns that many Americans have about the sitting president's actions is, to put it simply, a remarkable argument.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by benchaney on Sunday January 29, 2017 @04:02PM (#13516621)
I never used the women's march as a "hater's gonna hate" dismissal. I never even dismissed the concerns of protesters. My point was that protests are based on emotion. I only felt that need to make that point because eropple took some weird offense to me saying that the cause of protests was people being unhappy. It is fine with me if you want to defend him, but don't pretend that context doesn't exist.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by eropple on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:44AM (#13528564)
I took offense to your cavalier dismissal of some real shit as "being unhappy". You trivialized it, and you knew what you were doing, and it was lousy behavior. And you shouldn't do that and you should be better.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by nerfhammer on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:31PM (#13515740)
Cutting surge pricing means fewer drivers, increased wait times. Does not convenience anyone.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by danharaj on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:19PM (#13515204)
Everyone's trying to get on with their lives. However, everyone getting on with their lives crucially depends on other people doing their jobs. When a grave injustice is being committed the purpose of a strike is to say "we refuse to keep an unjust society running". A strike is an act of solidarity between people and the point specifically has to be to disrupt daily life. If a strike does not inconvenience anyone, then it isn't a strike.

By undermining the strike, Uber is saying that their profits are more important than the injustice being protested. They are saying that they are perfectly happy to help society function while it is committing such a grave act of injustice against a vulnerable minority. It is organizations and people like Uber who are perfectly willing to make money and let life go on as authoritarians destroy the lives of their fellow citizens that allow evil to persist and thrive. It is people who get on with their lives while those of their neighbors are being disrupted and destroyed that most threaten freedom.

Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by toomuchtodo on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:20PM (#13515211)
"Apologies for the inconvenience while we try to fix our country".
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by cls59 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:29PM (#13515293)
I don't get it either. Given the status of Uber drivers as independent contractors, I'm not convinced it's Uber's place to call an action like a strike. Such a decision should come from the drivers. On the taxi side it sounds like there were unions who clearly have the representation to make this sort of decision.
Re:Lyft donates $1M to the ACLU, condemns Trump’s immigratio... by notatoad on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:59PM (#13515532)
>How about other people that were not part of the protest and were trying to get home/get to the airport?

Inconveniencing those sort of people is exactly the purpose of protesting. It's supposed to make regular everyday people who aren't directly affected by Trump's actions feel their impact. If you disagree with the protesters that's one thing, but complaining about it affecting "normal people" is really missing the point.