Creating abusive policy targeted at people from certain countries seems xenophobic, isolationist, draconian, cruel, stupid.
Racism is a far more evil concept than any of those.
Abusing and rationalizing the abuse of people because you have made a generalization based on their geography, ideology or culture is certainly wrong.
Abusing and rationalizing the abuse of people because you believe they are genetically inferior is on a different level of depravity.
When we use "racism" as a catchall term for all bigotry and bias, we do it at the peril of diluting its power when that particular flavor of shitheaded thinking needs to be classified.
Or does it even matter? I don't see how you can try to create a ranking of "minor evil" or "far more evil."
Arguing against this being called "racism" is completely missing the point.
What Trump is doing is unamerican and unconstitutional. Arguably an impeachable offense.
And please, un-American? Our self-preservation is now un-American?
What kind of generalization is it though?
Breaking the strike is breaking the strike. They did not hold with refugees and immigrants, even after the taxi drivers explicitly asked them to do so. Everything else is just trying to mitigate damage to the point where people forget/engage in apologetics to obfuscate the choice they made.
Now that's being a hypocrite on a grand grand scale.
Please don't throw out generalizations like this, particularly as you're a member of the HN community yourself. If you feel strongly about this particular issue, write up a blog post making your case, and submit it to HN, or have someone submit it for you.
The point is you hold a strike to STOP work, not work for less money. That's called scabbing and is the opposite of solidarity.
This is about showing their support to the government, their allies.
If Uber was trying to help, they should have said so.
This was my original post for posterity:
"They did say so. This was their tweet:
'Our CEO's reaction to immigration order: "We'll compensate drivers impacted by the ban pro bono for next 3 months." http://ubr.to/standingup'"
Though I don't think the regular taxi companies or Lyft did that either.
>"NO PICKUPS @ JFK Airport 6 PM to 7 PM today," the union wrote in a subsequent tweet that was retweeted over 10,000 times. "Drivers stand in solidarity with thousands protesting inhumane & unconstitutional #MuslimBan."
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/the-scene-at-jfk-as-taxi-d...
The objection is not that Uber didn't join the strike but that Uber reduced their prices to undermine the strike and get new customers.
No it's not. The union encouraging != the taxi companies somehow forcing it.
The union and the taxi companies are not the same thing.
> Uber reduced their prices to undermine the strike
Uber reducing prices to normal levels means fewer drivers anyway! Fewer rides! This makes no sense! Why would Uber even bother with some Machiavellian scheme to get a hundred or two extra rides? Makes no sense!
Getting that first install is critical, because once someone installs the Uber app they are unlikely to go back to taxi cabs. 200 extra riders might not be a big group, but they tell their friends and family and it spreads. This is especially true if the rides are discounted since everyone loves to talk about how much money they saved by taking an Uber instead of a taxi. Think of the ride sharing market in NYC, more than half the cars on the roads are taxis.
tl;dr Uber has employed viral marketing like this for years and it works.
I'm definitely coming around to the idea that Uber is simply playing both sides of this, and that it gives them too much credit to assume good intentions of them removing surge pricing.
That means less people could travel to airport for protests. Suspending surge pricing reduces availability of cabs. You understand that right ?
Edit: Maybe Uber mis-stepped by honoring requests for rides FROM the airport, but given the above I don't think they're doing this to grab money. It's actually a little sad to see the knee-jerk response by people lashing out at a company that is trying to help, in this instance.