Ya know, coming from a person who feels it appropriate to refer to adult professional women as "girls", imma need a citation on that.
Nonsense, it's still an uphill battle for victims to get their harasser convicted in Canada. See Jian Ghomeshi, Marcel Aubut and the First Nations women v. the police in Val d'Or for recent examples.
That doesn't make any sense? You said:
> If a girl feels harassed - then that's it. Guilty.
Yet you go on and acknowledge that it may be hard to get their harasser convicted. In all those 3 cases I mentioned (including Ghomeshi), there were many victims that felt harassed. Yet no one in any of those cases was convicted. How does that make your statement true?
"Many valid incidents of harassment are dismissed/ignored, and many invalid/borderline incidents are punished unfairly, and therefore the current system sucks for everybody".
Which seems entirely possible.
The structure of western government and judicial systems is set-up to make it hard for the individual to get convicted. This is why there is a 5th amendment. This is why "innocent until proven guilty" is a part of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. (Supported by Eleanor Roosevelt.)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human...
It's about protecting the individual against the group, even if the group is operating under the auspices of the state. If such principles are abrogated to convict a guilty man, then the state can start to abuse its authority to start convicting innocent men. Precisely such actions are what spurred the creation of the Magna Carta.
Just because someone advocates free speech for a White Supremacist, doesn't make them a White Supremacist. Just because someone advocates the 5th amendment for a an organized crime chief doesn't make them a mob supporter. Just because someone advocates for due process and innocent until proven guilty for an accused harasser doesn't make them an advocate of harassment.
That's a fair point.
Because it was a criminal trial - not civic or employment suit, also, by blatantly lying, those women destroyed their own credibility.
He was definitely fired by the CBC - and I don't think anyone is questioning that. No trial or legal examination needed.
He should have been fired by the CBC long time ago - then those suits would have never come up.
Courts commonly impose it. When such sentences first arose, the internet was marginal enough that it wasn't vital. And most judges now could probably live a tolerably normal life with an internet ban.
But if anyone on HN got banned from the internet, that would be tantamount to "banned from work", and much else.
I haven't seen much discussion about overuse of these order though.
If that were true, the accused could counterclaim to be harassed by the accuser, and produce a stalemate.
This makes me think it's not true.
I often call people quite my junior 'boys' and 'girls'. I work with a startup of dudes under 24. I call them 'lads'. I could technically be their father. Is that wrong? No.
Neither is using the term Mrs. Ms. or Miss.. In far-left socialist Montreal, where women are not even allowed by law to take their husband's name - people use the French equivalent everywhere: 'Madame' and 'Mademoiselle'. Same in Germany. Is that harassment now?
I think this kind of comment is not helping the situation - you want to find prejudice wherever you can, even when there is none there.
Let's work on getting the actual harassment stuff fixed - and avoid getting into culture wars.
Complaining about identity politics is how white men practice identity politics. Your post here is a shot fired in a culture war. You can't do that and complain about culture wars.
The phenomenon you're exploiting here is that the status quo is seen as the default state of the system. When women talk about bias, it's easy to say, "Why are women always talking about bias? Why are they starting a culture war?"
The start of the war, though, is lost in prehistory. For millennia, women were basically property, traded among families and owned by men. In the last couple hundred years, we've been unwinding that. We're not done yet, though. E.g., in the US we only hit parity in the number of medical and law degrees circa 2005; we won't see parity in the number of doctors and lawyers for decades more.
Women didn't start the war. They, and a growing number of men, are the resistance. Hopefully we will end the war within decades. But please don't pretend that shouting, "Stop fighting back!" is equivalent to a call for peace.
That's either illogical or racist. It could only be logical if you have as an axiom that white men can't possibly have a legitimate reason to complain about identity politics, which is itself a racist axiom.
Are you claiming that every non-white who practices identity politics is perfect and correct?
You are also mostly arguing with something I didn't say. I'm not saying all complaints about identity politics are illegitimate. Just that when white men are practicing identity politics, one tool they use is to complain about identity politics. Similarly, your last line is another misinterpretation.
As a person of color, I have to say that this is one of the most corrosively racist concepts there is, flat out. White people aren't special. They aren't a "default." Everyone else isn't a flavor of the month. The "everyman" isn't a white man. Because to say such is to relegate everyone else to 2nd rate status.
I'm not saying all complaints about identity politics are illegitimate. Just that when white men are practicing identity politics, one tool they use is to complain about identity politics.
It sure sounds like you're saying that all complaints from white men about identity politics are illegitimate or are somehow special because they come from white men. That strikes me as racist. Also, it sure makes white people sound special somehow.
Now let's take another statement: in America from the 1700s onward, white men are the dominant group. This is explicitly in the foundations of the country, and although it has become less true over time, looking at things like wealth distribution, positions of power, and access to power, it's still not an unfair statement. That statement describes a racist system, but I don't believe to be racist in itself.
What do we get when we combine the two statements, using the generic thought expressed in the first and the historical specificity of the second? "The way white men practice identity politics is to complain about identity politics."
So I believe that's not a racist statement either. I also think you over-apply it. As I already explained once, I am explicitly not saying all complaints about identity politics are illegitimate. I am saying that white men acting to maintain their societal dominance will complain about identity politics as a means.
Now to your first bit, I believe what you say is correct, but you miss my point. The reason I'm bringing it up is as part of pointing out edblarney's treating of men as the default. I agree with you it's wrong that white men are treated as the generic. But in pointing it out, I'm trying to undermine it. (In case you're curious, the technical names for the phenomena that I'm concerned about here are erasure [1] and the unmarked case [2], and I'm opposed to both.)
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/07/magazine/the-painful-conse...
[2] http://www2.bakersfieldcollege.edu/driess/Readings_files/Mar...
It is a flawed assumption that "parity in degrees" has any meaning as a measure of some vaguely-defined "equality" value.
Yes. Yes.
Next question, boy?
Its less about the actual word, more about the context.
One, those terms are not interchangeable. Words have meanings.
Two, people will refer to themselves or people in their in-group by names that people in the outgroup should not call them. E.g., my friend runs a get-together called "nerd beers". I don't mind, because he is a fellow lover of technology. Other people do not get to call me a nerd. Many groups have similar patterns, including black and gay people: just because they call themselves a word does not mean that you can.
Three, guys aren't very good at noticing misogyny. Other people noticing something you don't could be idiotic. But it could also be you just missing something that they've had more time and reason to think about.
If you have a problem with the word girl in reference to a young woman then your quarrel is with the dictionary.
The discussion is specifically about calling an adult female human a "girl". Emphasis on adult, which in the US is typically regarded as 18.
Yes, they often are. And this is often the way it is received, regardless of intent.
edit: And, for the record, "females" is also a favorite objectifying shibboleth in certain circles. (Not accusing you, necessarily.) Just use "women".
If you don't, then you don't use the term "girls" to talk about your female coworkers. Period. End of Story.
You are welcome to call them girls if they are children. It might also be appropriate outside of a professional context to address a group of women you are close with, but I can't ever see a reason to use the word girls in a professional setting to refer to female coworkers. It's belittling and disrespectful.
Verbal norms change over time, just as other forms of norms change. You don't have to modify your norms to keep up with how the rest of society views those norms, but where they impact legal decisions your personal choice to reject the change in external norms may have a significant cost to you at some point.
Completely false.
'Lady' is the feminine of 'Gentlemen'.
I could, but would not usually say:
"Gentlemen, let's go out for lunch"
So I could, but would not likely say:
"Ladies, let's go out for lunch"
I would normally say:
"Guys, let's go out for lunch"
Or:
"Girls, let's go out for lunch"
'Girls' is fully appropriate in every one of those situations.
You are seeing sexism wherein there absolutely is none and this is a problem.
Calling women "girls" while discussing something like the politics of harassment has the effect of subtly diminishing their credibility and personhood.
Do you mean "adulthood" instead of "personhood", or are you using "personhood" as a term d'art unfamiliar to me? (I am assuming you consider a child or adolescent to be a person as much as an adult is a person, with as much personality.)
I've heard a similar argument before, in reference to race. The logic is equally weak when crusty old white bigots use it.
Do you realize that you're being a racist?
Its because thats the only logical fallacy they can remember because it so often reinforces their own arguments in their own heads by not adding information. Every idiot who never studied logic will cry "STRAWMAN!"
This comment is racist and bigoted.
My female friends are called 'the girls' as a group. But at work it's either 'woman', 'gals', or 'guys'. I would never call a coworker girl unless she referred to herself that way, and I haven't heard my male or female coworkers do it either. At work calling an adult a 'girl' brings up immediate connotations of "the girls in secretary" from an earlier era, just as 'boy' brings up unpleasant racial connotations from that same era.
Language matters.
This tactic is used to great effect by SJW's. I only need look down the thread to see how much you caused.
Many a times, this type of harassment is mainly what women claim against men. But what exactly is harassment? Well, there's no real good definition. There's a point where any sane individual would agree... But I've also met people that simply asking to go on a date was "harassment". I've also seen cases of obvious sexual harassment (me, when I was sexually harassed by a manager, and then they were subsequently fired). And then I've also witnessed claims of it that one party blew out of proportion.
Except, because someone says " girls", you jump all over that and derail the underlying ideas of harassment and how to develop ideas of what it actually is, and not gut feelings.
Also, I'm not a TLA, I'm a human benig.
And you're not even doing it correctly. Gendered pronouns in general shouldn't be used. Please use "Xir" or "Zhe" when referring to a group of individuals whose sex may be female, but whose gender identity is unknown.
Disclaimer: I'm probably older than the average HN'er so I'm used to using woman/lady interchangeably in casual usage, and now I'm wondering how out of date I am.
EDIT: Thought about this on my drive home. I think a lot of this has to do with intonation and context. "Hey, lady!" can be taken many ways depending on how you say it. "Alright lady, let's start this meeting." would be an awkward expression, even if 99.99% of the world takes it as totally inoccuous. Versus "ladies" which is easier to use, as in "Alright ladies, let's get started." without any odd implications by tone or inflection.
Or just 'you' - "would you all all like to come for lunch today?"
Guy is a general term most times, but I've known a few women that get offended by it because they aren't male.
Dude is also used for both, but a lot of folks don't want to use that in the office. Alternatively, just use person and be safe.
Hey I'm offended you used the word op. When I was a kid, these kids used to bully me by calling me an Op. Can you refrain was using that word.
This is very much a cultural issue. From my time in Korea, a young person speaking to an older person in a familiar way would've been a major faux pas. On the other hand, the reverse (and consequent potential for put downs on the younger person) seemed quite common (older referring to younger more familiarly than had been earned). Similar experience in Spanish-language communities and cultures. English, particularly American, speaking communities have developed an incredibly tendency towards informality and unearned familiarity in our language. That's not a bad thing, strictly speaking, but it is something to consider.
When you enter into a professional setting, or a setting with people you aren't familiar with, just speak to them in more formal, professional, or polite ways and you are incredibly unlikely to offend someone (outside the occasional, "My father was Mr. Such-and-such, I'm just Bob", or random enlisted Army guy, "Don't call me sir, I work for a living"). It is stress-free if this sort of language is something you practice on a daily basis, it's just how you speak to people.
Yeah, horrible choice of words on my behalf :)
There are a few people who get upset over it or intentionally make a vocial issue out of something that isn't. ("Guys" is generally a genderless term ["You guys, take a look at this!"]
However, I would not say that some people get offended by everything or that they are looking for things to get offended by - not in a professional environment at least. Though I believe it to be reality, I think saying this bit would cause more problems than the word, "guys".
I'd also avoid the term, "guys and gals", but that's mostly because I dislike it, but that's just personal preference.
Yep. It's the northeastern influence on my mannerisms.
And it crept into my English vocabulary. I think I sound weird when I use it sometimes, but you are the first to point it out :)
--> "I don't think there is one."
No - the feminine of 'guy' is 'girl'. Point blank.
"The guys/girls are in town this week"
"Those guys/girls are from Facebook"
This is very common and normal language.
There's a point in the language that we use where boys with little power become guys with some power, but there isn't a point where girls with little power become [some word we don't really have outside of regional vernacular].
Our language is not perfect (even mine isn't) - the things we say on an everyday basis show all sorts of things we as a society implicitly believe, often without realising it. That our language reflects our society, and vice versa, is a very old idea, and part of modern feminism and the academia which backs it tries to bring that to the forefront.
I don't think women have the equivalent to "boy." Boy is used by women to adult men to degrade the subject.
Even though we have two similar words which may belittle the person, we have another case where the womens' version is watered down to belittle less.
-----
That being said "dude" is a pretty weird neutral term is odd in use, and formality.
That's what calling women "girls" is like. It's a pejorative that maintains bias and prevents us from seeing a class of people as active and capable.
Men get tied up and abused as prisoners of war and they're heros. Women get tied up and abused by men, they're victims. Women as "girls" is part of this false socially constructed narrative about female "impotence."
There is rather enormous variation in individuals and, often even for the same individual, context in this, within the US.
Tell me, why do you have such an attachment to that word? Why is it so important to you to refer to women as children?
Sometimes I wish I was southern so I could get away with "y'all." It's such a useful term, but it sounds so wrong coming from my north eastern accent.
"Many of the spectacular car bombings and killings you see are as a result of al Qaeda — the very same folks that attacked us on September the 11th."
People works in some contexts, but has problems in others.
Note the difference:
> What are you guys up to?
Versus
> What are you people up to?
The first is fine. The second gets you a visit from HR.
EDIT: And to get back to my earlier point, "What are y'all up to?" is friendly and casual. The problem is that I sound as natural as someone's dad trying to rap when I say it.
As in Guys and Dolls. Isn't it a 50s american slang thing?
'Girl' is the feminine of 'Boy' but it is ALSO the feminine of 'guy'.
As in: "the guys and I are going for lunch, are you in?"
There is no condescension or diminution.
You might want to consider that you live in a bubble - and that your finger wagging is condescending.
'Girl' is the feminine of 'Guy' - just as much as it is also the feminine of 'Boy'.
Consider those words for a moment and their common usage.
I'll bet that 'girl' is your vernacular as much as it is mine, because it's universally common.
"That guy/girl is smart" - both acceptable.
"The guys/girls are going out for lunch" - both acceptable.
"Guys/girls, huddle in, let's chat" - both acceptable.
"The guys/girls from marketing are in town this week" - both acceptable.
Here are a few other examples:
Being addressed as a boy or a girl by a police officer is really disrespectful. 'Boys will be boys' is really a diminutive phrase when referring to men. 'Boys and their toys' when referring to men purchasing items they like is also dismissive.
Perhaps where you are it is not offensive to list it the way I have, but note that it is not the same everywhere and it's glaring enough that it warranted many people posting it.
In the same sense that we have to be aware of the implications of language and race, we have to do the same with language and gender. Without this, you're not treating other people as peers or equals or legitimate agents (referring to a woman as girl has the implication that she's a child, either needing correction or protection, from you, the big, strong man).
This is, as I noted in another comment, also very regional. I live in the South. I could probably call many women girl here and they'd have no problem with it, without familiarity they call me honey and doll. But I also lived in Raleigh (still the South, but culturally very different thanks to the universities and IBM and others). Girl there would have been seen as offensive or dismissive by many women I knew if the man wasn't someone they knew in a familiar sense.
In any case - I agree with you that we are at a time when we need to confront the fact that different social points of view can have equal validity and it's not just a matter of one side overpowering the other anymore.
You've attacked me twice now with ad-hominem, even worse, not providing any reasonable argument.
In which case above, do you think the interchange of 'guy' or 'girl' would not be acceptable?
Try to take thoughtful position, without trolling ad-hominem.
I really hope you're not trying to suggest the use of the word 'boy' is some kind of ad-hom attack. The irony would be too strong.
(hint English does not have gendered words like say French does)
The user experience of Clef is abysmal. Maybe she is doing something other than UX?
"Although harassing conduct must be objectively viewed as creating a hostile work environment to be unlawful, the subjective perception of the particular harassed employee is still significant. If the employee does not perceive the work environment to be hostile because of that conduct, the conduct is not unlawful harassment." from [1]
So, at least in the US (I don't know how this works given state laws) - harassment must objectively be so - but it's clearly also in the eyes of the beholder.
They give an example of 'blonde jokes'.
Telling a 'blonde joke' constitutes harassment if someone is offended by it. Otherwise, it's not.
Which is definitely interesting - 'Blonde jokes' are effectively considered to be 'objectively harassing' - but it's a crime (or not) depending on whether a person perceives it to be offensive.
[1] http://www.bizfilings.com/toolkit/sbg/office-hr/managing-the...
It's not that complicated to not be a jerk.
I'd also gently suggest to reread your post and consider how slanted your characterizations are. Do you know the people involved? I've met some of them. Many of the people directly involved would strongly disagree with you.
--> The 'blonde joke' reference is not my characterization - it's actually used as the example in the fairly legal and specific summary that I referenced. Whoever wrote that article (a lawyer, presumably) felt that was a good way to communicate the essence of the law.
So that you'd accuse me of 'being paranoid' when I'm just given you the example offered by what seems to be a very credible legal resource ... is not fair.
I don't know anyone involved in this scenario. I have no idea what happened. This person could have been viciously harassed for all I know. But I do know we've only heard one persons voice, and we've only heard totally un-contextualized snippets. (For example - I do not think that 'being told to ask the waitress for a cheque in a stern voice' constitutes harassment.)
Assuming that what she is saying is 'basically true'... then the guys she's dealing with are probably douche-bags. But maybe not. I'm not going to assume they are and I don't think anyone should, unless of course 'you know the people involved' in which case you have more information on which to make a judgement.