News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by whichdan on Friday December 16, 2016 @10:39AM (#13193956)
For someone trying to define how harassment should be dealt with, you're certainly keen on dismissively calling women "girls".
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by edblarney on Friday December 16, 2016 @10:54AM (#13194076)
I'm not sure I agree.

I often call people quite my junior 'boys' and 'girls'. I work with a startup of dudes under 24. I call them 'lads'. I could technically be their father. Is that wrong? No.

Neither is using the term Mrs. Ms. or Miss.. In far-left socialist Montreal, where women are not even allowed by law to take their husband's name - people use the French equivalent everywhere: 'Madame' and 'Mademoiselle'. Same in Germany. Is that harassment now?

I think this kind of comment is not helping the situation - you want to find prejudice wherever you can, even when there is none there.

Let's work on getting the actual harassment stuff fixed - and avoid getting into culture wars.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by wpietri on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:05AM (#13194161)
> and avoid getting into culture wars

Complaining about identity politics is how white men practice identity politics. Your post here is a shot fired in a culture war. You can't do that and complain about culture wars.

The phenomenon you're exploiting here is that the status quo is seen as the default state of the system. When women talk about bias, it's easy to say, "Why are women always talking about bias? Why are they starting a culture war?"

The start of the war, though, is lost in prehistory. For millennia, women were basically property, traded among families and owned by men. In the last couple hundred years, we've been unwinding that. We're not done yet, though. E.g., in the US we only hit parity in the number of medical and law degrees circa 2005; we won't see parity in the number of doctors and lawyers for decades more.

Women didn't start the war. They, and a growing number of men, are the resistance. Hopefully we will end the war within decades. But please don't pretend that shouting, "Stop fighting back!" is equivalent to a call for peace.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by stcredzero on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:51PM (#13195168)
Complaining about identity politics is how white men practice identity politics

That's either illogical or racist. It could only be logical if you have as an axiom that white men can't possibly have a legitimate reason to complain about identity politics, which is itself a racist axiom.

Are you claiming that every non-white who practices identity politics is perfect and correct?

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by wpietri on Friday December 16, 2016 @09:45PM (#13198877)
It's observational. Because we white men are the default, we don't have to directly advocate for white men; we just have to push against anything that draws attention to our unequal status.

You are also mostly arguing with something I didn't say. I'm not saying all complaints about identity politics are illegitimate. Just that when white men are practicing identity politics, one tool they use is to complain about identity politics. Similarly, your last line is another misinterpretation.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by stcredzero on Monday December 19, 2016 @01:04AM (#13209752)
Because we white men are the default

As a person of color, I have to say that this is one of the most corrosively racist concepts there is, flat out. White people aren't special. They aren't a "default." Everyone else isn't a flavor of the month. The "everyman" isn't a white man. Because to say such is to relegate everyone else to 2nd rate status.

I'm not saying all complaints about identity politics are illegitimate. Just that when white men are practicing identity politics, one tool they use is to complain about identity politics.

It sure sounds like you're saying that all complaints from white men about identity politics are illegitimate or are somehow special because they come from white men. That strikes me as racist. Also, it sure makes white people sound special somehow.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by wpietri on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @12:08AM (#13226925)
Let me take the second point first. I'll make the statement generic: "A way people in a dominant group reinforce the power of the dominant group is to try to prevent discussions where non-dominant groups explicitly discuss their experience as non-dominant groups and how they relate to the dominant group." That's pretty clearly not a racist statement.

Now let's take another statement: in America from the 1700s onward, white men are the dominant group. This is explicitly in the foundations of the country, and although it has become less true over time, looking at things like wealth distribution, positions of power, and access to power, it's still not an unfair statement. That statement describes a racist system, but I don't believe to be racist in itself.

What do we get when we combine the two statements, using the generic thought expressed in the first and the historical specificity of the second? "The way white men practice identity politics is to complain about identity politics."

So I believe that's not a racist statement either. I also think you over-apply it. As I already explained once, I am explicitly not saying all complaints about identity politics are illegitimate. I am saying that white men acting to maintain their societal dominance will complain about identity politics as a means.

Now to your first bit, I believe what you say is correct, but you miss my point. The reason I'm bringing it up is as part of pointing out edblarney's treating of men as the default. I agree with you it's wrong that white men are treated as the generic. But in pointing it out, I'm trying to undermine it. (In case you're curious, the technical names for the phenomena that I'm concerned about here are erasure [1] and the unmarked case [2], and I'm opposed to both.)

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/07/magazine/the-painful-conse...

[2] http://www2.bakersfieldcollege.edu/driess/Readings_files/Mar...

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by wpietri on Thursday December 22, 2016 @09:57AM (#13237594)
I don't have time to keep monitoring this for replies, but feel free to email me if you want to discuss this further.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by 15charlimit on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:50AM (#13194589)
> in the US we only hit parity in the number of medical and law degrees circa 2005; we won't see parity in the number of doctors and lawyers for decades more

It is a flawed assumption that "parity in degrees" has any meaning as a measure of some vaguely-defined "equality" value.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by wpietri on Friday December 16, 2016 @09:47PM (#13198883)
That's a very fancy way to say "nuh-uh".
[dead]
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by sctb on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:42PM (#13197567)
We've asked you many times to please comment civilly and substantively on Hacker News. Please stop this. It doesn't matter what we're replying to; we don't have permission to make bad threads worse.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by unethical_ban on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:25AM (#13194315)
I'll throw my hat in: using girl in the general form during an impersonal discussion (such as anything related to facts, debates, etc.) should be discouraged. It sounds as out of place as saying "boys" to refer to men. Your argument that "girl" is the same as "guy" applies in friendly terms and informal conversation, like the examples you provided.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by justaman on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:41AM (#13194478)
I think there is something to be said about "Not Giving A Fuck". People should try it. Sometimes people just speak, and sometimes people get offended. I believe the vast majority of the time, no offense was intended. Words are just words and they cannot relay perfect messages 100% of the time. The best thing anyone can do is keep their ego's in check, do your work and do it damn well. Let your work create the narrative. Nobody's going to shit on someone who carries the team.
[dead]
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by throwaway-hn123 on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:31AM (#13194391)
>Are you sure that I'm a guy? Or even white?

Yes. Yes.

Next question, boy?

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by justaman on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:42AM (#13194493)
An example of how NOT to use "boy" or "girl" -- (being a dick)

Its less about the actual word, more about the context.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by concinds on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:37PM (#13195031)
These comments contribute absolutely nothing to the discussion. Are you trying to be inflammatory?
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by dang on Saturday December 17, 2016 @12:46AM (#13199465)
Since you have a history of breaking the HN guidelines and are continuing to do so despite our requests to stop, we've banned this account.
[dead]
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by wpietri on Friday December 16, 2016 @10:54AM (#13194081)
Hello! Guy here.

One, those terms are not interchangeable. Words have meanings.

Two, people will refer to themselves or people in their in-group by names that people in the outgroup should not call them. E.g., my friend runs a get-together called "nerd beers". I don't mind, because he is a fellow lover of technology. Other people do not get to call me a nerd. Many groups have similar patterns, including black and gay people: just because they call themselves a word does not mean that you can.

Three, guys aren't very good at noticing misogyny. Other people noticing something you don't could be idiotic. But it could also be you just missing something that they've had more time and reason to think about.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by verroq on Friday December 16, 2016 @10:57AM (#13194102)
When people call females girls they are not infantalising them. Nor do people use this word in this manner.

If you have a problem with the word girl in reference to a young woman then your quarrel is with the dictionary.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by dgacmu on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:10AM (#13194193)
The key is "young" woman. From wikipedia, "A girl is a female human from birth through childhood and adolescence to attainment of adulthood when she becomes a woman. "

The discussion is specifically about calling an adult female human a "girl". Emphasis on adult, which in the US is typically regarded as 18.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by verroq on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:15AM (#13194226)
My dictionary says a girl is a young or relatively young woman. Keyword on relatively.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by neolefty on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:13PM (#13194782)
I recommend you give up on this one. It sounds defensive and isn't helping your argument.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by sagichmal on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:31PM (#13194968)
> When people call females girls they are not infantalising them.

Yes, they often are. And this is often the way it is received, regardless of intent.

edit: And, for the record, "females" is also a favorite objectifying shibboleth in certain circles. (Not accusing you, necessarily.) Just use "women".

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by pfarnsworth on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:48PM (#13195659)
Do you call your male coworkers "boys"? Like, "Well, the boys in my team are very experienced in Java."

If you don't, then you don't use the term "girls" to talk about your female coworkers. Period. End of Story.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by AlexandrB on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:10AM (#13194190)
Well you certainly made your point, boy. Now go fetch my slippers!
[dead]
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by sleepybrett on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:27AM (#13194332)
No, you should say "Hey ladies, there's an issue, let's huddle"

You are welcome to call them girls if they are children. It might also be appropriate outside of a professional context to address a group of women you are close with, but I can't ever see a reason to use the word girls in a professional setting to refer to female coworkers. It's belittling and disrespectful.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by yodon on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:28AM (#13194355)
Actually, what the responders above are saying is no, they wouldnt. You are saying that you would. A great many other people are telling you the norms you have internalized are quite different from the norms they internalized.

Verbal norms change over time, just as other forms of norms change. You don't have to modify your norms to keep up with how the rest of society views those norms, but where they impact legal decisions your personal choice to reject the change in external norms may have a significant cost to you at some point.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by edblarney on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:34AM (#13194419)
" It's belittling and disrespectful."

Completely false.

'Lady' is the feminine of 'Gentlemen'.

I could, but would not usually say:

"Gentlemen, let's go out for lunch"

So I could, but would not likely say:

"Ladies, let's go out for lunch"

I would normally say:

"Guys, let's go out for lunch"

Or:

"Girls, let's go out for lunch"

'Girls' is fully appropriate in every one of those situations.

You are seeing sexism wherein there absolutely is none and this is a problem.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by AlexandrB on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:09AM (#13194181)
Context is everything. If your employer called you "boy" you would be upset. If a judge in a court of law called you "boy" you would be upset as well. And rightly so. While if a friend refers to your group of friends as "the boys", that's clearly a term of endearment.

Calling women "girls" while discussing something like the politics of harassment has the effect of subtly diminishing their credibility and personhood.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by verroq on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:18AM (#13194246)
You seem to think the grandparent deliberately used this term to demean women. I don't think so. I think the usage is common enough that you are being oversensitative.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by st3v3r on Friday December 16, 2016 @08:03PM (#13198370)
Given that poster's other comments in here, I seem to doubt that. It's seeming like the grandparent is using it to demean women, and is getting angry that they're being called out on it.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by KMag on Friday December 16, 2016 @08:20PM (#13198502)
> Calling women "girls" while discussing something like the politics of harassment has the effect of subtly diminishing their credibility and personhood.

Do you mean "adulthood" instead of "personhood", or are you using "personhood" as a term d'art unfamiliar to me? (I am assuming you consider a child or adolescent to be a person as much as an adult is a person, with as much personality.)

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by mikestew on Friday December 16, 2016 @10:56AM (#13194096)
Grown women will also refer each other girls.

I've heard a similar argument before, in reference to race. The logic is equally weak when crusty old white bigots use it.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by xeeeeeeeeeeenu on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:08AM (#13194177)
>The logic is equally weak when crusty old white bigots use it.

Do you realize that you're being a racist?

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by indigo_rex on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:41AM (#13194476)
No, this is a ridiculous claim.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by verroq on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:04AM (#13194148)
Ah a term used mostly as a racist perjorative is comparable to the word "girl" with has no negative qualities when used in reference to a young women. Take your strawman home with you.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by mikestew on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:16AM (#13194232)
The only straw man is from the one arguing about the terms used. I was referring to logic used to justify the use of those terms, quoting your post in the process. It's almost the antithesis of the straw man argument.
Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by justaman on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:52AM (#13194603)
Ever notice how everyone only ever cites "Strawman" on the internet?

Its because thats the only logical fallacy they can remember because it so often reinforces their own arguments in their own heads by not adding information. Every idiot who never studied logic will cry "STRAWMAN!"

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by edblarney on Friday December 16, 2016 @11:24AM (#13194301)
"The logic is equally weak when crusty old white bigots use it."

This comment is racist and bigoted.

Re:Harassment at Apple: A personal perspective by in_cahoots on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:41PM (#13195584)
No, we don't. I am a woman and I do not use those terms interchangeably. Neither do any of the other professional women I know.

My female friends are called 'the girls' as a group. But at work it's either 'woman', 'gals', or 'guys'. I would never call a coworker girl unless she referred to herself that way, and I haven't heard my male or female coworkers do it either. At work calling an adult a 'girl' brings up immediate connotations of "the girls in secretary" from an earlier era, just as 'boy' brings up unpleasant racial connotations from that same era.