News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by siavosh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:30PM (#13064499)
My current thought is that corrupted capitalism has corrupted democracies making them unaccountable to the majority of people, leading to a massive and still accelerating level of economic inequality. When this happens all sorts of bad things happen; political monsters, populist demagogues, racism, loss of faith in democratic institutions etc. Leading to people wanting to radically change the system to someone who says they will 'get things done', which has to be outside of the system.

These are truly concerning times; in America at least, no one in political power is discussing serious policy proposals to reduce the influence of money in politics and hence address the accelerating transition of wealth from the lower and middle class to a tiny fraction at the very top. This is not a stable course. Even the current president elect despite his populist slogans is going to increase the regressive tax rate based on debunked trickle down economics (what actually helped lead to the current inequality in the 1980s), and wants to eliminate the estate tax all together. Both of these will merely accelerate the current course. No light is visible at the end of the tunnel.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by jseliger on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:58PM (#13064741)
Actually, it may be that there is too little corruption: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-05-07/in-politi... in most of politics, and too much ideological purity.

Right now, for example, it is very hard for party leaders in the House and Senate to wrangle their followers, in part because they've lost the carrot and stick that earmarks used to represent (by the way, I used to be against earmarks and have changed my mind and realized that the "solution" is much worse than the problem). Consequently, we have much greater ideological coherence at the expense of actual government functioning.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by ant6n on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:46PM (#13065207)
I'd say there are many other ways to make politics less dogmatic, rather than increasing corruption and pork.

How about a more representative democracy, celebrating pluralism, and as a result, requiring parties to engage in coalitions as nobody ever has the majority.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by metaphorm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:58PM (#13065330)
don't misuse the word corruption. you're obscuring the argument you're trying to make and misrepresenting the argument of the post you responded to.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dominotw on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:00PM (#13064752)
>reduce the influence of money in politics

Isn't money in media more of serious concern. What about billionaires co-opting media as their mouthpieces.

nytimes - carlos slim

slate/wapo.. - jeff bezos

salon - John Warnock

twitter - price al waleed

Ironically nytimes, for all their moral outrage, itself is funded by the money acquired through subversion of democracy in mexico , cheating mexicans out of billions of dollars every year. [1]

1. https://www.oecd.org/sti/broadband/50550219.pdf

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by KirinDave on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:32PM (#13065077)
If money in media were having an immediate and crippling effect on democracy then it would have already.

The history of American media is a history of very rich people growing, owning and acquiring media. They've always had this influence.

And yes it may be sub-optimal, but it is not new and therefore difficult to directly attribute recent changes to. In fact, it's somewhat arguable that the current predicament we find ourselves in is the result of making media less expensive to disseminate, not the opposite.

Our society and biology are poorly trained to reject incorrect information. So when small unethical actors begin to proliferate doing quick profit cycles on sympathetic populations, we see a lot of uptake for those ideas.

Want a great example that won't pick a big 2016 political fight? PETA. Despite being a rather ineffective activist group with a large incoherent message, they can inexpensively produce tons of populist media that helps keep them in people's minds and associate them (however wrongly) with helping animals.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dominotw on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:44PM (#13065198)
> If money in media were having an immediate and crippling effect on democracy then it would have already.

'tell the press' emails are not crippling enough?

http://www.salon.com/2016/11/09/the-hillary-clinton-campaign...

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by cafard on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:01PM (#13065792)
"Poll after poll showed that he would have beaten Trump in the general election by wide margins."

Poll after poll, taken after Sanders quit, showed Clinton beating Trump by wide margins.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by KirinDave on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:13PM (#13065872)
It's curious how blithely we ignore the systemic bias argument when people are talking about the might-have-beens around Sanders.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by gremlinsinc on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:24PM (#13065526)
Media's always been controlled by certain interests, yes -- but one of the worst things ever was when Reagan repealed the Fairness Doctrine - it was the beginning of the end of true journalism -- that required equal time for ALL sides of an argument. Now it's all opinion pieces and slanted news is now the norm.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dagw on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @05:20AM (#13069640)
that required equal time for ALL sides of an argument.

How would that make things better? Not all sides deserve equal time, nor is there any requirement to present the 'other' side in a fair and accurate light. Having clearly stated up front biases is far better than biases hidden behind a veneer of faked impartiality and careful stage managed 'fairness'.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by cmdrfred on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:49PM (#13065245)
>If money in media were having an immediate and crippling effect on democracy then it would have already.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Randolph_Hearst

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by KirinDave on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:00PM (#13065347)
Riiight, but honest question: do we think that constitutes a crippling of democracy?

The Hearst family is one I'm familiar with and referring to above.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by cmdrfred on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:02PM (#13065372)
What is a democracy but the choices of an informed electorate? If that electorate is misinformed, then you don't have one.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by KirinDave on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:20PM (#13068230)
I don't know what "an informed electorate" means.

Even "educated" people here debate climate science with absolutely ridiculous claims. This is as good as it gets. That's the painful truth I've been trying to swallow.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by basch on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:05PM (#13065389)
where do 99.9% of people get the information they use to make an educated vote? where do people source policy, position, and historical information from?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by richmarr on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @05:06AM (#13069589)
> where do 99.9% of people get the information they use to make an educated vote?

People use information to make an educated vote? I missed that memo

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by pg314 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:07PM (#13064840)
Do you have any evidence that Carlos Slim has any influence on the editorial board of the New York Times? Or Jeff Bezos influencing the Washington Post editorial board?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by mikeryan on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:48PM (#13065223)
I can't point to metrics but the current rash of Washington Post stories seem to be skewing much more left then in the past. It could just be the times we are in a lot of the news I follow seems to be that way.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by iainmerrick on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @12:24PM (#13072637)
In the past it may have been a cheap shot, but I think it's fair to say that reality has a left-wing bias right now. Denying climate change is now right-wing orthodoxy and is about to be entrenched in the White House.

Or to put it another way, I think politics has lurched right rather than the Post moving left. Do you have any particular stories in mind, though?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by aclsid on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:40PM (#13065645)
His assertion also made me curious. There seems to be a slight bias in favor of Slim at the NYT though.

Just read that article, it does portray the version from the other party, but always allowing for a proper justification for Slim's position so that one might find it reasonable.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/10/world/americas/mexicos-car...

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dominotw on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:19PM (#13064957)
My response was to a comment wanting generic policy towards "money in politics", assumption being that everyone who gets money is offering something in return. Your question is irrelevant in this context.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by messick on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:51PM (#13066550)
> Ironically nytimes, for all their moral outrage, itself is funded by the money acquired through subversion of democracy in mexico , cheating mexicans out of billions of dollars every year.

If by "funded" you mean a rich dude in Mexico owns just 16% of the stock.

You are going to need to provide more than Trump Campaign taking points if you are going to accuse NYT of being Slim's mouthpiece.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by jff on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:25PM (#13064997)
You forgot:

Bloomberg - Michael Bloomberg

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by andrepd on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:56PM (#13064721)
> no one in political power is discussing serious policy proposals to reduce the influence of money in politics and hence address the accelerating transition of wealth from the lower and middle class to a tiny fraction at the very top

This was the very platform Sanders ran on. Overturning citizens united was probably his #1 political priority.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by pg314 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:04PM (#13064807)
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by thesagan on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:12PM (#13064882)
I think a lot of voters didn't take her as seriously on the proposal.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by metaphorm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:00PM (#13065352)
I think a lot of voters found it impossible to take Clinton seriously on _any_ proposal she was making. The naked pandering and secret agendas were much too obvious.

Trump too was nakedly pandering. He was just better at it and had a more receptive base for it. He was better at keeping his agenda secret as well. Does anybody have a clear idea about what his administration policies will really be?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:03PM (#13065373)
> Trump too was nakedly pandering. He was just better at it and had a more receptive base for it

If that was true, wouldn't more people have voted for him?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by rconti on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:49PM (#13065714)
If that was the only factor influencing peoples' votes, sure!
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by richmarr on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @05:03AM (#13069572)
> Does anybody have a clear idea about what his administration policies will really be?

Their policy direction is pretty strongly hinted at by the chosen transition team, no?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by __derek__ on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:36PM (#13065125)
... which is hilarious given that the case was about a negative ad about her.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by musha68k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:44PM (#13065192)
Sanders should have founded his own party. How many signatures do you have to collect before that can happen in the US?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Futurebot on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @08:01PM (#13067616)
It's not hard to start a party; it's hard to do anything useful with it due to a raft of anti-third party laws and regulations:

https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/11/bernie-sanders-democratic...

'Over the three decades following US entry into World War I, as working-class and socialist parties burgeoned throughout the industrialized world, American elites chose to deal with the problem by radically restricting access to the ballot. In state after state, petition requirements and filing deadlines were tightened and various forms of routine legal harassment, unknown in the rest of the democratic world, became the norm.

The new restrictions came in waves, usually following the entry of left-wing parties into the electoral process. According to data gathered by Richard Winger of Ballot Access News, in 1931 Illinois raised the petition requirement for third-party statewide candidates from one thousand signatures to twenty-five thousand. In California, the requirement was raised from 1 percent of the last total gubernatorial vote to 10 percent. In 1939, Pennsylvania suddenly decided it was important that the thousands of required signatures be gathered solely within a three-week period. In New York, according to one account, “minor-party petitions began to be challenged for hyper-technical defects.

"Although these statutes have been assailed on all sides,” a 1937 Columbia Law Review article reported, “their severity is constantly being increased, probably because the interests oppressed seldom have representation in the legislatures.” Indeed, when the Florida legislature found socialists and communists advancing at the polls, it responded in 1931 by banning any party from the ballot unless it had won 30 percent of the vote in two consecutive elections; naturally, when the Republican Party failed to meet that test, the state immediately lowered the threshold.

By comparison, in Britain getting on the ballot was never a major concern'

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by int_19h on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:06PM (#13065405)
You don't need any. The problem, rather, is getting ballot access, election funding, and access to debates.

And even with all that, the FPTP system makes it virtually impossible for a third party candidate to win, unless one of the existing major parties collapses outright.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by forgotmysn on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:06PM (#13065401)
Zero. Any American can create their own party whenever they want.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by woofyman on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:01PM (#13064772)
Also public funding of elections.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by drewrv on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:43PM (#13064596)
I think the recent election demonstrated that money doesn't matter that much. Voters actually have power. That's the silver lining to the depressing reality that voters don't care if industry writes regulations, the executive branch tortures people, and the rich pay even less in taxes.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:47PM (#13064640)
I think the election proved the opposite - that if you can manipulate headlines, you can suppress voters from even coming out.

If you look past all of the fake news, twitter faux pas, etc., I think that FBI Director Comey's manipulation in the last week really did do a number on the voter base, and it's disappointing that nobody is enforcing the Hatch act.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by matt_wulfeck on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:11PM (#13064873)
When was the last time you spoke to people in towns of less than 10k people about their most serious issues?

It's so odd to me that Silicon Valley simply can't comprehend that their values aren't shared by the rest of the country. Literally the only explanation they can produce to explain Trump votes is that everyone must have been brainwashed by Facebook news (despite the fact that millions of voters probably don't even have social media).

There was a time when democrats represented the blue collar working class -- who have watched helplessly as their jobs and security has been outsourced to china and Mexico. Now it's Trump who represents their values and clearly they're not alone.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:17PM (#13064927)
I grew up in an unincorporated town in WI, so to answer your accusatory question: Sunday was the last time I talked to people in a town <10k.

I'm also not sure what "silicon valley sentiment" has to do with wanting enforcement of the Hatch act either. The idea that rural white america is a victim and needs protecting is one of those being spread by the alt-right, and it's wrong to think it justifies manipulating the election.

>Have you tried to start a business before? Are you familiar with the debilitating beauracracy and taxes associated with running a small business (15-50 people) that doesn't take venture capital funding? Nope. I'm a computer engineer and everyone should care about what I care about or they're brainwashed.

Yes. Yes. And that last remark is uncalled for, since I'm not a computer engineer or think that.

[dead]
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by madamelic on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:55PM (#13065296)
What matters more is we don't create an environment where a facist government can thrive.

I am not calling Trump a facist but hand-waving away racist policies like deporting all Mexicans (Trump didn't say that, but it was taken that way) or disallowing all Muslims (again, Trump didn't say that but it was taken that way) as "SJW" is irresponsible.

I think we can have a country where both can co-exist. Maybe people need to realize they can't work 35-hour weeks at "the factory" anymore. Those jobs are long gone.

That sucks and we need to figure out how to get those people back to work but this whole "bringing back the jobs" is complete political BS.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:32PM (#13065589)
>I am not calling Trump a facist but hand-waving away racist policies like deporting all Mexicans (Trump didn't say that, but it was taken that way) or disallowing all Muslims (again, Trump didn't say that but it was taken that way) as "SJW" is irresponsible.

It was taken that way by people opposed to him or trying to cut him down. I've never heard a supporter represent those as his positions, but rather constantly try to accurately represent what was said. If people decide to create absurd straw men, what responsibility do his supporters have to address them? And how does the wildly inaccurate view of his opponents make him or his supporters irresponsible?

A system where a fascist government can thrive is one wherein the press is in collusion with the government, and where people prop up ideological narratives in lieu of the truth. When we constantly push to dehumanize our opponents and their supporters, we start taking the first small steps down the ideological road that leads to the horrors of totalitarian governments.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by madamelic on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:14PM (#13065878)
Yeah, I agree with like 99% of what you are saying. All of that is right.

>(From my parent comment) But in the end, what matters more: "some democrat love-relationship with LGBT, environmental stuffs, SJWs, or whatever" -or- "food on your plate, and a place to live in with your family"?

What I disagree with is that we have to decide between denigrating others and fixing the economy. We can have both and it is irresponsible to pretend like we have to choose.

I am just hoping Trump and Senate Republicans understand that. But my guess is that they'll throw LGBT people under the bus when they need a distraction, which every politician eventually needs.

Politicians aren't dumb, their entire livelihood is dependent on knowing how to cater to their base.

(Sorry, I feel like my thoughts are becoming a little disjointed from what we are talking about. I buy into like 95% of what Trump supports but I don't buy we need to tear down 'SJW' so the economy can thrive, it is completely illogical to me)

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:34PM (#13066025)
I'm not sure I understand where the Trump is against gays things comes from. He's probably the most pro LGBT Republican candidate in the history of the country, and arguably has a better track record than Clinton.

Personally, I think political correctness is a problem, but that seems like a conversation for another time.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by madamelic on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:46PM (#13066522)
I would definitely agree with the political correctness comment.

I think the big issue with Trump isn't that he is anti-LGBT (He is actually quite LGBT friendly... the same cannot be said for Pence though), the issue is that his campaign has signaled that it is okay to not be. It doesn't matter what you believe, you still have to be civil and respectful of others.

It doesn't matter what Trump's position is, the issue is his spoken beliefs have somehow morphed into supporting alt-right beliefs.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:26PM (#13066761)
I feel like on the LGBT issue, you might be falling into an echo chamber trap. If you have some campaign points that support your claim, I'd be happy to hear them. Points for consideration, particularly as far as campaign messaging goes:

-He had Peter Thiel speak at the RNC

-During his speech at the RNC he talked about defending LGBT rights and said that it felt good to say that at a Republican gathering and get cheers. Think about that. He has the Republican party cheering for gays. I never thought I'd see the day.

-When asked about the bathroom row in N.C. he said he doesn't care what bathroom people use.

-He said if Caitlin Jenner visits Trump Tower, she can use any bathroom she wants.

Mike Pence is an obvious appeal to the Republican base. I think it's important to keep in mind the the VP tends to not be all that important. Unless the president dies. If you got any friends planning a Trump assassination, remind them of that :)

I'd also like to point out that there's a decent chance his stance on this isn't a contrivance (though it might be). The LGBT population isn't considered part of the Republican base, and generally they either ignore or campaign against gays. In a lot of ways, being as openly pro-gay was probably considered a risk by establishment Republicans.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by madamelic on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:38PM (#13066826)
Oh no, I wasn't meaning Trump himself was anti-LGBT. I was meaning that his campaign was kind of about being politically incorrect which I feel has empowered the alt-right to be more bold.

In that, because they perceive Trump as being friendly to their cause, they feel their anti-social behavior is ok. Trump seemed hesitant during the campaign to take a strong stance against alt-right / anti-social thoughts. But maybe I am wrong, I wasn't exactly an avid Trump supporter, hah.

There is nothing wrong with disagreeing with LGBT people, I actually think it needs to happen more often. There is something wrong with feeling LGBT people are wrong to exist or are 2nd class citizens.

As long as Trump stays alive and unimpeached, I am not really worried about LGBT rights. He was pretty direct in that gay marriage was settled (which brings up the whole point about how does he accept Supreme Court ruling on gay marriage but not abortion?)

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:21PM (#13067070)
I don't think you really have anything to worry about. And if by alt-right you mean white nationalists, you're talking about almost nobody. They've just gotten a shitload of attention lately because it's the media's most recent boogey man.

Like, the white nationalist gather in D.C. that has gotten so much attention consisted of 300 people: 150 attending and 150 protesting. They're nothing.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by aclsid on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:48PM (#13065704)
The work at the factory is working wonders for the economy of Mexico and China. Add to that, the fact that US labor laws are pretty strict and you should have a steady source of jobs right there.

I'm sorry but bringing back the jobs is not bs. How do you justify that Ford and GMC took TARP funds but they still preferred to let Detroit rot? I did not like Clinton or Trump. Bernie Sanders probably had a better platform, but socialist policies rarely do something good for the economy. But on this point, Trump is absolutely right, to the point where Ford backed down from their plans to move a factory to Mexico.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by JadeNB on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @09:21AM (#13070889)
> But on this point, Trump is absolutely right, to the point where Ford backed down from their plans to move a factory to Mexico.

But that didn't happen: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/17/trump... . (Note that the URL unfortunately suffers from some translation error so that it says the opposite of the headline: Ford wasn't planning to move the plant.)

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by madamelic on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:02PM (#13065800)
I just don't know.

Do we really want to stagnate just for the nostalgia of the past? I see letting go of these jobs as a freedom to move onto the next evolution of work.

Maybe that is incredibly idealistic but maybe it is better to accept that maybe NAFTA and letting jobs go to foreign countries was wrong and move onto building the future.

Corporations are definitely shitty but I am hesitant to cheer on bringing back the past just for the sake of thumbing our nose at people.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:49PM (#13066873)
Why aren't people lamenting more over the loss of agricultural jobs? We went from 33% Agricultural jobs to just 2%, thanks to automation, yet we love one form of manual labor more than the other. Even in China and other outsourced countries, manufacturing jobs are being replaced by automation.

This romancing of manufacturing jobs is a strange cultural obsession in the U.S. Maybe it's because our "American" identity is tied to working hard to producing physical things, but I digress.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by candiodari on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:19PM (#13068226)
Easy, back then: heavy back-braking vastly underpaid agricultural jobs with inconsistent hours were replaced on a voluntary basis by offering people higher pay in factories. Aside from agricultural employers, no complaints.

Now: we'll take that $30 per hour job you've been doing for 15-20 years thank you. Oh you need a job ? How about this 10$ per hour (with unpaid overtime and a horrible boss) burger flipping job ? No ? How about these 3 part time $8.75 per hour jobs that will require you to commute between them, at least once per day, cannot be done without a car (that your employer is not paying for) ... Better job ? You do have a masters or phd, right ? No ? Well don't expect them to even call back.

There is no romancing of manufacturing jobs, I believe that's a misunderstanding. There is a romancing of reliable, long-term, well-paying jobs. Once you get that, it's very easy to understand.

If the service economy cannot provide that, it's just not a replacement of the manufacturing jobs. The leftist/democrat point of view used to be that if the "new economic reality" can't provide that, it needs to be legislated out of existence, attacked and opposed at every turn. Now Trump is the one providing that viewpoint on the republican side.

I seem to remember that in the late 80s we had a similar push. Everyone pushed to be "little entrepreneurs" (ha!). Doing package delivery. Cold calling sales. Pyramid schemes. It was legislated out of existence, rightfully.

And yes, I get it. This is hacker news. "Legislated out of existence, attacked and opposed at every turn", we're taking about airbnb, uber, sprig, delivery hero, ... and by extension about google, yahoo, facebook, etc ... You really don't want those companies opposed, or god help us, destroyed, for obvious reasons. You don't get why that people feel that needs to happen, because none of your friends are confronted with reality like this, and there aren't any family members providing a perspective of what manufacturing brings. I just hope I can bring some more viewpoints in the picture here.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:04PM (#13068402)
Except nobody is talking about the bringing the reliable, long term service jobs back to the U.S. Manufacturing is only 11% of our jobs, Agriculture 2%, yet manufacturing is what is being romanced.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by flukus on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @12:05AM (#13068618)
Manufacturing had a permanence that service jobs don't, they were often jobs for life, you could long term financial decisions.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by kefka on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:58PM (#13068591)
Nobody wants to be out in the summer heat, with the sun blazing down. And then, the work itself is back-breaking hard work. And it never paid as well as the industrial and manufacturing jobs paid.

And you're also competing (in the South) with temp immigrants at low low wages, because those wages are good compared to Mexico.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by aclsid on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @07:33AM (#13070169)
Again, look at countries that do keep their manufacturing jobs. So maybe you think China and Mexico are backwards countries, so let me put it this way then. Look at what Germany and Japan are still doing.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by candiodari on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @07:03AM (#13070024)
Service jobs are mostly waiting tables, generously interpreted (e.g. from in an Actual restaurant, in a bar, in McDonalds up to maybe stacking shelves).

These jobs suck.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by threatofrain on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:58PM (#13065327)
Small towns of 10k? What about the city of hundred thousands? Or the city of millions? Off the top of your head, would you mind speculating as to what % of America lives in cities or urban environments?

Are we forgetting that small states and small districts generally get an unjust magnitude of political power? That the gerrymandering game of the last 30 years have favored these small states with small districts? Are all American lives equal or do those who live in cities matter less? The answer is yes. American lives are equal, and those who live in cities are worth less.

Trump did not win the populist victory. Hillary Clinton did. This is twice in recent memory that the majority of the United States was overruled by the minority.

As people criticize Hillary Clinton for arrogantly not visiting states and cities she thought were victories, do people in those states not realize that they get an unjust magnitude of power and influence every time election season rolls around? And that big cities and states basically get zero attention?

And why? Is it because big states like California or Texas are unworthy? Yes, thanks to the structure of American politics and districting. The Texan economy is doing great by the way.

Or did you think that Trump is a populist candidate? So popular that he didn't win the popular vote? Do you believe that Trump will ever win the popular vote?

How long should American voters remember that they were twice denied by minority voices? For how many years ought they bear this stain in their trust in government legitimacy?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:38PM (#13065627)
>small states and small districts generally get an unjust magnitude of political power

The electoral college exists for a reason: precisely to protect the interests of the minority of people who don't live in cities from the whims of those who do. I live in Maine and we recently passed a citizen referendum for a large minimum wage increase in the state. This is almost entirely because of the people in a few population centers. These places will be able to absorb that hike moderately well, but the rural parts of the state are going to get crushed by it, and they're already the poorest parts of the state. It should have been a city ordinance, but was not.

>Trump did not win the populist victory. Hillary Clinton did.

Both campaigns were strategized around the existence of the electoral college. Winning the popular vote is merely an artifact of the system in place, but holds no real meaning. There's little reason to assume that were the popular vote what actually decided the election that the result of the election would have been different, as the strategies employed by both campaigns would have been different.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:35PM (#13066811)
>protect the interests of the minority of people who don't live in cities from the whims of those who do

This is a straw man that is commonly made by advocates of the EC. The top 50 cities in the U.S. only account for 15% of the total population, so it's a nonexistent problem.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:26PM (#13067114)
Yeah, I actually mispoke. the EC is to balance the larger more powerful states against the interests of the smaller ones. It is a compromise that was necessary to fashion the union in the first place. The reason it's not obvious is because of the federal government growing far beyond what it was intended to be.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by throwaway729 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:51PM (#13067266)
> the EC is to balance the larger more powerful states against the interests of the smaller ones

This is not the reason the EC exists: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13038525

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by rconti on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:52PM (#13065732)
Yes, both campaigns were strategized around the existence of the electoral college, but that's tweaking at the margins. It doesn't explain a vote difference in the millions.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by int_19h on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:12PM (#13068196)
The main reason for the difference in millions isn't even electoral college per se, it's the fact that most (all but 2) states allocate all their electors to whoever gets more votes in that state. In essence, every state throws all its minority votes away. If you think of it in terms of vote suppression (which, frankly, it is), it's one of such epic proportions that it dwarfs everything else, including redistricting, voter ID laws etc.

I mean, think about it. In California, 33% of residents voted for Trump this year - and those votes didn't count in any sensible way. In Texas, 43% of residents voted for Clinton this year - and those votes didn't count, either!

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:45PM (#13066118)
How do you know that? How many republicans in California don't bother voting?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:37PM (#13066823)
Trump had the same number of Republicans voting for him as did Mitt Romney, while Clinton had far less Democrats voting than Obama.

This idea that there is impact from republicans not voting isn't true, and what happened actually exasperates the popular vote difference.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:54PM (#13066895)
>This idea that there is impact from republicans not voting isn't true

Which is supported by what evidence?

There are tons of people that don't vote in any given election. Everyone has their reasons, and I'm sure apathy is the leading one, but it's crazy to suggest some portion of them don't vote because they live in a state that won't flip anyway. If you a Republican in California or a Democrat in Kansas, you don't really expect your vote to count.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:02PM (#13068392)
Post election analysis. The Republicans came out and voted at the same levels as the last election, the Democrats did not. This is why the popular vote difference is exasperated, because the candidate with the most popular vote, by millions, had less of a turnout.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @08:30AM (#13070458)
You seem to be missing my point. In any election, some large portion of the population doesn't vote at all. At least some of them are refraining because they know their state is a foregone conclusion.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @01:12PM (#13073102)
And you're missing my point that your making broad generalizations about every election is pointless - that the difference between this election and other elections is what matters.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by JadeNB on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @09:25AM (#13070932)
> it's crazy to suggest some portion of them don't vote because they live in a state that won't flip anyway.

You mean that it's not crazy to suggest this, right?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @11:00AM (#13071758)
Yeah, whoops! I ended up arguing against myself there :)
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by flukus on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:17PM (#13068461)
> Trump had the same number of Republicans voting for him as did Mitt Romney

Was voting republican in california in 2012 any less of a waste?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by basch on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:15PM (#13065460)
>This is twice in recent memory that the majority of the United States was overruled by the minority.

Which means nothing because they were not playing a popular vote contest. We will never know who would have won, on that day, in a pure popular vote contest.

Winning the popular vote and losing the contest means you miscalculated, and misprovisioned your campaign resources, focusing too heavily on areas you already won.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by serge2k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:25PM (#13065533)
The problem is that this hasn't been a problem since the late 1800s. It's only in the last few elections that the combination of people moving to cities, polarization of most states, and capping the house have created a situation where you can actually lose the popular vote and still win the presidency (it's always been possible, but it didn't happen for over 100 years for good reason).
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by basch on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @11:22AM (#13071971)
the electoral college exists to prevent the popular vote from mattering.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by serge2k on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @01:55PM (#13073540)
It also exists to give slave states power and to make the choice of president up to the electors but we don't use it for either of those purposes nowadays.

Plus, the number of representatives has been capped since the early 1900s. That serves to take things further away from even.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by basch on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @02:11PM (#13073665)
>make the choice of president up to the electors

which maybe they should have.

>representatives has been capped

which should be fixed.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by threatofrain on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:18PM (#13065484)
The name of the game that's being played is gerrymandering.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by basch on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @11:21AM (#13071962)
How often do state borders change? How frequently do counties switch states?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by serge2k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:23PM (#13065521)
People who live in cities aren't real americans. They are the white collar elite. THey don't deserve votes worth as much as those hard working, blue collar gents in the Heartland of America.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by aclsid on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:51PM (#13065724)
I should probably point out that the vast majority of people that live in cities could hardly qualify to be called white collar elite.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by rconti on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:59PM (#13065782)
IMO, Democrats are STILL speaking to the plight of the poor far more than the Republicans are.

The problem is, whether through 'natural' forces, the destruction of union power, etc, most of the "we fight for the poor" is about implementing social programs, and, at best, the minimum wage.

But most people don't want handouts. Most people want to be proud and find value from their work.

The Republican party doesn't show more interest in this than they have in the past, but neither does the Democratic party.

Trump can appeal because he can tell them they can have THEIR jobs back. THEIR past glory. Something they were proud of. This is very different from telling a 50 year old "don't worry, we'll send you to 6 months of 'retraining' and you can start your career over in a minimum wage job -- but don't worry, it'll be the NEW minimum wage, $1 higher than the old one!"

Now, obviously Trump can't deliver on his promise. But then again, neither has anyone else, and at least his promise is appealing to them.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by GVIrish on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:41PM (#13065163)
Here's the thing though, Trump didn't get appreciably more voter turnout than Mitt Romney. Hillary on the other hand, got a lot less Democratic voters to turn out than Obama did.

We don't know how much damage Comey's actions in particular did to Hillary's candidacy but there is no doubt that the email scandal damaged her prospects tremendously.

> There was a time when democrats represented the blue collar working class -- who have watched helplessly as their jobs and security has been outsourced to china and Mexico. Now it's Trump who represents their values and clearly they're not alone.

Trump clearly tapped into that sentiment, particularly on trade deals. However, the Republican party has largely pushed policies that increase income inequality and hurt blue collar workers for some time now. Republicans have consistently attempted to weaken unions that tended to benefit blue collar workers.

Republican voters don't tend to hold them to account for that because the GOP campaigns successfully on wedge social issues, conservative media still largely supports trickle down economics and said social issues. Fake media only reinforces the echo chamber there.

Unfortunately there isn't much honest discourse on what to do about the effects of globalization and automation on the blue collar workforce now and into the future. I suspect that the job-reducing effects will continue to be used as a weapon for grievance politics but effective policy solutions will be hard to come by.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by micaksica on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:37PM (#13065623)
> We don't know how much damage Comey's actions in particular did to Hillary's candidacy but there is no doubt that the email scandal damaged her prospects tremendously.

I don't understand what logic there is in blaming Comey for actions Clinton made. Her and her staff decided to run the server. The FBI did not fabricate something here that needed to be investigated.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:42PM (#13066841)
Comey violated the Hatch act, which is in place to prevent people of his station from manipulating U.S. elections.

He outright disobeyed the Attorney General's (his bosses) orders and released the information before he even had a warrant approved by a judge to investigate, just days before the election.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by serge2k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:02PM (#13066620)
He went against standard procedures to bring up the investigation in public days before the election.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by curried_haskell on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:53PM (#13065278)
Hillary's campaign failed because it was so fucking forced. Come on guys, you have to vote for Hillary because she's a woman and its her turn and shame on you for thinking this was a democratic process.

I think a lot of Democrats were put off and disillusioned. Hillary wasn't a candidate to be excited about, she was the candidate waiting in line whom you were told you had to vote for.

And so people stayed home.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by tomp on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @02:18AM (#13069064)
> Come on guys, you have to vote for Hillary because she's a woman

For me, one of the biggest WTFs this election season was when I noticed that Hillary was literally selling "woman cards" on her website. The article below mentions at was meant as a joke, though I'm not sure most people took it that way...

http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/clinton-issuing-woman-cards/

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by matt_wulfeck on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:12PM (#13065866)
I was very upset at the DNC's very visible (no thanks to Russian hackers) attempt to discredit and downplay the Bernie campaign.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by matt_wulfeck on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:02PM (#13065799)
It's pretty clear that "republican" and "democrat" have largely lost their meanings, as Trump is more independent and pretty much hated by his own party, and the democrat running has a historical record of being friends with Wall Street.

This appears to happen every so often. After all, who do you know who votes for the Whig party?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:31PM (#13065585)
>There was a time when democrats represented the blue collar working class -- who have watched helplessly as their jobs and security has been outsourced to china and Mexico. Now it's Trump who represents their values and clearly they're not alone.

Judging by the way blue-collar communities turned out for Bernie Sanders, I don't think "their values" are the fascist tripe being pushed by the Trump campaign and transition stuff. No, blue-collar people are not automatically violent rubes who want to throw Jews, Muslims, and Hispanics from the country while reinstituting slavery and criminalizing abortion -- while telling people wages are too high.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by matt_wulfeck on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:20PM (#13065920)
I was ready for Bernie. I changed my party affiliation so I could vote for him in the primaries. Are you as upset as I am at the DNC's collusion to suppress his campaign?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:22PM (#13067080)
Of course I'm upset. I'm upset enough that I joined Democratic Socialists of America and have been involved in activism, rather than just getting mad and sending money to corporate shills on occasion.
[dead]
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Mikeb85 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:39PM (#13067201)
You're ignoring the fact that inequality has increased in a measurable way, it's not something that can be solved on an individual level. As the saying goes, when your neighbor loses his job, it's a recession - when you lose yours it's a depression.

Also, by definition, not everyone can out-compete the average, if everyone in the country had a PhD, there'd still be unemployment. Not everyone in such a large country can do the same thing.

And yes, maybe lots of these people are stupid. But they're part of society, and societal problems manifest themselves in ways that assuredly don't benefit people like you.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by flukus on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @07:22PM (#13067414)
> And yes, maybe lots of these people are stupid. But they're part of society, and societal problems manifest themselves in ways that assuredly don't benefit people like you.

Everyone seems to forget this. A large part of society is simply not cut out for academia and they still need to make a life for themselves somehow.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by kazagistar on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @10:28AM (#13071455)
There was higher turnout in this election then the last.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by mi100hael on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:45PM (#13064619)
> voters don't care if industry writes regulations, the executive branch tortures people, and the rich pay even less in taxes.

The irony in your statement is that it's pretty much impossible to tell which candidate those voters you're referring to supported.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by glhaynes on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:42PM (#13065174)
Seems pretty easy to me.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by mi100hael on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:21PM (#13065500)
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by glhaynes on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:58PM (#13065775)
Clinton speaking against torture because it's ineffective even though Salon (and I!) would have preferred she'd publicly made the case against it for additional reasons doesn't make it any harder to figure out which candidate one should vote for if they want industry to write regulations, the executive branch to torture people, and the rich to pay even less in taxes. False equivalence is fun until, say, the 2000 or 2016 elections happen.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Brakenshire on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:53PM (#13064686)
Well, Trump is a multi-millionaire, perhaps a billionaire. His level of spending may not be remarkable by American standards, but it is by the standards of most other countries. It still means that to get into power in America you either have to be an extremely wealthy businessman, or you have to be supported by big-business.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by KirinDave on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:35PM (#13065117)
We see hints in the Trump campaign (and concrete evidence in the Obama campaign) that a lot of the cost for running is interfacing with entities that expect a lot of money to play ball.

It may be that a canny candidate with a good but small PR department can do just as well. Certainly Twitter, YouTube and Facebook seem to be having outsized impact and they're relatively inexpensive.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by guildwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:54PM (#13065286)
It's worth noting that Trump's campaign was also deeply invested in using data to drive campaign strategy. Here's a relevant excerpt from an interview with Jared Kushner, Trump's son in law, who apparently masterminded the campaign strategy.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevenbertoni/2016/11/22/exclusi...

"This wasn’t a completely raw startup. Kushner’s crew was able to tap into the Republican National Committee’s data machine, and it hired targeting partners like Cambridge Analytica to map voter universes and identify which parts of the Trump platform mattered most: trade, immigration or change. Tools like Deep Root drove the scaled-back TV ad spending by identifying shows popular with specific voter blocks in specific regions–say, NCIS for anti-ObamaCare voters or The Walking Dead for people worried about immigration. Kushner built a custom geo-location tool that plotted the location density of about 20 voter types over a live Google Maps interface.

Soon the data operation dictated every campaign decision: travel, fundraising, advertising, rally locations–even the topics of the speeches. “He put all the different pieces together,” Parscale says. “And what’s funny is the outside world was so obsessed about this little piece or that, they didn’t pick up that it was all being orchestrated so well.”

For fundraising they turned to machine learning, installing digital marketing companies on a trading floor to make them compete for business. Ineffective ads were killed in minutes, while successful ones scaled. The campaign was sending more than 100,000 uniquely tweaked ads to targeted voters each day. In the end, the richest person ever elected president, whose fundraising effort was rightly ridiculed at the beginning of the year, raised more than $250 million in four months–mostly from small donors."

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:51PM (#13065726)
Holy shit. I just made a peer comment to yours talking about how I think Trump's campaign used technology really effectively, but I had no idea about any of this.

Any sense for how Clinton's campaign compared on a tech front? I get the sense that similar to the article's description of Trump, she's...uh...not too tech savvy. Was her campaign similarly data driven as his?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by guildwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:00PM (#13066603)
My general impression from reading on the subject is that most of the other political campaigns were not nearly as tech savvy as Trump's was. Generally speaking Clinton seemed to rely mostly on the traditional approach to election strategy that would have guaranteed victory in the 90s and early 2000s. It seems that political operatives in general have been much slower to adapt to the new generation of tools that have been made available to them or just don't understand the implications. This does not come as a huge surprise. Unless you grew up interacting with technology in the same way as the younger generation has, it's harder to digest, envision, and utilize new tech. Even my stepfather who coded with punch cards and builds old motherboards for fun struggles a bit with his smartphone.

I think this election has been a good demonstration of how rapidly tech is changing the world and how asymmetric the adaptation has been. The ground is shifting so fast that it's much harder to predict and imagine the myriad of implications and the way they will feedback into systems.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:47PM (#13065701)
I've been saying that had Clinton run her campaign the way Trump did, she would have been lauded as being a political genius who had learned to embrace being a political candidate in the age of the internet. I've run into some good analysis talking about how this election was a technology shift election in the same way Nixon v. Kennedy was. Just as Nixon didn't play well to television audiences, Clinton doesn't play well to internet audiences, particularly due to the persistence of information. There was a moment in the VP debate where Pence said something like: "This isn't the old days anymore, you can't just say whatever you want without repercussion." (that's a paraphrase).

I think people overlook how effectively Trump uses Twitter. To this day. He drove a ton of outreach and messaging even when he couldn't get it framed the way he wanted in the news, and twice in the last couple weeks he's done some pretty interesting stuff where he represents a position his opponents hold, then watches as the press attacks him for it. He relies on the fact that the internet will get the truth out.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by KirinDave on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:12PM (#13065857)
> I think people overlook how effectively Trump uses Twitter.

It's difficult to be enthusiastic about the propagation of outrageous lies as a communication revolution. Say what you will about effectiveness, he's said things he can't back up and it's hard to laud that.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by siavosh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:47PM (#13064647)
I think that was indeed a silver lining, but the scary question is does that make any difference in terms of inequality in America? His economic cabinet is mostly old faces of industry, his tax plan is a continuation of trends since the 1980's (when inequality in America started increasing). We can all wait and see what happens in the next four years, but if inequality increases even more, the people will lose even more faith in democracy.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by kzrdude on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:48PM (#13064653)
Are you ignoring all the congress member races and looking at just the presidential election? The problem is biggest in congress; the influence of money is making the institution wholly nonfunctional.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by YCode on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:46PM (#13064639)
> I think the recent election demonstrated that money doesn't matter that much.

Can you elaborate on that? I'm unaware of how it was demonstrated.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by tbirrell on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:51PM (#13064670)
I think he meant that despite all the big money and power behind the Clinton campaign, enough of the electorate chose to vote against the establishment to render it ineffectual.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by andrepd on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:57PM (#13064732)
Trump is a multibilionaire. Not quite the big money vs underdog story.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Amezarak on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:12PM (#13064880)
The Trump campaign as massively outspent by the Clinton campaign almost 2-1. It also received much less outside money - 60 million versus 190 million. [1]

According to OpenSecrets, Trump spent 56 million on his own campaign. [2]

In historical US election terms, that is quite the underdog story, even if it's still a lot of money.

[1] http://www.opensecrets.org/pres16/ [2] http://www.opensecrets.org/pres16/candidate?id=N00023864

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by andrepd on Sunday December 04, 2016 @10:07AM (#13100169)
For me, an underdog story would be a common citizen getting elected with little money, and 100% crowd funded money from the people, at that. A billionaire heir getting elected by spending his millions, and "only" 60 million from someone else, leaves absolutely no sense of being an underdog, even if he did spend less than his rival (100mil instead of 200mil. Big whoop)
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Amezarak on Sunday December 04, 2016 @12:18PM (#13100685)
> A billionaire heir getting elected by spending his millions

I don't think that's an accurate way of describing his campaign. The campaign funding includes donations to the campaign in those figures. Only 22% of Trump's campaign funding was from himself, while 27% was from small individual contributors and 15% from large individual contributors. Clinton obviously had much less self-financing (0.27%), while 18% was small individual contributions and 53% was large individual contributions.

The 'someone else' in my post is money spent outside the campaign altogether from superpacs. SuperPACs are associated with 'big money' but to my knowledge there's nothing stopping normal people from donating to them.

Unfortunately, your underdog story is just not viable in a democracy of three hundred million. A common citizen, as you put it, simply has no means of getting the attention of enough people, and standing out from the crowd, without money, or to raise that much money. Even wealthy, well-known non-politicians have trouble with that - you see them pop up sometimes in the primaries. There's a reason most American Presidents were already politicians.

If you add your email to your profile, maybe we can talk about it offline? I'm interested but I have a hard time seeing how we can have national politics without money playing a big role.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:24PM (#13064996)
If I understand correctly, Clinton poured far more money into the campaign than Trump did. She also had much more media support. It didn't matter, because there were enough voters that didn't want her no matter how many ads she bought.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by gedy on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:55PM (#13064714)
Meaning Clinton outspent Trump by a large margin.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by serge2k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:28PM (#13065560)
How much did the russians spend?

He actually did get obscene amounts of free media though.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by spullara on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:52PM (#13064681)
I think he is referring to Trump spending half as much as Hillary during the campaign.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by lifeformed on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:26PM (#13065005)
The election didn't show that money or voters has the power, it showed that the media has the power (and doesn't know how to wield it).
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by golergka on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:48PM (#13065228)
The media? After all the push against the Trump?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:52PM (#13065263)
Insofar as there was a late push against Trump by some of the mainstream media, it was after they spent many months fawning over him and giving him a multi-billion dollar free media advantage that was never erased.

Given that people rarely change their view once it is well-established (rejecting new I formation which conflicts with it), even if there was quantitative balance, the fawning early coverage would be more significant in effect.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by gdulli on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:52PM (#13064679)
Is it really a silver lining if the voters can be so easily manipulated into exercising that power to vote against their own interests and to magnify (or at least maintain) the same problems the demagogue claimed to want to solve for them?

Is it possible the former status quo, while far from optimal, was at least being stewarded by adults who knew how to keep it from going off the rails? A given Democrat or Republican has to at least preserve their party's ongoing reputation. Donald is a nihilist who doesn't even have that constraint.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by devoply on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:56PM (#13064718)
They did not vote against their own interests. They voted for their interests in the only choice available that claimed to represent their interests. The point is the voters don't have an actual choice and never did, most of the consent is manufactured. The ultimate point I guess is that liberal democracy, which often does not represent mass opinion is becoming more direct and the system does not really support that sort of decision making because only people like Trump can get up there to be voted for, demagogues. The elite now don't know how to put the genie back in the bottle. This article is crying out HALP!
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:29PM (#13065040)
It proved that billions of dollars in free media advantage overwhelms tens of millions of dollars advantage in direct campaign spending.

Which isn't exactly an indication that money is weak.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by devoply on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:53PM (#13064696)
Voters have always had power, they have just not been able to organize the "unenlightened" masses:

http://thefutureprimaeval.net/the-overton-bubble/

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bradfordarner on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:58PM (#13064743)
Of course, the irony is that Trump, an ardent capitalist and pursuer of wealth, ran on a platform of decreasing the influence of money in politics. According to his 100 day plan, he is going to put a number of serious barriers on lobbying.

I found this out after the election. It wouldn't have changed my vote had I known about it before the election (way too many other issues with Trump) but, at the very least, it is a hope that maybe something good will come out of this presidential cycle.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by throwaway729 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:03PM (#13064793)
> he is going to put a number of serious barriers on lobbying

All of the most influential people in his transition team are family members, career politicians, or industry lobbyists/partisans.

Trump's plan doesn't decrease the power of money in politics; it concentrates the power of money by neutering other forms of influence.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by blowski on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:07PM (#13064839)
The UK government is in the process of doing this as well. Charities are not allowed to lobby government with raised funds.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-35509117

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by chasing on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:04PM (#13064806)
He literally had working on his campaign the guy who headed Citizens United, the group behind the court case that allowed tremendous amounts of unchecked money into the political system.

Trump has no interest in reducing the influence of money in politics.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:01PM (#13065796)
To me this is a really interesting problem. Imagine for a moment that you became the president. The people you pick to do things is really important. You have to choose from: People you've relied on who will need time to build expertise; people who have been in the system forever and are part of the problem, but are also knowledgeable in how to operate it, and people who are part of the problem and incompetent.

To me, it seems you have to pull from the first two groups and hope you can use the people you know and trust and your own influence to get the necessary change from the people who have been thus far malignant, but know important things like how to get votes, how to draft legislation, etc.

This is where every presidential candidate succeeds or fails, and most of them end up failing. I feel like it would be hard to argue that Obama wasn't completely co-opted by monied interests as he took office. The finance sector got their claws into him from the beginning.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by chasing on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:55PM (#13066206)
> ... people who have been in the system forever and are part of the problem...

Not everyone who works in government is part of the problem. Many of them are working very hard to solve real problems. No one's perfect -- that's for sure -- but I'm worried we're throwing out very talented and well-intentioned babies with our bathwater.

And the Trump administration, such as it is, has already proven that the government doesn't have a monopoly on corruption. The man's been "part of the problem" since the 70s and people seem to give him a pass. Weird.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:06PM (#13066281)
I'm sure some of them are good people trying to do good things. I'll spare cynical rejoinders and just concede the point. I think many people would agree that there aren't very many of them in the government. There are of course various axioms about people seeking power and the corrupting effects of power.

>The man's been "part of the problem" since the 70s

Yes! The public doesn't have anybody from group A to choose from, and essentially always gets to choose from group B or C. The hope is that we might get lucky one day and get someone for the group you brought up. We want the D.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by chasing on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:51PM (#13066546)
There will never be a candidate who does exactly what you want. Bernie would've pissed his supporters off for some reason or other had he been elected. We have to pick from an array of imperfect options. Whichever candidate you feel is the perfect candidate, when put in power, they will make choices you don't like. And we all have to realize the difference between sloganeering and governing.

Which is why I really dig guys like Obama who have academic credentials and seem to understand the problems they will face. Then, at least, if they do something I don't want I can look at that decision and ask why they felt it was the best one.

Hillary wasn't perfect. So we screamed about it as a nation and, well, now look at the mess we've gotten ourselves into.

To quote a certain orange individual: "Sad!"

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:03PM (#13066623)
>Whichever candidate you feel is the perfect candidate, when put in power, they will make choices you don't like

I forget where I heard it, but there was a comment about Trump that was something to the effect of: The office of the President is so powerful that in essence the position itself controls whoever is in it. To that end, results can't really vary as much as people think. There is also out there, somewhere on the internet, an essay written by a European leader who garnered the mantle of power despite deep reservations and wrote about the effect holding the position had on him. I wish I could remember who he was / where he governed. It is a really amazing piece. Maybe someone else on here knows what I'm talking about?

>Which is why I really dig guys like Obama who have academic credentials

An immoral act is an immoral act. You just get fancier rationalizations. I don't see the advantage. I actually think it's a disadvantage. To some extent Obama's charisma has kept people from being overly critical of a lot of the terrible things that can be laid at his feet, whereas, if it was still G.W. Bush he'd have been excoriated.

>now look at the mess we've gotten ourselves into

It seems to me to be an error to treat this being bad as a foregone conclusion. Maybe yes, maybe no. Time will reveal.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by mercer on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @04:31AM (#13069475)
> There is also out there, somewhere on the internet, an essay written by a European leader who garnered the mantle of power despite deep reservations and wrote about the effect holding the position had on him.

Are you referring to Václav Havel?

> "With your permission, I would like to take advantage of my unusual experience and try to cast a critical eye of an intellectual on the phenomenon of power as I have been able to observe it so far from the inside, and especially on the nature of the temptation that power represents." - Václav Havel on the temptations of political power[1]

and

> "Someone who forgets how to drive a car, do the shopping, make himself coffee, and place a telephone call is not the same person who had known how to do those things all his life. A person who had never before had to look into the lens of a television camera and now has to submit his every movement to its watchful eye is not the same person he once was.

He becomes a captive of his position, his perks, his office. What apparently confirms his identity and thus his existence in fact subtly takes that identity and existence away from him. He is no longer in control of himself, because he is controlled by something else: by his position and its exigencies, its consequences, its aspects, and its privileges."

[1]: https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/vl/notes/havel.html

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @08:28AM (#13070444)
Yes! Thank you so much for posting this.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:02PM (#13066258)
> The man's been "part of the problem" since the 70s and people seem to give him a pass.

I would argue that the election results show that most people don't give him a pass, it just happens that those that do have a favorable geographic distribution.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by cmdrfred on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:53PM (#13065272)
> Trump has no interest in reducing the influence of money in politics

If you wanted to fix it, do you vote for the person who said he wants to change it or the person who profited from that system for decades? Both parties need to end if you want change on this.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by chasing on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:22PM (#13065512)
Citizens United vs FEC is only ~7 years old and, if I recall, Hillary only ran in one election during that time frame. The same number that Trump ran in.

Regardless: The whole idea of campaign finance reform is that it's too powerful: Most politicians can't do the right thing because it would hobble them too much in elections.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by cmdrfred on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:34PM (#13065598)
>Citizens United vs FEC is only ~7 years old and, if I recall, Hillary only ran in one election during that time frame. The same number that Trump ran in.

We didn't have corruption prior to Citizens United? Here's my purposed rule, if you take a nickel from a company you don't get to vote on anything that would effect them. No way in hell the neo-cons or the neo-liberals in Washington pass that.

>Regardless: The whole idea of campaign finance reform is that it's too powerful: Most politicians can't do the right thing because it would hobble them too much in elections.

That might be changing. People are pissed at the establishment. This is the first time since the 50's that the person who spent the most money lost.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by chasing on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:39PM (#13065638)
> That might be changing.

Maybe! But now there's going to be even more monied interests spending hard to make sure it doesn't.

> This is the first time since the 50's that the person who spent the most money lost.

This is neither here nor there. Simply spending money isn't the issue.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by klipt on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:35PM (#13065120)
> According to his 100 day plan

His 100 day plan says a lot of things, like 'cut taxes for the middle class', but if you look at his actual tax plan most of the benefits go to the top 1% and many middle class earners (especially single parents) will see their taxes increase: http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2016/11/...

I wouldn't trust his 100 day plan further than I can throw it.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by user837387 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:08PM (#13064849)
The guy lies and lies and lies. The only way to know what he is really going to do is to wait for him to do it. However, calling him the smartest, most powerful, and most beautiful person ever seems to go a long way with him so I would at least try that to try to get him on your side. Problem is, everybody seems to know that he is a sucker for complement.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by pasquinelli on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:30PM (#13065061)
This is why I say there's no excuse for voting trump. "According to his hundred day plan..." you have no reason to believe a word he says and every reason not to. afaic, voting for trump's like buying a car off him, or lending him money, or attending his university, or signing an employment contract with him, and so on. He says what he needs to.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:03PM (#13065806)
Step two is to demonstrate how these claims don't apply to the other choice.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by benevol on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:02PM (#13064784)
> corrupt capitalism has corrupted democracies making them unaccountable to the majority of people, leading to a massive and still accelerating level of economic inequality

That's it, right there. The US is on a declining path regarding this most central issue, and I don't see any signs of change or social/political will for change.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by musha68k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:21PM (#13064967)
I agree, all of these feel like symptoms of systemic failure on a global scale.

From that POV how could we get back to a state where influence is in the hands of polticians (public servants) again?

What if neo-liberalism really is a super contagious virus to economies/societies?

Correlating, Žižek likes to emphasize how important global decision-making bodies are - now more than ever (e.g. in undermining tax-havens trans-nationally, setting up binding climate-change policies, etc) so damn if we get rid of them (lack of directed global power towards global problems) and damn if we don't (coporate shills)?

Maybe we do need something new this time?

I don't know, I don't see it - I'm solution blind myself. I just have got this feeling looking back into our huge catalog of isms - that we can't (and for many should not/must not) rely on those anymore.

IMHO we definitely need to become more creative again..

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Tharre on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:01PM (#13064775)
Are you suggesting that communism is somehow less corrupt? If so, I encourage you to read about how communism was practiced in the real world, and the meaning of the phrase "All people are equal, but some are more equal than others".

Governments have, and will, always be corrupt. Politicians don't decide to become corrupt, it's part of the job. It's how power has always worked. If you want to reduce this corruption, the best thing you can do is to limit the power and money the government has. And the best way to do that is by passing solid constitutional laws.

Surely not an easy task, but a real first step in the direction of a stable democracy.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by blowski on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:03PM (#13064797)
The opposite of 'corrupt capitalism' is not 'communism'. It's possible to imagine a form of regulated capitalism that doesn't invoke Stalin.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Tharre on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:12PM (#13064879)
What is the opposite then? You can imagine a lot, but I don't see how telling the very same people that were supposedly corrupted by capitalism to regulate it would change anything.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by siavosh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:26PM (#13065013)
If you look at the post-war period, from 1946 till 1970s/early 1980s, the US has a much more progressive tax rate, and there was more bank regulation. It was also coincidentally the golden age of American economics. Since the 1980's, taxes have become more and more regressive and regulation on all fronts against corporate excess and distortion of markets has increased. Government has a very important role in capitalism (bust monopolies, ensure companies compete fairly etc). Since 1980's there have been steadily greater and greater economic crises. Many would argue that capitalism has been corrupted through a corruption of politics.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by throwaway729 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:31PM (#13065586)
>Since 1980's there have been steadily greater and greater economic crises

There were some pretty deep recessions in the 50's and 70's. With the very important exception of the great recession, this doesn't really hold up against inspection.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_Unit...

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by blowski on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:24PM (#13064994)
There are a lot of different political systems - it's not a binary choice between unregulated capitalism and communism dictatorship. For example - democratic socialism, regulatory capitalism, state capitalism, etc.

I have no idea how it will happen, but I hope we won't need a bloody revolution to reduce the influence of finance and economic markets on modern life.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by Tharre on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:36PM (#13065131)
You misunderstood me. I don't argue that there is a binary choice, nor do I argue that unregulated capitalism is what we need.

I'm merely arguing that corruption isn't inherently tied to capitalism or any other economic system. That Governments will always be corrupt. Meaning that blaming capitalism for being "corrupt" is about as productive as blaming people for being selfish.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by blowski on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:03PM (#13065377)
Capitalism is not inherently corrupt, nor is it the only system which can be corrupted. I think we can both agree on that.

But the current version of capitalism dominant in the world is corrupt, and desperately needs radical change. Unfortunately, there don't seem to be many well-thought out alternatives with good leaders - so we end up with Trump and Farage peddling demagoguery.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:10PM (#13065426)
> Capitalism is not inherently corrupt, nor is it the only system which can be corrupted. I think we can both agree on that.

Capitalism is inherently and fundamentally the corruption of government to organize society and basic law (especially property relations) to favor the narrow, capitalist class, which is the fact for which critics of capitalism coined the term "capitalism" to refer to the system corrupted in that way.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:08PM (#13065837)
You seem to be ignoring the lives lead by those not in the elite ruling class prior to capitalism. There is more wealth, distributed more evenly (though still unequally) now then there ever was under various forms of fuedalism, etc. And communism has a well established track record of lowering quality of life for the lower classes while serving to consolidate more wealth and power to the few, as evidenced by the 20th century.

I look forward to the day we take the next step in human organization, but surely it can be seen that, to this point, capitalism is the high water mark.

http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2015/10/04/wo...

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:35PM (#13067173)
> but surely it can be seen that, to this point, capitalism is the high water mark.

The dominant system of the developed west in the 19th Century for which the term "capitalism" was coined was certainly an improvement in most respects over its predecessors, as was recognized by its critics who named it.

The modern mixed economy, which has generally displaced that system in the developed west (and much of the rest of the world), which incorporates significant elements of the program of the socialist critics who named "capitalism" without, as those critics would generally have preferred, replacing entirely it's fundamental structure of property, is, while certainly far from ideal, I would say much better than capitalism, though it constantly seems to want to slide back into capitalism (or, rather, powerful interests want to force it back to that state).

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @11:19AM (#13071934)
Do you see any contradiction in advocating for the current mixed economy structure while also (hopefully, presumably?) decrying the trend of increasing wealth inequality that's been going on for much of the 20th century?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @11:49AM (#13072257)
Not essentially; the modern mixed economy is a fairly broad umbrella, and it's at least arguable that reforms within it that would still be within that broad umbrella could roll back some of the growth in inequality (and particularly the growth in inequality of opportunity produced by growing inequality of outcomes.)

OTOH, I think it's a mistake to see the particular shape of the modern mixed economy (even recognizing it as a broad umbrella) as the ultimate stage in economic progress, just as it would be to see capitalism or feudalism as the ultimate stage.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @04:01PM (#13074661)
>and it's at least arguable that reforms within it that would still be within that broad umbrella could roll back some of the growth in inequality

Yes, it's just that many people believe the current mix too heavily favors the government, which creates a massive consolidation of power & resources as well as a weak point susceptible to being co-opted or corrupted. This is what people who want the 'slide back into capitalism' are concerned about. Moving more towards state intervention moves us more towards the horrors of systems that are worse than wild west capitalism.

>I think it's a mistake to see the particular shape of the modern mixed economy (even recognizing it as a broad umbrella) as the ultimate stage in economic progress

I wasn't accusing you of claiming that.

My main point is that by most trends as the power of the US federal govt has grown it has correlated with wealth inequality and stagnation for most of the people in the country. Basically, the greater the mix, the worse things have gotten. As we look towards the ultimate outcome of too much mix, it would seem that if we're not going to move towards something better, then we shouldn't be too quick to write off moving towards a more pure capitalism.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by blowski on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:49PM (#13065709)
You're saying that capitalism corrupts government by its very definition? That begs the question of the natural form of government that would exist without capitalism.

It seems to me that once societies are big enough to need government, they first reach for something like feudalism, then capitalism. That's a simplified version of Marx. I don't see capitalism as inherently corrupt, but I can see how it has a tendency to become corrupt without tight regulation. It does favour the ruling class, but that's the inherent nature of government - those who put it in place put something that suits their interests.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:48PM (#13066140)
> You're saying that capitalism corrupts government by its very definition?

No, I'm saying "capitalism" is a name for a particular manner of corruption of government.

Or, more fully, a particular-but-still-quite-corrupt stage in the evolution of government away from the perfectly corrupt state of public power unified with the personal interest of the ruler or members of the ruling class with no distinction, wherein the structure of property rights established by government creates and maintains a ruling class which still has disproportionate and dominant power over the formal public power, but in which nevertheless (unlike preceding stages) there exists a formal, if often misleading, distinction between the formal institutions of public power and the members of the ruling class.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by blowski on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:03PM (#13066266)
You sound quite interested and interesting on this topic. Any recommended reading?

I'm a bit of a lefty, but don't see any particular innovation - the fight is between those who prioritise 'being electable' (Clinton, Blair) because you can't change anything if you're not in power, and those who focus on emphasising the genuine problems (Sanders, Corbyn) but are unlikely to gain power. Neither seem to have any real solutions, it's just a matter how much they tap into the anger and frustration of the non-elites. Trump, Farage, Le Pen mine that frustration much deeper but don't seem to have any wide-ranging agenda beyond protecting the elites while pretending to do the opposite.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by serge2k on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:12PM (#13065438)
> no one in political power is discussing serious policy proposals to reduce the influence of money in politics and hence address the accelerating transition of wealth from the lower and middle class to a tiny fraction at the very top.

Clinton talked about attempting to get in a more liberal justice who could have helped reverse course on the citizens united ruling.