News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:38PM (#13065627)
>small states and small districts generally get an unjust magnitude of political power

The electoral college exists for a reason: precisely to protect the interests of the minority of people who don't live in cities from the whims of those who do. I live in Maine and we recently passed a citizen referendum for a large minimum wage increase in the state. This is almost entirely because of the people in a few population centers. These places will be able to absorb that hike moderately well, but the rural parts of the state are going to get crushed by it, and they're already the poorest parts of the state. It should have been a city ordinance, but was not.

>Trump did not win the populist victory. Hillary Clinton did.

Both campaigns were strategized around the existence of the electoral college. Winning the popular vote is merely an artifact of the system in place, but holds no real meaning. There's little reason to assume that were the popular vote what actually decided the election that the result of the election would have been different, as the strategies employed by both campaigns would have been different.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:35PM (#13066811)
>protect the interests of the minority of people who don't live in cities from the whims of those who do

This is a straw man that is commonly made by advocates of the EC. The top 50 cities in the U.S. only account for 15% of the total population, so it's a nonexistent problem.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:26PM (#13067114)
Yeah, I actually mispoke. the EC is to balance the larger more powerful states against the interests of the smaller ones. It is a compromise that was necessary to fashion the union in the first place. The reason it's not obvious is because of the federal government growing far beyond what it was intended to be.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by throwaway729 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @06:51PM (#13067266)
> the EC is to balance the larger more powerful states against the interests of the smaller ones

This is not the reason the EC exists: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13038525

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by rconti on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:52PM (#13065732)
Yes, both campaigns were strategized around the existence of the electoral college, but that's tweaking at the margins. It doesn't explain a vote difference in the millions.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by int_19h on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:12PM (#13068196)
The main reason for the difference in millions isn't even electoral college per se, it's the fact that most (all but 2) states allocate all their electors to whoever gets more votes in that state. In essence, every state throws all its minority votes away. If you think of it in terms of vote suppression (which, frankly, it is), it's one of such epic proportions that it dwarfs everything else, including redistricting, voter ID laws etc.

I mean, think about it. In California, 33% of residents voted for Trump this year - and those votes didn't count in any sensible way. In Texas, 43% of residents voted for Clinton this year - and those votes didn't count, either!

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:45PM (#13066118)
How do you know that? How many republicans in California don't bother voting?
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:37PM (#13066823)
Trump had the same number of Republicans voting for him as did Mitt Romney, while Clinton had far less Democrats voting than Obama.

This idea that there is impact from republicans not voting isn't true, and what happened actually exasperates the popular vote difference.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:54PM (#13066895)
>This idea that there is impact from republicans not voting isn't true

Which is supported by what evidence?

There are tons of people that don't vote in any given election. Everyone has their reasons, and I'm sure apathy is the leading one, but it's crazy to suggest some portion of them don't vote because they live in a state that won't flip anyway. If you a Republican in California or a Democrat in Kansas, you don't really expect your vote to count.

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:02PM (#13068392)
Post election analysis. The Republicans came out and voted at the same levels as the last election, the Democrats did not. This is why the popular vote difference is exasperated, because the candidate with the most popular vote, by millions, had less of a turnout.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @08:30AM (#13070458)
You seem to be missing my point. In any election, some large portion of the population doesn't vote at all. At least some of them are refraining because they know their state is a foregone conclusion.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by bduerst on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @01:12PM (#13073102)
And you're missing my point that your making broad generalizations about every election is pointless - that the difference between this election and other elections is what matters.
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by JadeNB on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @09:25AM (#13070932)
> it's crazy to suggest some portion of them don't vote because they live in a state that won't flip anyway.

You mean that it's not crazy to suggest this, right?

Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by r_smart on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @11:00AM (#13071758)
Yeah, whoops! I ended up arguing against myself there :)
Re:How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’ by flukus on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:17PM (#13068461)
> Trump had the same number of Republicans voting for him as did Mitt Romney

Was voting republican in california in 2012 any less of a waste?