The same thinking has him arguing that we should get the oil fields after the Iraq war.
I don't agree with this reasoning but we're about to see this play out.
Edit: here's a video that I linked to in my other comments. It's an Opera interview from 1988 where Trump says Japan is "beating the hell out of this country" and "they aren't paying" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEPs17_AkTI
This has been the most consistent part of Trump's platform. America is getting the short end of the deal.
Again, I'm not a Trump supporter but this policy is what Trump genuinely believes and will likely pursue.
This goes for tech too. American companies like Uber, Netflix, Facebook, Google, Microsoft and Apple have been able dominate most of the world market. In a protectionist world they will be locked out, just like they are in China today.
And on the one hand, I think that might be good; I'm not a fan of hegemony and imperialism. But for all its faults, the US is at least a democracy, unlike Russia and China. As a European, I strongly prefer American hegemony over Russian hegemony. But maybe it's time for the EU to finally stand on its own feet and take up the leadership of the free world. Hopefully more benevolently than the US, although recent events don't look very hopeful there either.
And in time of danger every country becomes more egoistical, as the many recent crisis demonstrated (bonds, migrants, etc). So China and Russia will benefit of a US downsizing and Europe will get the worst of it.
The only way out would be ejecting every country not willing to really merge into a strong political union, make the United States of Europe, get back some of the other countries when they'll be willing to give away their sovereignty. Problem is: there are zero countries willing to give away their sovereignty now. National political leaders are not going to risk their authority and privileges and run for a European government which only a few of them will get into.
As a German, I don't see that happening. The EU is beginning to collapse outright (Brexit, the way Europe still treats Greece and the way Europe leaves Germany stranded with the refugees, esp. Eastern Europe) and even if the EU manages to stay together as an union, the trend to nationalism and right-wing populism is worrying:
- in France, le Pen/Front National has a non-small chance of winning the elections in 2017
- Hungary with Orban basically has a fascist in power
- the situation in Poland doesn't look much better (Kaczynski nationalist government, 100k right-wing demonstrants marched in Warsow today, https://www.zdf.de/nachrichten/heute-in-europa/videos/warsch...)
- Italy is under threat from the M5S party led by Beppe Grillo, they want to exit at least the Euro currency, and the general situation is unstable
- in Greece left-wing Tsipras is in a coalition with right-wing ANEL
- Germany has, mainly fueled by the refugee situation, seen a rise of both a nationalist party (AfD) in parliaments with people predicting 10-20% at the Bundestag elections as well as massive violence against refugees and left-wing people.
- Turkey isn't part of the EU, but I think that the situation in Turkey could explode into civil war sooner than later. Or into a Hitler-level dictatorship.
And should it come to war... well I don't believe that the EU stands a flying chance against the Russians. German tank troops practice with broomsticks instead of blank cartridges (I'm serious, https://www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article137549045/Bun...), the new NH90 marine helicopter isn't licensed to fly over sea, and the A400M transporter jet isn't remotely useful right now.
Europe without US protection is a nightmare, and I'm afraid that at least Russia will exploit this. Especially as no country in the EU except maybe France actually has the capability or will to fight.
Outside of France I fear it's mostly paper tigers, even the UK. France is clearly one of the most militaristic nations in Europe and the only one who has demonstrated willingness to use force (see UK's parliament report on the Lybian intervention).
I still think Russia is a lot stronger than people think.
You might think 1939 is not relevant anymore, how about 1994 obligations? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit...
In theory France was supposed to intervene in Ukraine in case of Russian aggression, in theory.
There will be ZERO reaction when (not if) Russia invades Estonia. Remember Russian invasion of Georgia in 2008? Guess who was the ONLY one actually doing more than public statements from the comfort of their own office(and note that some like Merkel didnt even criticize Russian aggression)? Polish president flew over warzone (Russian controlled air with active military aircraft around) to join Georgian parliament in protest. Guess where is Polish president Kaczynski now - died mysteriously in plane accident over Russian airspace two years later.
We did not "want them", in contrast to rest of Europe we Germans just upheld our moral obligations. About the only thing Merkel did right during her term. And I'm proud that the general population is doing their best to help those seeking a space safe from war.
What I'm ashamed of are the actions of the minority who attack refugess and their homes though.
> We celebrate independence from being occupied by YOUR country among other parties.
That's no excuse to let fascists march.
WTF. Dude, you are from the country that gave us Hitler and Nazi party, and you call national holiday celebration a fascists march?
That said, Putin plays a subtle game, and his ties to various European extremist groups is certainly cause for worry. He will continue to destabilize Europe, but a lot more than that is needed for Russia to rule over Europe. Though if the EU is sufficiently divided, the Baltics are definitely within reach.
And the economy will not be missed, even when trying to fix the ships that are Greece and Italy and Spain?
At some point it seems like Germany can't have the only economy propping up the rest of the EU
But Greece has to fend for itself, and has lost the means to fend for itself, because they're not in control of their monetary police. They're unable to devalue their coin as they should. But if they were to become part of a more integrated EU economic policy, the EU would eat up their debt without blinking, and invest in Greece to fix the problem, which is currently apparently against the rules.
I doubt Trump would had the same views of Japan specifically, as he did then. He seems to have transferred his ire to China.
https://www.buzzfeed.com/ilanbenmeir/that-time-trump-spent-n...
And read it almost verbatim at the third debate. It was quite interesting how little his views have changed in the intervening years.
So we should start to see him become more aware of the facts. What affect this has on him remains to be seen.
1. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-election...
http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/08/trump-didnt-lea...
Perhaps very little, since it's been known for some time they've been doctored to, shall I say, achieve certain domestic political goals.
If he wants to start dealing with this stuff sooner rather than later, he needs to get some of his advisers' clearances current again, and have them start digging.
And I don't know the answer to that question, but it's important in this discussion.
A couple interesting notes: the author predicts that in a world with less free trade the US would do relatively well thanks to shale oil and our other natural resources (like rivers and rich farmlands).
He also talks a lot about demographic changes. He says in the US this will cause some pain from ~2020-2030 as the baby boomers retire, but we'll recover as millennials enter the most productive years of their careers (40s-early 60s).
However he also predicts much more dire consequences for Russia due to demographic changes, and suggests they might not recover from a decline starting around 2020.
Compare:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Russia_Sex_by_Age_2015010...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USA_by_Sex_and_Age_2015-0...
I can't repeat the entire analysis from the book in this box but I've found the author's comments to be thought-provoking so far. :)
Of particular interest to the HN crowd, the author also argues that demographic issues mean that right now there is an unusually large amount of investable capital available, but this will soon change as baby boomers begin to retire and switch from accumulating and investing their money to trying to stretch what they've already earned to last the rest of their lives. He predicts we'll see much less money available for risky investments starting in the next few years, due simply to demographic changes around the world.
If one wanted to look on the bright side, there's a chance that "I am a master businessman who can cut better deals" is a merely way to have something say about foreign policy without having to go to the effort of thinking about it.
I'm willing to revise my opinion of the guy. He's done two things i thought were impossible, winning the primary and the presidency. Maybe he will get that trillion dollar infrastructure program in place. I doubt it, but, at this point there's not much for me to do but wait and see.
Being powerful and picking the wrong fight seems like the usual collapse. The Spanish losing their armada, or Germany's first invasion of France.
Help me out, remind me of some of those people, would you?
edit
Maybe Carthage falling to Rome? i don't know enough about the circumstances. I do remember something about Hannibal occupying most of Italy.
further edit
France falling to Germany is a pretty good example.
I can't help but think sudden all out invasion of the US leads immediately to nuclear war.
I dunno. backing away from playing world cop might be the worst thing ever. I'm just not smart enough to foresee what that world might look like. I'd hope some sort of international organization would be founded to pick up the slack, and the U.S. would play a role in that. Really, the election is over. all i can do at this point is watch what happens.
But after that, he wasn't able to take Rome, and the Romans refused battle in Italy. Instead, they eventually kicked enough ass in Africa that Hannibal was recalled to there, where he eventually lost. I think that was the 2nd, and the 3rd was simply finishing off a weak Carthage so it would never threaten Rome again, "Carthage delenda est" and all that. Neither fits the pattern you're looking for.
The number 1 thing we should focus on is keeping the sea lanes open. Everything else after that is gravy, and indeed, no longer playing "world cop" now that the Cold War is over is one of many areas where Trump and the people who voted for him are aligned.
As for other examples, maybe the Norman conquest of Britain? But that's seriously complicated in cause, and I'm not sure Britain counted as a wealthy nation back then.
Ah, that's a key, look for battles where the king was a participant and got killed in it. Resistance tends to fall apart after that.
And an "all out invasion" of the US is physically impossible prior to e.g. taking out our hunter-killer subs and otherwise securing a logistics line, unless you think Canada or Mexico/Latin America are up to the job, and there "a rifle behind every blade of grass" suffices.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Bronze_Age_collapse
It is interesting in that for Greece, they basically had to rediscover writing the fall was so complete. Though its likely a confluence of things contributed. Also our relative isolation in the USA means its unlikely we'll see anything truly similar but it does show what can happen to interdependent nation states.
Carthage is probably a more recent example we could key off of. But its still a ways off from suddenly as it took about 4 generations and a lot of mutual antagonism between Carthage and Rome. Rome also went a bit overboard in razing the city you could argue.
Another to add to the list, though not for plunder specifically is Portugal with its earthquake in Lisbon effectively ended their global dominance.
Amazon sells their extra servers as a product. The US can start selling their extra nuclear weapons as a product. Business 101!
It feels a bit like the U.S. thinks the rest of the world isn't capable of looking after itself. And perhaps it isn't, and some boarders will be redrawn, but I get the feeling a lot of people are ready to give it a shot.
Especially considering the U.S. as de facto self-appointed global police, is doing a terrible job of looking after it's own citizens with regard to education, healthcare, the war on drugs, shooting black men, mass shootings, etc etc etc.
Personally, the way I feel about the U.S. as the purported bastion of "The Free World™", the leading light of Democracy is this:
It has to stop. No one believes the charade any more. And with the presidential election being a choice between terrible and wacko, the U.S. would be the laughing stock of the world if the situation wasn't so frightening.
I'll give one strong example:
In October 2013, the incarceration rate of the United States of America was the highest in the world, at 716 per 100,000 of the national population. While the United States represents about 4.4 percent of the world's population, it houses around 22 percent of the world's prisoners.[1]
How can you take yourselves seriously?
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_ra...
Edit: fixed randomly incorrect reference
I agree. However, I also think that a lot of the world, especially Europe, has a strange and unrealistic vision of what a multi-polar world would look like. A multi-polar world looks like 18th and 19th century Europe writ large, with nation states jockeying for power, and war being considered as a logical extension of economic and political policy. It isn't nations coming together and negotiating peacefully at the EU or UN or wherever.
It feels a bit like the U.S. thinks the rest of the world isn't capable of looking after itself.
Arguably because the rest of the world isn't. If you look at the "free world", who actually spends even 1% of their GDP on defense? Heck, half of Germany's air force can't even fly because they've pared their maintenance budgets back too far to buy spare parts for their planes. When France and Italy bombed Libya, they had to rely on the US to provide necessary logistical support, like tankers and reconnaissance, and even the smartbombs themselves. Taiwan explicitly relies on US carriers to guarantee its territorial sovereignty against Chinese aggression. Japan likewise.
A world in which the US is in full retreat is not a more liberal, peaceful world. It's a world in which even more autocratic powers, like China and Russia advance.
EDIT: By the way, I totally agree that the US is overstretched. But unilateral retreat, leaving our allies in the lurch to face hostile powers on their own is not the correct way of addressing that problem.
China was the number one country in the world at the beginning of 1600, per population and economy, as usual. They also had an oceanic fleet travelling to India and possibly to Africa. Then they decided to concentrate on internal matters because they were the only ones important to preserve the government. They even burned the fleet.
That move played out very bad for them in a couple of centuries. The world is much faster now. My bet is that turning inwards, if it really happens, will play bad for the USA in two decades or less. They are laughing in Moscow and Beijing now. Any immediate commercial trouble will be repaid with interests by a more prominent international status. Even wars will pay off in the long run, especially if not fought at home. Check WW1 and WW2 for the USA, or any regional conflict after then.
Here are the numbers. All but five of the countries do.
You're point still stands, though.
http://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/pdf_2016_0...
Same thing on the other side of the planet: both Japan and South Korea have very little military might; they depend on the deterrence the U.S. provides. They are looking at China and wondering what happens next.
If the U.S. reduces or removes these relationships, it will dramatically change these nations. Japan and China hate each other. If the U.S. draws back, Japan will complete its transition away from pacifism and will have nuclear weapons of its own in less than a decade. Same with South Korea.
Even if you think that the U.S. is not a leading light of democracy, these are real relationships and altering them has real consequences: more weapons and more tension among more nations in the world.
And who will stop China from intervening if US is out of the picture?
So you think the current token US force in SK can stop China if it decides to intervene? That force just acts as a nuclear tripwire; it doesn't need to be larger to act in that fashion.
And it seems likely to me that as Trump continues to receive intelligence briefings, economic and military advice, we will see a whole lot not change. That's my prediction. Probably.
1) A big strong guy, stronger than anyone else, fucks with anyone who tries to change anything
2) lots of strong people stop anyone who gets too destructive
I don't think 1 is remotely sustainable. 2 might be doable.
> In October 2013, the incarceration rate of the United States of America was the highest in the world, at 716 per 100,000 of the national population. While the United States represents about 4.4 percent of the world's population, it houses around 22 percent of the world's prisoners.[1]
> How can you take yourselves seriously?
Totally agreed.
If the US had low crime rates, great quality of life, and was seen as universally fair and just - well then 1 might work. But when it's so unjust, unfair, and unbalanced at home, while we spend billions abroad... it stops making sense.
That's a very idealistic view. You can't have lots of more or less equally strong parties -- only a very few. From those few all secretly want to switch to 1).
Unless each of those has learned that 1) always ends poorly and has decided they're better off with strong allies comitted to the ideals of justice.
Yeah, we quibble over the details. But there is a direction we all want to go - safety and personal freedom are universal ideals.
Even dictatorships fake elections.
I believe the economic analysis would be: it's not a Nash equilibrium, and therefore it cannot exist for any length of time, because the cost of it rises exponentially over time.
So can I just say: Good luck with that, and I, personally, would like to opt out if possible.
In some ways the world is quite different now, with nuclear deterrent...but it's still worth considering history.
Well, this was the sentiment of most Americans after World War 1. It took the attack on Perl Harbor for Roosevelt to have enough support from congress to join WWII.
I think that after WWII the US government made part of its foreign policy to use economic integration and military might to prevent any country from ever dragging them into WWIII.
I am personally not worried about China, Russia, the middle east or even North Korea. But I would be seriously worried to see Japan rebuild their military because we pulled our bases out of there.
Those things aren't really related, except as far as american attitudes go.
For example, a massive amount of money is spent on health care.
A massive amount of money in the U.S. is spent on administering healthcare.
Not much actually goes towards actual health care.
Healthcare could be relatively inexpensive to provide, if we chose to eliminate the profit motive.
It's absurd to me that anyone should profit from my being unwell. That's the sort of thing mosquitoes, leeches, ticks, pathogenic viruses and bacteria, thrive on.
I don't have a fully-formed whole-system replacement for for-profit-healthcare, but it definitely seems like something we ought to work on.
How does it make sense that people's unwellness should be paying for my neighbours Toyota Prado (that's never been taken off the road).
I do think US attitudes lead to both things (world police/broken health care system).
Rather, I think what you've done here is mimic the common HN pattern of saying "X is orthogonal to Y, so I don't get what you're saying", which, as I've try to point out above, lacks imagination.
I even went to some length to try to explain why I feel like that.
A large daily dose of craven "speaks comfortable untruths for power" mainstream media, who have been owned by the military-industrial complex for decades. The morons at CIA didn't see it coming, that Americans would question the lies of network news, or else they would have attempted to strangle this internet thing in its cradle. They've adapted somewhat, e.g. the "good work" done at Facebook this cycle or the constant fear-mongering about Russia, China, North Korea, ISIS, etc. They just couldn't get their bloodthirsty old gal over the line, though.
The conspiracy theorist in me would like to be a fly on the wall in Pence's personal security briefings. If they hear what they like from him, he'll be our President in short order. Wasn't he a big incarceration fan?
If anything, I think what killed her is that she is a very unexciting stay-the-course President. No major changes, just incremental improvements. Very likely what is actually happen in any Presidency. What's sad is that the American people punished her for actually being realistic about what a President can actually do.
There's not going to be a new border wall and there's not going to be any more jobs for the middle class. Clinton knows that, Trump doesn't.
Also lies and corruption, that's what killed her. But you're right that it would have still been "no major changes" from what she was before.
She had major investors behind her, all that money from speeches, all the media, Obama, the DOJ, people at CNN passing her debate questions before hand. And she still lost. To a TV show star.
I don't buy the idea that was "experienced", "the most qualified", "a good manager". She lost to Trump. That is a fact now. The argument of her competence, integrity, intelligence is very hard to make at this point.
We had no data whatsoever on Trump or the RNC. Beyond his barrage of lies, low-level offenses (paying fines with his nonprofit, bribing elected officials, all that), and alleged sexual assaults, that is. I think he did so many little bad things that the American People couldn't keep track of them, and voted for the interesting television personality.
It is unfair to assume that "no news is good news", but assume we did. The Clinton campaign lost the information war badly. (And apparently against state-sponsored adversaries!)
And what did we conclude from Hillary's emails? That she got paid by investment banks and accepted donations to her Foundation from foreign dignitaries that she interacted with while Secretary of State? While I don't think that influenced her decision-making, the appearance of impropriety is just as bad as actual impropriety, and so I can see why people were upset. But like I said, I trust her decision-making and voted for her anyway, because her positives vastly outweigh her negatives.
(The DNC is another issue altogether, but it's very simple why they didn't support Bernie. They're the DNC, not the "independent who suddenly claims to be a democrat" NC. The system of political parties sucks. But it's the system we set up and keep voting for. I don't think Bernie would have beaten Trump. College students can make some pretty good subreddits and Facebook posts, but they just aren't enough of the electorate. Clinton and Trump both have Very Powerful Friends, and you need them to be elected.)
If the DNC's role in the primaries was replaced with a laptop to add up the popular vote of all of the primaries, all delegates and superdelegates eliminated, the members of the Democratic party who would otherwise be "superdelegates" -- elected Democrats in Congress, top members of the state Committees, past and current Democratic Presidents, Democratic governors, etc -- would still have an outsized influence in backing one candidate or another, because they are influential people with personal experience with the candidates whose opinions are trusted by many people.
Pretending it could be any other way is silly; when I need an opinion on someone, as either a political candidate, a plumber, or a potential new engineering hire, I talk to people who have personal knowledge, whose opinions I trust. Demanding that these people not share their opinions is absurd.
So what do think she should have done better? Did she not lie convincingly enough, and Trump was a better liar?
But yes charisma is often the ability to persuade, and persuasion passes through exaggeration, bravado, and if you are completely lost, lying. Everything indicates Trump is a pathological liar (same with Hillary). But because voters got caught up in his narcissism, he "won" (again electoral college only etc.)
Whether justified or not, many of the Trump voters/fans I've spoken to did not get caught up in Trump's 'narcissism'; they just feel so sick of 'the establishment' that they'd do anything to not get another Clinton in office.
To be clear, I myself would probably have voted for Hillary instead of Trump, because I'm a cautious person and I prefer the 'evil' I know over the unpredictable nature of Trump. But if I squint, so to speak, I could see myself voting for Trump just because I dislike Hillary so much. That in itself scares me a bit (I'm big on LGBT rights and whatnot, on a very personal level).
The reason why I'm pointing this out is that 1) we are now stuck with Trump, so let's try and make the best of it, 2) part of why we got here was the incredibly shallow name-calling and condemnation and stereotyping from both sides, encouraged by the media.
Our best way forward is to try and understand the situation and most important the people involved, and why they voted the way they did, and go from there. And perhaps being honest and factually correct is a good idea too.
Could be further analysis proves you right, btw. But right now I have no reason to believe that most people voted Trump primarily because they got 'caught up in his narcissism'.
She was a lawyer, first lady for 8 years, a senator, and secretary of state. She's incredibly experienced and qualified.
Trump is nothing but lies and corruption. It's hypocritical to whine about Hillary and ignore trump.
I didn't know I was "whining" sorry about that. Will try to keep my tone in check.
> and ignore trump.
Have you read the rest of the posts? Are you responding to the same comment section in HN? There is a lot of stuff being ignored but Trump is not one of those things.
> She's incredibly experienced and qualified.
Let's accept that. How do we reconcile the fact that she completely blew this election? With a star team of strategists, Obama behind her, all the financial support, media helping her every single step of the way, even down to passing her debate questions in advance, all that experience. Out of all people she lost to Trump? What happened there?
We don't reconcile them, because while not unrelated, they also aren't tightly correlated. "Experienced and qualified" don't guarantee success in an election (or anything else for that matter). Trump is clearly not experienced politically and a large number of people agree that he's not qualified, yet he still won.
Experienced and qualified people fail at stuff pretty regularly.
Everyone fails. But this was not a simple tactical fail, this is a strategic type long sequence of failures.
> "Experienced and qualified" don't guarantee success in an election (or anything else for that matter).
What good are those things for then? I would imagine such a long experience at being a politician should translate into the ability to manage an election, understanding and communicating the issues to the constituents, seeing what the voters want, and so on.
Really? Because from what I saw, the biggest failure from Hillary was the email scandal, and of course the failure to actually get elected. I didn't see sequence of failures. If anything, Trump had a much bigger sequence of failures, from the tax leaks, to the Trump University fraud, to belittling a former Miss Universe, to the pussy grabbing comments and more. He got elected nonetheless because he managed to sell a message people wanted to hear.
> What good are those things for then? I would imagine such a long experience at being a politician should translate into the ability to manage an election, understanding and communicating the issues to the constituents, seeing what the voters want, and so on.
Those things are helpful, in the same way that being smart is helpful if you're starting a company. But smart people start failing companies all the time and experienced politicians lose elections all the time, too.
I would say the sequence of failures is not understanding what voters were looking for. That didn't happen as a singular event. That happened at first, then later, it happen probably up until she canceled the fireworks show for celebration party. As a politician, knowing what the voters she (hopefully!) planned to represent wanted, should have been one of the top qualification requirements, would you say?
Losing the Rust belt was a major strategic failure. I can understand if it was down to a few electoral votes, could then argue it was random, but it was 60 votes.
> he managed to sell a message people wanted to hear.
But she's been in politics with all that experience. Out of all the people shouldn't she be the one who can sell people what they want to hear? Maybe the idea is that she has a higher integrity than Trump and wouldn't want to do that?
> biggest failure from Hillary was the email scandal,
Email scandal was not one thing. The contents of the emails show sequence of failures.
> If anything, Trump had a much bigger sequence of failures
Exactly, it was terrible, and she still couldn't win. That is just baffling to me.
> Those things are helpful, in the same way that being smart is helpful if you're starting a company. But smart people start failing companies all the time and experienced politicians lose elections all the time, too
That's a fair point I agree with that in general.
You seem to be convinced that experience and qualifications necessarily lead to winning elections, and therefore Clinton's loss proves that she has neither. But this is fundamentally untrue. Many times voters have chosen someone with less experience and weaker qualifications. I'd argue that Clinton was more qualified and more experienced than Obama when he beat her in the primaries. McCain was arguably more qualified and certainly more experienced when Obama beat him in the general election, too. He won because at the time voters preferred his message and his vision.
That makes sense.
Also good point on experience regarding Obama/Clinton/McCain
> I'm not clear where you're going with all this.
Nowhere really. I am just baffled about this and wanted to discuss stuff and see what other people think about it. As much as we don't do political stuff here, this still a more sane forum than reddit for example.
Yes Hillary blew the election. In the end Colin Powell was right - whatever she did right she ruined with hubris
The ones I read in Podesta's emails were quite clearly leaked, and then Donna lied about the message being changed by Russia. That was false, because it's DKIM validate and those headers cover the body as well as the headers.
Trump has, in his way, an Obama like gift for getting people excited to vote for him. It makes him look god awful to his opponents, but it gets people to vote.
There's also sexism.
I don't see making the case for her "experience" and "qualification" anymore. With all the resources, media, donations, etc she should have had this election in the pocket.
The irony of this failure is that heeding to the message "It's the economy, stupid!" was what put Bill in the White House to begin with.
Presidents generally do try to fulfill their campaign promises, and building the wall is the biggest, most concrete, and earliest campaign promise he made. Realistically, it's also one of the most straightforward of all his promises to achieve, and at $25-30B it's not very expensive in the grand scheme of a presidency. Its overall effect will be minimal, meaning that it won't wreak havoc, it won't do much good either (in fact it might ironically backfire by keeping people in instead of out), but it will satisfy his supporters.
I'd be interested to know the CO2 estimates for a 5,000 mile wall.
President Obama ridiculed him to his face at the Correspondent's Dinner a few years back. The campaign is a Fuck You to Obama and the rest of the establishment that laughed at him as a lightweight.
He worked very hard and won and now he'll be improvising. He'll have to pay back some people that supported his campaign, many of whom have specific political goals. He'll allow them to work towards those. But apart from a big tax cut for the very rich (strangely) I'm almost certain see that he doesn't care much at all about the rest of his platform. Certainly not the Christian-right stuff.
Maybe he has a real conviction about trade deals. It'll be interesting to see if he moves the needle on any meaningful trade metrics.
That's just my personal impression from listening to him talk.
That said, Trump's candidacy was not enthusiastically received by most of the wealthy conservatives. Carl Icahn and Peter Thiel are the only billionaires that I can think of that supported Trump. Charles & David Koch didn't endorse or fund his campaign or use their political entities to support him.
So your point remains and is good. I wanted to remind the HN audience that the elite is comprised of conservatives too, and they disagree with the liberal elite about much.
I'm guessing that most of the wealth in the Republican party comes from people that are Republicans because they want a lower corporate tax, rather than people that want bans on who can use which bathroom. But somehow they ended up in the same political party.
Maybe not directly, but Pence has pretty strong ties to the Kochs and his nomination as VP was widely seen as a nod to them.
While I give credit that Trump may indeed be well intentioned but the main difference between him and Clinton is that Trump does not understand his words have consequences. Clinton knew to attack Trump the persona and not attack an ethnic group.
We will all find out in time, but as I watched him sit with Obama yesterday and also with Paul Ryan, both of whom looked like seasoned politicians who knew what was expected of them, I saw in Trump a man who looked lost and uncertain.
I suspect that he liked the idea of being president more than he will enjoy doing the job.
I don't agree with Trump but to think he really doesn't want to do the things he's been saying over the decades seems wrong.
I feel like I need to keep adding a disclaimer that I'm not a Trump supporter because my comments make it seem like I agree with him. I'm simply stating his views because I keep seeing people project their own feelings onto him even though he has been clear about many parts of his platform. Sure, he's had to walk back many statements or clarify that he was "being sarcastic" but there are many parts of his platform where he is crystal clear, yet people don't think he'd actually pursue those policies.
...I feel like I need to keep adding a disclaimer that I'm not a Trump supporter...
Please don't, it does not add anything to the discourse. It does not matter whether you support him or not when pointing out facts (or fallacies, for that matter). Having to add disclaimers all the time is a damper on any discussion and as such should be avoided. Those who lack the wisdom to separate their personal opinion on people who support a certain policy or person from the merits of what those people say need to take a gander at the following rant:President Trump: How & Why... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLG9g7BcjKs
I see this come up frequently on HN, usually not as well-worded as your response. Typically it's just "ad hominem" with the link to the logical fallacy on wikipedia.
But the source of a fact or argument is valuable information. Since humans have finite time and attention, it's useful to know why someone is making an argument.
Wouldn't you want to know if a drug study was sponsored by its manufacturer before believing it?
Wouldn't you want to know if a drug study was sponsored by its manufacturer before believing it?
That is not the same thing. I assume someone is not sponsored by a manufacturer unless such a sponsorship is explicitly stated. I also expect someone who is in fact sponsored by a manufacturer to state this explicitly as that would be relevant in the interpretation of that person's claims which, in the context of drug studies, can be judged objectively. In the context of a political or societal discussion it is much harder to be objective as those fields are largely subjective - there generally is no absolute truth. Seen in that light it is hardly relevant whether a person supports this or that party, policy or politician when discussing claims about their merits as other participants in the discussion can make up their own minds on the subject regardless of what the claimant thinks about them. I'd go on step further and claim that the discussion would actually improve when such disclaimers are left out as it would reduce the influence of group think and open up the possibility to discuss matters which fall outside of the comfort zone without needing to excuse oneself for even mentioning the subject. This would only work in a place where the discourse is generally polite and thoughtful, HN being an example of such.Commenters on HN post both to persuade other commenters and to expose their own opinions to scrutiny by the community. I attempt to persuade and be persuaded by other HN commenters. It is useful to add disclaimers so other commenters can see if I have an agenda. Often I do, and it's useful to disclose that so suspicion is suspended and discourse can continue.
Sadly, I'd say the fact that every other commenter seems to go out of their way to point out that they're not a Trump supporter, and the fact that I feel the need to do so myself, is evidence enough that HN is not polite and thoughtful enough when it comes to this issue.
And honestly I wouldn't expect that from HN, even though I do feel this is still a place where there is relatively more politeness and thoughtfulness.
The debate in the comments was lively and both sides were represented over the Sam Altman post defending his decision to keep Peter Thiel at YCombinator.
It's going to be an awful four years where any of the good things Trump said (the stuff that resonated with Bernie supporters, renegotiating trade deals, infrastructure improvements, term limits and curtailing lobbyist influence ) are going to be flat out denied by this awful congress headed by one of the slimiest most cynical men in our history. Mitch McConnell's congress is a massive roadblock to progress.
So, yeah, we're looking at four years of obstructing their own candidate on anything good or reasonable that an "outsider" might want to do. While pushing aggressively forward (or backward, as the case may be) on all the same stuff they've been outraged at Obama for over the past eight years.
While it may work to get some populist laws through, this dynamic also makes us extremely vulnerable to an autocratic power grab.
Unfortunately I can't help but fear for the bad things he might push for, whether prompted by those close to him or populist sentiment.
I guess that means let's hope Peter Thiel wins the power behind the thrown? :/
I'm not a Trump supporter but I'd be behind purging the Old Guard and bringing in new ideas.
When push comes to shove and if Trump tries to suborn the Senate, McConnell, like Roberts on the Court, might be the great white hope.
Trump knows exactly what he's doing, and it is completely in line with his "America First" slogan. It's about focusing on improving our own citizens' lives before pouring trillions into wars, offshore military bases, NATO defense payments and UN programs in the name of globalization.
A withdrawal of forces from ROK and Japan means that they now have to turn to China for protection from the lunatics in the North.
A world without NATO means that Russia gets to annex Russian-speaking regions of Estonia whenever they want, just like they ALREADY DID to the Ukraine.
It's tempting to believe that there are no militarist nuts with guns in the modern industrial world, but it's not true. What is true is that they've been largely suppressed in the post-cold-war era by American military dominance.
Until now. I'll actually put this prediction down in writing: before the end of Trump's term, there will be at least one shooting war involving one of the players mentioned above.
They just elected a strongman into office who has a clear pattern of misplacing blame for all of the countries problems on the out-groups, including immigrants, Muslims, LGBT, liberals, politicians, the "upper class", and all kinds of other things. What will happen when his misplaced blame doesn't solve the problem? He will double down on the out-groups that gave him such easy support... It is DANGEROUS to have the principle of America first and everyone else second when you don't understand the consequences of America's actions and what it has inflicted on the world. It started the globalist capitalist elite, and now it doesn't want to be on the hook for them while blaming IMMIGRANTS for problems that were clearly caused by big corporations. So he wins by promising to cut taxes for those same corporations... I just don't get what he thinks his end-game is. Mostly WW3, I suppose.
This is literally the exact same argument the first group of people to use the "America First" slogan made: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America_First_Committee
And what those people ended up accomplishing was making sure that when the U.S. finally did enter World War 2, it did so more or less unarmed and with its Pacific Fleet sitting at the bottom of Pearl Harbor. Which meant that it took longer to defeat the Axis than it should have, and a lot more Americans (and people, both military and civilian, in all the other nations that struggled against fascism) had to die to make that happen.
In the age of rapid transit and telecommunications, the world is even smaller than it was then. Which makes hiding behind the oceans that sit between us and the rest of the world even less viable of a strategy today than it was.
Trump, apparently, won because Trump is whatever people want him to be, even if he has clearly and repeatedly said he is the opposite.
This is why progressives hate the Democrats so much lately.
The term 'regressive left' is becoming more common in my surroundings, and ever since Pim Fortuyn (2002, the precursor to our Dutch version of Trump, and I don't mean that in a pejorative sense) there's been a growing sense that our 'left' not only lacks an answer to populism, it's part of the 'evil neoliberal establishment 1% elite etc.'.
There's a sentiment around me that Labor/greens/D66 (center-left democrats?) are mostly an intellectual elite that doesn't understand the problems we face. They call for integration and multiculturalism, but don't feel any of the adverse effects or problems that result. And somehow they seem way too much into privatizing things, dismantling our welfare state, and general Neoliberal-tasting things.
Now, I don't know enough to have a very strong opinion on all of this. But I do sort of get the intense hatred of the 'intellectual left elite'. It feels degrading and shitty to be told that you're wrong and your problems are bullshit and you're being manipulated by a populist, and you're a racist, and all that, and I can totally see how that could make one respond with a big middle finger and a vote for exactly those populists. Even if just out of spite. And even regardless of the consequences.
Of course I have no answer to this problem. I'm a well-educated, left-leaning, academically-minded, LGBT-affiliated white man and I'll probably do fine no matter what. I feel the way forward for me is to start engaging more with those who feel like they need to 'fuck shit up' with their vote, and to try and properly understand why all these things are happening that I didn't predict and that don't make sense to me.
But dear God I'm trying my best to bite my tongue and not blindly disparage Trump or our own populist movements. Because 1) it seems counter-productive, and 2) a surprising number of my highly-educated, intellectual-type friends are in favor of those movements, so I can't afford not taking them seriously.
And I suppose 3) most people are smarter than they seem, including the really dumb ones.
Even when Republicans haven't owned all of the branches of government (which is the state we've now found ourselves in), legislation has ended up tilting to the right...because for all their flaws, they know how opposition works, even if you don't have the majority.
Tell me when you're through with the stabbing and want to work productively again WITH me to fix this. I'll be waiting.
(Edit just to clarify the sarcasm, as I feel you won't get it if I don't: if you check upthread, the metaphor I picked originally was "spitballs". I escalated for effect when it became clear that SwellJoe was more interested in yelling at the corrupt DNC establishment elites than in discussing what to do about a Trump presidency, which was the original topic.)
What have I said that is in a "yelling" tone? Please point it out to me, so I can adjust my tone. I'm speaking the truth as I see it, as clearly as I understand it. The Democratic party lost big this year. It was not just the presidential race. Republicans swept the board, at the national, state, and local level, including in places they shouldn't have won.
If you believe staying the course is the right course of action for the DNC and the party in general, I believe the onus is on you to defend that position; there are people who have tried to bring the party back to being a grassroots party of the working class (among others, of course), and have been repeatedly shushed, shunned, dismissed as being "extremist", etc. So, the working classes have spoken and embraced a fascist who, at least, speaks to them where they are and acknowledges the pain they're feeling. That he can get away with giving scapegoats rather than solutions is predictable in the absence of consistent messaging and action from the Democrats on those same issues.
The argument can no longer be made that the center lane is the pragmatic approach; though one could certainly argue that there's room for center-left Democrats in red state elections, and I would even agree with that and support that. But, the party has no passion left in it; it's been shoved out by party functionaries who cling to power within the party, all the while it sinks further below water.
Losing (big and wide) is not pragmatic.
This is part of his genius. There's a similar concept in some mythology that I can't place at the moment...
Source?
And, look at the legislative record of the people he has chosen to be part of his team. They are among the most anti-LGBTQ legislators at the national level (and his VP has been a nightmare on LGBTQ and women's issues).
I guess it is Trump's lack of legislative record that allows people to make him a grab bag of whatever they want to see. But, when you check the history of who he's got on the team, the story is pretty clear.
My suspicion is that he wants less direct military involvement and a greater threat if military involvement is required.
That is, he's proposing that we replace the "World Police" model with the Swiss model.
Russia has it even worse---they went from world wide (perceived) number 2 and scary antagonist to `also-ran in decline'.
I remember approximately 1 week ago that Trump being elected would cause a global economic meltdown. Krugman himself said the stock market would "never recover" if he is elected.
And already stocks are up, and have been the last few days.
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2016/02/25/infrastructure-co...
Countries destroyed by brutal dictators propped up and supported by US might have something to say about the "stability" part there.
> I think it's incredibly short-sighted.
Or we could try a few more regime changes in Libya, maybe create another ISIS because that was lots of fun.
I think "pax Americana" sounds not like you think it sounds to many countries in the world.
> It's essentially the end of "pax Americana".
> I think it's incredibly short-sighted.
Whatever you think of Trump's policies, the US portion of world GDP has been going down since the 1950s. How long do you think it's tenable for the US to maintain its current commitments? When it's down to 20% of world GDP? 10%, 5%?The US is still coasting on foreign policy that was essentially made in 1945 after WWII. There's just no way that policy can be maintained indefinitely.
Trump has made comments to the effect that he'd like to lay the foundations of a new type of foreign policy that'll last for decades to come. Whatever you think of his plans I think it's clear that the US can't maintain these foreign entanglements indefinitely, and will need to distribute some of the load to their current allies.
Of course, US spending could have been even lower still if we avoided using false pretences to engage in a pointless war of choice in Iraq, which, of course, had nothing to do with commitments to Europe or Japan.
The broken promises already started. And they're going to keep going. "Draining the swamp" already isn't happening. A lot of Washington insiders are on his team. I don't know if he's actually going to be able to do any of the things he's promised now that he's in the know.
Of course, how do you keep insurance companies from going out of business under the weight of that provision? That's where the individual mandate came from--which is the least popular part of the law.
So: good luck with making the numbers work, Trump.
I always believed that once you accept this as a required outcome, you initiate a dependency chain that ends in single-payer government health care. There's just no way around it.
He pushed the repeal of Obamacare pretty hard toward the end of the election when it became apparent that was a winning message. But he has said repeatedly that he does not believe that the U.S. can just abandon people without healthcare. "We have to take care of our people"--he said things like this a number of times.
The big question now is how much control Trump will have over his own administration, vs. the established GOP machine in DC.
Trump's inexperience with governing means he doesn't know all the tricks and levers for getting what he wants. He's used to just issuing commands to his corporate staff. The executive branch does not work like that. Everyone has their own agendas, and will undercut or sell out the president if they think it will help them.
Keep in mind Obama also made many (leftist) promises in his 2008 campaign, such as closing Gitmo. Once he understood certain realities though, he had to abandon those promises and become more of a center-left president.
In this election, the Democratic base wanted a real leftist. That's why there was tremendous excitement about Bernie. The Democrats decided to field a center-right candidate instead. The result is clear: they got crushed.
What would have a major effect on the world is the new copyright and patent laws and the investor-state arbitration. The world will less be changed from not having those, and by many views for the better. I don't expect China or Russia to try impose harsher copyright and patent laws, destroying ship loads with generic drugs or implement a world-wide investor-state arbitration.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-10/trump-or-n...
This backing off on world power actually began with Obama, and has been a theme throughout. I'm on mobile right now and can't dig them up, but there a lots of state and military papers on it.
Here's the Secretary of Defense speaking in 2011:
"But in my opinion, any future defense secretary who advises the president to again send a big American land army into Asia or into the Middle East or Africa should “have his head examined,” as General MacArthur so delicately put it."
Maybe it was a different week, but I thought his complaint was that we were weak against Russia and letting them do whatever they want. That's where his whole he's know Putin respects power but we have not been projecting it came from.
Again, maybe that was said at a different time. It is why I keep saying we'll have to wait and see what he really does and not just says.
https://chomsky.info/fateful02/
> We have to understand “stability” to mean maintenance of specific forms of domination and control, and easy access to resources and profits. And the phrase “fundamentalist religious zealotry,” as noted, is a code word for a particular form of “radical nationalism” that threatens “stability.”
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-china-media-i...
It's like your main competitor, who was always 10 steps ahead of you, just got as a CEO that guy who's yelling loudly all the time but knows nothing about the industry.
The other (arguably more important) component that differentiated Pax Britannica from the Pax Americana was colonies. The US was brought into WWII with an ideological high-mindedness that prevented us from doing what GB/France did in WWI with the Sykes–Picot Agreement and chop up colonies as war proceeds. Those colonies are precisely what kept Britain afloat -- i.e., from Indian spices, Indian silks, and high quality Wootz steel, as well as from rich land - Virginian soil that was ridiculously fertile and prime for tobacco. (All of which had to be routed through GB and taxed, often to return to its origin to be processed, leading to a bunch of pissed-off rich white landed gentry to commit treason.)
I digress. Pax Americana would have occurred regardless of our (overinvolvement) in national affairs. Quite simply, there was no one left with an infrastructure intact post WWII to produce the materials for reconstruction. A well-executed Marshall Plan in place ensured an economically secure US post-WWII, the profits of which allowed a "Leave it to Beaver" suburban (somewhat artificial) saudade. Teamsters needed to load that cargo on and off ships, machinists needed to work the lathes to create those widgets being exported to a reconstructing Belgium. This also was during an era when the highest federal tax rate was 91% rather than 35%, because yes, _wars cost money_. If congress declares a state of war, the executive administration has the moral obligation to the country to increase taxes appropriately (not print 30 year notes like they were going out of fashion, leaving the mess for the next administration / generation to clean up).
Surely, there are people making a net gain off of the security provided by the armed forces. But it's definitely not John in Minnesota working the Bridgeport. Those jobs are all mechanised. The net gain exists is going to someone working logistics in a nice bespoke suit from Saville Row will flying First Club BA from JFK to Heathrow. The profits will then get routed to some holding company that owns the majority stake in some set of Lichtenstein AG's with an executor being some nameless attorney in the Dutch Antilles who isn't allowed to reveal the name of his client.
He'll keep his money there, or maybe move it to UBS if he's accrued enough capital to be invited into the Private Wealth community. Maybe he'll be advised to move that money into a holding corporation based in Hong Kong, buy US 30 year notes and take the small hit on the 11% HK tax and tiny purchasing power loss if the coupons + payout doesn't beat inflation because you'll be claiming the profits at 15% long-term capital gains anyways (and that's if you even want to remit the money back into the US).
(I'm not a tax attorney (especially not one with experience in international tax law), CPA, nor a chartered accountant, but I do enjoy reading technicalities (in any system) because semantics of category is like a game of chess to me. An actual professional will obviously not execute the series of strategies I delineated above in that exact form, but it covers the gist of how Romney had an effective tax rate of 13.9%. For more details, PricewaterCooper has a PDF floating around for corporate tax minimization. Julius Baer, a former private bank for high net-worth individuals, was one of the first major Wikileaks. It delineated the methodologies of legal money movement for individuals and their method de jour at the time (though its an arms race against tax institutions, so they constantly evolve like infectious bacteria vs antibiotics (you pick which is which ;) ))).
I am not quite sure about the fiscal (?) impact of the colonies: industrialisation clearly made Britain rich, but I am not so sure about the colonies. (I am trying to find some good data, and I will have to formalise my hypothesis in a way that's testable with numbers.)
The American 91% federal income tax rate only existed on paper: the federal tax take as a proportion of GDP over time is mostly flat, no matter what happened to the top marginal tax rate. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauser%27s_law) One of the tax dodges to get around those high marginal rates was employer provided health care---and the US still haven't recovered from that mistake.
About the tax shenanigans you describe: that's one of the reasons I am a firm believer in land value tax---basically impossible to evade if implemented right. But exactly because it's such an easy to administer and hard-to-avoid system, it'll `never happen'.
The result will be a world that is more clearly apportioned among 3-4 major powers. Small Asian countries, if they can't get a feeling of solid support from the U.S., will eventually ally themselves with China. And the EU and Russia will battle (hopefully not openly) over the lands between and near them.
It's essentially the end of "pax Americana". I think it's incredibly short-sighted. Trump looks at international relations as a quarterly balance sheet but almost certainly does not properly account for the value of the stability the U.S. provides throughout the world now.